A number of arguments for and against the Reproductive Health bill have been posited and the debates have been mostly emotional, with the Senate seemingly succeeding in derailing the passage of the measure. The Catholic Church has taken the lead in opposing the passage of the bill into law, claiming that certain provisions are against Church teachings. The Church has even broadly defined abortion to include the use of condoms and other common contraceptives. It has mislabeled the RH bill as promoting abortion notwithstanding specific provisions to the contrary. Those opposed to the RH bill contend that we do not need measures to limit population growth because we are not really overpopulated. In fact, a number of global economists look favorably at the Philippines because of its young and growing population. They claim that the demand for goods that these young Filipinos need will increase the growth of the Philippine economy. But isnt this similar to our current situation, where the productive working class is unable to support the unproductive sectors of our population? Since population growth is highest among the poor, this vicious chain of the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer will be preserved. Access to contraceptives is contradicted only the very poor and uneducated in the country; it has never been a problem for the rich and a large part of the middle class. Thus, making contraceptives more accessible will not redound much to the benefit of these groups in our society. The RH bill, providing for better and
easier access to contraceptives and pushing for responsible
parenthood, is pro-poor and pro-development and will at least afford the poor the opportunity to better manage the size of their families. Access to a better life is a paramount right of every individual, and it is the governments duty to make this possible. People can be an asset or a liability. If they are educated, skilled and possess the right attitude and values, they are an asset. The ideal situation is, of course, one where there are both good quantity and good quality of Filipinos. However, blocking the RH bills passage and keeping the status quo will not make this possible. The governments current resources are not enough to take care of the poor and give them opportunities to pull themselves out of the predicament of continuing poverty. Undeniably, the chances of improvement in the quality of life of the greater mass of Filipinos will be better with the RH bill being passed. It is high time we set aside our personal beliefs as to Gods mandate for us to go forth and multiply, looked squarely into the face of reality, and stopped being hypocritical. Surely, the majority of the millions who hear Catholic Masses every Sunday use contraceptives one way or another, particularly those with less than four children. If this were not so, then the average size of the Filipino family would have remained the samearound nine children Even Senator Santiago said, "We must stand for freedom of conscience, we must stand for responsible family planning, we must stand in support of the RH Bill."