You are on page 1of 11

Project Peer Evaluation Form

Please evaluate yourself and your colleagues based on the criteria below. After each name giv
space below (and within the box) please provide any comments re: your evaluation in the "co
name. The comments will be kept private and not shared with any of your team members.
Evaluation scale: 1 = lowest 5 = highest
1: very poor performance, unacceptable
2: less than acceptable performance
3: average performance
4: good, solid performance
5: exceptional performance

Is this you? (put X above your name)


Criteria
% that the student contributed to the overall workload on this HW/Case
study

Comment

Did the student commit appropriate time to the HW/Case and meet the
deadlines set forth by the team? - % effort
Comment

Did the student attend team meetings and contribute effectively during
team meetings with valuable ideas, suggestions, and insights to the
HW/Case? - % effort
Comment

Did the students resolve any conflicts in a professional manner? - %


effort
Comment

Did the student carry out tasks thoroughly, accurately, and in a timely
fashion? - % effort
Comment

Did the student communicate effectively and in a professional manner


both in leadership and in support roles? - % effort
Comment

Did the student contribute as a team player or leader in developing,


maintaining, integrating and communicating HW/Case deliverables? % effort
Comment

Overall, how many points would you assign to the


student in scale 1 to 5?

Allison Olazo

Student 1

Student 2

Reviewed final document for flow.

created powerpoint template

2
Always complaining about working
and unable to meet demands of
assignments

I organized the meetings

Didn't say very much during


conference calls

no conflicts

no conflicts

I reviewed and submitted final


documents before class.
5

I scheduled teleconference, assigned


questions. It seemed I had to bring
up our assignment during class each
time to get the ball rolling.

5.00

3.71

Barry Ladizinski

Vipul Bhatia

Student 3

Student 4

no conflicts

no conflicts

4.57

4.29

Is this you? (put X above your name)

Criteria

Student 1

% that the student contributed to the overall workload on this


HW/Case study

Comment

Did the student commit appropriate time to the HW/Case and


meet the deadlines set forth by the team? - % effort

Comment

Did the student attend team meetings and contribute effectively


during team meetings with valuable ideas, suggestions, and
insights to the HW/Case? - % effort
Comment

Did the students resolve any conflicts in a professional manner? % effort

Comment

Did the student carry out tasks thoroughly, accurately, and in a


timely fashion? - % effort

Comment

the idea for the project was


mine. I created power point &
word on google. I reviewed
final document for submission.
I coordinated telephone
conference calls.

4
I researched and had a draft of
my part but I couldn't finish
task by due date/time
because I had to wait on
others to complete their part.
4
I assisted each with their
assigned questions. I had an
emergency at work and
couldn't attend changed
meeting date/time
5
I was frustrated we couldn't
meet on the date/time we
initially agreed upon but I
didn't mention it.
5

I had to take the initiative to


develop ideas for final project

Did the student communicate effectively and in a professional


manner both in leadership and in support roles? - % effort

Comment

Did the student contribute as a team player or leader in


developing, maintaining, integrating and communicating HW/Case
deliverables? - % effort

Comment

leader
Overall, how many points would you assign to the
student in scale 1 to 5?

4.71

Allison Olazo

Barry Ladizinski

Student 2

Student 3

I helped her with research and


gave input on best ideas
submitted

contributed ideas for final


project

Did not completee sections on


time, Waited two days before
report due to submit assigned
sections.

Did not complete section on


time but was ahead of
everyone else

We had to reschedule b/c


Didn't have a comprehensive
Barry couldnt make the
answer to questions.
time/date even though we ALL
agreed to it
5

No conflicts

No conflicts

found same great articles I did

contributor

contributor

3.86

4.57

Vipul Bhatia
Student 4
3

no ideas submitted but did


help evaluate the ideas that
others submitted

Did not completee sections on


time, Waited two days before
report due to submit assigned
sections.

2
Couldn't find valuable
information on his topics so I
don't think he put too much
effort
5

No conflicts

waited last minute to provide


content of slides/report

contributor

3.57