Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project Report
On
‘ COMPARISON ON MUTUAL FUND SCHEMES’
Undertaken at:
Principal PNB Asset Management Company Pvt.
ltd.
At Ahmedabad Branch
Submitted by:
PUROHIT SHIRISH R.
06MBA46
Guided by:
MR. NIRAV MAJMUDAR
MBA PROGRAME
(2006-08)
1
DECLARATION
Purohit Shirish R.
(06MBA46)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
2
Learning is a delightful experience and in the ocean of knowledge
you can acquire limitless understanding through your craving for it.
And in my craving to know more, it has been memorizing extravagance
of memorable experience. At this enlightening moment of completion
of my project, I feel obliged to record my heartfelt and deep gratitude
to those who have helped me.
I feel immense pleasure to thank Dr. Bankim Patel,
Director, Shrimad Rajchandra Institute of Management &
Computer application (SRIMCA), Gopal Vidhyanagar for
making available all facilities in fulfilling the requirements
for the research work and being there for me as and when
required.
I feel immense pleasure in expressing my deep sense of
gratitude to my project guide from the Institute, Mr. Nirav Majmudar,
(Internal Mentor) Shrimad Rajchandra Institute of Management &
Computer Application, Gopal Vidhyanagar, for his valuable guidance
throughout preparation of this report.
I wish to convey my special thanks to Mr. Nitin Zanje as Sales
Manager, Mr. Mohit as assistance sales manager and also thanks to Mr.
Ketan Shah as Sales Executive, At the same time, I am very much
thankful to all staff members of Principal PNB Asset Management
Company Pvt. Ltd., at Ahmedabad for their kind co-operation who has
been a constant source of inspiration and encouragement to me.
I would like to record my special thanks to my parents, friends,
and colleagues help me directly or indirectly in preparation of project
work. I am sincerely thankful to all the faculty member of MBA
department who directly or indirectly supported me during the project.
I am also thankful to all the non-teaching staff of SRIMCA for their kind
support.
3
Shirish R.
Purohit
(06MBA46)
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
During the last three to four years Mutual Fund industry is booming
in India, which created some eagerness for my summer training. Thus
I decided to work on the Mutual Fund Industry. This would provide
me an opportunity to understand the Mutual Fund industry in better
way. Finally I got consent from Principal PNB Asset Management
Company Pvt. Ltd., Ahmedabad to conduct my project.
Through the discussion with the project mentor and literature review I came to
know that in India there is very less awareness about the Mutual Fund, and the figure of
awareness level in India is approximately 4 to 5%. The major portion of people’s savings
is not invested into the Mutual Fund, because of lack of awareness.
The project is based under the assumption that, as Mutual Fund being a new
investment avenue in the market people likes to get some information about Mutual Fund
and also about the products. I want to measure the performance of different mutual fund
schemes of different AMCs.
In the duration of 8 weeks I study various mutual fund schemes like, Large cap
fund Tax saving fund, Child benefit fund, Balance fund growth fund etc. I also studied
performance of different AMCs in particular scheme of mutual fund. In order to compare
the performance of AMCs in particular scheme, I collected daily Net Asset Values of
AMCs for the period of 2000 to 2007. Then I compare the performance using Sharpe’s
Performance index model. Then I also compare Sharpe index value with CNX
Midcap200.
4
I compared different AMCs performance in Balance scheme, Saving Scheme,
Equity Scheme & Growth scheme by using Sharpe’s model and calculated return and risk
of schemes to compare actual return with index return, thereby to measure the
performance of scheme of different AMCs.
In equity scheme 2003 and 2005 ICICI AMC, 2004 Tata AMC, 2006 and 2007
Principal AMC out performs index. In Balance scheme 2002 to 2005 HDFC AMC, 2006
Principal AMC and 2007 Tata AMC out performs index. In saving scheme 2000 to 2002
Sundarm AMC, 2003 to 2007 Principal AMC out perform index.
Apart from report I made more than 25 clients, they invested more than 2.5 lacs in
Principal Mutual fund schemes. I had done marketing of different Principal schemes at
Nationalized Banks. Altogether it was a great learning experience for me throughout
these 8 weeks of training.
5
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION 1
2 Research Methodology 54
4 key finding 64
5 Conclusion 66
6 Recommendation 67
7 Bibliography 68
6
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
7
PRINCIPAL PNB ASSET MANAGEMENT COMPANY PRIVATE
LIMITED
SPONSOR
8
billion in assets under management and serves some 14.8 million
customers worldwide from office in 12 countries throughout Asia,
Australia, Europe, Latin America and United States.
9
Vijaya Bank hold 65%, 30% and 5% respectively of the paid up equity
capital of the Asset Management Company. To reflect the change in
the controlling interest, the name of the Company with effect from
January 24, 2005 has been changed to Principal PNB Asset
Management Company Private Limited.
10
On June 23, 2003, Principal Financial Services Inc. USA acquired
100% stake in IDBI-PRINCIPAL Trustee Company Limited, through its
wholly owned subsidiary Principal Financial Group (Mauritius) Limited.
Name of the Trustee Company was changed to Principal Trustee
Company Private Limited, to reflect the change in ownership. On
April 30, 2004, Punjab National Bank and Vijaya Bank became equity
shareholders of the Trustee Company and post this, Principal
Financial Group (Mauritius) Limited, Punjab National Bank and Vijaya
Bank hold 65%, 30% and 5% respectively of the paid up equity capital
of the Trustee Company.
Mr. B. G. Deshmukh
Former Cabinet Secretary, Government of India.
Mr. H.M.Singh
Former Secretary, Government of India
11
Key Personnel
Rajan Ghotgalkar
Managing Director
Rajan Krishnan
Business Head-Asset Management
Rajat Jain
Chief Investment Officer
12
Rajat Jain is the Chief Investment Officer of Principal PNB Asset
Management Company Private Limited.
CUSTODIAN
CITIBANK NA
Ramnord house, 77 Dr. Annie Besant Road, Worli, Mumbai 400018
SEBI Registration No. IN/CUS/004
13
HARIBHAKTI AND CO.
Chartered Accountants
PRODUCT DETAIL
EQUITY FUNDS
DEBT FUNDS
14
Government Securities Fund A 100% debt oriented fund investing
primarily in government securities.
Cash Management Fund A 100% debt-based mutual fund targeted
at investors with a short-term investment horizon
Principal Income Fund Open-ended Income Fund
Principal Short Term Income Fund Open-ended Income Fund
Principal Monthly Income Plan Open-ended Income Plan with no
assured monthly returns
Principal Monthly Income Plan - MIP Plus An open ended fund.
Monthly income is not assured and is subject to the availability of
distributable surplus
Principal PNB Debt Fund Open-ended Debt Scheme
Principal Money Value Bond Fund Open end Income Scheme
Principal PNB FMP 460 Days-Series I A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 385 Days-Series I A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Fixed Duration Fund 3 Year Plan Series I A Closed Ended Income
Scheme offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 385 Days-Series II A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 91 Days-Series IV A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal PNB FMP 460 Days-Series II A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 91 Days-Series V A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
FMP 385 Days-Series III A closed-ended Debt Scheme offering Fixed
Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 91 Days-Series VI A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
15
FMP 540 Days Series I A closed-ended Debt Scheme offering Fixed
Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 91 Days-Series VII A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 91 Days-Series VIII A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal PNB
FMP 460 Days-Series III A closed-ended Debt Scheme offering Fixed
Maturity Plan
Principal PNB FMP 385 days Series IV A closed-ended Debt
Scheme offering Fixed Maturity Plan
Principal FMP 91 Days-Series IX A closed-ended Debt Scheme
offering Fixed Maturity Plan
SPECIALTY FUNDS
BALANCED FUNDS
16
1.2) HISTORY OF THE INDIAN MUTUAL FUND
INDUSTRY
17
The main reason of its poor growth is that the mutual fund
industry in India is new in the country. Large sections of Indian
investors are yet to be intellectuated with the concept. Hence, it is the
prime responsibility of all mutual fund companies, to market the
product correctly abreast of selling.
The mutual fund industry can be broadly put into four phases
according to the development of the sector. Each phase is briefly
described as under.
1987 marked the entry of non- UTI, public sector mutual funds
set up by public sector banks and Life Insurance Corporation of India
(LIC) and General Insurance Corporation of India (GIC). SBI Mutual Fund
was the first non- UTI Mutual Fund established in June 1987 followed by
Can bank Mutual Fund (Dec 87), Punjab National Bank Mutual Fund
(Aug 89), Indian Bank Mutual Fund (Nov 89), Bank of India (Jun 90),
18
Bank of Baroda Mutual Fund (Oct 92). LIC established its mutual fund
in June 1989 while GIC had set up its mutual fund in December 1990.
With the entry of private sector funds in 1993, a new era started
in the Indian mutual fund industry, giving the Indian investors a wider
choice of fund families. Also, 1993 was the year in which the first
Mutual Fund Regulations came into being, under which all mutual
funds, except UTI were to be registered and governed. The erstwhile
Kothari Pioneer (now merged with Franklin Templeton) was the first
private sector mutual fund registered in July 1993.
19
by Government of India and does not come under the purview of the
Mutual Fund Regulations.
The second is the UTI Mutual Fund Ltd, sponsored by SBI, PNB,
BOB and LIC. It is registered with SEBI and functions under the Mutual
Fund Regulations. With the bifurcation of the erstwhile UTI which had
in March 2000 more than Rs.76,000 crores of assets under
management and with the setting up of a UTI Mutual Fund, conforming
to the SEBI Mutual Fund Regulations, and with recent mergers taking
place among different private sector funds, the mutual fund industry
has entered its current phase of consolidation and growth. As at the
end of September 2004, there were 29 funds, which manage assets of
Rs.153108 crores under 421 schemes.
Note:
Erstwhile UTI was bifurcated into UTI Mutual Fund and the Specified
20
Undertaking of the Unit Trust of India effective from February 2003.
The Assets under management of the Specified Undertaking of the Unit
Trust of India has therefore been excluded from the total assets of the
industry as a whole from February 2003 onwards.
21
• MUTUAL FUND - CONCEPT
22
• ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE OF MUTUAL FUND
INDUSTRY
Unit
Holders
Sponsors
Trustee AMC
Transfer
Mutual Fund
Agent
SEBI
Mutual fund is set up in the form of a trust, which has sponsor, trustees,
asset management company (AMC) and a custodian. The trust is established
by a sponsor or more than one sponsor who is like a promoter of a company.
23
The AMC, approved by SEBI, manages the funds by making investments in
various types of securities. The custodian, who is registered with SEBI, holds
the securities of various schemes of the fund in its custody. The trustees are
vested with the general power of superintendence and direction over AMC.
They monitor the performance and compliance of SEBI Regulations by the
mutual fund.
Sponsor
Asset
Mgmt.
Mutual
Custodia Fund Company
n
Trustee
Company
Schem Sche
Scheme
e me
24
MUTUAL FUND
The Mutual Fund Regulations lay down several criteria that need
to be fulfilled in order to be granted registration as a mutual fund must
be registered with SEBI and must be constituted in the form of a trust
in accordance with the provisions of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882. The
instrument of trust must be in the form of a deed between the sponsor
and the trustees of mutual fund duly registered under the provision of
the Indian Registration Act,1908.
SPONSOR
TRUSTEES
25
the object of such other trust is not in conflict with the object of the
mutual fund. Additionally, no person who is appointed as a trustee of
a mutual fund can be appointed as a trustee of any other mutual fund
unless he is an independent trustee and prior approval of the mutual
fund of which he is a trustee has been obtained for such an
appointment. The trustees are responsible for-inter alia- ensuring that
the AMC has all its systems in place, all key personnel, auditors,
registrars etc. have been appointed prior to the launch of any scheme.
It is also the responsibility of the trustees to ensure that the AMC does
not act in a manner that is favorable to i9ts associates such that it has
a detrimental impact on the unit holders, or that the management of
one scheme by the AMC does not compromise the management of
another scheme.
The trustees are also required to ensure that an AMC has been
diligent in empanelling and monitoring any securities transactions with
brokers, so as to avoid any undue concentration of business with any
broker. The Mutual Fund Regulations further mandates that the
trustees should prevent any conflicts of interests between the AMC and
the unit holders in terms of deployment of net worth. The trustees are
also responsible for ensuring that there is no change carried out in the
fundamental attributes of any scheme or the trust or fees and
expenses payable or any other change that would modify the scheme
and affect the interest of unit holders, unless each unit holder is
provided with written communication thereof.
In addition, the unit holders must be given the option to exit at
the prevailing Net Asset Value (“NAV”) without any exit load. They are
obli9ged to perform a quarterly review of all transactions carried out
between the mutual funds, AMC and its associates. As far as
professional indemnity cover for the trustees or the AMC is concerned,
industry practice in India reveals that the insurance policy is taken out
by an Indian insurance company (as is required by the Insurance Act,
1938) while the risk is subsequently ceded to an overseas re-insurer
26
who underwrites the primary policy issued by the Indian insurance
company.
27
• The AMC shall not act as a trustee of any mutual fund;
• The AMC shall not invest in any of its schemes unless full disclosure
of its intention to invest has been made in the offer. However, an
AMC shall not be entitled to charge any fees on its investment in
that scheme.
CUSTODIAN
28
Guidelines, 1996,any person proposing to carry on the business as a
custodian of securities must register with the SEBI and is required to
fulfill specified eligibility criteria. Additionally, a custodian in which the
sponsor or its associates holds 50% or more of the voting rights of the
share capital of the custodian or where 50% or more of the directors of
the custodian represent he interest of the sponsor or its associates
cannot act as custodian for a mutual fund constituted by the same
sponsor or any of its associate or subsidiary company.
SCHEMES
There is obligation on the AMC and the trustee to ensure that the
statements made in the offer documents are true and correct. The AMC
is also required to provide an option to the unit-holder to nominate a
person in whom the units held by him shall vest in the event of his
death. SEBI has also prescribed an advertising code that has to be
observed while launching a new scheme.
29
However, this requirement is not mandatory if the scheme provides for
periodic repurchase facility to all the unit-holders or monthly income or
caters to special classes of persons, if the details of such repurchase
facility are clearly disclosed in the offer document or if the scheme
opens for repurchase within a period of six months from the closure of
subscription. The units of close-ended scheme may be converted into
open-ended scheme if the offer document of such scheme discloses
the option and the period of such conversion or if the unit-holders are
provided with an option and the period of such conversion or if the
unit-holders are provided with an option to redeem their units in full. A
close-ended scheme is required to be fully redeemed at the end of the
maturity period. However, a close-ended scheme may be allowed to be
rolled over if the purpose, period and other terms of the roll over and
all other material details of the scheme including the likely composition
of assets immediately before the roll over, net assets and NAV of the
scheme, are disclosed to the unit-holders and a copy of the same4 has
been filed with SEBI. Additionally, such a roll over would be permitted
only in case of those unit-holders who have expressed their consent in
writing and the unit-holders who do not opt for the roll over or have not
given written consent shall be allowed to redeem their holdings in full
at NAV based price.
INVESTMENT CRITERIA
30
aggregates of securities which are worth Rs.100 million or more shall
be required to settle their transactions through dematerialized
securities. In addition to the above, mutual fund are not permitted to
borrow money from the market except to meet temporary liquidity
needs of the mutual funds for the purpose of repurchase, redemption
of units or payment of interest or dividend to the unit holders. Even
such borrowing cannot exceed 20% of the net asset of a scheme and
the duration of such a borrowing cannot exceed a period of six months.
Similarly, a mutual fund is not permitted to advance any loans for any
purpose.
The mutual Fund Regulations lay down certain restrictions on the fees
that can be charged by the AMC and also caps the express that can be
loaded on to the Fund. The AMC can charge the mutual fund with
investment and advisory fees subject to the following restrictions:
• One and a quarter of one per cent of the weekly average net assets
outstanding in each accounting year for the scheme concerned, as long
as the net assets do not exceed Rs.1 billion, and
31
• One per cent of the excess amount over Rs.1 billion, where net assets
so calculated exceeds RS.1 billion.
1. The first Rs.100 cores of the average weekly net assets – 2.5%
2. On the next Rs.300 cores of the average weekly net assets –
2.25%
3. On the next Rs.300 cores of the average weekly net assets –
2.0%
4. On the balance on the assets – 1.75%
32
MUTUAL FUND OPRTATION FLOW CHART
33
debentures. The income earned through these investments and the
capital appreciation realized is shares by its unit holders in proportion
to the number of units owned by them. Thus a mutual fund is the
most suitable investment for the common man as it offers an
opportunity to invest in a diversified, professionally managed basket of
securities at a relatively low cost.
34
TYPE OF MUTUAL FUNDS
35
Type of Funds, as per structure….
36
A close-ended fund or scheme has a stipulated maturity period
e.g. 5-7 years. The fund is open for subscription only during a specified
period at the time of launch of the scheme. Investors can invest in the
scheme at the time of the initial public issue and thereafter they can
buy or sell the units of the scheme on the stock exchanges where the
units are listed. In order to provide an exit route to the investors, some
close-ended funds give an option of selling back the units to the
mutual fund through periodic repurchase at NAV related prices. SEBI
Regulations stipulate that at least one of the two exit routes is
provided to the investor i.e. either repurchase facility or through listing
on stock exchanges. These mutual funds schemes disclose NAV
generally on weekly basis.
37
Equity Debt Money
Market
Fixed
Equity Fund
Income Money
Index Funds
Funds Market
Sector Funds
Mutual
Liquid Funds
Balanced Funds
38
Equity schemes are hence not suitable for investors seeking
regular income or needing to use their investments in the short-term.
They are ideal for investors who have a long-term investment horizon.
The NAV prices of equity fund fluctuates with market value of the
underlying stock which are influenced by external factors such as
social, political as well as economic.
39
General Purpose+
Sector Specific
Special Schemes
Index schemes
40
managed for such investors. An example to such a fund is the HDFC
Index Fund.
41
Debt Oriented Scheme
42
those not in a position to take higher equity risks, such as retired
individuals. However, as compared to the money market schemes they
do have a higher price fluctuation risk and compared to a Gilt fund
they have a higher credit risk.
Income Schemes
Gilt Funds
43
This scheme primarily invests in Government Debt. Hence the
investor usually does not have to worry about credit risk since
Government Debt is generally credit risk free.
Hybrid Schemes
44
Mutual funds cannot increase the load beyond the level
mentioned in the offer document. Any change in the load will be
applicable only to prospective investments and not to the original
investments. In case of imposition of fresh loads or increase in existing
loads, the mutual funds are required to amend their offer documents
so that the new investors are aware of loads at the time of
investments.
Affordability
45
would be affordable for an investor to build a portfolio of investments
through a mutual fund rather than investing directly in the stock
market.
Professional Management:
Transparency
Diversification
The nuclear weapon in your arsenal for your fight against risk. It
simply means that you must spread your investment across different
securities (stocks, bonds, money market instruments, real estate, fixed
deposits etc.) and different sectors (auto, textile, information
technology etc.). This kind of a diversification may add to the stability
of your returns, for example during one period of time equities might
under perform but bonds and money market instruments might do well
46
enough to offset the effect of a slump in the equity markets. Similarly
the information technology sector might be faring poorly but the auto
and textile sectors might do well and may protect your principal
investment as well as help you meet your return objectives.
Spreading Risk:
Liquidity:
You are free to take your money out of open-ended mutual funds
whenever you want, no questions asked. Most open-ended funds mail
your redemption proceeds, which are linked to the fund's prevailing
NAV (net asset value), within three to five working days of your putting
in your request
Variety
47
Flexibility
Convenience
Tax Benefits
Regulations:
48
requirements. Such a high level of regulation seeks to protect the
interest of investors.
Risks Involved
Changing market conditions can create fluctuations in the
value of a Mutual Fund investment.
There are fees & expenses associated with investing in Mutual
Funds that do not usually occur when purchasing individual
securities directly.
As with any type of investment, there are drawbacks
associated with Mutual Funds.
No Guarantees
Potential Loss
Unlike a bank deposit, the investment in a Mutual Fund
could fall in value, as the fund is nothing but a portfolio of
different securities. Apart from a few assured returns schemes,
the fund does not guarantee any minimum percentage of return.
49
The Diversification Penalty
While diversification reduces the risk of loss from holding a
single security, it also limits the larger gains if a single security
increases dramatically in value. Also, diversification does not
protect the unit holders totally from an overall decline in the
market.
Hidden Costs
In some cases, the efficiencies of fund ownership are offset
by a combination of sales commissions, 12b-1 fees, redemption
fees, & operating expenses. If the fund is purchased in a taxable
account, taxes may have to be paid on capital gains. Keep track
of the cost basis of your initial purchase & new shares that are
acquired by reinvesting distributions. It's important to compare
the costs of funds you are considering. Always look at "net"
returns when comparing fund performances. Net return is the
bottom line; an investment's true return after all costs is
deducted.
Prospectuses will not contain all the costs that affect the
net return on your investment. This is why it is important to
compare net returns whether or not the fund in a no-load or load
fund.
Expenses
50
These expenses are typically expressed as the expense
ratio - the percent of fund assets spent (annually) on day-to-day
operations. Expense ratios can vary widely among funds.
Expense ratios for Mutual Funds commonly range from 0.2% to
2.0%, depending on the fund. Consult the fund's prospectus to
determine the expense ratio for a specific fund.
51
• This mutual fund association of India maintains a high
professional and ethical standards in all areas of operation of the
industry.
• At last but not the least association of mutual fund of India also
disseminate information’s on Mutual Fund Industry and
undertakes studies and research either directly or in association
with other bodies.
52
Mutual Funds shall be established in the form of trusts under the
Indian Trust Act and managed separately formed asset
Management Company.
An AMC can not act as the AMC for another Mutual Fund
53
All Mutual Funds mu8st distribute a minimum of 90% of their
profits in any given year.
Where,
Net assets of the scheme = Market Value of the Scheme +
Receivables + Other Accrued Income + Other Assets – Accrued
Expenses – Other Payables – Other liabilities
Entry Load
Entry load are the charges levied by the mutual fund scheme to
meet their routine expenses of the scheme and initial expenses and
distribution expenses of the mutual fund. Generally entry load is taken
on the open ended scheme of the mutual fund where any one can
withdraw their money at any time. One some one invests in the open
54
ended scheme the entry load is added to its current NAV. Generally
entry load of the mutual fund is varies between 1.5% to 3%.
Exit Load
Exit load are the charges levied by the mutual fund when some
one redeemed the fund from the mutual fund. This load is levied to
maintain the investor to remain invested in the mutual fund for the
longer term. The exit load is generally taken on the closed ended
scheme of mutual fund.
As on Jun, 2007
55
ING Mutual Fund 157 5346
JM Financial Mutual Fund 128 3758
JP Morgan Mutual Fund 3 825
Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund 144 16722
LIC Mutual Fund 81 9222
Lotus India Mutual Fund 108 4165
Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund 1 3291
Principal Mutual Fund 129 11551
Quantum Mutual Fund 5 69
Reliance Mutual Fund 236 59857
Sahara Mutual Fund 29 187
SBI Mutual Fund 178 20273
Standard Chartered Mutual 203 12946
Fund
Sundaram Mutual Fund 147 9400
Tata Mutual Fund 265 14837
Taurus Mutual Fund 14 308
UTI Mutual Fund 216 39032
Reliance
Asset Under Management
ICICI
UTI
59144
86070 HDFC
Franklin
11551 50703 Birla
SBI
14586
16170 Kotak
Principal Pnb 56
Others
Bank V/S Mutual Fund
PARTICULARS BANKS MUTUAL FUNDS
57
The Investment Objective of the scheme would be to provide
capital appreciation and /or dividend distribution by predominantly
investing in companies having a large market capitalization. Principal
Large cap fund that seeks to invest in fundamentally strong companies
with Large Market Capitalization.
58
• Risk Taking Ability: On the operational side, they
have access to sophisticated information systems and use superior risk
management systems.
• Preference given by Institutional Investors:
Large Cap companies are the preferred stocks for long-term
investments for large institutional investors like insurance companies,
Provident funds, Foreign Institutional Investors (FIIs), etc.
Investment Objective
59
The Investment Objective of the scheme would be to provide
capital appreciation and /or dividend distribution by predominantly
investing in companies having a large market capitalization.
Investment Strategy
Dividend Frequency
Load Structure
60
Entry Load – For applications below Rs. 3 crore – 2.25%. For
applications of Rs.3 crore and above - Nil
Exit Load – For applications below Rs.3 crore – Nil.
For applications of Rs.3 crore upto Rs.5 crore – 0.50% if redeemed
within 3 months. For applications of Rs.5 crore and above - Nil
CHAPTER 2
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Objective
61
To understand the various schemes of Mutual Fund.
To compare the various schemes.
Research Design:
• Sampling Technique
Judgmental sampling
Data collection sources
–Web site
Data analysis Package - MS office
62
LIMITATION
The project is based on the Beta calculation, but the dates of the
index and NAV does not match to get reliable calculated Beta.
63
CHAPTER – 3
DATA ANALYSIS AND INTREPRETATION
Rp-Rf
St =
σ Ρ
Rf = Risk free rate of interest (Rf = 7.46% per annum T-Bills rate)
64
(%)
Balance scheme
The above table shows the unsystematic risk and return of the HDFC
AMC in the balance scheme.
The above table shows the unsystematic risk and return of the Principal
AMC & ICICI AMC in the Balance Scheme.
Reliance Regular
SBI Magnum
Tata Balanced Fund Savings Fund- Birla Sun Life 95
Balanced Fund -
YEA - Growth HYBRID PLAN- Fund-PlanB Growth
Growth
R Growth Option
RETURN S.D. RETURN S.D. RETURN S.D. RETURN Risk
0.11885 0.01220 0.11846 0.05155 0.00328 0.10257 0.01031
2006 0.01137
5 2 1 2 3 1 3
0.15309 0.07897 0.00837 0.00798 0.12381 0.00787
2007 0.00854 0.0902
7 2 3 5 8 4
65
The above table shows the unsystematic risk and return of the Tata
AMC, SBI Magnum AMC, Reliance AMC & Birla Sun Life AMC in the
Balance Scheme.
YEA
Sm
R
2000 -8.58366
2001 -8.76248
2002 -5.68094
2003 11.10953
2004 -2.34097
2005 3.851475
2006 3.636869
2007 2.147195
PRINCIPAL Birla
HDFC TATA SBI RELIANCE
YEA PNB sun
R child's
Growth CBP FGP
invt
0.83819 -
2002 -2.78226 -2.74495
8 10.6924
22.0121 -
2003 13.44011 12.7017
9 10.2822
0.95660 -
2004 -7.07276 -1.59364
3 7.64841
10.7299 -
2005 6.0454 5.469134
4 11.1473
- 2.71220 3.85760
2006 3.978302 -2.8534 5.653099 3.626864 -7.02041
6.70942 8 8
66
- 9.19168 6.25069 0.52215
2007 2.379476 0.132496 7.528484 1.953663
9.96886 6 9 5
Intrepretation:
The above tables shows the From the above calculation we can
say that in the Balance fund scheme in the year 2002 to 2005 HDFC
AMC, 2006 Principal AMC, 2007 TATA AMC out perform index - which
means that this Mutual Fund scheme is able to give more return than
the benchmark Index used for comparison.
Equity Scheme
Kotak
ICICI Prud Growth Tata Pure Equity- Sahara Growth Mahindra_kotak30-
Plan-Growth Growth Fund-Growth Growth
YEAR RETURN S.D RETURN S.D. RETURN S.D. RETURN S.D.
0.02562
2000 -0.19239 7
0.03485 0.02214
2001 4 3
0.01237 0.02425 0.01180
2002 0.05097 4 2 9
0.26775 0.01389 0.01582 0.01337 0.29682 0.07784
2003 3 4 1 2 2 5
0.45335 0.36317 0.01574 0.07199 0.02619 0.08132
2004 9 0.67122 1 9 7 5 8 0.013728
0.16096 0.01078 0.14642 0.01554 0.13307 0.03447 0.11145
2005 5 6 3 4 1 9 8 0.008363
0.14475 0.01640 0.14366 0.15487 0.01564 0.09944
2006 1 6 1 0.01718 7 6 8 0.012709
0.08195 0.01276 0.07575 0.01384 0.08482 0.01114 0.07783
2007 6 8 5 1 1 7 9 0.011268
67
The above table shows the unsystematic risk and return of the ICICI
AMC, Tata AMC, Sahara AMC & Kotak Mahindra AMC in the Equity
scheme.
Sundaram BNP
Paribas select Morgan Stanley Principal Large HSBC Equity Fund
focus Growth Fund Cap-Growth - Growth
AVERAG
YEAR RETURN S.D RETURN E RETURN S.D RETURN
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
0.14349
2005 5 0.02645
0.16323 0.03029 0.10985 0.16444 0.01645 0.12944 0.01720
2006 3 7 2 0.016262 7 1 8 4
0.08528 0.01276 0.09016 0.13636 0.01273 0.07935 0.01226
2007 8 3 9 0.01237 6 3 6 5
The above table shows the unsystematic risk and return of the
Sundaram BNP AMC, Morgan Stanley AMC, Principal AMC & HSBC AMC
in the Equity scheme.
68
2007 0.576084 0.083448 0.916928 0.287451 0.837421 1.25861 4.85086
Intrepretation:
Saving Scheme
The above table shows the unsystematic risk and return of the
Sundaram BNP AMC, ICICI AMC and Principal AMC in the tax saving
scheme.
YEAR Birla Sun Life Relief Franklin Templeton Kotak Tax Saver Reliance Tax
96 Mutual Fund- scheme-Growth saver-Growth
Growth
69
AVERAG AVERAG
E S.D E S.D. RETURN S.D. RETURN S.D
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
0.02746 0.01496 0.12086 0.01720
2006 -0.01234 2 0.096578 3 5 1.61349 0.10498 6
0.32889 0.04332 0.01187 0.14011 0.01112 0.04914 0.01135
2007 6 4 0.103634 7 3 1 9 9
The above table shows the unsystematic risk and return of the Birla
Sun Life AMC, Franklin Temp. AMC, Kotak AMC and Reliance AMC in the
tax saving scheme.
Sundar Birla
ICICI Principal Franklin Kotak Reliance
m Sun
YEAR
Tax
Personal
Saver
2000 -9.55604 -2.21862 -12.9816
-
2001 -0.95879 -9.37438 -8.54341
2.65248
20.2036 -
2002 -1.38932 1.123352
9 9.47791
-
2003 -5.38315 13.70113 17.1773
33.0119
- 2.77109
2004 -1.40075 0.397652
11.0893 5
- 7.50559
2005 2.169468 -4.53579
25.9142 6
- 4.28062 1.46884 0.02867
2006 1.549174 1.076482 -3.16583 1.765663
8.99192 5 3 4
- 10.1322 2.44454 5.89093
2007 -1.19814 2.52044 5.869633 -2.2406
10.9905 9 8 3
Intrepretation:
70
performance than index and bold figures show the highest
performance than others.
Growth scheme
Intrepretation:
CHAPTER -4
FINDINGS
• Balance Scheme:
In the year 2002 to 2005 HDFC AMC having highest rank with
highest return than other AMCs, 2006 Principal AMC highest rank with
highest return but HDFC AMC having low risk than other AMCs, 2007
71
TATA AMC having highest rank but Principal AMC having highest return
and low risk then other AMCs.
• Equity Scheme:
• Saving Scheme:
In the saving scheme mean that tax saving scheme in the year
2002 that is Sunarm tax saving having highest rank with high return
but low unsystematic risk was available in the principal personal tax
saving fund. In the year 2003 principal tax saver having high rank with
high return and low unsystematic risk. In the year 2004 principal
personal tax saver having high rank with low unsystematic risk and
high return is available in the principal tax saving fund. In the year
2005 Principal tax saver having high rank with high return and low
unsystematic risk. In the year 2006 Principal tax saver having high rank
with high return and Frankline Templeton mutual fund having low
unsystematic risk. The year 2007 principal personal tax saver having
72
high rank with high return and Kotak tax saver having low
unsystematic risk than other AMCs.
• Growth scheme:
CONCLUSION
The determination of the best scheme out of the 4 does not have
a yes-no answer. It depends on the objective of the investor along with
the risk return appetite. Thus we cannot make inter scheme
comparison. Rather we would have to make comparison of various
companies providing the same scheme, which is mentioned below:
In the Balance fund schemes the years from 2000 to 2005 HDFC
AMC is well performing (good return) among other in the same scheme,
after that Principal Child benefit scheme is performing good in year
73
2006, now in current year 2007 TATA AMC has given good performance
under this Balanced Fund scheme.
In the Equity Scheme year 2003 ICICI AMC performed well among
this scheme, in 2004 TATA AMC is performing well than any other
scheme but 2006 to 2007 the Principal AMC gives better.
In the Tax Saving scheme the years 2000 to 2002 Sundarm BNP
AMC well performing [good Return] among this scheme but from the
year 2003 to 2007 Principal AMC having well Position in the among this
scheme.
CHAPTER - 5
Recommendation
74
• The prospective investor should scrutinize the expense ratio of
the fund and compare it with others.
Bibliography
• http://www.principalindia.com/presentation/view/funds.aspx
• http://www.amfiindia.com/navhistoryreport.asp
• www.hdfcfund.com/fundschool/sebi1Show.jsp
• www.sbimf.com/portal/static/inv-faq1.html
• Punithvanthy Pandian, “Security Analysis And Portfolio
Management”,
3rd Edition, Vikas Publishing House Pvt. Ltd.
75
76