Okinawa Governor Revokes Permission for Construction of

U.S. Base
Photo Protesters on Tuesday scuffling with the police as they try to demonstrate outside Camp
Schwab, an existing American base in Okinawa in southern Japan. Credit Koji Harada/Kyodo News,
via Associated Press TOKYO A long-running political dispute in Japan over the proposed relocation of
a United States Marine Corps air base entered new territory on Tuesday, after the governor of
Okinawa revoked permission for construction work to take place at the site planned for the facility.
The decision, which central government officials in Tokyo said they would appeal, is the latest
setback for a 20-year effort by Japanese and American military planners to move the base, Marine
Corps Air Station Futenma, from its current location in the middle of a crowded Okinawan city to a
less populated part of the island.
Conflict over the base has grown more acute under Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who has pledged to
complete the site for the Marines on Henoko Bay a goal that has eluded numerous predecessors.
Tokyo and Washington agreed on the relocation in the 1990s, but popular opposition in Okinawa has
prevented the deal from being carried out. Many residents want the American military presence on
their small southern island reduced, not simply redistributed.
Photo Takeshi Onaga, the governor of Okinawa. Credit Hitoshi Maeshiro/European Pressphoto
Agency Mr. Abe has risked political resistance by reviving the relocation project, which is part of his
broader focus on national security. Mr. Abes agenda, partly driven by concerns over the growing
military power of China, is hawkish for a Japanese leader: Along with bolstering Japans already
strong defense ties to the United States, he has lifted restrictions on arms exports, reversed a long
decline in military spending and most contentious reinterpreted the pacifist Constitution to allow
Japanese forces to undertake some types of combat missions overseas.
Residents frustration with their assigned role in Mr. Abes plans is also increasing, however.

At a news conference on Tuesday in the Okinawan capital of Naha, the governor, Takeshi Onaga,
said that there were legal flaws with a permit issued by his predecessor that allows construction
crews commissioned by the Japanese Defense Ministry to work in the coral-filled waters of Henoko
Bay.
I have sent notice that I am revoking permission, he said.
Mr. Onaga wants the Marine base moved off Okinawa altogether. Okinawa is home to about 25,000
United States military personnel, more than half the total stationed throughout Japan. Most
residents support the governors position, according to opinion surveys.
Though Mr. Onagas decision had been widely expected, several dozen demonstrators who had
camped out in front of an existing United States military installation on Henoko Bay, Camp Schwab,
broke into cheers after the announcement, in footage carried by Japanese news broadcasts. Camp
Schwab would be greatly expanded under the relocation plan, with new runways extending into the
bay. So far, little actual work has been done, but even preparatory surveys have drawn protests.

In Tokyo, officials said they would seek to have Mr. Onagas decision overruled. The Ministry of Land,
Infrastructure and Transport has ultimate jurisdiction over the type of construction permit revoked
by the governor meaning the government would, in effect, be appealing to itself.
There is no change to our plan to continue with construction in order to prepare for relocation, said
the governments main spokesman, Yoshihide Suga.
Experts said the matter would most likely end up in court. Judges decisions and the inevitable
appeals could take years, and it was unclear whether work on the new base could continue in the
meantime or would remain frozen.
Masakazu Aharen, a professor at Shizuoka University, said getting Mr. Onagas decision overruled
could be politically costly for Mr. Abe. The prime ministers poll ratings fell this summer after he
pushed a set of national security bills through Parliament over widespread voter opposition. Ignoring
popular sentiment on Okinawa could add to his reputation for imperiousness.
Its a very big decision, Professor Aharen said.