Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Product Name
Confidentiality Level
G3BSC
Product Version
Total 25 pages
Confidential
Prepared by:
Date:
2007-03-10
Reviewed by:
Date:
yyyy-mm-dd
Reviewed by:
Date:
yyyy-mm-dd
Approved by:
Date:
yyyy-mm-dd
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 1 of 25
Confidential
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 2 of 25
Confidential
Table of Contents
1 About KPI Definition..................................................................................................................... 6
1.1 KPI Name............................................................................................................................. 6
1.2 KPI Meaning......................................................................................................................... 6
1.3 Recommended Formula....................................................................................................... 6
1.3.1 Formula of the BSC32...............................................................................................6
1.3.2 Formula of the BSC6000........................................................................................... 7
1.3.3 Measurement Time Points......................................................................................... 8
1.4 Other Definition Modes of the KPI........................................................................................9
1.4.1 KPI Definition of Siemens.......................................................................................... 9
1.4.2 KPI Definition of Ericsson..........................................................................................9
1.4.3 KPI Definition of MTN.............................................................................................. 10
1.4.4 KPI Definition of Turkey VDF...................................................................................11
2 KPI Test Method.......................................................................................................................... 12
3 Constraint Analysis.................................................................................................................... 12
3.1.1 Test Method Constraints.......................................................................................... 12
3.1.2 Test Environment Constraints..................................................................................12
3.1.3 KPI Definition Constraints........................................................................................ 13
3.1.4 Parameter Constraints............................................................................................. 13
3.1.5 Function Constraints................................................................................................ 14
3.1.6 Inter-KPI Constraints............................................................................................... 15
4 Baseline Commitments.............................................................................................................. 15
4.1 Baseline Commitments...................................................................................................... 16
4.1.1 Baseline Commitments in the Event of Network Relocation....................................16
4.1.2 Baseline Commitments in the Event of New Network Construction.........................16
4.1.3 Risk Analysis............................................................................................................ 16
5 KPI Optimization Means............................................................................................................. 17
5.1 Factors Relating to the Immediate Assignment Success Ratio..........................................17
5.2 Immediate Assignment Success Ratio Solution.................................................................18
5.2.1 Possible Causes of SDCCH Congestions and Recommended Solutions................18
5.2.2 Flow Control Analysis of Channel Requests............................................................19
5.2.3 Possible Causes of Air Interface Problems and Recommended Solutions..............19
5.2.4 Possible Causes of Equipment Failure and Recommended Solutions....................20
5.3 Analysis Method of the Immediate Assignment Success Ratio..........................................20
5.4 Optimization Cases of the Immediate Assignment Success Ratio.....................................22
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 3 of 25
Confidential
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 4 of 25
Confidential
Revision History
Date
Revision
Change Description
Author
Version
2007-03-10
1.00
Liu Xiuyu
2007-03-16
1.10
Liu Xiuyu
comments.
2007-04-20
2015-01-22
1.20
Huawei Confidential
Wang Fei
Page 5 of 25
Confidential
Abstract
This document describes the definition, test method and constraints of the immediate
assignment success ratio.
2015-01-22
Full Spelling
Huawei Confidential
Page 6 of 25
Confidential
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 7 of 25
Confidential
Note: When comparing the formula of the BSC32 with that of the BSC6000 given above, we can
see that the channel requests of the BSC32 exclude the channel requests whose cause value is
AC_PACKET_CALL but the channel requests of the BSC6000 are only call-dependent.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 8 of 25
Confidential
MSC
BSC
Channel REQ
Channl RQD
A1
Channel ACT
Channel ACT ACK
IMM ASS CMD
B1
first SABM
UA
EST IND(CM Service REQ)
C1
CR(CMP L3 information)
CC
CM Service Accepted
Note:
A1: Immediate Assignment Requests (Channel Requests (Circuit Service))
B1: Immediate Assignment Commands
C1: Successful Immediate Assignments (Call Setup Indications (Circuit Service))
As can be seen from the above measurement time points, currently the immediate assignment
success ratio of the BSC32/BSC6000 covers Immediate Assignment Requests (Channel Requests
(Circuit Service)) and Successful Immediate Assignments (Call Setup Indications (Circuit
Service)). A1, Immediate Assignment Requests (Channel Requests (Circuit Service)), is counted
when the BSC receives the channel request message. It includes the repeated channel requests,
the channel requests discarded in the case of flow control and the channel requests in the case of
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 9 of 25
Confidential
channel congestion. The three groups of channel requests will have negative influence on the
immediate assignment success ratio.
Requests
(Immediate
Assignment
Commands
Successful
Immediate
Assignments))
1.4.1.2 Analysis
Because Siemens counts the immediate assignment requests before channel assignment, the
above formula of Siemens excludes the failed immediate assignments due to flow control, the
repeated channel requests and the failed immediate assignments due to the air interface factor.
The formula of Siemens only considers the failed immediate assignments due to congestion. For
this reason, the KPI value may be very large.
Requests
(Immediate
Assignment
Commands
Successful
Immediate
Assignments))) 100%
Then only congestion and channel activation NACK will cause immediate assignment failure.
Immediate assignment will succeed in other cases. Therefore, the immediate assignment success
ratio will be very high.
Where:
CCALLS: Channel allocation attempt counter (on SDCCH) in the immediate assignment
phase
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 10 of 25
Confidential
1.4.2.2 Analysis
We can learn from the above formula that Ericsson excludes flow control and congestion cases in
measuring the immediate assignment success ratio.
Note: We cannot know how Ericsson counts the SDCCH congestions of the underlay during
SDCCH assignment and the SDCCH congestions of the overlay during SDCCH assignment. If
both the overlay and the underlay are congested in the intelligent underlay-overlay (IUO) cell and
Ericsson counts the congestions of both the underlay and the overlay, the congestions will have
positive influence on the immediate assignment success ratio of Ericsson.
1.4.3.2 Analysis
We can see from the above formulas that MTN also excludes the failures caused by congestion
when measuring the immediate assignment failure ratio.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 11 of 25
Confidential
Because the denominator CCALLS is the number of SDCCH assignment requests, the formula
also excludes the failed immediate assignments due to flow control.
1.4.4.2 Analysis
We can see from the above formula that the immediate assignment success ratio of Turkey VDF
excludes not only the failures due to congestion but also the channel requests retransmitted.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 12 of 25
Confidential
3 Constraint Analysis
3.1.1 Test Method Constraints
The data of the time span in which bursty bulky traffic events take place should be excluded.
Problem Description
Environment
Coverage
There are problems such as blind spots, low coverage level or cross
coverage in the test environment, and such problems cannot be solved by
network optimization.
Interference
Transmission
The quality of transmission lines such as Abis interface links are poor or the
transmission links are instable due to various reasons in the test
environment. This part should be excluded from the statistics.
Equipment
Terrestrial resources are unavailable or the equipment fails. This part should
be excluded from the statistics.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 13 of 25
Test
Confidential
Problem Description
Environment
Traffic
The actual network traffic is unevenly distributed and some cells have a too
high congestion ratio on SDCCH and are not to be expanded.
Configuration Requirements
MS max.
retransmission count
MS minimum Rx level
The setting of this parameter will influence the coverage. A value too
large will result in smaller coverage of the network and a value too
small will increase the number of invalid access attempts or too low
access signal to cause call drops and thus lower the immediate
assignment success ratio.
RACH minimum
The setting of this parameter will influence the coverage. A value too
access level
large will result in smaller coverage of the network and a value too
small will increase the number of invalid access attempts or too low
access signal to cause call drops and thus lower the immediate
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 14 of 25
Parameter
Confidential
Configuration Requirements
assignment success ratio.
1)
2)
BTS3X: The RACH busy threshold will not influence the access of
the MS but will only influence the reporting of CCCH_LOAD_IND.
The setting of this parameter will influence the coverage. A value too
threshold
large will result in smaller coverage of the network and a value too
small will increase the number of invalid access attempts or too low
access signal to cause call drops and thus lower the immediate
assignment success ratio.
Extended transmission
timeslot count
Requirements
Immediate assignment
command
will be fewer times for the MS to resend the channel request and thus
retransmission
Dynamic adjustment of
SDCCH
Immediate assignment
of TCH
Immediate assignment
preferred
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 15 of 25
Confidential
Constraint Factor
1)
2)
function
(otherwise
the
committed
immediate
4 Baseline Commitments
The KPI baseline is the statistical result of the KPI for various types of networks defined by Huawei
according to the above KPI definition when the network uses totally Huawei products.
The specific conditions that may influence the KPI commitments include but are not limited to the
following:
The test method of the KPI, including the test tools, test steps and calculation method, is
consistent with that of Huawei.
Refer to the description of baseline constraints if the above conditions cannot be satisfied.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 16 of 25
Confidential
Analyze the differences between the calculation formula provided by the operator and our
calculation formula. Select a calculation formula with the least difference to match the formula
provided by the operator. Then analyze and evaluate the differences between the evaluation
formula provided by the operator and our baseline formula. Give the influence of the
difference on the final KPI result.
2)
Analyze the calculation formulas given by other vendors for the immediate assignment
success ratio and the measurement time points of various sub-indexes. Compare them with
our calculation formula and measurement time points for the immediate assignment success
ratio, so as to find the differences. Evaluate the statistical result deviations caused by the
differences and compare the differences according to the actual conditions of the network to
be relocated.
3)
The immediate assignment success ratio is a KPI measured after the network is ultimately
delivered and normally put into operation. The worsening of this KPI caused by accidental
equipment failure, natural environment factors or man-made factors should be excluded.
4)
The decrease of the immediate assignment success ratio caused by the rise of the
congestion ratio on SDCCH as a result of bursty bulky traffic should be separately
considered.
Combine the corresponding influencing factors on the above basis to make the corresponding KPI
commitments.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 17 of 25
Confidential
The factors influencing this KPI include SDCCH congestion, coverage, interference, balance
between the uplink and the downlink, and CCCH overload. Therefore, we should first consider
improving the coverage, reducing interference and optimizing the balance between the uplink and
the downlink so as to guarantee the capacity of SDCCH and CCCH when the index value required
by the operator is higher than the baseline value.
Influencing Factor
SDCCH
Flow Control
SDCCH
Radio
Congestion
of Channel
Activation
Interface
Request
NACK
Factor
Messages
Immediate Assignment Success
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 18 of 25
Confidential
As shown in the above table, four factors influence the immediate assignment success ratio:
SDCCH congestion, channel request message flow control, SDCCH activation NACK and radio
interface factor.
Location area planning: Reasonable planning of location areas can help reduce SDCCH
congestions.
2)
Dynamic SDCCH assignment: This function can be enabled to reduce the congestion ratio on
SDCCH.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 19 of 25
3)
Confidential
4)
Check whether the related timers are reasonably set. For example, check the settings of
T3101, T3103, T3107, T3122, T3212, T3111 and other timers.
Below are the definitions of timers and some suggestions on how to configure them:
T3101: We can reasonably decrease the value of T3101 so as to effectively reduce the
congestions caused by double assignment of the SDCCH. If the set value of T3101 is too
great, signaling resources will be seized uselessly for a long time and thus system resources
will be wasted. To optimize the utilization of signaling resources especially when the queuing
function is activated, we should appropriately reduce the value of this timer.
T3103 and T3107: We can appropriately reduce the values of the two timers so as to reduce
the waste of TCH resources. In general, these two timers are set to 5 seconds or so.
T3122: Upon receipt of the IMMEDIATE ASSIGN REJECT message, the MS will start the
timer T3122. The MS will not initiate a new channel request message until this timer expires.
We can increase the value of T3122 so as to prevent the MS from frequently sending the
channel request message when there is no idle resource in the system and thus prevent the
increase of RACH and CCCH load in the network.
Note: At present, T3122 is automatically controlled by the system but can be configured in
BSC6000V900R001C03B104 and later versions.
T3212: It is the periodic location updating interval. We can appropriately increase its value so
as to reduce the load brought by periodic location updating to the SDCCH.
T3111: Connection release delay timer. It is used to delay the deactivation of the channel after
the primary signaling link is disconnected and purposed to reserve a period of time for the
possible repeated disconnections. T3111 is started not only in the TCH release procedure but
also in the SDCCH release procedure. Its value should be consistent with the value of T3110
on the MS side and is generally set to 2 seconds. If we set T3111 to a larger value, plenty of
SDCCH congestions could occur.
related
to
flow
control
are
reasonably
set.
Refer
to
Instructions
for
Using
G3BSC32V300R007C01B018 Third Generation Flow Control for the specific debugging alarm
analysis method and parameter configuration. If BSC flow control is started, we can check the
traffic statistics and see whether the index Immediate Assignment Commands is far smaller than
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 20 of 25
Confidential
the index Immediate Assignment Requests (the difference between the two is more than half).
This method is only a reference for determining whether flow control is started.
2)
3)
The transmit antenna and the receive antenna of the cell are not on the same plane or their
down tilts are inconsistent. We can solve this problem by antenna tuning.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 21 of 25
1)
Confidential
First determine the formula used at the site for calculating the immediate assignment success
ratio and find the relevant factors.
2)
Determine the problem scope, that is, whether the problem is universal or only occurs to an
individual cell. If the problem is universal, analyze whether the problem is caused by BSC flow
control and whether the SDCCH capacity planning satisfies the system requirements. If the
problem only occurs to an individual cell, make the analysis from the aspects of equipment
failure, air interface and congestion.
3)
BSC flow control: Check whether the BSC has started the flow control function if the
busy-hour traffic is huge at the site. Check the related debugging alarms to find whether
the BSC has discarded channel requests. Check whether the software parameter
settings of flow control are reasonable and reach the equipment specifications if flow
control is enabled. If the equipment specifications are limited, we recommend that the
hardware capacity be expanded. Refer to the section 5.2.2Flow Control Analysis of
Channel Requests for the specific solution.
Equipment failure: First check TRX availability in BSC overall performance measurement
and SDCCH availability in SDCCH performance measurement. Second, observe the
number of TCH activation NACK/TIMEOUT times in TCH performance measurement. In
this way, we can determine whether the problem is caused by board failure. Refer to the
section 5.2.4Possible Causes of Equipment Failure and Recommended Solutions for
the specific solution.
Air interface problem: Interference will cause SDCCH congestions and thus result in a
low immediate assignment success ratio. In particular, the system may receive quite
many interfering random access signals and the network will assign an SDCCH for every
random access request when the site spacing is small and the planned BCCH
frequencies are dense. As a result, congestion will occur. When the immediate
assignment success ratio and the paging success ratio decrease in the traffic statistics,
the RACH is possibly overloaded in random access performance measurement. We can
analyze the idle interference band and the TRX receive quality in the conversation to
determine the problem cause. Refer to the section 5.2.3Possible Causes of Air Interface
Problems and Recommended Solutions for the specific solution.
System capacity (congestion) analysis. First analyze whether the ratio of SDCCH
seizures in location updating is normal according to experience. If the ratio is very high,
further observe the location area plan and perform the drive test to analyze whether the
borders of the location areas are set at places where there are plenty of subscribers.
Observe whether the ratio of SDCCH seizure requests related to location updating at
these borders is too high. That is, query the ratio of successful SDCCH seizures (location
updating) to the total successful SDCCH seizures in SDCCH performance measurement.
If the ratio is more than 50%, then it is too high. Re-plan the location areas if finding that
frequent location updating is caused by unreasonable setting of the location areas.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 22 of 25
Confidential
If the ratio of successful SDCCH seizures (location updating) is not high, analyze whether the
traffic per SDCCH exceeds the planned limitation. In this case, first optimize the traffic and check
parameters such as location updating and SDCCH dynamic configuration. If the related
parameters are reasonably set, then it is necessary to expand the capacity of hardware. Refer to
the section 5.2.1Possible Causes of SDCCH Congestions and Recommended Solutions for the
specific solution.
Below is the specific troubleshooting flow chart:
Start
Normal cells
End of
troubleshooting
Faulty cells
System capacity
(congestion) analysis
Equipment
fault
Air interface
problem
BSC flow
control
Analyze BSC
debugging alarms
Analyze the
RACH
overloads
Analyze the
equipment
specification limitation
Re-plan the
location areas
Faults of equipment
such as TRXs or
transmission problem
Solve the
interference
Start
Start
Start
Start
Start
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 23 of 25
Confidential
Check the TCH and SDCCH performance measurement indexes. The TCH traffic is not large
and the busy-hour traffic per cell is no more than 2.2 Erl. However, the number of SDCCH
seizure requests is huge and reaches 3023 in the busy hour, the busy-hour SDCCH traffic
reaches 1.86 Erl and the congestion ratio on SDCCH is up to 8%.
2)
Major causes of SDCCH seizures: Signaling before call establishment, signaling in the
handover, location updating signaling in the idle mode, and short messages.
3)
Because the TCH traffic is normal, the number of TCH seizure requests (including handover)
is normal (318 requests) and the number of handover requests (146) is also normal, we can
conclude that possibly the excessive SDCCH seizures are caused by excessive location
updating or short messages.
4)
Check the LAC of the BTS. The LAC is 0500. The LAC of all other cells around the BTS is
0520. Change the LAC of the BTS to 0520. After the change, the number of busy-hour
SDCCH seizure requests becomes 298, the SDCCH traffic becomes 0.27 Erl, the congestion
ratio decreases to almost 0 and the immediate assignment success ratio rises to 95%.
According to traffic statistics, there are 300 to 400 SDCCH seizures in the busy hour for the
congested cells. All the BTS sites adopt the S1/1/1 configuration and every cell has eight
SDCCH/8 channels. This can generally satisfy the needs of 300 to 400 SDCCH seizures, but
dozens of SDCCH congestions occurred to every cell in the busy hour.
2)
We registered related traffic measurement tasks and found that most of the SDCCH seizures
were caused by location updating. We then checked the locations of the BTS sites and found
that most of the congested BTSs were located at the borders between two location areas
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 24 of 25
Confidential
along the railway. Therefore, the SDCCH congestions could have been caused by abrupt
location updating.
3)
We registered 5-minute traffic measurement tasks so as to verify the above assumption and
found that most of the location updating events occurred in a certain 5-minute time span. We
inquired the time schedule of trains and found that four to five passenger trains passed by in
this time span. When the trains passed by, plenty of abrupt location updating events took
place in a very short time and thus caused the congestions.
4)
For the BTSs located at the borders between location areas along the railway, we recommend
that the dynamic SDDCH assignment function be enabled for the BTSs and certain
redundancy be reserved in SDCCH capacity configuration.
2015-01-22
Huawei Confidential
Page 25 of 25