Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contents
Summary................................................................. 3
Ovum view............................................................3
Introduction............................................................. 3
Requirements for LTE mobile backhaul.................. 4
What do operators need?....................................4
Solutions for mobile backhaul................................. 5
Fixed solutions for mobile backhaul: Fiber........5
Wireless solutions for mobile backhaul.............5
Financial analysis.................................................... 6
AOptix Intellimax:
A New Alternative for Transport............................. 9
Introduction............................................................. 9
Diverse frequencies create robust platform........... 9
Ron Kline
Ron Kline is a principal analyst in Ovums Network
Infrastructure group. With over 29 years of industry
experience that includes 18 years working for a large
North American service provider, Ron has an in-depth
knowledge of network technology combined with a strong
business-oriented approach to problem solving. He is
responsible for the overall direction of Ovums North
American optical networking research, its network
infrastructure vendor strategies research, and its
mobile backhaul research. Ron specializes in DWDM,
bandwidth management, aggregation, and carrier
Ethernet technologies used in both wireline and wireless
networking applications.
Summary
In brief
In todays 4G/LTE wireless networks, there are many cell-site topologies, configurations, and sizes, each with a specific
set of backhaul capacity and performance needs. As we enter into the era of LTE-Advanced, single cell sites will start
to need capacities of 1Gbps and greater as a baseline capacity. With 5G looming on the horizon, carriers are now
recognizing the need to plan for backhaul capacity growth beyond 1Gbps.
Fiber delivers the capacity, reach, and availability required by most modern telecoms applications including mobile
backhaul. However, fiber deployment, even when it is feasible, can take months, partly because obtaining rights of way
can be challenging, notwithstanding the high deployment cost.
Given these challenges, mobile operators are turning to wireless-based microwave and millimeter-wave technologies,
but these technologies often sacrifice performance in the three most critical network parameters of capacity,
distance, and availability. A hybrid solution that combines an optical laser (through free space) and millimeter-wave
radio has emerged that is unique in its ability to provide a combination of guaranteed high capacity, extended reach,
and high availability at an affordable cost.
100000
10000
1000
100
10
5G
HSPA+ R7
HSUPA R6
HSDPA R5
0.1
EV-DO Rev. B
1
LTE-Advanced R10
(100 MHz)
EV-DO Rev. A
1x EV-DO
Introduction
WCDMA R4
Mbps
Ovum view
Source: Ovum
Availability
Backhaul equipment must be carrier grade, supporting
a BER of less than 10-6 and maintain 99.999%
availability regardless of weather conditions. This is a
strict requirement for mobile network operators which
have very low tolerance for downtime. Carrier grade
(sometimes called carrier class) refers to the equipments
availability to provide service. Carrier-grade systems are
typically engineered to stay in operation 99.999% of the
time meaning that, over one year, the system downtime
would not exceed 5.26 minutes.
Capacity
Backhaul bandwidth requirements for LTE and LTE-A
are increasing, as indicated in Figure 1. Traffic in a 3G
network gets aggregated as it makes its way to the
network core and can easily exceed 1Gbps on some
backhaul links. LTE in particular requires 10 times
the bandwidth of a 3G network and LTE-A bandwidth
requirements are six times that of LTE (nearly 100 times
higher than 3G) pushing backhaul requirements to the
range of 12Gbps for each base station. While 5G has
not yet been officially defined, early demonstrations and
prototypes use a 5Gbps downlink, meaning per-sector
bandwidth requirement would be 10Gbps, 350 times
more than 3G. It is critical that backhaul solutions being
Reach
Mobile cell networks are configured in a hierarchical
mesh. Traffic generated at cell site locations is
transported back to an aggregation point (sometimes
called a super cell) where it is combined (aggregated) with
other traffic for transport to the mobile switch. Average
distances from cell tower locations to aggregation points
Deployment
cost
Recurring
charges
Scalability
Deployment
time
Capacity
Typical CIR
Typical
distance
Typical
distance (CIR)
Fiber (own)
High
Low
Excellent
Months
Tbps
Tbps
~600km
~600km
Fiber (lease*)
Low
High
Excellent
Weeks
Tbps
Tbps
~600km
~600km
Unlicensed microwave
Medium/ low
Low
Poor
Weeks
10Mbps- 3Gbps
(using XPIC,
MIMO, and
compression)
N/A - cannot
guarantee rate
because of
interference
~924km
N/A - cannot
guarantee rate
because of
interference
Licensed microwave
Medium
Low
Good
Weeks
500Mbps- 2Gbps
(using XPIC,
MIMO, and
compression)
1Gbps
~50km
~20km
Millimeter-wave radio
Medium
Low
Good
Weeks
1 -3Gbps
1Gbps
~4km
~2km
Hybrid laser-radio
Medium
Low
Good
Weeks
2Gbps
2Gbps
110km
110km
Deployment time
Mobile operators globally spend billions of dollars each
year acquiring wireless spectrum to build out network
coverage. Much of the time cell tower locations are in
remote areas, and backhaul choices are limited. Running
new fiber is not only expensive, it often takes months to
plan and construct. Backhaul transmission equipment
Low cost
Millimeter-wave RF
Millimeter-wave RF, defined by the ITU as Extremely
High Frequency (EHF), operates in the 30300GHz range.
The subset of the EHF range used for telco applications
typically operates in the 70/80 GHz frequency spectrum
known as the E-band radios. Millimeter-wave RF can
support higher transmission rates in the 12Gbps range
but its system reach is much shorter than microwave RF,
and the technology is highly susceptible to rain fade and
absorption, requiring a reduction in data rate to mitigate
interference from weather. Millimeter-wave beams are
much narrower than microwave beams and, as a result,
the millimeter-wave RF equipment must be installed on
solid structures to avoid alignment problems. Given the
technologys shortcomings, its most often deployed for
Hybrid solutions
Given the choice, most operators will choose fiber
as their preferred backhaul solution due to its high
availability and near unlimited capacity. However,
in many cases, fiber is not an option, meaning that
operators have to deploy a wireless-based solution.
Signal attenuation caused by atmospheric conditions
leads to higher bit error ratios (BER) and inhibits
the capacity of microwave systems and the reach
of millimeter-wave technologies for macrocell site
backhaul. To overcome these issues, vendors are
developing hybrid solutions that use multi-beam or
multi-path architectures that can mitigate performance
issues caused by weather. One example of these new
hybrid solutions is a technology termed laser-radio
by MIT Technology Review: AOptix is a vendor that has
developed a version of laser-radio technology, used in its
AOptix Intellimax product.
Hybrid laser-radio combines an advanced version of freespace optics (FSO) with millimeter-wave radio frequency
(RF) technologies to create a hybrid transmission system
that operates in all weather conditions with carrier-grade
availability.
FSO is an optical technology that transmits infrared laser
light through free space (in most cases air) rather than
a physical media such as fiber. The technology supports
very high transmission rates with a low BER. Deployment
costs are low, the equipment is easy to install, it requires
Financial analysis
Fiber deployment
Microwave
3.5
Cost per GB
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Source: Ovum
$795.94m
Fiber deployment
$780.87m
Hybrid laser-radio
$829.49m
Source: Ovum
Source: AOptix
AWD enables carrier-grade availability and constant (non-adaptive) multi-gigabit throughput. At the heart of AWD is the
Dynamic Packet Resourcing (DPR) algorithm, which relies on dual-frequency transmission and real-time packet selection
across the two frequencies to produce an optimal output data stream. The technology enables error-free data transmission
of multi-gigabit capacity over long distances regardless of atmospheric challenges including fog, rain, and snow.
2015 Ovum. All rights reserved. www.ovum.com
Source: AOptix
10
Ultimately, the choice of a mobile backhaul solution is always based on the needs at the critical aggregation points in a
service providers network. For the vast majority of macrocell wireless backhaul, this comes down to a decision between
trenching for new fiber, leasing existing fiber, or deploying a wireless solution, whether that is microwave, millimeterwave, or laser-radio technology.
In a situation where carrier-grade availability is non-negotiable, high capacity is demanded, and fiber is too expensive
or unavailable, laser-radio technology provided by the AOptix Intellimax is the optimal solution for the needs of 4G/LTE
backhaul.
The AOptix high-capacity wireless solution is a true fiber alternative that provides advantages both in cost and speed of
deployment. AOptixs Intellimax can be deployed far more rapidly than fiber, and provides a return on investment (ROI)
in six to 12 months compared with trenching or leasing urban fiber connections. Additionally, AOptix Intellimax offers the
flexibility of deploying on any tower or structure, greatly simplifying site identification and network planning.
11
ABOUT OVUM
Ovum is a leading global technology research and advisory firm. Through its 180 analysts worldwide it offers expert
analysis and strategic insight across the IT, telecoms, and media industries. Founded in 1985, Ovum has one of the most
experienced analyst teams in the industry and is a respected source of guidance for technology business leaders, CIOs,
vendors, service providers, and regulators looking for comprehensive, accurate and insightful market data, research
and consulting. With 23 offices across six continents, Ovum offers a truly global perspective on technology and media
markets and provides thousands of clients with insight including workflow tools, forecasts, surveys, market assessments,
technology audits and opinion. In 2012, Ovum was jointly named Global Analyst Firm of the Year by the IIAR.
OUR OBJECTIVES
OUR SERVICES
Benchmark reports
Surveys
Webinars
White papers
Country reports
Company reports
Forecasts
Go-to-market reports
Case studies
Event facilitation
Speaking engagements
Workshops
For more details on Ovum and how we can help your company identify future trends and opportunities, please contact
us at enquiries@ovum.com or visit www.ovum.com. To hear more from our analyst team join our Analyst Community
group on LinkedIn www.ovum.com/linkedin and follow us on Twitter www.twitter.com/OvumTelecoms.