Professional Documents
Culture Documents
in
Maintenance
Cost
5%
Energy Cost
90%
Air Compressors
Positive Displacement Type
Centrifugal Type
Reciprocating
Rotary
Vertical Type
Screw
(high speed)
(100-500 cfm)
Horizontal
Balance Opposed
Radial
Flow
(200-5000 cfm)
Axial
Flow
Disadvantage: Oil
carry over
Motor starter
Inlet filter
After cooler
Valve
Inter cooler
Motor
Relief
valve
Trap
(Drain)
Trap
(Drain)
Pressure
switch
Receiver
Trap
(Drain)
Why Inter-cooler?
! Compressed air leaves cylinder at high
temperature
" Density is lower
" Volumetric decreases
! Inter cooling reduces temperature & volume
! Mass of air delivered increases
! Inter-cooler generally saves 7 %
Why After-Cooler?
How much is the energy savings?
A) Savings same as inter cooler - 7 %
b) Higher than inter cooler
c) Lesser than inter cooler
Why After-Cooler?
How much is the energy savings?
! At higher temperature moisture carry
over very high
! Condensed water moves with same
velocity of air
" Damage to instrument valves
" Makes instruments sluggish
Power consumption
Unload - 9 kW
Loading - 27 kW
Rs.
Rs.
Savings - Rs.59,000
Investment - Rs.50,000
Payback - 11 months
: Screw type
! Capacity
: 600 cfm
Refrigerated
Receiver
type
dryer
Average loading:
Load power
Unload power
Brine Air
Compressor
(6.5 bar, 210 cfm)
60%
: 85.2 kW
: 43.5 kW
Receiver
Annual Savings
Investment
Payback period
: Rs.4.28 lakhs
: Rs.0.02
: < 1 month
! Reciprocating compressor
stand by
= 180 kW (40%)
= 165 kW (40%)
# Operate Reciprocating
Compressor on continuous basis
! Keep Screw as stand by
P2 - P1
P
. VR .
1
t
= Atmospheric pressure
Reciprocating Centrifugal
FAD
Screw
KW
549
521
650
Specific Power
(kW/m3/min)
4.9
4.65
5.8
= 7.0 kg/cm2
! Motor
= 120 kW
10
= 7.0 ksc
! Specific Power
11
12
: Rs.31.86 lakhs
: Rs.8.25 lakhs
: 4 months
13
P
r
e
s
s
u
r
e
Upper Limit
7.0
Average Pr.
6.5
Ksc
6.0
Time
Savings Due to
Pressure
Reduction
With VFD
Reqd. Pr.
Time
14
1500
# Compressors Designed to
meet Fluctuating Load
C
F 1400
M
R 1300
e
q
1200
d
1100
# No useful work
12
24
Time
Case Study
PIC
VSD
Power In
Users
Receiver
M
Compressor 2
M
Compressor 3
4 Compressors in
Operation
Compressor 4
15
= Rs.12.00 Lakhs
= Rs. 12.00 Lakhs
= 12 Months
Precautions
Reciprocating Compressors
# Lubrication Oil Pump Connected to
the same shaft
Alternative
# Install Separate Lubrication Pump
# Complicated
# Details to be Studied
16
Production, 50%
Base Demand
(kW)
Total Demand
(kVA)
Time
17
PSIG
12:15
13:37
14:36
15:58
Time
18
Air In
On Load
Air Out
PSIG
On Load
Air Out
Air In
C/A Bypassed
Air In
On Load
Air Out
Unloaded
Air Out
Air In
C/A Online
19
!
!
!
!
= 20 Lakhs
= Rs. 29 Lakhs per annum.
= 2392 kWh/day ( ~ 19 % )
= Less than 9 months
105
95
85
160 kW
160 kW
160 kW
20
105
95
160 kW
85
160 kW
160 kW
to the plant
# Full automation of the present Compressor
System
# 18% Energy Savings Achieved
21
Annual savings
Investment
Payback period
Rs 12.58 Lakhs
Rs 15.0 Lakhs
14 Months
22
Minimise Leakages
! Common in all industries
! Tricky
! Quantification
Quantification
! Allow compressor to run normally
! Allow compressed air to flow in the system
! Close all the user points
! Measure the loading and unloading time
! Percentage of loading time is percentage of
leakages
23
Leakage Test
# Close all user points
# Charge the lines
# Note: On-load time of compressor (T)
Off-load time of compressor (t)
# Q : Capacity of compressor
Air leakage : L =
% air leakage =
T
T+t
.Q
Air leakage
Compressor capacity
x 100
Power
Orifice dia Air Leakage
Annual Savings
Wasted
(mm)
(cfm)
@ Rs.3.50/kWh.
(kW)
1.6
6.5
1.26
Rs.35,000
3.2
26.0
5.04
Rs.1,40,000
6.4
104.0
20.19 Rs.4,25,000
24
Calendar
Blower
AIr
25
= 4 kW/100 cfm
26
ETP
- 0.5 ksc
Annual Savings
Investment
Payback period
: Rs.3.36 lakhs
: Rs.0.50 lakhs
: 2 months
27
Action
# Replaced 40 pneumatic grinders
Annual Savings
Investment
Payback period
Annual Savings
Investment
Payback period
Atmospheric
Air
Compressed Air
@ 7.0 KSC
28
Existing ball
valve
New ball valve to
be provided
Compressed air
header
Nozzle pipe
Action
$ Provide a ball valve at the end of the pipe
Savings - Rs. 3.6 lakhs
Dessicant
Heatless Type
Dessicant
Heated Type
Refrigeration Type
Dessicant Heat of
Compression Type
29
100%
Service
Saturated Air
Heating
AC1
100%
Service
Saturated Air
Cooling
AC1
30
Low
High
High Medium
High Very Low
Medium Low
-40
-40
-40
-20
Medium
High
High
Low
150
100-750
>500
100
- 32 kW
- 10% ~ 5m3/min
31
32
33
Compressor Layout
Loop header most efficient
! Pressure losses are lesser
! Easier to add/delete user points
Compressor Layout
Loop
Unit loop
34
Compressor Layout..
Grid
Unit grid
Equivalent
power loss
(kw)
40
1.80
9.5
50
0.65
3.4
65
0.22
1.2
85
0.04
0.2
100
0.02
0.1
35
# Type of valve
! Globe Valves - Very high pressure drop
! Butterfly valve, Gate, Ball valves - Low
pressure drop
Dessicant
Heatless Type
Refrigeration Type
Dessicant
Heated Type
Dessicant Heat of
Compression Type
36
in
Regeneration
in
Regeneration
Purge
Heater
Blower
100% saturated air
(from compressor)
37
Refrigeration Dryer
Dry air
15oC
Air, 100%
saturated 7
kg/cm2,
28oC
17oC
2oC
Drain
Refrigeration
Unit
100%
Service
Saturated Air
Heating
AC1
38
100%
Service
Saturated Air
Cooling
AC1
39