Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Precision Engineering
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/precision
Robotics and Mechatronics Research Laboratory, Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Monash University, Clayton, VIC 3800, Australia
School of Mechanical Engineering, Tianjin University, Tianjin 300072, China
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 8 January 2008
Received in revised form 22 April 2008
Accepted 9 May 2008
Available online 3 June 2008
Keywords:
Flexure-based mechanism
Piezoelectric actuator
Ultra-precision turning
a b s t r a c t
This paper presents the methodology for modeling and control of a high precision exure-based mechanism for ultra-precision turning operation. A high performance piezoelectric actuator is used to driven
the exure-based mechanism. A parallel exure hinge mechanism is utilized to guide the moving platform and to preload the piezoelectric actuator. A high resolution capacitive sensor is used to measure the
displacement of the exure-based mechanism for closed-loop control. With consideration of the driving
circuit, the dynamic model of the exure-based mechanism has been established. The effect of the driving
circuit on the dynamic response of the precision mechanism is investigated. Experimental tests have been
carried out to verify the established model and the performance of the exure-based mechanism.
2008 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The mechanical machining techniques such as cutting, milling,
grinding, deburring, and fettling are categorized as material
removal processes [1]. These processes follow the relationship for
material removal as a function of cutting speed, cutting width,
cutting depth, and feed rate of cutter position [2]. Ultra-precision
turning operation is one of the efcient machining processes for
producing precision surfaces on at or cylindrical workpiece, where
the cutter tip position relative to the workpiece must be accurately controlled in order to achieve the desired surface prole
and nish [3,4]. Due to the characteristics of the infeed mechanism such as backlash, friction, and large inertia, it is difcult for
conventional lathe to implement nanometer level machining. In
order to overcome this problem, an auxiliary precision mechanism
is proposed and utilized on the turret of the conventional lathe
to implement nanometer level infeed. Combined with the infeed
mechanism of the conventional lathe, this dual type infeed system can guarantee the positioning precision of the cutter, and thus
the machining accuracy for the ultra-precision turning operation
can be achieved [57]. Parallel mechanisms are capable of much
high accuracy, rigidity, and stiffness [8], and in particular the piezoelectric driven exure-based parallel mechanisms have additional
advantages including no backlash, negligible friction, no lubrication, and free of thermal heat generation [9,10]. In addition, such a
Corresponding author. Tel.: +61 3 9905 3510; fax: +61 3 9905 1285.
E-mail address: yanling.tian@eng.monash.edu.au (Y. Tian).
0141-6359/$ see front matter 2008 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.precisioneng.2008.05.001
exure-based positioning mechanism can be monolithically manufactured to reduce assembly errors and guarantee the machining
accuracy. According to the applied voltage, piezoelectric actuator
can generate continuous expansion or retraction motion with innite resolution, zero backlash, and wide dynamic response range
[11,12]. Thus, exure-based mechanisms driven by piezoelectric
actuators represent the best choice for the secondary infeed system
for ultra-precision turning operation.
Various exure-based mechanisms for ultra-precision turning
operation have been developed in the past. Patterson and Magrab
[13] developed a exure-based mechanism to improve the resolution and accuracy of a precision lathe. In this approach, a diaphragm
exure hinge and piezoelectric actuator was used to achieve high
static and dynamic repeatability. The exure-based mechanism
has a closed-loop bandwidth of 660 Hz, and a maximum displacement of 2.5 m. Okazaki [14] presented a exure-based mechanism
using a piezoelectric actuator. The exure-based mechanism was
designed by using a wire-cut parallel spring mechanism, a piezoelectric stack actuator, and a capacitive gauge. Kim and Kim [15]
developed a piezoelectric actuator to mount on a conventional lathe
in order to control the depth of cut precisely and compensate for
the waviness on the surface of the workpiece. Such waviness can
be detected using surface roughness parameter measurement [16].
Rasmussen et al. [17] developed a piezoelectric actuated cutting
tool with a maximum travel stroke of 50 m and a bandwidth of
200 Hz. Altintas and Woronko [18] designed a exure-based mechanism for precision turning of cylindrical shafts. In this system,
exure hinge acts as a parallel spring to the piezoelectric actuator
leading to a total stiffness of 473 N/m. The exure-based mech-
161
of the moving platform for closed-loop displacement feedback control [20]. This sensor is a parallel plate device held on bracket
between the platform and the base. The platform can traverse forward and backward on a parallel exure mechanism according to
digital command signal. Further, the platform is located such that
it also preloads the piezoelectric actuator [21,22]. A piezoelectric
amplier controlled by a digital computer is used to supply control
voltage for the expansion and retraction of the piezoelectric actuator. Such piezoelectric actuators suffer from hysteresis effect, and
this is overcome by using closed-loop control [23], which can also
allow compensation for parasitic error motion in the exure guide.
The online real time compensation method is used to adjust the
position of the moving platform, and thus improving the motion
and position accuracy and resolution.
The moving platform is connected to the base through two
sets of parallel circular notch exure hinges. The hinges provide both a lateral stiffness guidance mechanism for the moving
platform and a spring preload for the piezoelectric actuator. In
the manufacture process, the geometric and dimensional tolerances of the parallel exure hinges are exactly controlled. Placing
shims of suitable thickness behind the actuator sets the preload
on piezoelectric actuator. This method trades off extra assembly effort against the cost savings and stability improvement for
avoiding positioning adjuster mechanism. Due to the characteristics including brittleness of such stacked actuator, the piezoelectric
actuator can withstand against large compressive force, but it is
generally weak against shear force. Therefore, the actuator cannot provide lateral stiffness and is liable to damage from lateral
force. To overcome this characteristic for piezoelectric actuator,
a ball is added between the moving platform and the piezoelectric actuator, and thus the preload is necessary to maintain the
required contact condition. The magnitude of preload is adjusted
through the shim between the base and the piezoelectric actuator.
The piezoelectric actuator can generate a displacement of up to
15 m, has an axial stiffness of 98 N/m and can deliver a maximum driving force of 1000 N. The high precision capacitive sensor
has a resolution of 3.3 nm over a measuring range of 60 m with a
bandwidth of 07.5 kHz. The piezoelectric amplier module has a
nominal amplication factor 10 0.1 and can output and sink a peak
current of 2000 mA and an average current of 300 mA, respectively.
A digital computer is used to implement the numerical control, user
interface and supervisory control operations. Through a 16 bits D/A
converter and the driving amplier, the control voltage is supplied
to the piezoelectric actuator. A 16 bits A/D converter is also used to
collect the displacement signal of the moving platform measured
by the capacitive sensor.
The dimensions of the notch in exure hinges and their positions
greatly inuence the characteristics of the piezoelectric driven precision mechanism, especially its working range, the effectiveness of
the preload and the ease of assembly [24]. A high stiffness preload
mechanism reduces the actual working range of the exure-based
mechanism while increasing the driving force, and thus the deformation of the moving platform will be larger under the same output
displacement. On the other hand, if the stiffness is too low, it
can affect the contact conditions between the ball and the moving platform, to the detriment of accuracy and working range.
The exure hinge mechanism is kinematically over-constrained,
the actual stiffness of each exure hinge cannot be calculated by
the formulation given by Paros and Weisbord [25]. Hence, the
hinges were designed using nite element analysis to provide
suitable preload and minimal bending deformation of the moving platform. Fig. 2 illustrates the mechanical characteristics of
the exure hinge obtained from the ANSYS nite element analysis (FEA), theoretical calculations, and experimental tests. The
162
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
cpzt + cfh
,
ms
n2 =
kpzt + kfh
,
ms
A=
1
nd33 kamp kpzt
ms
(5)
A
(s2 + 2n s + n2 )s
A
(s2 + 2n s + n2 )(s + 1/RC)
A
(s2 + 2n s + n2 )s
A(Ms + N)
(s2 + 2n s + n2 )
A
(s + 1/RC)
x(t) =
n2
en t
1 2
sin n
1 2 t
+
en t
+MA
sin n 1 2 t
1 2
NA en t
sin n 1 2 t
n
1 2
where
= arctan
N=
1 2
G=
(7)
GAet/RC
RC
2n n2 RC 1/RC
2RCn 1
2n n2 RC 1/RC
(8)
M = G.
From Eq. (8), it is noted that the rst term represents the
dynamic response to a step command input as if applied directly to
the mass spring system of the exure-based mechanism. The last
three terms represent the effect of the time constant RC in addition to the parameters such as the damping ratio and the natural
frequency n on the step response of the exure-based mechanism.
Similarly, the step response of the exure-based mechanism
during the retraction process, described as vd (t) = v0 for t = 0 and
vd (t) = 0 for t > 0 s, is given by the following relationship:
en t
x(t) = X0
sin n 1 2 t +
1 2
en t
+AM
sin n 1 2 t
1 2
AGet/RC
(9)
N en t
sin n 1 2 t
n
1 2
(6)
163
The experiments are carried out to verify the developed models and establish the performance measure for the exure-based
mechanism. The schematic diagram of the experimental setup
is shown in Fig. 4. Laser-based-interferometry sensing methodology [26] is chosen for dynamic position measurement. The
methodology and experimental setup provides low measurement
uncertainties and high accuracy and resolution, and are frequently
used for tracking of dynamic systems [27,28]. In this experiment,
a laser-based measurement system with resolution of 1 nm, and
dynamic range of 5 kHz is utilized. To reduce the external disturbance such as vibration, the experiments are carried out on
a vibration-isolated optical table. The environmental noise level
after the vibration isolation is approximately 5 nm. A pushpull
gauge (spring force gauge) is utilized to apply external force on the
moving platform of the exure-based mechanism to determine the
static stiffness of the mechanism. In order to examine the dynamic
characteristics of the exure-based mechanism, a dynamic analyzer is used to perform the modal analysis. Through dynamic
analysis method, the frequency response function of the exurebased mechanism can be developed, and the dynamic parameters
such as natural frequency, damping ratio, and modal shape can be
obtained.
Piezoelectric actuator may be driven using current or voltage.
However, due to the intrinsic friction among the crystals during the
expansion and retraction of the piezoelectric actuator, there exists
hysteresis when the voltage is used as control signal to drive the
exure-based mechanism. This was experimentally veried and the
hysteresis loop of the exure-based mechanism under open loop
control condition is shown in Fig. 5. The lower curve represents the
expansion process and the upper curve represents the retraction
process. When a 5 V control signal is applied to the piezoelectric
actuator, the maximum displacement of the exure-based mechanism is approximately 8.7 m. It is noted that the displacement
curve of the expansion process is different from that of retraction process, this is the hysteresis effect. The maximum difference
approximately reaches 1 m. Under the closed-loop control condi-
164
165
5. Conclusions
Utilizing a piezoelectric actuator and exure hinge guide mechanism, a exure-based mechanism for ultra-precision turning
operation was developed. The resolution of the exure-based
mechanism can reach 12 nm and the natural frequency reaches
1122 Hz.
The dynamic model of the exure-based mechanism was established. The inuence of the time constant RC on the dynamic
performance of the exure-based mechanism was investigated.
From the analysis, it was noted that the time constant RC can change
the dynamic characteristics of the exure-based mechanism, i.e,
the overshoot and the settling time of the exure-based mechanism
will change with various time constant RC values.
Using feedback control method, the dynamic performance of
the exure-based mechanism is improved. Therefore, the hysteresis
phenomenon is reduced, and the linearity of output is increased.
In addition, the static stiffness of the exure-based mechanism can
provide up to 250 N/m.
Acknowledgements
166
References
[1] Shirinzadeh B, Roberts M. Experiments in robotic fettling using visual feedback.
Ind Robot 1998;25(4):27681.
[2] Shrinzadeh B, Ng YK, Alici G. Intelligent robotic fettling using a visual feedback
technique and force sensing. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2004;24(78):60714.
[3] Wu D, Chen K, Wang XK. Tracking control and active disturbance rejection with application to noncircular machining. Int J Mach Tools Manuf
2007;47(15):220717.
[4] Elzy AT, Bone GM, Elbestawi MA. Design and control of a dual-stage feed drive.
Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2005;45(2):15365.
[5] Ku SS, Larsen G, Cetinkunt S. Fast tool servo control for ultra-precision machining at extremely low feed rates. Mechatronics 1998;38(4):38193.
[6] Stephen JL, David AC, Joseph AC, et al. Design of a rotary fast tool servo for
ophthalmic lens fabrication. Precis Eng 1999;23(4):2539.
[7] Zhu WH, Jun MB, Altintas Y. A fast tool servo design for precision turning of
shafts on conventional CNC lathes. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2001;41(7):853965.
[8] Alici G, Shirinzadeh B. Optimum dynamic balancing of planar parallel manipulators based on sensitivity analysis. Mech Mach Theory 2006;41(12):152032.
[9] Liaw HC, Shirinzadeh B, Smith J. Enhanced sliding mode motion tracking control
of actuators. Sensor Actuat A: Phys 2007;138(1):194202.
[10] Lu XD, Trumper DL. Spindle rotary position estimation for fast tool servo trajectory generation. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2007;47(9):13627.
[11] Andrew W, Jin H, Yusuf A. Piezoelectric tool actuator for precision machining
on conventional CNC turning centers. Precis Eng 2003;27(4):33545.
[12] Kim HS, Kim EJ. Feed-forward control of fast tool servo for real-time correction
of spindle error in diamond turning of at surfaces. Int J Mach Tools Manuf
2003;43(12):117783.
[13] Patterson SR, Magrab EB. Design and testing of a fast tool servo for diamond
turning. Precis Eng 1985;7(3):1238.
[14] Okazaki Y. A micro-positioning tool post using a piezoelectric actuator for diamond turning machines. Precis Eng 1990;12(3):1516.
[15] Kim JD, Kim DS. Waviness compensation of precision machining by piezoelectric micro cutting device. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 1998;38(10/11):130522.
[16] Al-Kindi GA, Shrinzadeh B. An evaluation of surface roughness parameters measurement using vision-based data. Int J Mach Tools Manuf
2007;47(3/4):697708.
[17] Rasmussen JD, Tsao TC, Hanson RD, et al. Dynamic variable depth of cut machining using piezoelectric actuators. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 1994;34(3):37992.
[18] Altintas Y, Woronko A. A piezo tool actuator for precision turning of hardened
shafts. Ann CIRP 2002;51(1):3036.
[19] Cuttino JF, Miller AC, Schinstock DE. Performance optimization of a fast tool
servo for single-point diamond turning machines. IEEE/ASME Trans Mechatron
1999;4(2):16979.
[20] Liaw HC, Shirinzadeh B, Smith J. Robust motion tracking control of piezo-driven
exure-based four-bar mechanism for micro/nano manipulation. Mechatronics
2008;18(2):11120.
[21] Alici G, Shirinzadeh B. Optimum synthesis of planar parallel manipulators based on kinematic isotropy and force balancing. Robotica 2004;22(1):
97108.
[22] Gao Y, Zhang DW, Yu CW. Dynamic modeling of a novel workpiece table
for active surface grinding control. Int J Mach Tools Manuf 2001;41(4):
60924.
[23] Liaw HC, Shirinzadeh B, Smith J. Sliding mode enhanced adaptive motion tracking control of piezoelectric actuation systems for micro/nano manipulation.
IEEE Trans Control Syst Technol 2008;16(4):82633.
[24] Zhang D, Chetwynd DG, Liu X, Tian Y. Investigation of a 3-DOF micro-positioning
table for surface grinding. Int J Mech Sci 2006;48(12):14018.
[25] Paros JM, Weisbord L. How to design exure hinges. Mach Des 1965;37(27):
1516.
[26] Shirinzadeh B. Laser-interferometry-based tracking for dynamic measurements. Ind Robot 1998;25(1):3541.
[27] Teoh PL, Shirinzadeh B, Foong CW, Alici G. The measurement uncertainties in
the laser interferometry-based sensing and tracking technique. Measurement
2002;32(2):13550.
[28] Alici G, Shirinzadeh B. A systematic technique to estimate positioning errors for
robot accuracy improvement using laser interferometry based sensing. Mech
Mach Theory 2005;48(8):879906.