Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
rules, which, when proved, have the status of legally binding rules of
general application.
7.
What is a treaty?
Article 2(1)(a) of the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties
provides that a treaty is an international agreement conducted between
states in written form and governed by international law, whether
embodied in a single instrument or in two or more related instruments and
whatever particular designation they may be given.
8.
9.
acting on the instructions of, or under the direction and control of, that State
in carrying out the conduct.
67. What conduct can be attributable to the State in the absence or default
of official authorities?
According to Article 9 of the Articles on State Responsibility, the conduct of
a person or group of persons shall be considered an act of a State under
international law if the person or group of persons is in fact exercising
elements of the governmental authority in the absence or default of the
official authorities in circumstances such as to call for the exercise of those
elements of authority.
64. What about organs placed at the disposal of a State by another State?
According to Article 6 of the Articles on State Responsibility, the conduct of
an organ placed at the disposal of a State by another State shall be
considered an act of the former State under international law if the organ is
acting in the exercise of elements of the governmental authority of the State
at whose disposal it is placed.
69. Can a State subsequently ratify the acts of a private person or entity?
Yes. In such a case, according to Article 11 of the Articles on State
Responsibility, the conduct which is not attributable to a State shall
nevertheless be considered an act of that State under international law if and
to the extent that the State acknowledges and adopts the conduct in
question.
65. Can the acts of State organs or entities in excess of their authority or
contravention of instructions be attributable to the State?
Yes. It is clear from Article 7 of the Articles on State Responsibility that the
conduct of an organ of a State or of a person or entity empowered to
exercise elements of the governmental authority shall be considered an act
of the State under international law if the organ, person or entity acts in that
capacity, even if it exceeds its authority or contravenes instructions.
71. What if the State is not bound by an international obligation at the time
the act contrary to such obligation was committed, can there be a
breach?
No. According to Article 13 of the Articles on State Responsibility, an act
of a State does not constitute a breach of an international obligation if a
State is not bound by the obligation in question at the time the act occurs.
72. What are the circumstances that preclude the wrongfulness of a States
action?
YE, according to Chapter V of the Articles on State Responsibility, a
wrongful act of a State is precluded in cases of a valid consent, self-defense,
countermeasures, force majeure, distress, and a state of necessity.
73. How can consent preclude the wrongfulness of an act?
According to Article 20 of the Articles on State Responsibility, consent by a
State to particular conduct by another State precludes the wrongfulness of
that act in relation to the consenting State, provided the consent is valid and
to the extent that the conduct remains within the limits of the consent given.
74. Can a State invoke self-defence?
Yes. According to Article 21 of the Articles on State Responsibility, the
wrongfulness of an act of a State is precluded if the act constitutes a lawful
measure of self-defense taken in conformity with the Charter of the United
Nations.
There is necessity where the only way a State can safeguard an essential
interest threatened by a grave and imminent peril is, for the time being, not
to perform some other international obligation of lesser weight or urgency.
79. When can necessity be invoked?
According to Article 25 of the Articles on State Responsibility, necessity
may be invoked if the act is: first, the only means for the State to safeguard
an essential interest against a grave and imminent peril; and second, such
does not seriously impair an interest of the State or States towards which the
obligation exists, or of the international community as a whole.
80. What are the instances wherein a State cannot invoke necessity?
According to Article 25 of the Articles on State Responsibility, a State
cannot invoke necessity if the international obligation in question excludes
the possibility of necessity or if the State has contributed to the situation of
necessity.
90. When can an injured State invoke the responsibility of another State?
According to Article 42 of the Articles on State Responsibility, a State is
entitled as an injured State to invoke the responsibility of another State if
the obligation breached is owed to either: (a) that State individually; or (b) a
group of States including that State, or the international community as a
whole, and the breach of the obligation: specifically affects that State; or is
of such a character as radically to change the position of all other States to
which the obligation is owed with respect to the further performance of the
obligation.
91. When can a State lose the right to invoke responsibility?
According to Article 45 of the Articles on State Responsibility, the
responsibility of a State may not be invoked if: first, the injured State has
validly waived the claim; or second, the injured State may be considered to
have validly acquiesced.
92. What happens if there are several States injured by the same
internationally wrongful act?
According to Article 46 of the Articles on State Responsibility, in such a
case, each State may separately invoke the responsibility of the State which
has committed the internationally wrongful act.
IX. ADMISSIBILITY OF CLAIMS
93. What are the requisites of admissibility?
According to Article 44 of the Articles on State Responsibility, the
Responsibility of a State may only be invoked if: first, the claim is brought
in accordance with any applicable rule relating to the nationality of claims;
and second, all available and effective local remedies have been exhausted.
XI. THE LAW OF TREATIES
94. When can a States unilateral declaration become binding upon such
State?
YE, according to the International Court of Justice in the Nuclear Tests
Case, unilateral declarations concerning a legal or factual situation may
create legal obligations when it is the intention of the state making the
declaration to become bound according to its terms, that intention confers
on the declaration the character of a legal undertaking, the state being
thenceforth legally required to follow a course of conduct consistent with
the declaration.
95. What grounds can be invoked to terminate a treaty?
YE, according to Article 54 of the Vienna Convention on the Laws of
Treaties, A treaty may be terminated or a party may withdraw in conformity