Professional Documents
Culture Documents
at UW - Stout
A Feasibility Study
Patrick Stariha
Zach Renk
Jon Hunter
Table of Contents
Background
Project Timeline
Project Proposals
Walmart
st
1 Congregational Church
UW Stout
10
12
15
16
References
19
Appendices
A. Poster Potential Collection Items
20
23
24
D. Key Contacts
26
E. E-Mail Trail
27
4).
Discarded electronics and printer ink cartridges can have a hazardous long-term effect on the
environment. The materials that house printer ink cartridges and the ink itself are potentially hazardous.
The plastic material takes decades to decompose. Discarded electronics, printer ink cartridges, and their
effects on the environment are important to understand. The environment is becoming contaminated with
chemicals and non-biodegradable materials (The Effect of Discarded Printer Ink Cartridges on the
2
Environment, 2010).
The ever-growing size of landfills continues to be a problem. Landfills are designed and built to store
waste and are thought to be a safe containment of our garbage. However, there are countless hazardous
wastes that are blended into the municipal waste stream lead from batteries, mercury from light bulbs,
heavy metals from TV and electronics, etc. When these hazardous waste streams find their way into
municipal waste landfills, the contaminants can find their way into our drinking water. Also, land areas
designated as landfills can pose serious damage to the soil for many generations, as that land cannot be
used and converted into livable space.
When waste is delivered to an incinerator it is usually sorted to remove recyclables from the waste
stream. Even so, when the remaining municipal waste is incinerated, pollutants are emitted to the air.
Typical emissions include CO2 (carbon dioxide), N2O (nitrous oxide), NOx (oxides of nitrogen) and NH3
(ammonia) (Johnke, 2010).
Environmental Extends the life of resources used. Terracycle creates items for consumers from the
items collected and allows consumers to return these upcycled or recycled products at the end of their
useful life. This closed loop system prevents items from being landfilled. The money generated from
Terracycle will allow Greensense to fund environmental/sustainable projects on campus.
Social - Boost economic need for shipping and jobs with Teracycle. More jobs can reduce the rate of
unemployment and increase the quality of life for people. This can also provide an opportunity to
educate the community on the importance of sustainability.
Economic - This spurs the shipping economy, creates more job opportunities on Teracycles end, and
extends the life of resources used.
Project Timeline
Tuesday,February14,2012
Thursday,February23,
2012
Tuesday,February28,2012
Thursday,March01,2012
Thursday,March01,2012
Presentoverviewofinitialplanofattacktoclass/instructor
Projectwork
Projectwork
MeetwithSarahRykalandJulianaLucchesidiscussopportunitiesoncampus
PROGRESSReporttoclass:howdoestheprocesscurrentlyworkhandindraft
overview
Tuesday,March06,2012
Projectworknextsteps:brainstormingandidentifyingpossiblesolutionsor
changestomoresustainablepractices.DeterminingaPLANofactionto
examinefeasibility/impactsofpossiblesolutions.
Thursday,March08,2012
Groupspresentoverviewofpossibleprojectproposalsandplanto
class/instructor
Implement1stcollectionbininJarvisScienceWing360
TrashBlitz dumpsterdivetocompiledataofpotentialTeracycleitemsin
wastestream
Projectwork
MeetwithRobMacDougalldiscussFCUCCopportunityforinvolvement
PROGRESSReporttoclass:Howfeasiblearetheproposedsolutions/changes?
Determiningfocus.Handindraftoverviewandbasicanalysisofproposals
Groupmeetingswithfacilitatortodiscussdraftreportandnextsteps
Updateinstructorsonrecentandfutureactions
Workondraftprojectreportanddocumentation
Meetwithadvisorstoframeupfinalproject
Discuss/proposeprojecttoEnvironmentalSustainabilityCommittee
Projectwork/PresenttoWasteReductionWorkGroup
Handindraftprojectreportandpartialdocumentation
Hostboothoncampusforearthweek
Groupmeetingswithfacilitatortodiscussdraftreportandfinalsteps
Projectwork
Projectwork
HandindesignprojectreportanddocumentationEvaluatepeersandindividual
contribution.
STEMExpopresentation
Possibledateforfinaloralprojectpresentations
Tuesday,March20,2012
Wednesday,March21,
2012
Thursday,March22,2012
Tuesday,March27,2012
Thursday,March29,2012
Tuesday,April03,2012
Thursday,April05,2012
Tuesday,April10,2012
Thursday,April12,2012
Friday,April13,2012
Tuesday,April17,2012
Thursday,April19,2012
Friday,April20,2012
Tuesday,April24,2012
Thursday,April26,2012
Tuesday,May01,2012
Thursday,May03,2012
Tuesday,May08,2012
Tuesday,May08,2012
Project Proposals
Walmart Project Proposal
Operational Details
Review and analyze data push for a regional/statewide rollout if pilot trial proves beneficial
Technical Factors
Marketing/Awareness
Resources Used
Collection bins
o
Ink,
Paper
Greensense
Terracycle Team
options that corporations are allowed to use to implement Terracycle collection at their site. This gave us
a better understanding of the requirements, costs, and logistics of Terracycle. Due to the added cost to
Walmart of implementing bins like those listed in Appendix C, Walmart is unable to participate.
We tried to make contact with a corporate level employee, but were unsuccessful in that their e-mail
system is an intranet and there are no employees at that level in Menomonie. Walmart was very reluctant
to hand out any contact information that would have helped us.
Due to rules within Walmart Corporation and the way Terracycle works, Walmart is unable to help us
collect items. If Walmart were to put bins in their store, there would be a major cost associated with this
Walmart would have to pay Terracycle to help them pay for shipping and the upcycling of collected items.
The way Terracycle receives funding is through companies that produce items they accept. For example,
Frito Lay pays Terracycle millions of dollars so their chip bags can be sent in and upcycled into new
products. Since this would be such a large scale operation, Walmart would have to sponsor this new
brigade to cover the shipping and bin manufacturing (B. Stevens, e-mail, Feb. 23, 2012).
Recommendations
Dale was not able to make decisions and could not implement this into this one store. Those decisions
need to be made from a corporate level. The implementation would start regionally to test feasibility for
national roll out. We recommend not trying to implement Terracycle collection bins at Walmart unless a
key corporate contact is identified.
st
2 options:
o
Proceeds go to church
Technical factors
Resources required
Collection Bins
o
Ink
Paper
Greensense
collected and $29.28 was raised. However, one unforeseen problem was the amount of electronic waste
that cannot be used for Terracycle (Table 1). Most of the non-Terracycle items that still worked were
donated to the Goodwill. Broken items will be recycled at Best Buy, Inc.
TABLE 1: TERRACYCLE ITEMS COLLECTED FROM THE 1ST CONGREGATIONAL CHURCH EARTH
WEEK COLLECTION.
Recommendations
Our recommendation is that Greensense continue to work with 1st Congregational Church. In the future,
the congregation should be better educated about the specific items that are accepted for Terracycle to
reduce the amount of electronic waste that cant be used for Terracycle. We also propose communicating
with other community churches about participating with the Greensense Terracycle project.
Technical Factors
Resources Used
Collection Bins
o Packaging student to build collection bins
o Enough cardboard to build bins
Shipping resources (shipping is free however resources are involved)
o Ink
o
Paper
Greensense
Terracycle Team
We contacted the General Manager, Crystal Halvorson, Thursday, April 27 by email and phone. The
Terracycle project was well received until the concern of space was discussed. Currently, due to the #5
recycling effort, there is additional space available for a Terracycle collection bin. Crystal mentioned that
there are plans to increase store size in the future, however that timeframe is unknown.
Recommendations
Due to the current space constraints, Terracycle cannot be implemented at the Menomonie Market Food
Co-op. However, Greensense should stay in contact with Crystal to help build Terracycle into the
business model when the store size in increased.
Operational Details
Create awareness among students and faculty about Terracycle and the items that can be collected
o
An advertisement on http://www.uwstout.edu/sustainability/
Krista James, professor in the biology department at UW Stout, has communicated that we can
implement a bin in Jarvis Science Wing room 360 and in the biology department office area. Professor
James has confirmed that she will allow her contact information to be placed on the bins with
instructions to call her when the bin becomes full. She will then contact the appointed Greensense
representative to empty the bin, sort items, and send to Terracycle (K. James, personal
communication, March 20, 2012). All proceeds will be sent to the nonprofit organization Greensense
to be used exclusively for environmental/sustainable projects on campus
Options:
o
Bins in Jarvis Science Wing room 360 and Science professors office area.
Technical Factors
Clear marketing/instructions
Resources Required
Links on http://www.uwstout.edu/sustainability/
Bins
Locations on Campus
displayed, Jeff recommended that we focus on a few higher valued items. The thought is that it would
reduce confusion of what can be collected and could increase participation. He also said he would allow a
bin in Stout Adventures and would call Krista James as needed for pickup (J. Keenan, personal
communication, April 13, 2012).
Patrick also presented to the Waste Reduction Work Group (WRWG) on April 17, 2012, and proposed
implementing a collection bin in the Memorial Student Center (MSC) to collect the items listed in Appendix
B. The idea was well received and Karen Lund, Interim Assistant Director of Operations and Services in
the MSC, referred Patrick to Darrin Witucki, the Director of the MSC. A meeting was set up between
Darrin, Patrick, and Sarah Rykal to discuss the opportunity for implementing a collection bin in the MSC.
Darrin proposed we start with one bin on the lower level, located in a very visible area. He found a three
slot container with side door key access in the Max R catalog and proposed that his office pay for the
container since its important to maintain the professional image of the remodeled MSC. Greensense will
be given a key to empty the bin as needed. Darrin will work on the wording and icons for the bin and will
obtain the necessary approvals. The three slots would be for 1) ink jet cartridges, 2) all other items in
Appendix B, and 3) battery recycling. Battery recycling is a possible new startup program that is unrelated
to Terracycle. The proceeds earned from Terracycle will fund the battery recycling program (D. Witucki,
personal communication, 1 May 2012). Greensense needs to follow up with Darrin Witucki at the
beginning of the fall semester 2012 to learn of any progress Darrin made over the summer.
Three cardboard Terracycle collection bins were implemented around campus: one in Stout Adventures,
one in Jarvis 360, and one in the Biology Department office complex (Jarvis Hall Science Wing 331).
These bins were designed and made by Jon Hunter in the packaging lab. Pictures and descriptions of
acceptable items were glued to the top of the lids.
Recommendations
Keep current bins in Jarvis and at Stout Adventures. See final recommendations for more details on
further implementation on campus.
11
FIGURE 1: VOLUNTEERS SORTING RECYCLABLES AND ITEMS COLLECTED FOR TERRACYCLE AT TRASH BLITZ.
2. In-Class Bin In Jarvis 360 we implemented a collection bin to collect the items listed in Appendix
A. The main contributors to the collection bin were the students from our class and the Trash
Blitz. The bin was made from C flute corrugated cardboard in the packaging lab on campus. The
bin requires almost 15 square feet of corrugated (note these bins are temporary). Below are
pictures of the collection bin in class and a layout of the design (Figures 2, 3).
12
FIGURE 2: COLLECTION BIN LOCATED IN JARVIS HALL 360 CLASSROOM WITH IMAGES AND DESCRIPTIONS OF WHAT IS
BEING COLLECTED.
13
FIGURE 3: DRAWING OF CLASSROOM COLLECTION BIN WITH DIMENSIONS. THIS WAS THE MOST CONVENIENT SIZE
FOR AREAS THAT DID NOT HAVE SPACE CONSTRAINTS. THIS DRAWING CAN BE USED TO REPLICATE THOSE BINS. THE
BOARD WAS CUT AND SCORED ON THE KONGSBERG XL44 IN THE PACKAGING LAB. LAB ASSISTANTS ARE AVAILABLE
DURING LAB HOURS TO CUT OUT DESIGNS. FILE FORMATS MUST BE PROVIDED IN .ACM FORM.
14
Product
Quantity
Price
Total
Cheese
23
$0.02
$0.46
Tortilla
$0.02
$0.04
Drink Pouch
$0.02
$0.16
$2.50
$0.00
$0.02
$1.80
$0.02
$0.00
$0.02
$0.02
99
$0.02
$1.98
$2.50
$10.00
23
$0.25
$5.75
Graphing Calc
$2.00
$0.00
Cell Phones
$0.01
$0.00
$0.02
$0.08
MP3 Player
Candy Wrappers
90
Bear Naked
Scotch Tape
Chips
Digital Cameras
Ink Cartridge
Beauty
Total
$20.29
TABLE 2: THIS TABLE SHOWS THE RESULTS OF A 3 WEEK PILOT TRIAL. THIS DATA INCLUDES ITEMS FROM A
CLASSROOM COLLECTION BIN AND SEPARATION OF TRASH FROM THE TRASH BLITZ. THE LIST OF THESE ITEMS CAN
BE FOUND IN APPENDIX A.
From collecting items in the classroom for 3 weeks and separating trash during Trash Blitz, about 4.5
pounds of acceptable items were collected to send to Terracycle. The only items gathered from the Trash
Blitz were candy wrappers, chip bags, beauty products, cheese packaging, and drink pouches. After
calculating the profit from each item collected, it is estimated that a total of $20.29 will be sent to
Greensense from Terracycle. This data helped us understand that the majority of the funding came from
the higher ticket items (Appendix B). These items, digital cameras, cell phones, ink cartridges, graphing
calculators, and mp3 players, were collected in the classroom (360 Jarvis). This demonstrated that
people will keep the environment in mind by saving these items for Terracycle.
15
5dumpstersanalyzedon
thesouthcampus
residencehalls
Totalper
week
Total
estimatefor
onesemester
Total
estimatefor
oneyear
Items
251
x4
Weight(lbs)
4.5
Estimateofall20
residentialdumpsters
Items
1004
Weight(lbs)
18
x15weekspersemester
3,765
68
15,060
270
x2semestersperyear
7530
135
30120
540
16
To eliminate ink contamination, one bin should be used for inkjet cartridges and the other for electronic
items. The appropriate marketing materials (visual aids and instructions) will be needed on the
containers to inform participants of the rules (Figure 4).
Ink Jet
Cartridges
players, and
cameras, mp3
graphing calculators
FIGURE 4: EXAMPLE OF PERMANENT COLLECTION BINS FOR INK CARTRIDGES, DIGITAL CAMERAS, GRAPHING
CALCULATORS, AND CELL PHONES.
The corrugated Terracycle collection bins currently located in Jarvis 360, the Biology Department office
area, and Stout Adventures should remain in those locations. These areas are frequently visited by
students and faculty that are conscious of recycling and aware of the Terracycle initiative. Krista James
contact information will be applied to the bins. When notified that a bin is full, she will contact the
appropriate Greensense representative to have the bin emptied. When funds are available for permanent
bins we suggest using the same collection system as the MSC.
A marketing program should be implemented that educates the campus community about the Terracycle
program and the location of collection bins. Marketing could include, but is not restricted to Campus Life
Today e-mails, Green We Go videos, and information posted on the Sustainability Stout Website.
Greensense should set-up a separate bank account for Terracycle funds. In addition, Greensense should
document the quantity of items collected and the amount of funds generated. Each fall and spring
semester, this documentation should be presented to the Environmental Sustainability Steering
Committee and the Greensense faculty advisors.
17
st
18
References
Johnke, B. (2010). Emissions from waste incineration . 455-468. http://www.ipccnggip.iges.or.jp/public/gp/bgp/5_3_Waste_Incineration.pdf
19
Appendices
20
Any brand and size of: lipstick cases, mascara tubes, eye shadow
cases, shampoo bottles, conditioner bottles, bronzer cases,
foundation packaging, body wash containers, soap tubes, soap
dispensers, lotion dispensers, shaving foam tubes (no cans),
powder cases, lotion bottles, chap stick tubes, lotion tubes, face
soap dispensers, face soap tubes, face lotion bottles, face lotion jars, eyeliner
cases, eyeliner pencils, eye shadow tubes, concealer tubes, concealer sticks,
lip liner pencils, hand lotion tubes, hair gel tubes, hair paste jars.
No hair spray cans, nail polish bottles, and nail polish remover bottles accepted.
$0.02 each
Any brand and size candy wrappers. No candy boxes or gum
packaging.
$0.02 each
We accept any brand and any size cereal bag. We do NOT accept
cereal boxes or the plastic cereal lining found inside cereal boxes.
$0.02 each
22
23
24
25
26
Hi everyone,
Can we move the 1:30pm Thursday meeting location to 225 Administration Building? We can meet in my
offices conference room.
Thanks,
Sarah
Sarah Rykal
Environmental Sustainability Coordinator
University of Wisconsin-Stout
715.232.5254
www.uwstout.edu/sustainability
27
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
From: Stariha, Patrick
Sent: Thursday, February 23, 2012 11:03 AM
To: Rykal, Sarah
Cc: Renk, Zachary; Hunter, Jonathan
Subject: FW: Teracycle discussion
Hello Sarah and Juliana,
My name is Zach Renk Im currently in the Sustainability Capstone course. My partners and I have
selected Teracycle as our semester project. I believe that Krista or Martha informed you that we would
like to meet and go over the feasibility of implementing Teracycle on campus. If both of you are free today
around 4:40pm to meet and discuss Teracycle that would be very much appreciated. If not could you
please let us know your next available time to meet?
Thanks for your time,
Zachary Renk
B.S. Packaging
University of Wisconsin - Stout
1107 8th St E
Menomonie, WI. 54751
(608) 220-7102
Email: renkz@my.uwstout.edu
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sent: Tue 3/20/2012 4:42 PM
From: First Congo (Rob)
To: Stariha, Patrick
Patrick, Thanks for the info. We talked about your project at our church council meeting and they
assigned a couple of people to work on this with you. Is there a time when we could get together to figure
out what is possible for our involvement? What might be a time in your schedule between Tues - Fri next
week? I usually just go by "Rob" so feel free to address me that way. Rob
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
From: Patrick Stariha
To: First Congo (Rob)
Cc: Hunter, Jonathan ; Renk, Zachary
Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2012 11:09 AM
Subject: Terracycle
Hello Dr. Reverend Rob MacDougall,
28
I just wanted to follow up with our previous conversation regarding the exciting opportunity with
Terracycle. Attached is a document of all the materials that we are collecting. I hope this clears up any
questions. If you have any questions or concerns I would be happy to answer them.
Best regards,
Patrick Stariha
218.341.1257
Thank you Sue!
Hello Dr. Reverend Rob MacDougall,
I am excited to be working on Teracycle for my capstone in Sustainability. Teracycle is an opportunity to:
collect items that are not typically recyclable, save them from the landfill, and have them up-cycled or
recycled into new products. An example is Capri Sun pouches that are made into purses, wallets, or
bags. Another great aspect is that there are proceeds for each item collected. The proceeds go to a nonprofit organization or charity. I was wondering if you think the United Church of Christ Congregationalist
may be interested in participating as a collection site? Greensense would manage the logistics of the
collection: making the bin, sorting, and shipping when bin is full.
If you think there may be an interest in the congregation, would you like to meet and discuss this exciting
opportunity?
Best regards,
Patrick Stariha
218.341.1257
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
From: Foxwell, Sue
Sent: Thursday, March 01, 2012 8:23 AM
To: Stariha, Patrick; James, Krista; First Congo (Rob)
Cc: Hunter, Jonathan; Renk, Zachary
Subject: RE: Terracycle
Hi Patrick and all,
Im copying Dr. Reverend Rob MacDougall on this e-mail. As the minister of the church he would be a
good one to initiate the discussion with. I am no longer the Moderator but I do believe that this is a project
that the 1st Congregational Church would be interested in exploring with you. Rob can hook you up with
the appropriate folks.
Thanks so much for doing this---its a great idea!!
Sue
Sue Foxwell
Research Administrator
29
30
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
From: "James, Krista"
Date: Thu, 1 Mar 2012 00:22:58 +0000
To: Stariha, Patrick
Cc: Foxwell, Sue
Subject: RE: Terracycle
United Church of Christ Congregationalist Church.
Im ccing Sue Foxwell on this email. Shell be able to help you connect with the right person.
She works at Stout (Research Services), but is also on the Church board.
Sue, Patrick is working on a senior capstone project to develop a feasibility study for Terracycling in
Menomonie.
This is a link to the Terracycle program: http://www.terracycle.net/en-US/
Krista C. James
Environmental Science
Applied Science Program
Biology Department
327 Jarvis Hall Science Wing
University of Wisconsin-Stout
jamesk@uwstout.edu
https://bluedrive.uwstout.edu/users/facultystaff/jamesk/wwwroot/index.htm
715-232-1557
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
From: Stariha, Patrick
Sent: Wednesday, February 29, 2012 5:17 PM
To: James, Krista
Subject: Terracycle
Hello Krista,
What was the name of the church that was mentioned during the Greensenes officers meeting on
Monday? I would like to get in touch with them to discuss the opportunity of a collection bin there.
Hope all is well,
Patrick Stariha
31
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sarah,
Patrick Stariha, one of the students in the Sustainable Design and Development Capstone course, would
like to present to the ESSC about Terracycle. He is requesting feedback from the committee about how to
make sure the project is sustainable (after they graduate). Hes also looking for practical feedback about
implementation.
Will you please add Patricks presentation to the meeting agenda?
Im ccing Patrick and his other project team members on this email.
Thanks!
Krista C. James
Environmental Science
Applied Science Program
Biology Department
327 Jarvis Hall Science Wing
University of Wisconsin-Stout
jamesk@uwstout.edu
https://bluedrive.uwstout.edu/users/facultystaff/jamesk/wwwroot/index.htm
715-232-1557
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Sent: Tue 4/10/2012 2:21 PM
From: Renk, Zachary
To: mhendrickson@oslme.com
Cc: Hunter, Jonathan; Stariha, Patrick
Hello Pastor Hendrickson,
My name is Zach Renk, and my group members and I are currently working on a senior capstone project
to develop a feasibility study for Terracycling in Menomonie. Teracycle is an opportunity to: collect items
that are not typically recyclable, save them from the landfill, and have them up-cycled or recycled into new
products. An example is Capri Sun pouches that are made into purses, wallets, or bags. Another great
aspect is that there are proceeds for each item collected. The proceeds go to a non-profit organization or
charity. I was wondering if you think the Our Saviors Lutheran Church may be interested in participating
as a collection site. My team and I would manage the logistics of the collection: making the bin, sorting,
and shipping when bin is full.
For more information this is a link to the Terracycle program: http://www.terracycle.net/en-US/
If you think there may be an interest in the congregation, would you like to meet and discuss the
feasibility?
32
Best regards,
Patrick Stariha
34
Sources
Johnke, B. (2010). Emissions from waste incineration . 455-468. http://www.ipccnggip.iges.or.jp/public/gp/bgp/5_3_Waste_Incineration.pdf
35