Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN 1561-8706
Volume 14 Number 4
January 2013
Research
Prevalence of Risk Factors of Non-Communicable Diseases Amongst Female Prisoners
of Pakistan
Asima Faisal, Salina Mukhtar
Factors Influencing Capital Structure of Pharmaceutical Companies Listed on The
Karachi Stock Exchange
Shashi Raja,Waqar Ahmed Siddiqui, Shazia Farooq,H. Jamal Zubairi
An Empirical Study of Working Capital Policy, Risk and Leverage
Sumita J. Shroff
Emotional Intelligence in Doctors and Nurses of Emergency Medicine Units in Tertiary
Hospitals
Humeira Jawed, Asima Faisal
AFRs for MSEs in Pakistan (2006) Challenged By IFRs For SMEs (2009)
Muhammad Aslam Dossa
Pay Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment in University Faculty
Nadia Ayub Ali, Shagufta Rafif. Shahid Iqbal
Feasibility of Application of IFRs On Companies Operating in Developing Countries
With Focus on Pakistan
Mehboob Moosa
Case Study
Engro Foods Prized Stallion in The Making!
Ahmed Mushtaq, Ali Raza, Roma Ramani, Sana Sheikh, Shazia Farooq
Discussion
Approaches in Leadership: Trait, Situational & Path-Goal Theory: A Critical Analysis
Adnan Khan
Book Review
What is Global Leadership?
Fareeda Ibad
January 2013
Volume 14 Number 4
Contents
Research
Prevalence of Risk Factors of Non-Communicable Diseases Amongst Female
Prisoners of Pakistan
Asima Faisal, Salina Mukhtar
Factors Influencing Capital Structure of Pharmaceutical Companies Listed on
The Karachi Stock Exchange
Shashi Raja,Waqar Ahmed Siddiqui, Shazia Farooq,H. Jamal Zubairi
An Empirical Study of Working Capital Policy, Risk and Leverage
Sumita J. Shroff
Emotional Intelligence in Doctors and Nurses of Emergency Medicine Units in
Tertiary Hospitals
Humeira Jawed, Asima Faisal
AFRs for MSEs in Pakistan (2006) Challenged By IFRs For SMEs (2009)
Muhammad Aslam Dossa
Pay Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment in University Faculty
Nadia Ayub Ali, Shagufta Rafif. Shahid Iqbal
Feasibility of Application of IFRs On Companies Operating in Developing
Countries With Focus on Pakistan
Mehboob Moosa
Page No
663
689
712
732
744
765
780
Case Study
Engro Foods Prized Stallion in The Making!
Ahmed Mushtaq, Ali Raza, Roma Ramani, Sana Sheikh, Shazia Farooq
796
Discussion
Approaches in Leadership: Trait, Situational & Path-Goal Theory: A Critical
Analysis
Adnan Khan
830
Book Review
What is Global Leadership?
Fareeda Ibad
843
Volume 14 Number 4
January 2013
Business Management
Referees
Dr. Ishrat Husain, Institute of Business Administration, Karachi
Prof. Dr Mehtab Karim, John Hopkins University, USA
Dr. Khalid Nadvi, IDS, University of Sussex
Dr. Peter O Brien, SADCC, South Africa
Prof. Sarfaraz Qureshi, Islamabad
Dr. T.M. Roepstorff, UNIDO, Vienna
Dr. Shahid Hasan Siddiqui, Research Institute for Islamic Banking and Finance
Dr. K.M. Larik, Iqra University, Karachi
Dr. Javed Iqbal, University of Karachi, Karachi
Professor Dr. Rashid A. Naeem, Chairman, Department of Economics and Management Sciences,
Allama Iqbal Open University, Islamabad
Dr. Rizwana Zahid, Government APWA College for Women, Karachi
Dr. Arshi Ali, Federal Urdu University, Karachi
Dr. Abdul Wahab Suri, University of Karachi, Karachi
Prof. Dr. Abdul Waheed, University of Karachi, Karachi
Dr. Naveed, Institute of Business Administration (IBA), Karachi
Dr. Moazzam Khan Sherwani, Institute of Environment Studies, University of Karachi
Dr. Samiuzzaman, Global Environmental Lab (Pvt) Ltd. Korangi, Karachi
Dr. Anila Ambar Malik, University of Karachi, Karachi
Dr. Seema Munaf, University of Karachi, Karachi
Dr. Nabeel A. Zubairi, University of Karachi, Karachi
Contd.
Dr. Zainab F. Zadeh, Bahria University, Karachi
Dr. Ziasma, University of Karachi, Karachi
Prof. Asim Jamal Siddiqui, University of Karachi, Karachi
Prof. Dr. Mudassir-ud-din, University of Karachi, Karachi
Ms. Yasmin Zafar, Institute of Business Administration (IBA), Karachi
Dr. Muhammad Zubair, University of Karachi, Karachi
January 2013
Volume 14 Number 4
Referees
Dr. Uzma Parveen, University of Karachi, Karachi
Mr. Mohsin H. Ahmed, Applied Economics Research Centre, University of Karachi, Karachi
Prof. Ghulam Hussain, University of Karachi, Karachi
Mr. Mahboob-ul-Hassan, University of Karachi, Karachi
Dr. Muhammad Mahmood, Khadim Ali Shah Bukhari Institute of Technology, Karachi
Dr. Nargis Asad, Aga Khan University Hospital, Karachi
Dr. Abuzar Wajidi, University of Karachi, Karachi
Ms. Rubina Feroz, University of Karachi, Karachi
Prof. Dr. Talat Wizarat, Institute of Business Administration (IBA), Karachi
Dr. Muhammad Zaki, University of Karachi, Karachi
Mr. H. Jaleel Zubairi, Allied Bank Ltd. , Karachi
Dr. Zaira Wahab, Iqra University, Karachi
Dr. Ismail Saad, Iqra University, Karachi
Mr. Naim Farooqui, Sindh Bank Ltd, Karachi
Dr. Sara Azhar, University of Karachi, Karachi
Prof. Ahmad Farooq Shah, Bahauddin Zakarya University, Multan
Mr. M. Mazhar Khan, State Bank of Pakistan, Karachi
Mr. Mohammad Soliman, University of Sciences and Technology Chittagong, Bangladesh
Prof. Abdul Mannan, School of Business, University of Liberal Arts Bangladesh
Dr. Fatima Imam, Federal Urdu University, Karachi
Prof. G.R. Pasha, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan
Mr. Shameel Ahmad Zubairi, University of Karachi, Karachi
Mr. Imran Naveed, State Bank of Pakistan, Karachi
Mr. Qaisar Mufti, Qaisar Mufti Associates, Shahra-e-Iraq Saddar, Karachi.
Ms. Afra Sajjad, ACCA Pakistan, Lahore
Dr. Khan Brohi, nstitute of Environmental Engineering and Management, Jamshoro
Mr. Amir Hussain, WTO Cell, Trade Development Authority of Pakistan, Karachi
Dr. Tanveer Anjum, Department of Business Communications, Iqra University
Dr. Arifa Farid, Department of Philosophy Ex-Dean Faculty of Arts, University of Karachi
Mr. Muhammad Asim, Department of Business Administration, Karachi
Mr. Muhammad Zubair, Department of Islamic History, University of Karachi, Karachi
Dr. Aliya Zahid, Anatomy Department, Allama Iqbal Medical College, Lahore.
Dr. Qurrat-ul-ain, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, Lahore.
Dr. Atif Mahmood, Shaheed Mohtarma Benazir Bhutto Medical College,
Dr. Muhammad Adnan Kanpurwala, Dept. of Physiology, Dow University Karachi.
Dr. Uzma Ali, Institute of Clinical Psychology, Karachi
Dr. Ali Rizvi, Universiti Brunei Darussalam, Brunei
Dr. Pervez Wasim, Applied Economics Research Centre, Karachi
Dr. Muhammad Usman Awan, Institute of Quality & Technology Managment, Lahore
Dr. Amber Gul Rashid, University of Karachi, Karachi
Production Unit
Literary Editors:
Muhammad Asif Khan
Wajdan Raza
Production Associate and
Editorial Co-ordinator:
Shahzad Ali
Research
Research
PREVALENCE OF RISK
FACTORS OF NONCOMMUNICABLE DISEASES
AMONGST FEMALE
PRISONERS OF PAKISTAN
Asima Faisal, Salina Mukhtar
Department Health & Hospital Management
Institute of Business Management, (IoBM)
Abstract
Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) are a group of
conditions that includes cardiovascular diseases, cancer, mental health
problems, diabetes mellitus, chronic respiratory diseases and
musculoskeletal conditions. Since NCDs account for a large number
of deaths in Pakistan, the objective of this study was to determine
the prevalence of risk factors for non-communicable diseases
particularly in female prisoners as this stratum has not been much
studied. The study also aims to compare the prevalence of risk factors
for non-communicable diseases in the female prisoners in four
provinces of Pakistan. For this purpose, a cross sectional research
was conducted at the female prisons, one in each province. A total of
269 female adult prisoners, having age of 16 years and more, belonging
to different nationalities, participated in the study. During the survey,
data on anthropometrical and vital measurements, smoking habits of
female prisoners were collected and analyzed. Among the female
prisoners, 71% were of Pakistani origin, while 23% were foreigners.
24.9% were smokers. 75.4% prisoners had no access to fruits in their
diet. 39% and 44.2% female prisoners used vegetable oil and ghee
respectively in their meals while 16.3% were unsure about the type of
663
Research
664
Research
665
Research
666
Research
Methodology
Central
Date
Jail
of
st
nd
Jail
of
667
Research
Diet (Section D)
668
Research
Research
670
Research
Smoking Habits:
The results analyzed showed that, out of total sample size of
269 inmates, 67 were smokers (24.9%) The youngest age at which the
smoking was taken up by the female inmate was 10 years.
Figure 2: Percentage of Smokers with Number of Cigarettes
Smoked per day by the Female Prisoners of Pakistan
n = 67
671
Research
672
Research
673
Research
BMI:
The mean height when measured was found to be 1.57 m (SD
+ 0.094 m) while the mean weight was 67 kg (SD+ 14.63 Kg). The mean
BMI was 26.63 kg/m2 (SD+ 5.3) (n=269).Minimum BMI measured was
17.6 kg/m2 and maximum BMI measured was 43.15 kg/m2. Amongst the
female inmates, 46.5% females had normal BMI ranging from 19-24.9
kg/m2 (n=125); 26.4% were found to be over-weight with a BMI ranging
from 25-29.9 kg/m2 (n=71) while 27.13% (n=73) were obese having BMI
more than or equal to 30kg/m2. None of the female prisoners were
found to be under weight (Figure 5).
Figure 5: BMI range of female prisoners of Pakistan
Vital Measurements:
Blood Pressure
Out of all the inmates surveyed during the survey, 25% (n=67)
of the sample had high blood pressure according to their doctor since
last 12 months. The average systolic blood pressure was 124 mmHg
and average diastolic blood pressure was 82 mmHg.
According to the blood pressure monitoring done during the
survey, 21% of the inmates (n=56) were found to have systolic blood
pressure greater than 139 mmHg; while 34.6% female inmates (n=93)
PAKISTAN BUSINESS REVIEW JAN 2013
674
Research
675
Research
676
Research
Table 1: Comparative Analysis of various risk factors of NonCommunicable Diseases (NCDs) in female prisoners of the four
Provinces of Pakistan
Sindh Punjab
Khyber
Baluchistan
(n=114) (n=73) Pakhtoonkhwa
(n=16)
p(n=66)
Value*
Variables
Options
Smokers
Yes
No
30
84
19
54
18
48
5
11
Yes
No
15
99
18
55
12
54
4
12
Ghee
Vegetable Oil
Not Sure
10
79
25
59
9
5
39
16
11
11
2
3
0 servings/week
89
44
48
1-4
servings/week
20
21
14
>5servings/week
Smokeless
T obacco
Oil
Consumption
Fruit Intake
BMI
Normal
92
18
12
Overweight
13
23
31
Obese
32
23
Chi
Square
Chi
Square
0.214
ANOVA
<0.000*
ANOVA
0.176
ANOVA
<0.000*
677
Research
678
Research
Educational Status
Smoking Status
Options
p-value
123
98.4%
1.6%
78
91.76%
8.2%
Primary Education
(n=1 9)
26.3%
14
73.7%
Secondary E ducation
(n=2 9)
6.9%
27
93.1%
Post- graduation
(n=1 1)
0%
11
100%
Smokers
(n=6 7)
27
40.3%
40
59.7%
Non-Smo kers
(n= 202)
181
89.6%
21
10.4%
42
85.7%
14.3%
166
74.4%
54
24.5%
24
184
30.4%
96.85%
55
6
69.6%
3.15% Chi Square
< 0.000*
Normal
(n = 25)
118
94.4%
5.6%
Over-weight
(n=7 1)
58
81.7%
13
32
43.8%
41
18.3% AN OVA
< 0.000*
56.2%
BMI (Kg/M2)
Foreign
P risoners %
(n=61)
No formal Schooling
(n =125)
Fruit Intake
Pakistani
Prisoners %
(n=208)
Yes (n =79)
No
(n =190)
Obese
(n=7 3)
AN OVA
Chi Square
< 0.000*
Chi Square
< 0.000*
Chi Square
0.1 35
679
Research
Discussion
NCDs have affected the health of inmates besides general
population. With special focus on inmates, our study revealed that
25% of the inmates have hypertension. In comparison to our findings,
Plugge et al. (2009) found that female prisoners in the U.K. have high
risk of developing CVD.
In our study, we found relatively fewer female prisoners who
were smokers (24.9%) as compared to other international studies done
on the prevalence of smoking amongst female prisoners. The main
reason behind this lesser prevalence of smoking amongst the Pakistani
female prisoners is because of overall decreased incidence of smoking
amongst Pakistani females due to ban on smoking imposed in public
institutions.
Smokeless tobacco appears to be an addictive product and
contains the same tumor-initiating properties as cigarettes. While
evaluating the use of smokeless tobacco consumption in the United
States, it was observed that while the prevalence of cigarette smoking
has been declining, annual consumption of smokeless tobacco has
nearly tripled since the 1970s. In 1997, 121 million pounds of smokeless
tobacco (chewing tobacco and snuff) were consumed in the United
States. (US Department of Agriculture 1982-1997).
Maniyar M. (2004) stated that womens crimes are seen to be
predominantly non-violent & reflect the social and economic standing
of women in the society. The needs of women in prison basically
reflect the same needs of those in the community at large.
Pakistan Human Rights Report (2004) reported that women
in prison have as much need for specialized care as women outside
the prison, but in most of the cases, women are facing a deprivation of
basic needs. In the prison, of all the various types of deprivations
which women are facing, of particular concern is the lack of healthcare
services in female prison.
PAKISTAN BUSINESS REVIEW JAN 2013
680
Research
Research
682
Research
Conclusion
Lifestyle and living pattern determine an individuals
health regardless of his/her place of stay. The study concludes that
Pakistani females who are imprisoned have chances of developing
NCDs in the future because of high blood pressure, sugar levels, less
fruit intake, lack of physical activity and increased BMI. The
prevalence of risk factors of NCDs in the female prisoners of Pakistan
was found to be high. There was a higher incidence of smoking
amongst the female prisoners than the normal female population of
Pakistan. This research is expected to provide valuable insight into
health policy planning for prisoners and designing health programs
to promote healthy living in prisons as well.
Recomendations
Routine health check-ups should be conducted to ensure a
regular health assessment in prisons to encourage a healthy
environment. Expertise from local primary health care centers
should be utilized.
Campaigns should be carried out at government as well as
non-government level to bring awareness amongst the female
prisoners about the hazards of smoking and smokeless tobacco.
Cessation programs can be carried out to help the current
smokers and tobacco users quit these habits.
The research findings recommend an inclusion of a proper diet
program for the female prisoners.
The food provided by the government must contain a balanced
range of all the necessary nutrients especially a balanced
quantity of fruits. Use of vegetables oil should be emphasized
by the prison.
683
Research
684
Research
References
Belknap, J. (2001). The invisible woman: Gender, crime, and justice
(2nd ed.). Belmont, CA:Wadsworth.
Boutayeb: 2005 The burden of non-communicable diseases in
developing countries. Int. J. Equity Health. 4:2.
Country Report on Human Rights, Feb 25, 2004 (cited: www.who.org)
Cropseya K., Gloria D.,Ladnerc T. Smoking among female prisoners:
An ignored public health epidemic. Addictive Behaviors, 2004 Feb;
29 (2):425-431.
Dawn Newspaper (April 7th 2005)
Fernando S. Antezana: Epidemiological Aspect of Hypertension in
World. BMJ 1995; 120:960-61
Herbert K, Plugge E, Foster C, Doll H. Prevalence of risk factors for
non-communicable diseases in prison populations worldwide: a
systematic review. Lancet. 2012 May 26;379(9830):1975-82. Epub 2012
Apr 20. Review. PMID: 22521520 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
Human Rights Watch-World Report-2002 (cited: www.who.org)
Edwards, J., Hartwell, H., Reeve, W. G. and Schafheitle, J. M., 2007.
The Diet of Prisoners in England. British Food Journal, 109 (3), pp.
216-232.
Kaufman. M. R.: Smoking and Tobacco in Ohio Prisons. Addiction.
2009; 70 (11), 2579 2585
Mackay J, Eriksen M.: The tobacco Atlas. Geneva, Switzerland: World
Health Organization, 2002.
685
Research
686
Research
687
Research
Annexure 1: Body Mass Index (BMI) Chart for Adult Males and
Females
688
Research
FACTORS INFLUENCING
CAPITAL STRUCTURE OF
PHARMACEUTICAL
COMPANIES LISTED ON THE
KARACHI STOCK EXCHANGE
Shashi Raja, Waqar Ahmed Siddiqui, Shazia Farooq,
H. Jamal Zubairi
Department of Accounting and Finance
Institute of Business Management (IoBM), Karachi
Abstract
This study focuses on investigating the factors influencing
the capital structure of seven companies listed in the pharma and
biotech sector of the Karachi Stock Exchange. Leverage has been
designated as a representative of capital structure. Seven variables
(all financial) are assumed independent and leverage has been taken
as the dependent variable forming the basis for our pooled regression
model. At an assumed 5% level of significance, three null hypotheses
are rejected. Reliability tests namely Cronbachs Alpha measure is
run in order to verify that the model is stable over time. The results of
this test suggest inconsistency in the case of the entire range of the
data but if considered individually the consistency, 5 out of 7 variables
have positive alphas. However, the conclusions drawn from the model
are tentative.
689
Research
690
Research
691
Research
tax incentive to use that capacity. The cost of financial distress is also
determined by the type of assets on the firms balance sheet. According
to Myers and Brealey (2003), the theory successfully explains many
differences in capital structure, but it is unable to explain why some of
the most successful firms thrive with little debt.
According to Grossman and Hart (1982) use of debt, reduces
the conflict between managers and shareholders. Their model
spotlights the bankruptcy cost in debt scenario and shows that
managers can prefer investing in lucrative projects to consuming perks
that benefit them only. The likelihood of bankruptcy increases as the
manager use more perks. It seems bankruptcy is costly to managers
because they lose benefits, so debt can create an enticement for them
to make better investment decisions and cut down on perks.
A competing theory, Pecking Order Theory, was described
by Myers (1984) and revisited later in several studies including the
ones conducted by Sunder & Myers (1999), Fama& French (2002) and
Frank & Goyal (2003). Donaldson (1961) proposed that management
favors internally generated funds over external funds in his study of
capital structures in large corporations. These findings by Donaldson
gave a hint of a pecking order before the theory was presented by
Myers. The Pecking Order Theory states that firms use internal
financing when available and prefer debt to equity when additional
financing is required. This explains why less profitable firms are more
leveraged; not because they have higher target debt ratios but because
they require more external financing and since debt is next on the
pecking order when internal funds have been deployed.
Bradley, Jarrell and Kim (1984) found that earning volatility,
investment in R&D and advertising have a negative as well as a
significant relationship with leverage. They also found that the nondebt tax shield is positively related with leverage. The study also
concluded that industry classification is also relevant in capital
structure decisions.
Rajan and Zingles (1995) studied the impact of four
independent variables including tangibility, sales, market to book ratio,
and profitability on capital structure. The relationship with all variables
was found to be significant. They found tangibility and sales to be
PAKISTAN BUSINESS REVIEW JAN 2013
692
Research
Research
694
Research
695
Research
National
M ultinationa l
Total
Punjab
Sindh
KhyberPaktunkhwa
Baluchistan
Azad
Jammu&Kashmir
204
92
50
05
23
-
209
115
50
07
03
02
-
09
03
Total
356
30
386
Source: Minist ry of Health (2008) ,OSEC (2008)
Licenses categories
Formulation
Punjab
Sindh
NWFP
191
109
45
Basic
manufacturing/
Semi basic
manufacturing
13
16
0
Repacking
Total
licenses
issued
2
0
0
206
125
45
Baluchistan
6
1
0
Azad
3
0
0
Jammu&Kashmir
Total
354
30
2
Source: Ministry of Health (2008),OSEC (2008 )
7
3
386
696
Research
Ove r 100,000
1% of profit (by ea ch
co mpany) goes to R & D Fund
of the Ministry of H ea lth.
47,000
1,100
R egistered drugs
R egistered Mo le cules (Ac tive
ingre dients)
C ontrolled price drugs
Alm ost all
M a rket siz e
US $ 1.5 Billion appr ox.
Avera ge growth rate
11%
M a rket Sha re of M ultinationa l
45%
M a rket Sha re of Loca l
55%
compa nies
M a rket le ade r
GlaxoS m ithK line ( Pa k) Ltd.
Quality requir em ent
High Te ch
Sou rce: M inistry of H ealth ( 2008), O S EC (2008)
697
Research
698
Research
Amoxacilin
Ampicillin
Aspirin
Cefixime
Cefadroxil
Cephlexin
Paracetamol
Description
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
Pharmaceutical 69,215
64,923
67,943
78,952
86,508
116,286 168,308
products
Source: State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), Trade D evelopment Authority of Pakistan (TDAP)
Research
Pharmaceutical
products
2003-04
2004 -05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
287,478
276,210
329,36 6
342,234
354,235
700
Research
Profitability
Size of firm
Growth
Liquidity (Quick Ratio)
Tangibility of assets
Non-debt tax shield
Research
Abbott Laboratories
Ferozons Laboratories
Glaxo Smith Kline
Highnoon Laboratories
IBL Health Care Limited
Searle Pakistan
Sanofi Aventis
702
Research
( NDTS )
703
Research
Model
(Constant)
Tangibility of
Assets
Firm Size
.005
.002
Growth
-.115
.078
Return on
-.956
.315
Assets
Return on
.685
.206
Equity
Quick Ratio
.009
.013
Non - Debt
1.801
1.595
Tax Shield
a. Dependent Variable: Leverage (Capital Structure)
Sig.
-2.344
.912
.022
.365
.355
-.271
-.833
2.933
-1.471
-3.039
.005
.146
.003
.694
3.329
.001
.120
.219
.685
1.129
.496
.263
704
Research
Research
706
Research
1.
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
.309
N of Items
2
The above results signify a positive Alpha value and as the value is
less than 0.7, which is denoted as a good level for reliability, a moderate
consistency in item data coding is seen between capital structure and
tangibility of assets. A positive correlation between these two
variables indicates a positive and moderate reliability.
2.
The Cronbachs alpha in the case of firm size and capital structure
comes out to be only 0.025 which is nearer to zero and signifies poor
reliability and consistency in data coding.
3.
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
N of Items
.344
2
707
Research
Reliability Statistics
Cronbach's Alpha
N of Items
.058
2
An alpha result of only 0.058 depicts that there is poor or almost no
consistency in the data coding of non-debt tax shield. This is supported
by the fact there is very low correlation between the two factors (0.124).
Conclusion
The study uses a sample of seven listed pharmaceutical
companies in Pakistan. The data covered the quarterly period from
July 2008 December 2010. Pooled regressions were run between
leverage and independent variables. Low R- square of regressions
imply that only about a third of the variation in leverage of the
companies is jointly explained by the above mentioned seven variables.
Furthermore, the results regarding the significance of individual
variables are summarized below:
708
Research
709
Research
References
A.A. Kanwar (2007), Booth Revisited: Identifying the Determinants
Of Capital Structure in the Sugar Sector, Market Forces, Vol. 3 No.2
Booth, L., Aivazian, V., Demirguc-Kunt, A.E. and Maksimovic, V. (2001),
Capital Structures in Developing Countries, Journal of Finance, Vol.
56, PP. 87-130.
Bradley, Michael., Jarrell, Gregg A. and Kim, E. Han (1984), On the
Existence of an Optimal Capital Structure: Theory and Evidence, The
Journal of Finance, Vol. 39, No. 3, Jul., 1984, pp: 857-878
Chen, J. (2004), Determinants of Capital Structure of Chinese-listed
Companies, Journal of Business Research, 57, pp.1341-1351
Donaldson, G. (1961). Corporate Debt Capacity: A Study of Corporate
Debt Policy and the Determinants of the Corporate Debt Capacity,
Boston: Division of Research, Harvard Graduate School of Business
Administration
Fama, Eugene F., and Kenneth R. French (2002), Testing tradeoff and
pecking order predictions about dividends and debt, The Review of
Financial Studies 15, 133
Financial information retrieved on 04 24, 2011, from www.abbott.com.pk,
www.ferozsons-labs.com, www.gsk.com.pk, www.highnoon-labs.com,
www.sanofi-aventis.com.pk,
www.searlepak.com,
and
www.ppma.org.pk.
Kraus and R.H. Litzenberger (1973), A State-Preference Model of
Optimal Financial Leverage, Journal of Finance, September 1973, pp.
911-922
Leary, Mark T. and Roberts, Michael R. (2005), Do Firms Rebalance
Their Capital Structures? The Journal Of Finance, Vol. Lx, No. 6
Mahmud, Muhammad; Herani, Gobind M.; Rajar, A.W. and Farooqi,
Wahid (2009), Economic Factors Influencing Corporate Capital
Structure in Three Asian Countries: Evidence from Japan, Malaysia
and Pakistan, Indus Journal of Management & Social Sciences
Modigliani; Franco and Miller, Merton H. (1958), The Cost of Capital,
Corporation Finance and the Theory of Investment, The American
Economic Review, Vol. 48, No. 3. (Jun., 1958), pp. 261-297.
Myers, Stewart C. and Brealey, Richard A. (2003), Principles of
Corporate Finance, 7th Ed, pp. 482
Pakistan Pharmaceutical Sector. (2008), OSEC Business Network
Switzerland.
710
Research
711
Research
Research
AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF
WORKING CAPITAL POLICY,
RISK AND LEVERAGE
Sumita J. Shroff
Department of Accounting and Financial Management,
The Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda, Vadodara, India
Abstract
The current study examined the structure of current assets,
efficiency of current asset management, the nature of current asset
investment financing policy and the overall working capital policy
and working capital leverage of ITC Limited belonging to Indian
Food and Beverages Industry over a period of 11 years from 2000-01
to 2010-11. It was found that the inventory management has
deteriorated whereas debtors management has improved over the
study period. Further, the relationship between working capital
leverage and profitability as well as between working capital policy
risk and profitability was examined to understand the impact working
capital policies on the profitability of the Indian food and beverages
industry. The results indicated that ROTA was not very sensitive to
change in current asset investment policy. Also it was observed that
aggressive working capital financing and investing policy had
negative impact on the profitability of ITC Limited. However, the
results were observed to be insignificant due to which it could not be
applicable to the entire industry.
Keywords: Working Capital Policy, Working Capital Leverage,
Working Capital Risk, Net Working Capital, Current Asset
Management
JEL Classification: G31, G32
712
Research
Introduction
The corporate finance literature has traditionally focused on
the study of long term financial decisions. However, the short term
financial decisions are equally tactical and important for any enterprise
in order to carry on its business operations productively, consistently
and efficiently. Working capital management involves managing of
the dynamic relationship between current assets (CA) and current
liabilities (CL) which are ever changing and volatile. The high risk
high return working capital investment and financing strategies are
referred as aggressive whereas lower risk and return strategies are
called moderate or matching and still lower risk and return is called
conservative working capital policy (Moyer, Mcguigan and Kretlow1,
Pinches2, Gitman3). A firm may adopt an aggressive working capital
management policy with a low level of current assets as percentage of
total assets or high level of current liabilities as percentage of total
liabilities. However, excessive levels of current assets may have a
negative effect on the firms profitability whereas a low level of current
assets may lead to lower level of liquidity and stock-outs resulting in
difficulties in maintaining smooth operations (Van Horne and
Wachowicz4). Similarly, use of current liabilities to finance the current
assets as well as portion of fixed assets is risky to the company as the
current obligations are to be honoured every 12 months. The higher
the use of current funds to total assets, higher is the risk but such a
policy gives higher return in the context that it saves the cost of long
term funds used (since the cost of long term funds are presumed to be
more than the short term funds). However, if more of long term funds
are used to finance current assets, the risk is less but the returns are
also less. Thus, every management strives hard to adopt such working
capital policy which ensures risk return tradeoffs.
Risk in working capital management is therefore an outcome
of aggressive working capital investment and financing policy. Net
working capital (NWC) position represents the excess of CA over CL
and is a measure of risk of working capital financing policy. This is
713
Research
Research
715
Research
Research
for the initial four years and an aggressive policy in the last five years
resulting in negative working capital which had a negative impact on
the profitability. However, the positive association between risk and
profitability was substantiated in the first period.
Mandal (2010)6 assessed the impact of working capital
management on liquidity, profitability and non-insurable risk of ONGC
over a nine-year period from 1998-99 to 2006-07 and the analysis
revealed a statistically significant positive relationship between
liquidity and profitability as well as risk and profitability.
Saini and Saini (2010)7 assessed the efficiency of liquidity
management as also the association between liquidity profitability
and the trade-off between profitability and risk of Infosys Technologies
Limited for a period of ten years, i.e. 1999-2000 to 2008-09. The analysis
revealed that the investment of sample firm in current assets in relation
to total assets was very high and was consistently maintained. They
found a mildly positive association between risk and profitability
indicating that high degree of conservative policy adopted by the
company has made a negative impact on its profitability.
Thus, studies of Gardner9, Jose et al10, Mandal6 and Saini
and Saini 7 substantiated direct relationship between risk and
profitability, whereas, Afza and Nazir (2007)15 and (2009)16 found
negative relationship between risk and profitability thereby challenging
the conventional theories.
2. Objectives of the Study
In the light of literature reviewed, the present study is undertaken
with the following objectives:
a.
717
Research
b.
c.
718
Research
719
Research
720
Research
Year
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
2010-11
CA
(Amt in `
Crores)
2872.70
2956.20
3390.01
3647.66
3465.67
5016.39
6037.08
7031.30
8171.61
7878.51
9863.58
Median
Mean
Standard Deviation
TABLE 2
Current Asset Structure Ratios
ITCAR DTCAR CBBT
PETCAR
(In %)
(In %)
CAR
(In %)
(In %)
39.85
39.52
1.23
0
39.93
45.31
1.50
0
36.93
41.08
11.18
0
42.06
37.88
9.33
0
57.80
32.97
1.60
0
52.55
24.82
17.06
0
55.58
23.95
14.91
0.36
57.61
27.9
8.11
1.08
56.29
21.9
12.62
3.37
57.74
22.83
14.30
2.91
53.40
20.10
22.74
1.64
53.40
27.90
11.18
0.00
49.98
30.75
10.42
0.85
8.40
8.92
6.96
1.26
LATCAR
(In %)
19.4
13.26
10.81
10.73
7.63
5.57
5.20
5.30
5.82
2.22
2.12
5.82
8.00
5.17
721
Research
Year
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
2010-11
Mean
Median
SD
722
TABLE 3
Current Asset Management Ratios
ITR
IHP
DTR
ACP
(Times)
(In days) (Times)
(In days)
7.60
48
7.66
48
8.34
44
7.35
50
8.81
41
7.92
46
7.70
47
8.56
43
6.67
55
11.69
31
6.16
59
13.04
28
5.82
63
13.49
27
5.29
69
10.94
33
5.05
72
12.99
28
5.80
63
14.68
25
5.82
63
15.45
24
6.64
57
11.25
35
6.16
59
11.69
31
1.28
10
2.96
9.91
CATR
(Times)
3.03
3.33
3.25
3.24
3.86
3.24
3.23
3.05
2.85
3.35
3.11
3.23
3.24
0.26
Research
TCA
2872.70
2956.20
3390.01
3647.66
3465.67
5016.39
6037.08
7031.30
8171.61
7878.51
9863.58
Total
Assets
5997.84
7257.77
8681.34
10689.76
11758.15
13318.26
15235.23
17549.22
19785.21
23357.69
25844.21
Mean
Median
SD
CATAR
0.46
0.39
0.40
0.32
0.30
0.37
0.37
0.38
0.39
0.32
0.36
0.37
0.37
0.04
in
CA
----83.50
433.81
257.65
-181.99
1550.72
1020.69
994.22
1140.31
-293.10
1985.07
TA-CA
----7341.27
9115.15
10947.41
11576.16
14868.98
16255.92
18543.44
20925.52
23064.59
27829.28
Mean
Median
SD
WCL
----0.403
0.372
0.333
0.299
0.337
0.371
0.379
0.391
0.342
0.354
0.36
0.36
0.03
CASR
(In %)
33.02
30.02
30.74
30.86
25.94
30.90
30.95
32.75
35.15
29.84
32.20
31.12
30.90
2.32
723
Research
724
Research
TABLE 5
Year
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
2010-11
TABLE 6
Results of Simple Linear Regression of WCL on ROTA
t
Variable
Intercept
R2
Slope 1
p value
statistic
WCL
19.99
0.183
21.54
1.4189
0.190
Table Value of t = 2.262 at 5% level of significance
725
Research
Year
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
2010-11
TABLE 7
Working Capital Financing Policy Ratios
Total CA
Total CL NWC
CL/CA CR
2872.70
1604.39
1268.31
0.56
1.79
2956.20
2559.25
396.95
0.87
1.16
3390.01
3198.74
191.27
0.94
1.06
3647.66
4158.85
-511.19
1.14
0.88
3465.67
3617.18
-151.51
1.04
0.96
5016.39
4137.05
879.34
0.82
1.21
6037.08
4597.27
1439.81
0.76
1.31
7031.30
5277.12
1754.18
0.75
1.33
8171.61
5872.58
2299.03
0.72
1.39
7878.51
9185.60
-1307.09
1.17
0.86
9863.58
9791.74
71.84
0.99
1.01
Mean
0.89
1.18
Median
0.87
1.16
SD
0.19
0.27
CV
21.35
22.88
CLTAR
0.27
0.35
0.37
0.39
0.31
0.31
0.30
0.30
0.30
0.39
0.38
0.33
0.31
0.04
12.12
Year
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
2009-10
2010-11
Research
TABLE 8
Ranking s of Measures of Risk of overall working capital policy
Risk
NWC
Rank
Rank CLTAR Rank CR
Rank
Factor
11
11
1.79
11
1268.31
11
0.44
0 .27
6
5
1.16
6
396.95
6
0.13
0 .35
191.27
-511.19
-151.51
879.34
1439.81
1754.18
2299.03
-1307.09
71.84
5
2
3
7
8
9
10
1
4
0.06
-0.14
-0.04
0.18
0.24
0.25
0.28
-0.17
0.01
5
2
3
7
8
9
10
1
4
0 .37
0 .39
0 .31
0 .31
0 .30
0 .30
0 .30
0 .39
0 .38
4
2
6
7
8
9
10
1
3
1.06
0.88
0.96
1.21
1.31
1.33
1.39
0.86
1.01
5
2
3
7
8
9
10
1
4
CATAR
CLT AR
CR
NWC
Risk
Factor
CL/CA
CAT AR
1
-0.48 568
CLTAR
CR
NWC
0.870808
0.646913
-0.83634
-0.80003
1
0.794794
0.849182
-0.84 918
-0.85856
0.858562
0 .96897
-0.96897
0.892648
-0.89265
Risk
Factor
CL/CA
1
-1
727
Research
Research
729
Research
References
1 Moyer R.C., Mcguigan J. R. and Kretlow W. J. (2005). Contemporary
Financial Management. 10th Edition. New York:South Western
College Publishing.
2 Pinches G. E. (1992). Essentials of Financial Management. 4th Edition.
New York: Harper Collins College.
3 Gitman L. A. (2005). Principles of Managerial Finance. 11th Edition.
New York: Addison Wesley Publishers.
4 Van-Horne J. C. and Wachowicz J. M. (2004). Fundamentals of
Financial Management. 12thEdition. New York: Prentice Hall
Publishers.
5 Luther C T Sam (2007), Madras Cements Limited-Working Capital
Policies. Icfai Reader. April 2007, pp. 55-67.
6 Mandal N (2010). Impact of Working Capital Management on
Liquidity, Profitability and Non Insurable Risk and Uncertainty
Bearing: A Case Study of Oil and Natural Gas Commission (ONGC).
Great Lakes Herald, Vol.4 No.2, September 2010, pp. 21-42.
7 Saini A and Saini R D (2010). Analysis of liquidity management and
trade-Off between liquidity, risk and profitability: An empirical study.
Journal of Accounting and Finance. Vol 24 (2). April September
2010, pp. 29-42.
8 Walker, E. W. (1964), Towards a Theory of Working Capital,
Engineering Economist, Jan Feb, 1964, pp. 21-35.
9 Gardner M. J., Mills D. L. and Pope R. A. (1986). Working Capital
Policy and Operating Risk: An Empirical Analysis. The Financial
Review 21(3): 31-31.
10 Jose M. L., Lancaster C. and Stevens J. L. (1996). Corporate Returns
and Cash Conversion Cycle. Journal of Economics and Finance.
Vol 20(1), pp. 33-46.
11 Weinraub H. J. and S Visscher (1998), Industry Practice Relating
To Aggressive Conservative Working Capital Policies, Journal of
Financial and Strategic Decision, Vol 11(2), Fall-1998, pp. 11-18.
12 Salawu R. O. (2006). Industry Practice and Aggressive
Conservative Working Capital Policies in Nigeria. European Journal
of Scientific Research. March 2006. Vol. 13, No. 3, pp. 294-304.
730
Research
731
Research
Research
EMOTIONAL INTELLIGENCE IN
DOCTORS AND NURSES OF
EMERGENCY MEDICINE UNITS IN
TERTIARY HOSPITALS
Humeira Jawed, Asima Faisal
Department of Health and Hospital Management
Institute of Business Management, (IoBM), Karachi
Abstract
Emergency medicine staff of Karachi has the emotional
competency to manage patient care. Emotional Intelligence Score of
nurses was comparatively higher than doctors (p< 0.01). There was
no significant difference between the scores of males and females
when dealing with medical emergencies (p = 0.057). Emotional
intelligence increases with years of clinical experience (p<0.01). Score
of doctors and nurses in the public sector was higher as compared to
hospitals in the private sector (p=0.002). Workload was rated as the
most common factor for affecting their emotional strength and
recommendations were provided. This is a preliminary study to assess
Emotional Intelligence in order to identify the levels of emotional
intelligence in health care practitioners of an emergency unit. The
results will assist the management to identify areas of improvement
to develop effective performance and good communication with
patients, while the hospital can design strategies for the right career
placement for its personnel and provide training to emergency
medicine staff to facilitate quick decision making skills.
Keywords: emotional intelligence, emergency medicine, SEIS, work
performance, emotional competency
JEL Classification: Z000
732
Research
Introduction
Emotional Intelligence (EI) is the understanding, managing
and controlling our own emotions and recognizing the emotions of
others. Asan (2003) has described the importance of emotional
intelligence in identifying an individuals success in work, family, and
social life and an individuals ability to manage his/her relations
efficiently with the environment. This includes the awareness and
judgment of the knowledge related to the emotion, and operating on
the emotional knowledge as a part of problem solving in daily life.
According to Goleman (1996), EI is defined as the capacity
for recognizing our own feelings and those of others, for motivating
ourselves, and for managing emotions well in ourselves and in our
relationships. In everyday language, EI is what typically referred to
as street smartness or common sense.
Wagner et al. (2002) published the first study that focused
on a state of a physicians emotional strength and the relationship
between physician and the patient. They found that only one subscale of emotional intelligence (i.e., happiness) was related to higher
patient satisfaction; the other sub-scales (i.e., interpersonal skills,
adaptability, stress, and mood) were unrelated. Stratton et al. (2005)
conducted a study on medical students and found that attention to
feelings, empathic concern, and perspective were positively correlated
with communication skills, while emphatic concern did not have a
positive correlation with physical examination skills.
Salovey and Mayer (1990) state that EI has been described
as social intelligence which is the ability to monitor ones own and
others emotions, segregating emotions and using the information
generated to guide ones thinking and actions. A person who is
emotional intelligent is skilled in identifying, using, understanding,
and regulating his emotions. According to Goleman (1996), self
awareness, management of emotions, motivating oneself, identifying
733
Research
734
Research
735
Research
less than six months during the study period. Out of 150 respondents,
120 gave consent to the study. A sample of 100 gave complete
response. Nurses also included paramedics operating in the wards
while doctors included house officers and post graduates level
attending the ward at the time of data collection.
Data collection tool was in form of a questionnaire with of
the Schuttes Emotional Intelligence Scale. According to Jonker and
Vosloo (2008), the scale is a 33-item self-report questionnaire with the
highest EI score of 165 and lowest score of 33. The scores were
totaled of each respondent. Demographics were extracted after a focus
based interview with two doctors and two nurses from emergency
medicine set up. An interview based questionnaire was developed
with an attached disclaimer and consent form. Data collection was
mainly done in the low traffic morning hours, the time where the
frequencies of casualties are low. Data was tabulated on SPSS 17 and
analyzed and results summarized. P value was used to find out
relationship between demographics and EI scores were analyzed using
independent t test while p value of workplace variables was calculated
using Fisher Exact test.
Results
There were 55 female and 45 males respondents. Majority of
the respondents belonged to age group 25-40 years. From private
hospitals, there were 43 respondents and 57 from public hospitals. 30
respondents had a clinical experience of 1-5 years. Around 34
respondents were attending more than 20 emergency cases per day.
(Table 1)
736
Research
Age (years)
Hospitals
Staff
Male
Female
<25
2 5-30
3 1-40
4 1-50
>50
Private
Public
Nurses
Do ctors
<1
1-5
6-10
>10
<10 cases
1 0-15
1 6-20
>20
Frequency (n)
55
45
23
24
25
14
14
43
57
59
41
19
30
26
25
3
33
28
34
Gender
Hospitals
Staff
Clinical
experience
(years)
Male
Female
Private
Public
Nurses
Doctors
< 10 years
Mean SD
127.25 19.93
120.04 16.88
117.44 20.38
128.96 16.13
135.63 10.57
107.29 15.30
109.44 13.52
>10 years
137.41 11.89
P value*
0.057
0.002
<0.01*
<0.01*
737
Research
Workload
Nurses
Doctors
Frequency
(n)
Percentage
(%)
Frequency
(n)
Percentage
(%)
Monetary
Recognitio incentives
Personal Colleagues n from
from
stress
at work
seniors
hospital
21
15
10
35.60%
25.40%
16.90%
15.30%
6.80%
31
75.60%
14.60%
4.90%
4.90%
0.00%
0.002
* Fisher Exact
Discussion
The duty of emergency medicine staff is to stabilize patients
who have a life-threatening injury or illness. In contrast to medicine
or primary care, emergency medical care focuses on the provision of
immediate or urgent medical interventions. Emergency medicine staff
needs to work like critical managers practicing medical decisionmaking and executing the actions necessary to prevent life risk or
disability because of time-critical health problems whatever the age,
gender or demographics of the patient may be.
EI is recognized as an important personal attribute involved
in nurturing the patient physician relationship and is thus
increasingly included in the medical education curriculum. Medical
738
Research
739
Research
740
Research
741
Research
References
Asan, . & zyer, K., (2003). To identify demographic factors that
influence emotional intelligence an empirical study. H. . Journal of
Economics and Administrative Sciences, 21,1, 151-167.
Birks Y, Mc Kendree J, Watt I: (2009) Emotional intelligence and
perceived stress in healthcare students: a multi-institutional, multiprofessional survey, BMC Medical Education, 9:61
Geiser J, (2001) An Analysis of Emotional Intelligence with relation to
Sales Professionals, Unpublished Honors, Ohio University
Goleman D, Emotional Intelligence, (1998); Why It Can Matter More
Than IQ, Bantam Books. ISBN 978-0-553-38371-3
Guthrie, M.B. (1999). Challenges in developing physician leadership.
Frontiers in Health Services Management, 15: 3-28.
Jonker, C.S.& Vosloo, C. (2008) The psychometric properties of the
Schutte emotional intelligence scale. SA journal of industrial
psychology, 34(2):21-30.
Meisler G., Gadot EV., (2010) Emotional intelligence empowers positive
attitudes in private sector; not in public sector.PHYSorg.com. Last
retrieved: www.phys.org/pdf212328722
Ngah R, Jusoff K,(2009) Emotional Intelligence of Malaysian Academia
towards Work Performance, International Education Studies, 2, 2
Pau AKH, Croucher R: (2003) Emotional intelligence and perceived
stress in dental undergraduates. J Dental Education , 67(9):1023-28.
Prez ZA; (2009) Evaluating Emotional Intelligence in the Workplace:
A selected sample, University of Puerto Rico, ISBN 1109304803
9781109304800
742
Research
743
Research
Research
Abstract
This research paper shows that the AFRS for SMEs, introduced
by The institute of Chartered Accountants of Pakistan (ICAP) in 2006,
served a very useful purpose by providing a framework, which was less
onerous than the International Accounting Standards (IAS) to comply with,
but at the same time included the key elements required to provide clarity,
transparency and comparability of the financial statements, to investors
and other users. However, with the release of IFRS for SMEs, by the
International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) in 2009, the earlier
introduced AFRS for SMEs have become albeit redundant.
Key words: Accounting Financial Reporting Standards (AFRS) for Medium
Sized Entities (MSEs) and Small Sized Entities (SSEs), International Financial
Reporting Standards (IFRS) for Small and Medium Sized Entities (SMEs),
International Accounting Standard Board (IASB), The Institute of Chartered
Accountants of Pakistan (ICAP)
JEL Classification: M410
744
Research
Introduction
AFRS for Medium Sized Entities (MSEs) and Small Sized
Entities (SSEs) were approved, by the Council of ICAP on July 28,
2006, and is applicable on or after July 1, 2006. As stated in the
preamble This Framework sets out the conceptual basis for the
preparation of general purpose financial statements of Medium-Sized
Entities (MSEs). The said Standards have been notified by the
Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP), and
compliance is mandatory, for qualifying companies registered under
the Companies Ordinance 1984.
The Standards are in two parts, one for MSEs and the other
for SSEs. The Standard for MSEs has 17 sections spread over 104
pages (refer Annexure 1) whereas the Standard for SSEs has 50 clauses
and are spread over just 5 pages. Clause 14 of the Framework, that
precedes the Standard for MSEs, suggests that where a transaction
falls outside this Standard, guidance be obtained from International
Accounting Standards (IAS) and International Financial Reporting
Standards (IFRS) and related documents. Clause 22 of the Standards
for SSEs suggests that where transactions and events fall outside
this Standard guidance be obtained from the Standard for MSE. For
the purposes of this paper and for comparisons with IFRS for SMEs,
only the Standards for MSEs, which are more comprehensive, have
been used.
As per Clause 1 of the preamble to AFRS for MSEs headed
Qualifying Entities (QE) compliance with MSE Framework and
Standard is necessary in order to give a true and fair view . As per
Clause 2 of the QE: A Medium-Sized Entity (MSE) is an entity that:
(a) is not a company that is listed on the Stock Exchange, or a
subsidiary of such company;
(b) has not registered, or is not in the process of registering, its
financial statements with the Securities and Exchange
Commission of Pakistan (SECP) or other regulatory body, for
PAKISTAN BUSINESS REVIEW JAN 2013
745
Research
746
Research
Problem Statement
Pakistan has been committed to implementing IAS since the
mid 1970s, and had adopted most of the 48 IASs and IFRS released by
the IASB up to the mid 2000s. However, ICAP realized that the IASs
and IFRSs adopted in Pakistan were generally much too complex and
cumbersome to implement by the MSEs and the SSEs. Thus ICAP
took the initiative to develop the AFRS for MSEs and SSEs which
were released by ICAP in July 2006 and notified by the SECP.
The IASB, also realized the need for having separate IFRS
for SMEs, and in July 2009 released the IFRS for SMEs. The latter is
designed for SMEs to meet the needs of the investors, creditors and
other users, for information about cash flows, liquidity and solvency.
It takes into account the costs, and the resources of SMEs to prepare
financial information. As per the Guide to the IFRS for SMEs issued in
March 2012, in comparison to the full IFRS there are considerable
fewer disclosures required (estimated 90% elimination), and the
standard has been written to enable easy comprehension. and facilitate
translation for various countries . To additionally lighten the burden
for SMEs, amendments to the IFRS for SMEs would be made only
once every three years.
The IFRS for SMEs were released by the IASB in July 2009.
As the name indicates these are meant for use by smaller enterprises,
and have 35 sections and a glossary of terms spread over 231 pages
(refer Annexure II).
As per Section 1 of the IFRS for SMEs, this standard is
applicable to organizations that (i) do not have public accountability*,
and (ii) publish financial statements for general use.
The basis to qualify as an SME thus depends on the nature
of the entity, and not on how big the entity is projected.
* An entity has public accountability if:
PAKISTAN BUSINESS REVIEW JAN 2013
747
Research
Research
749
Research
Research
751
Research
Research
time of release of the AFRS for SMEs, in July 2006, and reflects that
the latter is no longer current.
Section 3 of the IFRS for SMEs deals with Financial
Statement Presentation, and requires that the financial statements
present fairly the financial position, financial performance and cash
flows of an entity. The standard further elaborates that these include
the five main financial statements, by their revised names, including
the Notes comprising of a summary of accounting policies and
explanations to the financial figures in the statements; there is also
mention of requirement of the statement of comprehensive income.
Section 3 of the IFRS for SMEs includes requirements for
going concern (clauses 3.8, 3.9), frequency of reporting (clause 3.10),
consistency of presentation (clauses 3.11, 3.12, 3.13), comparative
information (clause 3.14), materiality and aggregation (clauses 3.16).
However, the IFRS for SMEs does not address presentation of segment
information, earnings per share, or interim financial reports (clause
3.25); an entity making such disclosures shall describe the basis for
preparing and presenting such information (clause 3.25).
It would appear that the IFRS for SMEs is more current and
more comprehensive than the AFRS for MSEs in Pakistan. It specifies
(clause 3.17) the concept of comprehensive income and other essential
reporting features such as (clause 3.14) requirement for previous
comparative results, and (clause 3.25) specific omission of certain
disclosures.
Cash Flow Statement
Section 2 of the AFRS for MSEs in Pakistan deals with the
cash flow statement, and summarizes the main features of IAS 7 in 2
pages. The AFRS mentions the three classifications of cash flow i.e.
Operating, Investing and Financing Activities, and briefly describes
in general what is to be included in these classifications. The AFRS
753
Research
(clause 2.5) also indicates that the cash flow from operating activities
is to be reflected either by the direct method or indirect method, and
describes the same.
The AFRS (clause 2.15) requires that an enterprise shall give
a Note indicating the amount of cash and cash equivalent that cannot
be used by the enterprise. However, there is no mention of what is to
be specifically disclosed in each of the three classifications of the
cash flow statement.
Section 7 of the IFRS for SMEs describes the requirements
for the statement of cash flows. It details the scope of this section,
description of cash equivalents, information to be presented in the
cash flows under its three activities. The IFRS (clauses 7.7, 7.8, 7.9)
also indicates that operating activities may be presented using either
the direct method or the indirect method, and specifies details of
these two methods.
The IFRS states (clause 7.10) that total cash flows arising
from acquisition and disposal of subsidiaries or other business units
be presented separately and classified as investing activities (as per
amendment to IAS 7 effective April 2009).
The IFRS also describes the treatment of foreign currency
cash flows, as well as specifies alternatives allowed for reflecting
interest and dividends.
Upon reviewing the above two standards, it is observed
that both the AFRS for MSEs in Pakistan and the IFRS for SMEs have
largely adopted IAS 7 as their standard, and there is no change for
the users of the respective users of these standards. However, the
IFRS for SMEs has been presented in a more comprehensive manner,
and is more current with recent changes.
754
Research
755
Research
Research
757
Research
758
Research
759
Research
IFRS for SMEs released by the IASB in 2009, and are self
contained and fairly comprehensive. This makes it user friendly.
IFRS for SMEs are designed for use by entities that do not
have public accountability, with no limitation on size of the entity.
Thus, the standards can be used by a larger and less restrictive group.
IASB is committed to regularly update the standards, and
has the resources to do so. We understand that over 80 countries
have adopted the IFRS for SMEs or proposed to do so. These included
Nepal and Sri Lanka in South Asia. The IFRS Foundation and IASB
are providing implementation support including formal training, and
publishing a monthly newsletter, IFRS for SMEs Update.
A large number of entities would be using these standards
and thus comparative financial statements and related ratios and
statistics may be available for comparison. The international ratios
and statistics that would be available could be used as a benchmark,
after necessary adjustments, if required, for comparison.
Submission
The AFRS for MSEs and SSEs were approved by the ICAP
Council in July 2006, at which time the IFRS for SMES were not
available. However, six years have elapsed since the issue of this
Standard, which is now no longer current, and has outlived its
usefulness. It is suggested that consideration be given to replacing
this with IFRS for SMEs issued by IASB, with any modifications if
required. This would give additional credibility to financial statements
issued in Pakistan as well as enhance international credibility of the
accountancy profession in Pakistan. Now that the IASB has issued
the IFRS for SMEs and have the resources to keep these current,
Pakistan should adopt the same. The financial statements produced
in compliance with IFRS for SMEs would produce more reliable
financial statements that would be acceptable internationally, and
would not be more onerous to prepare. These would be comparable
to international financial statements, and better serve the users
including present and potential investors, management, lenders, and
others.
760
Research
References
Coetze Stephen, 2009 IFRS for SMEs IS small, small ENOUGH?
Accountancy SA; Accounting & Tax Periodicals pg. 32.
Deloitte UK GAAP, 2010 IFRS for SMEs in your pocket UK edition.
Deloitte, 2011 onwards, Summaries of IAS and IFRS.
International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), Illustrative Financial
Statements and Presentation and Disclosure Checklist accompany the
International Financial Reporting Standard for Small and Medium-sized
Entities.
IASB, 2012, A Guide to the IFRS for SMEs IASB
IFRS Foundation; issues for January, February and March 2012
IFRS for SMEs update.
International Accounting Standards Board (IASB), 2009 International
Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) for Small and Medium-sized
Entities (SMEs).
Ionescu, Cicilia, 2011, International Financial Reporting Standards
For SMES, Professor PhDFaculty of Financial-Accounting and
Management Bucharest Spiru Haret University Lucian Dorel
ILINCU, Lecturer PhD. Faculty of Financial-Accounting and
Management Bucharest Spiru Haret University.
Pascu, Ana-Maria, 2011 International Financial Reporting Standard
For Small And Medium-Sized Entities- A New Challenge For The
European Union Alexandru Ioan Cuza University of Iai CES Working
Papers, III, (1).
761
Research
762
Research
ANNEXURE I
CONTENTS
Accounting and Financial Reporting Standard for Medium-Sized
Entities (MSEs)
Framework . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..... . . . . 1
Qualifying Entities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..7
Sections
1. Presentation of Financial Statements . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... .. . . . . . 9
2. Cash Flow Statements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . 19
3. Property, Plant and Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .21
4. Leases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 29
5. Intangible Assets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .33
6. Inventories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . . . 41
7. Accounting for Government Grants and Disclosure of
Government Assistance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
8. Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets . . . . . 45
9. Revenue . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... ... . . . . . 51
10. Borrowing Costs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... . . . . 55
11. Income Taxes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .57
12. Accounting Policies, Changes in Accounting Estimates
and Errors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61
13. The Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates . . . . . .. . . . 65
14. Events after the Balance Sheet Date . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . 67
15. Related Party Disclosures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .71
16. Investments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 75
17. Employee Benefits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . 81
Annexures
1. Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .85
2 . Examples . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . .... . . . .97
763
Research
ANNEXURE II
IFRS FOR SMES JULY 2009
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL REPORTING STANDARD
FOR SMALLAND MEDIUM-SIZED ENTITIES (IFRS for SMEs)
PREFACE ..6
Sections
1 Small And Medium-Sized Entities 10
2 Concepts And Pervasive Principles .....12
3 Financial Statement Presentation ..22
4 Statement Of Financial Position 27
5 Statement Of Comprehensive Income And Income Statement ....31
6 Statement Of Changes In Equity And Statement Of Income
And Retained Earnings 34
7 Statement Of Cash Flows ..36
8 Notes To The Financial Statements .41
9 Consolidated And Separate Financial Statements .43
10 Accounting Policies, Estimates And Errors ..49
11 Basic Financial Instruments .54
12 Other Financial Instruments Issues 69
13 Inventories .....76
14 Investments In
Associates........................81
15 Investments In Joint Ventures ....85
16 Investment Property .....89
17 Property, Plant And Equipment ...92
18 Intangible Assets Other Than Goodwill 98
19 Business Combinations And Goodwill 104
20 Leases ..... 110
21 Provisions And Contingencies 118
764
Research
Research
Abstract
This study highlights the role of pay satisfaction and
organizational commitment in faculty of different private business
universities located in Karachi, Pakistan. Based on previous literature,
it was assumed that pay satisfaction will predict organizational
commitment. A survey of 80 faculty members (47 males and 33 females)
of different private business universities was conducted. To assess
pay satisfaction, Pay Satisfaction Questionnaire (PSQ; Heneman, &
Schwab, 1985) was used. The Organizational Commitment
Questionnaire (OCQ; Mowday, Steers, & Porter, 1979) was employed
to assess organizational commitment. Linear regression analysis
suggests that pay satisfaction influences organizational commitment
among business university faculty.
Keywords: Pay satisfaction, Organizational Commitment, Private
Sector University
JEL Classification: Z000
765
Research
Introduction
Private sector universities are facing challenges in retaining
the faculty and research findings also highlighted this view. Sumita
(2004) emphasizes that to maintain workforce has remained a problem
for the human resource management specialists. According to Lavy
(2007), Variety exists in terms of working conditions, pay packages,
recognition, fringe benefits, and incentives. The influence of these
variables on organizational commitment is significant to investigate
in educational organizations, particularly universities which are
responsible for educating the intellect of the countries. Faculty is an
essential part in educational structure which holds a variety of
responsibilities. In particular, performance of universities is based on
their teachers and their level of commitment. This commitment can be
influenced by different variables and pay satisfaction is one of the
imperative variables. Therefore, understanding the relationship among
faculty pay satisfaction and commitment require more consideration
in higher education institutions. This research was an attempt to
explore the role of pay satisfaction on organizational commitment
among private business universities faculty of Karachi.
Pay or salary is a periodic reimbursement from an employer
to its employees, which is clearly stated in workers agreement. Pay is
believed to be single most imperative organizational compensations
(Heneman & Judge, 2000). It is evaluated with portion of pay, where
every work, time of job or other piece of work is compensated on a
periodic basis. Pay is conceivably prominent element to the majority
of individuals as it proposes them a corresponding level of purchasing
power. Wage, salary or pay is considered a significant reward to
motivate the workers and their behavior towards the goals of employer
(Oshagbemi, 2000). Pay dissatisfaction can lead to job dissatisfaction,
turnover, less interest in their work, more absenteeism, decreased
motivation and low commitment level with organization. It is also
extensively studied that pay satisfaction positively influences overall
766
Research
767
Research
768
Research
769
Research
770
Research
pay satisfaction [(R =.113, F (1, 78, 79) = 9.905, p <.05)], while
continuance commitment [(R =.010, F (1, 78, 79) = .790, p e.05)] and
normative commitment [(R =.016, F (1, 78, 79) =1.261, p e.05)] reveal
insignificant prediction with pay satisfaction.
Results
Table 1 Demographic Information of respondents
Demographic Variables
Percentage
%
Demographic Variables
Qualification
Masters
MS/M.Phil
PhD
70.4%
21.6%
8%
Length of
Service
Gender
Female
Male
58.75%
41.25%
Marital Status
Income Level
20,000 -30,000 Rs
31,000-40,000 Rs
41,000-50,000 Rs
51,000-60,000 Rs
61,000 Rs or above
20.6%
32%
18%
12%
17.4%
Designations
Percent
age %
19.6%
12.8%
24.4%
16%
27.2%
57.6%
34.4%
8%
35.75%
19.4%
8.75%
13.2%
8.8%
15%
R2
Adj R
Organizational Co mmitment
.321
.103
.091
df= 78
a.
b.
771
Research
F
8.930
Sig
.004
Un-standardized
Coefficient
B
SE
Constant
19.166
3.608
Pay Satisfaction
.207
.069
Standardize
Coefficient
Sig
5.3 12
.000
2.9 88
.004
Organizational
Commitment
.3 21
R2
Affective Commitment
.336
.113
.101
Continuance Commitment
.100
.010
-.003
Normative Commitment
.126
.016
.003
Dependable Variable
Adj R
df= 78
a. Predictors: (Constant), Affective Commitment, Continuan ce
Commitment, Normative Co mmitment
b. Dependent Variable: Pay Satisfaction
772
Research
F
9.905
Sig
.002
.790
.377
1.261
.265
Commitment,
Un-standardized
Coefficient
Standardize
Coefficient
Sig
6.960
.000
SE
Constant
35.275
5.0 69
Affective
Constant
.518
45.991
.165
5.4 05
.336
3.147
8.509
.002
.000
Continuance
Constant
.154
43.015
.173
6.9 24
.100
.889
6.213
.377
.000
.200
.126
1.123
.265
773
Research
Discussion
The main hypothesis of this study was to explore that whether
pay satisfaction would predict organizational commitment among
faculty in private sector business universities of Karachi. The statistical
analysis [(R =.103, F (1, 78) = 8.930, p <.05)] of current study revealed
that pay satisfaction emerges as one of the significant variables which
appreciably contribute in organizational commitment of faculty
members. The result are in line with numerous preceding findings
which suggest that pay satisfaction has a positive influence on
organizational commitment (Heneman & Judge, 2000; Lee & Martin,
1996; Shapiro & Wahba, 1978). Furthermore, this contention has been
supported in a meta-analysis (Mathieu & Zajac, 1990) and various
empirical studies (Huber, Seybolt, & Veneman, 1992). In other words,
people with a high level of pay satisfaction are highly committed to
the organization, (Cohen-Charash & Spector, 2001; Hom & Griffeth,
1995).
The rationale of the current finding is that the mean age of
the sample group (i.e. 39 years) highlights that young university faculty
has a higher organizational commitment when pay satisfaction is also
high. This postulates that the young faculty does not regard teaching
as a rewarding profession in terms of salary and remuneration. The
recent rise in pay scale of university faculty in Pakistan has given a
boost to facultys higher satisfaction with remuneration. This higher
level of monetary satisfaction with the job resulted in higher
organizational commitment. Academically inclined, the young faculty
relates prestige, monetary rewards and prospects of professional
growth to university teaching. They feel that they are well-placed in
society as teachers of universities. Moreover, once committed to
university teaching, they show commitment to their chosen university.
Additionally, regression analysis was performed to explore
which of the three dimensions of organizational commitment (affective,
continuance, normative) signified pay satisfaction. Results suggest
that only affective commitment is a proven statistically significant
predictor of pay satisfaction. The possible reasons of this findings is
that affective commitment will be associated to the affective part of
pay satisfaction because affective commitment assesses an employees
attachment to the organization apart from its instrumental or economic
PAKISTAN BUSINESS REVIEW JAN 2013
774
Research
Research
776
Research
References
Adebayo, D. (2006). The moderating effect of self-efficacy on job
insecurity and organizational commitment among Nigerian public
servants. Journal of Psychology in Africa. 16(1), 35-43.
Allen, N. J., & Meyer, J. P. (1990). The measurement and antecedents
of affective, continuance, and normative commitment to the
organization. Journal of Occupational Psychology, 63, 118.
Buchanan, B. (1974). Building organizational commitment: The
socialization of managers in work organizations. Administrative
Science Quarterly, 19: 533-546.
Chen, H., & Chen, Y. (2008). The impact of work redesign and
psychological empowerment on organizational commitment in a
changing environment: An example from Taiwans state-owned
enterprises. Public Personnel Management, 37(3), 279-302.
Clark, A., & Oswald, A. (2002). A simple statistical method for
measuring how life events affect happiness. International Journal
of Epidemiology, 31(6), 1139-1148.
Cohen-Charash, Y. & Spector, P. (2001). The Role of Justice in
Organizations: A Meta-Analysis. Organizational Behavior and
Human Decision Processes, 86(2), 278321.
Gerhart, B., & Milkovich, G. T. (1990). Organizational differences in
managerial compensation and financial performance. Academy of
Management Journal, 8, 663-691.
Heneman, H. G. III, & Judge, T. A. (2000). Compensation attitudes. In
S. L. Rynes & B. Gerhart (Eds.) Compensation in Organizations:
Current Research and Practice, 61-103. San Francisco, CA: JosseyBass.
Heneman, H. G., III, & Schwab, D. P. (1985). Pay satisfaction: Its
multidimensional nature and measurement. International Journal of
Psychology, 20, 129-142.
777
Research
778
Research
779
Research
Research
FEASIBILITY OF APPLICATION
OF IFRS ON COMPANIES
OPERATING IN DEVELOPING
COUNTRIES WITH FOCUS ON
PAKISTAN
Mehboob Moosa
Department of Accounting & Finance
Institute of Business Management, (IoBM), Karachi
Abstract
This study examines the feasibility of application of
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) on companies
operating in developing countries with focus on Pakistan. It has
been a challenge to present financial information in a manner
understandable globally to the users of financial statements. In this
respect, IFRS has become the only globally accepted source of uniform
understanding to follow in the presentation of financial information.
This study strongly recommends application of IFRS which is not
easy for a swift process because of the current non-availability of
human capital trained to apply IFRS in required volume. Implementing
IFRS will need revision in presentation of accounts, revision in
different accounting policies and disclosure requirements. A very
crucial aspect of the application of IFRS is that it brings more
transparency to the presentation of financial information which
necessitates greater measure of integrity of the accountants and
auditors.
Keywords: IFRS, IAS, IASC, IASB, ICAP, ICMAP.
JEL Classification: G000
780
Research
Introduction
The present study examines the feasibility of application of
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) with the objective
of studying the challenges and risks specific to companies operating
in developing countries with focus on Pakistan in implementing IFRS.
IFRS is considered a principles based set of standards in
that it establishes broad rules and specific treatments for different
issues in accounting.
International Financial Reporting Standards comprise:
International Accounting Standards (IAS) issued before the
year 2001
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) issued
after the year 2001
Interpretations given on different issues by Standing
Interpretations Committee (SIC) issued before 2001
Interpretations originated from the International Financial
Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC) issued after the
year 2001
Framework for the Preparation and Presentation of Financial
Statements
II
Literature review
781
Research
782
Research
783
Research
Research
785
Research
Research
Suggestions
2.
3.
787
Research
4.
5.
6.
Conclusion
In the light of global development of accounting profession,
it is strongly recommended that not only Pakistan but the entire
developing countries must implement the requirements of IFRS for
financial reporting. Although this implementation will not be a swift
and painless process, it will bring in conformity with the global
standards of reportig financial information to the users of financial
statements. For example, application of IFRS will require change in
accounting formats, change in different accounting policies as well
as change in disclosure requirement. Therefore, those responsible
for financial reporting - e.g. directors of companies, Securities and
Exchange Commission of Pakistan, members, specially practicing
members of ICAP and ICMAP must contribute towards global
harmonization of financial reporting and convergence of local laws
with IFRS. They must also ensure that the subsequent amendments
in IFRS are also incorporated in the application of IFRS for financial
reporting of future periods.
788
Research
References
Adams, C.A., Weetman, P. & Gray, S.J., (1993). Reconciling national
with international accounting standards: lessons from a study of
Finnish corporate reports, European Accounting Review, Vol. 2,
No. 3, pp. 47 1-494.
Adams, G., (1994). What is compliance?, Journal of Financial
Regulation and Compliance, Vol. 2, No. 4, pp. 278-85.
Ali, A., Hwang, L., (2000). Country-specific factors related to financial
reporting and the value relevance of accounting data, Journal of
Accounting Research, Vol. 38, No.1, pp. 122.
Ali, J.M., Ahmed, K., & Henry, D., (2004). Disclosure compliance with
national accounting standards by listed companies in South Asia,
Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 34, No 3, pp.183 -199.
Al-Shiab, M., (2008). The effectiveness of International Financial
Reporting Standards adoption on cost of equity capital: A vector error
correction model, International Journal of Business, Vol. 13, No. 3,
pp. 271-298.
Ball, R., (2006). International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS):
pros and cons for investors, Accounting and Business Research,
International Accounting Forum, pp. 5-27.
Bertoni, M., De Rosa, B., (2006). Measuring balance sheet
conservatism: empirical evidence from Italian first time adopters of
IFRS, Proceedings of the international conference in
International Accounting and Business, Padua, Italy, July 20-22,
Vol. 1, pp. 33-54.
789
Research
Callao, S., Jarne, J., & Lainez, J., (2007). Adoption of IFRS in Spain:
Effect on the comparability and relevance of financial reporting,
Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, Vol.
16, No.2, pp. 148178.
Damant, D., (2006). Discussion of International Financial Reporting
Standards (IFRS): pros and cons for investors, Accounting and
Business Research, Vol. 36, pp. 29-30.
Daske, H., Gebhardt, G., (2006). International Financial Reporting
Standards and experts perceptions of disclosure quality, Abacus,
Vol. 42, No. 3-4, pp. 461-498.
Daske, H., Hail, L., Leuz, C., & Verdi, R., (2008). Mandatory IFRS
reporting around the world: early evidence on the economic
consequences, Journal of Accounting Research, Vol. 46, No.5, pp.
1085-1142.
Giner, B., Rees, W., (2005). Introduction to special section on IFRS
adoption, European Accounting Review, Vol. 14, No. 1, pp. 95-99.
Goodwin, J., Ahmed, K., (2006). The impact of international financial
reporting standards: does size matter, Managerial Auditing
Journal, Vol. 21 No. 5, pp. 460-475.
http://www.icap.org.pk BCR awards 2010
Pakistan Accountant: July-Sept2009
Lopes, P.T., Viana, R.C., (2008). The transition to IFRS: disclosures
by Portuguese listed companies,
Working Paper no 285,
University of Porto, (Previous version presented at the European
Accounting Associations conference,Lisbon, Portugal, May 2007:
1-21.)
790
Research
Research
ANNEXURE A
Investor Perspective
Adopter Perspective
Increase in transparency.
The application of IFRS/IAS
promotes transparency in financial
rep orting.
Accounting
policies
applied, and financial statements
prepared and presented according to
IFRS/IAS is advantageo us over
accounting policies applied, and
financial statements prepared and
presented according to national
accounting regulation and practices.
792
Research
ANNEXURE B
LIST OF BCR 2010 WINNERS
RANK
SECTOR / COMPANY
Miscellaneous
1
2
3
4
5
Textile
1 Gul Ahmed Textile Mills Limited
2 Kohinoor Textile Mills Limited
Bank
1
2
3
4
5
NBFIs
1
2
3
4
5
793
Research
Annexure C
COMPARISION BETWEEN 4TH SCHEDULE OF COMPANIES
ORDINANCE & IFRS/IAS
Fourth
Schedule
Companies Ordina nce
of
IFRSs/ IASs
Additional Disclosures
ICA P Comments
RESERVES:
(A) "revenue reserve" means
reserve that is normally
regarded as available for
distribution through the profit
and loss account, including
general r eserves and other
specific reserves created out of
profit and un-appropriated
profit i.e., credit balance of
profit and loss account after
appr opriations for the period to
the date of balance sheet;
794
NON
LIABILITIES
CURRENT
Research
CURRENT LIABILITIES
Current
liabilities
and
provisions shall, so far as they
are
appropriate
to
the
company's
business,
be
classified under the following
sub-heads, namely:__
(i) Trade and other payables,
which shall be classified as:
(a) creditors;
(b) Mur abaha;
(c ) accrued liabilities;
(d) advance payments;
(e) payable to employee
retirement benefit funds;
(f) unpaid and
dividend; and
unclaimed
Para 86 of IAS 37
reproduced as f ollows:
is
795
Case Study
Study
Case
Ticker: EFOODS
Price: P KR 23.22 as of 20 Dec, 2011
Forecast
Summary
Net Revenue (PKR Mn)
EBITDA (PKR Mn)
2010A
2011F
2012F
2013F
2014F
20,945
30,195
38,025
46,295
69,054
1,761
2,917
4,321
5,362
6,564
Case Study
Key risks to our investment case: are (1) Differing tax treatment
for loose and UHT milk, (2) Increase in level of competition, (3) failure
Market Profile
12 M High/Low (PKR)
25.97/21.8
Avg Daily Volume (000)
208
Market Cap (US$ Mn)
Market Cap (PKR Mn)
191
17,129
748
27/4
KSE
EFOODS.KA
Bloomberg Code
So urce: Bloomberg, KSE
EFOODS.PA
89.97%
6.42%
3.61%
5.48%
14.85%
17.13
P/B (x)
2.4
PEG (x)
0.26
EV/EBITDA (x)
7.3
797
Case Study
Business Description:
Engro Foods Limited (EFoods), initially founded as a wholly owned
subsidiary of Engro Corporation in 2005, started commercial operations
in 2006. It was listed in August 2011 through an offer for sale of
shares by shareholders of Engro Corporation. The company is listed
on Karachi, Lahore and Islamabad stock exchanges. It is well known
in Pakistan for its various brands including Olpers, Tarang, Omore
and Olfrute.
EFoods operates on its strengths of skilled management, strong brand
equity, diversified product portfolio, state-of-art production facilities,
specialized supply chain management and an international presence.
It is currently the market leader in the packaged milk industry with a
share of 44%, beating giants like Nestle and Haleeb which respectively
accounted for 35% and 13% of the market as of November 2011.
EFoods also emerged as the 2nd biggest player in the ice cream industry
in just three years of operations, with its brand Omore gaining 23%
market share as of November 2011. The company posted CAGR of
93% in topline revenue during CY06-10; its peer Nestle registered a
CAGR of mere 24% during the same period.
798
Case Study
799
Case Study
Ice-cream
Ice-cream segment ranks second in terms of contribution towards
sales, 10% in 2011. Ice cream is marketed under the brand name Omore
which was launched in March 2009. The company has managed to
become the 2nd largest player in the industry attaining market share of
23% to date.
Global Business Unit (GBU)
GBU was formed in 2009 in line with the companys vision to expand
into global markets. As the first venture, ECorp acquired Al-Safa, the
oldest Halal meat brand in North America, at a total cost of US$6.3
million. The business is currently owned by ECorp for regulatory
reasons, but under management of EFoods, and as soon as Efoods
obtains approval from State Bank of Pakistan, it will purchase AlSafa at cost from the parent company. This step towards international
diversification has made EFoods the first Pakistani company to target
Halal meat market to cater to Muslim minorities in the West.
T able 1: B ran d C at eg ory
U H T W h ole M ilk
O lp ers
H i- C al L o w F at
O lw ell
(H C L F )
F lavo re d M ilk
O w sum
C re a m
O lp ers Cr ea m
O lf ru te
Juic es
G he e
T arr ka
G lo rious
Sk im m e d M ilk p o wde r
Liq uid T ea W hit en er
T ar ang
Te a W h ite nin g Po w de r
T ar ang P ow de r
Ice C r ea m
O mor e
So urce : Com p an y P ro spe ctu s
20 09
2010
368
401
8,760
10.29
19.03
800
Case Study
801
Case Study
different flavors of milk and ice cream. The demographic profile also
provides business opportunity to FMCGs to penetrate further into
infant and nutritional market segment.
More educated, sophisticated consumers
As people are becoming more aware, they value safety, hygiene and
convenience resulting in increasing dissatisfaction with unpackaged
milk. Consumers now appreciate the fact that packaged milk does not
need to be boiled before use, which is the case for loose milk. In
addition, packaged milk can be stored for up to three months before
opening.
Rural consumption of packaged food to accelerate
Demand for packaged food is on the rise, even in rural areas where
mothers want to ensure that their children receive a balanced diet.
According to PES 2011, 49% of total average monthly per capita
expenditure is spent on food. Of this total expenditure, rural
population spending constitutes around 55% while that of urban is
about 41%. Higher expenditure on food by rural population augurs
well for FMCGs as majority of the population belongs to his group.
With Pakistan average monthly income increasing to PKR 21,785 from
PKR 14,456 during CY08-11and rural income increasing to PKR 18,712
as compared to PKR 12,625 during the same period registering CAGR
of 13.8%, exhibiting a rise in their purchasing power. This growth in
rural income further enhances FMCG opportunity to expand into these
areas.
Non-Cyclical Industry
The food industry is relatively insensitive to economic conditions
and the consumers keep on spending on premium products despite
slowing economy. This can be witnessed from the fact that average
monthly income grew at a CAGR of 14.65% where as per capita
expenditure on food, milk & dairy products and package milk grew at
a CAGR of 20.08%, 18.22% and 27.07%.
Liquid Dairy Products (LDP) Consumption
According to Tetra Pak dairy Index, LDP consumption increased at
CAGR of 2.8% in Pakistan through CY09-12 which is higher than
many other countries as can be seen in Figure 3. The packaged LDP
consumption grew at a CAGR of 8.4% during CY06-09 and is expected
802
Case Study
803
Case Study
Industry Structure
Currently, EFoods has presence in the following segments within
the food industry:
Ambient UHT
Ice cream
Powder
Case Study
parlors, shops and carts. Unilevers Walls controls 75% of the market
followed by EFoods at 23% while the rest 2% belongs to the unbranded
segment and small brands (Hico, Igloo etc). The target market of ice
cream industry is a wide consumer segment encompassing kids, teens,
and families.
Powder
This industry, with a total worth of PKR 26 billion, is divided into three
main segments including Growing up and all purpose (27%), Infant
Nutrition (55%) and Tea Whitening (18%). EFoods is currently present
in only tea whitening segment with a market share of 1%, with Nestle
controlling 98% of the total market.
Juices, Nectars and Value Added Still Drinks
This market is divided into Juice and Nectar (JN), Still Drinks (SD) and
Value added Still Drinks (VASD). These products vary in fruit content
with that of juices at 100%, nectars at 25-99% and SD at 0-24%. VASD
is SD with value addition such as innovative packaging or addition of
pulp. The total JNSD market stands at 507 million liters out of which
EFoods focuses on JN and VASD at a market size of PKR 11.4 billion
with total volume of 114 million liters. Nestle is the market leader with
66% share, Shezan at 19% and Engro foods at 3% in 2011 while
remaining 12% belongs to the unbranded fresh juice market.
(Please see Appendix for Snapshot of Key Dairy Producers)
Investment Summary
EFoods is the fastest growing FMCG in Pakistan in the last 5 years
and one of the leading players in the food industry. It has successfully
fended off competition from market giant Nestle and Unilever to become
market leader in Ambient UHT industry and 2nd biggest player in the
ice cream industry. EFoods with its skilled management, powerful
business model, diversified product portfolio and specialized supply
chain should maintain its competitive position. The company has the
capacity to face current and future industry competition and it will
remain a premier growth company in the food industry, in our view.
Increasing urbanization, changing life styles and a large untapped
branded food segment bode well for industry demand. We rate EFoods
a Buy and set DCF based target price of PKR 30.05 for 31st December
2012. Our Buy rating is premised on;
805
Case Study
806
Case Study
807
Case Study
808
Case Study
809
Case Study
Valuation
EFoods attractive investment story comes at an undemanding
valuation, suggesting market is yet to fully appreciate companys
growth potential. We have set target price of PKR 30.05/share for 31
December 2012 based on DCF method. Our target price offers an
upside potential of 29.41% over its 20 December 2011 price of PKR
23.22.
Methodology
Given EFoods dynamics (growing company with limited price and
financial history); we believe DCF is the most suitable method to
value the company. For FCFF valuation, we have discounted the
projected free cash flows using the weighted average cost of capital
of 13.47%. The cost of debt represents average interest costs on all
long-term and short-term loans taken by the company based on current
rates.
We have used required rate of equity return of 20.40%, derived
through Capital Asset Pricing Model. The risk free rate in the model is
the prevailing discount rate in the country i.e., 12%. Recently, the
State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) slashed the discount rate by 150bps in
the monetary policy announced on 08 October 2011. In the last
monetary policy announcement on 30 November 2011, the rate
remained unchanged. Going forward, we believe that SBP will keep
the discount rate at current levels.
EFoods has recently turned public (Offer for sale on July 5-7, 2011)
and does not have much of a trading history so beta calculation
would not be reflected in our view. Hence, we assumed a beta 1.2x as
the company is moderately leveraged that exposes it to interest rate
risk, and is still in its infancy stage, promising high growth.
Moreover, we have taken a conservative approach and have assumed
that Employee Stock Ownership Scheme (ESOS) will be exercised
fully by December 2011. The impact of this dilution is incorporated in
our Target Price.
Risk to Target Price
A50bps increase in the Cost of Capital will still give an upside of 15%.
(Please see Appendix for a Detailed Sensitivity Analysis)
810
Case Study
Relative Valuation
Local Peers
Lack of investable stocks in the local market limits the comparison
with domestic peers. Nestle and Unilever are two big names, however,
liquidity in both the stocks is low. Following should serve only as a
reference point for EFoods. It is currently trading at 51% and 25%
discount to Nestle and Unilever EV/EBITDA multiples respectively.
On a similar note, EFoods is also trading 77% and 69% cheaper to the
P/S multiple of Nestle and Unilever respectively.
Regional Peers
EV/EBITDA and PEG multiples of EFoods is lower than most of the
regional companies in comparison, trading at 7% and 45% discount to
12 months forward respective average regional multiples. All of these
companies are engaged in dairy business and are big market players in
their local markets.
(Please see Appendix for Detailed Table of Regional Analysis)
Table 4: Assumptions
CAPM Calculation
Risk Free Rate (S BP DR)
Risk Premium
Beta
Required Rate of Return
12.00%
7.00%
1.2
20.40%
WACC Calculation
Cost of Debt
Cost of Equity
Weight of Debt
Weight of Equity
Tax rate
WACC
13.26%
20.40%
0.59
0.41
35%
13.47%
811
Case Study
PKR -2,118
Enterprise Value
PKR 30,678
PV Debt
PKR 7,550
Equity Value
PKR 23,128
769
PKR 30.05
Source: Io BM Research
*See Appendix for Detailed Table
P/S
NESTLE
19.26
2.56
ULEVER
12.64
1.88
EFOODS
9.5
0.59
EV/EBITDA
Chin a Mengniu
0.59
10
Almarai
Juhayna Food
Industries
Modern Dairy
0.48
10.7
0.2
4.4
0.17
12.2
Saudi Dairy
1.21
7.2
0.15
2.6
0.47
7.83
EFoods
0.26
7.32
Investment Risks
Likely imposition of GST on processed milk
Food segment is not affected by government regulations but it is
likely that the Government of Pakistan may impose General Sales Tax
on processed milk in order to generate taxes at time when the
government is faced with tight fiscal position. This can potentially
create divergence on tax treatment for fresh and processed milk prices
812
Case Study
and may threaten the gross margins in case GST is not fully passed on
to end consumers. We believe EFoods and other players enjoy pricing
power and should be able to pass through any new tax. We have
calculated the impact of 1% change in gross margin and estimate
bottom-line impact of average PKR 0.30/share from every 1% move in
gross margin on our future estimates.
Intensifying competition
Current and future competition in the foods industry among key major
players may negatively affect EFoods margins as each will be competing
to attain highest market share, which will lead to higher product price
pressures leading to lower margins. For now, we see low risk of increase
in competition as existing players are focused on increasing overall
industry sales due to low penetration. Secondly, heavy investment
requirement also creates an effective barrier for the new entrant.
Failure of acceptance of new products
EFoods intends to launch new products in various food segments,
making it vulnerable to risk of failure of new offerings. So far, the
company has launched 10 brands which have enabled EFoods to gain
a strong position in the market. We see low risk of the same happening.
Raw material cost hike
Rising energy and input costs can increase cost of production leading
to lower gross profit margins. EFoods is investing heavily in dairy
supply chain in the form of Milk Collection Center. Furthermore, the
company operates a dairy farm to partially meet its fresh milk demand.
We believe EFoods will remain exposed to the risk as the company is
unlikely to increase own milk production.
Interest rate risk
All of the debt financing is based on floating rate loans and currently
the company is highly leveraged so any hike in interest rate will squeeze
net margins. However, the impact on bottom line of any increase in
interest rate should remain limited, in our view. We estimate downside
to our estimate of PKR 3.4 from 50bps increase in interest rate.
813
Case Study
Financial Analysis
Sales growth driven by product line and market share expansion
Ambient UHT UHT sales grew at a CAGR of 89% during CY06-10,
with the most significant contribution to total revenue. Going forward
we expect sales growth of this segment to ease down as the
competition from peer companies including, Nestle and Haleeb,
stiffens. UHT sales volume is expected to reach 490 million liters by
CY14, contributing 85% share in total revenue. Steady growth in
market share is expected to be fuelled by budget milk brand Dairy
Omung which is priced at 7.5% discount to fresh milk and will target
the unprocessed segment of milk industry i.e.93%.
Powder Milk Powder milk business, commenced in the year 2010,
has a market share of a mere 1% and contributes only 0.50% to revenue.
However, it is expected that the contribution will increase to 2.93% by
CY14. Currently, the business has presence in only six cities. Following
expansion, sales of this segment are projected to grow at a CAGR of
80% during CY11-14 reaching PKR1.6 billion while volumes are
projected to show a CAGR of 62% increasing to more than 2500 tons
during the same period.
Juices & Nectars Initiated in 2010, this business segment has been
successful in gaining a 3% market share with a presence in 23 cities.
Sales are expected to grow at 74% CAGR during CY11-14 reaching
PKR 1.78 billion in CY14 following the introduction of new brands/
flavors and geographical regions.
Ice Cream EFoods is the 2nd largest player in the ice cream market.
Sales are expected to grow at a CAGR of 23.7% during CY14 and will
reach PKR 4.8bn by the end of CY14. Ice cream revenue will be
primarily driven by a thrust on kids and teen segment since significant
percentage of population is under 15 years of age. Sales volume of
this segment is expected to grow at a CAGR of 12.50% reaching 24.8
million liters by CY14. The management plans aggressive expenditure
to improve supply chain of ice cream business which also includes
geographical expansion plan. Ice cream segment is expected to break
even by end of CY12.
814
Case Study
815
Case Study
816
Case Study
APPENDIX
DCF Valuation (PKR/Million)
Cash Flow from
Operations
Less: Other Income
on Ca sh
Capital
expenditure
Add: After Tax
Interest Expense
FCFF
Dec-12
Dec-13
Dec-14
Dec-15
Dec-16
1,693.52
2,476.87
3,316.89
4,210.38
5,153.90
(139.17)
(50.55)
(67.53)
(75.87)
(89.97)
(4,883.79)
(784.69)
(765.34)
(3,781.32)
(406.1 0)
933.64
792.50
633.06
624.70
419.90
(2,395.80)
2,434.12
3,117.08
977.89
5,077.73
Discounted FCFF
(2,118)
1,896
2,140
592
2,707
Enterprise Value
30 ,677.83
PV Debt
Equity Value
No of Shares
Outstanding (Mn.)
Target Price Per
Share
Source: IoBM
Research
7,550.00
23 ,127.83
769.00
30.05
817
Case Study
818
Case Study
Sponsors
Sponsor key
business
Flagship
Brand
Plant
Location
Year of
Launch
Current
Market Share
Milk
Procurement
Method
(Main)
Bottom-line
Other
segments
Expansions in
pipeline
Expected Size
(o n
completion)
ltrs/day
Key Dairy
Brands
Nestle
Pakistan
Nestle SA/
Packages
group
Processed
Foods;
Consumer
packaging
Haleeb
Foods
Shakarganj
Foods
Chaudhry
Illyas
Cresent
group
Nil
Sugar &
Allied
MilkPak
Haleeb
Good Milk
Olpers
Kabirwala &
Sheikupura
(Punjab)
Rahimyar
Khan &
Bhai Peru
(Punjab)
Faisalabad
(Punjab)
Sukkur
(Sindh) &
Sahiwal
(Punjab)
1981
1986
March-06
March-06
36-35%
30-35%
5%
44-45%
Self
Co llection
3rd Party
Contractors
Self
Collection
Self
Collection
Positive
Beverages,
Infant food,
Confectionary
Positive
Positive
Juices
Juices
Positive
Juices,
Powder, Icecream
3x
Expansion
in
powdered
milk
3x
3x
3,000,000
300,000
850,000
Good Milk
Olpers Milk
Good Milk
Cream
Olwell Milk
Ghee
Olpers
Cream
MilkPak
Nesvita
Nido
Milk Pak
Cream
Nestle Yogurt
Everyday tea
whitener
Nestle Butter
Nestle Raita
Haleeb
Milk
Haleeb
Butter
Haleeb
Cream
Candia
Milk
Dairy
Queen
Milk
Labban
Lassi
Haleeb
Ghee
Chedder
Cheese
Engro
Foods
Engro/
Dawood
group
Fertilizers,
Energ y
Tarang
Nestle Fruit
Skimz
Yogurt
Source: Company Publications, IoBM Research
819
Case Study
Management Profile
Name
Designation
Experience
Chairman
25 years
CEO
CFO
Mr. Faud
Chund rigar
Qualification
20 years
Affiliated Companies
E ngro corp., Dawood Corporation,
Dawood Hercules, Engro fertilizers
Nestle, Pepsi and Coca Cola
20 years
CA
Unilever, Danone
MBA
MSC
E ngro Corp
MBA, MS
engineering
Vice president
19 years
Marketing
Vice President
Mr. Babur Sultan
25 years
sales
Vice President
Mr Ahmed Sheikh
20 years
Supply chain
Source: Comp anys Website and Publications
MBA
MBA
SWOT Analysis
820
Case Study
Strengths:
Strong Sponsor Profile
Engro Foods operates under the parent company Engro Corporation.
Hence, when Engro launched Efoods, people instantaneously
associated it with well-established and successful brand Engro
operating in the fertilizer, IT and infrastructure sector. Strong brand
equity allows Engro Corporation to easily attract investments, as seen
in the case of Engro Rupiya Certificate. The offering received
overwhelming response from public, resulting in exercise of green
shoe option. A consistent funding stream and strong distribution
network in the agriculture sector are two key strengths of the parent
company that Efoods can capitalize upon.
Management
The company is being led by Mr. M.Afnan Ahsan who has 20 years
experience with multinationals including Pepsi, Coca Cola and Nestle.
The senior management brings vast experience in blue chip FMCG
companies in marketing, human resource and supply chain. The board
of directors consists of 10 directors out of which 4 are independent
with members comprising of Ex CEOs of Gillette, Unilever China and
Kraft.
Market Awareness due to Intensive Consumer Research
Engro conducted thorough consumer & product research before and
after entering the FMCG sector through well reputed global research
partners like AC Nielsen, Mindshare, JWT Asiatic and MARS
marketing and advertising agencies. Market research paved the way
for Efoods success in the business, making it a formidable player in
the FMCG sector previously dominated by with decades of operating
history. In its first year, EFoods crossed 1.4 billion in sales figure
reflecting customers satisfaction with its products.
Well established Linkages with Farmers and Dairy Dealers
EFoods has been doing business with the farmers in the fertilizer sector
with a good reputation in the market. Strong long term relationship
with the farmers has facilitated consistent supply of milk to the
company.
821
Case Study
Dairy Farm
Dairy farm was established in 2008 and has more than 2500 animals.
This move is to help EFoods vision of future milk exports and
production of high quality infant and growing up milk powder.
Weaknesses:
Packaging
Efoods depends on Tetra pack for packing in case of milk and cream.
Since Tetra Pack has a monopoly in the market, the company is
vulnerable to high packaging costs resulting in a decline in margins.
Opportunities:
Enhanced Awareness about Consumption of Processed Milk
With the passage of time people have realized that loose milk termed
as khulla doodh in Urdu may not be as nutritious as it may sound.
Some decades ago processed milk was not considered good for health
due to the misconception that all of the nutrition is sucked out of the
milk by passing it through machines operated by electricity. This
mindset is changing now since consumers are more educated and
open to new ideas such as a separate milk brand especially for tea.
Pakistan, the third largest producer of milk
Pakistan ranks among the largest producers of milk in the world, with
a total production of 33.25 billion liters of milk per annum. Processed
milk is only 7% of total production which if enhanced can enable the
country to expand export volume of dairy products.
Threats:
Competition
Efoods has been successful in combating intense competition from
experienced players of the industry such as Nestle and Haleeb. Old
brands have been in the industry for quite some time with an
established clientele. EFoods will need to consistently come up with
innovative ways for dealing with competition from existing as well as
new players. With Nestle planning to double their milk output within
three years, EFoods is in for a market share war, the companys
introduction of low budget milk will help their cause.
822
Case Study
Pricing
Price differentials pose a threat for the company. It is of vital importance
that Engro fulfills their customers expectations in terms of offering
quality products at competitive pricing. Since the company targets
middle class and the lower middle class, pricing will be a significant
factor to capture market share as these two income segments are
extremely price sensitive. In order to effectively capture these price
sensitive segments, the company has launched its low budget milk
which is priced even lower than fresh milk.
Outbreak of diseases in dairy animals
Almost a decade or two ago, the dairy dealers and farmers would not
have to worry about any outbreak of lethal and dangerous diseases in
the animal, but as the world turns into a huge global village, the
diseases have also found roads to travel and reach far and wide.
Various diseases in livestock such as the foot and mouth disease that
affect the productivity of farm animal are common these days. EFoods
having a commercial farm with more than 2500 animals is subject to
risk of diseases which can hamper farm productivity. In order to
effectively deal with this issue Engro foods has vaccination programs
to stop outbreak of livestock diseases.
Critical Success Factors for Dairy Business
1.
823
Case Study
a)
b)
c)
824
Case Study
d)
2.
825
Case Study
826
Case Study
2009A
20,945
2010A
20,945
2011F 2012F
30,195 38,025
2013F
46,295
2014F
56,338
2015F
69,054
19,058
19,058
27,035 33,629
219
90
1,579
219
90
1,579
16,552
40,274
48,056
57,557
508
653
3,235
918
1,116
3,987
1,649
1,780
4,853
2,405
2,726
6,365
16,552
23,612 29,658
36,410
44,692
55,385
15,061
15,061
21,127 26,161
31,613
38,100
46,193
173
71
1,248
4,393
173
71
1,248
4,393
216
280
1,988
6,584
395
549
2,554
8,366
706
934
3,157
9,884
1,259
1,487
3,846
11,646
1,831
2,283
5,077
13,669
3,997
3,997
5,908
7,468
8,661
9,956
11,364
46
19
331
46
19
331
61
54
560
113
104
681
212
182
829
391
294
1,007
574
443
1,288
277
335
2,548
548
950
1,305
2,419
2,913
3,951
4,378
4,983
5,512
6,112
55
129
304
347
473
549
618
681
748
829
80
176
55
139
51
68
76
90
(340)
(31)
974
1,803
1,061
2,224
3,420
4,288
5,462
6,818
153
285
499
700
700
694
901
1,074
1,103
1,252
(187)
254
1,472
2,503
1,761
2,917
4,321
5,362
6,564
8,071
32
20
53
131
131
282
381
456
553
665
23
105
354
515
660
1,001
1,436
1,219
974
961
(395)
(157)
567
1,156
270
940
1,603
2,613
3,935
5,192
230
334
303
223
95
329
561
915
1,377
1,817
(165)
177
869
1,379
176
611
1,042
1,699
2,557
3,375
(2.82)
(1.29)
(0.80)
0.81
1.36
2.21
3.33
4.39
0.31
0.31
827
Case Study
828
20 07A
2008A
2009A
2010A
2011F
20 12F
2013F
2014F
2015F
2,744
4,567
5,809
7,148
11,633
15,6 16
15,327
14,989
17,518
0
10
4
0
307
19
153
439
28
980
428
142
0
471
157
0
518
172
0
570
190
0
627
209
0
69 0
22 9
23
28
33
40
48
58
0
2,763
0
4,901
0
6,436
0
8,722
0
12,288
0
16,3 40
0
16,126
0
15,873
0
18,495
38
79
188
290
442
664
837
1,018
1,239
1,519
152
2
418
8
1,239
9
1,164
25
2,089
52
2,320
55
2,914
69
3,578
85
4,392
103
5,442
12 6
41
41
122
339
244
269
295
325
358
39 3
54
0
865
0
711
56
572
31
721
9
757
10
795
10
834
11
876
11
92 0
12
136
423
1,987
155
1,566
4,329
99
2,425
7,326
148
2,569
9,005
180
3,738
12,460
169
4,244
16,532
225
5,146
21,4 86
253
6,104
22,230
300
7,279
23,152
43 3
8,846
27,341
1,000
2,200
4,300
5,423
7,000
7,690
7,690
7,690
7,690
7,690
603
200
50
0
0
0
0
(444) (1,064)
1,158
1,336
0
0
(1,6 18 )
2,732
0
0
(2,052)
3,371
0
0
(1,876)
5,124
147
0
(1,265)
6,572
0
0
(223)
7,467
0
0
1,476
9,166
0
0
4,033
11,723
0
0
7,408
15,098
2,030
350
1,393
2,742
3,325
4,625
6,085
7,816
6,508
4,304
17
12
15
0
2
369
452
2
1,859
599
3
3,358
301
3
3,637
181
3
4,814
181
4
6,272
181
4
8,002
181
5
6,693
181
5
4,490
18 1
6
2,216
58
117
200
465
1,199
1,621
2,204
2,275
294
542
790
1,583
2,041
2,219
2,815
3,450
4,235
5,252
5
2
154
460
61
15
511
1,135
176
23
180
1,236
183
2
108
1,997
275
2
0
2,522
0
0
1,000
3,687
0
0
2,000
6,017
0
0
1,300
6,371
0
0
500
6,939
0
0
2,500
10,027
1,158
1,336
2,732
3,371
12,460
16,532
21,4 86
22,230
23,152
27,341
Case Study
2 010 A
2 011 F
2012F
2 013 F
2014F
2015F
(620)
(5 54 )
(433)
176
611
1,042
1,699
2,557
3,375
2007A
153
(41)
285
(1 09 )
499
(102)
700
(152)
694
(222)
901
(172)
1,074
(182)
1,103
(221)
1,252
(280)
Stock -in-trad e
Trade debt s
(267)
(6)
(8 21 )
(1)
75
(16)
(925)
(27)
(231)
(3)
(594)
(14)
(663)
(15)
(814)
(18)
(1,051)
(23)
0
(811)
(82 )
154
(216)
139
94
(148)
(24)
(36)
(27)
(38)
(30)
(40)
(33)
(42)
(36)
(44)
0
0
(55 )
0
24
0
22
(1 )
(0)
1
(0)
0
(1)
0
(1)
0
(1)
0
248
69
248
123
792
(15)
458
93
178
(277)
597
0
635
0
785
0
1,017
0
Taxes recoverable
Derivative finan cial instruments
2008A
(1,274)
(8 12 )
747
290
688
1,694
2,477
3,317
4,210
(1,587)
(2 ,108 )
(1,741)
(2,040)
(5,178)
(4,884)
(785)
(765)
(3,781)
0
(10)
0
(2 97 )
(153)
(132)
(827)
11
980
(43)
0
(47)
0
(52)
0
(57)
0
(63)
(15 )
(9)
(115)
(14)
(16)
(17)
(19)
(21)
(1)
(3)
(15)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(10)
247
(1,352)
(2 ,422 )
(2,034)
(2,986)
(4,260)
(4,952)
(860)
(849)
(3,874)
1,200
2,100
1,123
1,577
690
(403)
(1 50 )
(50)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
147
(0)
(147)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1,043
(5)
1,407
6
642
(10)
1,383
(5 )
1,725
(2)
2,465
(3)
(886)
(3)
(1,621)
0
(2,204)
0
Deferred taxation
Deferred liabilities
452
0
147
0
(297)
0
(120)
1
(0)
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
357
-
(3 32 )
-
(72)
-
(108)
-
1,000
-
1,000
-
(700)
-
(800)
-
2,000
-
Deferred taxation
Cash Flow From Investi ng
Activiti es
Share Capital
Advan ce against issue of share
capital
Share Premium
Hedging reserve
Long term finances
Obligation s under finance lease
2,645
3,178
1,336
2,728
3,560
3,315
(1,589)
(2,421)
(203)
136
155
99
148
180
169
225
253
300
19
155
(56 )
99
49
148
32
180
(12)
169
57
225
28
253
47
300
133
433
829
Approaches In Leadership
Discussion
Discussion
APPROACHES IN LEADERSHIP:
TRAIT, SITUATIONAL AND
PATH-GOAL THEORY:
A CRITICAL ANALYSIS
Adnan Khan
Nova Southeastern University Fort Lauderdale,
Florida, USA
Introduction
Since the advent of the industrial revolution, employees,
managers, psychologists and researchers have continuously asked
themselves and others one fundamental question, What makes a
good leader. Interestingly, although a plethora of research and data
now lies at our fingertips, it seems that the answer to the question is
much more varied, diverse and complex than previously imagined.
Northouse (2010) summarized, some researchers conceptualize
leadership as a trait or a behavior, whereas others view leadership
from a participative or relational standpoint. Moreover, a review of
scholarly research on leadership clearly indicates there to be a wide
diversification of thought in explaining leadership theory. (Gardner,
1990; Antonakis, Cianciolo, & Sternberg, 2004; & Mumford, 2006).
Also, a lot of new research has paved the way for fresh perspectives
in understanding the study of leadership since when it was first
investigated in the earlier half of the twentieth century. Thus, in light
of new advances, a clear need for re-examining three early approaches
in leadership, namely trait, situational and path-goal theories has
arisen. Taking a narrative approach, the author will examine the three
leadership approaches discussing their merits and drawbacks after
which findings will be summarized and conclusions drawn keeping in
view some of the latest research emerging from studies in leadership
science.
830
Approaches In Leadership
Discussion
Trait Approach
Initially studied and developed in view of certain
characteristics and qualities present in certain political and military
leaders, such as Mohandas Ghandi, Abraham Lincoln, and Napoleon
Bonaparte in the early twentieth century as a way of determining
what made them great. It was assumed that they reached their high
status or greatness only because of their being born with certain
traits. The traits as defined by Stodgill (1974) were being adaptable to
situations, alert to social environments, ambitious and achievementorientated, assertive, cooperative, decisive, dependable, dominant
(desire to influence others) ,energetic (high activity level), persistent,
self-confident, tolerant of stress and willing to assume responsibility.
Kirkpatrick and Locke (1991) stated that leaders differ from others on
mainly six traits, drive, motivation, integrity, confidence, cognitive
ability, and task knowledge. Zaccaro, Kemp and Bader (2004), identified
the following traits as being central to good leadership: extroversion,
emotional stability, openness, agreeableness, motivation, social
intelligence, self monitoring, and problem solving. Some of the traits
central to the lists of almost all the researchers studying trait leadership
over the years are intelligence, drive, integrity, and sociability. (Zaccaro
et al., 2004).
The Trait approach involves identifying and selecting leaders
based on the possession of certain prerequisite traits. This approach
is nowadays almost never utilized in isolation, although the
identification of certain traits certainly plays a part in assessing and
exemplifying a potential candidate for higher office, it is by no means
the sole criteria utilized. This is because the Trait approach suffers
from certain inherent weaknesses, the first being its rather
discomforting premise that good leadership can only arise from certain
traits which are themselves inherent and genetic, a statement which
leaves little room for motivation, advancement or growth in an
individual who feels that they do not match up to the required trait
831
Discussion
Approaches In Leadership
leadership criteria. Secondly, the theory fails to take into account any
situational, motivational, emotional, or contingency factors in its
evaluation of leadership. As we now know, these are all critical aspects
of leadership which cannot be sidelined both from a theoretical and
practical standpoint.
The theory remains alive however, and has even made
somewhat of resurgence in recent years, primarily (a) because of the
vast wealth of data and research that support its roots and (b) because
of recent research in genetics that suggest that we do in fact acquire
a large portion of traits from our ancestors. In an article in the Harvard
Business Review, Sorcher and Brant (2002) concluded, experience
has led us to believe that much of leadership is hardwired in people
before they reach their early or mid-twenties. Advances in recent
research in the field suggest two relatively new contributions to the
science, if included, would transform the trait approach into a more
powerful theory capable of explaining good leadership from the genetic
perspective in the twenty first century. First, recent research of
charismatic leadership suggests that certain leaders with charisma
consistently possess traits of self monitoring, confidence and
impression management to attain a vividly enhanced sense of being
in the public arena. (Jung & Sosik, 2006). Secondly, and more
importantly, Emotional Intelligence has emerged as a formidable asset
for managers and leaders not only because of the vast range of self
monitoring, relationship assessment and control mechanism it
possesses but also as it is increasingly being demonstrated as being
one of the key elements behind successful leadership practices.
Emotionally Intelligent leaders are more flexible, value driven,
informal, connected and especially exude resonance. Their excitement
and enthusiasm spread spontaneously invigorating those they lead.
(Goleman, Boyatzis, & Mckee, 2004, p.248)
A strong case can be made for emotional intelligence which
encompasses the abilities of understanding ones own and others
832
Approaches In Leadership
Discussion
833
Discussion
Approaches In Leadership
Approaches In Leadership
Discussion
835
Discussion
Approaches In Leadership
836
Approaches In Leadership
Discussion
837
Discussion
Approaches In Leadership
Approaches In Leadership
Discussion
839
Discussion
Approaches In Leadership
References
Antonakis, J. Cianciolo, A.T., & Sternberg, R.J. (2004). Leadership:
Past, present, future. The nature of leadership, (pp.3-16). Thousand
Oaks, CA: Sage
Blanchard, K. Zigarmi, P. & Zigrmi, D. (1985). Leadership and the one
minute manager: increasing effectiveness through situational
leadership. New York, New York: William Morrow
Drenth, P. J. D., & Den Hartog, D. N. (1998). Culture and organizational
differences. In W. J. Lonner, & D. L.Dinnel (Eds.), Merging past,
present, and future in cross-cultural psychology: Selected papers
from the fourteenth international congress of the international
association for cross-cultural psychology (pp.489502).Bristol,
PA: Swets and Zeitlinger Publishers.
Evans, M.G. (1970). The effects of supervisory behavior on the pathgoal relationship. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance,
5, 277-298
Fernandez, C.F. & Vecchio, R.P. (1997). Situational Leadership theory
revisited: A test of an across-jobs perspective. Leadership Quarterly,
8(1), 67-84
Gardner, J.W. (1990). On Leadership. New York, NY: Free Press
Goleman, D., & Boyatzis.R, & McKee. A. (2004). Primal Leadership.
Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press
Graeff, C.L. (1997). Evolution of Situational leadership theory: A critical
view. Academy of management review, 8, 285-291
Haidt, J. (2006). The Happiness Hypothesis: Finding Modern Truth
in Ancient Wisdom. New York, New York: Perseus Books
840
Approaches In Leadership
Discussion
841
Discussion
Approaches In Leadership
842
Book Review
WHAT IS GLOBAL
LEADERSHIP?
Fareeda Ibad
Department of Communication
Institute of Business Management (IoBM), Karachi
843
Book Review
844
Book Review
845
Book Review
846
Book Review
Book Review
848
Book Review
balance are by building mutual respect and devoting time to know the
new environment. This can be done by asking questions to challenge
the status quo and presenting new perspectives. Positioning the
leaders role was another adaptation technique where the leader drives
new initiatives with imposing his own expertise.
In regard to core values and flexibility, the data gleaned from the
research supported the notion that learning the values of the new
culture would help in establishing meaningful relationships which
would allow for support from local colleagues, thereby allowing the
leader to be flexible and effective in the new environment. Inability to
be flexible would never allow a leader to be successful. Another aspect
of dealing with core values was in regard to dealing with corruption
effectively. When this happens, an atmosphere of fairness, honesty,
respect, effective feedback, openness, respect for the law, allegiance
to common objectives and meaningful allocation of resources follows.
The authors have used case studies, examples and quotations to
support their views.
Chapter seven discusses the final stage of global leadership
development where Establishing Solutions emerges as a concept
when testing the effectiveness of leaders in global locations. Influence
across boundaries and third way solutions are key behaviors that
assist in the act of creating solutions. Influence across boundaries
refers to global leaders being able to work where support systems are
unequal to their home markets, having to work without direct authority
and being able to influence others across the organizational matrix.
Additionally, they need to serve as ambassadors of their country
both inside and outside the organization. Their influence must extend
across functional boundaries and they have to create solutions in an
atmosphere where there is freedom to experiment and follow a rapid
learning curve.
Third way solutions means being able to put everything together,
drawn on all the behaviors discussed earlier, and produce real
solutions. As usual, the authors use case studies, examples, and
849
Book Review
850
Book Review
851
January2013
Volume 14 Number 4
INSTRUCTIONS TO AUTHORS
(Research Section)
1.
2.
Submission of a paper will be held to imply that it contains original unpublished work and is not
being submitted for publication elsewhere. The Editors do not accept responsibility for damages or
loss of papers submitted.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Volume 14 Number 4
January 2013
INSTRUCTIONS TO AUTHORS
(Research Section)