Page 1 of 4

C:/2015/ZUMA/HOA Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma

(Review 19577/09) [PART B MAIN JMENTS]

IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA,

NORTH GAUTENG HIGH COURT, PRETORIA
CASE NO.: 19577/2009
In the matter between:

DEMOCRATIC ALLIANCE

Applicant

and

THE ACTING NATIONAL DIRECTOR OF

PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

First Respondent

THE HEAD OF THE DIRECTORATE OF

SPECIAL OPERATIONS

Second Respondent

JACOB GEDLEYIHLEKISA ZUMA

Third Respondent

THIRD RESPONDENTS HEADS OF ARGUMENT:

PART B
LIST OF THE MAIN ZUMA LITIGATION JUDGMENTS

Page 2 of 4

C:/2015/ZUMA/HOA Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma

(Review 19577/09) [PART B MAIN JMENTS]

NO.:
1.

ITEM:

DATE:

Judgement
attorney)

in

Mahomeds

application

to

(Zumas 9 September 2005

set

aside

search warrants Mahomed v NDPP

and

Others

(19104/05)

[2005]

ZAGPHC 90
2.

Shaik Judgment per Squires J - S v

Shaik and Others (D&CLD case No

early July 2006)

CC 77/2000)
3.

20 June 2000 (sentence

Hurt J in application to set aside search

warrants Zuma v NDPP 2006 (1)

15 February 2006

SACR 468 (D)

4.

Van der Merwe J: Rape charges

against Zuma dismissed S v Zuma

8 May 2006

2006 (2) SACR 191 (W)

5.

Msimang J in NDPPs application for 20 September 2006

adjournment of Zuma criminal trial,
(permanent stay application brought
but

postponement

application

first

heard and case struck from the roll

when prosecution did not proceed) S
v Zuma and Others Case No. CC
358/05

(Annexure

MH5 to

Third

Respondents answering affidavit)

6.

Shaik Judgment in the SCA S v

Shaik and Others 2007 (1) SA 240

6 November 2006

(SCA)
7.

Shaik Judgment in the CC S v Shaik 2 October 2007

and Others 2008 (2) SA 209 (CC)

Page 3 of 4

C:/2015/ZUMA/HOA Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma

(Review 19577/09) [PART B MAIN JMENTS]

NO.:
8.

ITEM:

DATE:

SCA in Warrants - National Director

of Public Prosecutions and Others v

8 November 2007

Zuma and Another 2008 (1) SACR

258 (SCA) ([2008] 1 All SA 197)
9.

CC decision in warrants Thint (Pty)

Ltd v National Director of Public

31 July 2008

Prosecutions and Others; Zuma v

National

Director

of

Public

Prosecutions and Others 2009 (1) SA

1 (CC)
10.

Levinsohn J in application for Letter of

Request (LOR) Litigation NDPP v

2 April 2007

Zuma [2007] 4 All SA 791 (D); DCLD

Case No: 13569/2006
11.

SCA judgment in LOR litigation

NDPP and Others v Zuma and

8 November 2007

Another [2008] 1 All SA 197 (SCA); (same date as LOR)

Zuma v NDPP 2008 (1) SACR 298
(SCA)
12.

CC judgement in LOR litigation Thint

(Pty) Ltd v NDPP, Zuma v NDPP

31 July 2008

2009 (1) SA 141 (CC)

13.

Nicholson J in S179(5) application

Zuma v NDPP [2009] 1 All SA 54 (N)

14.

SCA in S179(5) application NDPP v

12 January 2009

Zuma 2009 (2) SA 277 (SCA)

15.

12 September 2008

DA

Review:

Judgment

Ranchod

locus
22 February 2011

C:/2015/ZUMA/HOA Democratic Alliance v Acting NDPP-Head of DSO-JG Zuma

(Review 19577/09) [PART B MAIN JMENTS]

NO.:
16.

ITEM:

Page 4 of 4

DATE:

SCA Judgment re Ranchod J order

20 March 2012

17.

TPD Judgment re implementation of

Record order of SCA

18.

16 August 2013

SCA Judgment re TPD order

28 August 2014

KJ KEMP SC
AA GABRIEL SC
HS GANI
T KHUZWAYO
Chambers Durban
22nd June 2015.