Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Doyle
Success of War Yet To Be Determined
After the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, there was belief
among many inside and outside of the White House that something
March 19, 2003, two days after insisting that Saddam Hussein and his
two sons surrender and leave Iraq within 48 hours, the United States
began bombing Baghdad. This would signify the start of one of the
costliest and most controversial wars in the United States’ history, the
that the United States would deal with threats before they emerge. In
this case, Bush believed that war with Iraq would stop the threat of
eight specific goals that the U.S. hoped to accomplish through the Iraq
• "to end the regime of Saddam Hussein by striking with force on a scope
and scale that makes clear to Iraqis that he and his regime are finished."
• "to identify, isolate and eventually eliminate Iraq's weapons of mass
destruction, their delivery systems, production capabilities, and distribution
networks."
• "to search for, capture, drive out terrorists who have found safe harbor in
Iraq."
• "to collect such intelligence as we can find related to terrorist networks in
Iraq and beyond."
• "to collect such intelligence as we can find related to the global network of
illicit weapons of mass destruction activity."
2
Doyle
• "to end sanctions and to immediately deliver humanitarian relief, food and
medicine to the displaced and to the many needy Iraqi citizens."
• "to secure Iraq's oil fields and resources, which belong to the Iraqi people,
and which they will need to develop their country after decades of neglect
by the Iraqi regime."
• "to help the Iraqi people create the conditions for a rapid transition to a
representative self-government that is not a threat to its neighbors and is
committed to ensuring the territorial integrity of that country." (Murphy)
These goals were mostly fair and valid reasons for invading Iraq.
Toppling a ruthless dictator who had killed thousands of his people was
certainly a justified goal of the war. Although the United States would
elimination of the threat of terrorists in Iraq was also a just cause for
war. The Iraq War was only to be an extension of the larger “War on
Pakistan. Also, the goal of securing Iraq’s oil fields was justified
invaded Iraq. Overall, although the reasons justifying the war were
mostly valid, the war itself has been poorly managed and executed,
possibility that the situation in Iraq can improve but that is yet to be
determined.
3
Doyle
By ending Saddam Hussein’s regime, the United States finally
everything. (135)
that there were WMDs was attributed to David Kay, head of the Iraq
fact, he was given $10 million in a covert CIA fund to offer to any
stockpiles after the Gulf War but bluffed that he still had them in order
(Ricks, 375)
However, Kay did believe that Saddam still had the capacity to
Doyle
2004, President Bush reverted to Kay’s belief that Hussein had this
Hussein was dangerous with the ability to make weapons.” (Ricks, 376)
However, Bush and Kay are not the only ones to be blamed for the
destruction. In his book The War Within, Bob Woodward discusses how
Colin Powell, the Secretary of Defense, “had been the “closer” for the
president’s case for war.” (Woodward, 46) Powell spoke to the United
Nations a month before the war, claiming the “facts” about Iraq, which
clearly was invalid and has been very damaging to the Bush
Administration.
Islamic terrorists in Iraq. (Ricks, 377) Vice President Dick Cheney held
and Corn, 4) However, the CIA often reported that there was little
influencing their work. (Isikoff and Corn, 4) In June 2004, the National
5
Doyle
Commission on Terrorist Attacks upon the United States concluded in
its report that although there were contacts made between Hussein’s
intelligence concluded that the invasion of Iraq had turned it into a new
Iraq’s oil fields and resources. In his article “When Is the War Won?”
for CBS in 2003, Jarrett Murphy stated that “the oil fields have been
secured and most of the relatively few oil fire have been extinguished.”
(Murphy)
States has at least partly succeeded in that goal. After the country’s
those in Iraq. In the words of interim Prime Minister Ayad Allawi, “We
are entering a new era in our history, and all Iraqis, whether they voted
Doyle
nongovernmental organizations must register with a higher authority
limit the amount of rights and privileges each of these groups receive.
current civic society is far better than the one under Hussein’s rule.
There are now over 6,250 organizations in Iraq, including the Ministry
However, the United States itself has not entirely helpful with the
President Bush met with the newly elected president of Iraq, Jalal
(Woodward, 141) This was a large flaw that existed within Bush’s
policy. While one of the strategies of the war was to prepare and train
Iraqi forces, the United States was unwilling to provide the necessary
and more money is being spent each year. The following chart
displays the amount the U.S. has spent from 2003 to 2007 on the war.
2003 $53.00
2004 $75.90
7
Doyle
2005 $85.50
2006 $102.00
2007 $133.60
Source: zfacts.com
From the chart, it is clear that the U.S. has been paying the price
for a long and drawn out war that is becoming more expensive every
Western teachings there. (Ricks, 431) Also, other goals would have
On some the stated goals of the Iraq War, the United States was
both fair and valid reasons for going to war. However, other goals, like
terrorists in Iraq were not justified. It was clear before the war that
Saddam was a ruthless dictator but it was not clear that there were
terrorists and Iraq. Had the Bush gone to war without those two
pretenses, billions of dollars could have been saved and used on other
goals instead.
8
Doyle
Has the United States’ war with Iraq transformed the Middle East
the future the Middle East can become democratic. Until then, the Iraq
Works Cited
Abouzeid, Rania. "The Iraqi Government's New Target: Do-Gooders." Time Magazine
Burns, John F. "The Iraqi Election: Assessment; Iraqis Begin Tabulating Results of
"Cost of Iraq War and Nation Building." ZFacts. Web. 14 Dec. 2009.
9
Doyle
<http://zfacts.com/p/447.html>.
Isikoff, Michael, and David Corn. Hubris The Inside Story of Spin, Scandal, and the
Murphy, Jarrett. "When Is the War Won?" CBS News. 11 Apr. 2003. Web.
<http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2003/04/11/iraq/main548893.shtml>.
Ricks, Thomas E. Fiasco The American Military Adventure in Iraq. New York: Penguin
Singal, Jesse, Christine Lim, and M.J. Stephey. "Shock and Awe." Time Magazine Mar.
2003. Print.
Wong, Edward. "Hussein Charged With Genocide in 50,000 Deaths." New York Times 5
Woodward, Bob. State of Denial. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2006. Print.
Woodward, Bob. The War Within: A Secret White House History 2006-2008. New York: