Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Premise 1: A city is
deemed valid to exist only
when the net utility of the
city's population trumps
the net ecological footprint
that generates huge costs
to the city
Sub-Premise: Majority of
the city's population lacks
to contribute to the
betterment of the society
in matters of arts, research
and Maslovian ventures
Sub-Premise: Life in
cities is unsatifactory,
chaotic, stressful and has a
long-term negative impact
on the future generations,
as it lowers human selfdevelopment and
potential.
pulmonary disease than cities. The age-adjusted death rate for unintentional injuries
amongst the rural American population was 86% higher than city-dwellers. (MS,
2001) These facts can be linked to the premise that effective healthcare facilities are
lacking in rural areas, which Peele failed to acknowledge. Furthermore, less than 11
percent of physicians in the U.S. practice in rural areas, contrasted with the 20 percent
of the population that comprises the rural American population. These recruitment and
retention problems in rural areas are related to factors such as lower salaries,
geographic isolation from educational opportunities, and lesser facilities, all of which
are provided in cities. (Survey, 2002) More than 20 million rural Americans live in
rural areas that have a provider-to-patient ratio of 1 to 3,500 or less and are federally
deputed as health professional shortage areas (HPSAs), while the recommended
provider-to-patient ratio is 1 physician for every 2,000 persons. (Program, 1997)
Peeles first key argument claims that majority of a citys population doesnt actually
contribute to the betterment of the society. This is backed up by reports that estimate
828 million people living as urban poor in slum conditions within cities, constituting
for around one third of the worlds urban population (World Urbanization Prospects,
2010). The urban poor as well as the mundane middle class create no value to arts,
research and other service reform issues, thus increasing the citys combined
ecological footprint with no benefit of reducing the costs associated with the citys
existence.
References
Chen-Yen Chang, P.-K. C. (2005). Human Response to Window Views
and Indoor Plants in the Workplace. HortScience, 40(5), 13541359.
MS, E. (2001). Urban and Rural health Chart-book. Hyattsville:
National Centre for Health Statistics.
Program, N. C. R. H. R. (1997). Facts about Rural Physicians. North
Carolina.
Survey, N. H. I. (2002). Rural and Urban Health.
World Health Organization, U. N. H. (2010). Hidden Cities: World
Health Organization.
Young, R. D. (2013). Environmental Psychology Overview Green
Organizations: Driving Change with IO Psychology. New York:
Routledge.