Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FO C U S
Free thinking
The innovative design of a hospital project in Nottinghamshire
prompted major departures from the prescriptive Firecode
guidance. Andy Passingham reports
HE Central Nottinghamshire
Modernisation of Acute Services
scheme includes the 95,000m2
redevelopment of Kings Mill
Hospital in Sutton-in-Ashfield, Nottinghamshire, England. It includes both
refurbishment and new-build elements.
The existing facilities are being fully
redeveloped to create a single unified
hospital comprising 28 new wards, a new
state-of-the-art diagnostic and treatment
centre called the Kings Treatment
Centre (KTC) a new emergency care
and assessment centre with an out-ofhours general practitioners service, and
a dedicated women and childrens centre.
Some of the new facilities are now in
use, although the project is due to be
fully completed in 2011.
Three T-shaped ward blocks, linked
together over five floors, are located to the
rear of the diagnostic and treatment and
women and childrens centres. These two
major new-build elements are separated
by a concourse about 200m in length.
The women and childrens centre,
which has its own dedicated entrance
from the main hospital concourse, is
a two-storey elliptical building, which
includes outpatient and rapid access
departments, as well as in-patient facilities.
Challenging Firecode
This project has been the first major
PFI healthcare project for SHCA in
the UK. From Arups perspective as fire
engineers, it has been clear from the
start that the architects approach to
design of the building, particularly the
diagnostic and treatement centre block,
has been unhindered by the healthcare
design baggage sometimes encountered
with designers who have been using
the Department of Healths Firecode
guidance documents technical fire
safety guidance for healthcare for many
years.
Horizontal evacuation
Guidance for the fire safety design of
healthcare buildings is given in the
Firecode suite of Health Technical
Memorandum (HTM) documents. This
building was designed based on HTM
81: Fire Precautions in New Hospitals
(now superseded by HTM 05-02).
www.frmjournal.com
M A Y 2010 31
FO C U S H e a l t h c a re
32 MAY 2010
ww w . f r m j o u r n a l . c o m
Vertical compartments
It is often acknowledged that the HTM
guidance does not address diagnostic
treatment buildings particularly well,
and this project provides a good example
of this. The strength of the HTM
document is that it is likely to produce
a conservative solution. However, where
innovation is desired, closer examination
of the code is essential.
A conventional code-based approach
would require each floor to form a
separate fire compartment in the KTC
block. As can be seen in Figure 1, the
open fingers which bring natural light
Healthcare FOCUS
FO C U S
Linking walkways
To address the issue of the dead ends and
stairs in each finger, walkways linking
the ends of the fingers were introduced.
This greatly enhances the horizontal
evacuation, allowing options for moving
into adjacent compartments from all
areas of the KTC block. By providing
these additional options for horizontal
egress, the number of stairs required
could be reduced.
By extending the logic of initial
horizontal evacuation, it became
possible to provide a single stair in each
compartment. These were moved into
the voids and are fully open, designed
to appear as accommodation stairs. The
protection to the stairs is provided by
the lines of compartmentation in the
building occupants would not use
the stairs to evacuate the fire-affected
compartment; the stairs would only be
used once occupants had already passed
into an adjacent, protected compartment.
Concourse space
Linking the KTC block to the rest of
the building is a large concourse space.
As this area is used as part of the egress
routes for the KTC, and is a key area of
the building, it is provided with automatic smoke control. This is designed
using a fire engineering approach, based
on agreed design fire scenarios. These
are developed to allow flexibility in
the use of the concourse base, while
ensuring that fire in this space would
not cause the evacuation of the adjacent
compartments.
The smoke control system is provided
by coordinating the natural ventilation
of the space at high level with the
openings required for smoke venting,
and providing automatically opening
make-up air routes at low-level into
the space to ensure effective removal of
smoke. This is shown in Figure 4.
To assist the NHS foundation trust
with the implementation of the fire
strategy, typical examples of the level
of fire loading that the smoke control
system is designed for were provided.
This was based on a collection of fire
www.frmjournal.com
M A Y 2010 33
BAFSA
Page
H e a l t11:10
h c a re
FO
C ad
U S21/4/10
BAFSA ad
21/4/10
11:10
Page 1
Safer Living
Safer Living
The benefits of automatic fire suppression
British Automatic Fire Sprinkler Association
The benefits
suppression
systemsofinautomatic
residentialfirecare
premises
systems in residential care premises
Sprinklers
Safer Living
Living
Sprinklers for Safer
isisaareport
commissioned by
byBAFSA
BAFSA
report by
by Arup
Arup Fire, commissioned
ISBN:
ISBN: 0-0-9552628-6-9
0-0-9552628-6-9
34 MAY 2010
FAS Ad Quarter.indd 1
ww w . f r m j o u r n a l . c o m
19/02/2010 09:18