Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Facts:
Wilfredo Banez, accused-appllant was living with his father in Pangasinan.
His father, Bernardo P. Baez, complained to Elvira and Emelinda Banez that
accused-appellant made trouble whenever he was drunk. The elder Baez wanted
to put up accused-appellant in another house.
In the evening of August 14, 1994, Elvira and her sister Emelinda discussed
with their father the latters plan for accused-appellant. After a while, when her
father went to his room, accused-appellant, who looked drunk because he was
red in the face, ran to the kitchen and got two (2) knives and then went inside
their fathers room. Elvira went inside the room, she saw accused-appellant
stabbing her father saying, Pinalalayas mo ako!. Elvira said she tried to stop
accused-appellant from inflicting further injuries on her father. But as Elvira tried to
take the knives from accused-appellant, the latter lunged at her and stabbed her,
hitting her on the right hand, forearm, and buttock. Emelinda tried to stop accusedappellant by throwing a piece of wood at him, but accused-appellant turned to
Emelinda. Emelinda was so frightened she ran away from the house and was chased
by the accused-appenllant. Elvira locked herself inside her fathers house and
stayed there until three (3) helpers from their poultry farm and their maid arrived.
She asked them for help to take her father to the hospital, but accused-appellant
came back and threatened them with harm. It was only much later, after accusedappellant had left again, that she was finally able to get help to take her father
hospital. By then, however, her father was already dead.
Elvira stated that accused-appellant had been staying in their fathers house
for four (4) years after accused-appellant separated from his wife; that in 1988
accused-appellant was confined at the Bicutan Rehabilitation Center in Taguig,
Metro Manila for addiction to gasoline; that he had been discharged from the same
a long time ago, although she could not remember the year he was discharged; that
accused-appellant had not shown any indication that he was crazy although he was
also treated at the Baguio General Hospital for addiction to gasoline.
The autopsy report showed that the victim suffered 10 stab wounds on
various parts of his body.
A plea of insanity was made by the defense in behalf of accused-appellant.
Issue:
(1) Whether or not the accused-appellant should have been held exempt from
criminal liability because he suffering from schizophrenia when he killed his
father.
intoxication, his will-power had been impaired such that he did not know
what he was doing.