Best Practices Department of School Education, Government of Haryana
I. Background to the Project in which the Best Practice is emerging (Why was/is this program done? What happened in the project and why?).
Background: The Government Schools in Haryana catering the economically backward and marginalised sections of the society under the ambit of Department of School Education, Government of Haryana, have over the years tried to counter the problems of low attendance among students and a lack of order in the academic calendar. In a number of diagnostic workshops and studies, it was found that teachers had to often delay the to-be taught curriculum or repeat the curriculum covered in the initial months of the academic session because a considerable percentage of the students joined the school much later into the academic session as opposed to joining school on April 1 when the schools reopen for the new academic session. As a result, almost 45 teaching days of the academic session were lost because of low turnout of the students in the initial months of the academic session. This became a critical problem for the Department. The primary reasons behind the low turnout in the initial months were found out to be: 1. Harvesting-season: A number of children were being asked to join in the harvest to help their parents with the work. Girls would also be asked to look after younger siblings in case the mothers were required to help in the harvest as well. 2. Indifference of parents: Parents were also found to not be proactive about the admissions of their children and were also less involved in the school affairs. 3. Lack of change in school environment (leading to boredom): The students in the schools were not exposed to newer environments of learning and there was limited implementation of the suggested innovations in pedagogy in the classrooms. The lead to boredom in the classrooms. 4. Lack of attractive reasons to go to school: With a lack of a constant push from the parents and a straitjacketed approach to learning, the schools in the state had also begun to lose the attractiveness for the students thereby resulting in low attendance. In light of the above conditions, educationists at SCERT Gurgaon and DIETs across the state under the guidance of the Planning and Management Team designed a programme that to create Page 2 of 9
a positive academic environment in the schools. The focus of the design was to make the education child-centred, activity based and creatively inspiring to make the schools more attractive to the children and parents and help in an increase in school enrolment and attendance. This program was called the Class Readiness Program. Objectives: In line with the guidelines of the National Curriculum Framework and the National Policy on Education, the designed Classroom Readiness Program (CRP) of the Government of Haryana had the following objectives: 1. To recreate the learning environment in the schools by making it more participatory 2. To raise the motivation levels of the teachers 3. To give impetus to project and activity based learning 4. To help the students localise their education 5. To make children familiar with their new class-room environment 6. To provide maximum learning days as per RTE Act, 2009 7. To develop a new curriculum inclusive of the existing curriculum 8. Assess human and infrastructural resources of the school and ensure optimal utilisation of the same 9. To increase student-strength 10. To provide opportunity to the students to display their hidden talents and skills
Activities: The following activities were planned and implemented in the schools as part of the Class Readiness Program:
1. Library Week: With a standardised curriculum that mandates a certain number of books for each academic session, it was found out that the students in the schools did not enthusiastically pursue reading beyond the prescribed curriculum. So in order to develop the habit of reading among the students and open their imagination to a whole new world, Library Week was made part of the CRP. Thorough this programme all the schools ensured that each student was provided at least one book per day from the school library. The students would read the books and present a brief summary of the book to the rest of the class. These follow up activities of the Library Week ensured that students gained confidence and honed their talents.
2. Handwriting Week: With a dual focus of improving both the Handwriting of the students and their skills to express themselves better through the means of the pen, Page 3 of 9
Handwriting Week is an integral part of the CRP. To build a generation that is better equipped to understand and express, the modules targeted at handwriting development were also designed to help the teachers and the students to work together on the quality of expression.
3. Yoga Sessions: Aimed at achieving physical and spiritual acuity, every day yoga sessions were organised through broadcasted lessons on Edusat in all the schools. Morning assemblies in all the schools started with yoga sessions during CRP.
4. Assessing Learning Level: There is an urgent need to implement Multi Grade Multi Level teaching in the government schools in the state as it has been seen that students studying in the same class demonstrate starkly different learning levels. CRP, through different activities, helped the teachers identify and group the students as per their learning levels so that more individual-focused learning could take place.
5. Quest for Knowledge: CRP is also designed to develop motivation among students to seek knowledge outside of their text books. Hence, as part of CRP, students were assigned eminent personalities every week to research and make presentations upon. Sometimes, a quiz would also be held in the classroom. This activity has shown a considerable improvement in the persistence levels of the students while tackling problems.
6. Educational Tours: Localising education is as important for the students as it is for them to understand the texts they read in the larger context. Hence to bring around such a local understanding of theoretical knowledge, educational tours to local factories/industries, banks, post offices, local hospitals, parks, grain markets, vegetable markets, bus-stand, railway-station, police-station etc. were organised for making students aware of the government/social system around them.
7. Communication Skills: Integrating various activities under CRP that pushed students to take initiative are the modules and activities designed for enhancing communication skills of the students. These activities included basic communication practices like speaking on phone and greeting elders and officials as well as public speaking and presentation.
8. General Knowledge: To help students gain awareness about current affairs and general knowledge, sessions were held in every class as per need and level of class. Outdoor activities like seed-gathering, collection of pictures, plant-leaves, post stamps, coins etc. were also promoted. Grant for two newspapers per school was sanctioned and students Page 4 of 9
were encouraged to read daily news in the morning assembly and write the same on the notice-board of the school.
9. Film festival: Just after the Mid-Day Meal, television films were screened for the students in all the schools. The aim of this activity was to create awareness among the students. As a result, students were shown moral based children-films, inspirational films, and awareness films for children with special needs.
Documentation of Good Practices and Lessons Learnt:
The documentation of good practices and lessons learnt was done as follows:
1. CRP Register: All schools were required to maintain a CRP register that recorded daily activities conducted for each class during CRP. Planners were also provided to teachers as part of the modules to help them plan and record their activities better.
2. Project Work: As part of the CRP, students were asked to develop projects and models based on their learning during the period of the CRP. These projects and models are saved every year as part of documentation.
3. Workbooks: A record is maintained by the students as well through their CRP files and scrap books which showcase the work done by each individual student during the period of CRP.
4. Media Coverage: The CRP program has been well covered by both the state and the local media. A record of the same through newspaper cuttings and web clippings is maintained at the state level.
5. Social Media: Teachers and school heads are also encouraged to share the work done in their schools through social media like Facebook and Google Plus. A record of the same is maintained at the state department.
II. What is the Good Practice from the project and Why?
1. What is the Good Practice? The processes followed during the Class Readiness Program, stand out as a Good Practice. It is aimed at delivering an educational environment in the schools of the state Page 5 of 9
that is child and teacher oriented and encourages participative learning. The program was, at all times, focused at improving the student-teacher relationships while providing a platform for burgeoning creativity through morale building and community engagement. For the success of the program, a state resource group was constituted that monitored and streamlined all the activities under CRP from development of teacher modules to implementation of the program. At the district level, committees were set up which were headed by the District Education Officers and had the participation of district and block level officials including the DIET Principals and the Block Education Officers. As part of this system, 3 state level trainings and 4 division level trainings were conducted. At the block level, all the 119 blocks underwent 1 training each while all the 1500 clusters were also similarly trained through 1 training for each cluster. Besides these trainings, the Block Resource Persons and Assistant Block Resource Coordinators were trained at SCERT Gurgaon for CRP. The activities that were then conducted were widely covered by the local and state media as every senior secondary school organised two or more educational tours for its students while motivational lectures and competitions were organised in all the school on a weekly basis. This resulted in solving the critical problem of the loss of 45 academic days due to low attendance at the beginning of the academic session and helped create a better student-teacher relationship for participatory learning.
2. Key Outcomes of Applying Best Practice: Some of the key outcomes of the implementing the CRP can be divided into diagnostics and solutions. To counter the problem of absenteeism in the initial months of the academic session, a number of surveys were conducted which were followed through with workshops and seminars to develop a holistic understanding of problems of the school education at the grassroots. This diagnosis process helped the Department identify the problems which could be addressed as part of CRP. The problems identified included low teacher morale, lack of energetic environment of the school, low participation among the students and the communities and a lack of academic nous among those who monitor the schools. Hence solutions were developed which included: a) Content Creation: National level organisations like the NCERT were incorporated in defining the purpose of the content and developing it to suit the needs of the teachers and the students of the state. b) Innovation: Innovative teaching practices were developed as part of the CRP. These practices were in sync with the Learning Level goals of the students of each class. For example, as part of the English language, special focus was laid on developing oral skills of students. Through poems and symbols, basic instructions were taught to the children. Alphabets were taught through various patterns as opposed to rote learning. These patterns were also used in developing an understanding of more complex words. Similar patterns were also used in Hindi for developing grammar and spelling skills among the students. Vocabulary for both languages was developed through Page 6 of 9
puzzles, jumbled words and other games. Under EVS, special effort was made by certain schools wherein the best practices stood out. For example, one school held the elections of the gram panchayats in the school to help the students understand the electoral process of the gram panchayats. Another school stood out by creating the whole banking structure inside the school with all the concerned stakeholders. c) Art as a Tool for Learning: Under CRP, art was identified as a special tool of learning. To teach Mathematics, kids were enabled to use collage material and beads to introduce them to numbers, positive and negative space, classification, and sequencing and pattern recognition. To increase general knowledge, students were asked to create had made journals wherein students used paper, paper bags and collage paper to create journal covers, pages and binding. Various history lessons were also taught in schools through the help of drama and theatre. It was seen through these activities that children love to practice art and it helps them attain an authentic medium of self-expression. d) Community Engagement: Creating ownership among the community of the government schools was understood to be an important factor in developing a more accountable system driven towards academic excellence. By involving community assets and important public spaces as part of the learning process, the community was engaged beyond mere functions and administrative procedures of the schools but also in a direct relation with the students of the schools. e) Teacher Motivation: The programme was able to act as an initiative to plug the ever widening gap between the students and the teachers. Teachers on realizing that their efforts are being recognized at a state and district level, have been very motivated to show their capabilities and there is a certain degree of healthy competition that has been sparked between them and their peers. f) Attendance: As compared with the previous years there has been a marked improvement in the student attendance figures due to this programme. Through informal talks it has also been realized that teacher absenteeism, which is a huge problem that plagues our countrys education system, has also seen a reasonable improvement in the schools.
3. Critical Success Factors in Leading to the Best Practice: a) Volunteer Groups: Volunteer groups from within the Department were created at the district level. These groups were called the Shiksha Diksha Groups. They were comprised of both District and Block level officials as well as school heads and teachers. This led to a greater ownership of the program and with proper support of the Department, the enthusiasm levels for implementation of the program remained high throughout. b) Social Media: Through online social media like Facebook, teachers got an opportunity to engage with the wider community and provide feedback to the state for Page 7 of 9
improving delivery and monitoring mechanisms. Any wrong doings were also brought to light and necessary actions were taken. Looking at the success of this program on the social media, the Department is also looking at using similar means in other processes. c) Crowd Sourcing: Teachers also used the social media to engage with each other and post their problems while implementing the CRP. Solutions and other creative ideas at tackling problems and ensuring constant student interest in the classrooms were regularly exchanged. d) Resource Optimization: Instead of dedicating more human and monetary resources, the CRP was targeted at optimizing the utilization of the existing resources. This removed the challenge for the teachers and students to get used to new resources while it enabled the creation of a new holistic educational environment from the old one. e) Training: To change the outlook of the monitors and the school heads towards the students and their education, comprehensive and timely trainings were conducted for them
4. Key Conditions for the Good Practice: a) Research: Before starting the journey for transformation in teaching processes, it is essential to understand and localise the problems. CRP was drafted as a result of intensive surveys and workshops conducted by the Department. The finding from these exercises helped in not only identifying the problems but also the kind of solutions that work and the ones that havent worked. This provided the scope to develop better solutions specifically tailored to local problems. b) Mobilisation and Communication: Any state level program relies heavily on the right kind of mobilisation and appropriate and specific communication for its success. Block level resources were mobilised months in advance and trainings through master trainers were provided at all the levels. To create enthusiasm among all the stakeholders involved, massive advertising of the program through Radio and local Television channels was also carried out. c) Constant Support Mechanism: Through social media and interactive processes on the ground, teachers and schools heads should be supported on a constant basis. Too often, because of lack of power or resources, teachers have felt helpless. Dedicated effort was made at improving the support system by hiring block level professionals for academic support in the form of Block Resource Persons. BRPs provide constant feedback to the teachers and help them in innovating their teaching practices. BRPs are also encouraged to use social media in guiding those teachers who may not have an online presence.
5. Key Initiatives to be Taken: Page 8 of 9
a) Module Design: The modules for CRP were designed in sync with the Learning Level Outcomes for the students of every class. Special effort was made in ensuring that these modules were made interactive in nature so as to help increase student- teacher interaction in the classroom. Hence these modules were prepared in a way that they were both teacher oriented and student oriented. b) Regular Visits: School visits were made a priority during this program wherein officials and teams from the state level visited schools to encourage the teachers and help them perform better. This resulted in an increased translation of the focus of CRP from the state to the school level. c) Rewards: Independent committees were set up to evaluate and recognise the best performing schools under CRP. In a special event, these schools were also felicitated by the Honourable Chief Minister of Haryana.
6. Why could it be replicable elsewhere? a) Participatory: One of the constant imperatives of quality school education is to increase student participation in the classroom activities. CRP, as a program, has been intrinsically evolved on the ideals of participative teaching and participative learning. While there may be geographical differences, there are basic tenets and ideals that all classrooms share. Following the CRP model could help build school education in a holistic manner. b) Bottom Up: All the activities of the CRP have been designed in a way that the flow of action is always bottom up. The program in itself was designed based on grassroots study and feedback and is being continuously evolved through the support of teachers and the community engagement. c) Low Cost: The effort of Department, while implementing CRP, was not at providing new resources but at providing new mechanisms to teacher and school heads to use the old resources in a new way. Hence the cost incurred on the program is minimal and a number of states through limited budgetary provisions could implement this program effectively.
7. How could it be useful for other Programs? a) Child Oriented: Any educational program could take a leaf out of the CRP booklet in order to design a curriculum that is child oriented. Understanding the needs of the individual student is at the centre of implementing the program. These techniques, which are imparted to the teachers, have been developed by educationists and child psychologists and work well in diversified classrooms. b) Scale: CRP was implemented in close to 15,000 schools in Haryana. The processes of CRP were the main reasons as to why such a scale could be achieved so efficiently. In larger states as well, with proper support mechanism, a CRP styled program could be implemented. Page 9 of 9
c) Knowledge Base: CRP works not only because of high quality modules and trainings but also because of the continuous monitoring and feedback mechanisms that help create a knowledge base for the state through which various strategies are improvised and evolved. Such a knowledge base is not only useful for improving the CRP in particular but also the newer initiatives of the Department.
8. What would you tell the designers and implementers of other programs to look out for when applying this best practice? a) Guidelines: In any new effort designed to improve the education system, it is important to keep in mind the guidelines of the National Curriculum Framework and the National Policy on Education. Both these documents demonstrate well the desired education environment for a child and these guidelines combined with the feedback from the ground can help develop robust strategies for school education. b) Focus on Specific Problems: While doing diagnostics, one can come across a number of problems. However, not all problems can be fixed through a single program. Hence objectives of the program need to be specified and specific problems should be addressed. c) Strengthen Grassroots Support: Haryana Government, through its Block Resource Persons, has provided for the teachers in the schools a constant support mechanism. For such a program to work grassroots support is essential and all district, block and village level need to be involved in order to create a robust system that works for the teacher and eventually for the children.