Professional Documents
Culture Documents
yes-no question
wh-question(or constituent question)
Other types of yes-no questions and wh-questions can be formed from the same basic
sentence. Since these are less frequent, they are also called minor types of questions:
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
declarative question
negative question
tag question
echo-question
multiple wh-question
2. Yes of no questions
Typical yes or no questions are derived from declarative clauses by moving one
constituent, the auxiliary (or the modal). In traditional grammar this is called inversion of the
auxiliary with the subject:
She has written an essay.
She can speak Japanese.
When the lexical verb is in the present simple or past simple, do-support (or do insertion) is
used.
He plays the violin.
He told the truth.
-inversion
-do insertion
The only marker of interrogation is the rising intonation attached to the declarative sentence.
Declarative questions are typical of spoken language and be used when the speaker thinks
he/she knows or has understood something, but wants to make sure or express surprise:
1
+inversion
+ negative contraction
If it is not contracted, the operator moves without it, the result being an extremely rare kind of
question, dubious for most speakers:
*Has Joe not attended the course?
+inversion
-negative contraction
In very formal British English, some speakers allow the uncontracted not to get attached to
the operator constituent:
Has not the Prime Minister attended the press conference?
Such a question is more likely to be rhetorical rather than information seeking. In general the
contraction is used instead of not in negative questions. See Baker p 391
2.3. Tag questions
Tag questions consist of a declarative clause followed by a tagged-on yes-no question. The tag
has a repetition of the auxiliary (or modal) in the declarative clause and a pronoun
referring to the subject:
He will find a well-paid job, wont he?
If the declarative clause has no available auxiliary or modal, the emergency operator do is
introduced:
Mary bakes the apple pie, doesnt she?
Mary baked the apple pie, didnt she?
If the declarative clause is affirmative, then the tag is normally negative. If the declarative
clause is negative, then the tag question is affirmative. The negative in the tag is always the
contracted form nt:
Harry gave you a cheque, didnt he?
Harry didnt give you a cheque, did he?
Following the analogy of positive and negative poles in electricity, the clauses and tags are
sometimes said to have affirmative or negative polarity. If the declarative clause has
negative polarity, then the tag must have affirmative polarity, and vice versa. If this restriction
is not observed, the sentence is likely to be interpreted not as a question but as a reflective
statement to oneself, or perhaps a sarcastic or threatening remark.
She has told a lie, has she?
They are rarely used in British English because they are felt to be aggressive:
or an adjunct in the structure of the sentences (i.e. an optional constituent such as Adverbial
Modifiers, Attributes):
d. She will live in London.
[PP Where] will she live __?
e. The train arrives in time/ early.
[PP/AdvPWhen] does the train arrive __?
f. He has gone bankrupt because he couldnt pay his debts.
[CP Why] has he gone bankrupt __?
1. Questioning the Direct Object
4
NPs functioning as Direct Objects appear after transitive verbs: simple or complex.
Jane will meet [NP her aunt].
Astronauts burn up [NP a lot of calories].
They accused John of theft.
In order to derive questions out of these declarative clauses, the targeted constituent, the
Object NP, will be replaced by a corresponding wh-phrase which will be moved to front
position after inversion takes place:
Jane will meet whom?
Astronauts burn up what?
Whom will Jane meet?
What will astronauts burn up?
+inversion
+wh-movement
preposition stranding
pied-piping
preposition stranding
pied-piping
To put it differently, the IO can be questioned only in the Oblique Object Construction.
The oblique object - double object alternation is not fully productive, i.e. not all ditransitive
verbs can appear in both constructions. There are ditransitive verbs that allow only one of the
two constructions.
a. Verbs like donate and distribute appear only in the oblique dative constructions with no
have no double object counterpart:
Only one of the wh-constituents moves into the Spec position of CP, the other(s) remain in
situ.
2.Echo questions
An echo question is used as a reaction to a declarative sentence by a speaker who wishes the
interlocutor to repeat part of the declarative sentence. Echo questions are formed by simply
substituting a question word for a constituent. The speaker may question a constituent (Su, O,
etc), a verb or a whole question:
This type of question refers back to all or part of the previous utterance (made by someone
else), which the hearer either does not understand or finds difficult to believe:
Ive bought an electric tooth-brush.
Did the Vice-Dean leave a message?
To question one constituent, the whole sentence is repeated and the wh-element replacing the
questioned constituent is stressed:
Just take a look at that.