Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kazim Abdullaev
enturies of research on the cultic beverage haoma have produced an abundant wealth
of scholarship. In fact, any additional mention of this subject may seem redundant,
except to state that the present study relies on the existing literature in order to further evaluate new conclusions that are extracted from less frequently discussed artifacts. This
analysis follows a historical and cultural approach and is based on archaeological findings
from the Bronze Age and the early medieval period, present in the stratigraphic layers in
Bactria, Margiana, and Sogdiana. The surviving material from the antique period is not as
useful as that from these eras, which despite their large chronological gap, provide sufficient
archaeological sources on the continuous use of the haoma plant.1 The criterion used in the
selection of the material for this study is thematic and based on the reliability of the sources.
The absence of explicit identification of the haoma plant in the Avesta has produced a
wide range of hypotheses and conclusions. Commentary on the interchangeability of different
plants in the preparation of the soma drink, the Indian parallel of haoma, has led to contradictory hypotheses, including the identification of haoma with the fungus of the fly agaric.2
Consequently, determining the composition of haoma is still a topic of dispute. Ephedra is
often the suggested plant in this connection. This interpretation is supported by conclusive
proof such as the use of ephedra until the present time in the ritual practices of contemporary
Zoroastrian-Parsis. The fact that Parsis have over the centuries brought ephedra from Persia
and stored it in temple depositories further supports the identification of haoma and epheo f
dra.3 Proponents and opponents of the theory that haoma and ephedra were the same plant
ies
d
u
t
eS
trace this connection to evidence from ancient Iran and Central Asia.4 The ethnoreligious
ti v
d
a
r
an
a
a
p
studies of Mary Boyce are especially important in this regard.5
c
i
om
fr
,A
The question of the relationship between haoma and ephedra is further complicated as C
si a
A
u th
we learn that narcotic plants or substances are not necessarily related to the haoma and the culas t
So
eE
l
d
tic rites of Zoroastrians and their predecessors. In the ancient world there are known examples
id
3. Sir Aurel Stein, On the Ephedra, the Hum Plant, and the
Soma, BSOAS 4 (1931): 50114.
th e
ol.
V
30
.
No
3, 2
08
5 /1
01
0
92
20
1x-
er
.12
ni v
i 10
U
Man Stands in the Forest), Acta Iranica 10 (1985): 17984; I.M.
o
e
uk
d
Steblin-Kamenski, Flora iranskoy prarodiny (Flora of the Ira-
yD
1b
1
nian Homeland), Etimologiya 1972 (Moscow, 1974): 13840;
20
3 29
10
- 01
y
si t
Pre
s s
330
Co
ra
pa
ie
tu d
So
so
A
u th
ti v
si a
t
nd
he
a
frica
A
st
Ea
le
d
d
Mi
of the use of narcotic drugs for medicinal, therapeutic, and ritualistic practices.6 Sir Aurel Steins
discovery of the burials in the Lop Nur desert
(Tarim basin), where the utter aridity of the climate preserved some organic objects and bodies
of the deceased, revealed sacks containing twigs
of ephedra.7 Stein did not draw any definitive
conclusions on the significance of this discovery.
The presence of ephedra at the burial site could
indicate that it was used for its cultic and religious qualities or as an embalming plant. New
evidence from the late Bronze Age in Turkmenistan also points to the cult of haoma and the use
of narcotic plants. Research on this evidence
and the writing of V.I. Sarianidi on temple and
cult practices of the ancient inhabitants of this
region, and especially his use of the term protoZoroastrian, generated considerable discussion
and criticism among scholars.8 Notwithstanding
the abrupt use of the term proto-Zoroastrian,
the importance of Sarianidis investigation was
not entirely diminished.9 His arguments could
be interpreted as a reference to those elements
that were incorporated into Zoroastrian religious practices of the later epochs and were
gradually systematized into religious doctrines.10
Another criticism against Sarianidi pointed to
the contradictory nature of the source data that
Saka Haomavarga
14. Bactria cannot be included in the historical territories south of the slopes of Gissar (Baysuntau and Kugitangtau), where iron gates with the system of fortifications are located (contemporary Surkhandarya
region).
15. Srednyaya Azia i Dalniy Vostok v epokhu srednev
ekovya/ Srednyaya Azia v rannem srednevekove
(Central Asia and the Far East in the Medieval Epoch.
Central Asia in Early Medieval Age) (Moscow: Nauka,
1999), 21819.
16. V. I. Sarianidi, The Necropolis of Gonur (Athens:
Kapon, 2007).
17. V. V. Grigoryev, O skifskom narode sakah (The Saka
Scythians) (St. Petersburg, 1871), 8; Ferdinand Justi,
Geschichte des alten Persien (A History of Ancient Persia) (Berlin, 1879), seit 57; B. A. Litvinskiy, Saka Haumavarga (Saka Haomavarga), in Beitrge zur Alten
Geschichte und deren Nachleben: Festschrift fr Franz
Altheim zum 6.10.1968 (Contributions on Ancient History and Its Influences: Festschrift for Franz Altheim,
for 6 October 1968), ed. Ruth Stiehl and Hans E.Stier,
2vols. (Berlin: de Gruyter, 1969), vol. 1, seit 117, 11526.
331
vine services in connection with religious festivals and ceremonies.16 In this specific case, the
discussion focuses on the production of the cult
beverage, which theoretically can be identified
as haoma or haoma-l ike drinks, whose use in
cult rites and rituals, as attested by the rockstone inscriptions of the Achaemenid kings, was
common in Central Asia.
Kazim Abdullaev
is overlooked in the Greek worldview of Herodotus, for whom temples had certain defined
characteristics. As architectural constructions,
they exemplified the finest achievements of the
Greek art intended for the dwelling of the deities
who were personied as statues and images.13
This perspective excludes buildings in the valleys of Murgab and Oxus as temples. In a similar
vein, a historical interpretation of the Central
Asian cult practices cannot be determined on
the basis of orthodox measures borrowed from
Zoroastrian doctrines. For instance, some widely
popular ossuary funeral practices in Central
Asia during the Sassanian period do not follow
the orthodox and canonical Zoroastrian rites of
burial of the time.14 For instance, the custom of
burying the gathered bones of a body after exposing it in a special place (dakhma) in a ceramic
box prompted some scholars to argue for the
existence of a branch of Zoroastrianism in the
northeastern provinces of the Sassanid state.15
A similar kind of diversity exists in the
case of the haoma potion and its identification
with an actual plant. Excavations, particularly
in Bactria and Margiana, have revealed cult
chambers in temple complexes where sacred
beverages were manufactured. Sarianidis excavations on the sites of Gonur, Togolok-1, and
Togolok-21 outline this archaeological complexs special feature to be the inclusion of all
the rooms and constructions into the temple
household that carried cult procedures and di-
332
Co
ra
pa
ie
tu d
So
so
A
u th
ti v
si a
t
nd
he
a
frica
A
st
Ea
le
d
d
Mi
21. If we take into account the expansion of Achaemenid kings in the northern and northeastern directionsthat is, through Ragi, the Caspian Gates,
further through Hyrcania into Parthia and Margianathen it is more plausible that, on their way, the
Achaemenids could have first met the tribes of Saka
Haomavarga, which were located in the territory of
modern Turkmenistan. The tribes that populated the
eastern Pamirs were those removed from and less accessible to Achaemenid power.
22. Dandamaev, Pohod Dariya, 102.
23. A. N. Bernshtam, Istoriko-arheologicheskie ocherki
Tsentralnogo Tyan Shanya i Pamiro-Alaya (HistoricalA rchaeological Essays on the Central Tian-S han
and Pamir-Alay Regions) (Leningrad: Nauka, 1952);
Bernshtam, Saki Pamira (Pamir Sakas), VDI, 55
cusses. 24 Those who challenge this view compare the names Amyrgoy and Haomavarga with
the hydronim Murgab in southeastern Turkmenia, which they identify as the Amyrgian plain.25
These discussions delineate the geographic territory where haoma was considered sacred and,
consequently, facilitate a comprehensive analysis of the archaeological findings that refer to
this mysterious Avestan flora praised in the ancient hymns. In this context, the archaeological
sites Togolok-1, Togolok-21, and Gonur are especially important. As mentioned earlier, these
sites were discovered by Sarianidi in the Murgab
valley in the lower reaches of the ancient rivers
bed of Murgab (Turkmenistan), in the southeastern part of the Kara-Kum desert.
Togolok-1, a settlement, held a central
position in the oasis. Its area includes a temple
that was frequented by the local population of
the settlement and the satellite territories. It was
built on the slopes of a hill, next to the settlement fortress. The latter had a central yard surrounded with narrow corridors. Among the several rooms built around the yard was a special
room designated for preparing the intoxicating beverage haoma for use in cultic rituals. 26
This room contained clay and ceramic vats that
were placed into the floor. Another important,
related structure was a room located across
the yard and in close proximity to the haoma
production room. This room, distinguished
for the gutters installed in it, was built at an elevated ground level, which, as Sarianidi argues,
facilitated the flow of the blood of sacrificial
animals beyond the confines of the room and
into the yard. He further explains that not only
the walls, but also the floors of many rooms of
type, which, as Mr. T. A. Joyces analysis of the anthropometric materials collected by me has shown, is best
represented nowadays among Iranian-speaking hillmen of the valleys adjoining the Pamirs. Stein, On
the Ephedra, 502. See also Aurel Stein, Serindia: Detailed Report of Explorations in Central Asia and Westernmost China (London: Clarendon Press, 1921) 3:1351;
and Stein, Innermost Asia, 2:99697.
25. Litvinskiy, Saka Haumavarga, 11526.
26. V. I. Sarianidi, Margush: Drevnevostochnoe tsarstvo v staroy delte Murgaba (Margush: An Ancient
Oriental Kingdom in the Old Delta of the Murgab River)
(Ashgabat, Turkmenistan: T
rkmendwlethabarlary,
2002), 16263.
29. See N. R. Meyer-Melikyan, Analysis of Floral Remains from Togolok 21, in Margiana and Protozoroastrism, by V. I. Sarianidi (Athens: Kapon, 1998), app.
2, 17879.
30. V. I. Sarianidi, Protozoroastriyskiy hram v Margiane i problema vozniknoveniya zoroastrizma (A
Proto-Zoroastrian Temple in Margiana and the Problem of the Emergence of Zoroastrianism), VDI, 188
(1989): 158.
333
replica of the temples of Togolok-1 and Togolok21. The architectural composition of the temple
consists of a central yard and its surrounding
corridors, a special room for producing the
sacred beverage, an elevated ground with vessels imbedded into it, and remnants of gypsum
coating used for preserving the objects. Laboratory analysis of the vessels contents revealed the
remains of hemp.33 The temple of Dzharkutan,
in northern Bactria, also shows similar architectural characteristics.34 The distiller room at this
site is especially important for this discussion. A
small room, it stands alone, separate from the
rest of the structure. 35 In the later period this
construction is immured and completely covered with gypsum. The presence of this room
at the temple suggests that the liquid was a sacred intoxicant with ritualistic significance. The
evidence from Margiana, Togolok-1, Togolok-21,
Gonur, and Dzharkutan shows that these temple
communities produced the beverage that was
often referred to as haoma.
Kazim Abdullaev
33. Ibid. See also N. R. Meyer-Melikyan and N. A. Avetov, Analysis of Floral Remains in the Ceramic Vessel
from the Gonur Temenos, in Sarianidi, Margiana and
Protozoroastrism, 1767 7.
34. Grenet, O kornyah zoroastrizma, 17071. Grenet
investigates the similarities between the cult characteristics of the temples of Togolok-21 and Dzharkutan.
35. A. A. Askarov and T. Shirinov, Rannyaya gorodskaya
kultura epohi bronzy yuga Srednei Azii (Samarkand,
Uzbekistan: Izd-vo Instituta arheologii, 1993), 108.
334
Co
ra
pa
ie
tu d
So
u th
so
ti v
,
si a
t
nd
he
a
frica
A
st
Ea
le
d
d
Mi
335
Kazim Abdullaev
The monotheistic and highly principled demands of the teachings of Zoroaster inevitably
had to address the issue of other deities and
also the ritualistic practices of the ancient cults.
Although it was acknowledged that the cult of
haoma and its use of the cult beverage had an
adverse influence on the spiritual and physical
336
Co
ra
pa
ie
tu d
So
so
A
u th
ti v
si a
t
nd
he
a
frica
A
st
Ea
le
d
d
Mi
states of the potential followers of Zoroaster, ultimately the prophet was defeated in his stance
against haoma, whose stupefying properties he
had condemned. The cult of haoma, with its
godly incarnation, was incorporated into the
Zoroastrian religion. 55 The tradition of using
the cult beverage developed over time, with a
focus on the extraordinary influence that the
beverage exerted on the mental condition of
humans to the degree that they were able to
perform wondrous and divine actions. The powerful presence of the cult was such that it was
rehabilitated in later times in the Zend-Avesta
through dialogue between Zoroaster and the
personified, anthropomorphic image of haoma.
Gherardo Gnoli considers this influence in great
detail.56 He notes that Zoroaster condemns the
sacrifice of animals to haoma, an indication that
at some point the need arose for the spiritual
reconsideration of some of the cult traditions
that accompanied the mysterious dedications.
These traditions were some of the common
sources for Indo-Iranian religious practices and
attempts for understanding mental visions, internal self-contemplations, and the appearance
of inner illuminations.57 At the center of this development is the cult of haoma, which Zoroaster
condemns for its stimulating and hallucinogenic qualities (muthrem ahya madahya) (Yasna
48.10). In the Yasnas it is stated that Karapans
break the rules, established for the herdsmans
life (51.14). They train people to the evil matters in order to destroy life (46.11). With the
aid of intoxicating abomination beverage, they
intentionally fool people (48.10). If we assume
that Zoroaster allowed the practice of applying
a hallucinogenic beverage in the Zoroastrian
337
Kazim Abdullaev
338
Co
ra
pa
ie
tu d
So
so
A
u th
ti v
si a
t
nd
he
a
frica
A
st
Ea
le
d
d
Mi
74. The importance of the terra-c otta composition from Koshtepa is the arrangement of the two
components described above and, precisely, the soc alled altar and poppy. The location of the altar is
clear; however, since the terra-cotta was found, the
arrangement of the poppy has changed twice. The
first version is represented in Suleymanovs Drevniy
Nahsheb (fig. 182.2), where the poppy is placed in the
middlein the row of figures, along the diameter.
The second version is represented in the composition
after a recent restoration, in which the poppy was incorrectly moved to the altar. Finally, the third version was made after the original by the author who
found it, A. Raimkulov. In this, the most reliable version, in my view, the poppy is placed on the edge of
the disks base, opposite the altar.
339
BC and AD 100. It depicts a group of men dancing around a mushroom effigy.76 The terra-cotta
composition at Koshtepa could be another instance of primitive, vertically confronting figurines with short horizontal hand branches,
making it difficult to study the images anthropomorphic quality. That notwithstanding, if we
take into account the places where the terracotta is chipped, we can conclude that there are
forty figures positioned in the lines and semicircles. This scene reveals a certain procession
that was carried out as the participants lined
up in circles. The hands of the figures are held
in an elongated horizontal gesture, known in
Christian art as oranta. This motif is seen in certain Christian seals from the Sassanian period,
but it is absent from the ancient art of Iranianspeaking people.77 In addition, the reconstruction of the terra-cotta disk composition cannot
be modeled on the basis of Zoroastrian iconography. Although it is difficult to speak about the
details of the figures, who are practically lost
from the artifact, judging by their outlines that
are extant in the continuous rolled mass with
the expansion to the base, one can assume that
they are clad in long dresses that extend to the
heel. The horizontal position of their arms does
not necessarily imply traditional prayer position,
because in prayer the arms are, for the most
part, slightly separated to the sides and bent at
the elbows, and the hands are lifted upward.
A unique model of the art of early medieval Sogdiana, this terra-cotta composition
demonstrates the cultic scene with the ritualistic worship of and offering to the poppy, which
is possibly the personification of haoma. In addition, the number of participants at this cer-
Kazim Abdullaev
340
Co
ra
pa
ie
tu d
So
so
A
u th
ti v
si a
t
nd
he
a
frica
A
st
Ea
le
d
d
Mi
Conclusion
The archaeological discoveries in recent decades and the analyses of the artifacts and
other evidence from sites in Central Asia reveal
new information on the ancient religious cultural life of the region, which was home to the
Saka Haomavarga tribe. The ancient regions of
Margiana, Bactria, and Sogdiana still hold archaeological evidence that will constitute new
discoveries, which may confirm or refute the hypotheses and the conclusions that are proposed
by the present article. This study has proposed
arguments that address and raise further questions about the complex nature of the composition of the cult beverage and the level of the
78. Avesta v russkih perevodah (Avesta in Russian
Translations), ed. I. V. Rak (St. Petersburg: Nauka,
1997), 14950.
79. Ibid., 149n4. Zaleman writes: The ritual of the
preparation of the beverage Haoma included actions, which consisted in the fact that the priest accomplished several circuits around the mortar for the
squeezing of the juice of Haoma, reciting in this case
1921 stanzas of Hom-y asht. However, the terracotta representation from southern Sogdiana, if we
allow that in it is present a sacrificial altar and the
image of poppy, more resembles the scene of worship. Theoretically it is not possible to exclude the elements of worship in the process of the ceremony of
the production of the cult beverage.