8™em0803%)%0 N~EJMemmaogeo Agbagemo ggmbo 89-3 g09mGq80 | AFIS O~ abQoy 3gogq~@o (*) ] é :Fm Ecru Ts Anotigdigmore aage ensdar dogymedg (ag. HI9) qqsds drone (gg. xivexvi, 377-91) ° Boone ggoMocbgerns (gg. 120-30, 143-214) oso mmAndg (gg. 190-43, 337-67) 2qg06 mmabsdg (gg. 177-336, 368-76) doorgegn gadegg®ab GggedGe%g20 mada Boehana Bgnbsd borodg meingoBsepigtin gadmiyganb bobgexSmegds: Andrew Heywood, Poltical Ideologies, ‘An Introduction, Third Edition, Palgrave Macmillan. © g6reMarg Ingen 1992, 1998, 2003 nBsbodygomds © pSrering ggdeo 1992 © eqmamb IMgha, JaMorgenn oo%gds6o'2004 | fg3etnbGo 2005 ganeno DeyeggB BUTTERS. 08 aadmggAnb Msndg Laban Haireneiygargdo, gminrigdo o6 gomoygde agMdaeygeqns BgMincymbnen Ggdariagal Bo%g8o- 08 godmgg8nb MmBgegn8g ImBosgqenk ApIencesq grass, smInrgdo 96 gorQoggdo-BpSsbgo qwaboBgqdno Abmenencg BoM ncemBncin Bydariongab 96 Bybee grBntgBab odIggdo Mon¥y cegdyergBnb Iabgregow, ong sdggatin egdgergd> Bdmag@ganas grBoroaGab Cogs bam garb baoagosmb (Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Totlenham Court Road, Londan W1P SHE) 8nig¢4, Bgdabdagttin dnrimgbgdo, AmBgeqay AnBorasgh asMdocoger Jagegeob 98 godmaggdnb BaBarian, Bgndeggdo gabcegh babbegnb LoBsrorcgab 26 badngaemaden Lodoringal eggGab mangdGe Aaygigogena Vomocab godm. 03 BoBemBob sgGmeinb ggagnd ROGIER grdormongab, gabenGnbys eo BoGqHOqInb 1988 Berob agGab Bobgregnor Bogbo asémantgegns “gnbbMomgta ggMmiab ‘gSnggMbagaSob Borst gdBgermBnan Smggab” (CEU Translation Projacl) Absctcgaggne, gba OSI-2ug, SqQodgAGab mas bomascomgdnb abb}aGjGab bagodmaggdcer bogdob gsSgnosrigdnk gg58nbe (CPD), genbiy “ens LoTmgaromgdo — bodotergacemb" (OSG) Lmgoseeg BggGngMgaoos Bbotcgoggrnl See- amodabs (SSSP) wo bogsdediegdenrr-Bowegdbjeymonan IMiegrodnb (TP) goGobbegtin byer BgSymBnen ‘The edition was published with the support ofthe Central European University Translation Project, sponsored by the OSI-Zug Foundation and with the contribution of the Center for Publishing Development of the Open Sociely Insitute - Budapest, Social Sciencas Support Program and ‘Translation Program of the Open Society - Georgia Foundation, ISBN 99928-928-4-6 godmacggbeamBa “eam Igho” anos goggegednb gadBorin 13, mBnerabo 179 ae. 250258;.gSbongo wwlogospress.com.geBobssMbo Boboriongdo Bobsorgds Bot ggeoo godeygdob Enbobagygomds 1 Bgbogomna: Kimgen™ gagogma ogegmargas aggacs Mingo As atin’ omgeregmgna? orggmenmgaob (3698980 orggmermgns, $9880 989 wo doenoigengds AgdorysbyBgmads, BgBarigeggbgmds wd (GAHHGaLGmBs IeaanGo3qGo awegmarmgagdo myQodjgMarg boy gxGg3o Ggcro%@0 Abagenam Bgbrngo Seb Gaenegtbr gormdaqa Boao FggmApbanra@o KGS 2 eendqoggaBdo Bor8mmds wo ysbgoaotgds abrengnw@al yBgbsgbmds — Borgata odgdo obrongorwga onogobeygengo> ambgdo Lodariogensbmds FyABybsrigdeemds cos Irogoemeggrghgdo cendgtonBIn, Bomanggemmds Qo —Q_IM3MH2GHOo madgGocngtn bobgmabngm grb GGg0%9% DsMonggermds gd roGoo xi xiv xv 28 31 32 34 37 38 4 44 44 46 48Vi Onbssbo gmoboggtin modgMama bao | 53 Se98g3Cng gg_emgdoos agers | 55 waGocenGorin Bo 56 ggmbrda 390 eendgtoenn Bao 58 beygasemgtin @otgabn do 60 Egmond gtocern 0 62 onbsdgeomiengy endgtoeaBI0 64 obwogowmsocomde 65 BeBagogen aogobsygergdo 66 beygaseragtin eondgtocea®éo 68 gambrndo396%0 Aoriange i a ndghogmobIa my~adggMing boy yy6g30 74 BasmapGaQgr aero oGgMeG-gMo 77 3 gmbbgtigoQoBIo 78 Bom Inds Qo gobgooweigds 78 SMbydgcrab B_FMAhig6gdnboado LEMagga — datinas~n ag8gdo 81 GMo~—A309 j 82 semo8nsbab omabegerymgaergas 84 mM gobqe0 boBmgoc@mgoo } 88 agGatgos wo domoygeng’e \ % bogegontig3o | 93 sgMAnGsGgero. gmbbgMgoGoBIo \ 94 IoGoSGoerabHeyMo gmbbgrqoGodEn 97 gion gob grblygo§o Bde 7 AHabGoobger0 cogdenztoG0o 100 EndyMBor-gera yrbby%gzoGoBIo : 102 abe BgGoMgegq5jm3> 104 end gtogngto abogrn Apdoreegg6gmdo 106 gmblgMgoGogeno oboenn QpAotisegg6grmdo ith @QosoFabsntg3gdn sboee Aydatigegqb6grmdoTo 15 gmbbyMgoGobIo mEmsdggtag baygz35730 16 Mo gmIQbegdqaero eenGgmeGeyso 19 4 beagoogga8o 120 BomMdmBmds eo gobynasMgds 120 26g gon sQsdnsbo of atin’ y_bdyjero — daminoga ag8gdo 122 LoBmgogmydo/agdo 123 or06od Bendeoendo 126 odsbobimimds 127mego 1 Agbagoeno: GMamM 30g0gM OQ BOS amegoons.eneno | 8 sab argmeomgas? 3 Apdorigbqbqrds, AgdoPpeqq098 wo GghGHrbsrdo Smemogo,zaito omgmanmgagen mu@cdygGag bogs.96980 ee aeqodnobo SmemngagyMae sbemgbgdb; bazqowt gbgwgegd0m go IeabsbsBIQ 46 SdAab grdmbomg8geroe, GEMBagGE org oMIGEMBOQMSE, 3m- moGogg® owggdbo «wo GHgsQ’> oygegBb. ymageregnoy% BgGysaegeBo God- gorg8-98 gogrgdoar GgMaobgdb: “omgabygengds”, “badoriacras6mBs”, “orsbob- Geacmds”, “bodsmiosea”, “qgengdgoo”. adab Abgoghoe, boSyggdk “3mbbgmgo~ Bogen”, “epndymaeegto”, HergoserabGeeo”, “ymagooaqemo”, “goBobog- a” sbggq bBorore Andarranggs ba zeyenst%o ob Lbgaors Bgbycergergdgbab wobs- babroorgderae. (@d arggo abgan GByGInGgdO Agggeea, Boboerghing yr, dom |BZNIONE bBoMmagd By Qo IoM@oInen BdgPgermBom. Mo stab, gordgoor, “orsbabBeatmds”? Mab BoBESgh godmerfds: ygners omedno60 owbsbGe- no? edsegons6 osbobHmMpBoe? bo dagaymgas doa Mimgymmyy HLH rear, alg yeas gobabnepagmgh? SQddOsbBb qbrys SyrGajor sbsdoro jargon, AghodengdeamBgdn, Imeyaggg aogcra6, byergobo? Rggyergting, oMob- Sma basmimdg6 abgor badygndbog, AmamMnges “gmdgbabGo” wo “qoBob- Go" Gab GaBGagh,,Amge godsgh “qodoSb” gaSmeagdar? Amgmtins go Gob | gayoMgdo GoSabSByBb mamraqmgoqoo gs BAB sdb, wo Hood groggeraeae abobo Boor? Kaa gsbbbgsqmndo gmagoabGgBob Bybawe-aeratado, gordgoo, ceo- gmoeegdab, grbbyMgaGrMgdnb a6 bergoserabgob Bpbgeeyerge980bge6? ab Babin Borsgotin Imengnggn acegmermgagdab dagger omggshs wo wmg- GMnb 7b goGnbaeeagb. 03 Bxbogoee nogdn gabyoboayaga neeggdob mer I~ m0 Go39B0, Imenn@agyGn, owgmeymanab Sgbgdsb; 3gd%xgq6q/8q8oMsbg69 L3gJBMob BoBgbgemBsb omgmermgnses. geabogazogonbargod wo. o@gn- camansans dogo godmBggggdh mgm@odggtag bayg76980- A~_EMS Gomgra + acgggBbo Qo oregmegmangdl enw BoB_EjermBs’ yagere ImayoHo gato Ins Reahbg Ringo sSnggdb. Imenagojab, Garg AIgnsOwe, emsdnb daeroyyengor- 12 dmanngngigo orwegmepmangaa bomgab BoBgger SMdmerabow6 sngnggdg6- ong gh sbgs, Imago gyMo oggdo sPBroepm 36%en39g6Qd, bootfiggbm bagdnb o6 Loymggerawm Sbatiesdgtn’ 8m- bodenggdemow ByMBgynerr boGyggdobs eo mmbyGggdab ghinagorin qyrmdo ymenene. Bgbodsaboe, Qegado gs owgmarmangdn, gomacrmg, “goGSobob Beathorngenmdss”, MmAgerbsy ImeraGoggGa GbergMgdab, QM Mga~mmdoms AgbaGomdow ayghg3y6. gh, Ho nfo 76s, SnSggamMobBow Im%Bngaas ~ gybo- Jremannb BndenbsMigmBabs, Mmageragy BME _ymBbrBabs (1878-958) go 3. q, byoBgMab (1904-90) bobgmagdb «qgogBoraaqds, SndggamMowbdab gomoboby- £2156, amdIOb mebog arg goBbbgogmegds Samermgnrgtin BobJobabge6 r= Agena gorgge6n LOrdgennb Lodobygbraw Imdagaagdb (gam LEmemoe, 49230- gab). Beas bemgG by dagdS’, sbaga @mgammy dnb awgggdh, gompeyerg2980, aMdimdgdbs wo Brabggdb AoIgogermdo, goMocgme, o gonggds. grwedo8gg- Gam Abasgh Bybgwrgengdob ggagodmdqs “~nsergdoggqeo Sgeooemab- Ang” — bodgmans jogdaRMnbs a Lbgo meamgmgLgera gmAgbobSqMn babger- Bagmgdab o&SgeradG meg garqageIo godoGmbgdgeno Iom_baBInb wgby- Bo qeneABo, 98 EnBranborgmank ImdbAgaw vB, Incengaggtn awggdo Ioen- eg ad 3aMas gymbmIngwghn ong gerobmarago HGBYMpL_sADDb Ao8mBcqo6o~ Ag snGQo goboboergdmeagb, 306% Bar godmbaGygh. ogggdh .“BoSynxerg%p Boab” odgh, oderrgja@pdmow obabo yorggeragom Lebenbb ob doo Igogen~ Bob Amyengdygenno. Bybsdodnboe, mMamgm|ba Borigbabgo0 ImeoGAjob Armen co breve bmgnaerghn gerobovbogea ggmgboergdab yorbSg46G30 gobabaemagg6 Qo SmaaGagyA awgmermgaogah Borger gmbsMoG gee gepobens ob GgMqbadab godmboSqengdoee Inok6g3Q6. SMBGSMos bss AossRENE 7 Bab (ab. ag. 71) 88 30930, Dbemgramb dainow~mee ggm6mdo maSagab gacembengmbers amggdo Botioagh. Imagyesb SaByggGe Bnbo Brgo- 90 angenennbs (John Maynard Keynes, General Theory) gab sgbnom aggMagorQob: ons 9 Gen IHadGogegenn genbgBob o~odnv6g8o, AmBergdog bs gigas arog Mon8p bobab obGacradG:areyg% gogerginbgyré Leganse gooogobygergdy- crarg BanRbggq6, Bagaengd%ng, Mmdgerndy grbbgggogeen gymbmaabgob BenBqdo aMns6. bycrabeggengas’Tn Iymao goggdn, MmIgerawy 6890 ao- gQ96 RoghBna, omgno6or Ladergagh MabQg6099 Bernb Bab dnemga6g bgennd ogomgbay™o ymodEnerab BimIgdaQs6 Giyrsgg6 (Keynes, [1936] 1963, 33. 383). gb eiBogos Leyenayg 94 gomymed nob, m8 aceggdo IMssGagzaeoo gorigder gBpoor go6IommBgayjenn Bsbyxpgdn9; ab GomBmafg6b, ony MoBpbow gsbbodeag~ Fogh Bpbgreqengdgdo Ws ageatngdn estostion Yag~QgZgab. baBmmgern 329830, Abogennm’ “szeqdaryn Bxgesd6yeqqh0” gobrqgbq6. obgom Bybpregeegdob 8o- bgregne, Bogomenanseg, orsbsidgariengy goInGoero'l IaFgogermgo6Foeroeg co98 “bfaaralss (0b. 4-59) «90 congo Fn gotcomb (1772-1823) jensbn 3x96 gymBmdo gnxgab Aencgab, badgoncns gmgbnBdo goren BoMqbobs (ab. ag. 45) cea g. 0. exgbnbnbs (ab. ag II) BeimBgdnb anstrgDgo gedeygabrern, Ba grbSeyGo ag8s6nob abBeenab go~ 4989 go Bbrageneg SngengMnk Mein Kamprols comJBMobgrcgo6 argo Bpbsdoegdgero.AqloIq grdmGqdob Bobsbogygomds Seen Goggtn owgmermangdab” Iomggeea gedmggdo 1989-N SergdJo amAmbagengar gyMmioBo ImIbQaMa FiggmeaGagaA’ qmby QoaB gM. MgG- FmbIgdGegenowe, “gmAqbaBAnb gmenaqbo” gMonwrimigmoe B7Goe CambI_bs- Bn Bbog ceo IMagoero Fegerbacr Mangos jogdoMjSqer SImanaGoggerabger Ainejen dgtisons Lginab 86nqqbGagr9G Qo JoeBoo Beng ayo. a0 Ber Fink yagers’dg Bond gogromge6a ByI~gge ayer: geomdsenghin gosoGoerabGyo aIMBMAn jab Bree, gabog-ghn Go gombseroBAnbs wo Ageagngs gyy6esdg6- GomaBdob gosdoymgds, ImbHsmeg_rGgerd obey “nb gymMmdcgrgero” babe gowmpdgdob Rodmyornndgdo, Aggragdgjeon BaGgoab mAnbboGmBoa oer Sagcgncro qoImanotirgera Abmamam Bgbrngab Qodyorgdo ws germBsergo GIFMAGBAL BSAIMImaS. abmeos nogoMeywsdbgagow oBfomes. qSoGrog- Gro goMaggjenmds we bodyorg o8yodow 96 gdgdad9 waab, a6, Smangra Bd cibgggoSn, bagmameg Imo Baers. 09 IMmighyab qeoncwgho Sngbgeemdo S4on6- 2S BmenaGaggGn acegmenmgagdnbergab. bmgnseabdab osmbsbg (sboeegeo, md ols, qBogmdngow, Imggws; Smgngtangdn wabagersyin endghoen dob boSmanmen GMingdGdg boydmadg6, 3o3n6 Mego Lbggdn gomagemdg6, Mm’ ob sRindabyer BegmBorigmBsIns} GogombocndIa LyIMobogombaeobdnbs Qo BeyerGogzaerGyamocaBInb godmBggggdaboedn omaIGrMgSob IreygghBoo; 00.8. Dan gmIgHBOmmn o8gg06 dgMgdb qato wna simgghab, gyrdmre, ZOO A_MERMBANL, HmamMg sbgernb, (go Boborob gone IimaMadByero ImenaGogga so Snnb) sebsbFrgerab badBmIs~@ SnakGggh. ImennSngyso AregMERMaanbaga’ wSGoeme segoara sah MBgda ImbSImeg_S6ger, ger BoeenByd-yen BbergycanmBn, GmIgeag bmignaergtin obobyg@po-jeemBao ba- Lasorggds Qs FimAgee Bog Sormgogera Amborgds cemdnbsBGmab. Ingbgme- g@ SdnLs, Rgg6 mBIgEo goro ame adegbowe negmarmgank wabsbrgeenbs (Anko godmgbaegdnbab: ynggmraga LagMobnerg ggdoringdh), Makegbaeag 18 gagGabs, mI abGerMnsd, qodSmaringoe, gowoabSMim negmermgngh SMoQoyagdb. sboero agwgmermanrghin soeimgbyBs odnbargab oMdgnbs, Mma Ladysto abgose sengdqdmegb, mamta ab Mob eo gymBMggemoe oqo- atgdb, mB cmafdab omaGantn Bomdmmeggbo ata oJgb, bone Anak gb-bod- yotim. «a Bonby, acegmermgnab, mgm BAdgogermBabs Ed awggsern' dab Shabyndgqen Syorimb Imagngyn3sBo, Hs s96—o bob ws GmMds dongmbs, oA- bgBmBab goaMdgangds yBgGno. Smeemb Qs Smegmb, egnegmermgnbyd-gjero 29d AmabBrgaenman’ BboF—oddghin Imeengnzo gooGorgenns, Howegab ob bo- Bgdgaeb oh sdenggh o~@odns6ydb, Mamsry jamin wagab ABIg6o Smeg, ORM AdSghnsergMn msobSgMghpdo3; Qo Mowggab o~modnobgdab Iocmg6y- xvWi Agbodg goderyyg4nb BoBobsygomdo een Bomagnggd0 Bo IgogeemBab Abmenmne a3 BgdenbgggoIo ndgbb, Amys gg Fim gation abgmmoger BomsGog8ns ImJggaero. Agbo8y aodersgds GRocemab agora gooeggimb, ong mam omoIGorea domncega deeenGggM% omgmenmangda ~s Yao aggmenmans By8ma ho- Bmangaeney godmBggggdaw6. Babs8eqdo%g Sogn Ancrasbages gobsbangdgero obama dgMgdnbs Qo sboern Aodmggerggdonb goagocrabBoBgdnm. Lbggdor6 Bg WHMgBae, en wo Agrtl croggdo GoBgGgermgio~m gowdyTog~o abgown be- gorrbgdnb gamgomobBnbgdom, Fimammnszo9.(ggoerg3o@0 bagenm Bgbngo, ammboenbsi309, SmbSImagMHGq ws ImbSImegMEnBdo, aromdoergmo Gy- Petia. gh bajocrbgdq sbg39 Bbododob yorbyMaGwyer magqoSoo Inmboergy- emo, bagarg, adabersbogg, bergdorine abgon “ImbS-n¥agonb” gohigbobg, Amar- acgos ImbGerndgMoerbBo, ImbSIMgb B30 Qs ImbGygdn6Bdo. o~gmenm- B09880 sMbgd gen GErdgigemgs6o wodsdyenmdo-osaFinbIomgogonbs, Qo IeBogdtig LySo~ngagdab wobSggMg&nb godmABgqgo Lagnmbgdnb ngowe baRaBrg Qo Ma Bgdomgdgerore SoMdmPgonb Anna sboera obsragdns c>- BoGgd-yeen, sbagg wWodGgdqgenns Raboriogdn BmobMmgbggsobs wo “oBagdob” Bgbabyd. | Bbighb Bow~mmds gowogqbsem yagerab, 306g gmIgbGorn gogggow o6 ao- AngbFoy%o Engbob Gabs godmEgagsr eo o8geq gsdmgarggs, md 8999p go- Aengygdd 8gB-Bozergdow ‘qSobyjogdb Ion Inge Gsdmgeingn bo gnorbgdbs es 8en- babdmgdgdb. A660 3ONBILIAnbssbn vii beygnogegtin yepobn boBmgoremgaringn bayger%gdo Bdg8o beagnoeeaBJob3q6 Biggmenggegtin bragnogpa Bao agmenggagtn beagaornn&do BRomyyocnn Bdob goticongocrmds? BomgboBdo : grpobn ign dot gbo&ia gocembmegns garnbrdo30 SegpnGo3> bamemgbnena yedey60 Bo cxgbnbn8do bGocpaba Bio orsbodgetingg dor glia Bde Boe fbn Bb oeobobeinern? bmgaacrgtn wggdmgmagoo gonngigtin bragnocea Bo 6iggn bambabGgho beysnocon Ba begnoceento cogdenzta§nab grn%abo Bgeatggn Bombo bdo oo “Aghodg 3%.” begooao bo megm@sdgg%ag borg 3gog30 Basmapbaqegeo moSoMoG gM GogomBoeado BorBm8mds Qs gobgnowrgds dgayGob baygotgerna — dotinarsign ogdgd0 ‘gta mMigsbigcen gMormds engnorgsdrn 33999 gnome 6 Gaga zogonb dmeongago GogomBoennB¥o ws ImenngGogs ndgtocnintia By3ambogea bdo gmbbarigoGomena bsy3amboenn Bio gqb336ba:960 6o(yorboen0 BA SB Go gmaambayn Qo Ib ymeombowyto boigombsenn Bo BoigoenBoena Bab Bamds ndg Hoenn nbgM6si3ambsen0 80 besnogrol§igo 08§,9%6.(30rmboem0 BIO BagamBaannBan mamodggMiog boy gg6y80 Ag3mAgbeagdgmo moGgMoGg%> 130 132 134 135 137 139 143 144 144 146 148 149 150 152 154 156 159 tet 163 167 169 174 176 7 177 181 182 186 188 191 194 195 198 210 214vill dabsoMbo aah foB8o BoM8mAmds wo gr6growmgds babgm®Tngm’ SoSsomiega — datinasg@o oggda 6G abobgemdBogmgdcinmds/s6GabGgrGo Bo 8e98g3Cngn Bgbringo 6G gengtnjocoa Bao gambmdagentin orogobegggemg&s gmmadGagabyta s6omJoBIo Bog Gorngeoo B80 obo gfor-babn joer Ba oBothigergmdg60 B80 abeagnerqsmab&gMo s69MJoB8o gamo%éo end % Gon BI obothiger-jodoGocra do adgdn abomJon’ 395 Aggenenigtgeighia doemscomds BoMgpodncin BenJ8gce985 domogmdnb gomymgo sbotgnBdo mg@odggtiog boggq6g8e HgsmAgbQgqe gare roGgMoGymo go8o%Io BomdmBmds wo gobgoowtgds dows ghomasdns — datinasma agdgdo 26 Gro(yomBaeon Bo Sridengms eengggtimds co gonna Bin bragnoce do sem GGobogomBboern Ba BrdnBIo eo babgemBBager SeBsevHoGgwoo Ojo gender Bdo Arngg gb Bo(309 GrBoBIo Qo MabosernBdo Rabmdenga Seen §go BoigabG igo Mobmaeingn agmiogdn Eengbigo omgmanmgns Bodo BIn ma@sdggMang borgzig5g80 MagmOgGeagdgera maGgGoGq%e 215 215 218 218 222 225 226 228 230 231 232 234 236 236 238 239 240 242 243 244 246 247 247 250 251 254 256 258 260 262 262 264 266 266 267 269 272 273 276Aobsobn ix 8 galo6oBdo GoMAmBmds Qo go6goorgdo BoMo@genab Imeragago — danas agagdo Rogge “bo Brgow@emg&tngo/sntawgeo” BGs Jocoends bagbo mo gabegrin crabobBrtimde wo bbgomde bgbo co meragago erndgtiocmrntia g98n60 80 begacepabgigtin 998060 B80 Rowen goenigto @gdob0%do obama gpInbabG yn G®owengogso BANE BI enygeQadggMiog bog 3196980 Aggm@pGagryer enGyMoG-qmo 9 garaymgoddo BaG8mBmds wo go6gno%gdo BeyGqdobj96 GoBGqGgdo ~ danogo engBgdn gamcemgno Seen do angnorg BOB ggeryemgo gb gn mbIg63oergtn gonzo engaonagGeqoen0 B30 BaGgdo go Imenngajo gAorsegn69 gamcomgo Bo ggrbergasera bdo ggroborJoB8o ngmggdn6n B80 damMeEmgoB8o mEmodggMang boggy HasMmApeaqeaeo qoGgM*Oygeo 10 Kgmogoyto gySm@sdgoGemodso BoM8mImds wo gobgaowMgdo 49396, boonsgggdabgq6 — dasinasmo agdgdo Figemngnes (mo SmannGajo 21960 96G crab yn o-5erb0 26 G08eeg9°560%I0 bomdocn Ligeonb3gg01980 277 277 281 282 283 285 288 290 2 295 298 303 304 307 308 308 310 3t 315 319 323 325 327 328 330 331 333 334 336 337 337 340 341 344 347 349X Gnbssbo BnGQod_EGoeoBAnb bobgmBacrs mgzabo abenstigtn gegScovdghorro®do BoaSinhin qr7broodgSoera Bio dhobGorbyero g:6—Q08982c00 B80 oboenn gGnbGoobgenn dgdorge gg6grBo gip6eQodghGomraBdab bbgo bebgmdobo Kigemngnrgmn |_6sdgHGseroBJr mE~Qsdggting Lagzn6980 Mggm@pbaQgegera eng go Hh QobggGo: qhebegage omgmenrgos? arggmermgnab mabsbergena? abGemnnb eobsbeger0? ImbGImegMEn8o mame acogmenmans acemdamaddn Mmgenz omgmermans GagmBgiageaco moggMoGgeo GaAnborw engjoagmbo Sndcramg Mogae badogdgeno 351 352 356 358 360 362 365 367 368 369 370 372 375 376 377 392 403BoboMagd0 Ams dHemgb6y9d0 agwy6ob0, Bnbooee Saco, ~sbagee yoda, geq%qI0 39M 30, IQR B_MBAGsAGO, georgareg Se gPabo, Ingrigo gn@gbbo, gSambo ameggabo, sqoen03d ato8Ba, s6gmbam 29 emg qatin, Lodmby 3906D0, seb Agnboeig gepoobn, BamIn 3OMIMBgnGo, 3amBe mpogenmgo, ROI emgbobo, genom cage, mb Asm gdp, 8g%Bq%S Bombo, goer dodabo, gegbg8q Ageabrobo, 909% Boga, mb Leoqeme, Agbmevabo, By60G 6ai3Bq, YHnrnb BmBogo, HmBjAG 3eg~mb, Bogtrgm’dg Gengenbo, gem6 Sighe, gob-yog 227 369 84 164 332 173 222 299 72 374 234 318 151 45 165 145 195 50 35 264 252 tt 230 189Xi Robotongdn L8ncw, 2908 LGomobq, ambyd Bebo, Hake 3960 OMG, 3 gmegbaxngSgriagon, Into BMnQVba, Bgho BqBabgrn, GMs (QELS QMacQehnb) Bebo, 638 beAgnbn, snsamens Hg3med RIGIALMEN, orndsb 3onggo, |MowGab gymb SoGengMo, sQraegy, 3mdbo, mdb -- 0B8gd0 agGmMoGotn In 6G nbg8aGoBdo aBrengnreqorna bdo abyghMooeraBdo gar8Bos6oBI0 gmangdogoBdo gmdgGnGoo%8o smbbGnSggamboern%o sOMImMI;HoBI0 gmbémImerngnBIo R0Bg%G9A(096)nB80 IgeSngaumGaPoan dso BoGgMbaenoBI0 B9GMamGoddo Beergrioggn Bo Semdqera°dJo ImbSImegA6o°BIo 3rogdoGoBI0 oboogo%o MagomboeraBIo bombn®8a GaMmMnBIo GmmMoao Geren GoMnBIo gGomenGsmaBIo aGM30BI0 GanbeQ0dgGGoemnBIo 59 153 162 2i2 2H 280 321 245 354 108 255 86 5 269 33 319 72 124 171 47 265 209 103 75 192 42 348 373 267 37 365 351 100 263 57 223 345,Bobseiongdo xii agommbsbMabygdo . . . sQsdns6ob BgSgdab Bgbsbgd 87 Sagbgdob Bgbabgd 312 agbragMab Bybobyd 287 QpIMyMsGonb Bgbsbys 52 g3m6en gab Bgbobgd 133 gfiinb Bgbabyd 185 crsgobyygengdab Bgbob9d 36 onababBmeimdob Bqbsbgd 129 acggmegngand Ipbsbgd 17 abGeban’ gsbys a7 Mgepngnal Bgbsbyd 342 boBmasemgdab Bgbabgd 90 babgenBBageb Bgbsbyd 220 boepnbggengdob Bgbobyd 257 mMssoMab3aMgdgdo -. . eqbogaMbamabGinha mrnBghaern Bo Vv SmgMemabGinhia modgMaeen®a 43 Jenoba gti enodg aera ao v. osbsdgmrimngg endyMocesbda 73 IHogdoGujeno gmbbyMgoGhoBdo V. mmndyAGarugena yerbbymgoGoIo 104 cmndgMoerghin sbocnn AgBamgeggbgmds V. 3rbbyMgoGo-gern sbocnn Bgdorigeggbgmds 115 beegnsenagtin cQgdenxeFioGao Vv. gmdeqnB8o 165 Agbafly ada v. bmgoacrgha eg8mjeoGoo 174 bodmgocnagen BogambseraDIa V. gnbmyqjemBaymrgjeno GagombsernbIo 193. emndgomintn BaigambseraBGo V. qJessbboeyin 6s(gomBoenabJo 197 aBeeogowesrrabGeytn asda Blo Vv. jrengdSogabGaio sboriJobda © “239 qoBodSa V. 6sg0%I0 272 gaoernGatiqenn qg8a6n%Io V. LogemBob —gda6o%I0 290 Rocgagoerantin qgdaboB8o Vv. emadghoengto eqqdnbobdo 302 GIS QImemgodBso v. Bwasiomgaro gymeamaobao 314BabsmJdo acggmenmansh sqGGogho abGentos adgh. Bondergdgeros gogdoxbma ogo cor Bodgerimgg Ibeagerenb ImenaGogjGo godImgRncrgdrbge6, org8ye, o89gQ%m- eIEN9E, SerMAGOgob byyey ModegBdg enw agmMaGagmbb org, Bengdgdbgs> Gotan bidygo abo Inbsdomanen. Lbgar@sbbgs dnbpbom Bob 9M LByoeamdro6y6 abgnn gsbbbgogge-gero gnagMgdn, mgmMgdq.y aygbn6 gory Aomgbo, danger eagg8man Qo HsmsnG Soebmbbo. neggmanmgoob mImbyeHgvv ob obgorn bo- lagna (Gg3gd0b LodamnbInMim Madg@ ghobjdmasor, AmamMarsa2 sJBdoro- 89d, BgGbogMpBs, Hagnmbsegmds, mBagdSg7AMBs Co Gomgmbrago. ob ocr Go BGagh Bgbyenengdgabs ws QrgHAoGgab, GmBengdag a6 sMngogadabargab BogBgomagen cemgegdl Barmogaghb, a6 Medgemar Eomsddggd Samamo wo RBIGIG obGgPghgdn odoergdo bmerdp- gabboggogmgdgenn ab otab, aa6bs3qormMqboo 28 BZ aGoyn gobygggnob gogmnabab gomgorrabBabgdna, md QMmw@ogrn Imeymoag, oagengderags aggmermgodd mobsdamgds, ~@> Baba smbsbegerr gsdmaboregds. dogro4 Abgogbore abGmennbs wo ImEagogob domo, sbseomangmo AgmeqeemOgoo- bo, acggmenmans, BagyengdMng, bamabers qBMinBagSm@S bmerdg obdorgdb. enbodgeongg Soegeramb SmennGage bdoabe ogmanmgnrgGo GHaQogrr qdab bogyegdggerg Boryorrndgo. ngmermangso JdSIB MghgMbb Br amagsh SmenngozqGo Fgommdab BogdGob, asobodagrinbs we Byobgdob- engab «Qo 3een4G 333% A|BBMBAL Rodmyserndgdobargab. : BeQMory BgogiyOnd BagGab qenmgba moMbgdo aba, Ged ogo bymambg- cage ]GORIBS YI AEQMENMAOnL bogabl, Imadbgdr0» we amBaBgoab moe bo engacebahobingdinc Bomdmakgbb mgmt grrsbo3qgMo wobogern%o oye eamgogdab gobbbgsggoyex bsbnab, aby gobergbo o@gmEmangtn vdMab age Bago gobs Wd GoBstrornengdgdb. 396 ByJSbo, ghorgMan boyggagh 08 BaLsgowr gaabongs6, Gmdangbory 28 odo ereeqh8g @a6gGoere wo adsrggenere- gobo gong orggmanmgarg GS Goh, Hmageebsy boggy Igngho8g69 Logggbab qs6gger ws odgMng gee BggmanygedeIo wog~m, 0% oBergB'g~ Rage Sererngagab goagonb baBqoergdgbo gd ob o%g Imaeragogg% sbeHnb mogoen oMowabogeng® Mago good ogggdo @s A~gmermangdo Imewngaggh gbengMgdo%by bbgowabbgog goMowe Spderddgregdb. Bagger ng 8, abobo badyorimb goaganbe @o obLEnb 3g%bI9J- Gogsb ggasgeBmab. o@sdns6gdn Ladyorimb byw@og9b smo abgob, Amgen athab, sma8ge abgob, Amgmmsgog ab Bomdmgmagénac; Logo bagyggdom — abnbo bedystiob Mog godgQetin ABIPL, obMgdabs We gomoy~gdob Ma- c2g8a +y8BMHgs. GOmBngMace org OMI ySMBagMow, ygger> o—QV8ns60 ImeraGo- GOH BABA wo KaMpsgengdsoo goMggqaced gMammramanb Sndoggero brogdo, MmBgenary Bobs Jgggedg Bgdmgdg~gab go GoBoMarngh. v8ggoroe, 3m- cman gan acgggdo we n~gmermangdo babagh sd gaGgab, Mmeagdog Imero- Gog odSogmdsb goboInmmdgdb. 08 Abeng, Imeangagmbgdn mtn bergen adbbbgoggeqero. gogeegGob Jgq9 Bgadengd> Bmqg6g6. BogMornsbydgera IBsdLams ws aMpSgergdgdon goMgbggerymgb. Imaro~Agbogoema & GogWH0 o~gmenmangdn, Lomas, smBjzMqG oer brgnserigh jerabjdon6 sbegntagds, Iogocrnog, erndgMoeraBsa — boBgoone gypbobas6, jmbby%qo- HoBAd = IB omdgeamagen nQagormg6gBa06, beagnacrnBIo — Aydoas yorob- O96 d 9.8. gv om~gGd Legnomgen gesbab GbmgMgdnbgge godmgeaeg- gdb, oGGgMghgdbs eo BobSMaggdgab sbabagh wo, adonGo~, byerls yBymab 8o- SIOZH_dgermBnbs Qo Lmerngeimdab gMdEmBab godmdyBagqdob. orgdyo, agggdbs @s a~egmenmangdh sbqg9 Bgdeqnser, bbgowabbge ImbBn goody d~egmn- Bo gargqgdo wo yeobgdq Bgo39gdocmb Lodmaseemgdab BogGnor. ogorranse, mobagengonal bobgmdBagman g8gGgomBsB sMbymab mmndgroergh-copde3- MaGorger MoMgdgengdoow godogMornsbgdgera bLedsbabe Iinb\godgdn, bmene abeesdnb bybgmdSagegdSn abesddIs BEgmaFing IMnbyo3or es BMBsdbor bo- gown Labgg8o Rodmsyoennds. Lodmascemgdab. gansba ImmaGoggho gygee- GYAN’ JyJBoa ImenaGoaggGo oegqdo GgbMngnbs’ Eo Leygoom’gin bysd0~ emaFimdab ~odyomMgdal qSymab byenb. Labmasemgonb BogGan SaGgdsingace Bgndemgds gobyansieagh ImmoGo- BIH O~gSOS QO CaNMgdyengdsow gMons6 bab}q9s. 8g%9 Bgbodengdgeos ob BgIm@s6—g aymb orogh Smbggyern, GmgamMgy Imenergdnb. wosbyMagob Agagermds 9, s8eagGae, beiynsergHn JmMEGMmeab guyb{gosbsg sbMgergd- 2g). agdyengdpdn geonGsMgero Rag|Isbs, MmaeMgdogso: IreonGojiy- Go Qd LobbgcaMie crawgtigdn, BoogMimdnl SggMgdn, SSsndgermdgenjdn 36 AgGoOggd, B6oIZogermg{Gaq Agadenjds wobgommgh doboo cond yerg- BqBL. Labgenabyygenm genngsd, Bgbsdeams, ImeyaGogghn arwggdn mImBayo- ab Agbsgoggderoeq godmayyGmb Qo. Qo8atabInegds ow~gmermgnrgh Isbo3y- magnon gbnor Bpdeyge@mb. sbgor M08 dad sBzoMow begdmee a8 gyn ns BydorbgggoBo, HmIe~rgdog “Mgagnsergys” aggmermgagab gab jogograby6, gordgany Ba gabqM goMBsGnsBo ca boddmow ag3aMBo. mbingg Bgderbgggodo go gnseragi 6 ImemaGaggtn “bondgem” IMBsdbn — Bgombseney-bengod- | eanbGgHin Qo BoM {bab gjer-emgBobigGo — I9GmbmBQs ImenngGayegh SoegMy- Bob] ws, Maboggoriggeras, yggero Lergnoerg nbbGoGaS By: bgeggojdo%q, IIMB], goGomengdsbg, Sn~nsdy go 9.3. baBobssmdmgam sBgdn cs Apbgtexjergd|do, HoMoeree, (sq byMab jdandeoqdomgdmes 26 aortignSqomes. BmangMncs IBsoggdon, aggminmgaymn IsErIgera(gnol ame cosbgqSoce | GMMBS’ yggers Lo Bmgo@mgas9a gbgwmgdom. odob Boorgerboymeyse:godmrggr | BmQs BomMqbabG yero IAB s8bon; MmBgenbo(y AmIcqqgg6m GsGaerBo gsbgnbaesgar | QS GeBerob owbbIs@9y, GUMBO’ goIoGoabGgS badmascemgaqd3o BaMoGgbowe ab aeggdo go6aaqb, MmI~gSng gymbmAngaMiow godoGmbydyy- / ra gemabab bsdbabyHSns. Ho aGab aggmeamaos? + ab Bag6o, qBoMggergh ymganobs, Smaangaggh owgmermgnsons ygerggoo wo B69 ~ n~@AMErmgnnl By6ydnb aboernkdn. sdsbons wojogdoMgo-yern o—Mggo, Gmaneg Bab, dorinosQoe 03 gognQ06 AmAonbsegmdb, end ongdey “owger-6 Smerabaginin ogmmnmgogéo camanabs” ae “orggmenmangae” Brink sBseo gogdarin sMbydmBb, ggerggab agoerbsdGnbnor obaba bagBome godbbgoggogaro bogbgBao. “orgeevimgoab” ApLGsgers grbzMgGaeqo Godob ImerngGaggGo sbHmgbg8ob gr6boergsb 608- Bagh, GmAgernts, asbbbgagmgds, gadgoo, SmeenagyGo Bggbog@goabga6 96 SeennGa349%. Qaerebganbass. ImennGogwGo oggmermganb ggera3° ao- cmabbamadbs. sbmgbjBob 28 yagamtanb pGgdob, Gemabs wo IoIg6geye- Bob aboernBh; Bgdegggn goerbgab Sbgsgh yoorgqdBq Ssbqbab dagdabs: ImeraGo~ BIH acegoon Qs oMa'gagEGo Amgen ghramacramagdn “g6Qo gerabogyognm QQdMEGL MegmMHy a~gmanmgngdo? Bogsenowea, godooogabygergdgcrs arggmenmgns ong BRogggeya, dgBdomngos ony Bgq@orn wo 9. B.?, sbogg, oGab ong amid JmBbyMgoGo8n Qo GogamBsern°bIo o~gmermangdo o8939 geaj3r Bemamtnasy modgmoeradJa ge bmgasmabIo? Ageneig BbMng, “owgmenmansns” sgergge EMEA gH. sdMmghyBob o- bab oGoenn db, bbgowabbgo awegmenmangtin GMsan(ganb Soa 08 GHsQog0- gdab BogMgg BamdemJd6omr negggdob, eengGMnbgdnbo «eo agmeagdnb Bgbbog- ensb GoBGogb. Iogorynaoe, Mab’ ggqgo6qo endpMomads ongabygengerb AgbobyB? mgm ayogg6 sGorigab—gdo qhabgerdSagrm bosmgscmgdab ocQgab? MoGHmd.ngern~eBy6 qoBabgdo Sridmmrabs co mab bobsMageane? Bogesd abgena “BnbasMbmBGnga” bagombgab gobooboera dda sgEroen” cmas SmimaGogg%n sBmg6gdob 08.%Gasab” gsGbaarge, mBgenbsg ggbgsom ggg gaMgar Bragdjmo aggmermgngdnb odsbobooagbger_oceqgebs ge cQmgMobgab gobgnboerogcogar ggdomangab waggndrrggar, od Imbas ocggr 2009 38 gmomdgnmagdab gagMonsbyo aggrarmgnsas goannas. 3e03 syqtion B6nBgGgayegebs, gogoMsgoma, Msb agadergge sbgar goSgamnbor Goo? Hs Bondengds BggnSyroy Bogseenoe, eondgrraeqaB8nb, beygnseoBsob, GQboGoBInbs «wo qoBoBsab Agbobgd, ong door acggmenmangdoe gersboyyago~ ab Imgabrogion? “ agggmermanab (3692930 Bomggenn 3Mimdengde oregmermannk dxyxGgdnb gobboargnb abobg ob aeinb, md 26 abgdMBb’-08 GgAnGnb Modegbadg wowaghneyo 96 BgowbLdgdab bogynd- ggenp Bomgdaceo weAGoBnGNS. obZBMBb Borer syongMabs6 obooedregan Ragaboyngdn. egg dogeagers6nb (1995) go6mBgdnm, “oegmagmans beagns- emt BggbogMgdsos Boggy LobggBo8 yggeno%y Segbgereggero (|69B9S": G7 GS Bre} 3G% GBTIOGL ory godergBgggns sbgm MBS Qo Adorn Gabor Aragamdo. oBsb ean Gogo sJgb. Borgqer Hing Bo, HoBregbmog ogmenmgnab gam G599 agMMnabs co IMaJGagob gogJoHb aqnaeAgBb, gh BYIob Goer AmnaBg6ls BGs daorrgdo Smolsgbngdyero qomMgho~y 8gogq QgBBqB0b seobgom- Bobs Smenagyogsdo aggoc Fimaabs ~d, Ja doting, IABaALgdbo wo aymMa- 8b, brnggen Agentig Bb6ng, BoSySnoerq% gbmgMgBab 96 SmernGogg® Jang’ BmcAnl yonghnBodstagdab Bgboby®. grey Gogo, Bygderasgeros ow—ger cago’ 6gdnb aobyg6gdo SmarnGogin owggmermansas Bmeab aohagogero Bradenmabs_o6. cxmorgOob Bagegn eagabo sebgamBab B6daee%g GyMEbo “oweg-Aybogoren 7 memmans” ImeaGoggrin nomen’ Fimeb sbrgmp@a, GmJnB3g organs 06 BAB adler ghomBeamdgdab gMngyngnb o6 gdmdnb Iga6oBn aym. domenee By- migg begga Sgmmg SabggaFa wanbymgo gorome orgmarngon’ gar ggq- geeBomoeg BynGamegtin wo sAzomaw mBngdahn jmbyggqqwgo, 8g40d "jos6- bamgds oegmermann’ begnsergtn Fmeabs Qo ImerngagyGo B6nSgEgremdab, otagenng Bob Bp8conasry atdgemondmms,an Gmangtan 08 Go SgegeemBacgo- En, Fmd grrong orgmermgnab Boo8 gMicabyh: SmmaGaggtn ABIL babs gdo. JBomadoSy meingGorigd gern SmegnGagn® argoow babggdo. Borionggern gerebob awggen. smb zAgGigaro bmgosergtn yarsbob o6 gainqab dbrrgerdbgceggcemds. ImepnGaga% owaggdn, GmBeagang gepobmBeing o6 begosery abGgegr bgdb goBobobagtgab o6 godmbaSogb. © neggdn, Mmamgdng gdbdergoSomigd yer 96 RogMiger gp6gd%e BGmo%/yound agomBgaSgdab ogMggerodb. © aggdq, FmAeagdoGg aBrongnah gomsggace bmgnsee gh gmbGadbh 9 oer9g- gdb eo ymengd Goan sgagorergdob yrdomab Fade Bmab. © Seageagazeimn LabGglob 46 Magadob engangnBagoab 8oB6aa mao gooee-y- Mog bob{GoMpd-ger gow ghomamamds. © yengegabamagggeno ImeraGogahin comsGMnbs, MmAgenary ogbacegab AnBrr- Smacnsb PoBdoraGgdo¥p. © SeneanG 77% ago ddLGAIIS Eo Qo ToAMQbo~ bob}gI-qe%n Bygds. graggeanggb Snighg@ogow, 93° GyS8nGnb SsMdmIogermas' Goorgenns: baGyge Hre_Marmans bagMsbggon’ Mggmengyndd wMmb godmngmés G6 e_bGo 9 GMgbn8 (1754-1836), Loyang yo ab Sorggeraw 1796 Ege godmaygogb. 29 GMgbabsengobs iddologio Ga Bags" sboey “Sg(sGagMgdsb ocegams Bybsbgd”, LaSygoboSygr, orgo-meimans’s. gs6dsboarmgdemBnbongab wadsbabosag- Sgegn HogombserabSigein goGoggdo, Bab: b8o8q0, md Bpbadengdgera ay HEAICw' BoMImBagermanb mangdGyGn obb6s; cos ogbomgdcea, Amd gb sbsera BysBrighigds a8sgq LESGqbb wand ;gnMgdQs; Amamtng GGs@agoyer 8g3- Bagtgdgdb, Asgocencm, Samegmgnab 36 Bmmaegmgoab, Idmbgo. 9 ®Mgbo go- 2893 J|Mm eels Incgnmmas:. 330 Yggero gaerdge awmggs’ gayorgda, ocegm= camgas badmenmm. IgybagMndso sn~mmgmrs Bros gisbra.|B54%09, 08 SBomaRQoaEo Imapmmnbnb Inxybjwsxs@, GyGInGob Iorignerow GoIg6qerer- dob Gab BpaamdeQrenbrger godmygogao%q Goa Bgbyeemgabn gagengba oA 8m- ‘abragbns. Borrgotin BmaraGo jain G_SoGnb baboo' awegmenmgaod FoAOOgogero aoaMiggaegdo bacnaggb yorey Bom glob: Irimgdnmgs6 aagdb: rBgbgermgobE- Pow LBmbigeg BM gWabs ws Borglabs Ima Beimgogor Ideogg5m osmBgdab 28 GaFANGEr wWInBBIMgbgBn sobbGBo ob ImIgmarimads, menawy agger- eemans owbsdgaitigg bmygnsergh Qs ImaagGaginh obMimghyBo8o bor%ggad- EM’: cos Bonbys, BGAgEgenmds, Himgebo(g 03 sEgdob Bargin sbaggdmas, doce Sp jabbbgagmgdo 8 Bo Igogermanbsgo6, Amgerbsig Bob ImeaGageghn v68B amamngGaygto ormegmarmgagdn BSB Ans6yMg6.[BomYbIo-gh GgMInGn gobo sEMgyca Bsdmmdab bsmoy%Bo ggMdsbaycen oegraermgoe (The German Ideology, [1846] 1970) godmaygbs, Mim gerng ao6qyrigey enbodms dg gPrnehinb ofagce- Lans6 (1820-95) grionoee wabighs. 98 Go3mmI3 yagemadg gorgow Bobb, mgr gh8ab Bomgbb omgmegmgos: Bdsmnggenn jerabab aceggdo yggere gdmgeSn SoMdomanggero g~ggdno, 49.0. genabo, MmAgenng bodmgagmgdob Woraggera Gagrnoergea do~ co, ABogQMinxgcro~e BaMddoringgern obSaeradSwoerga doensi3o>. grmobo, HmBgnnb bymrosgss dSgMinoerigtn Sodmgdob LoBgoergdgoo, ABdg~Miengerse Leyenng® Itmergdgnaboly ogmGGMmegab, obg: md, ofgrQo6 godmAgn69%g, Drgowoe Md gaggoo, nBoorn ngggdn, gobs bymagtin Bomdmgdnb bs jdatnbo LoBgaengdgdn os odgb, Bob gdeeABa~ ceads. (Marx and Engels, 1970, ag. 64) arggmenmanab Boigbabgger ymBggguarr Modmeg6o89 b3gga6der’ BoBs60 oggl. se06 geen, ow@gmarmgns omgbosbs Qo BnbGagogogoob Byghgds; ob Ladgariob Bgbobgd yoor’d 6 Jg~@oem Bgbgeomergdab oyoorndgab, GmAgerboy go agmbo Imagosbgdaa “yorrd/Ag~Qom argnordgg6g9b” qSmaegdb. Bsmgbo oceg- enemmgnsh sng nzaer S6I39E AygEqBQo, MmAerab Aodsbi3 Bgrmcesy in Aob- Bogagogoab Iimggbabsagab gorigols abyaal Laggan owggav ab Bygbog- Bacanb Maby Io Bobnbaeog~@d, MoQZv6 Log nerOoyIEIME Bro dMgdgerse@ Bo- SB5QS mbSmeFanbs gs Lsdmao~mgab ByImg8gegab Mimgrab SomderbsAg- Boe. odceg69e2, 08 BrgEgermdabsagnb, MmAgerbog domfio' s8 GyMIn6Io cogdb, go@sdBygaSos smHGBMavGo owymeymanobs Qo IggbogMgosb_Bncab, boyoedghs coo dyBBornggdob ImMablagmMgg, agaMEMZOs yxgIOMIN2 geese Lemding bab@gdsbows6: domgoob MBIj5r, LoyserBg», MmBgenag agmarmgos- Bo pBsergds, ob gobo3InMmdgdb, Gm aggmaymgns badmgogmgdnb andsen BBoringgena. gensbob nBGgMghgdbo Qo. SgMbIgdHgob. sbobsgh.. Bomorgger - geal 0% byMb, bog gootn ogo disagMgeroe smascimb, abggg, Gmamg AmBornbgdqjenns, PogMigcon genoa AoggMgcrow’ Bpotngmb. s8ago%ow, grgobmdringn babggds omgwoyntios Somammagonennfgb GBgdo BoMgb8s camera abscurab babaa Sgdrngsbs, Hoy mBngdGagon gomomgdae 06 agocran o6s- beg ByBMApSgdyen: godmbabyjengdsb. GaBGogh. eendqMacrnBIo, mdger0g abgn gangdgah omBgMb, Mmiergdoag Sdmarmme Bgdergeger6n «Vo sngo- eaggoMgd-yerin Bgodengds boMagdermBQb6, AmamMmy Loymggranm geca Sadmbamgaganar, BgvsdsIabse@, o~gmermgan’ gerabagzymo Bogocnoowna. Aqbsd gis, owAMermans damoygenjdob ardmbymengdoo. 08 BnbsomIggarr Boow ogoMgou, Fmdegaborg gergdsgdo goInGomaBdn ygqeys bbgo gersvmnd- Ginga bodmascempdab Abgsgbs, awgmemans BnBriongerns, gdb3enegeGorgr enn SeimengGornaGab Fa6sBq Bponm3mb bagqowsin gdoseeyaooGmemanb odo, Gone bogygdgger’ yogMpdb qoubabmee gmabmdringo domroyg- eqgdab vols frgeceean>, bobodiggnengdn, Amagdgenn Sgrinmmnb “Bor OI” HQN_IdL Bomdmomgqsh. sdmamb, dorgbo agegmermanab ga6obaerog- 5 Mengmnyy Mmgdna Imgengbob. ab omer agebeag GebG96L, babsd InboAgbogoeo 9 BoctmBirbo geqsbrBeingo bobgsl> ootbgbgBb. aimanggarinagy Bor foo- bagg brSygganm — godoGoeo Barb “bodstab dnbrigemab", gsboBbqergdo9 oo gmabmdmngo baBmgocemgdnb sbocra. gemBab RodmysernBgds, oMs9ge — 8s GqMnsergh qGobygermagddy smengddowgtin bogqorrgdnk BpdmeagBo jeo- Lmdciaga yasbabBriimdab bogmome goxgdgds. oIggomow, IMmengGoins- Gob aBGgMghgo Borgern bLodmgscmgdnb oGGyMgbgab. gdnbgggo. Imgergeo, Iimeng Goring Go of bogamiongdb ogmanmansh, Hscgs6 ab grrosegtion 3ero- baa, imBgerbayg aenigdngdq of bgnrmagdo. AsMYbobaw ByleegndAs crsmdgB8o oragmermanabsrdn, gam6B, qyeo RAD HBG gAga godmodyersgGqb, goog ogo Bor {L8o. sab Bayo 8603- gOgerengobSoerse@ ab99, Hed Bomgbab oogwogMpyeQo Snbsb6oIgGygger9- Bo goInGoeraBInb Sgcenb Bybabgd ghormd mIGdabsyyen gadecego; 9896 doe goabgow BmAiggin asmdgdb Bo gowybb6, Jagan yamowmgds owegmergo- 39 Angdomonn FmgmMmys grorgho osha, Amgenag GomImgdn’s goso~ Goerabsytn GmmBab mPgggae ImgéneymBab bLGAb. orgdgo, 08 GpIb, Go IgEgermBnb engoembsdminbnan, bogMd6mBo GgerrergoqIrvy gd6oyo@s. yg0- cnsidy baygoramngde abso, md axgmarmgns yaners gemabob Bobaboaagderoy gabnbagngdmes. emgnGn crdgab Bag6Bo Mo gojgormen? ([1902] 1988) 3emengGo~ FnsGab n@ggdb o@ByMies GmamMg. “begaserabGy oggmermgnss”, 6 “AsridbabSyer ac~gmermgoss” — sbgan godmorJagan Bomqub edbyMereroe BorghgaBdmced. engSaGnbs cs Igmgg bog_Gob BorgbalyBor -g8ggomanb Bg- gabgdno, omgenmans gb sMgGqano beignoeegtn gemabobongab esdobobas- epdgen ncgggdb seb B6sgW@s, aceggdb, Hmaeagdnvy dab aBGgMgvgBb Babs 3er96- Bp oyg6HBes, Bogbgmsgoe gersbmdmngn BrgmBarigmdnbs. Inygbg@ogore o8o- bo, Bend, yggero Logs: gensbab aba oghow, IMmangGotnsGb, abggg mang BaMygoBoob, gomaggrgma argmenmgns sfgb, 38 GgSINL qomymgoon org WodsAQomgdgend ynbrBsigagdn Raber gnengdsero Ifrm6Qo. agogmanmans aoe _BaRTObbImBmo oyGompBam boysedpbo wo InbGngojogarb, omar 2q3609- | Mgdob ydomnbdarcgdergs; “AggGagMgen Leygnsegab4n” (BorqboBI) 3eer~ le emg Gatigens Hegmenmann’ gmMBse agbs omnstgdyern. Baigég@2g9@ o8nbs, Fe awggmermacnk mgbo6abygenn ymbygaar oMbgdoowe ByoGMrooryy%o aye, eaqbo8b gorgom ghdmegs, Mo Gereed o8o8mBmo, orggrieprgns jod0Gs- leonbGuytn Lob@gdab BgSsMRig6gdo Bo. epgSGb oBFine, “Syggoedoyero ggr emenengank” Boge sdmBgdqenn IimengSsmnaGo gersbridengo (SmBagagdob Rodmysesndgdsls odmingowgdcrawy gymabriggh Iydengdws. odnGerd eegGoGn Bowjononjdegs “sgobasMernena” doMABanb sygamgdeomdsdg, Medgera3 bsor- 980 Poqeggdmmms SyBso Bsbgdb Barn aggeeggaryma ImBg6yorerab ga6- bemigngengdob 3 body. TRISH OM TpgEQGsom, amPMamgond dMJooSgera agymmnad Beard gabgooomgdsh s6mGom g_MoB8ob badger ong QogygegBoMgdor. gHoTIob ([1935] 1971) oBeinen, godoGoenabSxyMio jerabmingo babGgdo qaMoryneg yor BobBebin g3mBmOnjq% Qo meaGaygh doemorggergdsh yo oh gdysmgdo, SH4989%, BASTBbs 39 BHIMB SIO, — Saygyodorger owgoo -o agmenaa “3p gg8eBoo”. 3ggg8enGos emaggMmasb o6 SoGmbmdob Gn Bagh, awgmenegnry~10 dmapagazyGn oregrrenmgngda Go Igag8mbook GoI:6gemBa0 ab godmbaGogh IgSygodogero owggdab Iob8gq38o, gengaereamoy® Sgdygaeradols Qo boarby gamegGoBo. amodIIb ABsoga- Boor, SeaMggoboger 3qgg8mbrabas6 odoMab3nrHgdo dbmeome Imeagogg Qo AGMA DCI Qrbgp, aby begnaeabGgy Ib yn3gd%y, mamgo-y- BQVLS (d- agMMngddy wsdyomgdgjero AmBnbssmdegag “SHimengGomejero Igqgdebab” Kodmyaerady3aor ong Boodgngds. goodGo~addab qooMb, Amdgerg exgargodgeman’. Boga6ner bAoery- Gedob BoBogsb gegeabbImab, grbbogyamgoyjero yeSocegdon LBogenmBao BRB IQAGBAL bLymeary — qBomMaBghow. gqdobigenn GomImImBob. bymdoe- ghobGors gaaqgo, GmIgea GagabG Mo gqMI6angeé’ godgggarb Boece 089 Go gob BggMongd ger BGBIVI 993goWMAVd. 93. RaaGab Loymgg~mesme G6mr- Sogn Bago 3yhOyMB B55 319°bq (ab. ag: 155) naga’ B8imIIo greg obomdorng- Sna6o o~@odoobo (Marcuse, One Dimensional Man; 1964) 98830 393b, m3 gs6gaostg- Sqeeds aGergh@Morgedo Lodmgscqmgdod Laggan owgmermganb yBseob. — stom’ sBmghdo Qo 9% Hmb mImBa goin Bgbgeremgdgdnb gsdebs@gob sngengds — datinane godmgengbow “Gm@oarnGomigenmds” @oowganbs. yommd Imarbegbongdgdab BgJAoorw. Qs osdnabons bd. GmAbIomgderg- Bow gorodigggner sbs8geMimgg bo dmascmgogab doengdor, boymggerasm go “godsbsw@ayMgdgara” Loghgob gogMiggergdab gboor gMingagabdnb 3omoo- Dqdo Imabeabmb. Bo jy Inbg~@gnor, modgMaergMo godaGoero bob .99jo- Go pPGybomgdemdary go MyIMghoger AnBabb gdbobyegds, Gowmgss sro onsgabsggemnn goiggene-gadmeggerabs @o adsorb Bosdgconergdab Bgf86oo Boqogh, ory Ho IbBGIdgQab omBggh aw—egmenmanrya wady Boggs eo.owgr- eamanrgia 3mbGGmero. FF ngsenngenn daguab§o ea bmgnseagMa agmMasogmbo. Esdseo Gobgab babyer~ 5) ABagn Bebgexab gogo, aro88n bergnocgobSegh IAgavBn 1913 yerls Bggnego, 1921 | J] Bogals go sbonagg Radmyserndgo.genn nGoank ymAgbobSyr%o IoMBonb ygSyMocrg- | Fn BgngsGn gsbos. 1924 Baerb dob agoernak Somensdg6Gob Sggmore ofgg05, Bg~ 98 1926 Bgeab Agbmarnbnd gaadaga8es. 49903 boymgbeeab gsrfgbnmo Bexgdn Gabg8o googoro. 1929-1935 Bexgd3n wabyMoce gnbab 86569783 (Prison Notebooks) (Gramsci, 1971), Ba8Bad Lyyo~eo, meamemAbygero BargboBAnb Groen oggg6Go g3mdmInzy 96 3o- BaMnserIgh godGmeMgddq gowogGo6o. ob arymeygo “Ayging*gero” wpSgyMdIaba- Bab BBNbIagm qmMBsb eo Iggqdmbnab ogmmonb Ssdsbq Imennagyen ws 06g madSipoergtin Sideenab AaBgogermBab yodmgggangs. GbmgMgdab Sereom@rep gon cxgbnbabGoe we MagmenggnmEgMoe cots. Fggmerygan’ awggdabs~do BobAs gobbaggarigdzyjordo gMogyergdod wo “Egdab mIGa8o BEES” aod Go aborn Bg- Boryybgb mdtamBabayy abnoto.Agbogomnn th aggmgmgcal sMadsm_babSgera ymBygqGoob ymEbGMgatigdab gor ghion a@tigigera Agregermds gyjagbab ggMdobjer Legamanma, goer B63o- 8b (1893-1947). Barighab s6 ogmb, dsb3g dnsh6@s, md s~msdnsbas a~ggon Boor Lenignsengh ZoMgder-3oMmBgBSo yorrodQqoo, 394%, BorAbobogo6 go6- Lbgogadne, ago abEmagees, aggmemans Gabo bagaGogMa dggGgdvGgdovo- 08 gogongabiygengdnbs. frogob BsdMmdda omAmermBN® Od +GMso (Mannha- im, Ideology and Utopia, [1929] 1960) As63snd0 a~gmeemgngdls amBgMiao mgmt oBMimgogob babGgIgdb, GmIegd0g ymByMoGyero Lergoawgma Symdab RQIEGab PobabyMgQda26 Ea MmBeagdagy Gomame grdmbsGogg6 Garinggern o6 BodoGmbpdyjenn RaWGIob o6GyMgbgBb. Igme%g Boeing, qGe3ngo SmBogenabs aggomapdxyjevn go6bsbngMgdgoo, GmAegdag hogMgeno o6 wadgg8egdseg- Bye RBT|I0rb o&GgMighgdnb gabghrigen bodbsbysBo yma Howoajzoery Lengoomnagt (ggemnengdgdb aremabdmdb/ 236 gMinds6ganbog06 godng6s obggq aggmamgoal “ymb3MgGgaro” go “EmGsergGo” goggogdo. “ymbsMgG geo” arggmarmgngdn gobbogqarmgdgqera oSeago~gdab, xayqgdob 06 IomMgagdab FABSIL Qo gQQds, “BIergMo” a~egmanmgagdo go beagoserrgtin gerobobs, LoBmgo~gmgdob 96 Lyay abOmdGargma’ Igtinmeab Ioger Weltanschauung-, 26g “Abemgcedbgrmggemdab” Imagogb. 08 agorsbsSmabnar, BmAbaBo, emodg- Hoenighin ysInGsqnoIn Qo abersdghn GgSossjGGomndBdo “Gmgsergs” ngegmarmaagase@ Igndengds Paomgomrmb. wo Bon6,3, Bo63a09b-Inah6eQo, md yggere oRImEeIMgZOyM babGyd, qOmIoaas Raagenan, ZodMgeagdyen-Qods- baby gdygenno,: MIm—QgZeb cmnormg.yera domgr6o begnserigtin FgseqmBab 6a60- mrmBting Wo QAM MIE bozos FGoMghgddy wodysmpdiner byregob BIMSGODMAL. oryAG0, OBSbG oImaqs, Hed mangd&yMo dyBdomnGgdob erg Bob dgmpemmdody meemeq worn of sym gorjgoo. B63oa¥ab: Inbg~gan, mdagd&ghmdo, 330440 8am, bo zMdsere “Le gosergMow onsgobyygqocna a6- Bang g6gonbs”, abSgergdGwgoeraw yarobabs, Mm¥gmory ghowoeg%ons, goby Agaderns wabynIeaboMgdjeen’ Qo AovyggMdmgdgena ggeeggo oBom8rmb, | Ramgeb bs gqestin ggmbménggtin abBgMgbg30 9% goohbns. Am~gmemagnn’ bqeab Bd~egmd gabgrorsmgdodq MBs ygoma ~oo8R6ns mBasdmnb Ighamgso BasdmImBowds GmGoeraGoriged oJGoGor genBs Myyo97385 wo XX b-ob 50-60-nabn Smgdab ago mab orgs eadadgqends nmgmenmangtde gosbbdmgdg8%. babgernomdm, madgMsera og neg Gagmbgdo GoBabGqto aGoeronb, bagabSghn gg@Ia6onbs ws bGseo~ BabGeaMia Gegdganb Mggngb obobnoagdQb> mamma BWorarggermn’ ab- GMMog_ms~e obae'mo gs6bsgqamgoqeroe ShoggMger LabSgdgdb; Sommshy6- 266 Mens, Mmdgenbars “mea(goseriga” aeogmanmangdo Ordodmdmeby6 Hm- BmMZ ~WpBSGgdbs ~Qo yMinGagoBdob Bboayegsdo, aby mMgaboBpdqero 1 BeaBommgdal 39638 321393580. bregma. gs6bbgagqdqemo ImBacgagdab 9gGen- gd, obgagdo, mamas sMna6 yotge Im3g%o (1902-94), Bobo oMgbQGo (1906-75), 9. ep. GgmIME Qo IgMBoMe gPingn, obg99 “ocegmermanal sebab- ugeeab” engentgGajebgdo, mdmgabsry Agi! sgn gabgoboesgo,, GgMdo6 Hocggmmnmana” Bodgogmmmanb wagoSteagdadeg SngamGy6, dob dongar 3ogo- MRAAIIO YsTaBILs Qs ymdyoBIb sbabjeng3obgo. skgcno Ia BgoqemBa,12 Smapago igo aregrenmgngso ARIMERM|Agsn SBmghgdab “BaggGoaro” bobSyGqas, Gerdengdoy sgVoMHo- N39]. ImEmImenaals SagGgobona ImBoGoomI~ggg owgeas Qo ABI BpBWyboMgdeymdsby gow odmab, sBagoriow, ogmermgogdo “bogher Sgr cangngdns”; 850 “gsgradnerna6gdab” Sqbqs odgb wa Bamdmomgg6b beygs- ho. grbSGmerab aL G%g875GHq3b, Gag geyggrymeb drefineegdabs <2o (Wad ggteegdergdab. 08 ;inGgMn-gdom, yggers ImemaGoggrin AABdbo er Od O~|MEMANs. Bogomonse, ENd_MaendJn, Mmdmab sdebogomo Io6- GoIgdo ordgobiggengdabswdn MIS garg qengds, BpsBybomgdenmda wa Ato pong Mmgbgdas, oBtimgbydnb “qa” LabGgdob Gaagegn dogamaans (3m3g%0, 1945). sbgga: BgbsdergSgees owegmarmgnn’ baBbemerngow grbbyMgaGorgero Gbadob Cawag6aG. Ibo Byatin adbGModS gen IMinbgndms qo goeymbegyno- ao Andorian bobatdenngn gmbbyMgogogern qoemBemdss, Amagmay Mogorr- Boma bAnbs (eo SimaMighabswedn byp3agatn edmgnwpdjengqangoé Amaen- Borigmab. sbgan bgegom, bodyatin qbobMrgaome orgerd Qo a@odoobab gm- Egdnboorgab onargaob dargSg~mageras. 08 Indomorgengdol ygnero%o agacrbo- Babe osbsdgormmgg BoMdmdowmagsgere SMngsbyen0 Imenogagayso. goereber- gqmbo, Boagen ony gBmorne (1901-90). cnsgob Bog6Bo, ogamboennBdo dmanngago (Oakeshott, Rationalism in Politics, 1962), xy z8man sdmBb: “Imeagagin% 9JGory- ids sppcenad gegndbo (1842-1910) ee amb eayo (1859-1952), SmogdoGobdo agobBogernb, Fmd ABB_Hsas Bo BgEgemanbs «we Imgagognob Bpgobydo ddan Shadogwend Byer 80800 Gos Smbegb: ovaj ceAgaBn gan’ Aabgrognar, Imeagozob IogdaGyjero bGo- aaa sSNGAMEDMAA-AMS, Ban gongnggds DIFIAB Iam mImMGBsGoBIns6 9% Booderg- Bo. IogdoGoBIn Ggerrergdbawdo qiebace admgncegejergesh arerabamab; ogo apotymab Fognjacegs HggmMsgdbo co Figgmeragerd, HmgmAG gerade ByaBo- gobs Boggenam@ Bobs, ofGog% woMigayeeotpdsbo go, bogoMogeme, aIMCVIEIIA Bramamgbbsry “ygoAb AborA.Apbogoara 13. goMmoddGnb Bgrgermagdb ggydigds. grata sboene Igdormgegq6y mdmomBnb qa bmd a~gmanma natin ImeonGogob gogregbob Jgg8 Imgdgammby, gm6bye- goGeneg3n, ongg8mab ong oggvgbbgdne, “GMa yorBrabG.y% Smaiosb” Stgg00696, CimIgeng owgmermgnss qomyme, SHogdohoBab gdbAmdo eo aodmacorngdabs wo abGentnab sednabigen dgggnb ygaeze%y baba etingb- GMs babogb. TIgdGs, 1960-nsb Beaganwss Imymmgd gern, SMooGNDo bmyroegmo Qo SmenNgGayqhin sbocedtoab Smarbmgigdab Bgbadsnbow, yMAnG “owgeere- nab” babggganad Baba -gqtie Gorham goghggergds grbsInMimds. agra 3nd Ban GMa wo mngdGy% GHgBHE od ;QnMee, Bab RoBmbgomres ab SmernGazaHo WoGgorings, FmAgeray Snbso AngSgrgdmmo. obg, ogocra- 9@Q, 89% G6 byeangeg%n (1976) ~gmermgnsd gobdomBagh FmgmMyg “ocgo- and bab@gdsb, Fmdmab bsBgompdnorng omsdnabgdn syorrndgdg6, bLENs6 ceo sbodgqorgdg6 mmgsGnBjSqgeon bmgnscrgein J8gw@gdab InB6gdbs wo beBgoerg- gab, begengtions, Mob jgbs0 SnBsorgera abgan gAg~gdo ~ dmagdgega beign- ocmgtin Bymaab BybomPeqgdab, goydemghgdobs, ommeybgtinbs org byerobs- cnn BgGgdnbs396”. ofg@s6 grdmdconbarg, awgmermans Jeg~qosbg mAngsGo- Mgdwyeho SBmg6ydob babGgdos. oIggoen gabbodmgrind ByArgg ob omamos 3MGO 96 GAIA, PgTEoCingn o6 Bgmotn, eno 06 RogaBoma, godoongobygerg- Spero 06 Pog gMigasn — aragmenmans yggeraGaein Bgadengdo oymb. 38 bmgnomgmraggoogMaeen (Segond gFdsMnGo Mamgoyengoo obo, Hd ab gemabowyMna, Mow_o6 yggens “oBIL” Agndggdo Eagbomogerb: emnByMocrad- Absg we BorgbaBabsg, gmobyMgoGoBIy wo qoPoBsbog eo s-B. owgeeren- ganb BgaaGaig gbgdsa Bayona gn Boon Bxdompgnomdss:|Bomgbo enodyro~ AG | gmBb|MgoGoger ocqgqar aggmarmaagM’ gqmmagdqo, bmagm bogge as% ngggdb Aggbogtneae Innhog3@o; cgndgMoergdo ymIgEoVAs Qs go- BoBAL agmenmansa Msg Io goEnbnerogyb, BgMod emndgMomabab sbgoo] 3 engenos6; “Ssoengrane afiarosbnsote endghoqraBAb, BomqboBabs| 6 nm ene eet LoBoSrmgdgdo. ggdderg,, Imemaghagzitin: ogo aga’ nsgows6 Smigiengdnc 08 @yMAnbIs nBQgbs~ BgBIoengn Qo gooSrigsaq- | Bejenn baby Igndergds Song’, md yRagngygera boddagrmg beyernsy «Qs- | g9M|Ob. onggo: HSQMErmgns Bmeagobos abgorn’ GyMInGgdabs, AeacnMaygos: “ABAgHnarn Lolsyhgd0”, “Bbmaendogeggeamds”, “emdGein6s” ob “SmenngGoaggto Beeembmans”, gobs agsmandadigmBe 999, 30093 g99H30GME, Hed Bob b93xy~ dH Qd gobbszqowAgdwgera Bn Bgogmmas ofgb? 99 Abeing mem Logncrbl b- Bodagdmme aodmgymeca: Mo ndoriongdgdns aggmienmgnabs Qs ggBdamnggaob men’ Qo Gmamt Bgadengds n~egmagmans aymb domoggergdab gyemas? NEQMenMa|ns, JgTIaMaGJdo Eo dammoynyengos nregmanmaon’ Msndgagerin Smjerg 96 gto Snbs~@acegdedo Amdgggier go8- Bo Ggdo obyby3y q|Mm IgG gnorbgob GomdmFmdb. wo donby,.ob boboV4 Smepngagigo oregmapmgngso BBN WO SAGAENQdZEN sémbogemyn SyMBaaro nfBqdo. 09 Gago acegmerm- ano Bp8eogaSooioe oink goagdqen0: omgmarmans arggaas IgG-Gagergdoq Bymdeia babGgydos, AmIgerag boagdggenb ‘gab mrgsEnbgayer Imeragozg% J8nwgdeb, bigerge- anna, HS BaBsbb gabsbyyMgdo ab: ombySgenn Labgdnb o6 damroggerg- Bab ASomPryBydab, babgygerabs ong @odbmBab. oBeagbog, yggers o~—gm- eemans agmsgoBmal: (2) oMbgdgera BymBob Iggabydob, Bggzergdmng, “AoengerdbgreaggeemBnb” baba, (3) bobyggera EmBagennb Seager — “jogo bodmao~gmgdab” bragob, wo (3) azadabs arg Amamt Bgadengdo 28 "gH odbmMgagermgh Imerngasighio (sgeroergdo — mam dngo- 9m (3)-1996 (3)-AxQ9- ab ggobagns og mengnboeyyMns Qs ory BmgaGmMrgen —o 99 GyG80- Bab bmgnsenigh- Sgn BnBgbgemdobow6 beigey BpbododabmBoBo. cos Bonbyy, ab: nrgmanmgan’ qgbmagGnbs demangrion Bo Igogermge6 wa ~odababoo- agdge Go Baby ‘ng gnomagab.. gqMidme, Gsmdmskig6b;. md. acegmieemanab ImBenAI-gMmdo cogh;Magyargenn Qo EmMBsGogern vbMimg6gdab, Imeago- gxita agmmnnbs @s IodGayob SMow@agoyer bodmgMgdb Beeiob Agriygmdo- 295 ImdqoGsrigmdl. han baBygom, acegeemgos eGo Labab Lobagbb. 6a BmIMaL: gro dbrFing ogMomsbgdb goagdobo co gorrregdyergoob, bmevm Bg-| entag AbeAng ~ sbMengbgdobs ~wo ddawobsb. Bomggena bsbab baba oss, 264) goggdobo ed goemagdqenganb. BgHBydob- ons 039g SaMgdn amgrigmans sdgogmgobydb ga6bbgoggdob nBsa Intab, Gog “Mab” Qo. Hy “gHEQD AYMb”. AgrerMgngdnb epbsMnggogermas ndob En Bagh, ed ababn, bLabsBegrergB, Goerzger s@sdnsbydbs Qo R|agoee LonsgomBg6 Bao Ladmgommgdnb ggbJgombomgBob gMinggoM obBgergdG9- ommigh ggadeb eo, 3093 TSGM gHGMIE, bsdyorimb Bmgase bgmgeb. gb, I~ BOMOOdsE,- BgVbBoMgQdo a~gmenmannb abGgainmgdab So Iggerego6o, 969" Gob ebL633o, qBamabs, AmAgerny o@odnsbydab yebsGgGger ber gooeeg% gor geno “Bmansghgdab” gigamabbImdb. obgan egh3Gaggagena goggdo OMI- 89. BrdRQSKn HmgamMy sMbydgena beagnoengta ImBymBab Bgbosygober- nb, aby seGgSGoGorgena o6 ImIogorea boBmasemgdab. SyGgdob Bgbsbgd KmmBoGager 96 ghsMngygrga MBI_6s0 babGgloSo. sdegboe, amggeere- ano denagtin gdegorgtn: dgbgdaboo: ab a8gegdabs ~o InBgdab, ggercges6- Bymaabs es badgargnrol, IAT ILO wo gagA9d0b gsdmbsBgab bo Bgjoengdoo. 498cQ9689915 (0). 29 :(3) BMIGESNd. qongMowagogdomg’d:geros, “BodGo- Bo” agagmanmgagdSa goreoygeoy IaeMggneyas. ramgdgyengdgoon6”. Byer Boabs Qs UggGagMgonb Mandgageta djzagom godoggbo. 03 Abeing, yoMao agby- Ieee, arg a~gmenmangdh omo~gngdgdoe gobgnbarrogQam, Fmammy sdoby 239mg8b amdab g:96 crvgab Bng68o Ags6ogigero. Bggmenigsogdob LG Mgd- xy%e (The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1962). sbym BpIabgggsBo o~@gmermans Bgndengdo amgnggsor 08 IMnbyo3on, —mJGGabsow eo agmMinsow gHamdeea- BQ, MenBergdagy ABGIIIG D9eIG sgerggb Iinggbab LMaIs amg |Apbogomma 15 Bsdo aggbdotAgds. babsdggamgan gn gabab RoMfimb, Mmaegnb Iogboowy 3o- eqngagintin (gercgGob — ImeaGag.nta gobsgMbob g6nb — dagds SorQobsrg- mdb] dogsmaas@, ajomgdngn SmenGagyto SygongMgoobs Qs, sows IF Fin wBgahaw — ggmbm8nggh BgghogMgdo0w, obeogooyomobGyMo -s M30 MEaerabGyMn gatogegdn, qjRogme, mndgtoegmn SomdmIogemdnboo. oggmermgand FimgmMy rbGgmgdSgoergtn KoMBmb o6 ImmaGogighn gob 898959, obggg BoBggenmgabo, Mo—~geb_ab Bomdmakg6b Lommagh, mAma- 9G A~W{MeMaNd s@oTnDbyGn goagdnb LHg_IOaMntigdsb obegbb. bo gga ABI_GIOw NeEQmermanghmdnb «goMymenb Gybege gos (ISI Mego. Lbggdb bBamMag BybGoe nog Gmegnb RowgEnb asd g3aigbogo) oBac Bgndengdo og- bLEsa, Mimd LEmMmg@ of gmbggg_grro BImongadgdom, Fmergdy boByo- Fens gaboggdb bran’, Rggb ormgmermans geaddia%ere oomdgdo (gPnbomrag- Bo). gat goORgger, 96 se agnbros AggodREamen, Med bsBysrtimb .seagndgodcr abgob, Mimammagayg dob ofigb Bgg6gg agmengdnbs Qo’ gomayepdab Mnwg, £0 o8ab dabg~@gow gobrggQdar Bob (bodyotmb) S6oIgogemdob. Bgetig Lsbab bobgto, sbrimgbpdabs gs Jagenbob Gsdsg0, MimBgerng (3) 29'(g) ImAGEGO 3ogorhner godmnbsGgdo, oMoba3;engd Joo dgogenmgobno. o9o- Bq gaMommgdsh aBobgnergdm2 byeraxgto (1976) omgmermgonb, dobbogg G9MIOGPBbL org gabIomian, “_aGOrd|HBy” coo “MIgMoGorgen” combyqgdbq bo- DoFnbsb. |ySQosgsGg comBgy a~gmanmgngd ImerGaggh Qammbego~ Hdl Bgagb, Momgoh odbGMoJGeyer owmggqdbe ws agemMngdb ghydo. Haig Bygbgdo 28 arggmenmagngdob SboMmQoddgMgdb, Joon. godemggengggdo Bmageg® Bgdotiog- Bob Imgemgdymrowe Iyndengdo Imagohiggdmb. GYA0GL “ideologue” bIntacw yer6- IMIGIE oM|MemAnsons wayegnbg3gero o6 SmmMagdyjero Sorirasddgmgdnb obababasagders~e ny96996, orgdgo, aAMerMangtn GMoeogonb gobgons- 93930 Bgeracra aby BsGogggeger ImeroG3'Qh Gommbagymbgabsy Go- sadeggnn, Mmammgdng amoab seB enengo (ab. ag. 45), gem6 LGoyoAG Boero (a. 83-34) Qo Qo~Mnb Bagg (6.33. 108). mIgMs Goyer mbgdy yo owgrcam- | g0gd0 gQotiam Immogaggh ImdMamdaas YmMsb omgdb eo boerbab amdo- MADIGNaLS Qs domoyQergdabsorgab SmhdmensBo gMaonggdo. sbaon ogMbsbon aggmarmgos Bgodengds godmababrob dnBmegpdgBEo, ImenGogge GoGmeo- 3980, BoM Ganb G6rgQgqhGgdbs eo dosgMmdab ImeynGogzgh gg. ocege- | emaAngda marcy n—egq3Bg, Sbgagg Janm~adsddg ByesaBggGror eneingBGarg- Syega Ged aymb, Bogod BmgagMaa awgmermand, qoogme, go cmbydq gains drag, garg ~ AgmtAghy. dogomnasm, godnBso yrggmagab mag- CraGorgee Bo BEGb, g6ydIgor, LoJ8nb SmennGagsb, ‘qogsds bb. s6seigo'Go 30) BAHL IOMABI Bgenigg bog gGob BgoSleagdgob Imymengdgenn, IoBgoq- mgo6Enmoe, BySQodIGHG|M oF Qaermbergary cembgoyo BgImMfigdoerer 2d Bsnb,y, O~Qmenmangdb ImernGoggM Gorrmbegagdabsrgab wsdsbo~ boaagdgend Bzoqome Rodmyorrndgo gern YmMHIs Eo Bobogsbo gmblsobq609 d69 odgh; aban Bbmepme AgG-Gogerqdo~Qos MsGAodeaggMyers. gh odyorto DAMAIMBS GoGaermdeing ada BgeQqgano, Mma neogmernmangdn. sbrimgegoob BHIQSQeOW MabBjano babOgAgdn aMoo; Meagetg Bgbn, aboGo sqm BeyeQ- Bago (3g9eRgd9—QO A~gIOd LabOgIgdN9, HmMAeegdny bbgo ar~gmeamgngdon616 dmemagagigtin nmgmanmgngeo eaPongmong8geegdg6 Qo yGangMndmBoagergmdg6, Hy n~gmarmgorar go6- goorstghabag yBymdb bomb Qo abgan SoBMGaweera owgmarmangdn’ oc@en- GaBQBdsboy, matings Agmoerqto ymBbyMgoBoB8o, beagooegabGyn g98060%8N wo ymBbyMgoGogero GogambenaBIn. ynggena awgmaemans go6= bbgoggdace, 890g — QaIoGabIomgdiger GMaQagosos wo agomebsbenbow W3qdHMb9g yo Bgogsgh. omigorg oBgrvowe@ gHon wo odogq awgmermgonb ImBbrgow Bren’ sors gsiygerorgadmggers TEAM Gbshy Wo yooyatgdg> cna, gorgtg ~ InTnbomAcagag awgmermanson EmabMggaas6 jedoan, owao6 9099 EmPQMErmgnnl sgTIHng SyBgBob: Bygbgdo: Msb GnBGogb “ggBIor%ngo” Lengnomn 8a, “fg Bdoringa”, exnBghoernbOo ob “yg Boringa” o6r4oAn? Hegmenmaog® Gowgngnoow BagGoow ~o goMgn Indgnbom%g wogeb goxag Bair ooryeagal ab yorgGegdo, md Bobo bBomag gran |s ogngg Seman Gogatin GgMFIoGg ImbsSamgmab. obgor 5Jdg3b, Fmgmenggoo “orogobogye engdo”, “qoghen3oQos", “Lodatiorgnabmds” go “ooGsbEmemmds” 8mjado0g Aorggdo Boo BgbgcgergSgdnbaargnd casbsbsapdgao AOBgEgermBoo yg6g396. od Bageigdon IMimBergdab, MmAgerboy gore. d. ggnaynd (Galle, 1955- 6) abgorn babgenn denegdgBba: “ambgBaorg bageBoorn (ggdgB0”. gb sn’ G6g2g- Bo, Mendgenans Bpsbgdoy Smangdnge nBreg69E fMdoo, Mid Mong Inboeogd eg- gabrgoo'y Bgor6bdq35 Bogdergdgennd. 98 Being, owgramanad gBgdo, Mo endo 96299, “sMbgBaerse bo zodsams”, abggg, Angry bogs GyMANBQI, B96~ borngenn Babsmongd8o “agorbo%ornbgdo . .. Egbobyd”. cngdga, S8ya%es, HMI aegmermgan’ smonsbIndegggermdsbs. ge AQMMAmBo’ Beagotin sy6ros IfmBeeqgh. Bee sHbyBmacgqh Gnxbo, bogey oag- mmgnmgns, mdgennbg gobboygatgdom beonygobgdgeq SMnbyod%) gornb erddoa, 96 ogtig stabytamdgeoe GohEg gern agm*innl gerbosMgdno, bogg- as agandymgoemdsh yoMgogh 96, Bqbsdeoms, ImBoboamdeagag oggmern- gnsBo BorsnborJagdo. ae higdo eradyMacabdo cendgMseynDIog, o~yJo 7g~ Lggengdaboedn gMiong geegasdy gem oBygob? gothgds Lengnsera Gn bemgn- oem Bdog, domergmBabs Qs mAb Bowrggoergagab oxy gabognoeAgdh? dooger qgincegbab (Freaden, 1996) crs6sbJoe, 08 SmimdengAnb gomoSygadnd gran abs, sdebs goer (HpBq7oOS6 —azogBorgdaoy, owegramengnnb Inrigmermgon, go Bobo Qa LAGgdyMnb SomdmPgboo, LEmeMga abg, Fmammy mowbo oggxeab goBenoggdo a3 g9HsbmBb, MmAgeros LeIBomigy erm, bednbgdgeno, babOgysGm mansbo 9 9.8. yorggenn aggmanmgns, odggbo~, GAHGBMocyig%, SmAngeG9g9 9 | Bgmoggrogarn GHpdgdab BoyMpdabog6 Bpweagds, GmIgerowas6 qaengoer0g yggeob oMbgdmds seygneegogero 9 oFink, Moos agen 96 ~eJgPnbs 08 agmemannk BBaggaw gomoatimar Bogamomoe, bedborggerm bsdboeggr came QotAigds, BsbBo Engaris Qo gorbsgho Mendy 9% aymb, samy FaMderae barggbo AsbfoSpdnbs Qo BagMimgaermegs6o edergdab aby age Bae grab Bob yarigs bbb agMbsbyb. oBengnwgocro'Bdo, cogabeyyengee Qo aQodn- SBagto argomboennds, Bagsepacag, madyMomadIob sghBMoergy g6gsso seoggow Bgndangdo GogokGomen. gMorgMornb gsdmjergd> semJGMnbab eendg- Romig Bab yndgdb yosbga’ Jaq 94 maoygbgd’, 800’, ovg 08 Kaggh mn GBg8> gaders zencends, gb +4390 SboerO agMenMgeryMa Grenb GaMdergabab BobrBbgdgaon adgdo.Tere Aybogocn 17 ob aggyd6gd9 yrggmogg gb amgmagmganbo «Qo ggBBorngdob, Modagbo@d1y gobdoorengds gIsM_dS Boor 08 Bpbgaergdoo Van Azoqgoma 29 dBo;eAMQBCrIe Fadmysenndgd9B, o8ceq6a.gq bogggms, 04039 adboormng- Bs 98 Bpbywrxjengdgob mebag Booby Gogergd byBogdGgMb o6 GBs 8gGo~e doggatdegdger’ begncggh. gb odab 6oBbagb, md 96 sMbgdmab sgBIonGgdob Mong mBogJGyGo yo- GgMgIn, MmAgerows AdomagdoBoy Bgagoderns owgmermangda gobgnbo- conan. Astonmers, nrogmarmgngdo’ Bbmenmey JgBdrinGoe 96 8ymomo~w Byqgo- Lpdaw abgeggermdols domds MBgSo ob gdmsgMgho ImAgbgo, Med dbab orwgab ongdn Qampd-jengdgb, mEsgdgdbs Qo EaLEMaggdgdb sgMarn26y396, meng ng, LEmmMg~@ doen SyGgdnQ0b_ gsImAqabstg, SysGogMygex aboero' Bb 04. gd gobegdsrgds.. smagnb Byqdenas “3Byngrb”, mI Lodamagrasémanb. gon angm@ine Bgmtgby gggagbos, abgga GmamMg Bygdergdaane, osdnsbnb By- Bqdab Agbabgd sbgd-gena qrangMabsBabsmagqgm ymByqgange Jomge- gowgena Rotiggnor BgdmBogh — 08 gdnnr ghnbyer Qo. bodgmsdme bohgghgdn of6ab, Med aQadnabgBb ggyergdgon oJgo, Mim mogobyygengd doorn gobgqye- Gorn Qgergdo0, Hmd SgyOgdan abaGo 36 mogjgMde6a amine 96 BEg4ggmrb0. aagmanmgngdb gogeng6s adgor of nlngend, Md abobn Las ymmMghs wa com 40g sbaroDb g4gnGegdoMgdns6, oModj~q adn Gnd, Mmd Goerggacr 9odoe- GqdL, RaIGIOLS eo LoBmgacmgegOb gbdamgd0o6, boBinbn wonbsbm6 bodyo- FmBa, AmIger Bary ghmgGmadg6. going goSbgGGobs 9M ayb (Vincent, 1995), “oggmmmaash onbodgdsgGob smbagorgs’ gggg%7S « oto — BynGMio- gta ~sdggoriggdcenbs”. sg Mend, oegmanmangd’ qeQogme adgh gg@orn@gdab oceggbab 3gh96- D9; 08 yaagdom, Boor “PgIIoMaSgonb Mggndgdn” Igndergd gySmremanr. agg eagnengngda agongomdg6 Imerng agen gab jqMbob g6ab, ImboomgdgBbo wo goMowyQQBb: Adob Bgbobgs, ag mame |ABgombaMgdb wo Gmgme yoas Basdgombnmgdegh Lobmgaw@mgds; s8Qgb5@Q, abnbn gobbsdegMagq6. Mmm aintyg Bggbb sbeegbgdob, aby — J8gagdsboig. Hmgamme “sgBdamnggdnb ggo- 86”, arggmanmans ymggeragab jog8oM ns doeroygangdabon6. @odarinbsam%g- Bejean Aga Ggdgdob, CaMgdyjengdgdnbs Qo agmMingdab LadyseieBo agg- memmangdn goMggayene moMgagergoganb Lbgqdby SmammMnggSyerow oe09- Fgdobs3g5 Qs yMByMABLO agmMngdabs og BrgEgermooow bobSgégdo- baagab ceggngodqmmdab Bnbnggbabjq6oo Bo8omorgenn. Agog, oreqrenrgog- Bo Leagoseegtin badyomek o&BgemrgdoigoergMn Mygggdam |godotoggeg® Qo Bo HbRryBggerymeys, gon dbming, oemggaee S@ddInabgdbo wo acgadnsbens SRBUIGIOL, brane Agee AbeAng, dommoggenganb gan garam LargaIs amb Bcob AGorngtamdob adyorgBsb. s8agbo~, omgmermangdo gomadbygod Gengab 39STMBYE mgmMey yodoGmboqero damoggergdngo LOGgdSI-Agbsgoceo 19 nb ByGoehg6gd530, goGabaeagg6 Mo ob mgm bodstimansbl, dgigd- Fingh, gobmbagMb we 0.3, aby Inb wab-ybSgeobo io Aob BnBotan gdgnb gow 39g9953, Fireqhsyy Inb sqhsBsmingrmdgdb 96 Beaqage b3gdBMnb 6y3e00 bss, Fmd Bab Imegngog> gear gobmBoengbod- 129 Qddyogd «go 8g gEOIEGDL, mB ImeanGogyco Bgbgwxgergdgdob gerobo~ qogorgde dbmarene ghon gMnByrnyAob Gabgragneroys Bgadengds; bya 340 Barinrgda go ggeroregdabaredo wsdmnregdyergy Agadenado ogmb, omBab- | ere bot Seis tnss po qanbeda afin sumekneaa ime aga ORG mggmaogdn @BIy6a, qomgdqergBoow @d rongGMnbsar ByBse Gorgero 693- FgBns «Qo Bab godsGoggBsb gos6oot%o LIgd%n aggre’ age oxygenab. oyrr Agregermdgdn qayMm wsbgpSoaa Imeagogatio b3g4Gob BgJa6ab9, Cen= Agenbs/g mo 96 FgGo.gobmdorgdo gd6pdmeo|BMgngo bIgdBMob 3MnGogob, oZoRATeE, BmgRIG ab obyggv, Hd dbo gowrMn Bggtgdo, gmA_bnBAo wo goBobIo, Aogoghdgdb ogengEb. gaMdme, Amgmag yrdqgbobGeyH8s, oby go~ BobGyAds Mgqo8Bs ImeenGaggGn doragad MgsMgbaygern, ogGnMFngargero {mado gobogoosts, GmIergdboy Bergaghinn “Gmasmogstmer’” nfin=Agbogoero 2 (Q02g%08512 — Goerabgdta bagdhG0 grdqbob80 g9BoBI0 + begoomodo [gmBbyMgoGoBIo end goeo%8o Arb. Bjeggse, emBgMGoGrgero ImengnggGo LIgJGMn Gsegab qeMaab Bpadengds aymb, snore 8ngga6oT6ySb, md goroxgtin Bormybg6o wo Borgegqbo Beegegda UggMangdnk 396 BoobEmoggab wo Fnnsy meinggh eondgMomobJab, LmgaseoBInbs wo gmbbyMgeOBIob “~qgdmgSoGorger” IMBIsorgo6 yo6oe- Rogb (woogreds 12). 393 BM L3gdHML ygorogoBedb Bo6b an’og63o ongob, Gogy6Io bo Bobo 20 qhoBGnbmde gbagmamgoe Gn (Eysenck, Sense and Nonsense in Psychology, 1964). 30%y6 399 GMoengorjero Ipdoryshq0q-8qestgegab bIggeMo bszyootn b3gd- GMb ImMnbmbGoergh' egMdow godmnygbo,.89g%99. dob ImenaGoggha 3e- Dgagdnb Loma ggM@ogzoeegMo egMdo woodogo; Gmdegab ghar Smeg “HabGoe™ Ams Briegoy6n”, obey. ogGMMoGoMgon, beam. AgmMg. Smemby “*BBoq6A”, o64y E_IMyMoGgdn gaboenogs. s8~epbaw, ImaagogzMo owggdnb aobmoggde BgbadmgSgavas Mmamrg BgIomgbybq-BqGoeigegg6y egMdby, abggq “babab®abs” Qo “Lamb” mgMddyy. abger BIorbgggoTo, go6bbgogqdgdn, gardgoo, Bago D8bs eo b&reenGoBIb BmeMab Gormrow Bgndengds gokggomor, org Baer Bg 90M 3b|6-A7IoMgVgN] MAQMIAL yo~™m Smenmgddy gobgorragjda, bm eam Boor, Abgaghgdgdb CommgoRigba, org mbnggh g9a%Gog2ergho egedob “bobs” Smencidg Igoe Imgoonggdor (~noamodo 13). ‘SGabab, yggens, sbgan L3gdG 0, Latiogenggdb Bamdmamab, Haggeb Im- eNGOGTGO OQ? b joeMgbse ymdergqb-yAn LabGgdgdob gedomBogqdobo @d obImgsmgdnb ;96s9 BnIomorgero. bayyggagbion ByInbgqgeSo abnbo Smeno- G039G0 o~AQoAbLS Ed MBIogBobs ombsByMow gnggo LAgomaogorger dg- amma Bgodergdmes Inggok6os Qo sdnGmd Ionon6 weajogBamgdaar bag- Harboeng agdoMagab. AzgeggoMan —jagSgbmdo bye gatin bIamMae bogt- came omymab 89a 3b969-8dSMeRGQoID CaYymaol o~geb. mamMm ys Zo~ge- bo (Giddens, 1994) smboBbagh, aber Imengg4% argdoow BomMImdmd09, mgm gdnga0:, QndbaBIo, sbeggqeros “yyergd930 ws gohgdm, ®Moeaigr.ge0 Jy- Bor gby6q-8989%3egN69 OLIN Boo BgoqjermgabTorroy QAMImPdgeow of(g0o- 28 SBHb Ighow moda godemboGoggh IEgobgg3o abgor eemByaq390, Mmae- Hogso: “Hy BoMlzb50g, 9M ISM 3VGHNg, ImermrE Bob”. gb IMeiggho goomMdo- go. dgace gmmabmdeng wadnmabInmgdgd%y Hora’ mfdrdog, Gob ByQq32e213,22 dmenngogigtSa nwegmergng&o (2003400013 mMaobdmdneajdnsbo bagdGMo — & o3GrMaGsGobIo # Lg acenBo%Io Seeon een # sboena SgoMgeggbigmds apBoegbg6grdo 89806 g¢g96789 . begnaen tin g8mgMaGoo . borden go3nGae0BI0 onogabrggeng03 Bogor, gmbbyMgoGBmMpab gorgPGwsar MowngomadAnbs > o~egmanmge- eyMin SennGngabs eda: IBscaa Bn~@rajnengs, bev bmgnacrabggdo o- Bods cs 3mb 317% qH$989-BonGoGgo. B3ggoxFow ymBGMabSqer Bybgeqengdob agoogoBmab GriBg%Ger 3eBam (Bobbio, 1996); Bobo sen, Mocegs’ 8056- sbabgmds coo Iqdomexgnbgmds owbsbFmmmBob Bqbsbgd sAiqdose as6bbgs- BIBI VsImgowpSyengogah sbabsgh, gh GyInGj30 Ladmaac~mgaringa ~o FBoemQn genmdoerghin sqosbabBmemanb aboern |mMdgdab. Ldyorimo ca Bo Sgogenm begenoyy s'sab, SeagaGogyMe o~gmmermaogdo mEmedgg%iog boy3ygd0 Bgmgg bowgexnb Sercancgat mymangd-gera ImennGazgMda, bmgnceeyMdo ory FOG IMgerdo dgMgddo babg ‘gagoeegh bsdyorimb, GmIgerBog ggbegMmdoy abgain Bosdggeocgos of86gds, moadmb abGmmMosd “bgerok dogo". For | Ligand: ngoeab og go@ogogengdar, obGargnab waggInwob (1789) 3gMenbab go@erab sbgriggedcag (1989)! memsbBqrasba Byoerge@n, gaboziyaege0r go Samggero Bleagarnm mn’ sBygdsbs (1914) eo 2001 Brrals fl ba4GgGdqeb Gory ent gb3 Qo goTobaGmbdy gobbemgogengd yer GISmenbGger ByGqgqo Beor- Fink SgMomeao, nsbdndmgghrgermanaw wo Bgworigdnoin Lgsdoarigmdao bo- Losmiggds, yengger Bpdarbgqgo3n, mss8gerMmgg Ladyormb smodegmoamBabs ong qammdmdsbos6 Bywotgdnor. 1848 Byeb doMJoob Ing% Boorfgada goo, “Jonggenngg Ayatin gobfoMmegds”, gb BpdodMB-ybgdende, Iogyiod sBzomow Bomingdqerse@ yeagMb. Bmaabsagnb gb dgMgdo “owgmermansas bs6ob” ~o- bobeigerd GaBbagh; Bano SBene, Iosgara aggmermangdo sbers ornmdab Bo- Bebygoes ImenaGagg% gbagMydob, Gmdgerboy meghesy go6bsdmgrog- 28y6 (Qs OYoendyBcQHyH. 59 sHgindgHGgab Engbob qgo6b ;6ger oogBo yo6gobo-Apbsgoeen 28 HBO. Yr gg ByBerbggge9o, GGogagrgea owggmermangdn adyergdymno, BggSymbs AMogoer sboerbs go LIntmag graBsbqnas6 Ign~eMee ws yog30rg- Bugae godeB gqgob, Dmageg% gn Boor gogergbna sbera~Qeb gababobagemb oo- g0- 08 3edmB gqgoonge6 yggre’g Bn Igogeomgeboo: © Ggrem@o Bbeageam Bgbengo © SebGimagMGn we “ImbS-nB3gao" © ammdomabagns GZer9EQN EbLagemam BgbMago Abeaeram Bgbngn B6r8gEpeemgbore Biygoers (gago mAnb wsdargMgdo4, 213, ensgab bring, 1989-91 Bengdnb smBmbogengor ggmmiab Mggmanagogdab bobaa grdqGoB0ab BoMighob, Byeotgdom abgpabs6 yo genmBsergtin GgMmMoBdab “Aebygenab” (nb. 39. B51) Bpreggns. “bbgrdeago” Gaga mBnb — v6 KmamMg BmBb3seyAn (Hobsbawm, 1994) nBymms, “Imgerg” Spry beggabnb, 1914-91 — dono- gotin Bsbobasagdgenn oym aggmarmgagmn Smdmare yodnGomababs co jm- BeyGnBAb Brachnb, AmAgerorg gorwgg “IGM goeddsqrro Agméig Bbeagceam mab Bpdcegmnd SoFinemeB s8gMingob Apgmagd geo BHoSgdabo wo bodgeow yogdo- Gab DgbsbymdSagmow bsbrar wssnMabdInegss3. ymIgorBIab ymobo Sro- gomdbeingo Qo MMGIS a~gmenmanegtn ygoe0 ~agmga, mAgerns weaghoy AbLygemBob bogsbos. organ Iorignern wo yanmoby 8oIz8yermg960 o5- GIMIEHgGoxgo00y]3mB-7HHBIb Immagngqho sbIorg Boos. ysbgerab Bydon9 Beaman gransegrio Largmisheabyybsrnas awegmarmgnrgt Imegerse Qo" Logenyto yonronb, ygtdme, Igo ggenn modyMomrgtn wgdmgaGoo a gMfo. 03 ‘gbgw@yergoob abobgoo 9. 6. “obGmmoob gobobMgeob” agbabaJam- Bgebog Bg go gogodbseraBpdor. ebgsghds dywmgagads, MabasgaMggemn, demagtin @atGyde Bnayg6s LrgnseraAb. Magmeragortin, ,obbsgqnMgdon LodgengGin | BomfonbSqee-mg6nbigea Lgagrab beygnaeenBdo gogggaaey do- OQ AIG AmMAmMy gobgoaoMgdo~ bodyoMim, aby ImbGymAgoobGom dg046038n 5. PsBsmser@s gImyMmoGorjera beagnseradanyy; Bmangmomb sb- Ha, ab Cabodacigdab Logdorbab Fn63j aw@ge. JAMIME, (SAEBMoergMa wor g930g0b egal Bor(3b9o LabgerIageb’ “Dyga~@ob Jgggan” Iatangals IgcQoMg- Baar Inghdamgd yer GmMIIO Indorio(y jo BpobybGe MB8g6o co wgdmyhio- |] 80 Lergosgnab§gdo adadey Bnoyga6s, md Boe dosti bodeoseMnb Boddbab, ptosegticn Londggm boBqomngdow omnatglf 90 dgMgab woBgringrgdam Ag-4 cnagdo gobgnbaeragor. (gngdo mAds ggocra ofa Boman begnoerabSig% oregmamansb coséRéna. phnggMboergtin modgmomod3y Briss godomegodobogcs; [gdyjoobIob Gabds obama amgmanmgartn damgan Bomdmags. dargad qdowgMga ncagr- eEman'gtn Andsmorgengagans GagnmbsernBd, gobboyjarrgdoor geabogy%o Bs gnmboegndIn, Mmagerdary, Mmamry ImBabagq owgmenmgas’, Fagor 3mb- G3MB_GabG7% dggyoboI Iggows oMgbnB-eg6n60%4; Qo Agengng%o BDBOVIQEGIMBAn, MmAgenAG, oagnb IbMng, Imogoerbsbmgo6ns wo bye TE- Fen ByGo gogerg6s odgh godgnornmgdow badyormIn] IgGoG, das6o 8no-go,24 SmeraGaggto owgmermgag&o Denggea™ BOB_EgergoGnry, 08 agmermgngdboy yo, AmAgerovagabog “ber QoommndBab gare ggoergdah” bomagagern ‘gowe SmpGabo, ga6bozqanmgdoo — andgMamabAbs eo gmbbyMgeGoB. Igmrgg bag gg6yao mnBgyMoernB8abs ws JmbbyMgoGoBabsargab sdobabosagdger ogGMAGgGLo Wo boymdrgh, BoM gggaeBnenow, ab gorigdmgds goSoInmmdgdmo, Amd abobn brygnsceabGyg- Bo ong gerdqgbab-yha “BBMnbGn” QoInMnbIomgdyjermBob yerbGgdySo gaGnbsdegmigdmmby6. sbg Bogomnone, Agmgg bogggGob Smee’ oboea q- BorigaggGg AmdtomBnb godmAgbo “Bydorogo (creeping) beyyosenoB8nba@da” Bmgo~@n o6Godsnanbs Qo bodgmen gmag_EnBInbo@So gobbszzowigdqero ABMiQe QoImgo~pdgengdab godmboSgengds ayn. GSsQogogao IGnb ddI Gbgd9 96 Anbargol YMogdnb Bygggga dob EnBsboo, MFm3 meg~odggrag bowgggby8o eendgMomaBdaga co ymbbIMGoSoBI5 big ae wojorgogh gmtda damnsbmdsb eo mebsBggMegoo. 2001 Benabs 1 bagGgdBgKn, Sg ammgba go goInbgGrbdy IpdaG-ybyodq- co GPSMAnbG jaro crgWobbAgdnb eng, GoMamee garSgdmeas Aman ong, aga begeram Bgougeers”. Bog%8 Incrse Googe o% awinb, imam Bgaggaers og0; 91g Ob Stok Boagera, Mo BoIgOgermBo odgh 06 Yy- adengds SgmBqgh o8ab donogarin aggmanmgngdboargnb. aermboengo Gothen AndOab Gormsb, gFgh goMgago, ‘geacwgbn bogMowIneabe es Bgomboerg- Fn Bycegagan Im3ygo. bogmowSmeabr wmbg Ray, wy. SxyIob “Byemein- Bors6 mak” ganar sBgtingob BggMagdgerd BoGg89e goeaghow Bgd- Gage Qs, BoM gggaEen agoeboBAnknoy, goerdengo Logotgn Imeeagoggho gotba sofas. ofob Bogsemnagdns owmadsGnb Mgyo8ab gsdbmdo ogma6gor3o 2d mba bao’ Sqbgnbnb Gobssmdmga HroyBo. wa Aooby, Gargenns obgo J8g- Qdsas awymarMgrgtn Byegagdob BabobFam googmrs. gMan abring, orgy “BgRmbaBIo6 dn” Adergdb Bdagemb 36 smAmabgeab sbgowobogensy- Ao Mgernaneyn sby~QMgdo Qo AmbImb obnb, goby 08 BpPomngdsb Aborrb eaga%g6, 85806 836 erndgroerg*-apImgMoGogeno eaMgdyergsgor go o6- bGoG.9Hg80 bobgMderagn wMmne boymggerars Byndengds gsbowmb. Igme%g Abeing, bgsegger BobSoGgGebnb (Huntington, 1993) gagowroBogasor Byxobgdob axgdabnls osbsb8e@, 836 Bgndengds gowgg ‘gam ABgogq o6GBsdgMoggqero eo sGGowabogengmo bodobgben Gacrme SoBmgob go yqybssybGecroBIo go~ | 2293 Jam gosderaghmb, Bagnmbsrgh mbby arrmBoeraytin GMa B80, vodegorme, bobymrBBageb ImbBagogdb oG9g@s, JBI DEL 3%, 8800 Engano ayo Bab 396, Fen’ babgerdBagm byerabyygergds Byotow wogggdsgo~ Bo Bab Qo nbengorgoera sgmgesedy gym domme Bgbmnghs @o LsbymdBagm qbogyMorbmgdab oyg6gdb, ab gerbbgtgoGoBInb 396 gogobmabs Qo CndgMomgh Bbyezyergdoo yHmboab Bgndengds 9919523" Bathe.Agbogoepa 25 ImbBImagain — THRAGIGAM OQYMAMBNSS gokgos 08 IMimEgdgonQed nb ygdo, Mmdegodoq cnsbsdgrgrimgg Ladyatimb smbgdmasb eogem boersgg. SmmghBrBaygnnb seie- Gaba Lmgnsenghin, ImenGazyHo ws saeBaee dabsbraogdsqqdnn oBm- Apdo. Lrgnsenaytin ngagrboBnboa, ab Sosy degng® etinghGorgdgero ZOINGIabvG.yHo._gymbmInzgdob GoGImImadsb ~qgogSoMeogdmes, BmBergd- Bay Borogotin does sbaera begnserghn gemabgdo — LoBgocem GIS wo BeyBo- ens gensbo aye. Smenagnggtn agombsdenboo, aan mbamgogeno sdbrery- GoBInb 3mELGaG-gGogen Qo, bagormgdnbs8gdm, wgemsMoGoyero SBomorgge comdnn Pabsggengoab agerablImdes. samBaMigera agomrbsdhinboo, gb ao6- obormgdermBab awgggdabs ws Bbgwryergeq3b gog@sqerg023o godmaboGo, FimBemgdnyg BMBJSNLS QO SMimaMgbabsedo gMorgqerganb Iinbgns7sBQ ~od- goMgdqee Ggmogonb, ImennGagnbs Qo, bodmgseme, bagerab GMoQogrgr QMIGAFNGyBb |: gemobo yegtn enndyGoero' do a crabodge@rengg cod gomobde moadgmoer bdo ma@odagGag boas769 9. fn ok en onal ait af Pe ak ARE Tern et desta BahImImdo ~—s gobgomstges GoMIO6L “epndgMoeng{Mn” BpormenbdgGy bogs boas’ Imymerge gave bdoeen- qb, ongBGd Bob 98 bnb gobogenrhdsIo qadeiogo gobbogogqeyer BGaBgogere" Bo BagBaMgBergo. cromobighn Logygo crndg™ ongobyworr owodabens gersbb abo Ibagms, o6iy seosd0sb gov, Fmdengday ay geo ogghgb e 3g ambyBo. gb boGyge qbgb9G boBbogme — LoJ8gey-Lobdgerab “gbg” BebIsMgoob; Leagos- eng Bndsmogda¥o yo LoBtggergh 96 IogqggSdmgdermBob Baabbamdes. As qqotawnce “pgrgBOMIQBYH oogobyGengBnbs wo oMBggo6ob axgggdbo«. Sor exo ga esGgntogeh GyMAobn “endyHorrobIn” gogamgoom age odg6b — 38 BEnTgEgermBnn Soriggaree ab BygbHo8qGq Leryzwbob qabsByab@o, 39 dong, 1812 Baga, gh3oSgar’ gsdmoygbyb. wo engentngd- Bg gabgnowrigs, HmImgsaG Borgeen bedsbo Beno’ anbdogepmdodn yorrodegr Bega. enoBgoenrghn aceggdo garmdsIo gyrmwocobIab eygqas ee dab aqgnentdy goangemrabSinto bsdmao@egdob ysbgnowsgdnb Bareggo>- eqndg- Romobda gota ababogqs gdbgnowAgbogo LeBgomer ggbod Bobb mogg- gab, HemBeqab oFyMgbgso Bberer'gSI% SmboeJow ceo AnBondgenmdgera doepaggengdob oBgQNgN~O Baba Smamagoatin ws@gntngs bIamo~e yoyo~eegdab Anmds MAgds] BorrQs- gM badyorimdn boasbseme of ghdmaro, Mm’ nbeagngb boggaotn obGg- Cighgdn o6 Boeageme Aobagal eodababnaagdgaro, agpbGdo ImbeQs. 89806 sQodosby3b 0 Lrgnoergdo RaIgIAb ygMgdo~ agerngby6, MmBagdboos aboba gznorgimeebg6: maxsbgdab, Lengeanb, omgnermBmnga agGab. a6 bogoo- eagtin gonababs. 8a ymaabs Qo NQ_EGBMBsb BEoBgigermgebTomog 03 yao- gob SgByBo gobhodagmagwo, GmAgerarg avgabo gabgnowMgdab gbs'by om- SoqQab romasArgg anaJanb of oggergdmMm@e. dogMo8 Bob Bybega, Moxy goreo- cmon SsBsHby denngh meinghQomgoqjerdo bo bmaocemgsyod Byggorre, 06- Qngorgdab BobsBg qq_tm gotiow oMRggabo wee bmgosergn 3gMb3gdog0- Bo goon Toms. Boor, (bengMgoSn Bgbsdegens InMggers.a, dngygsar bsIqo~g2, admin gnagamoe gedMmgb0 gd baggasta aogo Bammgbgeno gyorbaor Jg- aqabgdo6sor. Bs_rmracse, yO, GmBeab mgRobIag Borgen GbrgMgdo yor Gog- egy BnBsby gooGoro, “oogabyygocrn aQadns6n” gabyos; Bob «q3gq SderBreo Bg- bodengdmamas, ogtfins, goborgab gx98go, 96 Lyers(y BnBab- Boenggds. gowe~ pBygnGs Qo SboMco JoerodgIn gdgd6o Logon. BaMEoey'yta gbmgMgdnb bagyydggeron bgM%gg98 sbomro NEOJerado DIT Fo genndoGa Irngsbo. ®ogagagenro Ayernarqein sbimghyos orsbcvorsben~ dom MoyneBoerj%8s wo Sggbngmgeds bgmgo8 Byggoero- Bgeggewg bobmas- comgdnk Bggsbydsb aGengnwgab argommboSaghin wage. obmngrggqeBo “9330 BoPimgGger Qo Damargo’ codabsbasangdgen, dsbow6, gobbogqarmgdyqyer0 cn- Agdgengdab AfrBy agobydgb bg~oogi0696. 280 AmBIma«es Ipfigneedga-dgor- 398989 Lom gSg988o deyBgdMng qqenjdson ongmthngdob gobgnmomgdo. 08mndgtoenn%do 33 TQMARnam anbsbdow, obaagowgdo omPgMgareba nygog6 agangdndo~mergdy- cen SeyHydengo ggrgdgdnor, meagdag yee6 enmgde (Locke, ab. gg 43) aby gdbbodeagho: “bagmaberg, ongabyggengds wd bag qor%gds”, s@sdasban mot Lgdabs @s osGsdst%a Magdqgergdab sbgabogq Bogobgdob agowgodmab age- Bobgenn Goeembmeebo H336 gore 3o6Go (Kant, 1724-1804), Amaerab gmbGaqGe~ ab onsbabdam, obrgngnga “ agnmndebas” wo ots Lbgoow Anbbab dae ggab ba- Bryoengds. Owes seabaBmns, md aBrengawenb mena’ bsBgsb4s8o min ye cragtabssatiab3amio sbn ogyeabbdgds. gon, Fmd yao~mgds godmdo onnormgyjenn o@odnsbab -ghngommmdab: abrengorgdl, gloMggergh ymgenabe, L3ggngaggMin BnGsgo6n agnbgdgdo mo Iababnaagdengdn gebbsdmgMogb. gr gG, SQo8Os6gBb Bon6(s Man LAIBybe o4gor 08 argoebo%dnbo, md ygq- robo, Sobor gh yogernbs, oBrengaw~gdn of n06. BaMngeg, Egndghoergto orggmegmgnn’ Sagem Bnbsomdreggmdab boogy gOngoermBabs «eo onabab- Broriman’ gb Amsg}%g arggde Bgndengds aymb. cbgngorenk sy bpbs_bmBob AB8g6s ceadyroenyn owegmaermgnnl wadabo- boamgdgaa Am@ngns, Bog%o8 Gob eondgMorggh oBMimgogdo'%dy orraghionggo- Aimgabo 3goCR0 —dGmge. Babe gogergban Smanghion cadyMoero badmgower 2896 “ySGoeme abengowars Ga 3MqBa@ gobabarg@s, Mmdennb mamggcea Bggtin dbmarme ba zzymstin bogarimgdgdnbs Qa abByMgbgdob wagaymgoenge Bab Geoamab. sbgor by~geb aBmBobS-gn byrQgo gSire@o, Gorge’ ab aBceago~ Cb LoBSmrgoremgdsBa'“go6dbmregmgdye dBmAg3o~w” Sms BAgab: 99 Bgbg- OI7KNDISI IoMonesyy Byndengds Anagnggo6mbs MEIVGaIwd, md “Laomgacege 3” angnborsgoe 9% oMbydmab, md ob, gaMorme, agnorgbotin abrongows- Bab bogs abgan qyowyMgho oBRagamNIERdIO Hd ZoMa_RAQIG dreab, Fmd aBengnw~n cgggMdos, SHgsMgdnabn ~s gMamd mogwogegMgeyeno- B.3.Bsdegghibebo (Macpherson, 1973) omrager adgMacend4b sbbosogdb m= BMGs “Aqbagqarsqen obengowjomoBAb”, 3326, Inba seine, obeagn@o Kgenmadb: bazyos™ Botiengbydob 96 abQagagnls yogGoqmBab ABIES’ SqGQdMingo Bngyogoran abngownb ~wo- Aerjgo@gdeemBob sqnshgdsaeag.- oGQagogob ognbygengds (oogobygengd2 Qo ~oe¥ggnQgdeymds gMomgModmBbssgeng Gbpdg09). pndgmoermongob egbgGogbo ImenGagzgo aMgdyegds Qo cendpioergy™. amgmamgos’o, Achogomnn g0gqd0m, ZodogMonsbydgenn IMnbyndns. sEMg~ea IgMameal eon- dyMawasango. aogobyygqengds SqbpoMngo qeergds ayer; ob ayo -gdorgMgho sygnengdermds ggddMnGoe@ sodnabighin sMbgomanboagob. Bobo Syaron= Bn, smHAggsbols godmyg6gSnb gba, aQo8nobgdb Iggdermar-gubmgmonr bsgr cnatin bighgomngdab IgbsdsInbaw. Bggdermar sgMBnso Logbmggdgera s~Qo- cay gabrrgab g3gdogon, Mo gyn@ae @d 9.3. Imggnabgdnm cendyracngade o- gobyyqengdsdo wanbsbgb gronegtan Borimds, HmAgerng o@odna6b boBgo- eegdob sdengg@s, gabggoasrigdnbs (gmgGo wo Bago wo LMgeor~e gobgbmMgor gangdnbo msgabo Im@gbgnoer0. We TMH, MOTHS IO Sh SeHSM AOS, Med abgongrga odben a ensgnbaggorno m6Qo Oymb. Bp dqraQoga cognbygengds Igndengdo goondgge F_domangow”, Logoos BynMagbyrgob oe. foroga mon ao0g0- biggengdab Agbobyd [1859] 1972, ag. 73) g26 LAorgoS Been (Mill, ob. g3.35) abgor SBMb ogocrstgdbs “gmonrgrion Inbs6o, MmBgerny sdommengQdb dopo’ go8enyg6gdsb sagocnn’dydigenn Lobmgommgdnb Mmigerndg BggGnb Indoror 03 qgobabsbgerob LigMgomab baBabssmAcoggmne, bbggdnbsngob bos60b BaynSn- Bob oogac@s6 oigaemgd9s” Bogab ImBngoo madyMGsMgenos (ab. gg, 103); ogo DabSAgqboy agmrab oGgngowab ongobygergdab Admrarene’ ggntgh Bybe- 23.Q993b Qo abagy “Lbgoorargab. Bavbab Inygoydob” oogows6 yyremgdab_Ao%- Goon. fan Dzggmmawm rbabegoggdb baygantin aagabs@dn Bobamorgey Jdgeo BqoL, mgs aGenga~gn sdbmangSryGowe ongobygacrns bbgpdabo@do nde ongenn Jgmgdgdabog06, Mmdgmorsyy bogoors onogabagergdn Boagage 6 Lbgoorsagab baobab AnygSgdo Iygderns. Goera 9% gor6bg8o oGngargab Ma0- Ag6d0% BoBergegob, MmAgerag Bob bogota crgob Bndsta Bnygbgdger0 godogzigho org Amtoegn Bnsbobogo6 ogogd. obgan bgcgob msbabJo~a, ogo mas, gombgdo, Amdeng3n. Iemerb Qo939g0 Je8Pnb, FBmyagerobS 30 Rogbindob bdorgdab sgororogdmengeb, obggg Boamgegeens, Gmammig Bgsabso~ afin GgSBgtho, AmBgenary obngogh qbergQogh Jargosh, Bongncbmbs a6 In eqb8aGmb aBsb, Mog Bab byGb. 08 ImBagoogsé gsdmIcqnbot%g, osgabygergdob eemgSGabob AsQagscrayt ImAbMpgaL Bogdernsen dn ggoé s~QoIno6ob gyerImodgtoqnnbde 36 aogMansbgdgiqe bsdggmb grezmbmgmbn, g3mbmabiSo wo Imegngojmbo. ysdeyo- aMgBxER Wd AJeGHin LBagergdnk Mpyo88s, MmBgenoyy Bob 85958, qSarasorinbIov Engrg Gogmbas geqn8® Ineydo gabiySgbo, 20 Berab sboy8o Ioeqnb qbagdnggso ge cmaqbo 3s8mnBgns. BgdegmIG 86 ~ooombs wo bgeAdargobgmrmBigo London Re- View-b, nyo sbggg nBycrobab 3smens8ghGab Eygtin 1865-1881 Senge. Bocool AmogocedbFingds co jmBdergdvigMBe BAmdgQsIs madgacrnBAnb gs6g0- stg&sBn gomolB yggGo Gmagn newdos, Moxgo6 Aer bya gown gersbagnm ws sBodgerimgg agmtingdh Ieenls. gmengdogobSeg%o GySegoyogdabs go Sogo~ Gnp8abs@dn Bngrab Gabsomdceggmde SgybMo8jGg boggqbob Inf godgbageG Ge enh. bodogagMme, nBengomyjomgto semgAgdab bagganb — oSergamqocrmdob SyGoeRBBexmBnb — boSgobdoa, Jarrow booMfiggdm qeyergdab senoigdaoy, magos~ Bgdno go BeyBons grimIymoGnggdabom@dn aGowmgmdnor, ab Agmgg bogggbab Amgerg- gdb -qhAnsbgdmags. Enenab BrimBoosge6 ogboGBbagno: argobyygengdnb Jgbobgd (On Liberty, 1859), Emagen w76ce9 ayeals BordmAsceggbeemdaan drogtmdo (Considerations on Representative Goverment, 1861) 9s Jocmars wodgqdceg&origdo (The Subjection of Women, 1869). da, asdmaygimb Gr jmBggdn, Bogoerane, IgMmnbo wo gmgonbo. oGengagb, Ho orgds “69, qa|engdo ofgh, arsgow gob jorge’ bagqaotin beg ger Qo béy- co, Fogo croamngryer omsdar6 qh~Qo ghdmegh eo IoGoagh beg%egh bigs scQodnobab sbgabsgy agergdob, nymb agobyggeena.|go SBRos aodmbsmgero DsbsSgQMmgg eradyMoconb, MG eegerbab (Raws, ob. gg. 70) 3Ma6y038, imBenols cnsbsbdowsyy, yrgaE a~odna6l -qBwo IxmBbrogh BadbodoergMn oogo- Legqengds; mBgmary oF pdmocyagh bbgo wabsMRgbow sbgxvsg9 aeergeb, nygig6 aogab-yqoe6n. Bomionsenos, emodpMoeagdn OsbbIggdns6 agobsagergdob morMgdyergonb cromda%g, 843489 abnba yoggmargab of of na6. ghems66n bojonbBo, Gab “96 (gd Go BEogragh oBeagnronbergnb “orognbiggergdo”. groMonsbydijena bsdggmb AegMeRMge Gd omQgIaIS abSrarnals B3gqqg0%e/abans BAERGA (1909-97) ow ABBA aasgobeygEayand mira ymbesqe7(50° (Isaiah Berlin, [1958] 1969) gobs: Bggh ongobsggegdnb “bgg0Gogh” wo “ ImBagGayg®” ageeingdh. saMgiyer wd geabagn® eendgmsegab LEsdeaa, Mmd aogabyygengds' GoBbogws aomrgge cnn SeQSIA EAL ceddmenZOgerMmasb, Bab sbrnghigds¥o RoyMagermBabs @d ‘Ng cagdshs, pdmgge@s obg, GmamMs Liye. agobyygengdab gh gmbygqane “Sg- BoGoryens”, GoiQZas dBrngarwab gorggaé Spbergmggdb 96 adgyengdom ‘ber Ad’ SH oergsemrabBabyBb. sbsdgaeMimngg eodgBoerqdo’ aogabygengdab qq- Aim “Ben BaGowyA” 3mbe3gqqgqoob _gabmAmana6, FmAgerny Sgmena6da gobbobe- gio Fimgmtg bogymotin asgab d4Gmb-3oGBMmbo~e yreyonb, sghmbm3ogeer- ob qBotin. Lagyyesin crgab I9Gmb-BoGMAmBMBs FaBsgh, md abeongogh (gmebab, Engob, asagdqb ‘gBorin’ gagomarngds wo BoB6jdob bores yBybbI +6 2d Bggdermbs [gemb bGogohB Goma’ sdGnm, Iagarace, ogabsygergdo go- GAq_S|S IPH’ GoTbsgb, gnwoMig qroerme yogdg Bybe Dmgo~se gragdaenn sigo m%ngoxyo s'ehnoy i exingceg 96, Henceghors ersgnbyygengdsb oegsdoa6ob SmBgbgascgab goobmegngerg Bow gobobreraggs. sBotiJobggdo ogobyygergdsh adbmergGqs compere SookGggg6. Baan ob- om, omgabygersds Iggengbgdgerns Imeangnygn domoygergoob ByobBog% getAsbos6. aga boBgoeegdo0 Jomingbgeno ogmbmdnn’ dnboea’gg°~, HOG BI erbbdedb ambngMegcy embgdg bazgantin ByBnew wo bogyematin gorwe8 ysnbcrg Bner sHbgdmBsb Qs sho Moana “baggontin orgob ebadorIe” woeAgbob. BrBobggdo oGongawysergytn argobrygengiab EyoabIag qeedob , 3093 BOM BH bo8awaeg.3en- AengmB, Ear ndgdb yo Laq~aBsjabargab asgob omBagob derngta bggneno SBmdMoggdn. Bmmsergtin agorgbsdMnbrn, bodsrocnabmds abrngogab agengdoors BoGagabagdsh Imnabragh. go~eM%g\ oesdnaGgd0 bsBoroeynsbs~q Beadeggdg6 96 Logab gorsby39496 bag gqanm bnbQagMgh, baBgawrink ga6a6o- emgds, HEM@g6 orsbobBmemey ‘q6ms aye’ ago, badamomas69eg gbmeo Ron gocomb. sqm qborno6 06 godMxRQ oodno6b bndnehig “rman oda 65- Bergin” Qo BoMABorsbg 06 -yAgm%Bq qagagh GbrgMgosb odbabyrgdb, bode cnemnaGmank, sbgan agmtins gsbognosto geen6 enmgdo Bpkgomnb9 borgsa6g- Bo; gh agereins Igmiyg bogggrb Smegmb Egmenndgymaengads onGsgqh, Gmd- eagbing bdarog Mendy Grn%n job (Nozick, ab. ag. tl) oggdob aogerabsbs—s go~ Gaigrqns6. Agmeig Bbeing, obs9gearmgg eendgMoangdn bergnsergh bodarioncens6mas- Bo Magog Broan beagnoergh onbsGmmmdsbay gyerabb4mdg6. Isgomo- 1909, G6 Cenegcbsn (Rawls, ob. 9g, 70) bdsmonmas6mdab ongenttins Ba (1970) s9- mab, Mend ggmbeBorytin qorsbsbSmemada Iman 09 BodenbgggoSos godor- crengd-genn, arg ab bsdmgsemgenb geoGagghe GsGarrab bobsmagdeme od- Ggdo Andomongenn. Bbsdsdabse, Mmggrbb Abgsgho LeygnseerarndgMoargen ab 396096, Fm’ Lodomorensbas ab bodmaacmpds, AmEgerBag IoGgGnoerghia baggangin Legnoersyto gBMgggerymgnd babgganb gosgaaeo Bemaob AyBggmBnar Gsjeogasee Bgdengdjer ImbsbemgmBs'bq arwsbsForronds/bmygro- emgh badomacns6mdsdy sbgan go6bbgogqdqern gommbsBnbgdo sbabogh dorigayen qasbbimgdob mmndgthaaeg® sBegbgds8o 08 Iammdgdo6 393° Borhgdaw, FmAgeras ByBggmBoasxy *VBQo RodmyoomnBragh bodsmoneenséa ba- Degacengds. gensbaggh emndymoergab Lada, Amd ono 96. zo3oGoenob- Batin bodmgsc@mgdan |mmoernBInb Byggerod obgow berynseegin Inver Bgdq BgJd6s, GerdengSGary yagen abreagneb Bogderm 8 gaanmemgmdon ggbrgms, AmAgerbs,y Baba Gago ndLabymgdwo. jerabogighin endgMoeagdabs- 396 gabbbgogqdom, asbsgermngg epndgmoengbn 03 abMabsbo snob, Ged Bgr sabeyig@W9gBo. godoGooBIs godmnBgoo bmynserig%o qhoBsrinemBob obs- cma GmM8gdak gokgbs, Mmaargd8xy oe@adoaGgdn sMsos6adst SorimdgaGo Rooyg6o.endgtoepo%da At A_dByEsMgdemmds Ls IMog0erqQqMmgbgdo eendghomrgt bmgosegh SmMamh gobbszgaMgano obsbosagdb Absmdo, sqastiob dmmomghn, Geary Qs ImenngaziyMin Brsgoonageing6yds. oMo~ary, JergMomoBIa, sbiy BsaMagarimds, Bgadengds oorfgob, Roggbggd-y- mas abgagogyomabInk InbgI80 ~Qo 09 ImbaBMgdsIo, Fmd ocgsdoabgdo admgzncogdger0 3 6, md epAagMaeagdab Bagh Srogsmeggmmg6yonb babomagdmme sosgngoero GBingsbo ByASyboAgdenedsb nye sqyogBomgonds.[ jd ySoyermBo Gad- Bagh Bmamdnbm, soGa6m-, MHmd bb3o8 Bqbaa6 gobUbgogqoqero~@ agogMimb, agro BoFogeb Qo NBmgg~@mb. gb SBM grdmbGs |Mrbgdo BgMomds geneGyAao (1694-1778) orga’ eggmotai3noa: “Bdogb, Mobsy 83md, 89g%9 Lagensgab MDA] QdjOGIS Bob yyergdsh, enfgo ByGo Loenfdgeno” [Aj yBorgdenndo BEgmoMago NR|EETAGSS Bd L—EREMO IMGOING. gMa0 IbMng, ab 3ar%ege Bigenn ogGmbmAnab AnBsbb gobsbsbaghMgAb, Bgmeg Abrng go, o@sdos6gdb Ber Fob gag Mordmsymmdab Egbgdb oag6b.[BgdB yosmgoermBab ong8s eradgro~ gM SoMengbydodo Borgg~mow SpPignedgdg bo-g;yHdo P6regds; ob genb Iogn- GerGabs (Milton, 1608-74) wo gb epemjab’ Bagh Ageragagtin asgobyygqengdob 289939 AsdMabaBe. eemgo gob ByCnerTo GmengmoHGmdab Agbobyd (Locke, A_etter Conceming Toleration, [1689] 1963) o8mdb: Maga’ BaogMmdnb qIomaqerg- bo Bgbdgne bagmgberab, aogabggergBnbs qo bojyaxFgdab wo(ggoo, Bdb qr engd9 ots adgh “ocadnsGns Lijengddy BMHry6goIo” RogMinmb. sbgorn Bygabydo Booreose agahgg6q3b, or MoBo by~oagq® erndgroenpjdn “bogeatim” eo “Baro” GbegMgBsb Bmmob Iosgar gobUbgagqdsb. ByISYyGormpdenmds yHrws gMsqercog~ eagh yggeroggdg, Mog Agodengds gabgnborrman Mammy “Samoa”. Mgr eengank Abgagbs@, SoMomgends Bgmdringa bognorbgdo, MmBengdbjxy Ober cee Imisg8jen aBrengn~@n “EOS sagdwgb Sabybb. ®mengms6GmBo, o8ago- Mag, EgasGogtio ongobygergdob gomabGo otinb. sR. b. Bngga ensgab. Gog68o orogobggengdnb gbobyd (Mill, On Liberty, [1859] 1972), BpaByBorgdermdnb am goram gsdsmagpdsb agasgodmab, bso. ab Bab 86a BgogemmBab Ssdmaby6b GmgmMy Lodmac@mgenboagab, sbggq o6- Wagagnbaagabsy. abengngab Imba gangs’, IIWyForgdermdo, q3orggergh yrrgerabs, 3nMacQn sg GmBmMInob LaBboswin ~s, BybsdsBabse, BogmBingo agnargobgoosmgdob 3nMimdss. Igmeg ding, BI ybomgdenmds sbg39 HgG0- megdganas Bagmnaboe LoBmgsmmgdab dograbs Qo bogs6bogab gBeqeggerbo- YMG. Torevme nggons gabsggocyn SoSMnb 3o%mdgdSo, og, bow@og go@- BO MAGIA (BIE aggdb gbxsgerd0s, Bns~ogn guergds gogEMIOSb, SMIm(gg5- HBS “Ag BBornGgdo”. goSbbgoggdqermBabs eo Imagomaygrimgbgdab Baymgo = BggZoBAn, yoda wo SSMow goggers-godmggers — bergosenaytia sMman- Lab dragosf Boma GagMmows, md youggergg d8sb goboosgargdger bo8o8- Pmgosb qAd6ows cegdmyMoGao wo “Smoygymo gmBQmMoBInb” aogrggerg- Bo, MmAgeragy ~QogzogZdoMgSqera aym MBAgbobon6, m9 bodomaeg ymgger- ago’ geMagergbmBnb absMgh Gro ayeb. Boren ([1859] 1972) msgnb sdmb obg ogoonstgdb:42. dmenagazigtio omgrenmgagso Bengern ZoGMBGamas, gan s~sdnabob godmgergdom, gan sdrabs Fim age’ s Abeer oF ghar s~@adnabb Idmb~mqb ba3neab3nrm sd- Gn, ZogMaMomBdb Bog% 09 prow agab obMinb gagergdgergmesh obg- 39 8% gfBgdo godoringngds, mgm 08 gogab Ing Borgero Ls bmgs- QmpBab SBmab -ga-gerqogeymgeb, ab adnb daero MmIg BgbOygcegb- AB yGFompdegmdabs ceo Irogamagimgoyonbowedn cendyMacra. gg go6Bymds skggg ngogdomregdo gob mbsbEmmgaqeno bodmgswmmgdab MEIgGab = Lo dmaswempdabab, Am8geeag darigger gmbysragGb. Bqody 0% gogbergPne. Bogbgmagaw oBabo, Gerd abrengo~agdh eo bmgnsergh RIG Legere gobbbgogqd-yer0 oBGgMghgdo admdMaggdnr, moBoMoegVh. LEI, md 8, @o- Bomab3omgdjer oFGgghgdb Berab gaye ems Ba48mbno org SmbabGor- GimBo oMbgBmdb. dogscncwow, Madobgornbageb gebbbgogmgo dyBo-Imbodbs- beygan go BgSomgon obGgFighgdn: IqyBo-debodbabyrggdb qggagbo gsbsd- igeaEIMr, -nQMM Genzeng badgdor mag we badgqdom Iommdgdob goxAgndghg- Bo beyMay AgBomAgg3b oognabenn Amagdob goBMmwmo joao Comdmgdody Mag Bgodengds Qodeero obsbshxgdnb — door Imbnb bgergabgdnb — BybaeiPeyby- doa. GIGmeE md MGM sRyIeaQs bodmascmasedo, ab grenGab 26 Aoringgern jepabal bgexBo ff ayob msgh. Sugon mein Seng SomroBdb, Bggayeegng, aosgo~ pb Game “aqowgGo ImeraGesob” agmMosb, GsV5 ob aigngrbbamabs, ame gyo- WMO Iorgrmanb Radmyserndgds Goma wAdmyMoGoyer sdbogmdsb geeryogger- ymgb.gondgMognn®do 43 20 Bony, mndgMoenghn Bp yBorgdeamdo Igy begmogn SergseqqoBIa- bs «9s Bmogomngygrimgbob BbommoggMab om aeqenabbAmdb. ogaeramse, ca- gp ByWyBoMgdeomdnb IMG godb.o% ogMggergBwe goomenagg7ebg, SmBeag- Bag, Boba Sdn, gegen LyyggMg6nGgGaboagnb Logmabys Gomdmor- a05m696, Mogeb -nGbm Job JMorggegdebso/_Mm goMome, 37d yosMgo- cambds Apndenges gobobodmgrimb 08 Bpbjwoyerg8y3o6 jogBoMBo, AnBengdog angobogae BggSyborgdgenn. emodghoangdn, s8ggorow, Bgadergds ogeng5- (2696 Bbo~ymebol abgan gs6mbgdnb aomrosbsdgMom, Smaegsoy, Iogamro- on, Gobabsgenn soHgdob gsdebshgob, o6 sMowgdmzoGoyero SmeenGogyy- Fin Boh Gng3ob ombyBmasb yMdogagh — 8 Angra, md abgon ogo’ aagmeggengdo o6 sbgorn Io Gogdob FoMBGqds emndomoenytin Byd6 yborgd- Bb. [gs Bonby, eendgmomas SBMnm, JogSgo Igdobgggodn yO yoorigommaab Bp dmjwoge byeravy 9% oMab og gomgdgero. mgs 3%. b. Ingan sBmBmQo, Qo Q_BoGgdbs. qs Gob;gbogdb ab 3603369- Amdo odgh, Gm “GQ” a~ggdo goImodzomog~qeo, Moxy “Zot go” araggenb BmgoBgdsb GaBGagb. aby Fmd, BpByborrgdermBab ABIgGs ygrgdorcegdo sqBoggMboenabaeys MBIQGSb, mI ndphoreyn IMnbga3gd0 Lo. MoMgdyy- eagdgd0, badmagmm yoda, oggnergdeaw QoRosinb omoemmdgmoery ocy- aM6oG0g996. TogMsd Jymeg bagggoab Smemmse Smymangdgao SMogoRa adgAoea AP yPompdegmdnb oma gobgmo wo. AmmomrgMo byrGacvaGgGob owge anGoge- gh dgMaeg% awgmarmgooda gonggMbaemn Ange’ Iergtoeyn’- Babs 396 gorwsbMsb] IgSygaeagdb; egndghoegdn bInmowe ong, s6goqdmb6 BTHLIIVHGN® KOM_Sgergdsen babSgIob dngdsb wo sdgmBobydmbq6 gged- ser obgorr Sammdgdnb Bysdo%q, Amgeror SysoamBaoney gobbbgogqoyer0 Bentroenentin Qo BGgMnaee-gn Imarbrgbneggdgdnb omodnsbydo ghar I3gn- MBN sbaw Ws bag ostin ogo’ baboggameE agbergMgd~byb. sbgan by~ega 93- gogds MEIQbaL, MimAgeg ghomd wsdoggMnrmowe yeagMb obone Ig%err6nb AemAg3So ([1958] 1969}: mamgdjengdoo gmBgeraggdo o~modnobab gbmg%g- Boboorgab SqbgSMngns. Imgengea Hm’ gnggoor, ogadosbgdo baygmegbeeab bodm- mm AoBbySnb bazombGo. gg rs6bdmgdno6. 38 sBeink godm erndmsergs LO _ejengsqQab Tgbsderms ImagoenganmpSgen bAxBgbab eomdmds serg- ere, | cmodgomo bio (1) BhoggMbomabs, cmadgGomoBIo spinggMboenrgtn gobo godBonggdab dogds BarQIgAH Bao oMgdqengogoo rodgroenyyrin BBG yBorgdermBo acgadnabnb ggerg8g80 QndgMomarreandmyMoG. samGym QndgMoergtin GMngdgodJo , SeegMomobSqGo endyMerabéo | baa8Seuodao Bgbeingnbo396 LE Moggo oMgdyergdsow SerigMommoBJo gabbbgoggdab 3mennGago sorGa%gean garaeaso BgerBogaroarocre bdo Seq Mocergn meangazghn gyeMdgoo44 SmepngoginGo negmarmgngda Gomoy Asgriod gb godm3gaeb BISySorgdaomanb qBmqbggmadymg egadgeo- AA oBLGGqGo, Grammy IengMoenBInb gmbSgdbG8o Sghringabs eo LGodnerghimdab pboMhig6gdnb bagggagbe wa, omBooy, yMaseagti boBgo- Rgdsos B6o'BZE{mBoL’. ogdGo, GmgmmMy 30 eRndpmomoBso. emmMocmayh See Momna BAL o~Qnsgdb, Gorgega bragdo Inbargnb epndyocrgein Boefen’ Immiggds. gemb |rigaboogals (Gay, 1995b), Iogoernawe, Ser-gMomaBéo “Iebs- emndgMocng®” Smbagoab aegernbbdmdb, GmBegnbs dobgrognowy, eodptorrgy Mamgdqjengdgdb, oBLSNGyGgdvs wo Mpgndgob mggnGod-grmads%y Smbeser- cane Qo gorggcna odo modgGomo bo, Botonggermds ws ~gdemgHoGoo mndgMomyMo LabgmdBagm NdgMoengab oe byggrou, Mm’ (aerggrEr Mono orogobygecro JOg@neq- Bo od BgdsymgeamBacn gogMoinabgagdo SqbydMingow gobogomargBb gober- BobGermpd-jer, GmangMobSger Lodmgowmgdsb. LSmAg~g 09 bognobBa om gosbb8gdns6 emndgMoengdn abaMgobSgab, MmAergdboy booting of Bosk6o- Sor 913 gaHmEn Wd SM BoogMmds. MBgMompah goymBngMpSqera odgn bagtinbg abobs, md aogabiggar omodna6gdb, bog gastin nBGgMgbgdagoo QodmAgnds%g, Bgadernser QahogMmb, gsdoMgge o6 bigeroy Ambgdsee ofgo- on6-bbggda. ong Labgatime Snakbagh, bsgostin ymbGModhqo0b aomddnds inga(y Bgaderoser[sdrGmd gaan o~odsbab oagabygergdodo bb gaon (gaigMmanb bagranbyg ag yeablagdo. Bgndengdo andgab, bs Bmgscr- Bab yrggern Bggtn bagrinbgb “gq46nb Logob ws oogomorg adage sbangg Lsoymionbab gg. Rga6a onsgobiqgengds dmanbengh, bbggd¥ ago Bgozogb Ao- ba bgeayma@abogs6, oom angabgqengdoyy, gab dbt%ng, Bgqba96 CoGacrmdsb bogarimgdb. eradgMomgdh, GMoOaGag@oe, Lda, md sbgan ~oiygo Aber came bunggtighgen bsbgmdBagmb byee_Boggds, magerbog bobmgogmgdab Bogner yggens oenggryera Byg@obs arg gaqgab gogmOBMmengdab qosen ogg s8cqg6w9, rdgabyqengds Bgndengdo aMbgdmBaqh Bberermnag “\zo6mbab 3n- mBg3Bn"; geerG eengb orgy waggbgbbydnar: “mognbygergdo om oMob ng, boQog o8mB0 oF orHbigBmdb”. gb amg gdg6Go beagasingtn gmbGMagGab agmMina boygdggeros, Mendy cng Bghigom Sng bog3198y80 o1mdsb 3mBLI (Hobbes, ab. gg. 86) @o RMB eomJ- Bo gobogosrigh Qo MmAgenawy eondgMomgdn babgendBaginb BabsGy nbcgngo- canb ImenGogyh gommeagdgergsgao gobIomMGogq6. SmSLIs qo ermjz8o wabs- Ggb byMoern GbmgMpBnbs qhobgmdBagem, BorogMmBsBeeger boomascomgao- Bo. abgo bs dmgagmgdsb obabo “BqGgdob babgerdSagerb” yBraggdm6ys. Ma«g- 305 ogadnabgdn mogggtdo, boo wa domoggengsnbdmygoreyerbn sM36, dey- Bgdab babgerdBagmbsargnb Igmango Iababnsegdgerd ofSqdergo LoAmdograden 80 compas ygarreb Sabssmdmga, AmAg~mng, Smabab bogygqdoo, aegs8naGnb Lagmgbeng ofg3mmqe “gyEn0, boByorro, bodoggera, bobgogo es“eondghisennbda 45 abgceabgega Goaembrgmbn qo Imeyagynjmba. gongs bmBgMbgG3; B@Sb3q- Gob Sortggegn |Maqab, gBombn gBana yqdgab Arengbow gobramBodegg mogyer- 98a Bgcengabab LBageymBres. Gabo ImenagagaGo Bpdgcegergdqd0 oBgcqabnb Mggr- exggonk qeb'q RadmyoerndQo. comgh, sdbmemgGobdab qoeigs mImbgbHL, Baro 16BB Bennb “BMByoGgorrg Aggmesggonk” goembmagmbb gBmcegdg6, 08 Mggmerageabs, MmBgerdsry gmbbso~ SgyoNMN Bmbsrigas ~oodjgnreMo. aqmja omMggern EynByMacgabIab gMor ghar Besgorh Ima bMimgege rengengds. Bororrerns, emmgo SAmpBo, Amd omodnaGgdo Bubqbnn ongabygerrin «ws asbsbGmAbn oFn36, AgMod qBomoBgbeds, mIgabsyy ob bogyertighob qqergdg3b oGndgdmes, boerb Brags, ombodgerengg aba SfeGo- Qo SmeRNGag Ae onsbobErembabo go cwqdmgMagna'p. eomgab ysacpdg B6oBgbq- eimgs6n Smegngnggto BrimAgdna GyPingen GmengMohGmdnb oomBo by (ALetter Con- coming Toleretion, 1689) ros BBamiaggaymdnb mtn GMoJ9 (Two Treatises of Government, &} 1690). bSbIMeng”. odo Bgeggow, Isa oBinen, Imo%omgbgba Bgorsbbdeagdmebyp, obey “brignoerrg® gmbGMoJGb” googeMag8wbye biggM@gSgern Boraggere- Bab PSdmyserndgdnb bagnorb%g, Amaceab gomgdqg Badergogero ofBgdege ImByLFnggdyyero Ws LGdoerxjGn GhmgMgdo. gobmB Madyamydigaro babgy- Babs BgbsfB6jeraee ygaers abrangawh «yBmo:geunompdnbs bogota ongabyg- eagdob GsBemob abbgg3erow gorgdab sagnmaberets Baboomdcegg: 3g2- anbgggoTo Asan -ggengdgdo 19; 3 ado ows, Lary Anwdago bsBo8- 3 adBgdmrcos.[BmBLBog eo a a mn gh “3mbGMog- G0" abGeeingaen GagGne oymr. begrsergtia gmbGGoJGab og gdq6Gob Ao- Bobo abrengowgabaagab beygaMgh geno babgerdBagm’ Io IgogermBnb SoBe BgBoo. bbgoagoMow Fmd gordgo0r, IMBLLS co EAMgL bgMi~maar, ABagnmgdo oby Ie garnenoyg6y6,, end abGrrmoqena Gogigne sgBIoMnggdob wodbgoghyBmeo; abgonn qgago: BorgmBnbs eo ga6mbab Imefnergdabs Qa. SsGagolyygdob arjmabbamdas doe@erngMgdob 6o863Q 03. qLogmnbmpdabargab, MmBgeray Doman byggMgiqer babgendBogn’ Byqderns qbmbggeryb. Lmgnagnatin gmbQMogGab ofiggdjhGo aagab orga agMans6gdb. coodg- ocaens Godceg6n¥g Fr Bgbgerrgos agommbs inkl smbsMaSacoe bobgmd6o- gerbs Qo Basse Imigagngghin daeroygyengdab BgbsbqB. Sarigger ag Bo, ab gejenabbdmdb, Fim Smengaggeo damraggenges, geMgsoDT 8239000, S4gq8eQo6” Bencgnb. LabgmBogmb abrengnregda A606 sbggq_ nbwengowgdo- Loargab; dnbo oMibgdmBab BaBsGs, Aor abSMnkjSbs wo BmarbmgrengdgVb DAbsb Amb. BBstinggermds Iomargeror ByoobIgarQV6, 96 ow6b8mBaQob om- Bmniggbcegds- grjenabbAgds, mI Amgomredggdn SmermAeg gomegogcrbo o ofns6, yggeRo go5mbb wagdmmocems 96 oraggemdab SgSnb8ng%a qeAds Boncenb. forg BoogMmos JmoGMoGGv awadonds, MmIgeboy AaraggenmOnb dg08 Byorg3Gn sceg 966, omgow~ BonsgMmBad Bgodengdo 99 gmbSMoJob 3o%e- BqBo osMagomb. ag, LeOsQy BWoranggermBab erganGasgemds oBFnGgoo,46 dmemnGoginn ogggmermgngan SHIT GOD SRSHYHSAD |yaqqs gdeggoor 98 Iabgndod gobgoorstgoob goo QogH mMgnb BagSIn AorenggermBk mo GGoAGoG0 (Two Treatises of Gover; ment) ({1690} 1962); Bobo 8a bsGn 1688 Benab “SAB yobgsong Mpgeemeagoo’” 37 Aomonngds aym, HmBgendory GHrbGogQa6 Rodmagcm gzgndb Aymeg wo HnGor| Boro Anqg “oernadabs’ go ~geMGee” dorinadnb BdsminggermBan gmbbHor GaGogtn rbsm Yao oodyots. gb 3en6.yn3n sbggq Boars goImbsg> axndols RIG]Mb BIG (defferson, ab. ag. 55) Cade gosgdermdab oOgMn ger wg jeroeo- 90980 (1776), mAgerBng sobgbomgegeroo: meaghag SBomonggermds sBbr- eg Gig egh3mBobIob bobgb aga’, “boenbb ggergds odgb, Bagram’ 26} googgémb ogo”. Ageeigg, bmgnomgtin ymEMogOob amino babyrdSagmb. bigsghoe- IoGPnb 96 Kyo Moee-ga oMdn{Mnb qg6{goob goGigSqbgab. babgerdBage oh othab Bgd86nema SMngaceganrgdyero JernGab Bog, MmAceab bggnega dobg- Bob gdderqoGo nas. bobgmrBBageb boygdgger yggcro oodasbh Smenb Bg ons6b3QB09 1Q>, a8eggow, ob yggero Amgoeradad oGHyMgLgb> ogMarnsbgBb wo FgrGMserghin sMnGMab mero ygggerobgoo, Gmeapboy abengomgso ony BYVIIO FOI6yob IomobIomondns6Togaqaow, 08 IpdarbyQgeIn, Oy GORATTEO o~dsosbgon cooreggggg® Loggdao6 scegdiger yerbGo4Gb,' bor bgen8Bngzen “fonsdsGab Ggbgdb” oyyGgdb eo ymbGMoJGab dorimdg3b gobsbme- Gagengdb. Mo ards q6co9, nggeablIgds, md ornamggann Bbq. gmbSMogOL BpdoyzenmBians Qo LgePn IobgbobagdermBaor. BprygMags. Sgoab8ngr%n abgor bgighomdo8 nb ‘dbo Bgbgemgo8gbn Asbsbosagdgenns ob, Fmd Babo fAg~adgdo BogggMdmgBgeyns Qo abgensge aqadagds yoRgG: og goMaw, IMB Asengdn bsbgendBagm’ bo dmgscqmgdsBa mosdomobIomyB.yer obangAE Eo R|TGoo Ercink AmdGnggdom eMBoSMow gobnbacrogg6- gmbbGoGyGo1gHo Woringgenmds Aotnsenns, candy Monga BamonggermBab bogntimgdsBo gggo 9% g30"%gd90, Bogtod yor gore bycngy6 03 LogMonbygdb, GoBeegBbog ab BomdmBmab. dono aBeinoy, yggers Bastongaermds ab—oogomab = aygtin Gatabass] gion dbeAng, sbgoo See bagendggenn ob gore, Amd BaogMimds baggMasgern doemoggmgsoass sagyMgorra Qo s8oGm’ Bgogo- eab ensgobngengdab deqio80g bogtinbgb ‘gdawnb. dgmeg Beng, gb ab jg69.do~ ensggangdob Sobor cpodgtoeannargab Qedsbabasogdger Bre sbsbogu/a—o- Tosbgdn sogaMigaosbo Gabaragajo0 sob «Qs any DomoyRagood — Vogoo dag~ goby aogergGob Ambrapbab «qbseb ~ fog qgqgda bger, abobo Bb, dybgngos, onsgnbsgg babomagdeamme godmnygigd96, Gaz Lbgoos borge’by. Bom Gagowu end gorggoon cmodgmomgan 88h 35936, Ged garnBl ergs damraggengdo nab jmMungsrsb. pb sBHns ZosoMgdqeno cemMicg sfGeBob Emory 39g MenboengdsBo: “amroyyangd> bABEAL, bmegm sdbmergGyMio domoggerges LABEL. sBbmergG-yH0@”, od Inbbogg cwabzg6oBo: “wnwo s~osdns6gdo Babs ynggemenqal (amcoo sc@sdosbgdo otiaa6”Jadngedas, md mmodgtoergoo enogobyygocna BdscanggenmBab oggab wyMorbs6 go Bberperyer Bdotorgy-gpndgtioepn®do 47 3b G08330mbemmo bdo gmBbGagiGambsayab—n, goBrim goandam, Bba gees doraggeymdab gobbmrAyog- arabes, Fim@gerboey gmb_GnG Gs qeeagh bogndgerow. gmBUanGqgorboeenbIo, 03 ao and0m, Upndergds nerdgab, smbgdmab of, Lewsey smoLSqEr-g% go6mbjan doeong- e98King odbsnGgSgdv2 qo ImernGogy Imager oad aoe ogmBGmergah. Darin Goram goaqana, jrbbAoSqGomboanBAn sink Imaagagge eompdyergsoors £29 AnbBmaggdsons goMggqneen babGqdo, mageency godmbogagb gdb, eonggab ogo- Legqeegdd Egerabiggerqnbngal Bobsgs6 go gaMgaoba Sbegreggab wesBybyoom. Anbargab godababasegdgeras smbrdagea™ egdamgd9or SbarigodgMs, HmBergooy grObGaSmGamBocra Bab Ankbobb gob09¥yogg8b; ghgbro: babBydTo Imygabnern, 3m5- bGoBga9», BeRQdoas Bogen, dommag|eqgooo godngeqGa, mAdoepoGnoGmB9 wo qqwI- Macead3o sey BaP Ges. shy Med, smebsrSqGomboenab4 Imeragogaro mndgoeenBAnb babgmaso. eamBab Sob gad gIbMmBns6. IasgmmBs Bggderod By beoremb 6 “Inrfoeea gaboqgmb” ymbbGoGggrg Bdq-g7Og98b, 06 wydmyMagnab, Gob aomdoyy BmBcaggGm JgqagJo gobsydMgdo. FHEGAGTGAS Shinb Sqhans GMpoqEa, Smagmaws Indsbay dosmorggaer Bab Lbgow@abbge abbGaGqGb_ Breinb Smgoragmdgdnb, damoggergdgdobs wo GUSdoIobs@, ab Bomdmamggob Sybgab, Mmdeg- Bag ogo bymrabyygerqasb Boeing Heat gy obgann, ab bgmrobygergdob- angab damsrigqengdnb BmIsb

You might also like

• ილია ჭავჭავაძე - დემოკრატია

  

  Document70 pages

  ილია ჭავჭავაძე - დემოკრატია

  Marita

  No ratings yet
• მელოტი მომღერალი ქალი

  

  Document215 pages

  მელოტი მომღერალი ქალი

  Marita

  No ratings yet
• გურამ თევზაძე - კანტი

  

  Document273 pages

  გურამ თევზაძე - კანტი

  ელეონორაქვილითაია

  100% (5)
• • Magazines
  • Podcasts
  • Sheet music
• ალბერ კამიუ - სიზიფის მითი

  

  Document208 pages

  ალბერ კამიუ - სიზიფის მითი

  Marita

  89% (19)
• დიმიტრი უზნაძე - ზოგადი ფსიქოლოგია PDF

  

  Document451 pages

  დიმიტრი უზნაძე - ზოგადი ფსიქოლოგია PDF

  Marita

  80% (10)
• განმანათლებლობა (კანტი, ფუკო)

  

  Document54 pages

  განმანათლებლობა (კანტი, ფუკო)

  Marita

  100% (8)
• ბერტრან რასელი - ფილოსოფიის პრობლემები PDF

  

  Document77 pages

  ბერტრან რასელი - ფილოსოფიის პრობლემები PDF

  Marita

  100% (4)
• ქალები წარსულიდან

  

  Document88 pages

  ქალები წარსულიდან

  Marita

  No ratings yet
• ფრიდრიხ ნიცშე - ანტიქრისტე

  

  Document49 pages

  ფრიდრიხ ნიცშე - ანტიქრისტე

  ელეონორაქვილითაია

  100% (2)
• ალბერ კამიუ - უცხო

  

  Document44 pages

  ალბერ კამიუ - უცხო

  Marita

  100% (1)
• რელიგია და კულტურა

  

  Document29 pages

  რელიგია და კულტურა

  Marita

  100% (3)
• ფილოსოფია დამწყებთათვის

  

  Document147 pages

  ფილოსოფია დამწყებთათვის

  Marita

  100% (12)
• სამოქალაქო სამართალი

  

  Document9 pages

  სამოქალაქო სამართალი

  Marita

  100% (4)
• ილია ჭავჭავაძე - დემოკრატია

  

  Document70 pages

  ილია ჭავჭავაძე - დემოკრატია

  Marita

  No ratings yet
• რელიგია და ფსიქოანალიზი

  

  Document7 pages

  რელიგია და ფსიქოანალიზი

  Marita

  86% (7)
• კონსტიტუცია, მმართველობის ფორმები

  

  Document5 pages

  კონსტიტუცია, მმართველობის ფორმები

  Marita

  No ratings yet
• მექანიკური ფორთოხალი

  

  Document82 pages

  მექანიკური ფორთოხალი

  TheGreatZeus

  100% (1)
• სამოქალაქო შეგნება

  

  Document18 pages

  სამოქალაქო შეგნება

  Marita

  100% (1)
• დემოკრატია

  

  Document5 pages

  დემოკრატია

  Marita

  100% (1)
• ადამანის ძირითადი უფლებანი და თავისუფლებანი

  

  Document6 pages

  ადამანის ძირითადი უფლებანი და თავისუფლებანი

  Marita

  No ratings yet
• Academic Writing For Beginners in Georgian

  

  Document120 pages

  Academic Writing For Beginners in Georgian

  bermazer

  No ratings yet
• აზრის, ინფორმაციის თავისუფლება

  

  Document4 pages

  აზრის, ინფორმაციის თავისუფლება

  Marita

  100% (1)
• რელიგიის თავისუფლება

  

  Document5 pages

  რელიგიის თავისუფლება

  Marita

  No ratings yet
• სამართალი და სამართლებრივი სისტემები

  

  Document6 pages

  სამართალი და სამართლებრივი სისტემები

  Marita

  83% (6)