You are on page 1of 15

VOEST-ALPINE Industrieanlagenbau

Steelmaking

VAI TECHNOLOGY NEWS


Issue No. 31/Aug. 1999
1999

Oxygen in
Steelmaking
Technologies
Technology is Our Trademark

VAI Steelmaking Technology

Table of Contents
Dear Reader,

lities, such as oxy/fuel burner or oxy/gas burner, superso-

Page

nic water-cooled oxy/carbon lances and postcombustion


We are highly pleased to present this issue of Technology

systems gave the electric-arc-furnace processes a signifi-

News to you which will give you a survey of oxygen

cant impetus.

technologies in the iron and steelmaking sector.


Preface

Moser Herbert *

The Use of Oxygen in Metallurgical Processes

Dimitrov Stefan *

The supply of great amounts of fossil energy essentially


The history of VAI is closely linked with the development of

increases the productivity of the unit. Moreover, quicker

the LD or basic oxygen steelmaking process. The LD con-

response to changed process conditions is ensured in this

verter was developed in Linz, where the first LD plant was

way. Advantageously lower demands are placed on the

started up in 1952. This was the place from where steel-

oxygen quality (95.5% purity).

making was totally revolutionized.


VAOX Gas Generation Plants

Wawrina Rainer **

Hausleitner Hannes **

Basic Oxygen Processes

ble until tonnage oxygen was commercially produced and

is supplied to the iron and steelmaking industry worldwide.

oxygen was used in vacuum processes. This allowed char-

A large number of steelmaking processes became econo-

ging higher-carbon scrap and lower-cost ferroalloys (which

mically efficient only after oxygen was used more intensi-

resulted in a more general acceptance as well as the crea-

vely.

tion of new stainless steel applications worldwide).

During traditional converter operation oxygen with a purity

The increased use of oxygen in steelmaking was accompa-

of 99% plays a decisive role. A multitude of different con-

nied by a generation of new oxygen-generating plants

verter processes guarantee high adaptability to the specific

which are capable of separating oxygen from the air by

outline conditions and requirements. With supportive dyna-

means of pressure and vacuum swing absorption. These

mic process control the operational production process

generating plants will increasingly gain acceptance particu-

Kerschbaumer Helmut *

can be optimized via converter off-gas analysis while avoi-

larly in the electric-steelmaking sector.

Forsthuber Markus ****

ding overblowing of the heat.

Pirklbauer W. *

Gaugl S.*

The Dynamic Process ModelDYNACON

New Tasks of the LD Lance

The low-cost production of high-alloy steels was not possiToday, about half the industrially generated oxygen volume

Mller Johannes *

Enkner Bernhard *

10

12

VAI and its subsidiaries provide the entire scope of technoOxygen Management for Electric Steelmaking

Berger Harald *

16

Mittag Peter *

The latest developments in LD lance technology allow

logies relating to oxygen, from oxygen generation and con-

additional injecting of dusts accumulated in the process

sumers up to off-gas management. Moreover, VAI is conti-

together with oxygen used as a carrier gas.

nuously investigating new solutions to allow even more

Zhai Yuyou *

effective use of oxygen as well as improvements in the proThe development and integration of oxygen-operated faci-

Economic Effect of Oxygen Input in the EAF

Berger Harald *

duction process.

18

Mittag Peter *
Zhai Yuyou *

The Use of Oxygen in Stainless-Steel Production

Steins Johannes *

22

Schnell Gnther ***


Schrade Christian ***

VAI Technology News

VAI Steel Production Technologies

**

VAIS

***

VAI-Technometal

****

VOEST-ALPINE STAHL Donawitz

Issue No. 31/August 1999

The original LD patent


and the first LD heat (Linz/Austria, October 1949)

VAI Technology News

Work on the EAF in the late 50s

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Steelmaking Technology

The Use of Oxygen in Metallurgical Processes

M E T A L L U R G I C A L

A S P E C T S

Oxygen is employed in several different ways in steelma-

Adding of solid/bonded oxygen in the form of ore (i.e.,

king and occurs in more or less all of the process steps.

hematite ore with 85% Fe2O3 and chromium ore in

Oxygen especially plays a key role in the production of

case of stainless steel), scale ( 80% Fe2O3) or waste

crude steel, such as in hot metal pretreatment for desilico-

materials from the metallurgical plant (i.e., dust with

nization, dephosphorization, devanadization, etc. as a preli-

3070% FeO + Fe2O3) which takes place in the pretre-

minary stage in the production route (Figure 1).

atment of hot metal (deSi, deP, deV etc.), in the production of converter steel with ore cooling, and in metallurgical recycling of waste materials in electric arc furnaces

Oxygen serves as an oxidizing agent for

Optimized conditions for metallurgical reactions

The extent of the cost reduction depends on

(i.e., foamy slag in EAF)


Improvement of crude steel quality

The charge mix (including availability and price situation)

(i.e., low N content in the EAF melt).

World region and existing infrastructure

Process and plant status

Therefore using a suitable technology and plant design, a

Operational experience.

reduction in the operating costs of US $520 per ton of

The energetic advantages in the use of oxygen is summa-

crude steel is therefore possible.

rized in Figure 2.

and converters.

The removal of tramp and trace elements from the iron


melt during the refining process

Generally, the required purity of gaseous oxygen is as

(predominantly C, Si, Mn, P, etc.)

follows:
Reaction enthalpy

Direct energy generation by means of oxidation andcombustion of primary energies such as carbon, natural

For refining the metal bath 99.5% O2

gas, oil and other hydrocarbons

For combustion and postcombustion by burners and


tuyeres 93% O2.

Indirect energy recovery through postcombustion of primary process gases like CO and H2 to CO2 and H2O.

25C

1600C

The most important advantages of the increased use of

Fe(l)

1/2 O2(g)

FeO(l)

oxygen are

C(Fe,%)

1/2 O2(g)

CO(g)

+5.75

Si(Fe,%)

1/2 O2(g)

SiO2(s)

+2.82

Mn(Fe,%)

1/2 O2(g)

MnO(s)

+9.43

5/2 O2(g)

P2O5(l)

+9.53

Blowing gaseous oxygen through top lances, burners,

Increase in productivity by process intensification

tuyeres including submerged tuyeres in the metallurgical

Flexibility in the supply of energy sources

vessel

Oxidation of tramp elements dissolved in liquid iron with gaseous oxygen (typical for steelmaking)
1600C

The supply of the necessary amount of oxygen occurs by

kWh/Nm3O2

2 P(Fe,%)

(especially important for EAF technology)

Blowing air or oxygen-enriched air (up to 40% O2) pre-

Improvement in heat utilization


(i.e., foamy slag in EAF)

dominantly for off-gas postcombustion

Oxidation of tramp elements dissolved in liquid iron with solid/bonded oxygen from ore,
scale, waste materials (typical for hot-metal pretreatment)
1600C

25C

1600C

1600C

3 Si(Fe,%)

2 Fe2O3(s)

3 SiO2(s)

4 Fe(l)

+1.32

3 Mn(Fe,%)

Fe2O3(s)

3 MnO(s)

2 Fe(l)

+1.42

6 P(Fe,%)

5 Fe2O3(s)

3 P2O3(l)

10 Fe(l)

-2.50

Oxidation and combustion of carbon and hydrocarbons with gaseous oxygen


25C

25C

1600C

1600C

C(s)

+ 1/2 O2(g) = CO(g)

partial oxidation (submerged carbon type)

+1.46

C(s)

+ 1/2 O2(g) = CO2(g)

full oxidation (carbon burner)

+3.86

full oxidation (natural-gas burner)

+3.29

CH4(g) + 1/2 O2(g) = CO2(g) + 2 H2O(g)

Postcombustion reactions (reaction takes place only within slag and gas phases)
1600C

25C

1600C

CO(g)

1/2 O2(g)

CO2(g)

+6.25

H2(g)

1/2 O2(g)

H2O(g)

+5.60
> 0 exothermic reactions
< 0 endothermic reactions

Fig. 1: Usage of oxygen in iron and steelmaking process

VAI Technology News

Issue No. 31/August 1999

Fig. 2: Reaction enthalpy for important metallurgical reactions at given temperatures

VAI Technology News

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Steelmaking Technology

P L A N T S

VAOX Gas Gen eration Plants

Technical Data of
VAOX Gas Generation Plant Modules

The VAOX gas generators work on the adsorption principle

The regeneration gas is blown off to the atmosphere. By

adsorber 2 is pressurized with oxygen from adsorber 1. The

and offer important advantages:

switching from one to the next adsorber and back again,

pressure increases from pe to p2.

VAOX Oxygen Generators


Capacity range

oxygen production is sufficient to allow continuous supply

Low investment costs and power consumption

Stop-and-go operation for lower energy costs

Process Step 2

to the oxygen consumers.

Oxygen purity

To save energy, the pressure in adsorber 1 must be further

93%

during maintenance shifts of the steel mill

Feeding the oxygen first from the buffer vessel through an

reduced by expanding into adsorber 2. The pressure

No operation personnel are needed

oxygen compressor ensures the required delivery pressure.

decreases from p1 to p3. Adsorber 2 is pressurized with

Power consumption

High availability/low maintenance.

The system allows peak demands of up to 4 times the

oxygen from adsorber 1 and with ambient air. The pressu-

Generation

0.42 kWh/Nm3

design capacity at a constant, adjustable pressure ob-

re increases from p2 to p4. From the oxygen buffer vessel

Compression to 35 bar

0.20 kWh/Nm3

tained by passing a pressure reducing station immediately

oxygen is supplied to the oxygen compressor or to the

downstream of the high-pressure vessel. For backup and

consumer.

Plant Description

Cooling water consumption


per 1,000 Nm3/h capacity

cylinder filling purposes, a gas liquefier can be installed.


VAOX oxygen generators use pressure-swing adsorption

Process Step 3

Generation

Compression

technology and produce oxygen with a purity of 93%. The

In case of failure of the VAOX generator, the pressure in the

The vacuum pump evacuates adsorber 1. The molecular

impurities consist of argon (4.5%) and nitrogen (balance).

oxygen line to the steel mill decreases. As soon as it drops

sieve will be regenerated for the next production step. The

Ambient air is sucked in via a filter, compressed by an air

below a certain level, a sufficient quantity of liquid oxygen

pressure decreases from p3 to pe.

blower and fed into one of the two adsorbers (Figure 3).

is vaporized in an air-heated heat exchanger and automati-

First, adsorber 2 is pressurized with oxygen from the oxy-

cally fed into the oxygen line to the steel mill. The storage

gen buffer vessel and with ambient air. Near atmospheric

The adsorption part of the VAOX oxygen generator consists

capacity of the backup plant is usually designed to supply

pressure, a pressure equilibrium between adsorber 2 and

of two adsorber vessels filled with a special molecular sieve

the steel mill for approx. one day.

the oxygen buffer is found. From then on until the end of

In the first adsorber, the molecular sieve granulate mainly

25100 Nm3/h

Nitrogen purity (normally required)

99%

and fed to adsorber 2. Hydrocarbons, CO2, moisture and

explained in Figure 4.

nitrogen are adsorbed by the granulate. The pressure

Power consumption

increases from p4 to pa. Vessel oxygen is supplied to the

(purity 99%)

At the top of the adsorber, oxygen with a purity of 93% vol.

Process Step 1

oxygen compressor or to the final consumer from the oxy-

is produced and fed into the oxygen buffer vessel located

For desorption, which means regeneration of the molecular

gen buffer. Until pressure equilibrium is established bet-

downstream.

sieve, the pressure in adsorber 1 must be reduced. To avoid

ween adsorber 2 and the oxygen buffer, oxygen is supplied

losing the oxygen at the top, adsorber 1 expands into

from the buffer to adsorber 2. After pressure equilibrium,

In the meantime, the second adsorber is regenerated (eva-

adsorber 2. The pressure decreases from pa to p1. The

the buffer vessel receives and stores the produced oxygen

cuated) with a vacuum pump.

vacuum pump evacuates adsorber 2. At the same time,

from adsorber 2.

Adsorber
Vessel 1

20 m3/h

Capacity range (normally required)

The VAOX process is comprised of three process steps


adsorbs the nitrogen and the moisture from the process air.

2 m3/h (to be drained)

VAIS Nitrogen Generators

the sub-cycle, ambient air is pressurized by the air blower

granulate.

G A S

G E N E R A T I O N

1,0005,000 Nm3/h

Generation
0.55 kWh/Nm3

(delivery at 5 bar)

Compression to
0.07 kWh/Nm3

12 bar
Cooling water consumption

--

Oxygen and Nitrogen Liquefiers


100

Oxygen Buffer
Vessel
Oxygen
High Pressure
Vessel
Pressure Reducing
Station

Adsorber Vessel 1

pa

Adsorber Vessel 2

90

Capacity range

80

Modules of 10 or
50 Nm3/h

Oxygen Buffer
Atmosphere

Oxygen Product
to Consumers

V A O X

Filter

Oxygen
Compressor
Vacuum
Pump

Air
Blower
Adsorber
Vessel 2

Liquid Oxygen
Tank

Vaporizer

Pressure [%]

PICA

70

p1

Flow Description

60

p3

Process Air

50
40

Product Oxygen
p4

30

90

3
Subcycle 1

3
Subcycle 2

Duration of One Cycle

VAOX oxygen generator adsorber vessels at


Delta Steel Mill Co./Egypt

VAI Technology News

Fig. 3: Process flow diagram of a


VAOX oxygen generator

Issue No. 31/August 1999

10 kWh/h

Capacity 50 Nm3/h

35 kWh/h

Oxygen Refill
Product Oxygen

pe

0
Step

Capacity 10 Nm3/h

p2

10
Process Air/Waste Gas
Oxygen (gaseous)
Oxygen (liquid)

Purging Oxygen

20

Oxygen
Liquefier

Power consumption

Wast Gas

Cooling water consumption

Capacity 10 Nm3/h

0.5 m3/h

Capacity 50 Nm3/h

2.5 m3/h

Fig. 4: VAOX process steps

VAI Technology News

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Steelmaking Technology

Blowing oxygen into the melt oxidizes iron to iron oxide

Favorable mixing conditions enable rapid smelting of the

at the steelmaking works in Linz/Austria in order to replace

and carbon to CO. The iron oxide immediately transfers

scrap and ensure very low carbon-content values. Oxygen

the open-hearth process by an oxygen blowing process

oxygen to the iron tramp elements. Temperatures at the

blown through the bottom constitutes a substantially more

with high hot-metal input. In November 1952 the first LD

impingement range from 2500C to 3000C.

favorable method of mixing (Figure 7).

150

Total Mixing Time [s]

In the late fourties a great number of tests were carried out

plant worldwide was erected in Linz. The LD process turned out to be a great success and set out to conquer the

The circulation flow in the bath continuously conveys non-

Short mixing times due to increased bath agitation

world. The converter has been subjected to continuous

oxidized portions of the bath to the site of oxydation.

decrease iron losses in the slag and avoid overoxidation of

evolutionary improvements and has been shown to be sui-

Continuous production of CO promotes the formation of a

the melt (Figure 8).

table for the production of large quantities of steel. Today

foamy slag emulsion. The oxidation process is completed

approx. 60% of the worldwide liquid steel production is

as soon as the desired tapping conditions are achieved.

100

LD-S

50
K-OBM

While the iron losses remain the same, the extent to which

0.01

phosphorus is slagged in bottom blowing converters is

produced with the oxygen-blowing process (BOF).


Today there is a large variety of different converter methods

Figure 6 schematically shows the refining conditions over

higher than in top blowing converters with inert gas stirring

the blowing time.

as a result of the more intensive reaction between metal

0.05
0.10
0.50
1.00
Submerged Bottom-Blown Gas Rate [Nm3/min t]

5.00

10.0

Fig. 7: Bath agitation (mixing time) as a function


of submerged blowing from the bottom

and slag. This can be compensated extensively by post-

as follows (Figure 5):

stirring with inert gases in the LD-S process (Figure 9).

Oxygen top blowing (LD, LD-S)

The K-OBM-converter, result of further developments com-

Oxygen bottom blowing (OBM)

bines the good properties of the bottom and top blowing

Combined oxygen blowing (K-OBM)

process with pure oxygen.


30

The advantages of the K-OBM process versus the

through the development of various technologies, such as

LD/LD-S process can be summarized as follows:

Bottom stirring with inert gas

More intensive bath agitation

Slag cutting

Shorter tap-to-tap times

Process automation

Higher yield

Considerable increase in scrap input

Suitable for the production of stainless steel

LD steel plant
Linz/Austria

Total Fe Content in Slag [%]

The converter process has been substantially improved

20
LD

15
LD-S

10
K-OBM

5
0

Process with O2 Bottom Blowing

Process with O2 Top Blowing

Basic Thomas/
Acid Bessemer

1880
O2

1952

LD: Linz/
Donawitz

0.08

0.12

0.16

Carbon Content [%]

must be balanced with higher cost for equipment and

Fig. 8: Relation between Fe content in slag and carbon at blow end for different converter processes

maintenance.

O2

OBM

100

K-OBM

O2 CaO/C3H8

O2

1970
O2

LD +
BottomStirring

[C]+(FeO)=CO + Fe

O2+N2(Ar)

160
K-OBM

CLU

O2+CaO
CH4

4
75

KMS
O2+CaO
CH4

N2/Ar

1980

AOD

K-OBM
LD-HC
LD-OB

K-OBM-S

O2/CH4

1990

K-ES
O2+N2(Ar)/
C3H8

O2/CH4
O2/N2(Ar)/
CH4/Coal

KMS-S

3
50

Slag Weight
2

25

LD-S
80
LD

[C]+O or [O]=CO
1

40

O2+N2(Ar)/
CH4, Coal

120
(P)/[P]

LD: USA

Relative Slag Weight

1960

Carbon Steel
Stainless Steel

Air

0.04

The metallurgical advantages of oxygen bottom blowing

Decarburization [%]

C O N V E R T E R

T E C H N O L O G Y

Basic Oxygen Processes

25

50
Blowing Time [%]

75

100

10

15

20

25

Total Fe Content [%]

1998
85.5%

12.0%

0.5%

2.0%

Fig. 6: Relation between gas and emulsion


refinings and slag weight

Fig. 9: Relation between phosphorus partition


and total Fe content of slag

Fig. 5: Share of various converter processes in worldwide BOF steel production


VAI Technology News

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Technology News

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Steelmaking Technology

The Dynamic Process ModelDYNACON


D Y N A C O N

Figure 10 shows a typical off-gas development during

Metallurgy and Cost-Saving Perspectives

Cost savings of approx. US$ 0.5/t of steel can be achieved

blowing for a 240-ton LD converter. The changes in the

LOMAS off-gas sampling and analyzing

The Dynamic Process Model-DYNACON features

only as a result of lower Al consumption and lower Fe

ascent of the N2 and O2 curves or in the drop of the CO and

Improving the Hitting Rate

CO2 curves at the end of blowing relative to a reference

Based on the endpoint determined by DYNACON, a carb-

heat in which the achieved carbon content is known are

on-hitting rate of approximately 80% within a window

Lowest Investment Costs

separately evaluated in the last minutes of the blowing pro-

range of +/- 0.005% (for a target carbon of < 0.05%) is

With respect to precision, reproducibility and economic

cess. The individual evaluations are weighted and provide

achieved under normal but standardized production

aspects (investment costs), DYNACON thus allows a com-

a basis for determining the residual blowing time.

conditions.

plete dynamic process control which by far surpasses the

Depending on the degree of standardization (lance/blowing

process-control performance of, for example, a sublance.

content in converter slag.

In addition to the above off-gas curves, calculated values

pattern, bottom stirring, addition pattern etc.) higher hitting

such as the postcombustion degree are included in the

rates of approximately 95% are possible. As a consequen-

evaluation. In the last three minutes, a seconds countdown

ce, the standard deviation between predicted and actual

to the blowing end is calculated. As the axis in Figure 11,

endpoint temperature decreases by about 10 C.

the calculated end-blow time versus the actual end-blow


Quality-Standard Improvement

time for a target carbon of 0.03% is shown.

High carbon-hitting rates within such a tight carbon win-

Calculation of the decarburization rate

Calculation of the actual steel and slag analysis

The dynamic process model is embedded in the applicati-

dow also means avoiding overblowing the heat; the result

Calculation of the steel-bath temperature

on functions necessary for process control beginning with

of which is not only improved steel cleanliness but also a

End-blow determination.

start of blow until end of blow. These functions are

means of lowering the production costs.

The DYNACON calculation principle is based on the reac-

Process monitoring

Decreased Production Costs

tion kinetics between steel and slag components, the trend

Process tracking

Decreased production costs because of decreased oxygen

behavior prediction of the off-gas composition in the last

Process information acquisition and storage

activity in the steel by approx. 150 ppm can be reached

minutes of blowing and on heat and material balances.

Report system.

(Figure 12). This leads to

The DYNACON process model is based on the assumption


that the steel bath and the slag are in equilibrium in the last

The application functions and DYNACON process model

Lower consumption of Al for deoxidation

few minutes of the LD process so that the behavior of the

are installed on a conventional personal computer with

Lower Fe content in converter slag

gases measured by the LOMAS system in the off-gas is

interfaces to the level-1 and level-2 automation systems

Higher lining life due to decreased temperature standard

similar in all heats, irrespective of the quality and amount of

already installed. In this manner DYNACON serves as an

the hot metal charged and of the charging materials.

upgrade utility for existing automation systems.

deviation and lower Fe content in converter slag

Dialog window for DYNACON

25

25

CO2

100

40

20

Time until Blow End [s]

Process Time [min]

VAI Technology News

Fig. 11: Cyclic blow end indication during the


last two minutes of blowing process

10

Issue No. 31/August 1999

Fig. 12: Operational results of the 240t LD converter at EKO Stahl, Germany

VAI Technology News

>551

Aluminium Addition During Tapping [kg]

Oxygen Activity Prior to Tapping [ppm]

Fig. 10: Off-gas composition recorded


during blowing

531-551

60

511-531

80

491-511

100

471-491

120

450-471

12

430-450

10

410-430

390-410

370-390

305-370

0
<350

10

20

>1366

10
5

1278-1366

10

15

1189-1278

Operator

30

100-1189

20

40

10

1011-1100

30

50

923-1011

10

60

834-922

40

70

745-834

15

50

15

656-745

60

80

567-656

H2

90

479-567

20

O2

Target

20

Operator

20

<479

80
70

Time until Blow End [s]

N2

DYNACON Prediction

Frequency [%]

110

Off-gas Composition O2, H2 [%]

Off-gas Composition CO, CO2, N2 [%]

90

CO

Frequency [%]

25

100

Model

Model

120

11

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Steelmaking Technology

New Tasks of the LD Lance


L A N C E

Since 1952, oxygen-blowing lances have been used in the


LD converter for steel production. In the course of the past
45 years, the lance has undergone a number of design
modifications until it has reached its present functional and
lasting form. The findings in the field of thermodynamics,

1
p N TN
+
R
p 1 TN
=
p N T1 VN
VN =

the flow patterns of the water cooling system and the heat
transmission processes have played a decisive role in

aL = k

extending the lifetime of approx. 50 to today's lifetime of

p1
1

approx. 350 heats.

Cross section of the 5-hole lance tip

The concept of injecting the dust accumulating in the off-

gas cleaning system during converter operation through

pN normal pressure

the oxygen lance, which is tantamount to a new type of

TN normal temperature

recycling in the steelmaking plant, involved a modification

r1

of the lance design. Accordingly, the well-known 4-hole

p1 current pressure upstream

[J/(kg*K)]
[N/m3]

Fig. 14: Typical design of a 1-hole LD lance (1954)

[K]

current density of the carrier gas

[kg/m3]
[N/m3]

of Laval nozzle

lance is now equipped with a fifth central Laval nozzle, and


the carrier gas for dust injection is fed with the dust through

general gas constant

[m3/kg]

T1 current temperature upstream

[K]

of Laval nozzle

a central tube in the lance.

16

aL Laval velocity

[m/s]

In the following, the positive process results are first

adiabatic exponent

ignored, and the findings regarding the calculation of a

load in kg dust/Nm3 carrier gas

Nozzle Diameter 22 mm

[%]
[kg/m3]

Laval nozzle for dust-laden media are dealt with instead.


The original design was based on the laws of thermodyna-

This method of calculation only considers the influence of

mics for the Laval nozzle:

the specific volume of the carrier gas and disregards the


changed thermodynamic values for the mixture consisting

VN =
5-hole and 6-hole lance tips

R
p N TN

p 1 TN
p N T1 VN

p
aL = k 1
1

Nozzle Diameter 26 mm

14

of the carrier gas and the material to be conveyed.

Inlet Pressure at Laval Nozzle [bar]


Sonic Speed of Dust-Laden Media [m/s]

L D

where VN volume under standard conditions

Sonic Speed
12

10

Surprisingly, the results of the theoretical effective area that

method of calculation suffices to determine the delivery

15

20

25

Dust Load in Media [kg/Nm3]

was calculated in a simplified manner were perfectly corroborated in the course of testing. Therefore, this simplified

10

Fig. 15: Influence of dust load on laval nozzle

volumes and is fairly realistic. On the basis of these findings


it has become easy to apply this design to other dimensions as well.

As the project went on, it gradually turned out that this formula failed to meet the actual prevailing conditions. The

In the following, the required effective areas for a test lance

dust freight of the carrier gas was highly influential. In order

in the VOEST-ALPINE STAHL Donawitz steelmaking plant

to maintain the planned delivery volume, the area had to be

are recomputed.

increased by approx. 40%.


Strikingly, the Laval velocity or the sonic speed, respectiveThe required size of the area was theoretically investigated

ly, is highly dependent on the dust freight of the carrier gas

after having detected this influencing variable before modi-

as shown in Figure 15. Non-dust-laden gas features a

fying the design. In an initial attempt, the load condition

sonic speed of approx. 330 m/s, which is reduced to

was simulated by correcting the specific values for the gas:

approx. 80 m/s at a dust freight of 20 kg/Nm3.

Dust recycling lance tip


after 100 tons of dust injection

Fig. 16: Design of a dust-recycling lance (1998)

VAI Technology News

12

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Technology News

13

Issue No. 31/August 1999

30

VAI Steelmaking Technology

L A N C E

VOEST-ALPINE STAHL Donawitz runs two blast furnaces

with a production capacity of 1.25 million tons of hot metal

50 to DN 100 in order to reduce pressure losses owing

per year. This hot metal is blown to 1.37 million tons of

to friction

crude steel in the steelmaking plant. Three 60 t LD conver-

dure. Each converter is equipped with a 4-hole lance. The

Increase of the diameter of the Laval nozzle from 22 mm


to 26 mm

ters are installed for operation in a 2/3 LD converter proce

Increase of the design pressure in the bin from approx.


7 bar to approx. 8 bar

converter off-gas accumulating during refining is combuDust recycling plant at


VOEST-ALPINE STAHL Donawitz

Increase of the diameter of the piping system from DN

sted in a downstream vessel and dedusted in a dry elec-

Injection volume approx. 1400 kg/heat

trostatic precipitator with dust volumes of 13 to 15 kg per

Injection of approx. 100 tons of dust during a long-time


test.

ton of steel. The dusts accumulating in the steelmaking

L D

process are considered to be hazardous waste, so it is


absolutely essential to process these wastes by way of

Apart from confirming the applicability of the method of cal-

recirculation.

culation, the tests yielded valuable findings concerning the


advantages of the recirculation process:

Fig. 17: Plant configuration at


VOEST-ALPINE STAHL Donawitz

VOEST-ALPINE STAHL Donawitz and VAI had the idea of


charging the LD dust by means of an oxygen lance into the

dustone kg of dust accounts for 2.7 kg of scrap.

therefore equipped with a further central hole for dust blowing as shown in Figure 16.

The required scrap for operation was partly substituted


for the excellent cooling properties of the charged

area of the hot spot. The 4-hole lance normally used was

The operating time was reduced by approx. one minute.

The operating oxygen was partly compensated by the


iron oxide content of the charged dust.

To achieve the defined goals, an injection device with a bin,


the required lines to the lance equipment and a 5-hole

The bath temperature is reduced by approx. 25 C.

lance were installed. The plant (Figures 17 and 18) was

Chemistry of steel is not influenced, no changing in lead,


zinc and phosphorus content.

installed for testing on an industrial scale. The conveying


system is comprised of the following elements:

Chemistry of slag is not influenced, no change in iron


oxide analysis.

Loading station

Over-size screen

Dispenser with a fluidizing unit

Flow-control valve

The development of the LD lance of the 1950s reveals a

Transport line

tendency towards increasing the number of nozzles on

Discharge via central blowing-lance nozzle

account of the tasks of metallurgy and additional tasks ari-

Processing procedure is not influenced because feeding


is carried out during blowing.
Dust container

was not until the flow patterns in the cooling ducts were

meter of gas at a gas volume of 10 standard cubic meters

identified and appropriate geometrical adaptations were

per minute. The effective diameter of the central nozzle was

made that it was possible to satisfy the requirements of the

originally 22 mm.

operators of steelmaking plants.

According to thermodynamic calculations of the gas flow

The application of thermodynamic methods of calculation

rate without dust load, these values were to be easily achie-

allows predetermining the required oxygen flow rates

ved at a bin pressure of approx. 8 bar and with regard to

through proper nozzle geometry, the actual volumes corre-

the pressure losses occurring in the piping system. As

sponding very well to the theoretically calculated ones. In

described above, the influence of the dust load is so signi-

the case described, i.e. injection of dusts, this calculation

ficant that these values were only reached after appropria-

modelafter minor adaptationswas also implemented in

te corrections had been made:

practical operation.

Filter
unit

Ladder

and with a view to cooling problems and skull formation. It

ded according to design with 20 kg dust per standard cubic

Dedusting

sing, for example, from the recycling of metallurgical dusts


The carrier medium used was oxygen, which was to be loa-

Oversize particles

Dispenser unit

14

Issue No. 31/August 1999

7.5 m3
17 bar
0-80 C
1.8 m

Container for
oversize particle

Fig. 18: Layout of equipment

Fluidization equipment and dispenser

VAI Technology News

Pressure
vessel

VAI Technology News

15

Issue No. 31/August 1999

Dust container

2 m3

2 m3

VAI Steelmaking Technology

E A F / K - E S

Oxygen Management for Electric Steelmaking

Watercooled supersonic oxygen/carbon lance


manipulator FUCHS MARK IV

applicablestating that 1 Nm3 oxygen corresponds to

and based on the knowledge of water-cooled LD oxygen

Since it does not make sense to gain energy through the

approx. 3 kWh of energy. Although the metallurgical effect

lances, water-cooled oxygen lances were developed for the

oxidation of iron (scrap), it is necessary to charge fuel in an

of oxygen and the equipment for injection oxygen into the

electric arc furnace. These lances are translationally moved

appropriate manner. In most cases carbon is used as fuel.

electric arc furnace are described in detail in a number of

(Figure 19) or slewed and entered into the electric arc fur-

In view of the large number of problems occurring during

publications, there are only few reliable investigations of the

nace laterally of or through the slag door (Figure 20).

lump coke charged with regard to efficiency and unfore-

economic aspects of oxygen input and oxygen manage-

Oxygen at supersonic speed and carbon powder are injec-

seeable impacts on off-gas cleaning, reliable and automat-

ment in the electric arc furnace which can be reconstructed

ted onto the heat and metallurgically utilized to a great

able carbon charging into the electric arc furnace is a pre-

in the user's own plant.

extent.

condition for intensive oxygen application.

Equipment and Technology of Oxygen


Application

Burner Postcombustion Lances

Submerged Carbon Tuyeres

Three to eight of these lances are located along the furnace

This precondition is fullfilled by the installation of submerged carbon tuyeres (Figure 22), where carbon powder in

Apart from oxidizing with iron ore, which is employed parti-

circumference (Figure 21). The burner serves to open a

As with any other steelmaking process, electric steel-

cularly in the special steel industry, gaseous oxygen is

clearance by combusting gaseous, liquid or solid fuel for

a quantity of up to 25 kg/min is laterally injected through

making is an oxidizing process where oxygen is used in

injected into the heat through consumable lances.

the subsequent postcombustion of the CO which has

natural-gas-cooled tuyeres under the bath level. This gua-

meanwhile formed to CO2.

rantees excellent slag foaming and all of the well-known

varying forms. As the facilities for gaseous oxygen and its


commercial supply were continually perfected, oxidizing
with iron orewhich is advantageous with a view to

energy-related advantages.

Oxygen Lances

dephosphorizationwas superseded by oxidizing by and


injection of gaseous oxygen to an ever increasing extent.

The correct arrangement of the burner postcombustion


lances in relation to the direction of the burner effect (radi-

Moreover, appropriate CO formation is ensured, which

For a long time no appropriate manipulators were available

al and/or tangential) and considering hot spots or cold

benefits the postcombustion process described above.

so that a lot of manual work and considerable manipulation

spots along the furnace circumference are essential.

Submerged carbon tuyeres are successfully employed in

Gaseous oxygen moreover offered the advantage of having

efforts were required for the resetting of consumable

a high exothermic impact on the electric steelmaking pro-

lances. The costs of consumable lances also had to be

The position on an appropriate level at the furnace is deter-

melting and have a lifetime of several hundred heats.

cess in contrast to iron ore, which has a strong endother-

taken into account; but it was possible to reduce these

mined by the necessity of preventing the burner openings

Carbon injection, for example, by means of a lance, is to be

mic influence on the process.

costs by using pipes with a ceramic coating. The hard and

from being closed by splashes as well as of reliably trans-

adapted accordingly. All these facilities and procedures for

Therefore it was practical to utilize the gaseous oxygen not

troublesome manual work was reduced by using manipula-

mitting the additional energy to the melting scrap pile and

oxygen charging and/or conversion in the electric arc fur-

only metallurgically but also for energy generation accor-

tors for inserting consumable oxygen and carbon pipes.

preventing the additional heat from being removed by the

nace are highly promising from an economical point of

ding to the general rulewhich is often but not always

In view of the disadvantages of consumable oxygen lances

cooling water of the furnace roof.

view.

Fig. 19: Translationally moved water-cooled


supersonic oxygen/carbon lance

VAI Technology News

Fig. 20: Water-cooled supersonic oxygen/carbon


lance manipulator FUCHS MARK IV Type

16

Issue No. 31/August 1999

furnaces for scrap melting as well as those for sponge iron

Fig. 21: Burner postcombustion lance

Fig. 22: Installation of a submerged carbon


tuyere in an electric arc furnace

VAI Technology News

17

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Steelmaking Technology

Economic Effect of Oxygen Input in the EAF


E A F / K - E S

The economic effect of oxygen input in the electric arc fur-

Figure 26 shows the carbon powder input and natural gas


(Nm3

nace is basically determined by the amount of oxygen

consumption

injected.

input (Nm3 O2/ton of liquid steel).

CH4/ton of liquid steel) versus oxygen

It should also be pointed out that the savings potential for


variable costs considerably grows particularly between 15
and 30 Nm3 O2/t, whereas it diminishes above 30 Nm3 O2/t.

The economic effects are


This is attributable to the strongly increasing energy losses
through off-gas and the limited utilization of the high oxy-

Variable cost savings

Fixed cost savings

The benefit derived from the additional products which

Variable Costs

gen input for energy recovery for the melt.

The calculation of variable costs is based on the costs of

can be profitably sold.

Fixed Costs

This benefit can be determined by defining several specific

Oxygen

dependencies. In the following an example of a 100-ton

Electric energy

electric arc furnace with an electrical power of 60 MW and

Carbon powder

a 100% scrap charge is presented (Figure 23).

Natural gas

Personnel

The basis for the cost calculation is shown in Figure 24.

The variable costs of increasing oxygen input and the pos-

Departmental services for investment in equipment

sible savings of these costs are essentially determined by

Fixed share of maintenance expenditure

the ratio between oxygen costs (constant) and electric

Overhead costs

Figure 25 illustrates how increasing oxygen input

(Nm3/t

liquid steel) leads to the following results:


Decrease in electric power consumption (kWh/ton of

energy costs (not constant). Of course, the higher the electric energy costs, the higher the variable cost savings

On the basis of empirical values, a fixed cost figure of

achieved through O2 applications at higher kWh costs.

US$ 40 million per year was assumed for a single-furnace

liquid steel)
With regard to variable cost savings, it would not make

Increase in productivity in tons of liquid steel per hour

sense in terms of economy to apply oxygen when the costs

Increases in the annual output in 1000 tons of liquid

for electric energy are low. Benefits regarding savings are

steel per year

only derived at higher kWh costs.

Oxygen costs

Charge mix

100% scrap, 2 baskets

Variable electrical kWh costs 0.020.12 US$/t

Power-off time
Carbon input
Burner power

60 MW

Carbon powder costs

15 min

Natural gas costs

carbon powder only

Billet sales price

3 MW

Profit (rel. to liquid steel)

0.17 US$/kg
0.15 US$/Nm3
200 US$/t
25 US$/t

175
800

Energy Consumption

700

Production
Tap-to-Tap Time
Productivity

30
Carbon by Lance
CH4 by Burners

150

125
600

100
500

400

75

300

50

Tap-to-Tap Time [min]


Productivity [tliq/h]

100 t

Electric power input

800,000 tons of liquid steel per year (Case 1: Figure 27).

0.06 US$/Nm3

EAF tapping weight

Energy Consumption [kWh/tliq]


Production [1000t/year]

Oxygen lancing with consumable pipes

steelmaking plant with an output of approx. 600,000 to

Shorter tap-to-tap time

Carbon and CH4 Consumption


[kg/tliq.,Nm3/tliq]

Calculation of fixed costs is based on the costs for

25

Postcombustion of CO
Carbon by Submerged Tuyeres

20

15

10

Carbon
CH4

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

10

7200 h/year

Fixed costs

20

25

40.047.0 million US$/year


(based on reference values)

Fig. 23: Technical data of the EAF

Fig. 24: Costs per unit

VAI Technology News

18

Issue No. 31/August 1999

30

Oxygen Consumption [Nm3/tliq]

Oxygen Consumption [Nm3/tliq]

Production time

15

Fig. 25: Impact of oxygen utilization


on EAF operating parameters

Fig. 26: Operating parameters

VAI Technology News

19

Issue No. 31/August 1999

35

40

45

VAI Steelmaking Technology

increase caused by a additional oxygen input (case 2), the

As displayed in Figure 29, the additional profit in

additional fixed-cost savings may be close to zero and may

US$/ton of liquid steel constantly increases as the

even decrease in extreme case of higher oxgen input,

oxygen input increases.

depending on the value of the increase in fixed costs


(Figure 28).
This high impact (higher than the increase in fixed costs) is

Economic Effect of Increased


Oxygen Input

attributable to the fact that the increase in fixed costs is


fully represented by the fixed-cost savings as the differen-

The economic effects of increased oxygen input in

ce value to the basic figure. This, of course, can have a

the electric arc furnace are

Fixed Costs/Year Case 1


50

Fixed Costs per Year [US$ million]

E A F / K - E S

55

Fixed Costs/Year Case 2

45

40

35

30
10

15

Consumable lances for the DRI EAF

20

25

30

35

40

45

35

40

45

35

40

45

Oxygen Consumption [Nm3/tliq]

powerful effect.

Variable cost savings

This is why it should be carefully checked when the oxygen

Fixed cost savings

input is considerably increased whether the increase in

Additional profit from increased production.

Fig. 27: Fixed costs

fixed costs resulting from additional investments will essentially reduce the savings potential since fixed costs from

Under the conditions prevailing, a substantial econo-

investments have a sustained and long-term effect on eco-

mic effect can be achieved through increased oxy-

nomy.

gen input if boundary conditions such as cost relati-

20

Savings with Constant Fixed Costs (Case 1)

ons and decisions on investment are fully taken into

Savings with Increasing Fixed Costs (Case 2)

account.
Furthermore, the economic advantages are expected to increase most at oxygen values between 15

Oxygen lancing with water-cooled supersonic lance

As already explained, it is assumed that every ton of liquid

and 30 Nm3 O2/ton of liquid steel because at higher

steel produced can be sold at a profit of US$ 25/ton of

values the disadvantages described above may take

liquid steel. As the annual output increases, the annual pro-

effect.

Saving Fixed Costs [US$/tliq]

Additional Profit From Increased Production owing to Increased Oxygen Input

15

10

fit in absolute terms also increases.


0
10

15

increased production (increased O2 input) referred to in the


reference production figure (= 10 Nm3 O2/ton of liquid

input, the fixed costs per year were assumed to increase up

steel), the following relationship is defined:

to US$ 47 million per year at an oxygen input higher than

Additional profit from increased production can be summa-

This study shows that oxygen management must not

rized as follows:

be limited to technical matters and direct consump-

O2/ton of liquid steel in another case (Case 2:

demand (e.g., casting equipment, off-gas cleaning, cooling


water supply, etc.) resulting from higher production figures.

tion figures.

AP =

In practical operation, this relationship will greatly vary


AP

according to the specific plant conditions.


In case 1, the fixed cost savings will continuously increase

PIP

with constant fixed costs and increasing production caused by increasing oxygen input (Figure 28).
However, if the fixed costs increase, e.g., because additio-

PIP PPR
PRI

The following essential factors can also be taken into

additional profit from increased production


[US$/ton of liquid steel]

Cost relations of energies and utilities

profit from increased production at

Investment expense

increased O2 input [US$]

Profitably salable output

(= 10 Nm3 O2/ton of liquid steel) [US$]

If these parameters are correctly correlated with one

production at reference O2 input

another, increased oxygen input in the electric arc

(= 10

nal investments are required as a result of production

Nm3

O2/ton of liquid steel) [t of liquid steel]

account:

PPR from production at reference oxygen input


PRI

30

10

Additional Profit [US$/tliq]

20

Figure 27). This is due to an additional investment

25

Fig. 28: Savings fixed costs

Summary

However, since production increases with higher oxygen

Nm3

20

Oxygen Consumption [Nm3/tliq]

To represent the specific additional profit resulting from

furnace will lead to commercial success.

10

15

20

25

30

Oxygen Consumption [Nm3/tliq]

Fig. 29: Additional profit by increased


production, related to reference value

VAI Technology News

20

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Technology News

21

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Steelmaking Technology

As has been the case in carbon steelmaking, the large-

The metallurgical O2 is injected into the EAF by means of

scale industrial production of technical gases especially of

self-consumable pipes or water-cooled lances.

oxygen has revolutionized stainless-steel metallurgy since


the early fifties. Without the availability of low-cost gaseous

Some operators also use gaseous O2 for the operation with

oxygen, the increase in production and demand for stain-

door and wall burners or charge-excess Si as FeSi and use

less steel products would not have been possible. Only the

the Si oxidation energy to accelerate the melting process.

2.20

1st samples
AISI S04
AISI S16
AISI S30

1.80

2nd samples
AISI S04

1.40

1.00

oxygen makes the economic recycling of stainless steel


scrap from different sources from within as well as without

These techniques aim at speeding up the EAF, mainly in

the plant possible for the mass production of high-

case this facility is the bottleneck in the production chain.

chromium steel grades with low-carbon contents. Without

However, the use of O2 for the EAF stainless steelmaking

the availability of gaseous oxygen until the late forties the

production is restricted compared to the carbon-steel fur-

production of stainless steel was only possible with the use

nace to avoid an excessive Cr-oxidation.

0.60

0.4

0.8

1.2

1.6

2.0

(Cr2O3%)/[Cr%]

Fig. 30: Cr distribution as a function of the


[C] content of the bath in the EAF

of low-carbon internal scrap and high-cost low-carbon

85 t UHP EAF at Posco, Pohang


during tapping

C (wt%)

2.60

EAFs producing stainless steel are generally characterized

ferroalloys.

by strong transformers and a high share of electrical power


SiO2

input into the overall energy balance.

ding flat and long products were produced worldwide . A

false air infiltration through the slag door, other furnace


ss
Ma

C3S2

steelmaking plant are the primary and secondary metallur-

process. Despite the high carbon input from the charge

gical facilities:

materials, especially from the Ferro alloys and the high [C]

Converter plant up to 30 Nm3/t

content of the premelt in the EAF, a certain amount of Cr

EAF plant 515 Nm3/t

oxidation cannot be avoided during melting.

C3S
80

40

SIO

not easy to establish a precise oxygen balance for the EAF

The largest consumers in a typical integrated stainless

Cr2O3

00

C2S

1514
1407
1430

60

Therefore, compared with the converter and the VOD it is

Charging of a 90 t AOD-converter at Posco,


Pohang/Korea

1418

ss

plant.

VOD plant, if any

2 Liq.
40
CS

openings and the refractory material.

Ma

depending on the energy situation in the

80

2100

more than 50

20
0

oxygen consumption per ton of flat products amounts to

SiO2

180

rent sources, such as from oxides in the charge material,

2000

450,000 and 800,000 tons per year. The overall specific

Additional oxygen for the EAF, however, comes from diffe-

before reduction
after reduction

Ca

typical stainless-steel plant for flats produces between

Nm3,

100

1900

In 1997, more than 16 million tons of stainless steel inclu-

16

S T A I N L E S S

S T E E L

Oxygen Usage in Stainless Steel Production

C2KS3

1566
00

17

Ca7Cr2Si2O16

1450

CaO
100
0
CaO

20
Ca5Cr2SiO12

20

1060
1061

Ca3(Cr2O4)2
CaCrO4
Ca3Cr2O8

CK

80

Mass % Cr2O3

up to 10 Nm3/t
The oxidized Cr in the slags is normally reduced by the

Other consumers are of minor importance, such as raw

addition of FeSi at the end of the EAF process or during

material handling and preparation areas, rolling mills and

tapping. To minimize Cr oxidation some operators inject

power generation plants, provided that electric energy is

powdered carbon through a consumable lance during mel-

available on large scale. Special process routes based on

ting and desiliconization to maintain a defined [C] content

liquid hot metal usage and smelting reduction of Cr ore,

in the bath. Figure 30 shows the distribution of Cr bet-

require much more gaseous oxygen for stainless steel pro-

ween slag and metal bath depending on the [C] content of

duction in the range of 400

Nm3

or even more.

Fig. 31: Slag composition of EAF slags


before and after reduction

the melt.
The typical EAF slags before and after reduction are shown

Oxygen Used for Stainless Steel


Production by an EAF

in the slag ternary diagram in Figure 31.


In order to achieve Cr2O3 contents in the final slags of

Inside view of Posco Stainless


Steelplant N2 Pohang, Korea

VAI Technology News

Owing to the high affinity of Cr to O2, the use of O2 for the

below 5 %, the Cr oxidation in the furnace must be im-

EAF is far lower when producing stainless steel. The EAF

proved which causes a higher consumption of expensive

normally produces a high-carbon, low-silicon premelt for

FeSi for reduction. In general the main metallurgical tasks

the subsequent converter plant. Nevertheless, the Si con-

of the EAF for stainless steel are restricted to melting the

tent of the premelt has to be reduced to a level of 0.2 % by

charge material, desiliconization, superheating to the tap-

injecting O2 into the liquid bath in the EAF due to metallur-

ping temperature and reducing oxidized Cr to an economi-

gical requirements for the subsequent converter process.

cal extent.

22

Issue No. 31/August 1999

CLU converter main control room at Columbus


Stainless Steelmaking Plant/South Africa

VAI Technology News

23

Issue No. 31/August 1999

0
100
Cr2O3

VAI Steelmaking Technology

Zone 1:

The largest consumer of O2 in a stainless steel production


plant is the converter refining plant. In contrast to the

The peaks in the CRE curve indicate the switchover points

gaseous O2 reacts with [C] and alloys [Me],

to a lower O2/inert-gas ratio where the CO partial pressure

especially with [Cr] in the bath.

is lowered.

The generated Cr oxides and the Me oxides

carbon steel production, the converter process normally

surround the gas bubbles of CO and inert gas,

The course of the CRE shows that the Cr oxidation is rela-

includes decarburization and reduction period. The decar-

rise through the bath and are in equilibrium

tively high at the beginning and the end of the converter

burization of the premelt from the EAF is performed by blo-

with the [C] of the bath.

process. Low temperatures and high CO partial pressure at

The metal/slag interface where slag/metal and

the beginning and low [C] activity in the bath at the end are

top blown O2/metal reactions take place.

beneficial to C oxidation. The Cr oxide content of the slag,

The gas-reaction sphere where mainly the

however, is no significant figure for comparison because

bath and the slag are complex and take place in different

partial postcombustion of the off-gas takes

different additions of lime and other fluxes influence the

reaction spheres of the vessel.

place.

slag composition.

wing varying mixtures of O2 and inert gas through special-

Zone 3:

ly designed submerged tuyeres and a top lance into the


vessel. The metallurgical reactions between O2, the metal

S T A I N L E S S

Zone 2:

In the area in front of the tuyeres the injected

Zone 4:

Fig. 32: Reaction zones in a stainless steel


converter

For comparison the specific amount of oxidized Cr per ton


The reaction equations are well known:

In zones 1, 2 and 3 the [C], [Cr] and [Me] oxidations each

of steel can be considered for process performance as

3
O2 (g ) = 3 CO(g)
2

take place to an extent which is determined by the process

shown in Figure 34.

3 [C] +

CRE TC %C

conditions. The driving forces for the oxidation of the

3
O2 + 2 [Cr] = Cr2O2 (s )
2

various dissolved alloy components are different. In our

It is generally not the task to run the converter process with

converter process model the general metal oxidation is

a CRE as high as possible to save reduction agents, but the

expressed as follows :

CRE is a result of an overall compromise in terms of Cr oxi-

3 [C] + Cr2O3 (s ) = 3 CO(g) + 2 [Cr]

2,2

[Me ] + [O] = (MeO)

1700

dation, inert gas consumption, process temperature and


100

productivity.

CRE

The equilibrium is kept constant:


The equilibrium condition is given by the equation

a2 p 3
40358
log k 3 = log 3Cr CO =
+ 25.77
T
a C a Cr2O 3

by means of reduction agents, mostly low-carbon FeSi,

G0 = R T ln k Me = R T ln

From the equation above it can be seen that

After the decarburization period, the oxidized Cr is reduced

a MeO
a Me a O

during a short reduction period. Different slag practices


quasiternary diagram. The course of two different possible

High process temperatures, high Cr2O3 activity of the


slag and low CO partial pressure are beneficial to decar-

where kMe is the equilibrium constant for the oxidation

slag paths during the converter process is schematically

burization

reaction.

shown in Figure 35.

High Cr activity and low C activity are beneficial to


Cr oxidation

applied in the plant result in different slag paths in the

Fig. 33: CRE, T and [C] during converter


refining of Cr-containing heats

The driving force for oxidation at the metal/gas interphase

[Cr] and [C] activities cannot be influenced substantially

with a certain oxygen partial pressure is given by the

and are determined by the steel grade to be produced and

change in Gibbs free enthalphy according to:

the process step. The other parametersespecially pro0


GMe = GMe
+ R T ln

cess temperature and CO partial pressurecan be influenced to a certain extent by adequate converter process con-

Time

a MeO

40

1
2

k Me p O 2

(AISI 409 grade)

35

trol.

30

The relationship between O2 for decarburization and Me


The CO partial pressure is lowered during the different con-

oxidation is expressed as the so called Carbon Removal

verter process steps by mixing defined amounts of inert

Efficiency or CRE as follows:

gas to the refining O2. The process temperature is as high

CRE = 100

as it allows the refractory consumption to remain at an economical level. The slag shall be solid during decarburizati-

O2 [C]
(O2 tot O2 [Si] )

Chromium Oxidation Loss


(kg/t)

S T E E L

Oxygen for the Converter Process

[%]

on where the Cr-oxide activity is equal or nearly


aCr2O3 =1. In the VOD the CO partial pressure is lowered by
operating the process under vacuum.

The average CRE for the refining of regular grades of type

25

Cr

20
15
10
5

Cr

0 2 4

12

16

20

[C] (x10-2%)

304 is approx. 70% from the start to the end of the decarburization. The instantaneous CRE, however, considerably

In the VAI converter process model the reaction spheres

changes during the refining process according to the chan-

are defined as shown in Figure 32.

ging process conditions, as shown in Figure 33.

VAI Technology News

24

Issue No. 31/August 1999

50 t AOD converter at
Acciaierie Bolzano, Italy

Fig. 34: Cr oxidation during refining


of Cr steel 409 type 4

VAI Technology News

25

Issue No. 31/August 1999

24

28

32

VAI Steelmaking Technology

SiO2
100

0
resional slag from EAf
combined reduction/De-S slag
20

80

VAI has supplied various types of converters and process

2000

Ma
ss
%

1900

Ca

Cr2O3
40

00
17

1450

CaO
100
20

CaO

Reduction
FeSi + Line
addition

20

2
Ca5Cr2SiO12

Ca7Cr2Si2O16

C2KS3
1

1566

80

SIO

C3S

1514
1407
1430

60
%
ss

00
16

C2S

1418

Ma

C3S2

1060
1061

Ca3(Cr2O4)2
CaCrO4
Ca3Cr2O8

CK

and has gained comprehensive experience with AOD, CLU

Ladle metallurgy in a vacuum tank is one of the oldest

and K-OBM-S. AOD and K-OBM-S are identical from a

degassing techniques in use in the steel industry for impro-

metallurgical point of view, whereas CLU shows a higher Cr

ving steel quality. It is also certainly the most flexible one. A

oxidation and a lower average CRE during decarburization

teeming ladle is placed in a vacuum tank which is connec-

due to its particular process technology with steam injec-

ted to a vacuum pump system. The decarburization pro-

tion.

cesses with (VOD Vacuum Oxygen Decarburization) and


without oxygen blowing (VCD Vacuum Carbon Deoxidation)

0
100

80

Cr2O3

Mass % Cr2O3

As a consequence, the CLU converter requires more reduc-

are carried out in the ladle requiring a freeboard of at least

tion agents and fluxes, but consumes considerably less Ar.

1,200 mm. For decarburization under vacuum conditions,


one can take advantage of the fact that decarburization

Fig. 35: Different slag paths during


the AOD process

Oxygen is injected into the converter vessel by means of a

with oxygen occurs before oxidation of chromium. Thus,

number of submerged tuyeres and a top lance. The usage

low carbon contents with a slight loss of chromium can be

of top lances to speed up the converter process became

achieved.

DETEM-VOD at MICROSTEEL,
Durban/South Africa

more common after the output of the EAFs were increased,


100

CRE (%)

80

60

Bottom blowing

40

mainly by the installation of larger transformers in the stain-

The VOD plant has been designed in such a way that only

less steel melting shops. As a consequence, the tap-to-tap

melting and maybe certain refining with simultaneous des-

3. The reduction mix mainly consisting of FeSi and lime will

time of the converters was reduced by up to 20% and the

lagging take place in the melting furnace or other primary

be charged to the melt where chromium recovery and

refractory consumption reduced to a great extent.

facilities, while

desulfurization take place.

Some operators realize the metallurgical benefits of

Decarburization

combined blowing and explain the higher CRE by higher

Deoxidation

achieve the final analysis required. As a result of carbon

metal temperatures in the flame point and improved mixing

Desulfurization

content in the alloys added, the carbon levels in the melt

of bath and slag mixture and bath agitation (Figure 36).

Precise adjustment of temperature and analysis are exe-

increase slightly. The control of inclusion shapes will be

cuted during the vacuum treatment. The primary facili-

carried out by CaSi wire feeding.

Top lances for stainless steel refining mainly aim at a rapid

20

20

40

60

80

100

4. Necessary alloys and chill material are added to

ties can be relieved considerably in this way.

decarburization. They are normally designed as relatively

Top Blowing Ratio (%)

Fig. 36: CRE depending on top blowing rate

After treatment, the slag can remain on the ladle, thus, per-

hard-blowing lances compared with LD lances for carbon

The process steps for the production of a 304L grade in a

steel. The standard lance for converter units up to 120 t are

VOD plant can be summed up as follows (Figure 37):

normally of 1-hole design.

1. The required quantity of oxygen will be blown by a


water-cooled oxygen lance with a flow rate of approx.

Vacuum Oxygen
Decarburization

Vacuum Carbon
Degassing

Reduction
Periode

Alloying

0.45

1,000

Carbon Level
Oxygen Supply

100

offers the following process advantages:

.4 l/t min, starting from a vacuum pressure level of < 200

down to a [C] content of approx. 0.50.3%. The lance

mbar. During this decarburization phase, a preset oxy-

Increase of productivity of the furnace

height above the bath is between 1.82 m for a 100-t ves-

gen quantity, according to the existing analysis data, will

Utilisation of cheaper materials with high carbon content

sel and therefore higher than during the main decarburiza-

be supplied to the melt until a carbon level of approx.

tion of the LD process.

.05 % is achieved. Especially for this final phase, the

Decrease of production costs

(charge chromium)

end of the decarburization treatment is exactly indicated

Increase of quality

0.30

Some operators perform mixed-gas top blowing with O2

by control of the exhaust gas analysis and by further

Possibility of production of ELC grades with a minimum

0.25

and inert gas through the lance to lower the CO partial

lowering the vacuum. As soon as the CO gas reading

pressure even in the impingement range, in which the top-

drops off, the oxygen supply will be shut off and the next

Attaining of tight analysis tolerances

blown O2 hits the bath surface.

process step will begin.

Better yield chromium

0.20
10

In summary, stainless steelmaking by means of a VOD plant

0.35

0.15
0.10

Carbon Level [%]

Pressure

mitting the desired insulation effect during casting.

The lance is only used during the first decarburization steps

0.40

Pressure [mbar]

S T A I N L E S S

Oxygen for VOD-Plants

technologies currently in use in the stainless steel industry

2 Liq.
40
CS

2100

S T E E L

180

SiO2

of chromium loss

0.05
1
0

10

20

30

40

0.00
60

50

Time [min]

Fig. 37: Typical VOD treatment pattern

VAI Technology News

VAI reference installationsthe AOD of POSCO and the

2. Final decarburization is continued by the natural forma-

Depending on the steel grades to be produced, stainless

K-OBM-S at ISCOR Pretoriaare also designed for mixed-

tion of CO developing from carbon and oxygen dissol-

steelmaking can be carried out in two different process

gas top blowing. The Picture below shows the 90-t AOD

ved in the melt. After termination of this natural decar-

routes. The DUPLEX process route (EAFConverterCCM)

during charging which was supplied by VAI to POSCO,

burization, an exact indication of the carbon level can be

will be used for the production of conventional stainless

Pohang, Korea.

given by the exhaust gas control and the desired carb-

steel. Requiring extremely low levels of carbon and nitrogen

on content of approx. .01 % can be reliably adjusted.

the Triplex route (EAF-Converter-VOD-CCM) is applied.

26

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Technology News

27

Issue No. 31/August 1999

VAI Offices to Serve You Worldwide!


VA TECH International of Spain S.A.
Basilica 19, 8-A, 28020 Madrid
Tel.: (+34/91) 555-1927
Fax: (+34/91) 555-1399
E-Mail: kirpal@ibm.net
Argentina

Sweden

VA TECH International
Argentina S.A.
AV. Cordoba 1561-Piso 12
1055 Buenos Aires
Tel.: (+54/11) 4815-3964
Tel.: (+54/11) 4815-3965
Fax: (+54/11) 4815-3968
E-Mail: vaarg@ibm.net

VOEST-ALPINE STAHL AB
Nybrogatan 44, Stockholm
Postal address: P.O. Box 5270, 10246 Stockholm
Tel.: (+46/8) 667-0235
Fax: (+46/8) 667-2902
E-Mail: voest@voest.se
Taiwan

VA TECH International GmbH


Taiwan Branch, 9 Fl-3, No. 167
Fu Hsing North Road, Taipei
Tel.: (+886/2) 2719-8057, 2719-8058
(+886/2) 2719-8059, 2719-8060, 2719-8061
Fax: (+886/2) 2546-0902
E-Mail: vati@trace.com.tw

Australia

VA TECH Australia Pty Limited


Suite 5, Level 9, 100 Walker Street
North Sydney, NSW 2060
Tel.: (+61/2) 9954-0722, Fax: (+61/2) 9954-0782
E-Mail:janvaai@ibm.net
Belgium

Thailand

VOEST-ALPINE NV/SA
Avenue Mounierlaan 44, 1200 Bruxelles
Tel.: (+32/2) 770-0852, Fax: (+32/2) 770-0287
E-Mail: woegerer@voest-alpine.be
Peoples
Brazil

VOEST-ALPINE Indstria Ltda


Rua Mato Grosso, 960/7 andar
Bairro Santo Agostinho
30190 081, Belo Horizonte/MG
Tel.: (+55/31) 337-8778
Fax: (+55/31) 337-1752 (administrative area)
Fax: (+55/31) 337-6976 (purchase area)
E-Mail: vaibraz@linz.vai.co.at

Indonesia

P.T. VAI ASIA


Chase Plaza Podium, 5th Floor
Jalan Jenderal Sudirman Kav. 21
12910 Jakarta
Tel.: (+62/21) 571-2257
Fax: (+62/21) 571-2298
E-Mail: vaiajkt@cbn.net.id

Chile

VA TECH International GmbH


Agencia Chile, Avda. El Bosque 654
Providenca Casilla 57, Santiago 35
Tel.: (+56/2) 366-9022, Fax: (+56/2) 233-1751
E-Mail: voestalp@entelchile.net
Czech

Republic
VAI PRAHA ENGINEERING spol. s r.o.
Opletalova 55, 11121 Praha
Tel.: (+420/2) 242-11645
Fax: (+420/2) 242-10620
E-Mail: vaiprahaengineering@ms.easynet.cz

Iran

VA TECH International GmbH


Tehran Liaison Office
No. 9, 21st Street, Khaled Eslamboli Ave.
4th Floor, Tehran 15139
Postal address:
P.O. Box 14155-1735, Tehran
Tel.: (+98/21) 871-0433, 872-6426, 872-6427
Mobiltel.: (+98) 911-211-2187
Fax: (+98/21) 871-9203
E-Mail: vatechir@www.dci.co.ir

VA TECH International GmbH


Representative Office Cairo
Nile Hilton-Commercial Center
Office No. 39/40, Cairo
Tel.: (+20/2) 394-5639, 394-5640, 579-6332
Fax: (+20/2) 579-6331
E-Mail: vatechca@brainy1.ie-eg.com

VA TECH International GmbH


Hong Kong Liaison Office, Room 712
C.C. Wu Building, 302-308 Hennessy Road
Wanchai, Hong Kong
Tel.: (+852) 2573-7101, Fax: (+852) 2834-5056
E-Mail: vahkg@asiaonline.net

Germany

DEUTSCHE VOEST-ALPINE
INDUSTRIEANLAGENBAU GMBH
Vlklinger Strasse 4
40219 Dusseldorf
P.O. Box 260152
D-40094 Dusseldorf
Tel.: (+49/211) 3028-0
Fax: (+49/211) 3028-326
E-Mail: bindschus@dvai.vai.co.at
FUCHS Systemtechnik GmbH
Reithallenstrasse 1
77731 Willsttt-Legelshurst
Tel.: (+49/7852) 4100
Fax: (+49/7852) 41141
E-Mail: kreide@fsl.vai.co.at
VAI TECHNOMETAL
Gesellschaft fr Metalltechnologie mbH
Schifferstrasse 22, 47059 Duisburg
Tel.: (+49/203) 3182-0
Fax: (+49/203) 3182-100
E-Mail: schrade@tmduis.vai.co.at
VAI SEUTHE GmbH
Elsa-Brandstrm-Strasse 21
58675 Hemer
Tel.: (+49/2372) 506-0
Fax: (+49/2372) 3262
E-Mail: vaiseuthe@linz.vai.co.at
Hungary

VA TECH International GmbH


Magyarorszgi Kpviselete
Buday Lszl u. 12, 1024 Budapest
Tel.: (+36/1) 345-4537, 345-4538
Fax: (+36/1) 345-4540
E-Mail: vatechbp@mail.elender.hu
India

VAI INDIA Pvt. Ltd.


1/72, WHS, Kirti Nagar, 110015 New Delhi
Tel.: (+91/11) 511-9840, 544-8945
Fax: (+91/11) 511-9381
E-Mail: contact@vaiindia.vai.co.at
VAI Automation Private Limited
6 Circuit House Area (East)
Jamshedpur 831001
Tel.: (+91/657) 232-289, 226-899
Fax: (+91/657) 233-472
E-Mail: inbox@vaiapl.vai.co.at

VA TECH International GmbH


Istanbul Irtibat Brosu
Abide Sitesi, Tomurcuk Sokak
Murat Is Hani A-Blok, Kat 6, Daire 22
80300 Mecidiyeky-Istanbul
Tel.: (+90/212) 212-0816, 212-0817
Fax: (+90/212) 212-0818
E-Mail: vatechi@ibm.net
Ukraine

VA TECH International GmbH


Shanghai Office, Suite 325
The American International Centre at Shanghai Centre
1376 Nanjing Xi Lu, Shanghai 200040
Tel.: (+86/21) 6279-8651
Fax: (+86/21) 6279-8652
E-Mail: vashang@public.sta.net.cn

VOEST-ALPINE IMPIANTI Srl.


Via C. Correnti, 49, 24124 Bergamo
Tel.: (+39/35) 412-4036-7
Fax: (+39/35) 412-4032
E-Mail:vaimp.vi@pccom.it
registered office:
Via F. Turati 29, 20121 Milano
Tel.: (+39/2) 290-811
Fax: (+39/2) 655-5091

Philippines

VA TECH International GmbH


Regional Headquarters
Suite 401, Golden Rock Building
168 Salcedo St., Legaspi Village, 1268 Makati City
Postal Address: P.O. Box 2822, Makati City
Tel.: (+63/2) 8185-473, 8174-392
(+63/2) 8161-631, 8941-010
Fax: (+63/2) 817-4674
E-Mail: voest@mnl.cyberspace.com.ph

France

SOFRARET Reprsentant de VAI en France


48, Rue de Rome, 75008 Paris
Tel.: (+33/1) 4522-4084, Fax: (+33/1) 4294-9901

Turkey

JV INMET GmbH
vul. Nabereshna Lenina 17, k. 310
320091 Dnepropetrovsk
Tel.: (+380/562) 373-409, 781-824
Fax: (+380/562) 373-408, 780-282
E-Mail: inmet@online.alkar.dp.ua
United

Italy
Egypt

Republic of China
VA TECH International GmbH
Beijing Liaison Office, Han Wei Plaza, West Wing
18th Floor, Unit B8-B10, No. 7 Guang Hua Lu
Chaoyang District, 100020 Beijing, P.R. China
Tel.: (+86/10) 6561-3940-44
Fax: (+86/10) 6561-3946
E-Mail: vapeking@public.bta.net.cn

VA TECH International GmbH


Representative Office Thailand
12B Lake Rajada Office Complex
193/44 Rachadapisek Rd.
Klongtoey, Bangkok 10110
Tel.: (+66/2) 264-0353-7
Fax: (+66/2) 264-0362
E-Mail: vatbkk@loxinfo.co.th

Libya

VOEST-ALPINE
Branch Office Tripoli
Al-Hadaba-Al-Khadra, Tripoli
Postal address: Al-Hadaba-Al-Khadra
P.O. Box 80323, Tripoli
Tel.: (+218/21) 4900-938
Fax: (+218/21) 4900-939

Poland

VAI Polen Sp. z o.o.


Przedsiebiorstwo Automatyki Hutniczej
ul. Rekawka 51, 30535 Cracow
Tel.: (+48/12) 656-0032, 656-0608
Fax: (+48/12) 656-0246
E-Mail: vaipol@krakus.top.pl
Republic

Malaysia

VA TECH International Sdn. Bhd.


Suite 15.01, 15th Floor, Menara Haw Par
Jalan Sultan Ismail, 50250 Kuala Lumpur
Tel.: (+60/3) 206-2524, 206-7267
Fax: (+60/3) 206-8497
E-Mail: vatech1@ibm.net

of Korea
VA TECH International GmbH
Korea Branch, Hong Woo Bldg., 945-1
Daechi-Dong, Kangnam-Ku, Seoul 135-280
Tel.: (+82/2) 555-8718, 555-8719
Fax: (+82/2) 568-5008
E-Mail: vaseoul@bora.dacom.co.kr

Republic
Mexico

VA TECH International
Mxico, S.A. de C.V.
Paseo de la Reforma 509-801
06500 Mxico-D.F.
Tel.: (+52/5) 286-3072, 553-7707
Fax: (+52/5) 553-3933
E-Mail: vamex@mail.internet.com.mx
vatmex@vat-i.co.at
Netherlands,

The
VOEST-ALPINE STAHL B.V.
Willem Witsenplein 4, 2596 BK, Den Haag
Tel.: (+31/70) 324-5556
Fax: (+31/70) 328-2092
E-Mail: woegerer@voest.nl

Nigeria

VOEST-ALPINE Technical Services Nigeria Ltd.


Service Center, Newport Express Way
Ekpan, Warri
Tel. and Fax: (+234/53) 256-043
Sat-Tel.: (+871 or +873) 761-613-936
Sat-Tel.: (+871 or +873) 761-613-937
VOEST-ALPINE Technical Services Ltd.
121 Adetokunbo Ademola Crescent
Wuze 2, Abuja
Tel. and Fax: (+234/9) 523-9380
Tel.: (+234/9) 523-9381
Mobiltel.: (+234/9) 0801-536
Pakistan

VA TECH International GmbH


Liaison Office Pakistan
18/C Mezzanine Floor, Stadium Lane No. 3
Phase V, D.H.S., Karachi
Tel.: (+92/21) 585-4685, 585-2546, 584-5774
Fax: (+92/21) 585-0823, 585-2546
E-Mail: vatech@biruni.erum.com.pk

of Slovakia
LinKoMet Engineering spol. s r.o.
Bozeny Nemcovej 30, 04218 Kosice
Tel.: (+421/95) 633-5885, 633-7284
Fax: (+421/95) 633-8448
E-Mail: linkomet@fitech.sk

Republic

of South Africa
VOEST-ALPINE INDUSTRIES
(SA) (PTY) LIMITED
The Ferns Office Park VA HOUSE
364 Pretoria Avenue, Randburg 2194
Postal address: P.O. Box 2903, Cramerview 2060
Tel.: (+27/11) 886-0900-7, Fax: (+27/11) 886-0941
E-Mail: ingoreis@vaisa.co.za

Russia

Postojannoe predstaviteljstvo
VA TECH International GmbH
International Trade Centre CMT, Office 1107
Krasnopresnenskaja nab., 12, 123610 Moscow
Tel.: (+7/095) 967-0707-11
Sat-Tel.: (+7/502) 258-0707-11
Fax: (+7/095) 258-1478, 258-1479
Sat-Fax: (+7/502) 258-1478, 258-1479
E-Mail: vatechmsk@wtt.ru

Kingdom
VAI Industries (U.K.) LIMITED
39/61 High Street Old Orchard
Poole, Dorset BH15 1AE
Tel.: (+44/1202) 494-100
Fax: (+44/1202) 676-791
E-Mail: marian.howe@vai.co.uk

USA

VOEST-ALPINE INDUSTRIES, INC.


Penn Center West, Building Four
Pittsburgh, PA 15276
Tel.: (+1/412) 747-4600
Fax: (+1/412) 747-4646
E-Mail: vaii@vaiipitt.vai.co.at
VAI Automation, Inc.
P.O. Box 1408, 2390 Pipestone Rd.
Benton Harbor, MI 49023-1408
Tel.: (+1/616) 926-2148
Fax: (+1/616) 026-6854
E-Mail: email@vaiautomation.com
Uzbekistan

VA TECH International GmbH


Liaison Office Taschkent, Achmad Jugnakij
House 11, Apartment 67, 700201 Taschkent
Tel.: (+998/712) 649-553
Fax: (+998/712) 645-808
Venezuela

VA TECH International de Venezuela C.A.


Avenida la Estancia, Torre las Mercedes
Piso 6, Chuao, Apartado Postal 61.177,
Caracas 1060 A
Tel.: (+58/2) 992-4946
Fax: (+58/2) 992-8720
E-Mail: vateven@ibm.net
Vietnam

VA TECH International GmbH


Resident Representative Office in HCM City
163 Hai Ba Trung Str., 6th Floor, District 3
HCM City, S.R. Vietnam
Tel.: (+84/8) 8234-349, 8234-351
Fax: (+84/8) 8234-350
E-Mail: vatihcmc@hcm.fpt.vn

Saudi

Arabia
SAUDI VOEST-ALPINE Company Branch
P.O. Box 8697, Dammam 31492
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Tel.: (+966/3) 826-5968, 827-0836
Fax: (+966/3) 827-0134
E-Mail: voest@mail.gcc.com.bh

Singapore

VAI ASIA PTE LTD


100 Beach Road, #16-08 Shaw Towers
Singapore 189702
Tel.: (+65) 297-4727, Fax: (+65) 291-8824
E-Mail: vaiasias@mbox4.singnet.com.sg

VOEST-ALPINE Industrieanlagenbau GmbH


Steel Production Technologies
Turmstrasse 44, P.O. Box 4
A-4031 Linz / Austria
Tel.: (+43/70) 6592-8671
Fax: (+43/70) 6980-4760
E-Mail: contact.steelmaking@linz.vai.co.at
VAI Homepage: www.vai.at

Publication Date: August 1999

Spain

You might also like