Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Corrosion Protection
A Specifiers Guide
Hot-Dip Galvanizing for C o r r o s i o n P r o t e c t i o n
A Specifiers Guide
Corrosion: Wh a t & W h y … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … . . . 1
Corrosion Concerns
Metal & Alloy Corrosion
The Corrosion Process
Galvanic Corrosion
Corrosion of Steel
Hot-Dip Galva n i z i n g f o r C o r r o s i o n P r o t e c t i o n . . . … … … … … … … … … … … … … . . 3
History of Galvanizing
Iron & Steel Protection Methods
Galvanizing Process
Surface Preparation
Galvanizing
Inspection
The Metallurgical Bond
Coating Thickness
Design of Pro d u c t s f o r G a l v a n i z i n g … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … . 7
Sizes, Shapes, & Dimensions
Mechanical Properties
Other Design Considerations
Welding
Bolting
Painting Galvanized Steel
Environmental Compliance
Economics of G a l v a n i z i n g . . . . . … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … .10
Economic Analysis
Initial Cost
Life-cycle Cost
Cost-Per-Square-Foot-Per-Year Value Theory
Galvanizing’s Advantages: a Capitalized Expenditure
Cost Factors Associated with Other Corrosion Control Methods
Galvanizing vs. Painting
Corrosion Res i s t a n c e o f G a l v a n i z e d C o a t i n g s . . . … … … … … … … … … … … … … . . 1 1
Atmospheric Conditions
Chemical & Liquid Environments, Solution pH
Fresh Water
Sea Water
Soils
Concrete
Other Metals
Pra ctical Uses o f G a l v a n i z e d S t e e l ... . . . … … … … … … … … … … … … … . . … … … … . 18
Bridges & Highways
Power Generation
Contents
Transportation
Water & Waste Water Treatment
Buildings
Agriculture & Food Processing
Petrochemical & Chemical
Pulp & Paper
Original Equipment Manufacturing
©2006 American Galvanizers Association. The material provided herein has been developed to provide accurate and authoritative information about after-
fabrication hot-dip galvanized steel. This material provides information only and is not intended as a substitute for competent professional examination
and verification as to suitability and applicability. The information provided herein is not intended as a representation or warranty on the part of the AGA.
Anyone making use of this information assumes all liability arising from such use.
Galvanic Corrosion
Metals are rarely found in their pure state, but
are almost always found in chemical combination
with one or more nonmetallic elements. Significant
energy must be applied to reduce the ore to a pure
metal. This energy can be applied via metallurgical
or chemical means. Additional energy also may be
applied in the form of cold working or casting to
transform the pure metal into a working shape.
Corrosion can be viewed as the tendency for a metal
produced and shaped as a result of substantial
energy input to revert to its natural, lower energy
state. From a thermodynamic perspective, the
tendency to decrease in energy is the main driving
force for the corrosion of metals.
there are four elements necessary for corrosion to Figure 2: Arrangement of Metals in the Galvanic Series
occur: CORRODED END
Anodic or less noble
Anode - An anode is an electrode at which Cathodic protections can
(ELECTRONEGATIVE)
negative ions are discharged and positive ions Magnesium occur when two metals are
are formed, or other oxidizing reactions occur. Zinc electrically connected. Any
Corrosion occurs at the anode. Aluminum one of these metals and
Cathode - A cathode is an electrode at which Steel alloys will theoretically
positive ions are discharged, negative ions are Lead corrode while offering
protection to any other that
formed, or other reducting reactions occur. The Tin
Nickel is lower in the series, so
cathode is protected from corrosion.
Brass long as both are electrically
Electrolyte - An electrolyte is a conducting medium Bronzes connected.
in which the flow of current is accompanied by Copper
movement of matter. Electrolytes include water Stainless Steel (passive) However, in actual
solutions of acids, bases, and salts. Silver practice, zinc is by far the
most effective in this
Return Current Path - The return current path is Gold
Platinum respect.
the metallic pathway connecting the anode to the
PROTECTED END
cathode. It is often the underlying, substrate.
Cathodic or more noble
Removing any one of these elements will stop (ELECTROPOSITIVE)
the current flow and corrosion will not occur.
Substituting a different metal for the anode or instance of recycled steel, uneven internal stress, or
cathode may cause the direction of the current exposure to a non-uniform environment.
to reverse, resulting in a change of the electrode
experiencing corrosion. It is easy for microscopic areas of the exposed metal to
become relatively anodic or cathodic. A large number of
The galvanic series lists metals and alloys in such areas can develop in a small section of the exposed
decreasing order of electrical activity (Figure 2). metal. Further, it is highly possible several different
Metals toward the top of the list are “less noble” types of galvanic corrosion cells are present in the same
metals and have a greater tendency to lose electrons small area of the actively corroding piece of steel.
than metals found lower on the list.
As the corrosion process progresses, the electrolyte
Corrosion of Steel may change due to materials dissolving in or
The actual corrosion process that takes place on precipitating from the solution. Additionally, corrosion
a piece of bare steel is very complex due to factors products might tend to build up on certain areas of the
such as variations in the composition/structure of metal. As time goes by, there may be a change in the
the steel, presence of impurities due to the higher location of cathodic and anodic areas and previously
uncorroded areas
Figure 3: Changes in cathodic and anodic areas of the metal are
attacked and corrode
C A A C
A C (Figure 3).
A C C
The corrosion
C A A
A C C
rate of metals is
C A A
controlled by factors
such as temperature,
Mosaic of anodes and cathodes, Moisture in the air provides the As anodic areas corrode, new humidity, pH of the
electrically connected by the electrical path between anodes material of different composition electrolyte, and the
underlying steel. and cathodes. Due to differences and structure is exposed. This
electrical potential
in potential, electric current results in a change of electrical
begins to flow as the anodic areas potentials and changes the and resistance of
are consumed. Iron ions location of anodic and cathodic anodic and cathodic
produced at the anode combine sites. Over time, previously areas.
with the environment to form the uncorroded areas are attacked
flaky iron oxide known as rust. and uniform surface corrosion
results. This continues until the
steel is entirely consumed.
Surface preparation for galvanizing typically Fabricated items are immersed in the bath long
consists of three steps: caustic cleaning, acid enough to reach bath temperature. The articles are
pickling, and fluxing. withdrawn slowly from the galvanizing bath and
egreasing - A hot alkali solution is often used to
D the excess zinc is removed by draining, vibrating,
remove organic contaminants such as dirt, paint and/or centrifuging.
markings, grease, and oil from the metal surface. The chemical reactions that result in the
Epoxies, vinyls, asphalt, or welding slag must be formation and structure of the galvanized coating
removed before galvanizing by grit blasting, sand continue after the steel is withdrawn from the bath
blasting, or other mechanical means. as long as the steel is near the bath temperature.
ickling - Scale and rust normally are removed
P The articles are cooled in either water or ambient
from the steel surface by pickling in a dilute air immediately after withdrawal from the bath.
solution of hot sulfuric acid or ambient temperature
Inspection
hydrochloric acid.
The two properties of the hot-dip galvanized
urface preparation also can be accomplished
S coating closely scrutinized after galvanizing are
using abrasive cleaning as an alternative to or coating thickness and coating appearance. A
in conjunction with chemical cleaning. Abrasive variety of simple physical and laboratory tests may
cleaning is a process whereby sand, metallic shot, be performed to determine thickness, uniformity,
or grit is propelled against the steel material by adherence, and appearance.
air blasts or rapidly rotating wheels.
Products are galvanized according to long-
luxing - Fluxing is the final surface preparation
F established, well-accepted, and approved standards
step in the galvanizing process. Fluxing removes of ASTM, the International Standards Organization
oxides and prevents further oxides from forming (ISO), the Canadian Standards Association (CSA),
on the surface of the metal prior to galvanizing and the American Association of State Highway
and promotes bonding of the zinc to the steel or and Transportation Officials (AASHTO). These
iron surface. standards cover everything from the minimum
Steel or iron materials are dipped in an aqueous required coating thicknesses for various galvanized
solution of zinc ammonium chloride to apply the items to the composition of the zinc metal used in
flux layer. The material is then thoroughly dried the process.
prior to immersion in liquid zinc.
Testing methods and interpretation of results
Galvanizing are covered in the publication, The Inspection of
During the “galvanizing” process, the material is Products Hot-Dip Galvanized After Fabrication,
Cooling and
Drying Zinc inspection
Flux bath
Rinsing solution
Pickling
Degreasing Rinsing
published by the American Galvanizers as in service. The toughness of the galvanized coating
Association (AGA). This publication, as well as is extremely important since barrier protection is
all others referenced in this guide, can be found dependent upon the integrity of the coating.
in the literature section of the AGA website
(www.galvanizeit.org). Other coatings damage easily during shipment or
through rough handling on the job site. Experts will
The Metallurgical Bond argue all organic forms of barrier protection (such
Galvanizing forms a metallurgical bond between as paint) by their nature are permeable to some
the zinc and the underlying steel or iron, creating degree. Galvanized coatings are impermeable.
a barrier that is part of the metal itself. During
If the galvanized coating is physically damaged,
galvanizing, the liquid zinc reacts with the surface
it will continue to provide cathodic protection to
of the steel or iron article to form a series of zinc-
the exposed steel. If individual areas of underlying
iron alloy layers. Figure 5 is a photomicrograph
steel or iron become exposed as much as 1/4 inch,
of a galvanized steel coating’s cross-section and
the surrounding zinc will provide these areas with
shows a typical coating microstructure consisting
cathodic protection for as long as the coating lasts.
of three alloy layers and a layer of pure metallic
zinc. Moving from the underlying steel surface Figure 6 (next page) shows how corrosion will
outward, these are: begin and immediately progress at a scratch or gap
• The thin Gamma layer composed of an alloy in a paint coating. Figure 7 (next page) shows how
that is 75% zinc and 25% iron, corrosion will be prevented at a scratch or gap in a
• The Delta layer composed of an alloy that is zinc coating.
90% zinc and 10% iron, The galvanizing process naturally produces
• The Zeta layer composed of an alloy that is coatings that are at least as thick at the corners and
94% zinc and 6% iron, and edges as the coating on the rest of the substrate. As
• The outer Eta layer that is composed of pure coating damage is most likely to occur at the edges,
zinc. this is where added protection is needed most.
Below the name of each layer in Figure 5, its Brush or spray applied coatings have a natural
respective hardness, expressed by a Diamond tendency to thin at the corners and edges. Figure 8
Pyramid Number (DPN) appears. The DPN is a is a photomicrograph showing a cross-section of an
progressive measure of hardness (i.e., the higher edge of a galvanized piece of steel.
the number the greater the hardness). Typically, Because the galvanizing process involves total
the Gamma, Delta, and Zeta layers are harder than immersion of the material, it is a complete process;
the underlying steel. The hardness of these inner all surfaces are coated, including recesses and
layers provides exceptional protection against hard to reach corners. Galvanizing provides both
coating damage through abrasion. The Eta layer outside and inside protection for hollow structures.
of the galvanized coating is quite ductile, providing Hollow structures that are only painted have no
some resistance to impact. corrosion protection on the inside.
The galvanized coating is
Figure 5: Photomicrograph of a galvanized coating
adherent to the underlying
steel on the order of several
thousand pounds per square
inch (psi). Other coatings
typically offer adhesion rated
at several hundred psi.
• Levels of carbon less than 0.25%, phosphorus Figure 9: Effect of silicon on coating thickness
less than 0.04%, or manganese less than 1.35% COATING THICKNESS CURVE
are beneficial 250
The phosphorus content should never be greater 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4
large welded steel assemblies or castings weighing exceed 12 square inches. See the AGA’s publication
several tons. Galvanizing kettles up to 40-feet long Recommended Details for Galvanized Structures
are available in most areas, and it is common to find for more information on this topic.
kettles approaching 60 feet. Through progressive
dipping (sometimes called “double-dipping” – for Welding
products too deep or too long to fit into the kettle), it When welded items are galvanized, both the
is possible for the galvanizer to process articles that cleanliness of the weld area after welding and
exceed kettle dimensions. If you have questions the metallic composition of the weld itself affect
about a product’s galvanizability, contact your galvanizing quality and appearance. Some welding
galvanizer or the AGA. techniques that lead to good results include:
• Use of an uncoated electrode where possible,
Mechanical Properties
• Thorough removal of all welding flux residues
According to studies by the BNF Metals Technology
if a coated electrode is used,
Centre in the United Kingdom (as well as numerous
other national and international studies), hot-dip • Producing little or no slag,
galvanizing produces no significant changes in • Use of a submerged arc method for heavy
the mechanical properties of the structural steels weldments,
or welds commonly used throughout the world. • Selection of welding rods providing a deposited
The galvanized substrate steel is chemically and weld composed of the same materials as the
metallurgically equivalent to the uncoated steel. parent metal, and
• Avoiding welding rods high in silicon.
Other Design Considerations
Galvanizing requires cleaning solutions and liquid Galvanized materials may be welded easily and
zinc flow into, over, through, and out of fabricated satisfactorily by all common welding techniques.
articles. Designs that promote the flow of zinc are The American Welding Society (AWS, www.aws.
optimal. org) has produced a book detailing all aspects of
welding galvanized items. In general, anything that
Filling and vent holes must be provided to prevent can be welded before galvanizing can be welded
pickling or other cleaning bath fluids from becoming with relative ease after galvanizing. A copy of the
trapped in the piece. It is best to avoid narrow gaps AWS recommended welding practices is available
between plates, overlapping surfaces, and back-to- from the AGA or your local galvanizer.
back angles and channels. When overlapping or
contacting surfaces cannot be avoided, all edges Bolting
should be completely sealed by welding but provided Hot-dip galvanizing is a well established and
with a small hole or a short gap in the welding to widely used process for coating mechanical
relieve pressure build-up in overlapping areas that fasteners and welded joints. The prime mechanical
Figure 10: Bolt tension chart fasteners used for making field
kN (kips) connections in steel are bolts that conform
222.5 (50) to ASTM A 307, A 325, and A 394 and are
GALVANIZED BEESWAX ON NUT galvanized in accordance with ASTM A
153/A 153M and CSA standards. Bolted
178.0 (40)
galvanized structural joints can be
GALVANIZED AS RECEIVED BLACK AS RECEIVED
designed for both bearing- and friction-
type connections. Galvanized joints of this
Bolt Tension
19 x 76mm
44.5 (10) 3/4" x 3" BOLTS tension of galvanized versus black bolts.
A lubricated galvanized bolt can develop
greater joint tension than a black bolt.
0 1.05 2.09 3.14 4.19 5.24 6.28 7.33 8.38 For more information, refer to the AGA
publication Bolted Galvanized Structural
Joints. It provides additional information
(60) (120) (180) (240) (300) (380) (420) (480)
on the characteristics and advantages of bolted The specifier should check with the galvanizer to
galvanized structures and bolting procedures. determine if these facilities are available. When the
design life of a fabricated item exceeds the service
Painting Galvanized Steel life of the galvanized coating without a duplex
Galvanized articles are easily and successfully system, the initial galvanized coating can provide
painted. The two factors critical to success are proper subsequent corrosion protection by adding a brush
post-galvanizing surface preparation and proper or spray applied paint system. When a paint-based
paint system selection. Galvanized steel is painted corrosion protection system on bare steel reaches the
for a number of reasons: aesthetics, safety marking, end of its service life, abrasive blasting or grinding
and the desire for even longer lasting protection. back to white steel is frequently necessary in order
Galvanizers must be notified if galvanized steel to repaint. Preparation of a previously galvanized
is to be subsequently painted so they can avoid surface for a properly selected paint-based system
applying a post galvanizing treatment that affects of corrosion protection is normally much simpler.
paint adhesion.
Two AGA publications give more information on
A corrosion protection system consisting simply duplex systems; Duplex Systems: Painting Over
of galvanizing provides long-term, cost-effective Hot-Dip Galvanized Steel, and Practical Guide for
corrosion protection. Often the expected service Preparing Hot-Dip Galvanized Steel for Painting.
life of the galvanized coating actually exceeds the In addition to providing a wealth of technical
design life of the structure it protects. However, details and a discussion of the suitability of a
a duplex system, (paint over galvanizing), greatly number of different types of paints for application
extends the period effective corrosion protection is after galvanizing, these publications also present
provided. A useful rule of thumb is a duplex system a number of specific applications and color
will provide corrosion protection for 1.5 times the photographs of duplex systems.
sum of the service lives of the individual systems.
For example, if the life of the galvanized coating Environmental Compliance
in a particular environment is 35 years and the United States Environmental Protection
expected service life of the paint system is 10 years, Agency (EPA), in addition to many state and local
the expected service life of the duplex system will environmental protection agencies, has established
be 67.5 years [i.e., 1.5 x (35+10)]. While such duplex restrictions governing volatile organic compounds
systems often have a premium first cost, they are (VOCs). Many brush and spray applied corrosion
usually the lowest life-cycle cost solution. They protection systems contain VOCs and are thus
may be the only feasible solution for structures subject to this regulation. The galvanized coating
in aggressive environments where later in-service contains no VOCs and is compliant with these
painting is extremely difficult or impossible. regulations.
The synergy of duplex systems in Example of a duplex system (painting over galvanized steel)
corrosion protection stems from three
known factors:
• The paint film extends the life of
the galvanized coating by providing
additional barrier protection to the
zinc layers,
• An underlying layer of zinc tends to
prolong the life of a paint coating by
preventing an underlying layer of
corrosion from developing, and
• The corrosion products of zinc and its
alloys further retard paint coating
damage by sealing cracks and pores in
paint films.
Some galvanizers do have facilities to
shop-apply paint coatings after galvanizing.
Economics of Galvanizing
Economical Analysis life of 40-50 years, future repainting costs must be
Any exposed steel must be protected to ensure added to the total corrosion protection costs.
an effective service life. The cost of corrosion Maintenance painting consumes a significant and
protection for a structure will range from 0.5% to escalating portion of operating and maintenance
5% of the cost of the project. In exceptional cases, budgets. As more focus is placed on controlling
where a large area of lightweight steel is exposed maintenance costs, a reliable, low-maintenance
to corrosive attack, the corrosion protection system corrosion protection system can be estimated by
may represent a much more significant part of the using commonly accepted economic formulas.
project budget.
Cost-Per-Square-Foot-Per-Year Value Theory
First Cost The current method for evaluating any coating
Looking at the two primary corrosion protection system is to determine its cost in dollars per square
systems, galvanizing and paint, it is necessary to foot per year over the life of the structure. Concern
define the specifications for each so a reasonable with the cost of corrosion protection per square foot
cost comparison can be conducted. The galvanized of steel has attracted significant attention among
material normally would be specified to ASTM A 123/ specifiers, engineers, and corrosion consultants.
A 123M. This calls for a minimum coating thickness The cost-per-square-foot-per-year method seeks to
of 2.3 ounces of zinc per square foot of steel surface. minimize costs by analyzing all cost components
Based on a 2006 survey of galvanizers nationwide, including first cost, operating costs, and maintenance
the cost of the galvanizing component package in costs. An economic analysis that includes both
the fabricated steel price is approximately $240 - initial costs and future maintenance costs should
$440 per ton, depending upon size, geographic area, be used to select the most economical protective
and type of project. Assuming a 20% markup by coating system. When constructing a comparison of
the fabricator, the cost to a contractor would range costs, each system must be examined in detail for
from $288 - $528 per ton. possible additional costs and savings.
A high-performance paint system frequently
Galvanizing’s Advantage: a Capitalized Expenditure
specified in competition with galvanizing consists
Generally accepted accounting practices for
of an inorganic zinc primer, a high-build epoxy
building maintenance dictate maintenance
intermediate coat, and a polyurethane topcoat. To
painting be considered an operating expense. The
function properly, this high-performance system
expenses of galvanizing can be capitalized because
must be applied over a steel surface blasted to a
these expenses generally occur during construction.
Society for Protective Coatings (SSPC) Specification
Under this accounting practice, galvanizing does
of at least SP 10. Using the 2006 coatings economics
not compete for precious operating dollars.
survey published by the National Association of
Corrosion Engineers (NACE) as a baseline for the Cost Factor Associated with Other Corrosion
estimated cost for shop application, costs for this
paint system are approximately $874 per ton.
Control Methods
A multitude of cost elements exist typically not
These numbers indicate galvanizing is far included in an economic analysis:
more economical than the paint system it is often • Surface preparation in the field when repainting,
compared to. Remarkably, even more costs savings • Environmental compliance in the field when
are realized when the total project cost, or life-cycle repainting,
cost are compared.
• Downtime during painting operations,
Life-Cycle Cost • Containment systems,
Based on a moderate exposure to corrosive elements, • Materials disposal,
the galvanized system will have a projected life (to • Weather delays, and
5% surface rust) in excess of 75 years. The paint • Insurance and other unknown, uncontrollable
system, based on the same NACE report, will require factors.
repainting in approximately 21 years. Therefore,
when designing a structure with an anticipated These factors may cause the cost of repainting
to accelerate well beyond the projected cost a maintenance-free life for at least 50 more years.
as determined by the economic analysis. As a
case in point, the State of Ohio Department of The painted steel received a paint recoating in
Transportation has projected a 43% increase in 1969 during bridge expansion. Another painting
maintenance painting costs in one year. was done in the fall of 1980 and the summer of
1981. Localized touch-up painting was done again
Galvanizing requires little if any maintenance in 1991 and had already started to fail in 1997.
in comparison to the maintenance demands of
paint systems. When all elements in the economic Figure 11 shows the cumulative estimated
analysis are included, galvanizing has the lowest future costs for maintaining the structure in 1969
life-cycle costs. dollars. The cost for the galvanized structure is
fixed during the 80-year span, but the costs for
Galvanizing vs. Painting the paint option grow rapidly. Galvanizing saves
The Leaside Bridge, owned by Metropolitan money on the first cost and savings increase as
Toronto, extends 1300 feet over the Don Valley long as the structure exists.
Parkway at Millwood Road and originally was built
in 1927 using painted structural steel. Figure 11: Cumulative future maintenance costs
In 1969, it was decided that the bridge would $1,120,000
Cost in
be widened from four to six lanes. When bids 1969 dollars
were tendered, three different approaches were
solicited:
Option 1: Blast clean and paint all structural $700,000
steel (specified as blast clean, zinc rich primer,
$600,000
and two-coat vinyl). Initial cost: $294,000
Option 2: Galvanize new steel in the expansion, $500,000
and blast clean and repaint the bridge’s original $400,000
steel in the field (same paint specifications as
above). Initial cost: $230,000 $300,000
Environments in which galvanized steel and iron and density of corrosive fumes and pollutants,
commonly are used include outdoor atmospheres, amount of sea spray, number of wetting and drying
indoor atmospheres, hundreds of different cycles, and the duration of exposure to moisture.
chemicals, fresh water, sea water, soils, concrete, Although there is a range in observed corrosion
and in contact with other metals. Because of the rates, actual observed rates rarely exceed 0.3 mils
many years galvanizing has been used for corrosion per year. It is also worthwhile to note that when
protection, a wealth of real-world, long-term exposed indoors, the life of the galvanized coating
exposure data on zinc coating performance in a will be at least two to three times longer than
wide variety of environments is available. outdoor exposure in the same environment.
emissions. Most city or urban areas are classified Figure 13: Effect of pH on corrosion of zinc
as “moderately industrial.” 14
Sea Water types of soils have been identified and are categorized
Galvanized coatings provide considerable according to texture, color, and natural drainage.
protection to steel when immersed in sea water Coarse and textured soils, such as gravel and sand,
and exposed to salt spray. Influencing factors in permit free circulation of air, and the process of
the corrosion of zinc in fresh water also apply to corrosion may closely resemble atmospheric corrosion.
sea water; however, the dissolved salts (primarily Clay and silt soils have a fine texture and hold water,
sulfides and chlorides) in sea water are the resulting in poor aeration and drainage. Generally
principal determinants of
the corrosion behavior of Table 2 : Corrosion of zinc coated steel in selected natural fresh waters
zinc. Given the high level of Location and water Type of Type of Agitation Corrosion rate
chloride in sea water, a very Zinc Test mil/year
high corrosion rate might Gatun Lake, Canal Zone Intermediate Immersion Stagnant 0.52
be expected. However, the Tropical fresh water
presence of magnesium and Gatun Lake, Canal Zone Intermediate Immersion Stagnant 0.41
calcium ions have a strong Tropical fresh water
inhibiting effect on zinc Pedro Miguel Locks Special high Immersion -- 0.71
corrosion. One should be Panama, Fresh water grade
very skeptical of accelerated Pedro Miguel Locks High grade Immersion -- 0.53
laboratory test results that Panama, Fresh water
sometimes use a simple Pedro Miguel Locks Intermediate Immersion -- 0.44
sodium chloride (NaCl) Panama, Fresh water
solution to simulate the Pedro Miguel Locks Select Immersion -- 0.55
effects of sea water exposure Panama, Fresh water
on galvanized steel. Real Pedro Miguel Locks Prime Immersion -- 0.53
world results often differ Panama, Fresh water Western
significantly.
River Water 99% zinc Immersion Still 0.56
Hardness 7-6˚ (German) Lab
Soils
More than 200 different River Water 99% zinc Immersion Still 0.24
Hardness 7-6˚ (German) Lab
speaking, sandy, well- Figure 15 : Corrosion of galvanized steel pipe in contact with a variety of soils
aerated soils with neutral AISI Chart for Estimating Average Invert Life for Galvanized CSP
or slightly basic pH cause
only limited corrosion,
most likely below 10 μm/
year (0.4 mil/year).
0
1 3 12 1 3 12 1 3 12
Other Metals
Under atmospheric or aqueous condition, if zinc
Months of C uring
comes in contact with another metal, the potential
for corrosion through a bimetallic couple exists.
Source: University
of California
Black Galvanized
The extent of the corrosion Table 3 : Comparison of epoxy-coated and hot-dip galvanized reinforcing steel bars
depends upon the position Comparison Factor Hot-Dip Galvanized Epoxy-Coated
of the other metal relative Earliest Use Early 1900’s 1974
to zinc in the galvanic series
Requires care in handling No Yes
(Figure 2, page 2).
Can be dragged on ground Yes No
Installation requiring MUST be touched up No Yes
contact between galvanized Has barrier protection Yes Yes
materials and copper or Has cathodic protection Yes No
brass in a moist or humid Bond strength to concrete Excellent Poor
environment, can cause UV Resistance Good Questionable
rapid corrosion. Even run-
After fabrication application Simple Difficult
off water from copper or
brass surfaces can contain Widely used Yes Yes
enough dissolved copper Cost Comparable Comparable*
to cause rapid corrosion. Lead time 1-3 days 3 weeks
If contact with galvanized Availability of coating for other Readily available Scarce
items is unavoidable, embedded items
precautions should be * Epoxy prices vary widely throughout the US and Canada and wide variations
taken to prevent electrical should be expected
contact between the two
and aluminum or stainless steel is unlikely to cause
metals. Joint faces should be insulated with non-
substantial incremental corrosion. However, under
conducting gaskets and connections should be
very humid conditions, the galvanized surface may
made with insulating, grommet-type fasteners.
require electrical isolation through the use of paint
The design should ensure water is not recirculated
or joining compounds. The galvanic behavior of
and flows from the galvanized surface towards the
galvanized coatings in contact with various metals
copper or brass surface and not the reverse.
in atmospheric and immersion environments is
Under atmospheric conditions of moderate to mild summarized in Table 5, (next page).
humidity, contact between a galvanized surface
Table 4: Field performance of bridges with galvanized reinforcing steel
Inspection Chlorides Zinc Coating Thickness
Location Installed
Date (lb/yd3) mils µm
Boca Chica Bridge, FL* 1972 1975 1.95 5.1 130
1991 2.02 4.0 102
1999 3.21 6.7 170
Tioga Bridge, PA* 1974 1981 0.58 5.9 150
1991 1.06 8.8 224
2001 2.23 7.8 198
Curtis Road Bridge, MI 1976 2002 6.88 6.1 155
Spring Steel Bridge, VT 1971 2002 4.17 7.5 191
Evanston Interchange, WY 1975 2002 2.55 9.3 236
* Multiple inspections were made on these bridges. Since concrete cores are drilled out of the bridge, it is impossible
to perform this inspection in the same spot. When performing subsequent inspections, the cores must be drilled
in different areas which doesn’t allow for corrosion monitoring in one particular area. Hot-dip galvanized coating
thicknesses vary slightly over the length of the bars. This explains how a greater coating thickness can be read
when measuring the same bridge at a later date.
Table 5 : Additional corrosion of zinc and galvanized steel resulting from contact with other metals
Environment
Atmospheric Immersed
Metal in Contact
Rural Industrial/ Marine Fresh Sea
Urban Water Water
Aluminum and aluminum alloys 0 0-1 0-1 1 1-2
Aluminum bronzes and silicon bronzes 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 2-3
Brasses - high tensile (HT) brass (manganese bronze) 0-1 1 0-2 1-2 2-3
Cadmium 0 0 0 0 0
Cast irons 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 2-3
Cast iron (austentic) 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 1-3
Chromium 0-1 1-2 1-2 1-2 2-3
Copper 0-1 1-2 1-2 1-2 2-3
Cupro-nickels 0-1 0-1 1-2 1-2 2-3
Gold (0-1) (1-2) (1-2) (1-2) (2-3)
Gunmetals, phosphor bronzes, and tin bronzes 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 2-3
Lead 0 0-2 0-2 0-3 (0-2)
Magnesium an magnesium alloys 0 0 0 0 0
Nickel 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 2-3
Nickel copper alloys 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 2-3
Nickel-chromium-iron alloys (0-1) (1) (1-2) (1-2) (1-3)
Nickel-chromium-molybedenum alloys (0-1) (1) (1-2) (1-2) (1-3)
Nickel silvers 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 1-3
Platinum (0-1) (1-2) (1-2) (1-2) (2-3)
Rhodium (0-1) (1-2) (1-2) (1-2) (2-3)
Silver (0-1) (1-2) (1-2) (1-2) (2-3)
Solders hard 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 2-3
Solders soft 0 0 0 0 0
Stainless steel (austenitic and other grades
0-1 0-1 0-1 0-2 1-2
containing approximately 18% chromium)
Stainless steel (martensitic grades containing
0-1 0-1 0-1 0-2 1-2
approximately 13% chromium)
Steels (carbon and low alloy) 0-1 1 1-2 1-2 1-2
Tin 0 0-1 1 1 1-2
Titanium and titanium alloys (0-1) (1) (1-2) (0-2) (1-3)
KEY 0 Zinc and galvanized steel will suffer either no additional corrosion, or at the most only very slight additional
corrosion, usually tolerable in service.
1 Zinc and galvanized steel will suffer slight or moderate additional corrosion that may be tolerable in some
circumstances.
2 Zinc and galvanized steel may suffer fairly severe additional corrosion and protective measures will usually be
necessary.
3 Zinc and galvanized steel may suffer severe additional corrosion and the contact should be avoided.
( ) - Ratings in brackets are based on very limited evidence and hence are less certain than other values shown.
Note: The table is in terms of additional corrosion and the symbol “0” should not be taken to imply that the metals in
contact need no protection under all conditions of exposure.
Source: British Standards Institution, pp. 6484: 1979, Table 23