Professional Documents
Culture Documents
+ =
v c
v
y
h I Z
V (3)
where:
= 30
4
1
0
0
0
Z
h : Lines height [m]
I
0
: Return stroke peak current [kA]
Y : Distance to lightning strike point [m]
v : return stroke speed [m/s]
c : light speed =300[m/s
B. Jankov Equation
Frommultivariate regression techniques J ankov [31], have
found approximate equations for induced voltage calculation.
In order to obtain this equation it was simulated more than
300 cases with different values of T (Heidler equation front
time [15] [s]), (Heidler equation decay time[s]) and h
(lines height [m]), and was found the relation between the
maximal induced voltage (V
max
) and the distance between the
striking point and the line (D). For the simulations it was used
the Agrawal model as coupling model, TCS model was used to
describe the return stroke channel and the Heidler equation for
the base channel current; in this study is assumed ground as a
perfect conductor and a lossless unifilar line. The approximate
equation for calculate induced voltage is shown in (4)
( ) [ ] kV ln ln exp
5
5 1 0 0 max
D k D k k I k V
u
+ + = (4)
where:
( )
( ) ( ) s T T k
s T e k
k k
k
e k
h
T
h
k
T
T
u
1 . 0 , 10 ) 02 . 0 5 . 7 9 . 0
1 . 0 , 10 15 . 1 667 . 0 1 18 . 0 4 . 0
45 . 3
25 . 3 25 . 2
4
10 333 . 3 8 . 0 01875 10
100
4
5
4 85 . 28
85 . 28
19 . 0
19 . 0
5
0 0
1
55 . 0
1 . 0
0
6 . 0
4
4 . 1
45 . 1
+ =
>
]
]
]
.
|
'
]
]
.
|
'
+ =
=
+ =
(
D: Perpendicular Distance between the striking point and
the beginning of the line [m]
C. Comparison Methodology
In order to compare these three equations there were
simulated 400 different cases with varying the whole
parameters values randomly and assuming the ground as a
perfect conductor. It was used the same line configuration as
in the multivariate analysis shown in section IV-A. Taking
into account that the Rusck and J ankov equations use the
perpendicular distance to the line, and dont take into account
the incidence there was restricted the lightning strike area as
shown in Fig. 6.
Fig. 6. Line configuration for equation comparison
In order to observe how much could be increased the errors
of these equations, when the ground conductivity is
considered, it was simulated the same above cases including
this parameter with random values on the induced voltage
calculation.
D. Results Analysis
When it is evaluated neglecting the ground conductivity, the
three equations have similar results, (2), and (4) have a mean
error of 16% and 20% for (3). Although, the mean errors for
the three equations are similar, the equation that has better
results is (2) because errors ever are lower than 50%,
meanwhile, (3) and (4) could have errors higher than 100%, as
it is shown in Fig. 7.
Cumulative Probabiity for Relative Error
0,0%
10,0%
20,0%
30,0%
40,0%
50,0%
60,0%
70,0%
80,0%
90,0%
100,0%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Error [%]
P
r
o
b
a
b
i
l
i
t
y
[
%
]
Ec. (2)
Rusck1
J anckov
Fig. 7. Cumulative probability distribution of the Relative errors of the
approximate equations, when are compared with the Agrawal model
considering infinite ground conductivity
When ground conductivity is not neglected, it is observed
that (2) has errors lower than those when the ground
conductivity is not considered. The J ankov equation increases
its mean error up to 30%, meanwhile the Rusck Equation
continue having 20% of mean error, as it is shown in Fig. 8.
Cumulati ve Probability for Relative Error
0,0%
10,0%
20,0%
30,0%
40,0%
50,0%
60,0%
70,0%
80,0%
90,0%
100,0%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Error [%]
P
r
o
b
a
b
i
l
i
t
y
[
%
]
Ec. (2)
Rusck
J anckov
Fig. 8 Cumulative probability distribution of the Relative errors of the
approximate equations, when are compared with the Agrawal model
considering finite ground conductivity
VI. CONCLUSIONS
By means of this sensitivity analysis it was found the
parameters that most influence have on the induced voltages
calculation.
It is observed that current amplitude and lightning strike
position are one of the parameters that have a high influence
on the induced voltages magnitude. However parameters such
as ground conductivity and line height may be considered as
well.
It was found that nonlinear regression models are a good
methodology to determine the most influential parameters on
complex models.
It was obtained and approximate equation to calculate the
maximum induced voltage on a distribution line that has
reasonable results. This equation includes parameters such as
angle of incidence and ground conductivity. It is worth
mention that the equation just calculate the maximumvoltage
with the same polarity that the lightning current.
The comparison of the equation shows the three equations
compared with the Agrawal model have reasonable results,
with a mean error less than 16 % for (2) and (4) and 20% for
(3). When the ground conductivity is taking into account, the
errors of (3) and (4) increase up to 30%.
VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors will like to thank to the Colombian Science
Council -COLCIENCIAS, Research ProgramPAAS-UN, and
National University of Colombia.
VIII. REFERENCES
[1] H, Torres, F. Herrera. Lightning Research in Colombia. 22d
International Conference on Lightning Protection (ICLP). Berlin. Sept,
1994.
[2] K.W. Wagner, Elektromagnetische ausgleichsvorgange in freileitungen
und kabeln, par. 5, Leipzig, 1908.
[3] L.V. Bewley, Travelling waves due to lightning, Transaction AIEE,
Vol. 48, pp 1050-1064, J uly 1929.
[4] V. Aigner, Induzierte blitzuberspannungen und ihre beziehung zum
ruckwartigen uberschlag, (in German), ETZ, Vol. 56, pp. 497-500,
1935.
[5] C.F. Wagner, G.D. McCann, Induced Voltages on Transmission
Lines, AIEE Transactions, Vol. 61, pp. 916-930, 1942.
[6] B.F.J. Schonland, Progressive Lightning, part II, Proceedings of Royal
Society London, Ser. A, 143, pp. 654-674, 1934.
[7] S. Szpor, A new theory of the induced overvoltages, CIGRE, Report
308, Paris, 1948.
[8] R.H. Golde, Lightning surges on overhead distribution lines caused by
direct and indirect lightning strokes, AIEE Transaction, Vol. 73, pp.
437-447, 1954.
[9] R. Lundholm, Induced overvoltages surges on transmission lines and
their bearing on the lightning performance at medium voltage
networks, Transactions of Chalmers University of Technology, No.
188, Gothemburg, Sweden, 1957.
[10] S. Rusck. Induced Lightning Over-voltages on Power Transmission
Lines with Special Reference to the Over-voltage Protection of Low-
voltage Networks. Transactions of the Royal Institute of Technology.
No. 120. Stockholm, Sweden. 1958.
[11] P. Chowdhuri, P, E. T. B. Gross, Voltages Induced on Overhead
Multiconductor lines by Lightning Strokes. Proc. IEE, Vol. 116, No 4,
p. 561-565. April 1969.
[12] A. K. Agrawal, H. J . Price, and S. H. Gurbaxani, Transient Response of
Multiconductor Transmission Lines Excited by a Nonuniform
Electromagnetic Field IEEE, Transactions on Electromagnetic
Compatibility, Vol. EMC-22, No 2. Mayo, 1980
[13] C. A. Nucci, A. Borghetti, A. Piantini, J . M. J aniszewski, Lightning
Induced Voltages on Distribution Overhead lines: Comparison between
experimental results from a reduced-scaled model and most recent
approaches. In 24
th
Proceedings of International Conference on
Lightning Protection (ICLP98), Birmingham England, September
1998.
[14] H. Torres, E. Prez, J. Herrera, C. Younes, M. Salgado, C. Quintana, D.
Rondn , L. Gallego, J . Montaa, M. Vargas, Sensibility Analysis of
Four Factors For Calculation of Induced Voltages On Tree-Shaped
Distribution Lines in Proceedings of 12
th
International Symposiumon
High Voltage (12 ISH), Bangalore, India, 20-24 August 2001
[15] C. A. Nucci, Lightning Induced Voltages on Overhead Power Lines,
Part I: Return Stroke Current Models with Specified Channel Base
Current for the Evaluation of Return Stroke Electromagnetic Fields
CIGRE 33.01 (Lightning) Electra No 161, August, 1995.
[16] C.A. Nucci, F. Rachidi, M. V. Ianoz and C. Mazzetti, Lightning
Induced Voltages on Overhead Lines. IEEE Transactions on
Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vol 35, No 1, February 1993.
[17] M.J. Master and M. Uman. Methods for Calculating the
Electromagnetic Fields from Known Source Distributions: Application
to Lightning. American Journal of Physics, vol 51. 1983.
[18] F. Rachidi, C.A. Nucci, M. Ianoz, Influence of a lossy ground on
lightning-induced voltages on overhead lines, IEEE Transactions on
Electromagnetic Compatibility, Vol. 38, No. 3, August 1996.
[19] C.A. Nucci, M.T. Correia, S. Guerrieri, F. Rachidi, Influence of corona
on lightning induced voltages overhead power lines, in Proceedings of
the International Conference on Power Systems Transients, Lisbon, 3-7
September, 1995.
[20] S. Guerrieri, M. Ianoz, F. Rachidi, C.A. Nucci, C. Mazzetti, Lightning
induced overvoltages on an overhead line above lossy ground: a
sensitivity analysis, in Proceedings of the 23
rd
International Conference
on Lighning Protection (ICLP), pp.328-333, vol. I, Firenze, 23-27
September 1996.
[21] A. Borghetti, C.A. Nucci, M. Paolone, M. Bernardi, Effect of striking
distance expression and of the presence of shielding wires on the
evaluation of the number of lightning induced voltages, in Proceedings
of the 25
th
International Conference on Lightning Protection ICLP2000,
Rhodos, September 2000.
[22] A. Borghetti, C.A. Nucci, M. Paolone, F. Rachidi, Characterization of
the Respones of an overhead line to lightning electromagnetic fields, in
Proceedings of the 25
th
International Conference on Lightning
Protection ICLP2000, Rhodos, September 2000.
[23] F.H. Silveira, A.R. De Conti, M.A.O. Schroeder, S. Visacro, A. Soares,
M. H. M. Vale, Influence of Transmission Line Configuration on the
Amplitude of Lightning Induced Overvoltages, in Proceedings of
International Conference on Lightning protection ICLP 2002. Cracow,
Poland, September 2002.
[24] R. Montao, V. Cooray, M. Martinez, A. Da Silva, L. Laffont, M.
Olodsoon, Induced Overvoltage Sensitivity Analysis Using STIDA in
Proceedings of International Conference on Lightning protection ICLP
2002. Cracow, Poland, September 2002.
[25] C.A. Nucci, and F. Rachidi. Experimental Validation of a Modification
to de Transmission Line Model for LEMP Calculations, Octavo
Simposio y Exhibicin Tcnica internacional sobre Compatibilidad
Electromagntica. Zurich, March, 1989.
[26] F. Heidler, Analytische blitzstromfunktion zur LEMP Berechnung
paper 1.9, Munich, September 1985.
[27] M.J . Master and M. Uman. Methods for Calculating the
Electromagnetic Fields from Known Source Distributions: Application
to Lightning. American Journal of Physics, vol 51. 1983
[28] M. Rubinstein An Approximate Formula for the Calculation of the
Horizontal Electric Field fromLightning at Close, Intermediate, an Long
Range. IEEE, Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility. Vol
38, No. 3, August 1996.
[29] V. Cooray, Horizontal field generated by return strokes, Radio
Science, Vol. 27, No 4, pp. 529-537, July-Aug. 1992
[30] M. Baran, D. Cristescu and C. Bouquegneau, New contributions to the
study of lightning parameters, CIGRE 98 SC22 (WG33.01) 5IWD.
1998.
[31] V. J ankov, Estimation of Maximal Voltage Induced on an Overhead
Line Due to the Nearby Lightning, IEEE, transactions on Power
Delivery, Vol 12, No 1, January 1997
Ernesto Prez was born in Bogota, Colombia, South
America on November 21st, 1976. He received the
BSc (1999) and MSc (2002) degrees from the National
University of Colombia in Electrical Engineer and
High Voltage, nowadays he is doing his PhD courses
on the National University of Colombia.
He has been working on the research group PAAS-
UN in Colombia since 1998. His special fields of
interest included high voltage, induced voltages and
lightning protection.
Javier Herrera was born in Bogota, Colombia, on
July 28, 1976. He received his BSc degree in electrical
engineering fromthe National University of Colombia,
Bogot, in 1998. In the same year he joined the
Research Program on Acquisition and Analysis of
Signals PAAS-UN.
In 2002, he obtained his Msc. Degree on electrical
engineering fromthe National University of Colombia.
He has been engaged in lightning protection
systems and power systems transients with emphasis on
lightning-induced voltages. At present he is starting his
PhD. Studies at the National University of Colombia.
Horacio Torres was born in Bogota, Colombia, on
May 1
st
of 1949. He received his Bsc and MSc degrees
in Electrical Engineering fromthe National University
of Colombia in 1975 and 178 respectively. He made
his studies of PhD in Technische Universitaet
Darmstadt, TUD, Germany.
He leads the research group PAAS-UN since 1993,
and is titular professor of Electrical Engineering on the
National University of Colombia. His special fields of
interest included high voltage, lightning discharge and
lightning protection. He is author or co-author of more than 45 national
international related with his fields of interest.