Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A History of
Utilitarianism
Intrinsic Value
Many things have instrumental value, that is, they have value as means to an end.
However, there must be some things which are not merely instrumental, but have value in
themselves. This is what we call intrinsic value.
Pleasure
Happiness
Ideals
Jeremy Bentham
G. E. Moore
Preferences
Kenneth Arrow
Jeremy Bentham
1748-1832
Bentham believed that
we should try to increase
the overall amount of
pleasure in the world.
Pleasure
Advantages
Easy to quantify
Short duration
Bodily
Criticisms
Happiness
Advantages
Disadvantages
Competing conceptions of
happiness
Utilitarianism
Theory of Utilitarianism
CONSEQUENTIALIST APPROACH
We should decide what to do by considering the consequences of
our actions.
We should act in ways that produce better consequences than the
alternatives we are considering.
The Good: Things (goals, states of affairs) that are worth pursuing and
promoting.
The Right: the moral rightness (or wrongness) of actions and policies.
Consequentialists say that actions are Right when they maximize the Good.
Theory of Utilitarianism
WHAT IS MEANT BY BETTER CONSEQUENCES?
happiness, health, dignity, integrity, freedom, and respect of all the people affected.
Ultimate ethical goal from this theory: to produce the best consequences for all
the parties affected by the decisions
Theory of Utilitarianism
IT PROVIDES STRONG SUPPORT FOR DEMOCTRATIC INSTITUTIONS AND POLICIES
Government and all social institutions exist for the well-being of all, not to
further the interests of the monarch, the nobility, or some small group of the
elite
CHILD LABOR
Problematic consequences:
CHILD LABOR
Alternative Decisions:
Consequences
of factory jobs:
They would have less money for food and family support.
Young children who are prohibited from joining the workforce might
include crime, drugs, and prostitution
Child
Theory of Utilitarianism
Theory of Utilitarianism
Happiness
the only thing that it and can be valued for its own sake