Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A REPORT
ON
OPTIMIZATION OF AUXILIARY POWER CONSUMPTION IN
A TYPICAL 300MW COAL-FIRED THERMAL POWER PLANT
BY
Name of the Student ID No.
I.PRANEETH (2011B2A3672H)
AT
JSW ENERGY LTD.
A Practice School I Station of
BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY & SCIENCE, PILANI
JUNE, 2013
2 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
A REPORT
ON
OPTIMIZATION OF AUXILIARY POWER CONSUMPTION IN A TYPICAL
300MW COAL-FIRED THERMAL POWER PLANT
BY
Name of the Student ID No.
I.PRANEETH (2011B2A3672H)
Prepared in partial fulfillment of the
Practice School-I Course No.
BITS C221/BITS C231/BITS C241/BITS GC221/BITS GC231
AT
JSW ENERGY LTD.
A Practice School- I Station of
BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY & SCIENCE, PILANI
JUNE, 2013
3 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
BIRLA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY AND SCIENCE
PILANI (RAJASTHAN)
PRACTICE SCHOOL DIVISION
Station: JSW Energy Ltd.
Centre: Vijaynagar Works
Duration: May 22
nd
2013 to July 13
th
2013
Title of the Project: Optimization of Auxiliary Power Consumption in a typical 300MW
Coal based Thermal Power Plant.
ID No: Name of Student Discipline:
2011B2A3672H I.PRANEETH B.E. (Hons.) Electrical &
Electronics Engineering
Name(s) of Expert: Mr. Hanumanth Rao Designation: Shift In-charge
Name of PS Faculty: Mr. V.S.Prasad
Key Words: Auxiliary power, Optimizing techniques, Plant load Factor (PLF) etc.
Project Area (s): Electrical, Power engineering
Abstract: Energy conservation is the burning issue nowadays due to the tremendous scarcity of
electricity across the county. Energy efficiency is a technique which needs to be adopted seriously
for effective energy conservation. Indian power sector is caught between the pressure of adding
new generating capacities to match the rapid growing demand of power to achieve economic
and social development and the environmental challenges.
Therefore by implementing Energy conservation techniques in thermal power plant, we
try to recover the losses which go waste. This report describes basic understanding and
awareness about various types of auxiliaries used in a thermal power plant, their power
consumption and various measures such as installations of VFDs (Variable Frequency Drive) and
other modern techniques to optimize the auxiliary power consumption in a typical 300MW coal
fired thermal power plant using case studies.
Signature of the Student Signature of the Mentor
Date: Date:
4 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Contents
Abstract: ........................................................................................................................................................ 3
Acknowledgement ........................................................................................................................................ 5
PART-I (Orientation Report) .......................................................................................................................... 6
Know your industry (Power Sector) .............................................................................................................. 7
Know Your Organization (JSW Group) .......................................................................................................... 9
Process Mapping ......................................................................................................................................... 17
1. Coal handling plant ............................................................................................................................. 18
2. Fan System .......................................................................................................................................... 21
3. Boiler System ...................................................................................................................................... 22
4. Ash Handling System ........................................................................................................................... 26
5. Turbine-generator system .................................................................................................................. 28
6. Condenser System .............................................................................................................................. 31
7. Cooling Tower System ......................................................................................................................... 33
8. Switchyard ........................................................................................................................................... 35
PART II (Project Report) ........................................................................................................................... 37
What is Auxiliary Power Consumption? ...................................................................................................... 38
Why Focus on Auxiliaries? .......................................................................................................................... 39
Auxiliary Power Consumption in Thermal Power Plant .............................................................................. 40
Types of Auxiliaries ..................................................................................................................................... 41
Auxiliary Power Consumption Calculation .................................................................................................. 45
Energy meter readings of G, GT, ST for 4 consecutive days ....................................................................... 45
Analysis of power consumption of Major and Minor auxiliaries of SBU II Unit, JSW Energy Ltd. ........... 49
Approaches for Optimization of Auxiliary power consumption. ................................................................ 58
CASE STUDY I ............................................................................................................................................. 65
CASE STUDY II .............................................................................................................................................. 67
Suggestions and Improvements .................................................................................................................. 68
Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................... 70
INDEX .......................................................................................................................................................... 71
References .................................................................................................................................................. 72
5 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Acknowledgement
Firstly, I would like to thank Mr. Hanumanth Rao, my mentor, for guiding me
through this project and clearing various apprehensions and conceptual doubts
and providing us with experienced suggestions throughout the program.
I take this opportunity to thank all the staff members of Electrical Maintenance
Department and Operational Support Division for sparing their precious time with
us despite their busy schedule without whom our project would be incomplete.
I also thank the Practice School Division of BITS Pilani for providing me with this
opportunity to gain professional work exposure.
I am hugely indebted to our instructor Mr. V.S Prasad and our co-instructor Mr.
Khemraj for guiding me throughout the training.
I would like to extend special thanks to Mr. Kamalakar, Mr. Venkat, Mr. Bhaskar ,
Mr. Ram Kumar for providing me with the technical data required for the project.
6 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
PART-I (Orientation Report)
7 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Know your industry (Power Sector)
The power sector consists of generation, transmission and distribution utilities and is a crucial
component of Indias infrastructure. Indias rapid growth over the past decade has increased
power demand, which is still largely unmet. According to Government of India estimates, the
nations per capita power consumption was pegged at 779 kWh in FY10, far below the world
average of over 2,782 kWh1. However, the government is striving to increase the per capita
consumption to 1,000 KWh per year by the end of 20122 through large sale power projects and
rural electrification programs.
KEY DEVELOPMENTS AND THE CURRENT STATE OF THE INDIAN POWER
SECTOR
Power is considered to be a core industry as it facilitates development across various sectors of
the Indian economy, such as manufacturing, agriculture, commercial enterprises and railways.
Though India currently has the fifth largest electricity generation capacity in the world pegged
at 1, 92,792 MW3, the growth of the economy is expected to boost electricity demand in
coming years4.Exhibits a strong correlation between the GDP growth and increase in power
generation capacity over the last decade.
India saw a total capacity addition of approximately 54,000 MW during the 11th Five
Year plan3, of which approximately 47 per cent was contributed by the central government, 34
per cent from the state government, and a little over 19 per cent from the private sector5.
Some examples of top public sector companies include National Thermal Power Corporation
(NTPC), Damodar Valley Corporation (DVC) and National Hydroelectric Power Corporation
(NHPC). Some key companies in the private sector include Tata Power and Reliance Energy
Limited4.
In India, power is primarily generated from thermal and nuclear fuels, hydro energy and
renewable sources. Exhibits different inputs used for power generation and power
consumption by different sectors. To cope with the demand deficit, the Indian government has
implemented various progressive measures to maximize the countrys power generation
capacity and improve distribution. Some examples of such measures include rural electrification
programmes and ultra mega power projects5. In particular, the inflow of foreign direct
investments is expected to step up capacity addition significantly. The government has allowed
FDI of up to 100 per cent through the automatic route5 in all segments of the power sector
except for nuclear energy4.
8 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Consequently, the sector has drawn about US$ 4.6 billion investment over the past
decade, of which US$ 1.6 billion came in FY12 alone7. In particular, the petroleum and natural
gas segments saw the maximum investments from international companies (US$ 2.7 billion
since 2000) due to the governments New Exploration Licensing Policy (NELP). This jump in
overall investments was facilitated by the planned capacity addition of 76,000 MW and 93,000
MW during the 12th and 13th Five Year plans, respectively4. Further, a statement released by
the Ministry of Power revealed that the power sector is expected to receive investments of
about US$ 300 billion due to large scale expansion plans over the next few years. A large chunk
of investments is expected to come from private investors, who have high confidence in the
sector, as demonstrated by the success of recent IPOs of public sector undertakings under the
Ministry of power.
9 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Know Your Organization (JSW Group)
JSW Group is a part of USD 16.5 billion O. P. Jindal Group. Under the dynamic leadership
of Mr. Sajjan Jindal, JSW Group has grown into a USD 10 billion enterprise with interests across
various core economic sectors Steel, Energy, Cement, Aluminum, Natural Resources,
Maritime Infrastructure and IT.
In a short span of time, JSW has become the largest integrated
steel manufacturer in India. It is striving to become a leading player in every business that it
operates. Its activities have impacted villages and lives of thousands of people associated with
it. JSWs award winning townships and world class infrastructure have set new benchmarks and
won numerous accolades.
Vision
Global recognition for Quality and Efficiency, while nurturing nature and society.
Mission
Supporting the nations growth in power and steel with speed and innovation.
Core Values
Transparency
Strive for Excellence
Dynamism
Passion for Learning
Another benefit of VFDs is the improved energy performance of the motor itself.
The VFD control allows the motor to operate closer to its best efficiency point.
VFDs can correct for oversized motors by running them at reduced
speed. Compared to other speed control methods, with VFD there is no loss due to
mechanical slip between motor and load.
3. Motor Soft-Starting
VDFs also provide a soft-start when installed in-line with the motor by slowly hiking the
voltage for a smoother startup. Most motors experience start-up in-rush currents that
are 5 to 6 times higher than normal operating currents, which is reduced to 1.5 times
with VFDs, thus reducing wear and tear of the motor. Soft starting is mainly use to limit
large motor starting currents and better management of the power factor.
4. Power Factor Correction
The installation of a VFD helps to improve a motors Power Factor (PF). When installed,
the reactive power that is the source of low power factor circulates mainly between the
DC link and the motor, and therefore cannot affect the input AC electric power supply.
Higher power factor reduces the I
2
R losses in the power transformers and cables.
62 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
A VFD equipped motor system will typically have high PF of 0.98
compared to 0.83 for a typical motor. The PF(Power Factor) when using A VFD does not
degrade with the decreased speed, as is the case with typical motors.
5. Slip Compensation
Without a VFD, when the motor load torque is increased, the speed of the motor will
decrease. To compensate for this slip, torque vs. speed curve is modified with use of a
VFD so that the torque increase can be accomplished while maintaining a constant
speed.
This slip compensation is a standard function on most VFD drives and is
especially useful in application which require constant speed but varying torque.
Power Factor Correction
1. Power factor basics
AC Power flow has three components:
Active Power is the power needed for useful work such as turning a lathe, providing
light Or pumping water. It is expressed in Watt or Kilowatt (kW).
Reactive Power is a measure of the stored energy reflected to the source. It is
expressed In var or Kilovar (kVAR).
Apparent Power is the vector sum of both the active and the reactive components.
It is expressed in Volt Amperes or in Kilovolt Amperes (kVA).
2. Power triangle
The relations between the various power components are illustrated in the power triangle
Shown in in the figure. From the figure, it is apparent that the active power component is in
phase with the applied voltage while the reactive component occurs 90 out of phase with the
voltage.
The equation that defines this relationship is:
(KW)^2 + (kVAR) ^2 = (kVA) ^2
63 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Power factor (PF) is, in fact, a measure of efficiency. When the PF reaches unity, it can be said
that the electrical system in the plant is operating at maximum efficiency.
There are two commonly used definitions of power factor:
PF = Cosine of phase displacement between current and voltage.
PF = Cosine of angle between active power and apparent power.
3. Improvement
Some Components like the coal mills, etc. have very low power factor. Power factor can be
improved by either increasing the active power component or reducing there active
component. Of course, increasing the active power component for the sole purpose of power
factor correction would not be economically feasible. Thus, the only practical means for
improving the systems power factor is to reduce the reactive power component. One method
of reducing this component is to provide reactive power locally close to the load. This method
will improve the power factor from the point where the reactive power source is connected. As
an example, consider the load in the figure below.
64 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
The total power required is 100kVA of which 80kW is active power and 60kVAR is reactive
Power. If the reactive power is furnished locally, the power system only has to carry 80kVA
(80kW).
4. Problems with capacitor banks:-
When applying power factor correction capacitors, a couple of problems arise.
First, capacitors are a natural low impedance path for harmonic currents and will, therefore,
Absorb these energies. This increase in capacitor current results in higher element temperature
Which reduces the life of the capacitor. Also, because capacitors reduce the network
impedance, Capacitors can actually increase the level of harmonic current on the network.
The second and potentially more serious concern, is network resonance. When capacitors are
Added to the network, they set up a parallel resonance circuit between the capacitors and the
Network inductance. Harmonic current components that are close to the parallel resonance
point are magnified. The magnified current can cause serious problems such as excessive
Voltage distortion, nuisance fuse and breaker operation, overvoltage tripping of drives and
Insulation breakdown within motors, transformers and conductors.
Both risks increase with the size of the capacitor bank. The larger the size of the cap bank,
The higher the risks.
To address this issue, a tuned capacitor bank is one of the solutions that can be used to
suppress a given harmonic order to prevent network resonance.
5. Benefits:-
Power factor improvement allows the use of smaller transformers, switchgear and cables, etc.
as well as reducing power losses and voltage drop in an installation.
A high power factor allows the optimization of the components of an installation. Overrating of
certain equipment can be avoided, but to achieve the best results the correction should be
effected as close to the individual equipment in the building possible.
Losses in cables are proportional to square of the current and power factor improvement
reduced the distribution losses up to 1% from the existing levels.
By improving the power factor of a load supplied from a transformer, the current through the
transformer will be reduced thereby allowing more loads to be added. In practice, it may be
less expensive to improve the power factor, than to replace the transformer by a larger unit.
65 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
In order to reduce the Auxiliary Power Consumption the company, JSW Energy Ltd is planning
on implementing various optimization techniques available in the market, such as installing
VFDs at various components .A Comparative study of power consumption of CEP (Condensate
Extraction Pump) and ID (Induced Draft Fan) with and without VFDs is presented as two Case
studies below.
CASE STUDY I
CEP (Condensate Extraction Pump)
Design Data
Flow 795M3/Hr.
Head 335Mtrs = 33.5 Kg/Cm
2
Pump Required Power (795 x 33.5 x 10 x 9.81)/3600 = 715 KW
Pump Efficiency 83.5 %
Pump Input 856 KW
Motor Efficiency 95.36%
Motor Input 897 KW.
Rotation per minute( RPM) 1490
Present Operating Data at 300 MW Unit Load
Flow 790 M3/Hr.
Head 15.4 Kg/Cm
2
Pump Power 980 KW
66 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
To keep the pressure 15.4 Kg/Cm
2
, the required speed of the pump
N2 = N1 x (H1/H2)
= 1490 x (15.4/33.5)
= 1070 RPM
{According to pumps Affinity laws: P1/P2 = Q1/Q2 = (H1/ H2)
2
= (N1/N2)
3
}
Net Power Consumption with VFD = (1070 / 1490)
2/3
x 980 = 803 KW
Net power saving due to VFD = 980 803 = 177 KW
Net Money saving per 7500 Hrs. (per annum) = 177 x 7500 x 4 = 5.31 MIR
67 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
CASE STUDY II
ID (Induced Draft) Fan
Design Data
Motor power rating 2240KW
Motor speed 740 RPM
Power Factor 0.871
Flow Control Voith Hydraulic Coupling
Operating Data
Motor Speed 563 RPM
Power Consumption 1380 KW
If the Scoop is kept at 100% and with the help of VFD, the Motor is made to run at operating
speed of 563 RPM, the amount of power required :
= (563/740)
3
x 2240
= 986 KW
The Net Power Saving = 1380 986 = 394 KW / hr
Net money saving per annum i.e. 7500 Hr. p.a. = 394 x 7500 x 4 = 11.98 MIR
For two ID Fans, net saving per annum = 2 x 11.98 = 23.96 MIR
These two optimizations can save about 23.96MIR + 5.31MIR = 29.27MIR per annum.
Similarly inspecting and optimization of major power consuming Auxiliaries can help in saving
not just money but also power.
68 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Suggestions and Improvements
1. Coal Handling Plant
Coal conveyers :
i. Idle running of the coal conveyers can be avoided to save the power
consumption. Consumes 15-20% of full load power.
ii. Increasing the rate at which the coal is being filled into the bunkers can
help in saving power consumption.
E.g. The Power consumption for filling of all the three coal bunkers at a
speed of 200 TPH will be more when compared to filling at a rate of
1000TPH and also saving time.
Coal Mills:
To reach the maximum power load, the ideal number of coal mills
required is 4 out of the available 6 depending on the quality of the coal.
But, it is observed that around 5 -6 mills are running to attain the
maximum power load. Hence, any measures taken for reducing the usage
of the extra coal mills can help in saving around 200 KW of power.
2. Cooling towers
Optimizing number of cooling tower fans required to operate based on vacuum
during favorable conditions.
Optimizing cooling tower fan blade angle on a seasonal and load basis.
Forced Draft Cooling tower fans consume large amounts of current, around
1000A. So, instead of using Forced Draft Fans, using natural draft fans can reduce
the power consumption by approximately 2%. This must taken care of during the
designing of the plant.
69 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
3. Lighting System
Replacing filament lamps with LED lamps
Though the installation charges are high, payback period is short and has
very low maintenance and high life time.
Installing timers for exhaust fans and other lighting equipment.
All A/C systems set at 24
o
C at is the most energy efficient temperature.
70 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
Conclusion
The report reveals that the plant has a considerable ways of saving energy in the
areas of pump units, fan systems, boilers, compressors, lightings, coal handling
plant etc. The total energy savings that can be achieved through these
optimizations prove to be substantial as proved by the case studies shown in the
report. Though the cost of these investments are high, the payback period is
small. The criteria for the implementation of above mentioned measures should
not just be saving energy but also not compromising on the efficiency of the
process. There is a scope of reducing auxiliary power consumption by about 2-
2.5 % in JSW Energy Ltd by taking suitable actions. It is believed that a reduction
of 1% Auxiliary power consumption can save about 22.9 MIR per annum.
71 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
INDEX
ACDB Alternating Current Distribution Board
ACWP Auxiliary Circulating Water pump
ACWT Auxiliary Circulating Water Transformer
AHP Ash handling Plant
APC Auxiliary Power Consumption
BFP Boiler Feed Pump
CEP Condensate Extraction Pump
CFL Compact-Fluorescent Lamp
CHP Coal Handling Plant
CRH Cold Re-Heater
CT Cooling Tower
CWP Circulating Water Pump
DCDB Direct Current Distribution Board
DCS Digital Control System
ESP Electro-Static Precipitator
FD Forced Draft
GT Generating Transformer
HP High Pressure
HRH Hot Re-Heater
ID Induced Draft
IP Intermediate Pressure
LED Light Emitting Diode
LP Low Pressure
MCC Motor Control Center
MLDB Main Lighting Distribution Board
PA Primary Air
PCC Power Control Center
SA Sealing Air
SST Station Service Transformer
TG Turbine-Generator
UAT Unit Auxiliary Transformer
UPS Utility Power Supply
UST Unit Service Transformer
VFD Variable Frequency Drive
VSC Variable Speed Control
72 |Optimization Of Auxiliary Power Consumption
References
WEBSITES
https://www.jswel.net
https://en.wikipedia.org/
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable-frequency_drive
http://www.cea.nic.in/reports/yearly/
http://www.npti.in/
http://www.Ieeexplore.ieee.org
BOOKS
Schneider electric : Auxiliary Power consumption Reduction in Thermal
power Plant by Ramesh Batia
ABB Handbook of Energy Efficiency For Power Plant Auxiliaries
Increasing efficiency of the conventional auxiliary systems of power plants
by Thomas Schmager, Pasi Mannistro.
Power Plant Engineering by P.K. Nag.
Thermal Engineering by R.S. Khurmi.
Power Plant Engineering by Arora and Domkundavar.
Principle of Power Systems by V.K Mehta.