Professional Documents
Culture Documents
205
Abstract. Reclamation of former, degraded forest lands occupied by Imperata cylindrica is one of the crucial environmental and forestry issues in the humid tropics, notably Southeast
Asia. We suggest that it is possible to gradually restore the
original natural forest cover with the help of a sacrifice fallow
crop of fast-growing exotic tree species. Recently, a set of
suitable fast-growing plantation tree species has been identified and stand establishment methods developed for this purpose. We assessed the regeneration of natural vegetation in
stands of different plantation tree species and evaluated the
ecological impact of species composition in the plantation
understorey. PCA ordination, regression analysis and analysis
of covariance were applied at different stages of the study. We
found a marked vegetational resemblance between stands
dominated by Acacia mangium: they had the highest number
of indigenous trees in their understorey, whereas stands of
other plantation trees supported more diverse grass and herb
vegetation. A high proportion of evergreen woody vegetation
reduces the risk of fire and grass competition and enhances
secondary succession towards natural forest.
Keywords: Acacia mangium; Natural regeneration; Reforestation; Restoration ecology; Forest management.
Nomenclature: George (ed.) (1981); Anon. (1982).
Introduction
Along with the increasing population pressure and
need of new agricultural land, natural forests of southeast Asia are being decimated. During 1978 - 1988, the
deforestation rate has been 16 000 km2/yr. However, the
forest area is actually diminishing twice as fast as the
permanent agricultural land is increasing (Anon. 1992).
The difference may be accounted for by unsustainable
land use practices, including repeated logging of valuable timber particularly Dipterocarpaceae trees, which
often predominate the upper canopy layers (Kostermans
1992). Logging is usuall followed by illegal cutting of
the residual timber, and subsequent shifting cultivation
206
Kuusipalo, J. et al.
Results
151 vascular plant species, 89 trees, 19 shrubs, 13
climbers, 11 herbs, 9 grasses and 10 ferns, were found
growing spontaneously in the 5 to 6-yr old plantations.
Complete data are available upon request. Tree species
with a frequency > 50 % in the plantations include
Glochidion capitatum, Vitex pubescens, Alstonia angustiloba, Buchanania arborescens and Ficus grossularioides; the most frequent herbaceous species were Imperata cylindrica and Eupatorium pallescens. Both species
produce much above-ground biomass, particularly under open canopies. 18 of the tree species found in the
plantations, belonging to 11 families, were also found in
the Imperata cylindrica grasslands. They are apparently
adapted to the frequent occurrence of fires. Grasses
accompanying the dominant I. cylindrica include Saccharum spontaneum, Bromus insignis and Scleria spp.
Species-area relationships
The number of species appeared to be independent
of compartment size (Y = 27.12 + 5.262 log X; r2 = 0.14).
However, the number of tree species (Fig. 1) and the
arcsin-transformed ratio: tree species / total number of
all vascular plant species (Fig. 2) were significantly
related to log compartment size.
207
Species
Area NT VT
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
15
16
17
0.91
2.75
0.84
1.98
0.25
4.51
2.57
0.20
1.41
0.50
1.27
2.31
0.37
0.85
0.50
0.50
0.50
1987
1987
1986
1986
1991
1986
1986
1986
1986
1986
1986
1986
1987
-
13
16
10
29
6
24
35
4
16
16
25
14
3
13
4
9
10
1
21
6
5
18
3
2
8
6
22
31
3
6
26
10
12
7
Analysis of covariance
The arcsin- transformed percentage of the number of
tree species out of the total number of all understorey
vascular plant species was compared in the three
floristically different subsets of samples, pure Acacia
mangium stands, mixed A. mangium stands and stands
208
Kuusipalo, J. et al.
where A. mangium was not planted. Due to the dependency of the dependent variable on the size of the sample
plot (see Figs. 1 and 2), compartment size was used as a
covariate in the analysis (Table 2).
The result is quite straightforward. Both stand type
and compartment size have a reasonably significant
effect with a statistical risk level of about 1/20 on the
ratio between the number of tree species and the number
of all species. Multiple a posteriori comparison of means
(LSD) reveals that both pure and mixed A. mangium
stands differ significantly from all other stand types but
not from each other. In other words, the proportion of
tree species is significantly higher in pure or mixed A.
mangium stands than in the rest of the stands, where
grasses and other herbaceous vegetation prevail.
Discussion
Reforestation of Imperata cylindrica grasslands is
extremely difficult due to compact and nutrient-deficient soil, hydrologic instability, large variation in surface temperatures of the soil, grass competition and
allelopathy, and high fire susceptibility of the grass
(Soerianegara 1980; Ohta 1992; Parrotta 1993). Natural
succession processes are prevented by annual fires,
which, together with other conditions listed above, destroy plant propagules and seedlings, as well as fungal
root symbionts.
Problems of reforestation have already been studied
intensively in the Indonesian-Finnish trial area of Riam
Kiwa for more than ten years. More than 100 species
have been tested, including fast-growing exotic plantation species already mentioned above, but also easily
propagated indigenous trees have been planted and evaluated in the area, including dipterocarps such as Shorea
spp., Hopea spp. and Vatica spp., and others, e.g. Durio
spp., Peronema canescens, Artocarpus spp., Macaranga
spp. and Agathis borneensis.
Several exotic species of pioneer tree character have
shown promising reforestation results in terms of growth
as well as in suppressing I. cylindrica. However, a
successful establishment of these species requires rather
heavy site preparation, which turns over the rhizomes of
I. cylindrica and improves the rooting of tree seedlings
(Otsamo et al. in press). On the other hand, reforestation
with native climax species directly on grassland has
proved impossible or at least very laborious and expensive (e.g. Appanah & Weinland 1993). Low survival of
these most probably results from shallow rooting unable to penetrate into compact soil, and from the lack of
adequate fungal root symbionts (e.g. ectomycorrhizae
of dipterocarps). Rehabilitation of original vegetation
seems feasible only if environmental conditions are im-
- Restoration of natural vegetation in degraded Imperata cylindrica grassland improving the nutrient status (Sanchez & Miller 1986).
Phosphorus uptake is efficient due to the symbiosis with
compatible vesicular-arbuscular (VA) mycorrhizal fungi
(Malloch et al. 1980). All in all, A. mangium seems to
favour shade-tolerant, relatively nutrient- and moisturedemanding tree species at the expense of light-demanding herbs and grasses in its understorey.
Inside the Eucalyptus deglupta plantation the light
intensity was seemingly much higher than in A. mangium
plantations of the same age, and the amount of I.
cylindrica grass consequently much larger. Poor shading and vigorous competition by grass may have inhibited the germination and survival of the indigenous plant
seedlings. Plantations of Paraserianthes falcataria provided better shading than E. deglupta, and I. cylindrica
had been mostly replaced by other plants. However, the
stand was light enough to allow the weed Eupatorium
pallescens to become dominant, followed by Clibadium
spp. as the second commonest shrub. The shrubby understorey of P. falcataria is also pyrogenic, making the
stand very susceptible to fire during the dry season.
Some of the promising tree species were perhaps
underrated in this study due to a limited sample of
stands; e.g. Gmelina arborea was represented just by
one recently established compartment, although it is
known to have a good capability to suppress the grass
(Otsamo et al. in press).
Successful plantations seem to be able to act as
initial steps in the secondary succession of I. cylindrica
grasslands back to natural forests by allowing many
indigenous forest tree species to colonize the site within
a relatively short period of time. Acacia mangium is a
particularly suitable species because it turns the resource supply ratio into a more favourable one for
woody perennial undergrowth: light becomes a more
limiting resource than nitrogen, moisture and other soil
resources. Grasses and herbs cannot take advantage
from improved soil conditions due to their generally
higher light demand compared to woody perennials
which, in turn, can only establish on an improved soil
(Tilman 1982).
The more woody, evergreen undergrowth, the lesser
susceptibility to fire damage. This is a rule of thumb
which has, for a long time, been appreciated by foresters
and forest scientists working in Imperata areas, as well
as elsewhere in the tropics (Lugo et al. 1993; Parrotta
1993). A. mangium seems to provide an alternative
which creates suitable conditions for an abundance of
understorey trees. The results of this study support
suggestions made by Parrotta (1993), i.e. that forest
plantations on degraded tropical lands can be used not
only for production of wood and other forest commodities but also for soil improvement and acceleration of
secondary forest succession. Species and provenance
209
Sum-of squares
Extra
Area
Error
0.445
0.284
0.571
DF
2
1
10
Mean-square
0.223
0.284
0.057
F-ratio
3.901
4.976
0.056
0.050
1.000
0.045
0.031
1.000
0.867
1.000
210
Kuusipalo, J. et al.
References
Anon. 1982. Flora Malesiana. Series 1 - Spermatophyta (Flowering Plants). Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague.
Anon. 1983. Mangium and other fast-growing acacias for the
humid tropics. National Academy Press, Washington, DC.
Anon. 1990. Rehabilitation of logged-over forests on Asia/
Pacific Region. Report prepared for ITTO (International
Tropical Timber Organization) by the Japan Overseas
Forestry Consultants Association (JOFCA). Yokohama.
Anon. 1991. Indonesian Tropical Forestry Action Programme.
Country Brief. Ministry of Forestry, Government of Indonesia/ FAO, Jakarta.
Anon. 1992. World Resources 1992-1993. A report by the
World Resources Institute. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Appanah, S. & Weinland, G. 1993. Planting quality timber
trees in Peninsular Malaysia. Malayan Forestry Record
38. Forest Research Institute, Kepong, Kuala Lumpur.
Burnham, C.P. 1984. The forest environment: soils. In:
Whitmore, T.C. (ed.) Tropical Rain Forests of the Far
East (2nd ed.), Chapter 11. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Dela Cruz, R.E. 1986. Constraints and strategies for the reforestation of Imperata cylindrica grasslands. In: Forest regeneration in Southeast Asia. Proceedings of the symposium held in Bogor, Indonesia, 9-11 May, 1984. BIOTROP
Special Publication No. 25: 23-34. BIOTROP, Bogor.
Eussen, J.H.H. & Wirjahardja, S. 1973. Studies on alangalang (Imperata cylindrica (L.) Beauv.) vegetation. BIOTROP Bulletin 6. BIOTROP, Bogor.
George, A.S. (ed.) 1981. Flora of Australia. Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra.
Jongman, R.H.G., ter Braak, C.J.F. & van Tongeren, O.F.R.
1987. Data analysis in community and landscape ecology.
Pudoc, Wageningen.
Kostermans, A.J.G.H. 1992. A handbook of the Dipterocarpaceae of Sri Lanka. Wildlife Heritage Trust of Sri
Lanka. P.T. Gramedia, Jakarta.
Lugo, A.E. 1993. Tree plantations for rehabilitating damaged
forest lands in the tropics. In: Wali, M.K. (ed.) Environmental Rehabilitation. SPB Academic Publishing, The
Hague.
Lugo, A.E., Parrotta, J.A. & Brown, S. 1993. Loss in species
caused by tropical deforestation and their recovery through
management. Ambio 22: 106-109.
Malloch, D.W., Pirozynski, K.A. & Raven, P.H. 1980. Ecological and evolutionary significance of mycorrhizal
symbioses in vascular plants. A Review. Proc. Nat. Acad.
Sci. USA 77: 2113-2118.
Ohta, S. 1992. Influence of deforestation on the soils of the
Pantabangan area, Central Luzon, the Philippines. Soil
Sci. Plant Nutr. 36: 633-643.
Otsamo, A., djers, G., Hadi, T.S., Kuusipalo, J., Mikkil, A.
& Vuokko, R. In press. Effect of site preparation and
initial fertilization on the establishment and growth of four
plantation tree species used in reforestation of Imperata
cylindrica dominated grasslands. For. Ecol. Manage.
Parrotta, J.A. 1992. The role of plantation forests in rehabilitating degraded tropical ecosystems. Agric. Ecosyst. En-