Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ASSIGNMENT
Submitted to:
Prof. Dr. Liaquat Ali
Submitted by:
Arshad Chaudhry
Waqas Saleem
Sajjad Alam
Yasir Anwar
Imran Wattoo
Date of Submission:
2011-NUST-MS-DME-28
2011-NUST-MS-DME-21
2011-NUST-MS-DME-05
2011-NUST-MS-DME-06
2011-NUST-MS-DME-04
31
May, 2012
1.
INTRODUCTION
An aircraft tyre is as a ring shaped covering rubber covering that is installed on a wheel
hub. The basic purpose is to protect the wheel and provide a flexible medium that allow
absorbing of shocks. The wheel remains in close contact to the surface through the rubber tyre,
where any damage to the tyre consequently results in damage to the main wheel hub.
Synthetic, natural rubber, fabric and wire, along with other compound chemicals are used as
main materials for manufacturing the rubber tyres. The aircraft tyres consist of two main parts
i.e., tread and a body.
The purpose of tread is to provide the traction while the wheel body provides support to bear the
load of aircraft. Prior to invention of rubber and mere strip of metal was attached to the outer
circumference of the wheel hub to protect against wear and tear. Today, the vast majorities of
tyres are pneumatic inflatable structures, comprising a doughnut-shaped body of cords and wires
encased in rubber and generally filled with compressed air to form an inflatable cushion.
Pneumatic tires are used on many types of vehicles, such as cars, bicycles, motorcycles, trucks,
earthmovers, and aircraft.
2.
CONCEPT DEVELOPMENT
Tyres are an integral and most essential part of the aircraft as they play a vital role during
takeoff and landing phase. During these phases, these are subjected to enormous loading and
momentum and thus are prone to much wear and tear as compared to wheels and tyres installed
on ground transport vehicles.
We have recently come across with a problem of short life of aircraft wheels on Super-MU. In
fact, life of an aircraft tyre and its wheel hub are measured separately and in number of landings
and takeoffs. A shortened life of aircraft tyre would entail its replacement much frequently and
incur increased cost.
Thus the design team thought of redesigning the tyre for aircraft Super-MU with an increased life
and at competitive price as being offered by other manufacturers. It is important that the facilities
for rubber production and subsequent processing are already held with Rubber Shops at Aviation
Complex. This is mainly a reverse engineering approach while referencing to other aircraft tyre
manufacturers and their best practices. The team would focus on manufacturing processes of the
aircraft tyre and in this effort wheel hub would not be included as part of effort. The approach
would be to make a design, develop manufacturing processes, develop prototype, and devise
client acceptability and inspection criteria.
MISSION STATEMENT
PRODUCT DESCRIPTION
BUSINESS CASE
GOALS
PRIMARY MARKET
SECONDARY MARKET
available in market.
All Boeing 747 aircraft operating airlines
All individual / private aircraft owners.
Low Cost
Consistent quality
Michelin
General
Bridgestone
Users (Aircraft operators)
Retailers / Distributors
Service Centers
ASSUMPTIONS
COMPETITORS
STAKE HOLDERS
Production Facility
Aviation MROs
3.2
Interviews
Focus groups
Have the customer demonstrate the product and/ or typical tasks related to the product
Notes
Still photography
3.2.2
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Better quality.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
Should operate in a wide range of temperatures even under extreme weather conditions.
13.
14.
15.
3.3
3.3.1
Data collection
CUSTOMER
XYZ
ADDRESS
CHAKLALA
TELEPHONE
05190990
WILLING TO FOLLOW UP
YES
INTERVIEWERS
PROJECT TEAM
DATED
15 APRIL, 2012
CURRENT USE
MICHELIN
TYPE OF USER
COMMERCIAL
CUSTOMER STATEMENT
INTERPRETED NEEDS
Tyre life is measured against the number of
extensive
care
requirements.
inspection level.
Better quality.
support described functions and usage.
Weather effects should have minimal or
Protection against Weather effects
zero effect on tyre surfaces and rubber.
intact
and
in
3.4
Group the cards according to the similarity of the needs they express
3.5
S NO
INTERPRETED NEEDS
Tyre life is measured against the number of landings that should be higher
1
enough to match aircraft inspections.
2
3
encountered during the operational life
4
Weather effects should have minimal or zero effect on tyre surfaces and rubber.
Rubber of tyre should be of good quality to support described functions and
5
usage.
Tyre should not fail before completion of assign life in terms of number of
6
landings.
7
Should be able to support aircraft landing at rough surfaces, landing strips, ice
13
ranges from -25C to 60C.
Charging of air pressure and its checking for inspection should have easy
14
access.
Tyre should be able to retain maximum pressure for a longer period of time
15
without requiring frequent charging of pressure.
3.6
RELATIVE
S NO
INTERPRETED NEEDS
IMPPORTANCE
Tyre life is measured against the number of landings that should
5
be higher enough to match aircraft inspections.
5
be encountered during the operational life
Weather effects should have minimal or zero effect on tyre
4
surfaces and rubber.
Rubber of tyre should be of good quality to support described
4
functions and usage.
Tyre should not fail before completion of assign life in terms of
4
number of landings.
5
landing strips, ice and unpaved surfaces.
Procedure and access for removal/installation should be easy and
3
less time consuming.
Tyre design and dimensions should allow it to get installed on
10
11
12
4
4
3
temperature ranges from -25C to 60C.
Charging of air pressure and its checking for inspection should
14
3
have easy access.
Tyre should be able to retain maximum pressure for a longer
15
3
period of time without requiring frequent charging of pressure.
3.6
The metrics should include the popular criteria for comparison in the market place
4.
In order to approach the design and then manufacturing process, the team considered following
areas vital to the manufacturing process of aircraft tyres.
1. Functional Requirements
2. Material Selection
3. Manufacturing and Assembly consideration
4. Cost consideration
4.1
FUNCTIONAL REQUIREMENTS
Balance
The centrifugal forces exerted on the main wheel hub and axle during the rotation of the
tyre depends mainly on center of mass and the orientation of their moment of inertia,
referred to as balance, imbalance, or unbalance.
4.1.2
Camber thrust
It is the force generated perpendicular to the direction of travel of a rolling tyre due to its
Camber angle.
4.1.3
Centrifugal growth
A high speed rotating tyre develops larger diameter due to the centrifugal forces moving
the rubber tread away from the center, which may cause speedometer errors.
4.1.4
Circle of forces
The circle of forces, traction circle, friction circle, or friction ellipse is a useful way to
think about the dynamic interaction between a vehicle's tire and the road surface.
4.1.5
Contact patch
The contact patch is the area of the tread that is in contact with the surface.
4.1.6
Cornering force
Cornering force or side force is the lateral force produced during turnings.
4.1.7
Dry traction
It is the ability of tyre to deliver traction, or grip, under dry conditions.
4.1.8
Force variation
The tire tread and sidewall elements undergo deformation and recovery as they enter and
exit the center line area of tyre foot print.
4.1.9
Load sensitivity
It is measured in terms of behavior of tyres under loading and off loading conditions.
4.1.16 et traction
It refers to the tyre grip under wet conditions on a surface.
4.2
MATERIAL SELECTION
Keeping in view the functional requirements of the aircraft tyre as described above, team decided
to choose synthetic rubber as one of main fundamental material for aircraft tyre manufacturing. A
number of polymers are used to manufacture the aircraft type, brief description of each is given
below.
Natural rubber has the chemical name poly-isoprene and consists of polymer chains all
having an almost perfect structure. Natural rubber can attain a good regularity when
stretched. Hence it crystallizes on stretching, resulting in a high gu, tensile strength.
natural rubber is vulcanized with sulphur compounds that can cross link the chains
because of presence of reactive double bonds making it stronger.
4.2.4 Butyl
This polymer contains mostly iso-butylene units with just a percentage of iso-prene
units. Hence, unlike butadiene and natural rubber products, this polymer contains only a
few percentages of double bonds.
4.2.6 Nitrile
This is a co-polymer of two monomers, butadiene and acrylonitrile, Like SBR it has an
irregular chain structure.
4.2.7 Hydrin
It is a copolymer of epichlorohydrin and ethylene oxide that is primarily amorphous with
small amounts of crystallite.
4.2.8 Royaltherm
It is a relatively nw compound and is silicone modified EPDM. It is a good value for
mechanical properties.
4.2.9 Parel
Parel elastomer is a sulphur-capable copolymer of propylene oxide and allyl glycidyl
ether. This polymer elastomer is finding use in applications where good dynamic
properties and flexibility at extremely low temperatures are important.
4.3
Following are few material characteristics that need to be taken into consideration while
selecting a material for aircraft tyres.
Since the polymer is never extended to more than a fraction of its ultimate elongation
and tensile strength because of the presence of reinforcements, there is a considerable
amount of controversy regarding the value of the properties. However, the tensile
strength is a good estimate of quality of the rubber. It is measured in pounds per square
inch. A high value of tensile strength is preferred.
4.3.3 Modulus
The modulus of rubber is measured usually as the stress in the compound when
stretched to three to four times of its original length, the stress is calculated on the basis
of the specimens original ;length, a higher value of modulus is preferred.
4.3.7 Abrasion
Abrasion is initiated by the local stress concentrations at the contact between the track
asperities and rubber. The abrasion causes the formation of ridges perpendicular to the
direction of abrasion. These ridges are saw tooth shaped with the teeth pointing against
the direction of abrasion.
4.3.8 Traction
Traction is the adhesion of the tyre to the surface. The tract of the tyre depends on three
variables, tread design, tyre construction and tread compound.
4.3.9 Adhesion
The capability of the adhesive system is important in determining the mass of tread, the
angular speed that this mass can be rotated and the displacement that the tread mass can
tolerate when it passes through the surface contact point.
4.3.10 Processibility
Since the tyre has to be built on the drum and then cured in the mold, r rheological
properties of rubber such as green strength, building tack, and creep resistance are very
important properties.
Considering above factors, Butyl was selected as the most appropriate material form
manufacturing of the aircraft tyres.
4.4
models was employed. Pacejka has developed a series of tire design models over the last 20
years. They were named the 'magic formula' because there is no particular physical basis for the
structure of the equations chosen, but they fit a wide variety of tire constructions and operating
conditions. Each tire is characterized by 10-20 coefficients for each important force that it can
produce at the contact patch, typically lateral and longitudinal force, and self-aligning torque, as
a best fit between experimental data and the model. These coefficients are then used to generate
equations showing how much force is generated for a given vertical load on the tire, camber
angle and slip angle.
The Pacejka tire models are widely used in professional vehicle dynamics simulations, and
racing car games, as they are reasonably accurate, easy to program, and solve quickly. A problem
with Pacejka's model is that when implemented into computer code, it doesn't work for low
speeds (from around the pit-entry speed), because a velocity term in the denominator makes the
formula diverge. An alternative to Pacejka tire models are brush tire models, which can be
analytically derived, although empirical curve fitting is still required for good correlation., and
tend to be less accurate than the MF models.
where b, c, d and e represent fitting constants and R is a force or moment resulting from a slip
parameter k.
4.5
4.5.1 Tread
The tread is the part of the tire that comes in contact with the road surface. The portion
that is in contact with the road at a given instant in time is the contact patch. The tread is
a thick rubber, or rubber/composite compound formulated to provide an appropriate level
of traction that does not wear away too quickly. While designing thetread, void ratios
would be kept small to provide more rubber in contact with the road for higher traction,
but may be compounded with softer rubber that provides better traction.
4.5.2 Bead
The bead is that part of the tire that contacts the rim on the wheel. The bead is typically
reinforced with steel wire and compounded of high strength, low flexibility rubber. The
bead seats tightly against the two rims on the wheel to ensure that a tire holds air without
leakage. The bead fit is tight to ensure the tire does not shift circumferentially as the
wheel rotates. The width of the wheel hub in relationship to the tire is an important factor
in decideing the shape of tyre bead.
4.5.3 Sidewall
The sidewall is that part of the tire that bridges between the tread and bead. The sidewall
is largely rubber but reinforced with fabric or steel cords that provide for strength and
flexibility. Sidewalls are molded with manufacturer-specific detail, government
mandated warning labels, and other consumer information, and sometimes decorative
ornamentation, like whitewalls. Thus the team decided to take guidelines from
regulations issued by US Department of Transportation.
4.5.4 Shoulder
The shoulder is that part of the tire at the edge of the tread as it makes transition to the
sidewall. The team decided to take guidelines from regulations issued by US Department
of Transportation.
4.5.5 Ply
Plies are layers of relatively inextensible cords embedded in the rubber to hold its shape
by preventing the rubber from stretching in response to the internal pressure. The
orientations of the plies plays a large role in the performance of the tire and is one of the
main ways that tires are categorized.
4.6
ESTIMATED COSTS
4.6.1
Design Cost
Entity
2500 USD
Internet
25 USD
Modeling Software
5000 USD
Rubber Specifications
500 USD
500 USD
25 USD Avg/Hour
Entity
Raw Material
100 USD/tyre
50 USD/tyre
Compounding Process
75 USD/tyre
25 USD/tyre
Carcass Forming
25 USD/tyre
Buffing
15 USD/tyre
Vulcanizing
100 USD/tyre
Finishing
85 USD/tyre
Inspection Cost
35 USD/tyre
Human Resource
50 USD/tyre
Machine
35 USD/tyre
Tools
15 USD/tyre
Cost of Quality
These costs are estimated to be on average of 610-660 USD per aircraft tire
where the company was already buying an aircraft tire from foreign vendor at a price of
2000 USD.
5.
6. Most of the operations involved are low labor cost except the NDI that required high
skill and special equipment.
7. The process was progressive one as the final part was a single entity.
8. Step-by-step and one directional manufacturing technique is applied here.
6.
Original Design
Review
Client
Review Client
6.1
Simulation and
Cord Twisting
Banding
Conceptual
Bead Forming
Detailed Design
Weaving
Banbury Mixing
Carcassing
Design Review
Design Approval
Dipping Machine
Vulcanizing
Manufacturing
High Tensile Machine
Heat Rolling
Finishing
Quality Inspection
Calendaring
Cutting
Tread Extruding
Testing and
Tread Skivering
Evaluation
Inspection
Handed Over to
Release
6.2
7.
ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
Following acceptance criteria was reversed engineered from the design of the aircraft tyre of
company RICHELIN (name changed for confidentiality) for our design.
8.
Tyre Size
6.00-6
Ply Rating
Speed Rating
120 mph
Loading
1750 lbs
Pressure
42 psi
Thread Design
RB
Skid Depth
0.18 inch
Tyre Weight
7.8 lbs
Max Unbalance
6.0 Oz-in
Outside Diameter
16.90-17.50 inch
Section Width
5.90-6.30 inch
Shoulder Dia
15.30 inch
Shoulder Dia
5.8 inch
Loaded Radius
6.9 Inch
Aspect Ration
0.91
INSPECTION CRITERIA
Following is the inspection criteria for the tyre that have been manufactured after
processing through above manufacturing steps. The conditions given below are not acceptable.
4.
1.
Cuts
2.
Swirl Wraps
3.
Thread Separation
Groove Cracking
5.
Rib Undercutting
6.
Rubber Heating
7.
Cut or Snug
8.
9.
Kinked Bead
10.
9.
REJECTION CRITERIA
Tires with cuts penetrating into the inner liner and with cuts reaching to more than 40% of
the actual number of plies. For Radial tires, cuts reaching 40% of the belt plies.
Tire with cuts and weathering reaching the carcass plies on the sidewall and the bead area.
Dually mounted tires where one has burst in operation (Both should be scrapped).
10.
Geometric Test.
and tire tread width areas. These measurements ensure that the tire will not have any
defects that were not able to be detected by the uniformity and dynamic
balance tests. These defects could include bulges or depressions in the tire
sidewall, as well as in the tire tread that could compromise the integrity of
the tire and the ride quality of the vehicle.
2.
Compression Test.
capacity to sustain the loads and aircraft momentum for what it has been designed.
3.
Elastomer Check.
to be within the required and specified limits as per the design requirwements.
4.
Radiographic Testing.
rubber of the tyre that can not be detected by normal visual methods.
5.
Dynamic Balancing. This test measures tires according to static, couple, and
upper and lower plane imbalance. If not properly checked, these forces can cause an
aircraft to bounce, have tire wobble, and not steer properly.
6.
Uniformity Test.
appearance. Without properly checking these forces, the integrity of tire and quality is
dramatically affected. These forces can cause a vehicle to bounce, vibrate, and not steer
properly.
7.
Wear Rate.
Real time simulation of the tyre would be carried out to measure its
wearing during brake application under dry and wet conditions. These would provide a
good estimate for the life to be assigned to the tyre.
11.
CONCLUSION
With the financial challenges arising from the deregulation of the air-travel industry, the airlines
are faced with the challenge of reducing operating costs to remain competitive. As a result, the
airlines have demanded that the aircraft manufacturers produce new designs with high reliability
and low maintenance requirements. In basic design, costs associated with the aircraft tyre may be
reduced by aiming at simplicity, compactness, and minimum weight and maintenance
requirements. Simplified design and improved manufacturing techniques, are being used to
reduce the part-count.
REFERENCES
Airmichelin.com (2012) Michelin Air: The very best in aviation tires.. [online] Available at:
http://www.airmichelin.com/ [Accessed: 31 May 2012].
Bobo, S. (1988) Fatigue Life of Aircraft Tires. Tire Science and Technology, 16 (4), p.208-209.
Clark, S. (1985) Heat Generation in Aircraft Tires. Computers & Structures, 20 (1), p.535-544.
Clark, S. et al. (1972) Structural Modeling of Aircraft Tires. Journal of Aircraft, 9 (2), p.162-167.
Clark, S. et al. (1974) Dynamic Properties of Aircraft Tires. Journal of Aircraft, 11 (3), p.166172.
Goodyearaviation.com (n.d.) Goodyear Aviation Tires. [online] Available at:
http://www.goodyearaviation.com/ [Accessed: 31 May 2012].
Sacskyranch.com (2003) Aircraft tire balance and vibration. [online] Available at:
http://www.sacskyranch.com/tire.htm [Accessed: 31 May 2012].
Skytreads.com (n.d.) Aircraft Tire Construction Information. [online] Available at:
http://www.skytreads.com/tire_const.htm [Accessed: 31 May 2012].
Wattsaviation.co.uk (1965) Watts Aviation | Specialists in Aircraft Tyres. [online] Available at:
http://www.wattsaviation.co.uk/ [Accessed: 31 May 2012].