Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IRJPER
Review
1*2
Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Division, Power Research Institute, Bangalore, India
Dept. of Electrical and Electronic Engineering Central, National Institute of Technology, Surathakal, India
This paper describes the various methods for enhancing the energy efficiency of Boiler Feed
Pumps (BFP) in thermal power plants based on the energy audit study conducted in 28
numbers of 210 MW coal fired thermal power plants in India. The auxiliary power used by
BFPs is about 2.4 to 3.2 % of the total gross energy generation. BFPs are the largest (in
rating) motor in a thermal power plant. The detailed energy audit of auxiliary equipment in
various thermal power stations, operational optimization and appropriate control system had
shown ample scope for improving the energy efficiency of BFPs. The energy efficiency
improvement of BFPs by reducing the re-circulation flow, pressure drop across feed water
circuit elements, enhancing overall efficiency of BFPs, etc., are discussed with case studies.
The implementation of energy conservation measures reduce the average auxiliary power
used by BFPs for 210 MW plant from 2.97 % to 2.32 % of gross energy generation and release
an additional power of about 480 MW that reduce the CO 2 emission by about 3.9 million
tonne per year
Keywords: Energy efficiency, boiler feed pumps, auxiliary power, pump efficiency, sec, energy conservation
INTRODUCTION
The total installed power generation capacity in India is
about 223.344 GW, out of which the generation from
coal fired power plant is about 56 %. The average
auxiliary power used of coal fired thermal power plant is
8.44 % of gross energy generation at an average plant
load factor (PLF) of 73.3 % (CEA, 2013). Among the
auxiliary equipment BFPs are the major energy
consuming equipment that forms 30 % of total auxiliary
power used by thermal power plants (Siddhartha Bhatt M
et al., 1999).
The estimated auxiliary power used BFPs of coal fired
thermal power plants in India is about 4420 MW and
average estimated CO2 emission is about 36 million
tonne per year on account of auxiliary power used by
BFPs.
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
Mandi et al.
002
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
m FW
and O
003
PR
Pr 1 T 100
PRMCR
(1)
drop
across
hydrodynamic
resistive
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
Mandi et al.
004
o
mT
m 1 o 100
m MCR
(2)
3
FW flow (m /h) at MCR condition (100 % PLF) and m T
3
is the FW flow (m /h) at tested plant load.
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
O 1 OT
OMCR
100
(3)
005
P
P 1 T 100
PMCR
(4)
Power input
The variation of power input is plotted with the variation
in plant load (Figure 7). It can be seen from the Figure 7
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
Mandi et al.
006
i n
AP
P 100
i 1
(5)
PL 103
AP
AP 1 T 100
APMCR
(6)
E PPR PBFP
(7)
i 1 j 1
SIMULATION STUDIES
The mechanical power output of pump is directly related
with pressure gain and feed water flow. The electrical
power input to BFP motor terminals is also directly related
with mechanical power output along with motor and pump
efficiency (i.e., overall efficiency). But all these
parameters will not have the similar kind of variation trend
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
Wij
E
Wij A 1
Wij
(8)
007
Dn
(9)
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
Mandi et al.
008
Sl.
No.
01
02
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
Particulars
Unit
12
13
Plant load
BFP Motor rating
Booster pump suction pressure
BFP discharge Pressure
Pressure gain
FW flow
Electrical power
Load factor of motor
Motor efficiency
Electrical power input to pump
Mechanical power output
Main pump and Booster pump
efficiency
Overall efficiency
Specific Energy Consumption
14
15
16
17
18
MW
MW
MPa
MPa
MPa
m3/h
kW
%
%
kW
kW
Predicted value
at 80.95 % PLF
4.00
16.47
325.4
2330
54.17
93.00
2166.90
1460.92
4.00
0.56
14.20
13.64
393.78
2775.92
64.10
92.36
2563.84
1464.10
4.00
0.56
15.84
15.28
363.63
2854.24
65.94
92.42
2637.89
1514.57
67.42
57.09
57.40
%
kWh/m3/h of
FW flow
% of plant
load
62.70
52.73
53.05
7.16
7.76
8.64
kW
481.95
309.28
kW
-476.91
-190.22
kW
440.88
405.18
kW
445.92
524.24
BFP 1B
BFP 1C
170.0
2.74
3.31
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
009
Sl.
No.
01
02
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Particulars
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Plant load
BFP Motor rating
BFP Pump (Booster) suction pressure
BFP discharge Pressure
Pressure gain
Pressure drop across HP heaters
Pressure drop across FRS
Pressure drop across Economizer
Pressure drop across water wall and SH
Pump discharge FW flow
Re-circulation flow
Total FW flow in pump
Electrical power
Load factor of motor
Motor efficiency
Electrical power input to pump
Mechanical power output
Main pump and Booster pump efficiency
Overall efficiency
Specific Energy Consumption
Unit
MW
MW
MPa
MPa
MPa
MPa
MPa
MPa
MPa
3
m /h
m3/h
m3/h
kW
%
%
kW
kW
%
%
3
kWh/m /h of
FW flow
% of plant
load
Predicted value
at 100 % PLF
4.00
17.16
0.25
0.10
0.15
1.25
391.03
391.03
2578.45
59.95
93.00
2397.96
1828.50
76.25
70.91
BFP 3A
BFP 3B
4.00
0.56
17.90
17.34
0.28
0.35
0.16
1.31
394.56
1.29
395.85
3022.19
70.05
92.72
2802.17
1464.10
66.75
61.89
4.00
0.56
18.60
18.04
0.28
0.35
0.16
1.31
390.63
38.18
428.81
3216.86
65.94
92.91
2988.78
2107.99
70.53
65.53
6.59
7.63
7.50
210.0
2.46
2.97
kW
4.56
5.89
kW
38.01
49.10
kW
1.52
1.96
kW
9.13
11.78
-25.85
-33.38
8.59
315.47
23.51
-3.30
kW
kW
kW
kW
384.27
290.89
kW
443.74
638.41
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
Mandi et al.
010
P
PLF
PR
RMSE
SH
SSC
TDBFP
W
Power
Plant Load Factor
Pressure gain
Root Means Square Error
Superheater
Specific Steam Consumption
Turbine Driven Boiler Feed Pump
Weight
Learning rate of ANN
Momentum coefficient of ANN
Pressure drop
Deviation
CONCLUSIONS
Flow
Efficiency
REFERENCES
Anderson JA (2003), An Introduction to neural networks,
Prentice Hall.
Becnel CL, Kilgrore JW, Merrill EF (1987), Determining
motor efficiency by field testing, IEEE Transactions on
Industrial Applications, Vol. IA-23, pp. 440443.
Central Electricity Authority (2012), Performance Review
of Thermal Power Stations 1999-00, 2006-07, 20072008, 2008-09, 2009-10, 2010-11 and 2011-12,
website: http//:www.cea.nic.in, Accessed on June
2013.
Central Electricity Authority (2013), Growth of Electricity
Sector in India from 1947 to 2013, website:
http//:www.cea.nic.in, Accessed on June 2013.
Central Power Research Institute (2011), Instrumented
and Diagnostic Energy audit at Raichur Super
Thermal Power Station, Raichur, Karnataka, India,
Report No: CPRI/ERED/EA/83/11.
Central Power Research Institute (2011), Instrumented
and Diagnostic Energy audit at Guru Gobind Super
Thermal Power Station, Rupnagar, Punjab, India,
Report No: CPRI/ERED/EA/95/11.
El-Wakil M.M. (1984), Power plant Technology,
International Edition 1984, McGraw Hill Book
Company, pp. 219-250.
Engin T (2007), Prediction of relative efficiency reduction
of centrifugal slurry pumps: empirical- and artificialneural network-based methods, Proceeding of IMechE
Vol. 221 Part A: J. Power and Energy, JPE224 #
IMechE 2007.
John S Hsu, Kueck JD, Olszewski M, Casada DA,
Otaduy PJ, Tolbert LM (1998), Comparison of
Induction Motor Field Efficiency Evaluation Methods,
IEEE transactions on industry applications, Vol. 34,
No. 1, pp. 117-125.
Kiran Kumar, Srinivasa Rao G (2013), Performance
Analysis from the Energy Audit of A thermal Power
Plant, International Journal of Engineering trends and
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation
011
Enhancing energy efficiency of boiler feed pumps in thermal power plants through operational optimization and energy conservation