Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I. Introduction
In Indonesia, English is used as the third language or foreign language. The first
language is the local language, such as Javanese, Sundanese, and Sumatranese. The
second language is Bahasa Indonesia. However, in the field of education English has
been taught from elementary school up to the university level. English becomes one of
the important subjects in education. Nowadays, it becomes international language, for
example it is used in the language of business, economy, thought, and technology (Nur,
2004:20)
English has been being taught in Indonesia for many years. Unfortunately, up to
the present time, it has not given satisfactory result. Murdibjono (1990: 18) identified
the factors of the failure of the teaching of English as a foreign language in Indonesia.
They are: (1) the size of the class; (2) the environment; (3) the quality of the teachers;
(4) the time allotment for English; and (5) the students motivation. Those factors above
constitute the weaknesses of teaching and learning English in Indonesia.
In Indonesia, English at secondary level is offered as compulsory subject. A
compulsory subject means that the school should be ready, particularly with the teacher
resources, learning resources and curriculum. The major motivating rationales
underlying the decision to teach English to young learners are the status of English
language and Indonesians political and economic commitment to keeps up its relations
with foreign countries using English. Besides political reasons, parents demand also
forces the school to provide English education. Parents are concerned that their children
achieve high levels of English language proficiency and they are aware of that learning
English in earlier age support their children for better learning process in the higher
level. There are also some studies suggesting about the teaching of English at earlier
age. A study carried out in Korea relates to ELT at secondary school revealed that there
is positive effects of early English in Korea and Japan. It was also found that the early
English education helps to enhance studentsinterest toward English and facilities
learning motivation toward English after entering junior high school (Kutsuyama,
Nishigaki, and Wang 2008).
Related to the problems of teaching English, Kasbolah (1993:49) says that the
school and community also influence the teaching and learning of English. In this
regard, a language environment will significantly arouse the interest of the students to
learn English more enthusiastically. In other words, the teaching of English needs to be
linked to the language community in which the language users can communicate it one
another. Based on the research findings conducted by Efendi in 1987 about the students
English proficiency at Pondok Pesantren Gontor, it showed that the teaching and
learning of English in that pesantren becomes successful because of three factors.
Firstly, English is used regularly as a means of communication. Secondly, all of the
members in that pesantren speak English in their daily routines. The process of teaching
and learning English uses method and strategy which are effective and efficient.
Consequently in formal or informal meeting, the students need vitality and enthusiasm
to carry on the necessary oral work, from at the beginning, day after day, week after
week, they must use English as their medium of communication.
This research was done at IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary School
Palembang as a case study. It is located in Veteran Street No.F-3 Kelurahan 9 Ilir
Kecamatan Ilir Timur II Palembang. There are 5 classes in that school (3 classes of 7th
grade and 2 classes of 8th grade). Each class of 7th grade consists of 19 students and
each class of 8th grade consists of 18 and 28 students. English is taught as a compulsory
subject at IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary School Palembang. It means English
should be learnt at IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary School Palembang
specifically. IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary School Palembang has some
distinctive features such as it tries to develop the students in science, technology, and
cultural art by learning the subject from other countries through studying their books
which have not been translated into Indonesian. Moreover, it tries to create a good
learning environment that is especially dealing with language mastery. The students
learn English more intensively and use English as their compulsory language in their
daily communication. Besides studying English in the classroom, they must follow
some training to improve the students English proficiency such as English speech
training, English debate training, TOEFL Preparation class and English speaking class.
On Monday and Wednesday, the students of IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary
School Palembang have speaking class. This strategy gives the students more
opportunities to practice their English after regular schedule. Besides, each student has
to use English in his or her daily communication during the school time. The students
will be punished if they do not follow the rule. Usually the punishment is that they have
to look for some vocabulary items, memorize them, and put them into sentences. On the
other hand, the teachers have to apply reward (external incentives such as giving
dictionaries and point) in order to get the students involve in learning English.
Another distinctive activity, on morning briefing, the students have to perform
short speech based on the schedule they have got. They can take the material from the
scientific texts such as Biology, Chemistry, Physics, and Mathematics on other
information such as sport and travelling. Even though it is classified as a new school in
Palembang, the success of the teaching of English at this school can be proved through
the fact that many students of IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary School
Palembang had won some English competitions such as English Speech Competition,
English Debate Contest, Spelling Bee Contest, etc.
That was the main reason researcher to investigate the teaching and learning of
English as a foreign language at IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary School
Palembang. Therefore, the objectives of this study are; 1) to find out how the teaching
of English in terms of planning, implementing, and evaluating system was carried out at
IGS (Ignatius Global School) Secondary School Palembang, b) to figure out the
problems were commonly found by the teacher(s) and by the students of English in
terms of managerial and instructional problems at IGS (Ignatius Global School)
Secondary School Palembang, d) to find out what the students attitudes toward the
English program, and d) to find out the attitudes and involvement of students parents
toward the English program.
picture, audio recording, motion picture, television, real things, simulations, and
models, programmed and computer-assisted instruction.
f. Evaluation Systems
Ornstein (1990:111) says that evaluation is a process in which we put a value or
assign worth to something. Another definition of evaluation is uttered by Coombe and
Hubley (2007:12),
It is a process where in the parts, processes, or outcome of a
progress are examined to see whether they are satisfactory
particularly with reference to the program's stated objectives,
our own expectations, or our own standards of excellent. The
assessment of a program's outcome or results is facilitated by
measurement.
B. Factors in Teaching and Learning Process
The review of factors in teaching and learning process consists of the review
about teachers and students.
a. Teacher
Teacher is the most powerful person in the classroom (Gebhard, 2000: 9). He
has the authority to influence the kind of interaction that goes in the class. Each teacher
has his own teaching style, but they should be based on teaching principles. Mercer
(1989:12) states that teaching styles are developed individually, but they should not be
based on whims, biases, or personal opinions. Teachers have the responsibility of
examining the research and applying the findings as they develop teacher practices. One
of teaching principle drove the teacher to enjoy teaching, since good teaching is a
difficult job. It requires a lot of physical and mental energy.
b. Student
In order to teach effectively, the teachers need to learn about their students, since
some of the procedures will vary depending upon the students in their classes.
The teaching and learning process were conducted using pre-activities, whilst
activities, and post activities.
Pre-activities
In the lesson plan, the pre-activities were allocated 10 minutes, but in fact the
teacher sometimes takes more than 10 minutes to make the students ready to study.
In pre-activities, the teacher began the lesson by greeting the students, e.g. good
morning students, how are you today? Then, the teacher asked students some questions.
Before the teacher told the students about the topic of the lesson, sometimes the
teacher did a review. The teacher thinks that it is necessary to review the previous topic
of the lesson in order to keep students memory on the previous topic of the lesson.
This short activity was aimed to rehearse topics or things they had studied effectively, to
check their understanding of previous topic of the lesson, to wake them up and to
stimulate them. Moreover, the review activities also linked the previous topic of the
lesson to the topic that the students would discuss on that day.
After that, the teacher told the students about the topic of the lesson, for
example, ok class, today we gonna have a very interesting topic. Our topic today is
Sport. Then the teacher gave the apperception sport, for example by asking the students
some questions.
Generally, the students responded positively to the teachers apperception. It
could be seen from students enthusiasm in answering teachers questions.
Then, the teacher asked the students to open their textbook. (Sometimes the
teacher showed some pictures to link to the topic of the lesson or played a video.
Whilst-activities
In whilst-activities, the teacher asked the students to open their book and
explained the topic/material in the book. During the teaching and learning process, the
teacher provided the four language skills; listening, speaking, reading, and writing. The
teacher also created English atmosphere by making students speak English and involve
in the teaching and learning process through whole class, small group, and individual
activities based on the activities and the objectives of the activities.
Besides doing exercises and the tasks on the book, the students were also asked
to answer the questions directly. Sometimes they were asked to write their answer on
the whiteboard, for example answering the questions of the reading text, arranging
jumbled sentences, filling in the table, etc.
In presenting the materials, the teacher tried to make the students fully
understand the material. The teacher motivated the students to study by asking the
questions to almost all students in the class. The teacher gave instruction in English. If
the students did not understand, the teacher would use gesture or gave tactile clues
along with verbal instruction and then the teacher it into Bahasa Indonesia.
In getting students attention, the teacher firmly named the students, who were
still talking during the teaching hour, for example, Rafli, be quiet please! or the
teacher sometimes asks those students some questions.
Post-activities
In post activities, the teacher asked the students some questions which were
related to the lesson to make sure whether the students understood or not. Next, the
teacher concluded the topic of the lesson, then the teacher sometimes gave homework.
However, for some classes, the teaching and learning process could not be
exactly based on the lesson plan. The teacher sometimes did improvisation in order to
match to the real situation during the class hour, for example because when the students
were too tired because of having too many daily exams on that day.
b) The Results of Outside Activities Observation
Dealing with the use of English during the break time, some students were
consistently using English while chatting with their friends, and others were using
Bahasa Indonesia combining with English, for example Kelvin, lets go to the canteen,
I want traktir you. However, the students were always trying to use English when they
greeted the teachers and other staff and the students also showed their enthusiasm to
speak English with the teachers even though they did some mistakes
c) The Results of Questionnaire for the Students
The responses from the students revealed that the materials were 70.58%
interesting, 20% boring, and 9.41% neutral. Those who said that the materials were
interesting gave the reason that they like their teachers who were friendly, patient and
often made jokes; the class was relaxed, and the materials were not very difficult.
Moreover, according to the students, the teaching techniques commonly used by the
teachers were explaining and giving grammar exercises (45.88%), listening to CD or
audio (17.64%), translating English text into Indonesian (20%), comprehending the text
without translating English text into Indonesian (12.94%), and other techniques
(17.64%). The other techniques mentioned by the students were story retelling, singing,
discussion, memorization, and games. In short, the teacher used varied techniques in
teaching.
The students' opinion and perception toward the opportunity given by the
teachers to be active during teaching and learning process were that 61.17% said that
the teachers always gave the opportunity, 27.05% said that the teachers said sometimes,
and 11.76% said that the teachers said often. This finding showed that the teachers were
supportive and able to create a good atmosphere with their students.
According to the students, their teachers did not always give homework every
day. The students' responses stated that the teachers never gave homework to the
students (7.05%), sometimes (43.52%), often (36.47%), and always (12.94%). When the
teachers gave homework, they always checked and discussed it. Besides English, the
languages used by the teacher in teaching and learning process were 83.52% English
combining Indonesian and 16.47% Indonesian.
The students' opinion and perception toward the frequency of the teachers in
using the media showed that 41.17% of them always used media, 34.11% sometimes,
21.17% often, and 3.52% never. According to the students, the kind of media often used
by the teacher was whiteboard (51.76%), laptop and LCD projector (30.58%), and
pictures (17.64%).
The students said that they got a test every week (42.35%), every chapter
(34.11%), everyday (14.11%), and anytime whenever it was needed (9.41%). The forms
of the test given were oral test (67.05%), written test (22.35%), and multiple choices
(10.58%). The languages used in the test were English (100%).
Most of the students said that English was partly difficult (14.11%). The rest
said that it was difficult (20%), and not difficult (65.88%). The problems faced by the
students are listening (20%), grammar (22.35%), speaking (30.58%), vocabulary
(17.64%), reading comprehension (5.88%), and writing (3.52%).
d) The Results of Questionnaire for the Teachers
The questionnaire for teachers consisted of 15 questions. The questionnaire was
in the form of open questions. The questionnaire included the objective of teaching, the
syllabus, the material, the teaching technique, the media, the evaluation system, and the
teacher's problem they faced in teaching of English.
e) The Results of Questionnaire for Parents
Parents involvement and attitude questionnaire consisted of 24 items. The
scores were determined by adapting the Likert system of five scales from 1 to 5. The
answer to the choice Strongly Agree (SA) got score 5, score 4 was given to the choice
Agree (A), score 3 was given to the choice Hesitantly (H), score 2 was given to the
choice Disagree (D) and score 1 was given to the choice Strongly Disagree (SD).
The scores for an item in a question were multiplied by the number of the
respondents who attempted to answer the item, and then the scores were totaled and
divided by the number of those respondents who answered the item. After all, the
average scores were totaled and divided by the number of items.
The scores of the answers to the items for parents involvement and attitude
questionnaire were given in table 2. The total scores of the items were 100.7 and its
average score was 4.19. It means that parents involvement in learning English was very
high
Furthermore, the total scores of the items were 60.7 and its average score was
4.04. It means that the parents attitude toward to the teaching of English to teenagers
could be classified as very high
f) Results of the Interview with the Teachers
Basically the English teacher felt that her students liked to learn English even
though the students did not always pay full attention on the lessons. There were some
students did not like being given exercise or homework but all of them did it well. In
addition, the students liked if they worked in a group rather than individual.
Moreover, the teachers told that most of the students liked listening English song
and do exercise by filling the missing words or phrases of the song lyrics. The students
thought that they felt happy and really enjoyed when they were learning new words by
listening their favorite songs.
g) Results of the Interview with the Students
Based on the result of interview, most of the students liked if the teacher used
English when communicate to them. However, the students still felt nervous and afraid
when they had to talk or answer questions in English. Some of them still felt difficult to
practice English out of the class for example with their friends, their teachers and other
staff. This was because they were afraid of making mistakes.
The students had some difficulties in learning English such as pronunciation,
translation, arranging the words, memorizing the words, answering the questions. They
were also afraid when they were asked to practice English in learning activities. They
were afraid to make mistakes in pronunciation and grammar. In addition, the researcher
asked the students who didnt pay attention to the teachers explanation and didnt
involve in teaching and learning process. Those students said that they were not
interested in the topic of the lesson, they were tired, the were getting bored, and they
didnt like English.
written test is only given when it is needed. At the end of each semester, the students get
an oral and a written examination.
Second, during the teaching and learning process, both students and teacher had
some problems. For the teacher, the problem is the students' variety in intelligence. To
make the students understand easier in their teaching and become, they use their own
creativity to make simple media. Moreover, the teacher sometimes got difficulties in
getting students attention while the teaching and learning process. For the students,
they still felt nervous and afraid when they had to talk or answer questions in English.
Some of them still felt difficult to practice English out of the class for example with
their friends, their teachers and other staff. This was because they were afraid of making
mistakes.
Third, dealing with the students attitude toward the English program, they had
positive attitude toward the English program. It could be seen from their response to
their teacher while the teaching and learning process. Moreover, some students were
consistently using English while chatting with their friends, and others were using
Bahasa Indonesia combining with English.
Fourth, dealing with the attitude and involvement of students parents toward the
English program, it was found that students parents had positive responses toward
teaching English at that school. By learning English at young age, the parents hoped that
their children could obtain a job easier in the future, have higher intelligence by being
able to use English, and could broad their knowledge because their children could get
more information if they mastered a foreign language. Moreover, in helping their
children learn English, they provided facilities which were needed by children learning
English, for example, dictionaries, English videos, English textbooks, English pictures,
etc. They also bought their children some programs in helping their children learning
English with fun and enjoyable ways in form of DVD, CD, and other software. The
parents also tried to ask their children to use at home by involving their children
mentioning some things at home using English and asking their children to practice
English in daily life.
Furthermore, some parents sent their children to English private courses. The reasons
why they took their children at the English private courses because their English were
not good and they hoped that their children could get some benefits and advantages at
English private course. They also hoped that their children were able to gain a better
mark for English subject at school, follow the English at school easier, and develop and
have courage to speak English.
REFERENCES
Alsayed, Mounawar. 2003. Factors that Contribute to Success in Learning English as a
Foreign Language. Damascus: Damascus University Journal Volume 19.
Berg, Bruce L. 2000. Qualitative Research Methods for the Social Sciences 4th Ed.
Long Beach: University of California.
Brown, H.Douglas. 2004. Language Assessment: Principles and Classroom Practices.
New York: Pearson Education
Brown, H.Douglas. 2000. Principles of Language Learning and Teaching 4th Ed. New
York: Pearson Education.
Brown, H.Douglas. 2004. Language Assessment: Principles and Classroom Practices.
New York: Pearson Education
Cahyono, Bambang Yudi. 1997. Pengajaran Bahasa Inggris: Teknik, Strategi, dan
Hasil Penelitian. Malang: Penerbit IKIP MALANG.
Cansler, Luis E. 2008. Parents Attitude about and Involvement with Foreign Language
Programs for Elementary Students. An Unpublished Dissertation. Chape Hill,
California: University of North Carolina.
Djiwandono, M. Soenardi. 1996. Bahasa Dalam Pengajaran. Bandung: Penerbit ITB.
Doff, Adrian. 1992. Teach English: A Training Course for Teachers. Glasgow: Bell and
Bain.
Dardjowidjojo, S. 2000. English Teaching in Indonesia. EA Journal, 18(1), pp. 22-30.
Fadhlun. 2006. The Teaching of English as a Foreign Language at Izzudin Elementary
School Palembang: A Case Study. Unpublished Graduate Thesis. Palembang:
Sriwijaya University.
Fraenkel, Jack R and Norman E Wallen. 2011. How to Design and Evaluation Research
and Education Eighth Edition. New York: Mc Graw-Hill Inc.
Freeman, Larsen Diane. 2008. Techniques and Principles in Language Teaching 2 nd
Edition. New York: Oxford University Press.
Gebhard, Jerry G. 2000. Teaching English as a Foreign or Second Language: A Teacher
Self -Development and Methodology Guide. Michigan: The University of
Michigan Press.