You are on page 1of 16

Strategic Planning in Healthcare:

The Experience ofthe University of


Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics

DONNA K. SOLLENBERGER

SUMMARY » 1111999, after 25 years of stable leadership from a single CEO,


the University of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics (UWHC) Authority Board
named a new CEO. The 471-bed academic medical center had recently experi-
enced significant change and challenges. In 1996, it had emerged as a public
authority, a statutory designation by the state of Wisconsin that moved the hos-
pital and clinics from the University of Wisconsin and the state of Wisconsin,
and created it as a quasi-public entity with its ovm board. In 1999, when the
new CEO was named, the hospital was experiencing a loss of revenue and mar-
ket share, operating deficits, a 22 percent nurse vacancy rate, and patient satis-
faction scores below the 40th percentile. The first task assigned to the new
CEO by the board was the development of a new strategic plan that would
reverse these trends and position UWHC as a premier academic hospital.
The CEO began a strategic planning process that involved leaders, physi-
cians, and staff from throughout the hospital and clinics, its affiliated medical
school, and the physician practice plan. This article describes the collaborative,
integrative, and communicative strategic planning process UWHC used;
details the organization of the process; describes the results achieved by
UWHC; and lists the lessons learned along the way.

Donna K. Sollenberger is president and chief executive officer at the University


of Wisconsin Hospital and Clinics in Madison, Wisconsin.

D O N N A K. SOLLENBERCER • 17
T H E STATE OF THE HOSPITAL I N meeting volume and financial expectations:
THE WINTER OF 1999 margins had eroded from 3.1 percent to 1.2
In December of 1999,1 was appointed percent in one short year despite a 9.5 per-
president and chief executive officer ofthe cent charge increase, the nurse vacancy rate
University of Wisconsin Hospital and exceeded 20 percent, overall patient satis-
Chnics (UWHC), a 471-bed academic faction scores hovered below the 40th per-
medical center with over 20,000 admis- centile for academic medical centers, and
sions and 500,000 outpatient visits annu- employee morale was palpably low. No one
ally. Prior to that, I had been the chief had held the chief financial officer position
operating officer of two academic hospi- for four years, and the strategic plan lacked
tals, and while I had participated in strate- focus. Clearly, a new direction was needed.
gic planning, I had never led those efforts.
I had seen planning efforts fail from a STRATECIC PLANNING BEGINS
lack of organizational participation, from
a failure to use the strategic plan to drive Action without vision is a nightmare.
operations and organizational investment, —Japanese Proverb
and from a failure to stretch the vision
and goals to dramatically transform the Successful planning begins with owner-
organization. Thus, I found the UWHC ship ofthe process. While some organi-
situation simultaneously zations choose to appoint a strategic
The ultimate exhilarating and daunting; planning leader, the ultimate responsi-
responsibility and driving exhilarating because I bility and driving force for strategic plan-
finally had the opportunity ning must be the CEO. Many individuals
force for strategic may help with the process, but ulti-
to lead the effort, but
planning must be the daunting because for the mately the CEO, working with the board,
CEO. first time the planning and is responsible for strategy and direction.
responsibility ultimately This sets the tone at the top.
fell to me. The board—as well as the While the CEO is responsible for
entire organization—had great expecta- organizational strategy, the use of an
tions for new directions. experienced, outside consultant to facili-
While UWHC had benefited from 25 tate the process is critical for success.
years ofstable leadership, by December of The outside consultant should bring a
1999 UWHC had been through recent, national overview ofthe healthcare
dramatic change. As part ofthe University industry and the ability as a neutral
of Wisconsin System, the prior CEO had party to drive the organization to a deci-
reported to the university chancellor. The sion about strategic direction and issues,
hospital had also been a part ofthe state of particularly ones where organizational
Wisconsin, subject to all its policies and leaders have considerable or varied
procedures. In 1996, the hospital separated points of departure.
from the state and the university and A request for proposal (REP) that con-
became a public authority with the CEO tains clear planning objectives, consul-
reporting to its ovwi goveming board. In the tant responsibilities and experience,
summer of 1999, the hospital opened two deliverables, and an achievable timetable
new offsite outpatient clinics that were not is needed, as is the identification of

18 • FRONTIERS OF H E A L T H SERVICES MANAGEMENT 23:2


consultants familiar with healthcare, plan leaders, and members ofthe boards
and, in UWHC's case, academic health- ofthe hospital and practice plan—were
care. Once the RFP is issued, phone invited by the CEO to participate in the
interviews with the responders, onsite committees shown in Figure i. The five
interviews with the finalists, and careful working groups andfiveinput avenues
reference checking allow the organiza- reported to the leadership committee,
tion to select the consultant that is the which reported to the UWHC Authority
best fit for the CEO and the board. Board.
The invitation to participants stated
SUCCESSFUL STRATEGIC that they were expected to attend each
PLANNING BEGINS WITH meeting. The letter also included an esti-
CAREFUL PREPLANNING mation ofthe number of meetings (gen-
erally no more than four, two-hour
Spectacular achievements are always preceded meetings over a three-month period), the
by unspectacular preparation. topics each work group would address,
—Roger Staubach, and the beginning and ending dates for
Former NFL Quarterback the group's work. In the case ofthe lead-
ership committee, we scheduled two
The CEO and outside consultant can spend additional meetings to finalize the plan.
as much as two months in the preplanning If the individuals receiving the invitation
stage. At UWHC, preplanning began by could not attend all or a majority ofthe
identifying over 80 individuals from meetings, they were encouraged to
throughout the hospital, medical school, decline the invitation to allow someone
practice plan, and community to interview else to participate. (Very few people
and from whom to elicit opinions on key declined the invitation, and meeting
issues facing UWHC. From these inter- attendance was nearly 100 percent!)
views, the following key needs emerged Each work group and the leadership
that guided the creation of five strategic committee were assigned a UWHC staff
plan subcommittees: person to manage the meetings, notes,
and process. The work groups also were
1. improvement of service and access for assigned a staff person from the decision
patients; support department to manage informa-
2. strategies to retain and recruit UWHC tion and data requests. We also named a
employees, particularly in nursing; facilitator from the outside consultant
3. identification of a differentiating mar- group to each work group and the leader-
ket role; ship committee. The leadership commit-
4. better alignment among the medical tee included the chairs of each ofthe work
school, practice plan, and hospital; and groups to ensure coordination ofthe work
5. adoption of a clear and unified direc- groups' work product with the leadership
tion with respect to a local hospital. committee. The CEO provided a charge to
each work group, as well as a list of goals,
One hundred individuals—key hospital responsibilities, and members.
leaders, management and frontline An internal support person, in our
employees, medical school and practice case a senior management analyst, was

DONNA K. S O L L E N B E R C E R • 19
Figure 1 : Organizational Structure ofthe Strategic Plan

Strategic Planning
UWHC
Intranet Site
Board of Directors

Physician Reactor
Panels
1
Leadership
Patient and Family
Forums

Committee
Employee Forums
Health Science
Forums

* ' " ' • ' ' " A"

• Standard of Culture and Criteria to Financial • Local and


service morale evaluate performance regional
• Scheduling/ Organizational priorities Programmatic • Ambulatory
access values Potential performance strategy
• Admissions/ HR trends programmatic Access to future • Local hospital
discharge Compensation investments capital relationship
• Operating Fringe benefits Primary care Clinical • Branding
rooms Nursing and Service line resource • Outreach
• Bed capacity allied health development management • Primary care
• Outpatient professionals Inter- Capacity
capacity Support staff institutional/ Ambulatory
• Ambulatory organizational utilization
utilization program Managed care
• Culture development products and
• Information pricing
systems Fundraising
• Patient IS development
satisfaction Facilities
• Care development
systems

identified to support the CEO in the plan- the work groups' and leadership commit-
ning initiative. A master schedule of all of tee's work. The decision support depart-
the meetings, responsible individuals, and ment prepared data sets and support
dates, times, and locations was created. In materials for each work group and com-
addition, we developed a strategic plan- mittee member to provide an environ-
ning materials list. The CEO gave each mental assessment ofthe organization.
committee member a topic-appropriate All participants were invited to attend
book with a handwritten, personal mes- a two-hour training session to review the
sage inside. In addition, five to six articles goals ofthe plan, the responsibilities of
were sent in advance to provide a basis for the members ofthe work group and

2O • FRONTIERS OF HEALTH SERVICES MANAGEMENT 23:2


leadership committee, the key findings work. While the work groups began
ofthe consultant interviews, and the reviewing data, attacking the critical
organizational structure ofthe strategic issues, and forming recommendations,
planning initiative. The meeting also the leadership group started to review the
allowed the CEO to introduce the chairs vision and market position statements.
and facilitators ofthe leadership com- (The mission statement was not
mittee and the five work groups. addressed because UWHC's mission was
To elicit input from throughout the established by Wisconsin statute.) All par-
organization, our key constituents, and ticipants were encouraged to "think out-
customers, we created five additional side the box." The vision and market
input avenues: position statements the leadership com-
mittee developed follow.
1. Physician reactor panels to allow the
planning groups to present to internal Vision:
and referring physicians the plans as UWHC will be the foremost healthcare
they were developed and to elicit the provider and employer in Wisconsin, serv-
physicians' feedback throughout the ing as a statewide and national leader for
process. patient care, education, research, and com-
2. Health science forums that presented munity service.
evolving work group plans to faculty and
leadership ofthe schools of nursing, Market Position:
pharmacy, and medicine, and that UWHC will position itself as a market-
solicited feedback. responsive, regional healthcare provider
3. Patient and family forums that created of choice that offers a broad array of qual-
opportunities for customers to react to ity clinical services and emphasizes inno-
plans as they were developed. vation, learning, and cutting-edge
4. Employee forums that provided frontline research.
employees with eight opportunities for
input. VALUES
5. A strategic planning intranet site to m
post evolving plans for employee reac- Values are likefingerprints.Nobody's are the
tions. In addition, employees could same, but you leave 'em all over everything
use an e-mail address to submit sug- you do.
gestions to any ofthe work groups. —Elvis Presley

PLAWWONC BECDMS Another group led by the manager of


recruitment and comprised of former
Remember it wasn't raining when Noah built employees ofthe month developed a set
the ark. of recommendations for organizational
—Howard Ruff, author and financial values. This group was not a formal part
advisor ofthe planning process, something I
would change in the future. The impor-
In September, 2001, the work groups and tance of this group is that, heretofore,
leadership committee began their initial UWHC did not have consistent and well-

D O N N A K. S o L L E N B E R C E R • 21
articulated values. The group met multi- would enable UWHC to attain its vision
ple times to develop the following set of and market position:
values to recommend to the leadership
committee, which ultimately adopted them: 1. Achieve preeminence in selected, dis-
tinct tertiary services.
UWHC is guided in the pursuit ofthe mis- 2. Substantially elevate service quality and
sion and vision by a set of core values improve access for all of UWHC's cus-
expressed in the word CARE. These tomers.
values are: 3. Realize the full potential of existing
resources, including recent significant
• Compassionate Care—Compassionate investments in the local markets and
care takes the form of listening and primary care.
responding to the needs of all patients 4. Produce sufficient financial perfor-
and customers. mance and capital funds to meet the
• Active Learning—As an academic requirements ofthe strategic plan and
institution, we are committed to routine operations.
providing active, lifelong learning 5. Unify the clinical and academic enter-
opportunities for patients, staff, prise (UW Medical School [UWMS],
students, and the community. UW Medical Foundation [UWMF], and
• Respect for Others—We believe that UWHC) to speak with a single voice in
people who are treated with respect the market.
will respond positively. In all
interactions, we will be courteous, To meet the strategic goals, the leader-
kind, honest, and fair. ship committee adopted ten core strategies
Excellence and Innovarion—We strive to that would allow UWHC to achieve the
achieve the highest standards of cultural change needed for future success.
excellence in all we do. Expressed These strategies were highly interdepen-
individually and through teamwork, dent, requiring more alignment among
our commitment to excellence is a the three UW Health partners, enhance-
source of pride for those associated ment of UWHC's role in the market, and
with UWHC. improvements in service and access.

COALS AND STRATEGIES I. Develop an organizational culture


that reinforces UWHC's values and
Don't be afraid to take a big step when one is priorities, based on the core belief
indicated. You can't cross a chasm in two that patients come first. This goal was
small steps. the product of considerable debate
—David Lloyd George, Former about the core value of patient care in
Prime Minister of England an academic setting. Ultimately, all
participants in the leadership com-
The work groups created plans that mittee decided that everyone's focus
they forwarded to the leadership com- while practicing in the hospitals and
mittee. The leadership committee used chnics must be the patient, perhaps
the reports to finalize five goals that an obvious principle to some, but in

22 • FRONTIERS OF HEALTH SERVICES MANAGEMENT 23:2


an academic healthcare setting, a key leadership committee believed that
decision that allowed us to focus on gaining a better overall understanding
service as well as technical expertise. ofthe relationship between the local
2. Align the strategic, economic, opera- hospital and UW Health was essential
tional, and organization interests of for future clinical and academic suc-
UWHC, UWMF, and UWMS to cess.
ensure a coordinated approach to the 6. Develop distinctive tertiary services,
market and other providers. Until and position UWHC as the preemi-
2OOO, the CEOs ofthe practice plan nent regional referral resource while at
and hospital, as well as the dean, had the same time maximizing the value of
not met regularly. No formal mecha- significant prior investments in the
nism for programmatic and capital local market and primary care. The
planning existed. This goal commit- leadership committee decided that the
ted to much more collaboration, con- emphasis for the local market and pri-
solidation, and coordination. mary care woiild be on access and ser-
3. Align the economics, technology, and vice, while future investments should
organization of ambulatory care be made in eight areas called "clinical
within UW Health. UWHC, UWMF, program focus" priorities. The five
and UWMS all owned and operated boxes at the top of Figure 2 represent
clinics under the brand of UW the service lines for fixture strategic
Health, yet each clinic had its own development and investment, while the
information system, its own set of bands along the bottom represent the
policies, and different service stan- specific populations that would receive
dards, which created confusion the most investment for the future.
among patients using the various 7. Improve the profitability of UWHC's
clinics. payer arrangements. Several capitated
4. Promote "UW Health" as "the" acade- managed care contractual relationships
mic health system. The leadership were creating substantial losses for
committee believed that common UWHC. For fiiture financial health,
branding ofthe physician group and UWHC had to improve reimbursement m
hospitals and clinics "UW Health" and utilization within these contracts.
would minimize market confusion and 8. Improve employee retention and
take advantage of UW Health's strong recruitment. To reduce the turnover
brand recognition. and vacancy rates, particularly in nurs-
5. Define the collective relationship of ing, UWHC committed to improve its
UW Health—UWHC, UWMF, and culture, physical plant, and compensa-
UWMS—with a local hospital around tion. Changes to be pursued included
the clinical and academic needs of UW improved parking; increased work and
Health. Our area includes a local hos- break spaces; expanded training oppor-
pital that has an academic affiliation tunities that emphasized change man-
with the medical school and serves as agement/performance improvement/
the practice site for one-third of UW customer service training; and man-
Health physicians who function as a agement skills training for supervisors
community-based group practice. The and managers.
m

DONNA K. SOLLENBERCER 23
FIGURE 2 Service Line Development at UWHC

Trauma
Transplant Cardiovascular Oncology Neuroscience
Critical Care

t t t t t
9. Simplify and optimize the systems, eight-page report that wotild be available for
processes, and facilities that support distribution throughout the organization
access, service, and care management and to the public. The report was entitled
at UWHC, specifically, information HealthCAREfor the 21st Century, and the
technology improvements, the admis- UWHC Authority Board adopted the plan
sion and discharge process, and in March of 2002.
improvements in patient flow and
inpatient capacity. IMPLEMENTATION
10. Increase service to the community
and take a proactive role in shaping Both tears and sweat are salty, but they render a
and supporting sound legislative and different result. Tears will get you sympathy,
puhlic policy agendas. This strategy sweat will get you change.
was added when the leader- —Rev. Jesse Jackson
When we meet targets, we
ship committee asked,
set new goals so that we "what is missing from the Once the Authority Board approved the
are continually improving strategies articulated to plan, the UWHC executive council and the
date.^" UWHC needed a operations council began implementation.
our performance.
greater community pres- The two councils developed annual operat-
ence because our contributions were ing goals, and individual management
not well recognized by the community. goals developed during the evaluation
In addition, we needed to create a process were linked to organizational goals.
greater advocacy role for healthcare For each operating goal, the team assigned
policy, reimbursement, and graduate an executive/senior management sponsor
medical education. and developed a detailed list of tactics and
deadlines. Each sponsor assumed responsi-
The work group reports were consoli- bility to provide quarterly executive council
dated into two documents, a comprehen- updates.
sive and detailed report that management In 2002, UWHC developed formal busi-
would use for implementation, and an ness plans for oncology, cardiovasailar.

24 • FRONTIERS OF HEALTH SERVICES MANAGEMENT 23:2


transplant, and children's services. We measure our progress toward the stated
established targets including market share, goal. Any measure in the red or yellow
admissions, clinic visits, and profitability, outcome category required the senior
and administrative directors were hired to manager or executive responsible for that
work with the service-line physician target to submit an improvement plan
leaders. with dates for completion. That plan was
monitored by the executive council to
PROGRESS MEASUREMENT ensure implementation ofthe corrective
plan. In addition, when we met targets,
You cannot manage what you cannot measure. we set new goals so that we were continu-
—Phil Murphy ally improving our performance.
After the executive and operations
At this point, the executive council real- councils had used the dashboard for one
ized that UWHC needed a much more year, we began to roll out the dashboard to
consolidated and robust means to manage 80 directors. Each director received one-
the implementation. We began to develop on-one training in its use, development of
an organizational dashboard that con- variance reports, and application ofthe
tained important measures that linked to dashboard principles to their areas. While
the annual operating and strategic goals. we did not have individual departmental
The senior vice president for medical dashboards at the time of director rollout,
affairs and the CFO were the executive we decided it was important for all man-
sponsors ofthe dashboard development. agement to understand the organizational
Initially, we developed six domains of goals. We have subsequently developed
excellence. Beneath each domain, we "The Dashboard Dozen," a series of
linked specific measures to organizational UWHC's 12 most success-critical factors
strategic goals. The six domains included from the dashboard, and we share it with
patient satisfaction; market position— all employees and post it on the intranet.
patient access; clinical effectiveness, qual-
ity, and safety; operational efficiency; UPDATING THE PLAN
employee growth and management; and
financial health. Excellence is the gradual result of always striv-
The executive and operations councils ing to do better.
>
actively participated in the dashboard —Pat Riley, head coach ofthe 2006 NBA
development. We used simple visual champions, the Miami Heat
cues—red, yellow, and green—to indicate
progress toward meeting the goals. We
-i
In the spring of 2003, the CEO and
also identified the target measure using Authority Board decided UWHC should
available benchmarks, such as percentile engage an outside consultant and update
rank for hospitals in the patient satisfac- our plan. While we had achieved signifi-
tion survey, or we developed our own tar- cant results, we were concerned that the
gets based on our current performance original plan might be missing important 70
and the goal we wanted to achieve. These elements. We also committed to a three-
targets became part of the dashboard, and year planning cycle, but with the caveat that
the monthly outcomes allowed us to each three-year plan would not necessarily m

DONNA K. S O L L E N B E R C E R • 25
be a full-blown review ofthe mission, while the other five remained essentially
vision, and values or a complete environ- the same. Because the hospital is located in
mental assessment. a 30-year-old building and is now land-
The differences in the second planning locked, the sixth goal stated that the hospital
initiative versus the first included: must continue the development of on-
campus and off-campus solutions to
• selection ofthe outside consultant by address future facility needs. In addi-
the hospital, with considerable input and tion, we developed the following nine
consensusfromthe CEO ofthe medical strategies instead often.
group and the dean;
• a decision not to update the mission, 1. Achieve a culture of quality that pro-
vision, and values and, instead, to duces superior patient care outcomes
focus on the goals and strategies; and and customer service.
• reduction in the number of interviews 2. Align the strategic, economic, opera-
(from 80 to 50). tional, and organizational interests of
UWHC, UWMF, and UWMS to ensure
The consultant interviews concluded an overarching commitment to quality
that UWHC had made great progress and a coordinated approach to care
toward meeting the 2001 plan goals; how- delivery.
ever, the financial performance and unified 3. More tightly align ambulatory care
enterprise goals firom the 2001 plan needed across UW Health to improve patient
to receive greater emphasis because less service and decrease costs.
progress had been made. In addition, the 4. Increase operating efficiency to maxi-
UWHC Board and the executive team mize utilization of current resources to
decided that quality, capacity, and market accommodate future capacity needs.
presence would have a direct impact on 5. Become the ultimate employer for Madi-
UWHC's ability to flirther distance itself son and the region.
from the competition. 6. Increase the proportion of patient activ-
The organization ofthe planning effort ity from outside the local market for
looked very similar to the one three years both inpatient discharges and outpatient
prior; however, we replaced the employee clinic visits.
retention and recruitment work group with 7. Enhance structure and infrastructure for
a quality work group because most ofthe outreach to achieve regional alliances
initiatives for employee growth were now and promote increased inpatient and
embedded into operations, and consider- outpatient activity from outside the local
able progress had been made. In addition, market.
from the time we completed the first plan, 8. Achieve or exceed targets for financial
public reporting of quality had become performance to fiind capital and strate-
much more commonplace, and we needed gic priorities.
a more comprehensive, organizational 9. Enhance service to the commimity
approach. The new planning structure is through leadership in improving access
shown in Figure 3. for underserved populafions, legislative
As a result ofthe second planning initia- advocacy for sound health policy, and
tive, UWHC added one organizational goal continued outreach and education.

26 • FRONTIERS OF HEALTH SERVICES MANAGEMENT 23:2


FD C U R E 3 Mid-Cycle Strategic Review—Organizational Structure

UWHC Board
of Directors

Leadership Committee
(Steering Committee)

Unified H Financial
Enterprise i H Performance
WorkGroup H WorkGroup
Model of Future staff Outreach and UW Health Utilization
care needs referral commitment management
Outcomes - Model of network Common Operational
Customer care development processes, efficiency
Service assump- Out-of-area systems, and Philanthropy
Patient and tions draw for information Contracting
staff safety Future facility program Structure and
Processes needs priorities incentives to
and systems - Distribution Infrastructure grow UW
Infrastruc- of services to support Health
ture - Future out-of-area
expansion patients

During the planning process we Board, physicians, hospital leadership and


changed slightly the clinical program focus management, and frontline employees.
areas. We emphasized the special popiila-
tions of geriatrics and women; however, we RESULTS
incorporated the emphasis on children
through the clinical priority areas. While we ...right efforts will invariably bring about right m
continued our organizational commitment results.
to critical care and trauma, we did not des- —James Allen, author of As a Man Thinketh
ignate it as a clinical priority area this time.
Our revised clinical program focus areas The results of this structured approach to
included children, transplant services, car-
diovascular services, oncology, neuro-
planning, implementing, and measuring
demonstrate its success.
H
science, and orthopedics.
We presented the new plan to the
UWHC Authority Board at its March 2004
Patient Satisfaction C
Adult inpatient satisfaction has increased
meeting, where it was adopted. Aptly enti- from the 37th percentile of hospitals of
tled FOCUS for the Future, the plan was 450 to 599 beds to consistently exceed the
again the subject of many communications 90th percentile ofthe same comparison
throughout the organization in written and group for over four years. This result is
face-to-face forums among the Authority shown in Figure 4. m

DONNA K. SOLLENBERCER • 27
FIGURE 4: Adult Inpatient Satisfaction Results June 2000 to March 2006

B FY2000, Ql n FY2005, Ql FY2006, Q3


TOO _

80 _
n
60 _

40 _

I
20 _

^''

Employee Recruitment and Retention Philanthropic giving increased from an


Nurse vacancy fell from i8 percent to 4.2 average of $1 million per year in June of
percent; overall hospital vacancy rates fell 2000 to $10 million per year from July of
from 8 percent to 4.8 percent, and 2003 through June of 2006.
employee turnover rates declined from
16.9 percent to 12.2 percent. Nurse OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCY
turnover rates declined from 12.5 percent Lengths of stay declined from 6.2 days to
to 7.6 percent. 5.3 days. Patients' diversions declined from
a high of 100 to fewer than 20 per month.
Financial Performance Through a structured long-stay review
The operating margin increased from 0.5 process, discharges with a length of stay
percent to 4.4 percent; the total margin greater than 30 were reduced from an
increased from 1.2 percent to 5.9 percent. average of 199 in first quarter of 2003 to
Days cash on hand decreased from 142 80 in March of 2006.
days to 131 days, while the value of one
day's cash increased from $1,078,890 to Clinical Effectiveness, Quality,
$1,833,000. and Safety
During the same period, cash reserves During 2003 to 2006, UWHC received
increased from $145,773,000 to a number of national recognitions based
$239,584,000. Days in accounts receiv- on its submission of quality data. These
able decreased from 71 days to 44 days. include being named a 2004 Quest for

28 • FRONTIERS OF HEALTH SERVICES MANAGEMENT 23:2


Quality finalist by the American Hospi- tiatives that are used to achieve the
tal Association, a 2003 and 2004 Solu- plan.
cient Top 100 Hospital, a 2005 The process must be collaborative,
Solucient Top 100 Heart Hospital, a top involving physicians, frontline
quartile performer in the Leapfrog Sur- employees, and management, as well
vey, and in April 2005 one of 50 Excep- as leadership from other partner insti-
tional U.S. Hospitals by Consumer's tutions, such as the medical school
Digest. and practice plan.
In the fall of 2005, UWHC was the Involve many people through focus
top performer among 73 academic groups, reactor panels, and group
health centers in a quality and account- communication, but keep working
ability study conducted by University groups and leadership committees
Health System Consortium. The trans- small—no more than 12 people.
plant program exceeded all national and Use of an outside facilitator with expe-
regional United Network for Organ rience at similar organizations is a
Sharing (UNOS) benchmarks, and Uni- must so that you take advantage of the
versity Health Systems Consortium most current national thinking as well
named the cardiovascular program a as have someone who will push and
best performer for acute myocardial challenge your assumptions.
infarction in 2004. The plan must focus on those pro-
By the end of fiscal year 2006, every grams and competencies that are
strategic operating goal had been met or likely to help achieve distinctiveness
exceeded, with some goals achieved up in the market and promise the great-
to two years ahead of plan. est levels of successful outcomes.
Make tough decisions and prioritize.
Your organization doesn't have
CRITICAL SUCCESS FACTORS
enough people, space, or money to
implement all the good ideas and pro-
Success is a journey, not a destination. It
grams that will surface.
requires constant effort, vigilance, and
reevaluation.
Implementation and outcome mea- m
sures must receive the same focus and
—Mark Twain
rigor as development ofthe strategic
plan. In fact, all operational goals and
The leaders of every planning initiative
should take time to examine what the par- initiatives must help to advance the
ticipants learned from the process and plan. If not, they should be parked or
understand the factors critical for suc- eliminated.
cess. Our experience produced the fol- Have the right people with the right skills
lowing list of lessons learned. to implement the plan; you may need to
invest in people through training.
• All components ofthe plan must be Plans should be revised at least every
strategically managed and integrated. three years. The marketplace and
Figure 5 represents the strategic plan healthcare change rapidly enough that
framework that needs to be managed a thorough examination ofthe plan and
and the UWHC annual operating ini- modifications are needed frequently.
m

DONNA K. S O L L E N B E R C E R • 29
FIGURE 5 UWHC Strategic Management Framework

Component Description UWHC Initiatives

• Continuous, evolving • Annual, ongoing, dynamic • Implementation


plans stratigic planning process subcommittees
• Continuous, managed • Annual, ongoing, • Budget planning
implementation structured and controlled
• Capital planning
implementation
process • Program planning
• Finance and operations • Ongoing interaction, not • Define what we will and will
integrated limited to budget or not do
project review • Integrated budget
• Ongoing development process
• Strategy and
management decision making • Integrated program and
integrated driven by resource planning
strategic • Principles of decision making
direction driven by the plan

• Strategic planning and management the work believing that they can make a
must become embedded into the difference.
fiber ofthe organization. All goals, Today, strategic management has
decisions, and investments must be become embedded in the culture of
made to meet the plan goals. UWHC. People are encouraged and
• Cood tools to track and report on empowered to make decisions and act in
progress are essential. ways that advance a well-communicated
• The process must be led from the top strategic plan. We have seen no limit to
with the CEO in charge ofthe plan. what individuals and teams can achieve
The culture of communication and when their energy, commitment, and
focus must be led by the CEO and the skills are harnessed by a strong, cohesive
executive team to create a culture of plan. Staff at UWHC have responded
strategic management and focus enthusiastically, and leaders are commit-
throughout the organization. ted to future strategic planning to keep
• Communicate, communicate, the organization productively focused and
communicate! continually renewed.

In the end, you can do everything REFERENCES


Allen, J. "James Allen Quotes." [Online resource;
expressed in this article, but you will retrieved 8/7/06.] www.brainyquotes.com.
get nowhere if you do not have the lead- Jackson, J. 1994. "Action." In Speaker's Sourcebook II.
ers who will inspire the workforce and Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc, p. 15.
employees and physicians who will do Lloyd George, W. "William Lloyd George Quotes."

30 • FRONTIERS OF HEALTH SERVICES MANAGEMENT 23:2


[Online resource; retrieved 8/7/06.] Thinkexist.com/quotes/pat_riley.
www.brainyquotes.com/quotes/html. Ruff, H. 1994. "Preparation." In Speaker's Source-
Murphy, P. [Online resource; retrieved 11/7/06.] book II. Englewood Cliffs, NJ; Prentice-Hall,
en.thinkexist.com/quotes/phil-murphy. Inc, p. 301.
Presley, E. "Principles and Expediency, Values." Staubach, R. 1994. "Preparation." In Speaker's
[Online resource; retrieved 8/7/06.] Josephson Sourcebook II, Englewood Cliffs, NJ; Prentice-
Institute of Ethics, www.josephsoninstitute.org/ Hall, Inc, p. 301.
quotes/quoteprinciple.html. Twain, M. "Mark Twain." [Online resource;
Riley, P. "Pat Riley Quotes." [Online resource; retrieved 8/7/06.] www.leader-values.com/con-
retrieved 8/7/06.] tent/quotes.asp?Letter=M.

DONNA K. SOLLENBERCER • 31

You might also like