Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AGENDA BILL
AB 1003
Date, 2015
Consent Calendar
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
AMOUNT OF EXPENDITURE
$ N/A
AMOUNT BUDGETED
$ N/A
APPROPRIATION REQUIRED
$ N/A
RECOMMENDATION
Ratify appointments /reappointment to the Forest and Beach Commission and the Historic Resources
Review Board.
SUMMARY
City Boards and Commissions perform a valuable service to the City by providing a means by which the
City Council can obtain advice, opinions, and recommendations of City residents and other members of
the community.
For this cycle of appointments/ reappointments, the City Council is presented with a total of seven
scheduled Boards and Commission vacancies with terms ending September 30, 2015. The deadline for
applicants for Boards and Commission vacancies has been extended to September 18, 2015.
Mayor Burnett and Vice Mayor Talmage interviewed a first round of applicants for
appointments/reappointments the Forest and Beach Commission and Historic Resources Board and
their recommendations are attached.
ATTACHMENTS
Page 1
Date:
Douglas J.
Page 2
..6~ ~- /~
I
Ashlee Wright
From:
Sent:
To:
Cc:
Subject:
Jason K. Burnett
831 .238.0009
jason.bumetttmgmail.com
Margaret L. Eaton
t<i',)
,..._,
1; .
"
'7 'Jh
-- ------ --- -
ank you,
/1{ cfr
'v
'/(.~'-
, .
--=-.
City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
AUG 2 7 2015
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
BOARD & COMMISSION APPLICATION Received by City Clerk
lnstructiom: Please r('spond to all qu('sfions on this application. Print or type your
r espollS('S. You
explainin~ ~our
an~
\amc:
L.
... -
Initial
Phtlnc. -- . --- - . -
Business Addres s:
Plwnl' :
Email .-\ddrt:'s~:
---
Y cs : - - -
--------_
\'u:
- -x - -
R_e_ti_re_d_________
Education
fn~t itu tiPD.
( \lUrsc of Study
Dt:!.!ree veart:U
B.S. , Pharmacy
Union University
1972
Duquesne University
Doctorate in Pharmacy
1976
Juris Doctorate
1986
Stanford University
~1ost
Recent):
Scholar tmerita
- - --- -
Year: 1999-current
Y L'a r: 1989-1999
20 11-present
All mcmhcrs of hoards and commissions arc suhjcct to the conflict of in terest Ia" s
of the State of California and are required to suhmit Form 700. "Statlmcnt of
Economk lntrrcst," "ith in ten days nf assuming offic('. Form 700 must he filed
annually thcr('aftlr, and again upon the completion of a mcmhcr's term of office.
--- --+17
Work Address: ___ _
Home Address:
1976
Doctor of Pharmacy
Duquesne University College of Pharmacy, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Thesis: Analog Computer Simulation of Salicylate Pharmacokinetics
Following Acute Ingestion in Children
1972
1999-2006
1998-1999
1991-2005
Margaret L. Eaton
1989-1998
1986-1989
1980-1983
1976-1980
Assistant Professor
College ofPharmacy
University ofMinnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Chief Clinical Pharmacist, Drug Monitoring Clinics
Department of Medicine, Veterans Administration Medical Center
Minneapolis, Minnesota
1972-1974
Hospital Pharmacist
Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital
Cooperstown, NY
RESEARCH AWARDS
Human Genome Program - Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications (ELSI) Program, Department
of Energy
Grant No. DE-FG03-99ER62783. "Dilemmas in Commercializing Human Genome and
Biotechnology Products: Developing a Case-based Business Ethics Curriculum for Industry"
Awarded $140,000 for 7/1199-4/30/01
National Human Genome Research Institute, Ethical, Legal, and Social Implications (ELSI)
Program, National Institutes of Health
Grant No. 1R25HG02082-01 "A Case-Based Ethics Curriculum for the Biotech Industry"
Awarded $140,000 for the period 5/1/99-4/30/01
PAST PROFESSIONAL ACTIVITIES, MEMBERSHIPS AND AFFILIATIONS
Member, American Society ofLaw, Medicine and Ethics (1990-2007)
Stanford University School of Medicine IACU Committee (research animal welfare) (1990-1993)
Stanford University Medical School Institutional Review Board (human research ethics) (19901995)
Stanford University Hospital Ethics Committee (1991-2005, co-chair, 1999-2002)
Trustee, Union University, Albany College of Pharmacy, Albany, NY (1999-2001)
Ethics Committee, Santa Clara County Medical Association, Santa Clara, California (2000-2005)
Maternal, Child and Adolescent Health Advisory Board, San Mateo County, CA (2000-2001)
Consultant Member, Council on Ethical Affairs Committee, California Medical Association
(200 1-2005)
Advisory Counsel, Stem Cell Advisors, Inc., Palo Alto, California (2008-2009)
Board of Directors, Natividad Medical Foundation, Salinas, California (2008-2009)
PAST HONORS
Thurston Honor Society, Hastings College of the Law
Rho Chi Pharmaceutical Honor Society
Margaret L. Eaton
PUBLICATIONS
I.
2.
Margaret L. Eaton
25.
Eaton, M. (contributor) in: Rehbinder, E, Engelhard, M, Hagen, K., et al. Pharming:
Promises and risks ofbiopharmaceuticals derived from genetically modified plants and animals.
Springer-Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg, 2009.
26.
Eaton ML, Kwon BK, Scott CT. Money and Morals: Ending Clinical Trials for Financial
Reasons. In: Current Topics in Behavioral Neuroscience DOl 10.1007/7854_2014_337, Springer,
Berlin, 2014.
Margaret L. Eaton
MAJOR PRESENTATIONS
Eaton M (with co-presenters). Roundtable on Establishing Fair Pricing for Innovative Drugs. BIO
2004 International Convention, San Francisco, June 7, 2004. Available from URL's:
www.bio.org/events/2004/speaker/ethics.asp and
https ://www.bio.org/media/press-release/bi o-2004-roundtab le-exp lore-issues-access-breakthroughbiotech-drugs
Eaton M. "Ethical Responsibilities ofDTC Neuroscience Companies", invited testimony, The
Presidential Commission for the Study ofBioethical Issues, Meeting 19, Salt Lake City, Nov. 5,
2014. Webcast and transcript available from URL's:
http://www.tvworldwide.com/events/bioethics/14 I 105/ and http://bioethics.gov/node/4320
Margaret L. Eaton
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
BOARD & COMMISSION APPLICATION
Instructions:
Please respond to all questions on this application. Print or type your responses. You are
encouraged to attach a cover letter to this application further explaining your qualifications for the
position and why you are interested in serving.
Board or Commission Selection:
Check one or more board or commission. Members shall not serve simultaneously on more than
one Council-appointed Board or Commission.
Community Activities & Cultural Commission
Planning Commission
Personal Information:
Name: Last
.. {u~\2..0
Location of Residence:
Mailing Address:
{"\.
,....,
y..-
D~\J ~
"
..
.......
.Er Position:
~ <2e A-~c;\\mc~ 1
- -
'"''-/' A
I Business Phone:
Statement of Qualifif;ations
n '"la
2. \
I
---
cA
Business Address:
Home Phone:
Cell Phone:
Email Address :
First
Yes~
Fax Number:
t_
NoD
lni'
.
. . ..
- .J
"'
- ~ 2-J
Education:
Institution
Course of Study
I' c. cA.\ ~~~I' 1\eer'l (\Cj
6. 'S _ L\t\e\
tA e t-<' \ \
L. Y f\c... ~
+--
Position:
A"' C).\ y ~
ib u.S IV\ t> c;s N\o.V\a. qe(l,e ~.:tOrganization: 5 ?o.."~ 1
~v~~c..eJ. ~~c f'o f) ,.a \1 \ C'E'~
Position:
Organization:
c,"' /A
N cA
+I ~~a..\ s~
Se.~'O\'\=('..<;t
Position:
'&
MocA1.1.\e
t-
\Co~i.J__c +-or
Year: IG(~A -I Cl ~{-
r.eel/'
Co..t-ft\~\
\-,H'~~
Position:
Organization:
c.. o
IX\
I~
~' ~
u..<---
(._ o (\C
Year:
Position:
v-..fS
Year: 2.oi\-P0e~eoJI
J \3.-\ e S e~.~ c e
I
F r ~ \ tl. C t e. \.IV - C
u_l[' E~
I
l... _ .a~d\
Year:
20 I ~ - P re.<.~
I
In accordance with the Public Records Act, applications and attachments submitted are considered public records and
will be disclosed upon receipt of a public records request.
All members of boards and commissions are subject to the Conflict of Interest Laws of the State of California and are
required to submit Form 700, "Statement of Economic lnt~rest," within 30 days of assum ing office. Form 700 must be
filed annually thereafter, and within 30 days of leaving offite as well.
In accordance with Assembly Bill (AB) 1234 appointed members are required to attend Public Service Ethics
Education upon appointment and every two years thereafter.
Do you agree to file all required statements in a timely manner as prescribed by law or the City's
Conflict of Interest Code? YES Ql
NOD
X>lt~!za ~
Date
Return application to the City Clerk's Office, East side of Monte Verde Street, between Ocean and Seventh
Avenues or mail to PO Box CC, Carmel-by-the-Sea, 93921, attention: City Clerk's Office.
Revised July 27, 2015
City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
AUG 1 9 2015
Received
August 19, 2015
When I first visited Carmel, as an undergraduate student at Stanford, I was amazed at the bright
white sand and the view of Carmel Bay from the top of the Del Mar sand dune. I can only imagine how
it must have looked when the Spanish explorer, Juan Cabrillo, sailed by in 1542. I distinctly remember
sitting on the dune with friends watching the su n set along with countless others who you would have
thought had never seen a sunset before. Even today, I am astounded as to how many residents still t ake
the time to walk the beach and watch/admire the sunset. What I really enjoy about living in the village
in the forest by the sea is how passionate our residents are about anything that involves the beach and
for that matter, the urban forest including the Mission Trail Nature Preserve.
I continue to feel that it is im portant to ensure that both the beach and urban forest are
completely maintained in th e short term and that proper measures are put in place for their long term
preservation by strictly fo llowing the beach and forest management plans. I have served on the Forest
and Beach Commission for the last 4 years and for the last year, I have been acting chai r or cha ir of t he
commission . It has been an honor and a pleasure serving and I would like to continue being part of the
commission for another term.
I hope that the city will respectfully consider my application for a second term on the
commission . I feel that I have much more to offer and we, as a commission, obviously have much more
to accomplish.
Sincerely,
David Refuerzo
I have served on the Forest and Beach Commission for the last 4 years and in my mind, I feel
that there is still some very important unfinished business with regards to managing beach fires and to
improving/revitalizing the city's aging urban forest. I believe that during my tenure we have made
significant strides towards improving both the forest and the beach, but there is still much more that
needs to be done. Ideally, I would like to finish what I've started, but as everyone in town is so fond of
saying and I concur, our work will never be done protecting and improving the city's most valuable
resources: the beautiful white sand beach and the mature urban forest.
I have served on the Forest and Beach Commission the last 4 years. For the last year, I have
been the acting chairman as well as chairman for the commission . It has been a great learn ing
experience interacting with the public, working with the other commissioners, interfacing with the
various City staff members and finally chairing the commission. Some of the F & B' s accomp lishments
during the last 4 years include implementing the tree replacement tagging program, developing and
adopting the 26 site beach fire pilot program, thoroughly reviewing the City's Beach and Forest
management plans, getting the Carmel Beach shoreline assessment done and starting the process of
restoring the North Dunes. For the last 4 years, I have been actively involved as a block captain for the
Concours Tour d'Eiegance which involves coordinating the efforts of a team of 6-7 people for the
express purpose of ensuring that the owners' classic cars are secu re while they enj oy the city. In
addition, I have been the lead person on the Field Crew for the Concours d' Eiegance
1
supporting/directing the show cars as they exit the 18 h fairway after the culm ination of the event.
City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
AUG- 4 2015
Received by City Clerk
Subject: Letter of Interest and Applicat ion for City Board & Commission
Dea r Sirs/Madam;
This Jetter expresses my interest in serving on either on the Harrison Memorial Library Board of Trustees
or Forest & Beach Commission for the City of Carmel-by-the-Sea .
My interest in the Library Board stems partly from my mothers' (Joan Clancy) participation within the last
10 yrs. on the Board, and partly that my w ife of 32 yrs. (Diana Godwin) is currently on the staff of Pacific
Grove Public Library as the Local Historical Librarian. I am a current holder of a Library Patron ca rd, and
active user. I feel strongly that the library is a unique resource, and has been a focal point of the
community for years. Maintaining the relevance of the facility in the digital age, with an older
demographic is the biggest challenge, and I believe I can support the Board given my interest in history,
publications and maps.
My interest in the Forest & Beach Commission is related to my unique understanding of the
geomorphology of the Monterey Peninsula and the Carmel Area, as well as my interest in recreational
activities. The Carmel forest and beach offer unique opportunities for both residents and visitors to enjoy
outdoor activities and the beautiful setting. However challenges occur when these resources are
overused, neglected or subject to natural influences (drought, disease, storm s and rising sea levels). I want
to be a part of decision making with regard to loca l land-use, f ires on the beach, sand castle contest and
the need to reforest areas that have recently seen loss of canopy.
In general, I have a keen interest in the Carmel community and now that I have relocated back to my home
town (Carmel native, born in 1956), I intend to give back to the community, much like my father (Bill
Godwin, Planning Commission member in early 1960s) and Uncle (Fred Godwin, 2-term Mayor, 1940s)
did. I have been in leadership positions for a variety of boards and committees in my adult life.
I would appreciate the opportunity to interview with the City for either of these positions. I will be moving
in August to 25525 Shafter Way, which is a few blocks outside the City Corporate boundary. I include with
this letter my application containing my interest and qualifications.
Sincerely,
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
BOARD & COMMISSION APPLICATION
Instructions:
Please respond to all questions on this application. Print or type your responses. You are
encouraged to attach a cover letter to this application further explaining your qualifications for the
position and why you are interested in serving.
Planning Commission
Personal Information:
I William
Name: Godwin
Location of Residence:
--
Mailing Addres5
I H.
'
Business Address
Home Phone:
Cell Phone
Email Address:
I Business Phone
I Fax Number: N/A
YesO
-- . _....,....,
Reason for Interest in the Position: I am interested in serving on either position (Harrison Memorial
Library Board of Trustees or Forest & Beach Commission).
My interest in the Library Board stems partly from my mothers' (Joan Clancy) participation within the last 10
yrs. on the Board, and partly that my wife of 32 yrs. (Diana Godwin) is currently on the staff of Pacific
Grove Public Library as the Local Historical Librarian . I am a current holder of a Library Patron card, and
active user. I feel strongly that the library is a unique resource , and has been a focal point of the community
for years. Maintaining the relevance of the facility in the digital age, with an older demographic is the
biggest challenge, and I believe I can support the Board given my interest in history, publications and
maps.
My interest in the Forest & Beach Commission is related to my unique understanding of the
geomorphology of the Monterey Peninsula and the Carmel Area, as well as my interest in recreational
activities. The Carmel forest and beach offer unique opportunities for both residents and visitors to enjoy
outdoor activities and the beautiful setting. However challenges occur when these resources are overused,
neglected or subject to natural influences (drought, disease, storms and rising sea levels). I want to be a
Revised July 31, 2015
part of decision making with regard to local land-use, fires on the beach, sand castle contest and the need
to reforest areas that have recently seen loss of canopy.
Statement of Qualifications for Position: With respect to the Library Board, I have a long time
understanding and use of libraries, have conducted geologic research, have many publications, and collect
historical maps and archives. My experience via my wife of public, school and private libraries, and
personally supporting my wife in her obtaining her MUS degree are witness to my qualifications.
I have been practicing geology for my entire profession career. My technique knowledge of coastal
processes, climate and erosion make me uniquely qualified for the Forest and Beach Commission. My
focus recently has been on site restoration , with work at San Clemente Dam , Fort Ord Vegetation RI/FS
and park soil erosion management in Hollister being good examples.
In general, I have a keen interest in the Carmel community and now that I have relocated back to my home
town (Carmel native, born in 1956), I intend to give back to the commun ity, much like my father (Bill
Godwin, Planning Commission member in early 1960s) and Uncle (Fred Godwin, 2-term Mayor, 1940s)
did. I have been in leadership positions for a variety of boards and committees as my volunteer committee
experience below would attest.
Education:
Institution
University of Redlands , Redlands,
CA
Stevenson School, Pebble Beach
All Saints Day School
Carmel Mission School
Carmel Woods School
Course of Study
Geology
Secondary Education
Elementary
Elementary
Elementary
DiQioma, 1974
Grad 1968
Grades 1-3
Grade K
Year: 2001-09
Year: 2001
Position : Girls Soccer Coach, 3 teams- Under 15, Under 13 and Under 8
Organization : Carmel Centennial Planning
Year: 1997-2000
Year:2015 to present
Year:2014 to present
Year: 2000
Position: Moderator for 1 yr. (top Lay person position for 300 member congregation)
Year: 2004
In accordance with the Public Records Act, applications and attachments subm itted are considered public records and
will be disclosed upon receipt of a public records request.
All members of boards and commissions are subject to the Conflict of Interest Laws of the State of California and are
required to submit Form 700, "Statement of Economic Interest," with in 30 days of assuming office. Form 700 must be
filed annually thereafter, and within 30 days of leaving office as well.
In accordance with Assembly Bill (AB) 1234 appointed members are required to attend Public Service Ethics
Education upon appointment and every two years thereafter.
Do you agree to file all required statements in a timely manner as prescribed by law or the City's
Conflict of Interest Code? YES x NO 0
~~'
Signature
Return application to the City Clerk's Office, East side of Monte Verde Street, between Ocean and Seventh
Avenues or mail to PO Box CC, Carmel-by-the-Sea, 93921, attention: City Clerk's Office.
City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
AUG l 0 2015
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
BOARD & COMMISSION APPLICATION
Received
Instructions:
Please respond to all questions on this application. Print or type your responses. You are
encouraged to attach a cover letter to this application further explaining your qualifications for the
position and why you are interested in serving.
a_
D
D
Planning Commission
Personal Information:
First
Name Lastv\.C\.SS.o~
Location of Residence:
M,p. ~
Business Address: ~
- ,-de
C - {- ()c_e_o/7 Me_.
-./-....
Home Phone:
Cell Phone:
Email Address :
Registered Voter in
a~h1e/
...
Cam~el-by-the-~a..
rr~0
'J
Mailing Address:-:--
(A_
..
I Business Phone:
I Fax Number:
Yes') g( No D
Initial
}1
Education:
.fuvtQJ{I'rc
Organization:
'
Position:
Organization:
o..ll.
c- k
~1rA.c:\_Q._
D\ J ' s.\.,
1\...
Year:
Position:
Organization:
Year:
Position:
Year:
'
-C"'"I--
In accordance with the Public Records Act, applications and attachments submitted are considered public records and
will be disclosed upon receipt of a public records request.
All members of boards and commissions are subject to the Conflict of Interest Laws of the State of California and are
required to submit Form 700, "Statement of Economic Interest," within 30 days of assuming office. Form 700 must be
filed annually thereafter, and within 30 days of leaving office as well.
In accordance with Assembly Bill (AB) 1234 appointed members are required to attend Public Service Ethics
Education upon appointment and every two years thereafter.
Do you agree to file all required statements in a timely manner as prescribed by law or the City's
Conflict of Interest Code? YES 0
NO 0
Return application to the City Clerk's Office, East side of Monte Verde Street, between Ocean and Seventh
Avenues or mail to PO Box CC, Carmel-by-the-Sea, 93921, attention: City Clerk's Office.
Revised September 29, 201 4
City of Carmel-by-the-Sea
CITY OF CARMEL-BY-THE-SEA
BOARD & COMMISSION APPLICATION
AUG 21 2015
Received
Instructions:
Please respond to all questions on this application. Print or type your responses. You are
encouraged to attach a cover letter to this application further explaining your qualifications for the
position and why you are interested in serving.
Board or Commission Selection:
Check one or more board or commission. Members shall not serve simultaneously on more than
one Council-appointed Board or Commission.
0
0
0
Personal Information:
I Steve
Name: Anderson
Location of Residence:
Mailing Address :
I.
... ,_....,.
I E.
C' ..........
- -- .
~-
Business Address :
Home Phone
Cell Phone:
Email Address :
I Business Phone
I Fax Number:
--~ .....
"'-' ''
Yes
No
Reason for Interest in the Position: As a resident of Carmel-by-the-Sea it has always been my
goal to eventually find a position within the Carmel Forest and Beach commission. I am very
interested and enthusiastic in helping guide the Carmel-by-the Sea forests and beach into the
future.
I know that this position would provide me with the opportunity to showcase my talents, and it is
my goal to build on those talents to help Carmel-by-the-Sea continue to be a world class town that
people from all over the world enjoy visiting.
I am proud and excited to be a Carmel-by-the-Sea resident and will use my enthusiasm to work
with the Carmel Forest and Beach commission, City Forester, City Council and other government
instrumentalities to help solve city issues in a timely proficient manner.
Statement of Qualifications for Position: As a Meteorologist for the National Weather Service I
have over 25 years' experience in meteorology and hydrology. These two areas have huge
impacts on our forests and beaches and I feel I have much to offer the city of Carmel-by-the-Sea
in this regard . As a meteorologist I am frequently collaborating with other meteorologist to reach a
consensus on the forecast problem of the day. I feel this will translate well into working with other
members of the Carmel Forest and Beach commission in developing solutions for the issues
Carmel-by-the-Sea faces.
Education:
Institution
Ygnacio Valley High School
Diablo Valley College
United States Air Force
Course of Study
Communications/ Media relations
Meteorology
I Year: 1990-present
I Year: 2009-present
In accordance with the Public Records Act, applications and attachments submitted are considered public records and
will be disclosed upon receipt of a public records request.
All members of boards and commissions are subject to the Conflict of Interest Laws of the State of California and are
required to submit Form 700, "Statement of Economic Interest," within 30 days of assuming office. Form 700 must be
filed annually thereafter, and within 30 days of leaving office as well.
In accordance with Assembly Bill (AB) 1234 appointed members are required to attend Public Service Ethics
Education upon appointment and every two years thereafter.
Do you agree to file all required statements in a timely manner as prescribed by law or the City's
Conflict of Interest Code? YES 0
NO 0
-~e~~
Srgnature
Date
Return application to the City Clerk's Office, East side of Monte Verde Street, between Ocean and Seventh
Avenues or mail to PO Box CC, Carmel-by-the-Sea, 93921, attention : City Clerk's Office.