Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tata Indicom
A PROJECT REPORT
ON
SUBMITTED BY
YAMINI KALE
PREETAM DEY
JITENDRA KHATRI
PULKIT BHATNAGAR
Symbiosis Institute of Telecom Management
Pune- 411016
2003-05
VSNL
Tata Indicom
PREFACE
Just as two-lane highways were inadequate to support a growing nation, Plain
Old Telephone System (POTS) based upon copper circuits was not capable of
carrying the huge flows of information needed for providing multimedia
transmission that will drive Indias economy well in the 21st century. Based upon
this analogy, it was suggested that the nation needed an Information
Superhighway to provide the infrastructure needed to handle these information
flows. Now, in the new millennium, this Superhighway has been rechristened
The Broadband Network a network of high-speed circuits that can carry large
amounts of information to residences and businesses throughout India.
High-speed access to information and web based communication / transactions
have become a competitive differentiator. Internet based services (whether it is
work or learning from homes, schools, colleges) or connectivity for SOHOs /
SMEs is crucial for enhanced productivity and perhaps even survival. Absence of
inexpensive non dial-up options is becoming a major stumbling block for the
countrys growth. Ubiquitous and cost effective public and private Broadband
networks are as vital today as telecommunication networks were ten years ago.
Broadband networks, both wireline and wireless, are best not seen as
technologies but as non dial-up, always-on, integrated communication
highways delivering voice, data and video along with interactivity at speeds
necessary for delivery of different services at required quality levels and in a
manner that current delivery mechanisms do not enable.
Broadband connectivity and services, if designed appropriately and innovatively
and implemented effectively, can be a key driver for several socio-economic
gains including:
1. Empowering consumers to enjoy the full panoply of benefits of the
information age.
2. Providing a source for long-term sustainable economic growth.
3. Endowing education, health, governance and citizen benefits required to
achieve these economic goals for all citizens including the rural population
that cannot be covered effectively using traditional brick and mortar
solutions.
4. Making available broadband services at affordable price-levels resulting in
a positive impact on the gross domestic product (GDP). Hence, the
subsequent economic structures are likely to attract new investment,
create jobs, and increase productivity through infrastructure build-up and
access to new and improved services.
VSNL
Tata Indicom
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
A Spanish missionary was visiting an island when he came across three
Aztec priests.
How do you pray? the missionary asked.
We have only one prayer, they answered. We say, God, you
are three, we are three. Have pity on us.
A beautiful prayer, said the missionary. But Ill teach you one
even better.
The padre taught them a prayer and then continued on his path
of evangelism. Years later, when he was returning to Spain, his ship
stopped again at the island. From the deck, the missionary saw the
three priests on the shore and waved to them.
Just then, the three men began to walk across the water toward
him.
Padre! Padre! cried one of them, approaching the ship. Teach
us again that prayer which God heeds. We have forgotten how it goes.
It doesnt matter, responded the missionary, witnessing the
miracle.
Similarly, a teacher is not the one who educates but one who can make the
students understand the magnitude of his teachings. A teacher is never petrified
to lead by example but also knows when to step back into the shadows and allow
the student to develop into his own persona and spirit. A teacher is always ready
to guide but is modest enough to listen to any silly idea his students put forth. We
are grateful that people who personify these virtues have guided us.
We are thankful to Mr. Praveen Sadalage (Senior Manager, Sales & Marketing,
VSNL, Pune), who gave us a free hand allowing us to learn from our mistakes.
We are also indebted to Ms. Priya Karkhanis and Mr. Amit Mudgal who
welcomed us to be a part of their team and learn the intricacies of customer
behavior.
We also appreciate the good humor of Mr. Amit Ghoshal who kept us perked up
and didnt mind when we made his cubicle our home. We also want to thank for
their warmth and support the front desk at VSNL who provided us with everything
and taught us how to take a photocopy as well as to make a cup of coffee.
We would also like to acknowledge the efforts and perseverance of Mrs. Sujata
Joshi, who has been instrumental in tutoring us with the fundamentals of
Marketing.
Finally, our heartfelt regards to the Placement team for gifting us this opportunity
to learn a great deal and make us feel a proud member of the Tata fraternity.
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Yamini Kale
Preetam Dey
Jitendra Khatri
Pulkit Bhatnagar
VSNL
Tata Indicom
CONTENTS
1. Executive Summary
05
07
11
13
15
16
17
19
22
30
31
40
41
42
46
49
50
51
54
57
59
60
62
8. Glossary
65
9. List of Figures
66
67
VSNL
Tata Indicom
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
VSNLs new product Easy Surf envisages coalescing the advantageous features
of dial-up and dedicated port Internet into an affordable, prepaid, convenient,
broadband Internet access plan. This product is aimed at garnering the rapidly
growing market segment of dial-up users who want to upgrade to affordable
broadband alternatives. Essentially, the product will cater to the following three
broad categories of Internet users:
Residential Users.
Small Office Home Office (SOHOs).
Small & Medium Enterprises (SMEs).
The project was carried out in two phases:
Phase1:
Developing Strategies for Strengthening the Channel Network.
The first phase encompassed developing strategies for strengthening the
channel network. The major objectives under this were:
a. Understanding existing Channel Network.
b. Suggesting ways to improve performance of Channel Partners.
c. To identify prospects who could be potential Channel Partners.
Phase 2:
Cultivating prospective Channel Partners into Associates for the
Easy Surf plans.
The second phase encompassed cultivating the prospective channel partners
identified in Phase 1 into associates for the Easy Surf plans. The major
objectives under this were:
a. Interviewing the prospects and identifying how the product fits into their
business model.
b. Educating the prospects about the product both on the commercial and
technical aspects.
c. Handling objections of associate and suggesting a business proposition.
d. Obtaining feedback from the end customer of the service.
e. Suggesting improvements and projecting the future of the product
subsequent to analysis of feedbacks from both the ends.
The group decided to christen the project as Test Marketing for EasySurf, since
we have been a part of the VSNL team involved in test launching this product in
the Pune market. Depending on the success or failure of this test launch, the
management of VSNL will decide whether to continue with the existing product
offering or to take the product back to the drawing board and rethink upon the
techno-commercial aspects of the product.
Symbiosis Institute of Telecom Management
VSNL
Tata Indicom
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Customer Delight
Excellence
Teamwork
Trust
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Healthy Competition
Employer of Choice
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Wholesale Services
Corporate Services
Consumer Services
Wholesale Services
International Long Distance:
Perfected through long years of experience and expertise in international
connectivity, VSNL is on par with some of the best telecom networks in the
world through constant upgradation of technology.
VSNL offers International Direct Dialing (IDD) facility to 236 countries from
anywhere in India. VSNL handles approximately 9 million minutes of
international calls per day. This is through any of their 12 International
gateways, spread across the country.
10
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Corporate Services
Data Center Services: VSNL Internet Data Centers provide the physical
environment necessary to keep servers up and running 24 hours a day, 7
days a week.
11
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Consumer Services
The Internet was ushered in India by VSNL. Since then, they have offered
the consumer the best and fastest connections. Now with Tata Indicom,
VSNL is offering a whole gamut of affordable and reliable Internet services
to the consumer. Some of their services are as follows:
12
VSNL
Tata Indicom
DishnetDSL
Experience the full power of the net
Dial-up Division
ETH Division
Achievements of DishnetDSL:
FIRST and only to offer multiple Network Operations Centres with Data
Centre facilities.
13
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 1.2
Operational
National Backbone
VSNL gateway
Satellite
14
VSNL
Tata Indicom
15
VSNL
Tata Indicom
16
VSNL
Tata Indicom
17
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Broadband In India:
Till 1998, the Government-owned VSNL had a monopoly in providing Internet
access services in India. The deregulation of the Indian Internet market began in
November 1998 when competition was allowed in providing Internet services.
However, VSNL retained a monopoly on the international gateway. In 2000, the
Government of India also allowed ISPs in India to own and operate their own
international gateways.
The Indian Broadband Era started late in 1999 when DSL / Cable Service were
introduced. Later in 2000, the market for Broadband picked up. Now in the fifth
year of services, though things are not all rosy but the market has been rapidly
expanding in numbers.
The overall growth of the ISP sector is likely to be catalysed by growth in PC
penetration rates and also a likely increase in access through the cable television
(TV) route.
Moreover, the demand for Internet services from both retail and corporate
customers is expected to grow, as the infrastructure improves, access costs
decline and awareness of the benefits of Internet use increases. The growth of
the broadband sector, combined with increased bandwidth availability and
declining costs of bandwidth, is expected to result in a sharp increase in data
traffic and in the demand for value-added services such as web hosting, virtual
private networks, and unified messaging, besides a host of broadband
applications.
18
VSNL
Tata Indicom
19
VSNL
Tata Indicom
20
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Introduction
With the government looking at an exponential growth in the number of Internet
and Broadband subscribers and targeting a figure of 40 million Internet users
with half of them preferring Broadband by 2010, the ISP market never had it so
good. But these huge figures cannot be achieved at the current growth without
increasing substantially the level of PC penetration in India. Other important
avenues to be looked at are the government regulations and policies.
However, these two factors are beyond the purview of the different Internet
Service Providers. What is definitely within the scope of the various ISPs existing
today is strategic partnerships and establishing distribution channels, which
optimise the value of the ISPs.
DishnetDSL (now VSNL) has recognised the importance of the channel network
and insists that for the company, it is more suitable and apt to term the channel
partners as part of a growing value network.
A value network is a system of partnerships and alliances that VSNL builds to
source, augment, and deliver its offerings. Channel network establishment
decisions are among the most critical decisions facing management. The
channel chosen intimately affects all other marketing decisions.
The companys pricing depends on what will be acceptable to the channel
partner. The firms sales force and advertising decisions depend on how much
training and motivation partners might need. Also, these decisions involve
relatively long term commitments. VSNL, with its constant evolving market
offerings, is now beginning to focus on how to optimize the relationships.
A new firm typically starts as a local operation selling in a limited market, using
existing intermediaries willing to work with the company. The number of
intermediaries in any local market is apt to be limited: some direct sales agents, a
few wholesalers, several established retailers, and if need be, some
transportation and warehousing partners.
Deciding on the best channels might not be a problem. The problem might be to
convince the available intermediaries to handle the firms product line.
On the other hand, if a firm is successful, it might branch into new markets. It
might have to use different channels in different markets. In smaller markets, the
firm might sell directly to the end customers or involve retailers, whereas in a
larger market, it might sell through distributors.
21
VSNL
Tata Indicom
In managing the channel partners, the firm must decide how much effort to
devote to push versus pull marketing.
A push strategy involves the company using its sales force and trade promotion
finances to induce intermediaries to carry, promote, and sell the product to end
customers. Push strategy is appropriate where there is low brand loyalty, or
brand choices are made in stores, or the product is an impulse item and product
benefits are well understood.
A pull strategy involves the company using advertising and promotion to induce
customers to ask channel partners for the product, thus inducing the partners to
gauge the market demand and hence to order it. Pull strategy is appropriate
when there is high brand loyalty and customer involvement, or when people
perceive differences between brands or when people decide their purchases
before making the trip to the store.
Channel partners are expected to be a part of the VSNL family by assuming
responsibility for performing a number of key functions:
22
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig. 4.1
Sales Force
Partners
Retailers
Value Added
per Sale
Direct Sales
Channels
Tele-mktng
Indirect
Channels
Internet
Direct Marketing
Channels
Low
High
Low
Cost Per Transaction
Among the different options available for VSNL to market and distribute its
products to the end customer are the ones represented in the diagram above. As
manifested, if the cost per transaction involved to the company is low (eg.
through the net), the value added for a sale in terms of marketing or persuasion
is also low. A customer might not like the product and there might not be another
opportunity to evince interest in him by the company through another strategy,
hence, losing a valuable customer. On the other end of the spectrum, are the
direct sales team. The costs incurred for each sale increase depending on the
frequency of visits required to convince a potential client, the transportation and
daily allowances as well as the salaries given etc. However, the chances of a
client jumping onto the buyer-roster improve tremendously as well as the number
of products that he might choose finally. Hence, this channel is one that VSNL
emphasizes on continuously.
One channel that VSNL is currently working to improve is establishing more
channel partners who have a good knowledge about the area they operate in as
well as have a reasonable influencing capability in their business areas.
To understand the requirements of potential channel partners as well as
recognize the needs of the existing channel partners formed the first part of our
project. It was imperative to carry out a market research to visualize the need for
the new product offering by VSNL as well as gauge the acceptance for the new
product by new channel partners. Hence the respondents selected and the
questionnaire designed included a comprehensive layout of questions to facilitate
the company to select with whom it wanted to establish close relationships.
One set of questions was prepared for the existing partners and another simpler
set designed to pick probable newcomers. The questionnaires, the subsequent
analysis and recommendations are discussed in the forthcoming pages.
Symbiosis Institute of Telecom Management
23
VSNL
Tata Indicom
24
VSNL
Tata Indicom
NAME:
___________________________________
AGE: ____________________
ADDRESS: __________________________________________________________________
PHONE: _____________________________________________________________________
1)
Can you tell us your annual income and your customer base?
Income (Yearly in Lakhs)
<5
5-10
10-15
15-20
20-25
25-30
> 30
3)
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
3
4
4)
5)
Could you please tell me what you know about Cable Internet?
(Verbatim)_________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
(Translation)_______________________________________________________________________
6)
25
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Higher speeds.
Economical.
Dedicated bandwidth.
Number of service plans.
Quality of Service.
Others (Please specify).
7)
2
3
4
5
6
7
8)
Good (4)
Fair (3)
Poor (2)
9)
After understanding the product, how likely are you to try it?
|-----------------------|---------------------|---------------------|---------------------|
Very Likely (5)
Likely (4)
Maybe (3)
Less Likely (2)
Not Likely (1)
10) Which DSL operators / Cable Internet providers are you aware of?
DishnetDSL
Hathway
Iqara
Silicon Mountains
ICC Cables
Satyam Broadband
Others:
INTERNET USAGE
11) What is the average monthly
___________________________
expense
of
your
customers
on
the
Internet?
12) For how long do your customers access the Internet per week on an average?
<30 minutes
1
-1 hour
2
1-3 hour
3
3-5 hour
4
5-7 hour
5
> 7 hour
6
13) How many people buy Internet connections from you per month ?
<10
11-25
26-50
51-75
75-100
>100
1
2
3
4
5
6
26
VSNL
Tata Indicom
DishnetDSL
VSNL
BSNL
Sify
Iqara
Others
1
2
3
4
5
6
15) Can you suggest ways to improve market presence of Broadband in residential areas?
(Verbatim)_________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
(Translation)_______________________________________________________________________
Please rank from 1-8 (1 being highest), the following promotional activities that can be
adopted by an Internet Service Provider to increase market presence.
TV advertisements
Newspaper Ads
Hoardings
Glow signboards
Banners { Plastic, Cloth, Laminated }
Posters
Kiosks
POP display material
18) Please rank from 1-7 (1 being highest) the factors which are responsible for a customer to buy
Internet connections.
Promotional activities
Higher Speeds
Always-On connectivity
Price
Brand name
Quality of Service
Bundling with other products
19) Please specify which newspapers and magazines do you read regularly ?
Business Standard
Dainik Jagaran
Financial Express
Hindustan Times
Indian Express
Lokmat
Newspapers
01
Lok Satta
02
Saamna
03
Sakal
04
The Economic Times
05
The Times of India
06
Others
07
08
09
10
11
12
Business India
Magazines
01
Outlook
08
27
VSNL
Business Today
Business World
Dataquest
India Today
Filmfare
Sport star
Tata Indicom
02
03
04
05
06
07
PC World
PC Quest
Chip
Auto Car
Auto India
Others
09
10
11
12
13
14
Altavista.com
Sharekhan.com
Indiainfoline.com
Bazee.com
Sify.com
28
VSNL
Tata Indicom
NAME:
___________________________________
AGE: ____________________
ADDRESS: __________________________________________________________________
PHONE: _____________________________________________________________________
21) Can you tell us your annual income and your customer base?
<5
5-10
10-15
15-20
Income (Yearly in Lakhs)
20-25
25-30
> 30
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
3
4
expense
of
your
customers
on
the
Internet?
25) For how long do your customers access the Internet per week on an average?
<30 minutes
1
-1 hour
2
1-3 hour
3
3-5 hour
4
5-7 hour
5
> 7 hour
6
29
VSNL
Tata Indicom
26) How many people buy Internet connections from you per month ?
<10
11-25
26-50
51-75
75-100
>100
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
2
3
4
5
6
28) Can you suggest ways to improve market presence of Broadband in residential areas?
(Verbatim)_________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
(Translation)_______________________________________________________________________
________________________
32) Do you think your sales staff can support you better?
Yes
No
33) If yes, how would you like DishnetDSL [ VSNL ] to help you?
(Verbatim)_________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
(Translation)_______________________________________________________________________
34) Are you happy with the availability, technical features and prices of Internet offers based on
DSL?
30
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Parameter
Availability
Technical Characteristics
Prices
Yes
No
35) How does DishnetDSL [ VSNL ] add value to your enterprise / business?
i) Improved Profit Margins.
ii) Increased Product Portfolio.
iii) Product Bundling.
iv) Others:
(Verbatim)_________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
(Translation)_______________________________________________________________________
36) Please rank from 1-7 (1 being highest), what you think is the most selling feature of
DishnetDSL?
Always-on connectivity.
Higher speeds.
Economical.
Dedicated bandwidth.
Number of service plans.
Quality of Service.
References
37) What measures DishnetDSL should take to motivate channel partners to boost its sales?
i) More incentives/ Schemes.
ii) Better commissions.
iii) Better training.
iv) Others:
(Verbatim)_________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
(Translation)_______________________________________________________________________
38) Which value-added services do you feel should be provided with the DSL connection?
Web-Hosting
E-mail Addresses
Video and Audio Conferencing
Others:
Domain Name
Virtual Private Networks (VPN)
Server Co-Location
39) In your opinion, what do you think would prevent or discourage customers from switching
one operator or service provider to another?
i) Lower prices.
ii) Better Customer Support.
iii) Better speeds / QoS.
iv) Acquisition by Tata VSNL.
v) Others:
(Verbatim)_________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
(Translation)_______________________________________________________________________
40) Do you feel you have clear information on offers from DishnetDSL?
31
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Yes
No
32
VSNL
Tata Indicom
33
VSNL
Tata Indicom
53) Please specify which newspapers and magazines do you read regularly ?
Business Standard
Danik Jagaran
Financial Express
Hindustan Times
Indian Express
Lokmat
Newspapers
01
Lok Satta
02
Saamna
03
Sakal
04
The Economic Times
05
The Times of India
06
Others
Business India
Business Today
Business World
Dataquest
India Today
Filmfare
Sport star
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
Magazines
Outlook
PC World
PC Quest
Chip
Auto Car
Auto India
Others
07
08
09
10
11
12
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
54) Could you please tell me which sites do you visit most often?
Hotmail.com
Rediff.com
Indiatimes.com
Yahoo.com
Google.com
Others, specify
Altavista.com
Sharekhan.com
Indiainfoline.com
Bazee.com
Sify.com
34
VSNL
Tata Indicom
METHODOLOGY ADOPTED
It is imperative that before commencing on a market research, that you formulate
a strategy about how to approach the entire procedure from conceptualization to
follow-up. Hence, the formation of objectives for the market research becomes
important. Equally vital are the segmentation of the available market and
selection of a target customer base.
Here, as described earlier, the primary objective of the first phase of the project
was to study and understand the views of existing channel partners and to select
a number of potential channel partners.
Since, the new product demanded that knowledge of the local area of the
channel partner be high, Pune was segmented into seven zones to facilitate the
further research and analysis.
Also, computer hardware and maintenance vendors along with networking
experts form an influential set whose advice end-users seek before buying a new
Internet connection, thus making this set a perfect group to make channel
partners. Hence, the questionnaire focuses on them and their likes and dislikes.
A detailed list of the computer vendors along with their addresses and phone
numbers was compiled using sites like punediary.com, and indiabizclub.com.
The modus operandi used to contact these vendors was two-fold. The first
method involved calling them up and requesting for appointments or conducting
a quick telephonic survey about their awareness of DSL and broadband internet.
The second method was making direct cold-calls. This was a better alternative
because it allowed us to touch a larger number of respondents in a shorter
duration of time.
One hundred respondents were covered for determining the most prospective
channel partners. Twenty four dealers and DTOs were contacted for obtaining
feedback vis--vis DishnetDSL and VSNL.
A part of the questionnaire also delved into the marketing and promotional aspect
as well so that recommendations about the promotional strategy for the company
could also be simultaneously detailed.
35
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Kondhwa,
East Street,
MG Road
Bibewadi,
Pune-Satara
Road,
Timber Market
Hingne,
Ganeshnagar,
Karve Road,
Paud Road
Peths
Kirkee,
Dapodi
JM Road,
FC Road
Model Colony,
Aundh
Fig 4.2
Segmentation of Pune
39 % of the prospective partners confirmed that the have a loyal customer base
between 51 and 100 who usually make purchases or take decisions after
consulting them. Bigger outlets in the city area also said that despite a fixed set
of customers there is also a large number of drifting customers who need to be
targeted as well.
36
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 4.4
Annual Turnover
The outer circle represents the potential partner base while the inner circle
represents the existing channel partners. 20 % of the people contacted had an
annual income in the bracket of 5 10 lakhs.
The major computer vendors reported a much higher figure than the above 30
lakh segment that we had mentioned. Significantly, this segment has been so far
targeted by DishnetDSL and it would be a wise strategy to continue with the
same target segment.
Fig 4.5
Business Operations
The pie on the left depicts the business operations of the existing partners and
the right pie details the operations of possible partners. There is a striking
37
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 4.6
Customer Segments
With the new product offering by VSNL, the SOHO and residential segment
become increasingly attractive and an immediate target. Also, Small and Medium
Scale Enterprises can be tackled on a case-by-case basis. With need-based
offerings and Value for Money packages, it will be very easy to convince those
who are looking at a national or international presence through the internet while
keeping capital expenditure and operational expenses minimal to upgrade from
Dial-up to affordable Broadband.
Fig 4.7
38
VSNL
Tata Indicom
The two charts shown present the recommended ISPs by the existing channel
partners, with VSNL and DishnetDSL having pride of place, and the awareness
of Cable Internet or DSL operators by prospective partners 86% claim to know
that they know about DishnetDSL though there is only a 71% awareness level
about DSL technology. This is representative of the fact that with increased and
sustained awareness campaigns highlighting the advantages of DSL over dialup, the subscriber base can increase significantly. This is corroborated in the
following chart where the likelihood of people getting a low price broadband
connection was enquired.
Fig 4.9
Willingness to try Broadband Services
The parameters which everyone was happy about as an improvement over dialup were the high speeds and the always-on connectivity. These results were also
in sync with the results of a question where seven parameters were to be ranked
according to their influencing ability on the decision of buying a net connection.
Price was the primary concern for 60% respondents while approximately the
same number plumped for higher speeds and better connectivity.
93% respondents felt that promotional activities are important in generating
awareness about a product but hardly two-fifths mentioned that it could be the
sole criteria for a purchase decision. This complements global trends about the
39
VSNL
Tata Indicom
age of the informed-buyer who makes rational decisions after comparing all
offerings in the market. This is good news for the company as they can focus on
Value Added Services and Feature-specific promotional campaigns.
Fig 4.12
Newspaper Choices
With the recent ban on tobacco advertising, a large fleet of state transport
buses are looking for advertisers. This will be a boost to the current media
strategy of using localised hoardings as the buses travel throughout the city
and the visibility of the company will improve multi-fold even if the buses are
stuck in traffic.
Fliers can be inserted in newspapers of localities which are technically
feasible. This will ensure a 100% penetration into households as every family
subscribes to one newspaper. Additionally, people have a tendency to glance
at least once on fliers or pamphlets before discarding while newspaper
advertising may not be very effective locally. Also, the details of the local
channel partners can be included to increase their visibility as well as act as a
motivational factor for them.
40
VSNL
Tata Indicom
41
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 4.14
Fig 4.15
Motivational Factors
40% of the respondents did not mind better commissions or other incentives
while 33% were satisfied with only improvement in the training support given to
help motivate themselves and their teams.
Fig 4.16
60% of the customers of existing channel partners were satisfied with their net
connections though one-fourth of the total felt that to reduce customer churn,
better customer care and a small reduction in prices need to be implemented.
This might be a viable proposition to the company considering the new product
offering and VSNL taking over DishnetDSL was observed by 50% of the
42
VSNL
Tata Indicom
respondents. Also, a number of answers suggested that the company was not
advertising its other Value Added Services and hence losing out on a profitable
source of recurring revenue.
Fig 4.17
Almost the entire sample size had at least one grouse against the company and
a majority of it was directed towards an unfriendly customer support system.
There were instances recounted when people were turned away even from the
office. Surprisingly, the commission related complaints were not due to an
incorrect slab structure but due to unnecessary delays in the final pay-offs.
43
VSNL
Tata Indicom
44
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Dial
Low
High
Low
Low
Prepaid
None
Applicable
Dedicated
High
High
High
High
Postpaid
Exists
Not Applicable
Easy Surf
Moderate
Low
Moderate
High
Prepaid
None
Not Applicable
100%
Customer Base
90%
80%
Dedicated Ports
70%
60%
Market GAP
50%
40%
30%
Dial Subscribers
20%
10%
0%
2003
Fig 5.1
2004
2005
2006
2007
45
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Technical specifications
Globally DSL works on the co-location model, where the ISP or the DSL provider
will deploy DSLAM (digital subscriber line access multiplexer) boxes. One
DSLAM box can provide DSL connectivity to a radius of 2.5 kilometers. The
advantage in the co-location method is that it frees the telephone line and splits
data and voice - this is the core USP of a DSL connection. But in India, when
DishnetDSL started out, telecom was still a government monopoly and
co-location was an unheard term. But DishnetDSL tried forging a deal, though
unsuccessfully, with BSNL. With these realities, DishnetDSL started offering DSL
services based on the Multi Dwelling Unit (MDU) model. Here, the DSLAM is
based in a building and from there, close to 50 subscribers are serviced.
The following diagram illustrates the network layout for providing EasySurf
broadband connections:
Fig 5.2
A 512 Kbps dedicated copper cable is laid from the nearest DSLAM to the
customer premises. The technology used for this connection is DSL over copper.
The dedicated bandwidth is then fed into a router, which is thereafter connected
to a switch by means of a CAT5 cable. From the switch onwards, the network is a
10baseT Ethernet network (commonly known as LAN connect) over a CAT5 /
CAT6 media. The switch serves the purpose of distributing the bandwidth over 16
40 users depending on the kind of switch. The CAT5 / CAT6 cables derived
from the switch terminate in RJ45 jacks, which can be directly plugged into the
NIC (Network Interface Card) of the users computer. The network up to the
router is owned and maintained by VSNL. Thereafter, switch onwards, the
network is owned and maintained by the Associate. The technical limitations of
an Ethernet network permit the maximum loop distance of 100 mts in case of
CAT5 cable and 200mts in case of CAT6 cabling.
46
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Business model
VSNLs strategy is a combination of push and pull. The following prepaid tariff
plans are to be launched by VSNL:
Pre-paid Residential plans
Plan
Bandwidth (Kbps)
Usage
512 (shared
bandwidth)
512 (shared
bandwidth)
512 (shared
bandwidth)
512 (shared
bandwidth)
10 hours
25 hours
50 hours
100 hours
10 hours
MRP
(Rs.)*
149/-
Validity
1 month
25 hours
299/-
1 month
50 hours
499/-
1 month
100 hours
699/-
1 month
47
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 5.3
Key Deliverables:
VSNL
Brand
VSNL
Marketin
g
Support
Technic
al
Support
Bandwid
th
ASSOCIATE
LAN
Cabling
LAN
Setup
Trouble
shooting
Prepaid
Cards
Deliverables of ASSOCIATE
48
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 5.4
Flow of Returns
VSNL
Installatio
n
Charges
Recharg
e
Revenu
es
Custom
er
Feedbac
k
Establishe
d
Market
ASSOCIATE
Installatio
n
Charges
Recharg
e
Revenu
es
Loyalty
Points
Business
Opportunit
y
END CUSTOMER
Revenues realized
By the Associate
By the company
30% commission on the one-time
Port deployment cost of Rs.16200/-.
subscription charges.
30% commission on subsequent
70% of the one-time subscription
renewals.
charges paid by the end user.
Installation charges for setting up the
70% on the successive renewals done
LAN connect.
by the customer.
Intangible Returns
To the Associate
To the company
An opportunity to become a part of the Easy market penetration. Thereby,
largest ISP brand in the country.
enabling high growth of customer base
and market share
Value added service/ add-ons for the
Better knowledge of the local market
existing customer base
Business opportunity for bundling
Market intelligence is gathered
hardware peripherals, UPS systems,
automatically under the system of
AMC etc with the product.
surveying end customers
49
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Revenue Model:
Item
Installation
Switch
Cabling
UPS
Total cost
Date
June 4, 2004
(A)
50
VSNL
Tata Indicom
51
VSNL
Tata Indicom
52
VSNL
Tata Indicom
53
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Methodology
Subsequent to the Study of Channel Network, we were assigned the task of
marketing the product EasySurf to both the channel partners and the end user of
the services. We found the approach of questionnaire survey aptly suited to our
purpose. The methodology adapted for this assignment is as follows:
1. The potential channel partners for the new product were identified from
the database created during the study of the channel network.
2. These prospects were then contacted and acquainted with the technocommercial aspects of the new product.
3. The prospects, who found the business venture fruitful, were required to
sign a letter of interest.
4. These prospects were then asked to identify certain buildings or societies
where they were willing to undertake the installation.
5. We thereafter proceeded to survey these buildings on behalf of the
potential associate.
Objectives of the survey:
1. To determine the business potential of a particular building in terms of
hours of Internet usage.
2. To gauge the level of customer satisfaction (with the existing Internet
connection) on the following factors:
Download Speed
Uptime/Availability of Network
Economy/Value for money
3. To find the revenue potential for the proposed product offering
The Letter of Interest served as a vital tool to bring the prospective EasySurf
associate to a greater comfort level in implementing the network installation and
closing the deal. Moreover it also helped us in gaining first hand insight into the
local market and to provide more realistic revenue models based on ground
realities rather than estimates and projections.
At the end of conducting surveys for buildings picked by every prospect, the
survey results were summarized and a report provided to the prospect. Based on
the results of this survey, the prospect took the decision of becoming an
associate and setting up the local area network in the most profitable buildings
identified.
54
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Residential Users: This segment of the target market for EasySurf forms
an overwhelming majority. The residential users have been using
conventional dial-up access to the Internet for a long time now. As an
outcome, they have grown very used to the traditional dial up features like
year-long validity of the ISP account, separate billing for the ISP and the
telephone service etc.
We were principally exploring the market for residential users who are
willing to upgrade to an affordable broadband service. This entails that the
customer must surf the Internet for at least two hours daily, averaged over
a month.
Small Office Home Office (SOHOs): Small offices generally have limited
use for Internet. We were primarily targeting small offices in a business
centre scenario. Since the offices are contained within a geographically
small area, clustered together, it becomes easier to install a local area
network and provide bandwidth through the EasySurf model. The owner of
the business centre sees this as a value added service to his customers
and an additional revenue stream to his current line of business without
undergoing any major hassles.
55
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Questionnaire design:
The initiation of any kind of research comes only with the collection of the primary
data and no other research instrument is as powerful and flexible as a welldefined Questionnaire.
A carefully developed questionnaire was needed in order to get an appropriate
response. Realizing the need we outlined a questionnaire on the following lines
for the end user.
The questionnaire was an eclectic mix of close ended as well as open-ended
questions in order to obtain both quantitative and qualitative information from the
user.
The first few questions catered to knowing the basic demographic information of
the customer. Following them were queries to comprehend the Internet usage
patterns of the customer. These consisted mainly close ended questions of
Dichotomous, Multiple Choice and Rating scale type to interpret and tabulate the
response provided.
Though inclined more towards on the quantitative front, the question on
Evaluating the present internet connection also prompted the user to assess on
qualitative aspect.
Subsequent to these were certain open-ended questions that reflected the
respondents view on the product. These helped us in getting an insight about the
users willingness to accept the new product.
The questionnaire concludes with an open-ended question that presents the
remarks and suggestions from the user for the present service.
56
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Respondent
Name
4 Phone
Decision Maker
5 Mobile
Flat No:
Yes
No
Yes
No
10
11
57
VSNL
Tata Indicom
12
13
14
How much are you willing to pay for the installation of such a connect?
Rs.2,000
Rs.1,500
Rs.1,000
15
Remarks
58
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Summary of feedback:
Market share
The following pie chart illustrates the breakup of the subscribers for all the
four major ISPs operating in sample audience. The VSNL slice of the pie is
the cumulative sum of the subscribers for VSNL, Tata Indicom and Dishnet
Dial brand names.
Fig 6.1
Market share
BSNL
27%
VSNL
51%
Satyam
12%
Reliance
10%
Usage statistics
The following pie chart illustrates the breakup of the homes where one, two,
three or four users are using Internet:
Fig 6.2
One
48%
Two
41%
Four
1%
Three
10%
59
VSNL
Tata Indicom
The following pie chart illustrates the breakup of the average daily usage of
Internet for each household.
Fig 6.3
One
44%
Three
15%
Customer Satisfaction
The following graph summarizes the customer satisfaction levels on the
download speed factor.
Fig 6.4
Customer Satisfaction :
Download Speed
Poor
51%
Good
25%
Fair
24%
As it is evident from the pie chart, a majority of the respondents were not
happy with the download speeds offered by their existing Internet connection.
This data has unearthed a market supply gap in the residential Internet
market. The product EasySurf can be successfully promoted focusing on the
better speed of the connection.
60
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 6.5
Always
Available
41%
Hardly
Available
6%
The surveyed population was largely satisfied by the uptime or the availability
of their present Internet connection. This primarily due to the fact that
currently, the residential users in India have limited use of internet and that
Internet is yet to become a part of their lifestyle. Therefore, this factor cannot
be leveraged as the unique selling proposition of the product EasySurf.
The following graph summarizes the customer satisfaction levels on the
economy factor.
Fig 6.6
Fair
53%
Poor
31%
Good
16%
Respondents were largely content with the cost incurred on Internet, but were
willing to shift to cheaper alternatives given a chance provided that the cost of
churning is reasonable and affordable.
61
VSNL
Tata Indicom
The following graph summarizes the customer acceptance for the product
EasySurf:
Fig 6.7
Product Acceptance
Yes
84%
No
16%
Product acceptance was judged by the response to the last two questions in
the questionnaire. Abstract of the product information was divulged to the end
customer and their responses were recorded.
Also, the respondents were asked to give suggestions regarding what is their
expected level of service. This information contributed to the qualitative
analysis for the product. The interviewer noted down the suggestions at the
back of the survey form and then reported back to the trainees. This helped
us understand the market better and identify the problems faced by the
customers through first hand information from the market.
We found that an overwhelming majority of the survey respondents liked the
product and were willing to subscribe to the service.
Limitations:
The sample size of the surveys was nearly 200. For more accurate results,
we need to have a larger sample size.
Respondents were not always willing to part with the information to be used
commercially.
The data collected is completely dependent on the skill of the observer and
the manner in which he records and interprets them
62
VSNL
Tata Indicom
63
VSNL
Tata Indicom
The Brand Value of the largest Internet Service Provider of the country is
leveraged on the associate.
Associate perspective:
There are other hidden costs involved in setting up the LAN connectivity
within a building like permission from society and maintenance.
Marketing support needed before signing up, since the associate needs to
know the financial feasibility of the product before hand. The interest
levels of the end customer are necessary to be known before planning a
set up.
The associate is used to simple stocking and retailing of the product and is
hesitant to go any further than that.
64
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Dial Up
ISP Charges Phone Bill
Rs. 150.00 Rs. 240.00
Rs. 150.00 Rs. 600.00
Rs. 250.00 Rs. 1,200.00
Rs. 500.00 Rs. 1,920.00
Rs. 500.00 Rs. 2,400.00
Total Cost
Rs. 390.00
Rs. 750.00
Rs. 1,450.00
Rs. 2,420.00
Rs. 2,900.00
Easy Surf
Plan Total Cost
10 Rs. 149.00
25 Rs. 299.00
50 Rs. 499.00
100 Rs. 699.00
100 Rs. 699.00
Savings
Monthly
Rs.
241.00
Rs.
451.00
Rs.
951.00
Rs.
1,721.00
Rs.
2,201.00
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Rs.
Yearly
2,892.00
5,412.00
11,412.00
20,652.00
26,412.00
Cost Comparison
Rs.3,500.00
Rs.3,000.00
Cost
Rs.2,500.00
Rs.2,000.00
Rs.1,500.00
Rs.1,000.00
Rs.500.00
Rs.1
65
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Fig 7.2
Speed Comparison
40
30
20
10
0
Dial Up
Easy Surf
No Modem required
Does not engage phone line: Phone available for voice calls
66
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Recommendations
Two months of work at VSNL have been a great learning experience for all of us.
Working as a part of a team assigned the task of launching a new product was in
itself a privilege for us. This has given us an insight into how a new product
offering for an untapped segment of the market is test marketed.
During the course of our association with the product we have observed certain
issues that need to be looked into to make the product a run away success. We
would like to suggest the following issues to be given consideration:
EasySurf scores well on the price front and the customers are generally
content with the pricing.
Many of the existing dealers have shown skepticism in working again for
the company because of some conflict faced by them earlier. The
company needs to strategize to build a long-standing association with the
dealer.
The company can lower the entry barrier for the associate by selecting
either of the following two options:
o Reduce the installation cost levied on the associate and provide
company authorized personnel for carrying out the network
installation.
o Maintain the current installation cost, and include network
installation within the package.
67
VSNL
Tata Indicom
There is a demand for two month, six month, and unlimited validity plans
in the market. The company should harness this by introducing such plans
at attractive rates
The Cash n Carry model for stocking and retailing of recharge vouchers
should be put in place as soon as possible because The process of
renewal of a connection is a bit cumbersome and needs to be simplified
for the convenience of the associate.
Triple-play services (voice, video, and data) with heavy gaming content
will be heavily in-demand in the near future with TRAI expected to
announce a broadband-friendly policy soon.
68
VSNL
Tata Indicom
69
VSNL
Tata Indicom
The Future
Reliance's Gigabit Ethernet network
Reliance is preparing to launch a broadband platform, which offers Internet,
Cable TV and telephone on the same platform. They plan to charge Rs. 500 as
their monthly charges. If we take monthly charges as of present, 250 for cable
TV, 500 for a telephone, 650 for Internet, the total works out to Rs. 1400 per
month. Taking a Reliance connection will reduce customers monthly outflow by
more than half. Also, using the services of one provider reduces hassles faced
otherwise when the customer has to deal with multiple providers.
Reliance is in the process of setting up a Gigabit Ethernet network at some
200,000 buildings in 30 cities in India. In the first phase, Reliance is targeting
corporate customers, but the company also plans to take the Ethernet to
residential areas. Hopefully we should have more news on Reliance's all-in-one
Residential platform in a few months time branded as NetWay. For the first time
in India, television will be made available on broadband along with telephone and
Internet services.
Bharti is planning a national roll out of its broadband services.
Though the company is offering only broadband Internet services at present, it
will move into the entertainment segment with services like video on demand as
well as gaming services in the next three months.
It is also going aggressive on wireless broadband with the introduction of Wi-Fi
technology that allows access to high-speed data transmission even while on the
move.
A statement by Mr. Ravi Sharma, Managing Director, Alcatel India, confirms the
above how emphatic the future is going to be for the broadband industry.
"Revenues from voice calls are dipping owing to the drastic fall in tariffs.
Operators are looking to enhance their bottom lines through data traffic.
Broadband technology is one of the best technologies for tapping this segment."
Ravi Sharma
Managing Director
Alcatel India
70
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Glossary
Definition of Broadband
The CII National Broadband Economy Committee has adopted a dynamic and
flexible definition of broadband that is technology neutral and focused towards
delivery of services to the end user, rather than on speed. For the purpose of this
initiative, Broadband has been defined as An always-on network capable of
providing interactive voice, data and video services on public networks
In terms of speed, there should be at least two tiers of service the true
broadband being capable of providing minimum asymmetric bandwidth of 1.5
Mbps and a lite version capable of providing 256 kbps. Within these ranges and
including the variations possible with service offering mix, it is expected that
several tiers of broadband services will be made available to different segments
to meet the market requirements.
It should also be noted that by definition, broadband (triple play of voice, data
and video on the same network) requires the convergence of services for
enabling its adoption and usage.
71
VSNL
Tata Indicom
List of Figures
Figure
1.1
1.2
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
4.6
4.7
4.8
4.9
4.10
4.11
4.12
4.13
4.14
4.15
4.16
4.17
4.18
5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
6.1
6.2
6.3
6.4
6.5
6.6
6.7
7.1
7.2
Name
VSNLs International Switching Gateway
DishnetDSLs All India Network
Value Added versus Costs of Different Channels
Segmentation of Pune
Customer Base
Annual Turnover
Business Operations
Customer Segments
ISP Recommended by Different Partners
Operator Awareness of Potential Partners
Willingness to try Broadband Services
Features Liked
Promotional Preferences
Newspaper Choices
Contribution per Quarter
Number of Sales Staff
Motivational factors
Strategies for Reducing Customer Churn
Channel Partner Put-offs
Commission Related Complaints
Projections for the ISP market in India
Network Layout for EasySurf Connections
Key Deliverables
Flow of Returns
Market Share
Number of People using Internet in a Household
Average Daily Usage in Hours
Customer Satisfaction: Download Speed
Customer Satisfaction: Uptime
Customer Satisfaction: Economy
Product Acceptance
Cost Comparison
Speed Comparison
Page No.
8
12
21
31
31
32
32
33
33
33
34
34
35
35
36
36
37
37
38
38
40
41
43
44
54
54
55
55
56
56
57
60
61
72
VSNL
Tata Indicom
Bibliography
References
www. vsnl.co.in
www. trai.gov.in
www. howstuffworks.com
www. cellular.co.za
www. google.com
www. rediff.com
www. voicendata.com
73