Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Address correspondence to
Dr Eric Lancaster, 3400 Spruce
St, 3 W Gates-Neurology,
Philadelphia, PA 19104,
eric.lancaster@uphs.upenn.edu.
Relationship Disclosure:
Dr Lancaster has provided
expert testimony for the
Federal Vaccine Injury
Compensation Program and
received personal
compensation for teaching a
course from Grifols
International, SA.
Unlabeled Use of
Product/Investigational
Use Disclosure:
Dr Lancaster reports no disclosure.
* 2015, American Academy
of Neurology.
Paraneoplastic Disorders
Eric Lancaster, MD, PhD
ABSTRACT
Purpose of Review: Paraneoplastic disorders are autoimmune diseases associated
with risks for specific cancers and marked by specific autoantibodies. They cause
diverse clinical syndromes of the central and peripheral nervous systems.
Recent Findings: In the peripheral nervous system, autoimmunity to synaptic or axonal
proteins has long been recognized to associate with specific cancers. In these disorders,
typified by myasthenia gravis, the antibodies are directly toxic, and recovery with
immunotherapy is the rule. In contrast, the classic paraneoplastic syndromes involve a
higher risk of cancer, autoantibodies to intracellular proteins (eg, Hu proteins),
T-cellYdependent disease mechanisms targeting the CNS or peripheral nervous system,
and a poor response to treatment. Following the discovery of N-methyl-D-aspartate
(NMDA) receptor antibodies, a new and expanding group of disorders involving
autoantibodies to CNS synaptic and neuronal membrane proteins and a favorable
response to immunotherapy emerged. A final group of disorders involves antibodies to
intracellular synaptic proteins, such as glutamic acid decarboxylase 65 (GAD65), and it
is unclear whether these diseases involve antibody or T-cell mechanisms.
Summary: Neurologists should recognize the clinical syndromes associated with
paraneoplastic disorders, utilize autoantibody and other testing to confirm the diagnosis,
understand the pathologic basis of the diseases, and promptly give appropriate therapies.
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2015;21(2):452475.
INTRODUCTION
Paraneoplastic disorders are associated
with tumors but are not caused by
direct tumor invasion of the target
tissue. While paraneoplastic disorders
can affect many organ systems, some of
the most striking and debilitating affect
the nervous system. Numerous mechanisms were initially considered, but
many paraneoplastic disorders now
have a proven or likely autoimmune
mechanism. The same immune processes may occur in patients without
tumors, and the risk of particular tumors is highly variable among different
syndromes. Paraneoplastic disorders
should, therefore, be considered autoimmune disorders affecting various regions of the nervous system, each
conveying different risks for specific
cancers. The evaluation of patients with
paraneoplastic disorders is complex
452
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
&
&
&
DIAGNOSIS OF
PARANEOPLASTIC DISORDERS
The evaluation of a suspected paraneoplastic disorder is always dependent
upon the recognition of a clinical syndrome through a careful history and
detailed neurologic examination. Once
the syndrome is clear, the next steps are
to recognize how various paraneoplastic
disorders can enter into the differential
diagnosis, perform autoantibody and
other testing, search for relevant tumors, and give appropriate treatments.
In the case of encephalitis, brainstem
encephalitis, or cerebellitis, brain MRI
may show signs of inflammation affecting
the limbic system, brainstem, or cerebellum, respectively, but is often normal.
CSF analysis may show nonspecific evidence of inflammation, such as mild CSF
pleocytosis, elevated protein, or oligoclonal bands, but is often normal. Typically, multiple other causes are evaluated
in parallel to the paraneoplastic disorContinuum (Minneap Minn) 2015;21(2):452475
KEY POINTS
h Paraneoplastic disorders
are autoimmune
disorders associated
with risk for specific
cancers. In some
patients, the tumors are
thought to trigger the
immune response.
h Autoantibody testing
can be extremely helpful
in diagnosing
paraneoplastic disorders.
453
Paraneoplastic Disorders
KEY POINTS
h Antibodies to surface
epitopes of neuronal
receptors and other
membrane proteins may
have direct pathogenic
effects, but antibodies
to intracellular proteins
are more likely just
markers of other
autoimmune mechanisms.
&
&
h Paraneoplastic neurologic
syndromes frequently
occur when the inciting
tumor is still small and
otherwise asymptomatic.
h Cancer screening
should be informed by
the paraneoplastic
syndrome and the
autoantibody findings.
&
PARANEOPLASTIC DISORDERS
AND PARANEOPLASTIC
ANTIBODIES ASSOCIATED WITH
SPECIFIC TUMORS
While paraneoplastic disorders may
occur in patients with known tumors,
it is more common for the neurologic
454
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
KEY POINT
h Repeating cancer
screening may be
appropriate if a cancer is
not detected when the
paraneoplastic disorder
is diagnosed. The
likelihood of finding a
relevant tumor is
highest in the first few
years after diagnosis.
TABLE 10-1 Paraneoplastic and Autoantibody Disorders of the Peripheral Nervous System
Disease
Antigen(s)
Clinical Syndromes
Tumors
Myasthenia
gravis
Acetylcholine
receptor (AChR)
10% of anti-AChR
positives have thymoma
Muscle-specific tyrosine
kinase (MuSK)
(10% of systemic
myasthenia gravis is
seronegative)
Lambert-Eaton
myasthenic
syndrome (LEMS)
Voltage-gated
calcium channel
(VGCC) (85%)
Unknown in 15%
Autoimmune
autonomic
neuropathy
Ganglionic
acetylcholine
receptors (containing
!3"4 subunits)
Subacute pandysautonomia
(hypotension, anhidrosis,
dry mouth/eyes, sexual
dysfunction, gastrointestinal
dysmotility, fixed pupils,
fixed heart rate)
10% thymoma
Isaacs syndrome
Voltage-gated potassium
channel (VGKC) complex
(contactin-associated
proteinlike 2 [Caspr2]
or unknown subtype)
Thymoma in
a few patients
Inflammatory
myopathy
29% of dermatomyositis
patients have breast,
bladder, lung, or
hematologic cancer
Dermatomyositis patients
also have rash, Gottron papules,
skin and nail bed inflammation
www.ContinuumJournal.com
455
Paraneoplastic Disorders
KEY POINTS
h A paraneoplastic
syndrome in a patient
with a known tumor,
even one thought to be
cured, should prompt
an investigation into
whether the tumor has
returned or spread.
h The neuromuscular
junction paraneoplastic
disorders involve
autoantibodies to
synaptic receptors and
ion channels. They
typically improve with
immune therapy.
456
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
KEY POINTS
h Paraneoplastic
encephalomyelitis
affects multiple regions
of the nervous system,
causing altered
consciousness, behavioral
changes, and memory
problems; cranial
neuropathies, vertigo,
and ataxia;
and myelopathy.
h Limbic encephalitis
causes subacute
psychiatric manifestations
(eg, hallucinations,
delusions, abnormal
behaviors) and memory
impairment, especially
poor encoding of
new memories.
h Paraneoplastic cerebellar
degeneration usually
presents with progressive
cerebellar dysfunction
over a period of
several weeks.
www.ContinuumJournal.com
457
Paraneoplastic Disorders
Patient
Demographics
Clinical Syndromes
Tumors
Sensory neuropathy/
neuronopathy,
encephalomyelitis,
cerebellar degeneration,
autonomic dysfunction
Cerebellar degeneration,
encephalomyelitis,
opsoclonus/myoclonus
ANNA-3
PNMA1 (Ma)
Mostly males
(median age 34 years)
with fewer females
(median age 64 years)
Limbic encephalitis,
brainstem encephalitis,
cerebellar degeneration,
neuropathy
Cerebellar degeneration
Unknown
Cerebellar degeneration,
encephalitis, autonomic
dysfunction, motor
neuropathy
Lung cancer,
thymoma
ANNA-1 (Hu)
Target HuD and related
nuclear proteins
ANNA-2 (Ri)
Target the neuro-oncologic
ventral antigen (NOVA) proteins
ANNA-1 = antineuronal nuclear antibody type 1; ANNA-2 = antineuronal nuclear antibody type 2; ANNA-3 = antineuronal nuclear
antibody type 3; PNMA1 = paraneoplastic Ma antigen familylike 1; PNMA2 = paraneoplastic Ma antigen familylike 2; PCA-1 = Purkinje
cell antibody-1; PCA-2 = Purkinje cell antibody-2; CRMP-5 = collapsin response mediator protein-5.
458
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
Patient Demographics
7
Clinical Syndromes
Tumors
Cerebellar degeneration,
stiff person syndrome
(type 1 diabetes mellitus)
Usually none
Breast and
ovarian cancers
are common
TABLE 10-4 The Synaptic and Other Neuronal Surface Autoantibody Disorders
Patient
Demographics
Antigen
Clinical Syndromes
Tumors
N-Methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA)
receptor is an ionotropic
glutamate receptor important
for a form of synaptic plasticity
Early hallucinations,
delusions, bizarre behaviors;
evolves into seizures,
abnormal movements,
coma, dysautonomia,
respiratory arrest
Ovarian
teratoma
!-Amino-3-hydroxy-5methylisoxazole-4-proprionic
acid (AMPA) receptor is an
ionotropic glutamate receptor
90% Female,
adult to elderly
Limbic encephalitis,
psychiatric manifestations
Lung, breast,
thymus
+-Aminobutyric acid B
(GABA-B) receptor is
a metabotropic
inhibitory receptor
5 of 6 male, median
age 22 years
Leucine-rich glioma-inactivated
1 (LGI1) is a secreted synaptic
protein that organizes AMPA
receptors and Kv1 channels at
CNS synapses
1 of 6 high-titer
patients had
Hodgkin
lymphoma
Usually none
Faciobrachial dystonic
seizures may precede
encephalitis
Myoclonus (40%) may initially
suggest Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease
www.ContinuumJournal.com
459
Paraneoplastic Disorders
TABLE 10-4 The Synaptic and Other Neuronal Surface Autoantibody Disorders (Continued)
Patient
Demographics
Antigen
Clinical Syndromes
Tumors
Neuromyotonia,
encephalitis, or
Morvan syndrome
Thymoma
Dipeptidyl-peptidaselike
protein 6 (DPPX) is a
regulatory subunit of
Kv4.2 potassium channels
None so far
Prodrome of unexplained
diarrhea is common (due to
dipeptidyl-peptidase 6 in
myenteric plexus)
Stiff person syndrome,
progressive encephalomyelitis
with rigidity and myoclonus
1 of 11 had Hodgkin
lymphoma
6 of 11 female and
ages 5Y69 years
in one series
Metabotropic glutamate
receptor 5 (mGluR5)
mediates certain types
of synaptic plasticity in
the hippocampus
So far one
15-year-old
male and one
46-year-old female
Ophelia syndrome
Hodgkin lymphoma
Metabotropic glutamate
receptor 1 (mGluR1)
mediates synaptic transmission
in the cerebellum
Paraneoplastic cerebellar
degeneration
Hodgkin lymphoma,
prostate adenocarcinoma
Single case of
38-year-old man
Paraneoplastic cerebellar
degeneration
Delta/notchlike epidermal
growth factor-related
receptor (DNER) is a notch
ligand on cerebellar
Purkinje neurons
Paraneoplastic cerebellar
degeneration
460
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
KEY POINTS
h In addition to rigidity,
myoclonus, and
encephalitis, patients
with progressive
encephalomyelitis with
rigidity and myoclonus
also show pathologically
increased startle
responses with even
mild stimuli.
h Anti-Ma is associated
with diverse tumors and
clinical syndromes,
including limbic
encephalitis, memory
deficits, behavioral
changes, ataxia, dysarthria,
and ophthalmoplegia.
www.ContinuumJournal.com
461
Paraneoplastic Disorders
Case 10-1
A 22-year-old man presented with 3 years of vertigo and 2 years of generalized tonic-clonic seizures
that were only partially controlled despite therapeutic levels of valproic acid, oxcarbazepine, and
levetiracetam. Over the past 6 months, he also had slurred speech, disconjugate gaze,
and increased stiffness in his legs. He had periods of staring and confusion, as well as worsening memory
and concentration. Examination showed that he was alert and cooperative. He was oriented to month
and city, but not date, day of the week, or place. He had dysarthria but no aphasia. Recall was 1/3 at
5 minutes. He had continuous downbeating nystagmus that was worse with left gaze. Bilateral cranial
nerve VI palsies were noted, as was decreased upward gaze for both eyes. He had mild right facial, arm,
and leg weakness, as well as subtle slowing of right-sided movements compared to the left. Limb
reflexes were 3+ except 4+ (nonsustained clonus) at the ankles. Gait was spastic, and he could not
perform a tandem gait.
Lumbar puncture showed protein 33 mg/dL,
glucose 63 mg/dL, white blood cell count of 1 cell/2L,
red blood cell count of 2 cells/2L, five oligoclonal
bands, and elevated immunoglobulin G index (1.77).
Brain MRI showed increased T2 and fluid-attenuated
inversion recovery (FLAIR) signal in the medial
temporal lobes (Figure 10-1). Positron emission
tomography (PET)/CT showed increased radionucleotide
uptake in the left temporal lobe. Serology showed
positive Ma2 antibodies in CSF and serum.
He was treated with steroids, IV immunoglobulin, and
cyclophosphamide. Symptoms stabilized and his
gaze problems improved slightly (less nystagmus
and partial improvement in the sixth nerve palsies)
over the next 6 months. Seizures also became
controlled on a single antiepileptic medication.
Repeat PET/CT scans for cancer at 6 months and
1 year showed no malignancy. Repeated testicular
ultrasound showed a small nodule that was
biopsied and shown to be a benign cyst, and no
inversion recovery
further abnormalities were detected on repeated
FIGURE 10-1 Fluid-attenuated
(FLAIR) MRI of a patient with
scans 2 years after diagnosis.
paraneoplastic encephalomyelitis
Comment. Encephalitis involving the limbic
showing increased signal in the
medial temporal lobes.
system and brainstem is a common phenotype
with anti-Ma2. Eye movement abnormalities may
affect approximately 90% of patients, and multiple cranial neuropathies may occur with this
syndrome. Because of the strong association of anti-Ma2 with testicular tumors in young men,
periodic testicular ultrasound is a prudent precaution.
KEY POINT
h Anti-Ma2 is associated
with limbic encephalitis,
brainstem encephalitis,
paraneoplastic cerebellar
degeneration, or
neuropathy.
462
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
KEY POINTS
h Yo antibodies (PCA-1)
are found in women
with paraneoplastic
cerebellar degeneration.
A pancerebellar syndrome
with ataxia of gaze, limb
movements, and the
trunk is most typical.
h CRMP-5 antibodies
associate with
paraneoplastic cerebellar
degeneration, chorea,
uveitis/retinitis,
and neuropathy.
463
Paraneoplastic Disorders
FIGURE 10-2
KEY POINTS
h Antibodies to GAD65
and amphiphysin target
intracellular synaptic
proteins and associate
with stiff person syndrome
or other CNS disorders.
h Amphiphysin antibodies
are strongly associated
with breast or
gynecologic cancers.
464
CNS SYNAPTIC/NEURONAL
SURFACE AUTOANTIBODY
DISORDERS
These disorders involve antibodies to a
diverse range of neuronal membrane proteins. The antigens include ionotropic
receptors (NMDA receptor, AMPA receptor, GABA-A receptor, GlyR), metabotropic
receptors (GABA-B receptor, mGluR1,
metabotropic glutamate receptor 5
[mGluR5], dopamine receptor D2
[DRD2]), a secreted synaptic protein
(leucine-rich glioma inactivated 1
[LGI1]), a cell adhesion molecule that
organizes potassium channels on axons
(Caspr2), a synaptic scaffolding protein
(Homer-3), and a notch signaling ligand
(DNER). New antigens have recently
been added at a rate of approximately
two per year, making this one of the
most dynamic areas in neurology. The
diagnostic tests for these disorders
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
KEY POINTS
Case 10-2
h Autoimmune disorders
h Memory impairment
(inability to consolidate
new memories) is nearly
universal in the acute
phase of anti-NMDA
receptor encephalitis
and is often the last
symptom to recover.
465
Paraneoplastic Disorders
FIGURE 10-3
466
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
FIGURE 10-4
Cultured rat embryonic hippocampal neurons were immunostained live with CSF of a patient with cell surface
antibodies (in this case to delta/notchlike epidermal growth factor-related receptor [DNER]) (A). The same
neurons were immunostained with a commercial antibody to DNER (B). Merged images demonstrate the
colocalization (C).
Case 10-3
A healthy 28-year-old woman developed confusion, hallucinations, and
bizarre behaviors over 2 weeks. She was hospitalized on the psychiatry
service and treated with risperidone. Over the following 2 weeks, her
mental status worsened. She became less responsive to external stimuli
and had rigid posturing of the upper extremities, and periods of
tachycardia were noted. She had a generalized convulsion and was
transferred to the neurology service. EEG showed slow delta with
superimposed fast beta (extreme delta brush) (Figure 10-5). Lumbar
puncture showed a white blood cell count of 13 cells/2L, red blood cell
count of 2 cells/2L, protein 35 mg/dL, normal glucose, and three oligoclonal
bands. N-Methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antibodies were positive in
CSF. Brain MRI with and without gadolinium contrast was normal. Ovarian
ultrasound and pelvic MRI showed no evidence of teratoma.
FIGURE 10-5
www.ContinuumJournal.com
467
Paraneoplastic Disorders
KEY POINT
coma may show a characteristic extreme delta brush pattern. MRI may
show increased T2 signal in the medial
temporal lobes in some patients. CSF
may show signs of inflammation (eg,
pleocytosis, increased IgG index,
oligoclonal bands, increased protein).
Treatment protocols typically start with
Case 10-4
A 55-year-old man had four complex partial seizures over 4 weeks. He had
increasing difficulty remembering appointments, as well as irritability and
lethargy. He had previously kept meticulous records and financial accounts
for his small business, but these were a complete mess, according to his
wife. Examination was notable only for decreased short-term memory (1/3
recall at 5 minutes, even with prompting) and impaired concentration
tasks (serial sevens, spelling WORLD backward). Brain MRI was normal. EEG
showed rare spike-and-wave discharges from the left temporal region.
Serum B12, TSH, RPR, HIV, folate, electrolytes, complete blood count, renal
function tests, and liver function tests were normal. Over the next 2 weeks,
he developed more significant confusion and had angry verbal outbursts
on a daily basis. He had a total of 10 seizures over the 2 weeks, despite
titration of levetiracetam to 1500 mg twice daily. Repeat examination at that
time showed periods of agitation alternating with periods of somnolence,
extremely poor memory (with no ability to register new information), and
confabulation. Repeat brain MRI showed increased T2 signal in the left more
than right medial temporal lobes extending upward to involve the insular
cortex (Figure 10-6). EEG monitoring showed increased spike-and-wave
468
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
KEY POINT
FIGURE 10-6
discharges from the left temporal region and a complex partial seizure
originating from this region. Lumbar puncture showed elevated CSF protein
(62 mg/dL [normal 20 mg/dL to 45 mg/dL]), normal glucose, white blood cell
count of 2 cells/2L, red blood cell count of 4 cells/2L, and no oligoclonal
bands. A panel of antibody tests showed voltage-gated potassium channel
complex antibodies (Caspr2 subtype). He was treated with 5 days of IV
methylprednisolone (1 g/d) and then oral prednisone at 60 mg/d.
CT of the chest, abdomen, and pelvis showed no evidence of tumor. He
recovered to normal mental status over 3 months, but had a brief relapse
with the steroid taper at 1 year after onset that responded to an increased
prednisone dose.
Comment. The encephalitis associated with antibodies to LGI1 or Caspr2
tends to be milder than that associated with NMDA receptor antibodies,
rarely associates with tumors (a risk of thymoma in the case of Caspr2
antibodies), and often responds to immunotherapy. Many patients have a
good recovery. However, some cases can have relapses necessitating
prolonged immunotherapy.
469
Paraneoplastic Disorders
KEY POINTS
h VGKC complex
antibodies do not
actually target potassium
channels but rather
associated proteins.
h VGKC complex
antibodies that do not
target LGI1 or Caspr2,
especially those that are
low titer and present
only in serum, are of
uncertain significance.
h Faciobrachial dystonic
seizures cause rapid
jerks of the face and
brachial muscles on one
side. These seizures are
characteristic of
anti-LGI1 encephalitis
and may precede other
disease symptoms.
470
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
Delta/Notchlike Epidermal
Growth FactorYrelated Receptor
Antibodies
DNER antibodies are found in patients
with paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration. About 90% of reported cases associate with Hodgkin lymphoma. This
antibody response was recognized decades ago by Trotter and colleagues, and
cases were characterized by a pattern of
reactivity with cerebellar sections (anti-Tr).
Recently, deGraaf and colleagues have
shown that DNER is the true target
epitope of this antibody response, a
finding we have confirmed in our laboratory.33 DNER is a notch ligand expressed on cerebellar Purkinje neurons,
and the antibodies may have functional
effects on DNER-notch signaling between
Purkinje neurons and apposed Bergmann
glia, which express notch. While the true
disease mechanisms have not been established, DNER antibodies target surface epitopes of DNER and react with
live neurons, and therefore should not
be grouped with conventional paraneoplastic antibodies.
Dopamine Receptor D2
Antibodies
DRD2 antibodies have been reported in
children with basal ganglia encephalitis.
Patients typically have both psychiatric
(eg, psychosis, disturbed attention, emotional liability) and movement (eg, chorea, parkinsonism, dystonia) symptoms.34
Some patients have responded to treatment with IVIg or steroids and regained
normal function. These antibodies have
also been reported in patients with
Sydenham chorea, and the antibodies
are thought to have direct functional
effects on the receptor.35
KEY POINTS
h Antibodies to either
GABA-A receptor or
GABA-B receptor
target inhibitory
neurotransmitter
receptors and associate
with encephalitis,
particularly with severe
seizures, status epilepticus, or epilepsia partialis
continua.
h Antibodies to mGluR5
are found in Ophelia
syndrome, a disorder of
memory and cognition
in the setting of
Hodgkin lymphoma
that responds to
tumor treatment.
h Synaptic autoantibodies
are very specific for their
target receptor and do
not generally recognize
other closely
related proteins.
h Antibodies to GAD65,
mGluR1, DNER, VGCC,
and Homer-3 have been
associated with cerebellar
syndromes. Of these,
mGluR1 and DNER are
strongly associated with
Hodgkin lymphoma.
471
Paraneoplastic Disorders
KEY POINTS
h Cyclophosphamide can
cause infertility. Banking
gametes and treatment
with GnRH agonists (for
women) are two
considerations in young
patients being treated
with cyclophosphamide.
h Treatment of synaptic
autoimmune disorders
should be guided
primarily by the
patients symptoms.
There may be a role for
comparing CSF titers
from different phases of
illness in evaluating
suspected relapses.
472
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
473
Paraneoplastic Disorders
474
www.ContinuumJournal.com
April 2015
www.ContinuumJournal.com
475