Professional Documents
Culture Documents
From the *Department of Anesthesiology, Seoul National University Medical College, Seoul, Korea, Department of Anesthesiology, Seoul National University Bundang Hospital, Seongnam City,
Kyeonggi-do, Korea.
Accepted for publication June 4, 2007.
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Jin-Hee Kim,
MD, Department of Anesthesiology, Seoul National University
Bundang Hospital, 300 Gumi-dong, Seongnam City, Kyeonggi-do,
463-802, Korea. Address e-mail to anesing1@snu.ac.kr.
Copyright 2007 International Anesthesia Research Society
DOI: 10.1213/01.ane.0000278149.66027.0b
620
METHODS
The local IRB of Seoul National University Hospital
approved the study protocol, and the parents of all
patients provided informed consent. One-hundredseven children (2 8 yr), scheduled to undergo elective
surgery under general anesthesia, were enrolled in
this study. Patients with pulmonary diseases, such as
bronchial asthma, abnormal breath sounds, and malformations of the trachea or bronchus on CXR, were
excluded. Patients with difficulties in neck flexion or
extension were also excluded. The patients were randomly allocated to one of three groups according to a
computer-generated random number. Induction was
performed IV with 5 mg/kg thiopental sodium. Rocuronium (0.6 mg/kg) was injected for neuromuscular
blockade. The patients were tracheally intubated with
an appropriate size tube that allowed air leakage at a
pressure of 20 25 cm H2O. The tube sizes were
determined using the formula, Age (yr)/4 4. If an
audible leak was auscultated at an inflating pressure
15 cm H2O, the tube was replaced with a tube the
next size larger. If no leak around the ETT was
auscultated at an inflating pressure 30 cm H2O, the
tube was replaced with the next smaller size. Tracheal
intubation was confirmed by the presence of an endtidal CO2 and bilateral breath sounds by auscultation.
Uncuffed tubes with a bevel facing the left and a
right-sided Murphys eye (Contour, Mallinckrodt,
Ireland) were used, which enabled the tip of the tube
to enter the right main bronchus when being advanced beyond the carina. After positioning the ETT
and providing mechanical ventilation, the length of
the ETT was measured at the upper incisor teeth and
secured to the upper lip.
In Group I, after tracheal intubation, the patient
was manually ventilated, and both lung fields were
auscultated to confirm that the ETT had been placed
correctly in the trachea. With the head held at the
midline in the neutral position, the ETT was advanced
gently until it entered a mainstem bronchus, usually
on the right side. This event was confirmed by a loss
of breathing sounds, usually on the left side. The ETT
was then slowly withdrawn until equal breath sounds
on both sides had returned. Before being secured at
the upper lip with adhesive silk tape, the ETT was
then withdrawn a further 2 cm in the children aged
between 2.0 and 5.0 yr or 3 cm in those aged between
5.1 and 8.0 yr (1).
In Group II, the standard intubation position was
used. The ETT was set at the level of the vocal cords,
such that an ETT with an internal diameter 4.0 and 4.5
mm was placed with the 4 cm mark from tip at the
vocal cords, and an ETT with an internal diameter
larger than or equal to 5.0 mm was set at 5 cm from the
tip at the cords (4).
In Group III, intubation was performed using the
modified Bednareks method (5). During intubation,
the head was placed in the standard position. The
Vol. 105, No. 3, September 2007
621
Group I
Group II
Group III
n 35
17/18
59.9 22.5
20.3 7.0
108.5 13.5
5.5 0.6
n 36
23/13
54.7 17.0
19.8 7.1
107.2 11.2
5.3 0.4
n 36
26/10
62.4 24.4
21.5 7.3
114.0 14.2
5.6 0.2
0.909
0.249
0.738
0.295
0.107
0.216
7
16
6
6
4
17
10
5
8
13
10
5
Table 2. Measured Tracheal Length, Distance Between the Endotracheal Tube Tip and Carina, Change in the Distance Between the
Endotracheal Tube Tip and Carina After Neck Movement, and the Angle of Neck Movement in Each Group
Tracheal length (cm)
T-C neut (cm)
T-C flex (cm)
T-C ext (cm)
T-C flex-neut (cm)
T-C ext-neut (cm)
Angle flex ()
Angle ext ()
Group I
Group II
Group III
0.298
0.05
0.05
0.05
0.726
0.284
0.073
0.171
Group I: using auscultation; Group II: using prescribed marks; Group III: using palpation.
flex neck flexion; ext neck extension; T-C distance between the endotracheal tube tip and carina; T-C change in the T-C after neck movement.
Table 3. Relative Depth of the Endotracheal Tube (ETT) Tip from the Carina to the Vocal Cords in the Trachea
T-neut (%)
T-flex (%)
T-ext (%)
Group I
Group II
Group III
21.4 6.7
9.5 10.3
44.3 12.1
46.5 13.0
38.3 13.4
71.7 16.1
43.4 11.1
32.4 12.5
67.9 14.7
0.05
0.05
0.05
Group I: using auscultation; Group II: using prescribed marks; Group III: using palpation. Relative position of the ETT tip: the ETT tip at the carina and vocal cords was considered to be 0% and
100%, respectively.
T-neut distance from the carina to the ETT tip in the neutral position/tracheal length; T-flex distance from the carina to the ETT tip in full flexion of the neck/tracheal length; T-ext distance
from the carina to the ETT tip in full extension of the neck/tracheal length.
RESULTS
Table 1 shows the demographic data of the patients.
The tracheal length and displacement of the ETT tip
622
Figure 1. Relative depth of the endotracheal tube tip from the carina in Group I. The carina and vocal cords were considered
to be the zero and 1.0 point, respectively. (: relative depth in neutral position; : relative depth after full flexion; : relative
depth after full extension).
Figure 2. Relative depth of the tip from the carina in Group II. The carina and vocal cords were considered to be the zero and
1.0 point, respectively. (: relative depth in neutral position; : relative depth after full flexion; : relative depth after full
extension).
DISCUSSION
The ETT can be displaced as a result of the neck
movement causing accidental endobronchial intubation or extubation from the trachea (1,4). Therefore, it
is extremely important to accurately place the ETT to
a predetermined depth to ensure safety during neck
movement. Several techniques for positioning the ETT
2007 International Anesthesia Research Society
623
Figure 3. Relative depth of the tip from the carina in Group III. The carina and vocal cords were considered to be the zero
and 1.0 point, respectively. (: relative depth in neutral position; : relative depth after full flexion; : relative depth after
full extension).
reliably results in an appropriate ETT depth. However, there were five cases of endobronchial intubation
after neck flexion.
Bloch et al. (1) suggested, through auscultation of
the bilateral lung sound, that the proper position of
the ETT was 2 cm (in children under 5 yr) or 3 cm (in
children over 5 yr) above the carina. Neck flexion
causes the ETT tip to move towards the carina, thereby
shortening the distance between the tip and the carina.
In children aged between 16 and 19 mo, the ETT tip
moved a mean distance of 0.9 cm with a maximum
movement of 1.2 cm (10). Therefore, an ETT positioned 2 cm above the carina can be considered to be
safe from endobronchial intubation during neck flexion in children under 2 yr. However, the position of
the ETT in children over 2 yr needs to be modified. In
this study, the relative position of the ETT tip in
Group I was 20.9% 6.7%, which was placed closer to
the carina than to the vocal cord, and may have
increased the risk of endobronchial intubation during
neck flexion. Indeed, the relative position of tip from
the carina in Group I decreased to 11.0% 10.3% after
full neck flexion, resulting in endobronchial intubation in 14.3% of children. Moreover, endobronchial
intubation occurred only in those children aged between 2 and 5 yr, in whom the aim was to place the
ETT tip 2 cm above the carina. Consistent with these
results, Verghese et al. (11) reported that a low tracheal position and right mainstem intubation occur
more often in children younger than 10 yr, and
particularly in younger children with a lower body
weight.
On the other hand, the relative positions of the ETT
tip in the neutral position in Groups II and III were
46.7% 13.3% and 43.8% 10.9%, respectively. The
ANESTHESIA & ANALGESIA
625