Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 23
1 23
SHORT REPORT
Introduction
For architectural and environmental psychology, urban
design enhances stress feelings or well-being and quality of
life: perceived quality of urban design plays a role in
eliciting positive psychological molar responses, such as
place attachment and satisfaction.
Interests on urban quality constantly increased: e.g.
United Nations proposed CPI (City Prosperity Index), a
global, multidimensional tool to test cities prosperity (a
broad concept including wealth, happiness, and health)
avoiding a mere economical conception of it (UN-HABITAT 2012). CPI is a conceptual matrix with five dimensions composing a Wheel of Prosperity: productivity,
infrastructure, quality of life, equity, and environmental
sustainability are the wheel spokes.
The CPI mirrors a tool tapping so-called objective
quality assessment (Gifford 2002) of the urban environment, i.e. a kind of technical or expert assessment relying
on specific tools and measure systems (metrics, weights)
well established in the scientific and technical domain. This
type of tools fails in capturing the urban subjective
environmental quality (Bonaiuto et al. 2003), that is, the
users view and experience of a given place. The latter
relies on self-report tools for expressing a persons perceptions, observations, and impressions (but it could
comprise behavioural measures too). Tools measuring the
subjective environmental quality reflect a user-centred approach and help an evidence-based design
(EBD) approach to urban design and management (Bonaiuto 2004).
123
Method
Tool
PREQIs tool covers four macro-evaluative residential
quality aspects (eleven scales). First, architectural/urban
123
PREQI
Italy
(N = 1488)
N items
N items
Chongqing
(N = 340)
a
N items
1. Building aesthetics
.88
.89
.83
.86
.90
.84
.79
.84
3. Building volume
1. Internal practicability
6
8
.89
.83
6
8
.92
.76
5
6
.78
.74
4
6
.89
.74
2. External connections
.77
.76
.73
.80
10
.85
10
.89
10
.84
.85
.85
.92
.80
.82
1. Green areas
1. Security
N items
Istanbul
(N = 227)
2. Building density
V. Welfare services
Paris
(N = 383)
2. Discretion
.86
.78
.71
.68
3. Sociability
.81
.81
.69
.82
1. Education services
.85
.76
.71
.83
.71
.70
.62
.77
1. Sport services
.88
.84
.82
.89
2. Socio-cultural activities
.84
.84
.72
.72
1. Commercial services
.90
.82
.78
.82
1. Public transport
.89
.84
.68
.75
1. Relaxing/distressing
.89
.91
.75
.90
2. Stimulating/boring
.84
.88
.69
.77
7
12
.91
.85
7
12
.90
.85
7
12
.78
.79
7
10
.88
.85
X. Environmental health
XI. Maintenance and care
1. Environmental health
1. Upkeep and care
Number of items (N items) and internal consistency (a) in different linguistic contexts (compared to the Italian national sample, from Bonaiuto
et al. 2006)
Data analysis
Principal component analyses (PCAs) were run for each of
the eleven scales, to test factorial structure. Factor extraction was carried out on the results emerged in previous
Italian studies (see Bonaiuto et al. 2003, 2006; Fornara
et al. 2010b) and on the screen test output. Cronbachs
alpha tested factor reliability.
Results
Presented cross-cultural data confirm previous Italian
studies outcomes (Bonaiuto et al. 2006).
Table 1 reports a summary of the comparison between
Italian national samples and French, Turkish and Chinese
linguistic contexts samples.
Items number loading on each PREQIs is averagely
similar to the Italian results in the French context, whereas
it is averagely lower in the Turkish and Chinese contexts,
maybe reflecting higher culturallinguistic distance of such
samples from the original one. Cronbachs alpha is
acceptable: between .92 and .70 in the French sample; .84
and .69 in the Turkish sample (except for one factor
scoring .62); and .89 and .68 in the Chinese sample.
123
PREQI
Italy
(N = 1488)
N items
Malmo
(N = 110)
N items
Madrid
(N = 150)
N items
Tabriz
(N = 239)
N items
.74
1. Building aesthetics
.85
.79
.70**
2. Building density
.72
.75
.77
3. Building volume
1. Internal practicability
3
3
.83
.67
3
2
.93
.67**
3
2
.76
.37**
3
2
.80
.54**
2. External connections
.82
.81
.84
.80
1. Green areas
.87
.80
.80
.88
1. Security
.78
.92
.85
.87
2. Discretion
.79
.49**
.71
3. Sociability
.73
.83
.72
V. Welfare services
VI. Cultural-recreational services
1. Education services
.79
.31**
.81
.86
.62
.79
.69
.78
1. Sport services
.82
.88
.89
.91
2. Socio-cultural activities
.71
.68
.21*
.36**
1. Commercial services
.88
.85
.88
.87
1. Public transport
.81
.67
.79
.75
1. Relaxing/distressing
.71
.71
.71
.84
2. Stimulating/boring
.67
.76
.72
.77
1. Environmental health
1. Upkeep and care
4
4
.86
.70
4
4
.89
.68
4
3
.72
.69
4
3
.89
.93
X. Environmental health
XI. Maintenance and care
Number of items (N items) and internal consistency (a) in different linguistic contexts (compared to the Italian national sample, from Fornara
et al. 2010b)
In two-item indicators, the Pearsons r bivariate correlation is reported (** p \ .01; * p \ .05)
123
References
Bonaiuto M (2004) Residential satisfaction and perceived urban
quality. In: Spielberger C (ed) Encyclopedia of applied psychology, vol 3. Elsevier Academic Press, Oxford, pp 267272
Bonaiuto M, Alves S (2012) Residential places and neighbourhoods:
toward healthy life, social integration, and reputable residence.
In: Clayton SD (ed) The oxford handbook of environmental and
conservation psychology. Oxford University Press, New York,
pp 221247
Bonaiuto M, Fornara F (2014) PREQIs structure and reliability in
cross-cultural surveys. In: Paper presented at the 28th international conference of applied psychology (ICAP) From Crisis to
Sustainable Well-Being. Palais de Congre`s, Paris (France),
813 July 2014
Bonaiuto M, Aiello A, Perugini M, Bonnes M, Ercolani AP (1999)
Multidimensional perception of residential environment quality
and neighbourhood attachment in the urban environment.
J Environ Psychol 19:331352
123