Miami Beach Lobbyist Registration Irregularities

MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS
21November2014
NelsonBellido,Esq.,Chairman
MIAMIDADECOMMISSIONONETHICSANDPUBLICTRUST
viaemail
FollowUp:InformationFiledreLobbyistLawViolationsinCityofMiamiBeach
DearMr.Bellido:
Greetings!
AttachedyouwillfindaselfexplanatorycopyofanunacknowledgedInformationfiled
on15OctoberwithCommissiononEthics(COE)directorJoeCentorino,Esq.regardingcauseto
believethatfivelobbyistsviolatedthelobbyistordinanceoftheCityofMiamiBeach.
I understand that the COE has jurisdiction over lobbyist issues, and, upon information
foundorprovided,theCOEmay,withoutacomplaintbeingfiledbyanymemberofthepublic
or public official, proceed with an investigation if the information includes reason to suspect
thatlobbyistshaveviolatedrelevantcodes.
Please advise in writing whether the COE has taken or will take any action on the
Informationfiled,and,ifso,thenatureofthataction.
IfIreceivenoresponsebydeadlineon1December,Ishallassumethatsilenceconfirms
thatithasnotandwillnotactontheInformation(Quitacetconsentirevidetur).
Verytrulyyours,
DavidArthurWalters
Cc:
JoeCentorino,Esq.Director
MiamiDadeCommissiononEthicsandPublicTrust
RaulAguila,Esq.,CityAttorney
CityofMiamiBeach
RafaelGranado,Esq.,Clerk
CityofMiamiBeach
15October2014
JoeCentorino,Director
MIAMIDADECOUNTYCOMMISSIONONETHICSANDPUBLICTRUST
19WestFlagler,Suite820
Miami,Florida33130
INFORMATION:ProbableLobbyistLawViolationsinCityofMiamiBeach
Mr.Centorino:
PleasefindattachedinformationregardingprobablelobbyistlawviolationsoftheCityofMiami
BeachsLobbyistCodebythefollowingpersons:
20120501
BillEagerfor
forTRGAlaskaIIILLC
FailuretoidentifyChiefPersonand5%orMoreOwnershipInterest(s)
20120501
CharlesSieger
forTRGAlaskaIIILLC
20140408
MichaelJ.Marrero
forSeaSprayDevelopmentLLC
FailuretoregisteraslobbyistyetpermittedtolobbybeforetheHistoricPreservationBoard
20140708
MichaelJ.Marrero
forSeaSprayDevelopmentLLC
(Exampleprovidedofhiscomplianceelsewhere)
Page1of2
20110517
JoshuaM.Benaim
for321OceanHoldingLLC
20120709
JamesW.Carse
for321OceanHoldingLLC
TheCityofMiamiBeachhasevidentlybeenremissindiligentlyenforcingitslobbyistordinance
in crucial provisions, at least in respect to these lobbyists and their principals. It may also be
negligent in providing for effective penalties and adequate remedies so that the goal of
compliancewillmorelikelybeobtainedinthefuture.
ThiscommunicationcomprisesanInformation,andnotaComplaint,thereforeyouareleftto
act on your own initiative according to your conscience while the lobbying industry and the
publicwatches.
Respectfullysubmitted,
DavidArthurWalters
Cc
NelsonBellido,Chairman
MIAMIDADECOMMISSIONONETHICSANDPUBLICTRUST
Page2of2
30September2014
RafaelGranado
CityClerk
CITYOFMIAMIBEACH
Subject:LobbyistRegistrationandOurGoal
DearMr.Granado:
Thank you for allowing an ordinary person to participate in your government. It is for that
reasonthatIhaveagreatdealofrespectforyourofficeunderyoursupervisionaswellasthat
of your predecessor, the good Mr. Parcher, whom was known for his dogged independence
despitethecitysbranchlessormonolithicconstitution.
2014-09-29 Email: Rafael Granado to David Arthur Walters. Mr. Walters. Thank you for
bringing this matter to our attention. Our goal is to have the form(s) completed accurately
by the applicant, lobbyist and/or principal, As soon as that is done, they will be scanned
and posted. Rafael Granado
ItiswithindependenceinmindthatImustsaywithallduerespectthatIdonotknowwhom
ourmeanswhenyoustatethatourgoalistohavethefatallydefectivelobbyistregistration
formscompletedbysomeoneatsomeunspecifieddate.Isuspectthatourexcludesmostof
thecommunity.IhadaskedwhenyouwillreferthemattertotheEthicsCommission,asour
lobbyingordinanceprovidesyouwiththediscretiontodothat.
Icertainlyamlookingforwardtobeingalertedonthearrivaloftheinformationastowhoowns
10%ofmoreofthisAlaskanmemberoftheRelatedGroupcontrolledbybillionaireJorgeM.
Perez,thedeveloperbehindthehugeSouthPointedevelopmentsgobblingupthelastacresof
scarceopenspaceforthebenefitofwealthyinternationalclientele.
I hope that I and anyone else interested do not have to search the records everyday of the
workweektodiscoverthatinformationsomeday.
IfIwereclerk,Iwouldsetafivedaycompliancedeadline.Complianceisminimalornilwithout
punishment. The natural persons involved here know better. They know why the community
Page1of2
wantstoknowwhoisbehindrealestatedevelopersfaades,andyettheyhavescoffedatthe
lawexpressedclearlyonthelobbyistregistrationformitself.Theyknewbetter,andnowisthe
timeforthecitytoshowthatittakesthepeopleswillexpressedinlawsseriouslyenoughto
enforcethem.
Weareplaguedbynoncomplianceinthiscity.Thefaultliesnotonlywithcityofficialsbutwith
the ethics commission and the county board of commissioners, not to mention the state
attorneyandattorneygeneralandgovernor.Ipraythatyoumayincludeeveryonewithinyour
our,andactindependentlyofthewillofJimmyMorales,PhilipLevine,JorgeM.Perez,and
theClintons.
Sincerely,
David Arthur Walters
Page2of2
Defective Filing on TRG ALASKA Defective Lobbyist Registration
SEPTEMBER 27, 2014
10:58 AM
David Arthur Walters <miamimirror@gmail.com>

to Rafael Granado, Joseph Centorino, Raul Aguila,
Mr. Granado:
Please advise approximately when your staff will have completed its research, and
when the matter will probably be referred to the Ethics Commission.
As explained before, the 5% or more stake information and name of the person
controlling is very important information that should not be left off the registration form.
The perhaps coincidental word "Alaska" in TRG Alaska piques my interest because
I am personally familiar with the nature of Alaska, and because a prominent Miami
Beach official had his company investigated for fraud there.
As you can see from a sample below, other persons have rightfully expressed an
interest in who is involved in Mr. Perez' companies with 'Alaska' in the rubric.
The failure to fill out the forms as required should subject the party to the maximum
penalty. Perhaps a daily fine should be imposed on the lobbyists whose forms have
already been inadvertently accepted by the clerk, calculated from the time of
acceptance until the time the information is revealed.
Thank you,
Defective Filing on TRG ALASKA Defective Lobbyist Registration
Granado, Rafael <RafaelGranado@miamibeachfl.gov>
Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at

11:45 AM
To: David Arthur Walters <miamimirror@gmail.com>

Cc: "Centorino, Joseph (COE)" <CENTORI@miamidade.gov>, "Aguila, Raul"
<RaulAguila@miamibeachfl.gov>, "Granado, Rafael"
<RafaelGranado@miamibeachfl.gov>
Thankyou.Iwillaskmystafftoreviewandfollowup
Regards,
MIAMIBEACH
Rafael E. Granado, Esq., CityClerk.
From: David Arthur Walters [mailto:miamimirror@gmail.com]
Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 2014 11:27 AM
To:Granado, Rafael
Cc:Centorino, Joseph (COE); Aguila, Raul
Subject: TRG ALASKA Defective Lobbyist Registration
Granado, Rafael <RafaelGranado@miamibeachfl.gov>
To: David Arthur Walters <miamimirror@gmail.com>
<RaulAguila@miamibeachfl.gov>
Thankyou.Iwillaskmystafftoreview.
Regards,
MIAMIBEACH
Rafael E. Granado, Esq., CityClerk
Additional Defective Filing on TRG ALASKA Defective Lobbyist Registration

2 messages
Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 11:34

AM
To: "Granado, Rafael" <RafaelGranado@miamibeachfl.gov>

Dear Mr. Granado:
Attached please find another defective filing (attached), Charles Sieger's 2012-05-01
Lobbyist Registration Form giving TRG ALASKA III as principal in the 801
South Pointe (MAREA) project but without identifying those with a greater than 5%
ownership interest and who is in charge of the company as required by law.
If there is no correction on file for this fatally defective registration, please follow the
provision set forth in our lobbying ordinance and forward it to the Miami Dade
County Commission on Ethics and Public Trust for disposition.
This will make a half-dozen I have referred to you. There are probably many more,
and from lobbyists who know better.
Thank you for your usual excellent service.
On Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 11:26 AM, David Arthur Walters
<miamimirror@gmail.com> wrote:
Dear Mr. Granado:
Attached please find Bill Eager's 2012-05-01 Lobbyist Registration Form giving TRG
ALASKA III as principal in the 801 South Pointe (MAREA) project but without
identifying those with a greater than 5% ownership interest and who is in charge of
the company as required by law.
I have already remarked, in previous submissions of defective registrations, on the
importance of providing the information.
If there is no correction on file for this fatally defective registration, please follow the
provision set forth in our lobbying ordinance and forward it to the Miami Dade
County Commission on Ethics and Public Trust for disposition.
Thank you for your usual excellent service.
MIAMI
City of Miami Beach Office of the City Clerk
1700 Convention Center Drive Miami Beach FL 33139
LOBBYIST REGISTRATION FORM
Lobbyist means all persons employed or retained whether paid or not by a principal who seeks to encourage the passage defeat or
modification of any ordinance resolution action or decision of any commissioner any action decision recommendation of the City
Manager or any city board or committee or any action decision or recommendation of any city personnel during the time period of the
entire decision making process on such action decision or recommendation that foreseeably will be heard or reviewed by the city
commission or a city board or committee

activities
The term
Lobbyists
The term specifically includes the principal as well as any employee engaged in lobbying
has specific exclusions
Please refer to Ordinance 2004 3435
C 44 k
Last
NAME OF LOBBYIST
First
I
1412 1 SLJ
V 5 G 11
Number
BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS
2 7y
2j oZ
IT
and
Street
State
City
Zip Code
2 y
@vc
FAX NUMBER
TELEPHONE NUMBER
L 33
tAjLkI
M 0
EMAIL
Please notify this office if your contact information changes address phone or e mail address
LOBBYIST RETAINED BY
Ar 1 A
M6
NAME OF PRINCIP
315 5
f LL C
tkA
LICLIENT
tv
xx
r
Number
and
eAA
Street
FAX NUMBER
TELEPHONE NUMBER
State
Optional
EMAIL
Ziq C
o de
ilil b
caj
Optional
Fill out this section if principal is a Corporation Partnership or Trust Section 2 482 c
NAME OF CHIEF OFFICER PARTNER OR BENEFICIARY
IDENTIFY ALL PERSONS HOLDING DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY A 5
OR MORE OWNERSHIP INTEREST IN SUCH CORPORATION
PARTNERSHIP OR TRUST
II
SPECIFIC LOBBY ISSUE

A
Issue to be lcfbbied
Describe in detail
15
4Q
n1
III CITY AGENCIES INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED

Pursuant to City Code Section 2 482 a 4 include the commissioner or personnel sought to be lobbied and whether the lobbyist has entered
into any contractual relationship paid or unpaid with said city commissioner or personnel from 12 months preceding such person s
commencement of service with the city to the present date stating the eneral nature of the subject contractual relationship
Sec 2 482
title
4 Full Name
of
Individual
Contractual Relationship Explain
and
YES
NO
person to be lobbied
ofpp
1V
OAJ
OvLA
Pursuant to City Code Secti n 2 482 g Every registrant shall be required to state the extent of any business financial familial or professional
relationship or other relationship giving rise to an appearance of an impropriety with any current city commissioner or city personnel who is
sought to be lobbied as identified on the lobbyist registration form filed
Sec 2 482
Any
Financial Familial
or
Professional
Relationship
12
11 J
f
F CLER
ALL
aFORMS
LOBBYIST FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc
DISCLOSURE OF TERMS AND AMOUNTS OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION DISCLOSE WHETHER HOURLY FLAT RATE OR OTHER
IV
LOBBYIST DISCLOSURE
Required
PRINCIPAL S DISCLOSURE
OF LOBBYIST COMPEN
TION
Lad
REQUIRED
The following information must be answered

1
Pursuant to Miami Beach City Code Section 2 488 Entitled Prohibited Campaign Contributions By Lobbyists On Procurement
Issues
No
Yes
Are you lobbying on a present or pending bid for goods equipment or services or on a present or pending
award for goods equipment or service
Pursuant to Miami Beach City Code Section 2 490 Entitled Prohibited Campaign Contributions By Lobbyists On Real Estate
Development Issues
Yes1 10o
Are you lobbying on a pending application for a Development Agreement with the City or application for
change of zoning map designation or change to the City s Future Land Use Map
Pursuant to Miami Beach City Code Section 2 482 h Any person except those exempt from the definition of lobbyist as set
forth in Section 2 481 above who only appears as a representative of a not for profit corporation or entity without special
compensation or reimbursement for the appearance whether direct or indirect to express support of or opposition to any
item shall register with the clerk as required by this section but shall not be required to pay any registration fees
Yes
No
Are you representing a not for profit corporation or entity without special compensation or reimbursement
SIGNATURE UNDER OATH
ON FEBRUARY 28 OF EACH YEAR EACH LOBBYIST SHALL SUBMIT TO THE CITY CLERK A SIGNED STATEMENT UNDER
OATH LISTING LOBBYING EXPENDITURES AS WELL AS COMPENSATION RECEIVED IN THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH FOR
THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR A STATEMENT SHALL BE FILED EVEN IF THERE HAVE BEEN NO EXPENDITURES OR
COMPENSATION DURING THE REPORTING PERIO
Signature o Lobb
I do solemnly swear that all of the foregoing facts are true and correct and that I have read or am familiar with the provisions contained
in Section 2 482 of the Miami
pach City Code and all reporting requirements
Signature of Lobbyist
Signature of Principal Client
PRINCIPAL IDENTIFICATION
LOBBYIST IDENTIFICATION
VI
FL bwl tied
Produced ID
Form
of
S LC
roduced
ID
Yr i c
eweW
Form of Identification
Identification
ISABEL SATCHELL
Personally
known
Lobbyist
Aft
SIGNATURE AND STAMP OF
o p ry1
EXPIRES April 13 2013
df
VII
Personally known Princ
MYCOMMISSIONgDD879891
BondedThruNotaryPublcUnderwrters
ISABEL SATCHELL
MY COMMISSION RDD879891
Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters

State
of
Florida
Sworn to
County
of
anPubscribed
This
b fore
me
of
Notarizatio
N t
Lobbyist
ublic
of
2012
of
Signature
State of Florida County of Mi

S orn any subscribed efore me
Miami Dade
State
s sign
of
ay
2012
State of Florida
Ire of Public
ry
Notari ation of Principal s signature
Signat
Florida
re
TO BE COMPLETED BY CITY CLERK S STAFF ONLY

Annual Registration fee
Yes
No
Amount Paid
MCR
JAZ
Date Paid
Lobbyist Registration Form received and verified by

F
CLER
F CLER
ALL aFORMS
ALL
LOBBYIST FORMS
aFORMS
Lobbyist Annual Registration For
Revised 04
27 2012
City of Miami Beach 1700 Convention Center Drive Miami Beach Florida 33139 www miamibeachfl gov
CITY CLERK Office
Rafael E
Granada
Tel 305 673 741 1
City
CityClerk @miamibeachfl gov
Clerk
Fax 305 673 7254
LOBBYIST NAME
fzk
I understand that no later than February 28 of each year I must file the following form
pursuant to Section 2 485 of the Miami Beach City Code with the City Clerk s Office for
all active lobbying issues
LOBBYIST EXPENDITURE AND COMPENSATION FORM
Failure to file these forms on a timely basis will result in my name being transmitted to
the Miami Dade County Commission on Ethics and for code violation evaluation
In
addition
once
an
issue I have
registered
to
lobby
on
has been
resolved
I am
required to immediately notify the City Clerk s Office of lobbyist withdrawal in writing
Pursuant to Section 2 485 d
the City Clerk shall notify any lobbyist or principal who

fails to timely file a Statement and In addition to any other penalties which may be
Imposed as provided in Section 2 485 1 a fine of 50 00 a day shall be assessed for all
Statement s filed after the due date
The City Clerk shall notify the Miami Dade
County Commission on Ethics and Public Trust of the failure of a lobbyist or principal
to file the Statement or pay the assessed fines after notification
Any lobbyist who fails to file the required Statement by April 30th 2012 shall be
automatically suspended from lobbying until all fines are paid unless the fine has been
appealed to the Miami Dade County Commission on Ethics and Public Trust
Sign
CLER
ALL
Date
re
aFORMS
Qol

commission or a city board or committee The term specifically includes the principal as well as any employee engaged in lobbying
activities
The term
Lobbyists
5 kea
Silk
AJe
jul
rc
6AI
Number
I412l
and
Street
SLJ
M l
1t
Ave
A
33 x
aip Code
ANWA t
FAX NUMBER
TELEPHONE NUMBER
State
City
30S Z74 2
i 11
3b5
I1S
First
Last
NAME OF LOBBYIST
SI OCResiA ez
EMAIL
Please notify this office if your contact information changes address phone or a mail address
I
1 L LC
NAME OF PRINCIPAUC
2 tS S
TENT
i
Number
3 by y L
Ne
66
and
Street
3 6
00
FAX NUMBER
TELEPHONE NUMBE
3313 1
tt
State
City
tJ
11
01 2
Optional
EMAIL
Zip Code
v 2
lA
Ie
ca K
Optional
IDENTIFY ALL PERSONS HOLDING
DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY A 5
ii SPECIFIC LOBBY ISSUE

alt
Issue to be lobbied
2D
LS
3ijeb 7 C
Describe in detail
nI CITY AGENCIES INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED

into any contractual relationship
paid or unpaid with said city commissioner or personnel from 12 months preceding such person s
commencement of service with the ci to the resent date stating the

Sec 2 482 a 4 Full Name of Individual and
title
erson
to be to
eneral nature of the subject contractual relationshi

YES
NO
ied
Pursuant to City Code Section 2 482 g Every registrant shall be required to state the extent of any business financial familial or professional
Sec 2 482 g
F CLER
An
ALL
Financial Familial
aFORMS
or
Professional Relationshi
DISCLOSURE OF TERMS AND AMOUNTS OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION DI
IV
Required
LOBBYIST DISCLOSURE
J
I
CLOSE WHETHER HOURLY FLAT RATE OR OTHER
t fl
t
f V
PRINCIPAL S DISCLOSURE OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION
REQUIRED

1
Issues
Yes Oo
Are you lobbyinq on a present or pending bid for goods equipment or services or on a present or pending
Development Issues
No
Yes
change of zoning map designation or change to the Cit s Future Land Use Map
Yes bNo
Are you representing anot for profit corporation or entity without special compensation or reimbursement
THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR
A STATEMENT SHALL BEFUZD EVEN IF THEM HAVE BEEN NO EXPENDITURES OR
COMPENSATION DURING THE REPORTING PERIOD
Signatur
11A11k
f Lo
ylgt
in Section 2 482
of
the Miami Bea
e and all rep rting requirements

LOBBYIST IDENTIF
VI
ID
roduced
ATION
egS
I
Li G
Produced ID
ISABEL SATCHELL
MY COMMISSION DD 879891
Personally
known
Ptl1 WS LAC
For
pr
Lo
of
Personally

Notary Public underwriters
known
Principal
Bonded Thru
E P t ES Apr l 13 2013
VII
State
of
Florida
Sworn to a
County
of
Gnd d Thru Notary Publ Undenvriiejs

State of Florida County of Miami Dade
6efole me
and subscrib
Miami Dade
subscribed before me
This
day
12wprn
Thi
201 2
of
State of Florida
Signa ur of Public o ry
Notariz tion of Lobbyist s signature
TO BE COMPLETE
ISABELSATCHELL
f Y COMMISSION DD 87589 i
Yes
No
Amount Paid
Signa
Notar
41
of
2012
State of Florida
Public
ry
ation of Principal s signature
re of
BY CITY CLERK S STAFF ONLY

MCR
Date Paid

F
CLER
F CLER
ALL aFORMS
ALL
LOBBYIST FORMS
aFORMS LOBBYIST
Lobbyist Annual Registration Form doc
FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc
Revised 04 27 2012
li f
ij
C H1
City of Miami Beach 1700 Convention Center Drive Miami Beach Florida 33139 www miamibeachfl gov
CITY CLERK Office
Rafael E Granada
Tel 305 673 741 1
City
Clerk
Fax 305 673 7254
11 11
LOBBYIST NAME
lobby on has been resolved I am
required to immediately notify the City Clerk s Office of lobbyist withdrawal in writing
In
once
addition
an
issue I have
registered
to
falls to timely file a Statement and in addition to any other penalties which may be
imposed as provided in Section 2 485 1 a fine of 50 00 a day shall be assessed for all
Statement
filed
after
the due date
Any lobbyist who fails to file the required Statement by April 30th 2012 shall be
s
Signa
F CLER
ALL
Zolt
Date
aFORMS
Lobbyist Michael J. Marrero

Thu, Sep 4, 2014 at 11:08

AM
To: "Granado, Rafael" <RafaelGranado@miamibeachfl.gov>

Cc: "Held, Gary" <garyheld@miamibeachfl.gov>, "Aguila, Raul"
4 September 2014 to Clerk of City of Miami Beach
Dear Mr. Granado:
Attached please find Michael J. Marrero's July 8 registration as lobbyist for 304
Ocean Drive property owner Sea Spray Development LLC. His registration appears
to be three months late, in violation of lobbying ordinance: he appears on the April 8
video of the April 8 Historic "Preservation" Board.
Perhaps there has been a clerical error in not recording a registration for April 8. If
not, then it is astonishing to me that he was allowed to testify under oath before the
Board, since officials there are required by the ordinance to exercise due diligence at least I recall the word "diligent" in the code - which would require checking
credentials in advance when a lobbyist signs a log before the hearing.
Furthermore, Mr. Marrero does not make the necessary disclosures of persons
holding directly or indirectly an interest in the LLC, a fact that arouses my suspicion
because he is an experienced lobbyist, doing a tremendous amount of business on
the beach, and is licensed by the Florida Bar; the ordinance and the registration form
itself clearly require the information; other registration forms filed by him, including
the example I attach hereto, his filing for 8421 Crespi LLC, include the required
information.
Furthermore, one inducement offered by developer David Arditi to city officials for
the spot zoning of 321 Ocean Drive across the street was his promise to cause 304
Ocean Drive to be developed with foreign funds obtained. As you will recall, two
lobbyists for 321 Ocean Drive, developer Joshua Benaim and architect James
Carse, also failed to provide information on the substantial interests persons held in
that property's owner, the managing member being a Delaware entity unregistered
at the time in Florida.
So now the failures to supply the required information appear to be a pattern rather
than coincidence; a pattern apparently contributed to by official negligence.
I do not understand why the clerks would have accepted the forms absent the
required information. Disclosure and its publicity are intended to help the public and
its investigators ascertain the identity of the natural persons involved in public
Page1of2
business and their sources of funds.

Indeed, this information, especially where foreign entities, foreign cash, and foreign
architects are involved, should be just as important to Board members as to whether
or not a design is "foreign" to some current historical context.
That is not to say that I believe that the developers are not "nice boys," as Frank Del
Vecchio has informed me. Given the fact that even nice boys next door are
occasionally arrested for serious crimes, I believe it is better to obtain as much
information as can be had about them.
Please let me know what steps will be taken to remedy these issues so that I may
inform my dozen or so constituents in Miami Beach.
Sincerely,
cc.
Raul Aguila, City Attorney
Gary Held, First Assistant City Attorney
Page2of2
Lr
MIAMI BEACH
entire
city
decision making
cmmission
lobbying
process
on
such
action
decision or recommendation that foreseeably will be heard or reviewed by the

employee engaged in
city board or committee

The term specifically includes the principal as well as any
The term Lobbyists has specific exclusions Please refer to Ordinance 2004 3435
or
activities
Marrero
NAME OF LOBBYIST
Bercow Radell
Michael
Last
Fernandez PA
200 South Biscayne Blvd
First
Number
305 374 5300
and
Street
M I
Suite 850 Miami FL
City
305 377 6222
TELEPHONE NUMBER
33131
State
Zip Code
brzoninolaw com
mmarrero
FAX NUMBER
EMAIL
I
Yair Wolff
NAME OF PRINCIPAUCLIENT
Sea
Spray Development LLC
3180
Number
TELEPHONE NUMBER
Stirling
and
Road
Hollywood
Street
FAX NUMBER
Florida
City
33021
State
Optional
EMAIL
Zip Code
Optional

Development Board Approvals for 304 Ocean Drive Miami Beach Florida
Issue to be lobbied Describe in detail
III CITY AGENCIES INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED

into
any
contractual
relationship
paid
or
unpaid
with
said
city
commissioner
or
from
personnel
12 months preceding such
person s commencement of service with the city to the present date stating the general nature of the subject contractual relationship
Sec 2 482
a 4 Full Name of Individual

title of person to be lobbied
Tanning
Department
B HPB BOA
City
and
Building
Commission
Contractual
and
Department Staff
None
as
None
necessary
Relationship
Explain
YES
NO
X
X
Sec 2 482 g Any Financial Familial or Professional Relationship

G
I t
Nil 101
cl IP
C Users clerhatl AppData Local Microsoft Windows Temporary Internet Files Content 0utlook 83LGQDDH Lobbyist Registration
Formrevised 5 30 2012 doc
DISCLOSURE OF TERMS AND AMOUNTS OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION DISCLOSE WHETHER HOURLY FLAT RATE OR OTHER
IV
A
LOBBYIST DISCLOSURE
Required
445 00
PRINCIPAL S DISCLOSURE OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION
REQUIRED
445 00

1
Issues
Yes
No
Are you lobbying on a present or pending bid for goods equipment or services or on a present or
award for aoods eauinment or service
pe
Development Issues
Yes
No
Are you lobbvina on a pending application for a Development Agreement with the City or application
in Section 2 481 above who only appears as a representative of a not for profit corporation or entity without
forth
special
compensation
or
reimbursement
for
the
appearance
direct
whether
or
indirect
to
express
support
of
or
opposition to any item shall register with the clerk as required by this section but shall not be required to pay any registration
fees
Yes
V
X No
OATH
LISTING LOBBYING EXPENDITURES
ME THE
AS WELL AS COMPENSATION RECEIVED
IN THE CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
PRECEDING
EXPENDITURES OR
Sign
I do solemnly swear that all of the

in Section 2 482 of the Miami B
foregoing fa
C
re
ure efLobbyist
a and correct and that I have read or am familiar with the provisions contained
all rep rting requirements
VI
Produced ID
odn
Form
P ersonall
known
Form
Lobbyist
SIGNATURE AND STAMP OF NOTARY

i
State of Florida
Sworn to nd
of
re of
Notarization
blic
of
Notary
Lobbyist
jj
State
2014
of
o
co

Sworn
d subscribed
is
Signature f
Notarizati n
Amount Paid
ay
ubli
MCR
Notary
of
fore
me
2014
of
State of Florida
signature
iy
Datq Paid

C Users clerhatl AppData Local Microsoft Windows
cto
Florida
No
coz
g
0
s signature
Yes
TO BE COMPLET D BY CITY CLERK S STAFFiON

Identification
3
3 X
eore me
of
o a
Miami Dade
L
subscrijjj
y
This
Sign
County
of
ZPersonally
K o
o
VII
Produced ID
Identification
of
Temporary Internet
Files Content Outlook 83LGQD
H Lobbyist Registration
CLE
istration Form doc
Revised 04 27 2012
AAIAMIBEACH
City
of
Miami Beach
1700 Convention Center Drive Miami Beach Florida 33139 www miamibeachfl gov
CITY CLERK Office

Rafael E
Tel
Granado
305 673 7411
City
Fax
Clerk
LOBBYIST NAME
I
that
understand
305 673 7254
Michael J
no
Marrero
later than February 28 of each year

I
of the Miami Beach
City Code with
to Section 2 485
pursuant
must file the following form

the City Clerk s Office for all
active lobbying issues

1
Failure to file these forms on a timely basis will result in my name being transmitted to the
Miami Dade County Commission on Ethics and for code violation evaluation
In
addition
lobbying
once an
on
issue I have
or for that
that issue
registered
principal
Office of lobbyist withdrawal in writing

Pursuant to Section 2 485
fails to timely file
imposed
the
City
to
lobby
on
has been
or I am no longer
resolved
I am required to immediately notify the City Clerk s

Clerk
shall
notify any lobbyist
or principal
who
a Statement and in addition to any other penalties which may be
in Section 2 485 1 a fine of

50 00 a day shall be assessed for all
CountY Commission on Ethics and Public
b c Trust of the failure of a lobb
lobbyist or principal
as provided

Any lobbyist
automatically
appeal
Signature
who
fails to file the required Statement

from lobbying until all fines are
suspended
he Mia
ade
County Commission
on
by April 30th 2012

paid
Ethics
and
shall
be
unless the fine has been

Public Trust
lc dl v
ate
CFormrevised
Users clerhatl
AppData Local Microsoft Windows Temporary Internet Files Content Outlook 83LGQDDH Lobbyist Registration
5 30 2012 doc
CV
kAs
till
LU
Nom
cc
lion
O
LL

1700 Convention Center Drive Miami Beach
FL 33139
1J112 39

Lobbyist
whether paid or not
means all persons employed or retained
decision
by
to
a principal who seeks
encourage
Apr
pas s age
def
Fr l rr
decision
recommendation of the City

entire decision making process on such action
decision or recommendation that foreseeably will be heard or reviewed by the
The term specifically includes the principal as well as any employee engaged in
city commission or a city board or committee
lobbying activities The term Lobbyists has specific exclusions Please refer to Ordinance 2004 3435
modification of
ordinance
any
action
resolution
or
Marrero
PA 200 South Biscayne Blvd

Number and Street
305
commissioner
action
any
J
M 1
First
Last
Fernandez
any
Michael
NAME OF LOBBYIST
Bercow Radell
of
374 5300
305
Suite 850 Miami
377 6222
Zip Code
mmarrerona brzoninglaw coni
FAX NUMBER
TELEPHONE NUMBER
33131
Florida
State
City
EMAIL
Pierre Elmaleh
NAME OF PRINCIPAL CLIENT
8421 Crespi LLC
407 Lincoln Rd Ste 9D Miami Beach
Number and Street
TELEPHONE NUMBER
FAX NUMBER
City
FL
33139
State
Zip Code
Optional
EMAIL
Optional
IDENTIFY ALL PERSONS HOLDING
See Attached
DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY A 5
See Attached
II SPECIFIC LOBBY ISSUE

Development Board Approvals for 8421 Crespi Boulevard Miami Beach
Issue to be lobbied
Describe in detail
Ill CITY AGENCIES INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED

into
contractual
any
paid
relationship
or
unpaid
with
said
city
commissioner
or
personnel
12
from
months
preceding
such
person s commencement of service with the city to the present date stating the general nature of the subject contractual relationship
Sec 2 482 a 4 Full Name of Individual and
YES
NO
Department
Planning
PB HPB BOA
City
and
Building
Department Staff
None
as
None
Commission
necessary
X
X
Sec 2 482 g Any Financial Familial or Professional Relationship
C Users clerhatl AppData Local Microsoft Windows Temporary Internet Files Content Outlook 83LGQDDH Lobbyist Registration
Signature
of
NA
Principal Client
VI
a
T
Produced ID
Produced ID
Form
Identification
of
Form
of
Identification
1z lu
Mill
14
Personally
known
Personally known Principal
Lobbyist
at
VII
so
State
st
of
Florida Count y
Sworscri
This
of
ed
before
rNization
wor
me
299 3
Sign
g
Nota
av
Miami Dade
ota rY
State
of
Florida
an
lorida Count v of Miami Dade

ubscri
d before
e
tiof
f Public Nota
o ariza io
signature
201
State of Florida
signature
TO BE COMPLETED BY CITY CLERK S STAFW MY

Annual
Registration fee
Yes
Amount Pai
1xv
MCR
Date Paid
Lobbyist Registration Form recei ed and verified b y

C Users
clerhatl
AppData Local Microsoft Window
Tempora
Internet Files Con ent Outlook 83LGQDDH Lobbyist Registration
City
CITY
ind
13civh
1700 Convention
305
11
lrmmdo
673 741 1
Miami Beach
Revised 04 27 2012
Horid I 33139
understand
pursuant
CM
City Clcrk
Fax
305 673 7254
LOBBYIST NAME
Center Drive
J F1 1K
Rakid
I d
Nli
of
Michael J
Marrero
that no later than February 28
of each
to Section 2 485 of the Miami Beach
City
must file the following form

with the City Clerk s Office for all
year
Code
active lobbying issues

Failure to file these forms on a timely basis will result in my name being transmitted to the
Miami Dade County Commission on Ethics and for code violation evaluation
In
addition
once an
issue I have
registered
lobbying on that issue or for that principal

Office of lobbyist withdrawal in writing
lobby on has been resolved or I am no longer

I am required to immediately notify the City Clerk s
to
City Clerk shall notify any lobbyist or principal who

fails to timely file a Statement and in addition to any other penalties which may be
Pursuant to Section 2 485
Any
lobbyist
automatically
appealed
who
Signature
the
fails to file the
suspende
to the M
from
ad
required
Statement
all fines are
by
April 30th
2012
shall
paid unless the fine has been

lobbying until
County Commission on Ethics and Public Trust
Date
C Users clerhAtl AppData Local Microsoft Windows Temporary Internet Files Content Outlook 83LGQDDH Lobbyist Registration
Forrnrevised 5 30 2012 doc
be
Ownership Breakdown
Crespi
LLC
Sunstone Brokers
Rebond LLC
50
50
Sunstone Brokers
Pierre Elmaleh
100
Rebond LLC
Michel Besnier
100
Miscellaneous Cash Receipt

CITY OF MIAMI BEACH
Cash
0 Credit Card
check
20
Received
A1
of
kC
Alf
Address
For
Ilya
pt
liq
ra
4f
Office of Finance Director
THIS INFORMATION MUST BE COMPLETED
By
Account Number
Pr P arer
Dept
EXT
40
MIAMI MIRROR TRUE LOBBYING REFLECTIONS
FILE:321OCEANENRIQUENORTEN
August19,2014
To:DavidArthurWalters
Cc:"Aguila,Raul""Prieto,Silvia""Hatfield,Liliam"
Thankyou.WewillreviewandcontactLobbyisttoupdate.
Regards,
MIAMIBEACH
RafaelE.Granado,Esq.,CityClerk
CITYCLERK'SOFFICE
1700ConventionCenterDrive,
MiamiBeach,FL33139
19August2014
RafaelGranado,Clerk
CITYOFMIAMIBEACH
Subject:2011JoshuaBenaimDefectiveLobbyistRegistration
Mr.Granado:
AttachedpleasefindPDFoflobbyistregistrationformnamingJoshuaBenaimaslobbyist.
Bysomestrangecoincidence,hisprincipalhappenstobethesameasMr.Carse's,namely,the
Delawareentity321OceanHoldingLLC.AlthoughithasanaddressonBrickell,itapparentlyhas
nolegalstandinginFloridasinceitisnotlistedonourSecretaryofState'swebsiteasoftoday.
Would you please ask this lobbyist to amend his application to name the persons with
controllingandownershipinterests?Irealizethesameentityisprincipalforbothlobbyists,but
I wish to compare their separate answers with the information I have for consistency before
publication.
Thankyou!
DavidArthurWalters
August15,2014
To:DavidArthurWalters
Cc:"Aguila,Raul""Prieto,Silvia""Hatfield,Liliam"
GoodmorningMr.Walters,
Thankyouforbringingthismattertoourattention.
Wewillrequestthelobbyisttoamendhisapplicationtoanswerallquestions.
Regards,
MIAMIBEACH
RafaelE.Granado,Esq.,CityClerk
15August2014
RafaelGranado
CLERK
CityofMiamiBeach
Subject:PRRre9July2012JamesW.CarseLobbyistRegistration
DearMr.Granado:
GoodDay,Sir.
Attached please find the sworn Lobbyist Registration Form executed by lobbyist James W.
Carse,an architect employed by Enrique Nortens New York firm, TenArquitectos, and by an
officeroftheprincipal,321OceanHoldingLLC,aDelawareentitythenunregisteredinFlorida,
beingthemanagingmemberoftheownerofthepropertyat321OceanDrive,knownbythe
projectnameof321OceanEnriqueNorten.Theidentitiesofbothpersonswereverifiedbythe
notarybytheirNewYorkdriverslicenses.
Asyouknow,theMiamiBeachCodeofOrdinances,Sec.2482(c),Registration,mandatesthat,
If the lobbyist represents a corporation, partnership or trust, the chief officer, partner or
beneficiary shall also be identified. Without limiting the foregoing, the lobbyist shall also
identifyallpersonsholding,directlyorindirectly,afivepercentormoreownershipinterestin
suchcorporation,partnership,ortrust.
For all intents of purposes of this clause, a limited liability company is considered as a
corporationorpartnershipsinceitisasortofhybridofthetwotypesofbusinessentity,and
DelawarelistsLLCsasatypeofcorporation.
TheLobbyistRegistrationFormitselfdoesnotidentifythechiefofficer,partnerorbeneficiary
andallpersonsholding,directlyorindirectly,afivepercentormoreownershipinterestinsuch
corporation,partnership,ortrust,eventhoughtheformitselfclearlydemandstheinformation,
andtheoathunderpenaltiesofperjuryassertsfamiliarityofthesignatorieswiththelobbying
code:IdosolemnlyswearthatalloftheforegoingfactsaretrueandcorrectandthatIhave
readoramfamiliarwiththeprovisionscontainedinSection2482oftheMiamiBeachCityCode
and611reportingrequirements.
It appears to me that an incomplete form absent that information of great public interest is
tantamounttoafailuretoregistereventhoughitwasacceptedandinitialedbyacityclerk.
WhereforethisismyChapter119requestforanyswornLobbyistRegistrationFormthathasall
theinformation,trueatthattime,asrequiredbytheordinanceandtheformitself.
Intheeventthatyouhavenosuchform,andifIamnotmistakenastothelaw,Iwillappreciate
youradviceaswhatactionyouwilltaketoobtainaproperlyfilledoutformposthaste,orto
refer the matter to the Miami Dade Commission on Ethics and Public Trust as per Sec. 2485
Listofexpenditures;feedisclosure;reportingrequirements,(e)Thecityclerkshallnotifythe
MiamiDade County Commission on Ethics and Public Trust of the failure of a lobbyist (or
principal)tofileeitherofthereportsreferenced above[registrationandexpenditure]and/or
paytheassessedfinesafternotification.
Although I am not required to disclose my identity or intent for making this request, please
knowthatmyinterestissimplythepublicityoftheinformation.Ihadadvocatedthepublication
ofthatkindofinformation,notknowingthatlegislationalreadymandatedit.
BestRegards,
DavidArthurWalters
IAMIBEACH
M
commission or a city board or committee The term specifically includes the principal as well as any employee engaged in lobbying
activities The term Lobbyists has specific exclusions Please refer to Ordinance 2004 3435
NAME OF LOBBYIST
Last
First
f1 8 kiLae
81
Oc
@C5
umber and
Street
6
C3
TELEPHONE NUMBER
I
M
City
Ma
State
NefV
ch
FAX NUMBER
33 3
Zip Code
Oaidl o
EMAIL
Please notify this office if your contact information changes address phone or e
mail address
I
C 02
cl
Number and Street
TELEPHONE NUMBER
City
FAX NUMBER
State
Optional
Zip Code
EMAIL Optional
Fill out this section if principal is a Corporation Partnership or Trust Section 2

482 c
c
IDENTIFY ALL PERSONS HOLDING DIRECTLY OR
INDIRECTLY
A 5 OR MORE OWNERSHIP INTEREST IN SUC
CORPORA9N
rri
SPECIFIC LOBBY ISSUE

n
d t t
Issue to be lobbied
Describe
ry
32
JC
A
ov
in de
T
nl
CITY AGENCIES INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED
Pursuant to City Code Section 2482

4 include the commissioner or personnel sought to be lobbied and whether the
a
1bbb91t has entered
into any contractual relationship paid or unpaid with said city commissioner or personnel from 12 months preceding such person
s
commencement of service with the city to the present date stating the general nature of the subject contractual relationship
Sec 2482
4 Full Name of Individual and
a
Contractual
Relationship Explain
YES
NO
OA
by
I en
Pursuant to C
ty
relationship
r other relationship giving rise to an a pearance of an impropriety with any current city commissioner or city personnel who is
Code Section 2 482

g
Every regist
t shall be required to state the extent of any business financial familial or professional
Sec 2482
g Any Financial Familial or Professional Relationship
IV
DISCLOSURE OF TERMS AND AMOUNTS OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION DISCLOSE WHETHER HOURLY FLAT RATE OR
OTHER
LOBBYIST DISCLOSURE
Required
B PRINCIPAL
S DISCLOSURE OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION
Rquired
The
estn
tI
C utit dam
1C
UV
following information must be answered

Pursuant to Miami Beach City Code Section 2
488 Entitled Prohibited Campaign Contributions By Lobbyists On Procurement
Issues
Yes
l No
Pursuant to Miami Beach City Code 2 490 Entitled Prohibited Campaign Contributions By Lobbyists On Real Estate
Dev opment Issues
Yes
No
change of zoning map designation or change to the City
s Future Land Use Map
Pursuant to Miami Beach City Code 2484 h Any person except those exempt from the definition of lobbyist as set forth in
Section 2
481 above who only appears as a representative of a not for profit corporation or entity without special
comp
sation or reimbursement for the appearance whether direct or indirect to express support of or opposition to any
Yes
V
No Are you representing a notforprofit corporation or entity without special compensation or reimbursement
ON FEBRUARY 28th OF EACH YEAR EACH LOBBYIST SHALL SUBMIT TO THE CITY CLERK A SIGNED STATEMENT UNDER
THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR
A STATEMENT
LL BE
ILED
N IF THERE HAVE BEEN NO EXPENDITURES OR

oe
I do solemnly swear that

in Section 2 482 of the M
of the
foregoing
m Beach Cit
facts
are
Sign
ure
true
Id c rect and that I have read or am familiar with the provisions contained
obbyist
e and all reporting requirements
io
Signature of PrincipalClien
VI
LOBBYIST IDENTIFICA
El
ID
Y 61
ON
CA
IQ
aProduced IDS DI
Personally
VII
known
Lobbyist
Personally
ptttiltttiiiiel
SSio
NOT
c

Sworn to and subscribed before me
This
201
day of
DD 832367
GOMMiSSIpN
Principal
a 1I d
D8
State of Florida Count of Miami ga
236
3
Sworn and subscribed before me
mro
9o
I
This
j day of
r
z
known
tllltiiiii
e
i
2011O
Ga
ti
e
ll
9iit
ub
Si nature of Public Notary

St a
Florida
Notarization of Lobbyists signature
i
U
A
QC STATE
41
gi91ti110
16
Signatur
of
ub
ublic
Notary
State of
lorida
Notarization of Principal
s signature
TO BE COMPLET D BY CITY CLERK

S STAFF ON
Y
Annual
Registration
fee
Lobbyist Registration
F
No
Amount Paid
Form received and verified by
Yes
5
t
1VICR
CLER ALL a FORMS LOBBYIST FORMS Lobbyist Annual Registration Form

doc
ir
Date Paid
1
Revise
11
11
CA
MIAMJBEACH
BEACH
City of Miami Beach 1700 Convention Center Drive Miami Beach Florida 33139 www
gov
miamibeachfl
CITY CLERK Office
Tel 673
305
7411
CityClerk@miamibeachfl
gov
Fax 673
305
7254
LOBBYIST NAME
understand that no later than February 28th of each year I must file the following
form pursuant to Section 2485 of the Miami Beach City Code with the City Clerk
s
Office for all active lobbying issues
1
Lobbyist Expenditure and Compensation Form
Failure
file these forms
on a timely basis will result in my name being transmitted to the

MiamiDade County Commission on Ethics and for code violation evaluation
In
to
addition
issue I have
registered
lobby on has been resolved I am required

to immediately notify the City Clerk
s Office of lobbyist withdrawal in writing
gna
once an
i
ers
ure
to
D te
MIA
IBEACH
commission or a city board or committee

activities
The term
Lobbyists
First
T0 V AVZ Jx05
54
ll5
6ZO
Last
NAME OF LOBBYIST
Zliz
The term specifically includes the principal as well as any employee engaged in lobbying
Number
and
ti1EW Ok
A4e
Street
M 1
NV
10610 3
State
City
Zip Code
S
oix4 y
FAX NUMBER
TELEPHONE NUMBER
ca
EMAIL
I
32 1
CtAIU
7O0
Q
y3
Number
305
534
1a I
A t
and
Street
State
City
Zip Code
6
FAX NUMBER
TELEPHONE NUMBER
Optional
EMAIL
Optional
Fill out this section If principal is a Corporation Partnership or Trust Section 2 482 c

3Z 1
yel V E
Issue to be lobbied
np JF rf
Describe in detail
ui CITY AGENCIEVINDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED

into any contractual relationship paid or unpaid with said city commissioner or personnel from 12 months preceding such person s
commencement of service with the city to the present date stating the
Sec 2 482
4 Full Name
of
Individual
eneral nature of the subject contractual relationship

Contractual Relationship
and
Explain
YES
NO
M0
0
1
Sec 2 482
Any
Financial Familial
or
Professional
J A 111
Relationship
I
loll
0 9
F CLER
ALL a FORM S LOBBYIST FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc

J
D19CLOSUVE OF TERMS AND AMOUNTS OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION
IV
Required
LOBBYIST DISCLOSURE
i4r
DISCLOSE WHETHER HOURLY FLAT RATE OR OTHER
12L
PRINCIPAL S DISCLOSURE OF LOBBYIST COMPENSAT ON

UO
REQUIRED
P t l tt1 JT
M V r L

1
Issues
YesiNo
Development Issues
Yes
tNo
Ye4No
THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR A STATEMENT SHALL BE FILED EVEN IF THERE HAVE BEEN NO EXPENDITURES OR
in Section 2 482 of the Miami Beach City Code and 611 reporting requirements
VI
4 Lic
l
AeuJ
YP
Produced ID
roduced
ID
Personally
known
2K
Lobbyist
Personally
Principal
known
State
of
Florida
Sworn to
County
befgre
me
Signature
f Public
on of
St
Lobbyist
s s
a of
State
Sworn and subscribed bQfore me

Thi
Florida
of
No
Amount Paid
day
of
Wiz
2012
Signature
Public Nota
State of Floridan
Notarization of Principal s signature
nature
yes
County
Florida
TO BE COMPLETED BY CITY CLERK S STA F O

Miami Dade
wD
2012
This
Notariza
Miami Dade
of
and subscribed
g
U O M J
QR4
VII
Lic
Form o Identification
MCR
Date Paid

F
CLER
F CLE R
ALL
aFORMS
ALL
LOBBYIST FORMS
a FORM
Lobbyist Annual Registration Form doc
S LOB BYI ST FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc
ReviS d 04 27 2012
MIANAIBEACH
City of Miami Beach 1700 Convention Center Drive Miami Beach Florida 33139 www miamibeochfl gov
CITY CLERK Office
Rafael E Granado
City
Tel 305 673 741 1
Fax 305 673 7254
Clerk
CityClerkCmiamibeachfl gov
LOBBYIST NAME
1
In addition once an issue I have registered to lobby on has been resolved or I am no

longer lobbying on that issue or for that principal I am required to immediately notify
the City Clerk s Office of lobbyist withdrawal in writing

fails to timely file a Statement and in addition to any other penalties which may be
Any
lobbyist
who
fails to file the
required
Statement
by
April 30th
2012
shall be
20l2
Date
Signature
CADocuments
and
Settings
clermarm
Local Settings
Temporary
Internet Files OLK11 Lobbyist Registration Formrevised 5 30 2012 doc

Miami Beach Lobbyist Registration Irregularities

Uploaded by

Document Information

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Miami Beach Lobbyist Registration Irregularities

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

MIAMI MIRROR TRUE REFLECTIONS

David Arthur Walters

Defective Filing on TRG ALASKA Defective Lobbyist Registration

SEPTEMBER 27, 2014

David Arthur Walters <miamimirror@gmail.com>

Defective Filing on TRG ALASKA Defective Lobbyist Registration

Granado, Rafael <RafaelGranado@miamibeachfl.gov>

Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at

To: David Arthur Walters <miamimirror@gmail.com>

Additional Defective Filing on TRG ALASKA Defective Lobbyist Registration

Tue, Sep 23, 2014 at 11:34

To: "Granado, Rafael" <RafaelGranado@miamibeachfl.gov>

commission or a city board or committee

has specific exclusions

Please refer to Ordinance 2004 3435

BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS

BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS

IDENTIFY ALL PERSONS HOLDING DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY A 5

OR MORE OWNERSHIP INTEREST IN SUCH CORPORATION

SPECIFIC LOBBY ISSUE

III CITY AGENCIES INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED

Contractual Relationship Explain

LOBBYIST FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc

The following information must be answered

SIGNATURE UNDER OATH

pach City Code and all reporting requirements

SIGNATURE AND STAMP OF

EXPIRES April 13 2013

Personally known Princ

Bonded Thru Notary Public Underwriters

State of Florida County of Mi

TO BE COMPLETED BY CITY CLERK S STAFF ONLY

Lobbyist Registration Form received and verified by

Lobbyist Annual Registration For

LOBBYIST FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc

Tel 305 673 741 1

CityClerk @miamibeachfl gov

Fax 305 673 7254

the City Clerk shall notify any lobbyist or principal who

LOBBYIST FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc

City of Miami Beach Office of the City Clerk

has specific exclusions

Please refer to Ordinance 2004 3435

BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS

BUSINESS NAME AND ADDRESS

IDENTIFY ALL PERSONS HOLDING

OR MORE OWNERSHIP INTEREST IN SUCH CORPORATION

ii SPECIFIC LOBBY ISSUE

nI CITY AGENCIES INDIVIDUALS TO BE LOBBIED

into any contractual relationship

commencement of service with the ci to the resent date stating the

eneral nature of the subject contractual relationshi

LOBBYIST FORMS Lobbyist Registration Form doc

DISCLOSURE OF TERMS AND AMOUNTS OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION DI

CLOSE WHETHER HOURLY FLAT RATE OR OTHER

PRINCIPAL S DISCLOSURE OF LOBBYIST COMPENSATION

The following information must be answered

SIGNATURE UNDER OATH

THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR

A STATEMENT SHALL BEFUZD EVEN IF THEM HAVE BEEN NO EXPENDITURES OR