Logic Model Topic Evaluation Questions Indicators Data Source Activities Create partnership with pharmacies (redeem vouchers)
Are pharmacies experiencing any difficulties with the voucher system? If yes, what are the difficulties? How can we improve the voucher system?
# of partnerships with pharmacies challenges identified Survey Conduct weekly quit smoking groups in each office Why are groups implemented in some offices and not in others? Do clients actually want group support? Why or why not? # of group sessions held in each office
Records Key informant interviews Focus groups Dispense Nicotine Replacement Therapy vouchers How many vouchers have been distributed? Are the vouchers being redeemed by participants?
# of vouchers dispensed and redeemed Records Key Informant interviews Create referral link with partners How can we improve the referral system? Which offices receive more referrals and why? Why are some partners referring more than others? # of referrals suggestions on ways to improve the system received
Survey Counselors participate in TEACH training Have all counselors received their TEACH certification? # of employees who obtained TEACH certification Records Follow up with all clients at 6 months (from quit date) Do quit smoking attempts and rate of abstinence differ from one office to other? What are the elements that encourage participants to make a quit attempt and maintain their abstinence? # of quit attempts # of short term quits (1 week) # of medium term quits (2 months) # of long term quits (6 months +) 6-month follow up survey Focus groups individual case studies Outputs Strategic priorities and partners to be determined by steering committee # of partnerships Records Training & technical assistance Does the TEACH training certification adequately meet the needs of the trainers? # of employees who obtained TEACH certification Records Key Informant Interviews Community, and group based programs and services to be determined by steering committee Range and type of programs # of programs offered review of community programs Enactment of cessation policies to be determined by steering committee # of cessation policies review of community programs/ policies Local media campaign Is the program reaching the target audience? # of clients (all smokers with a special focus on mental health, lower SES and blue collar workers Focus Groups Key Informant Interviews Group 1: Quit Smoking Program- Data Matrix
Immediate Outcomes Increase awareness of the risks of smoking & the benefits of quitting to be determined by steering committee individuals can identify the benefits participant quiz Increase awareness of the availability of evidence- based cessation initiatives
to be determined by steering committee knowledge of programs participant quiz
Increase number and reach of evidence-based cessation initiatives especially among low SES and other high-risk populations
Is the program reaching the target audience? # of clients (all smokers with a special focus on mental health, lower SES and blue collar workers Focus Groups Key Informant Interviews Increase the proportion of smokers contemplating, preparing & taking action to quit Is the program meeting the needs of the target audience? # of clients who have a quit plan Focus Groups Key Informant Interview Intermediate Outcomes Increase number of quit attempts What is the average number of participants that make a quit attempt. # of clients that make a quit attempt. Records 6-month participant follow up survey. Reduce average cigarette consumption of smokers What is the percentage of clients that reduced their cigarette consumption? # of clients that reduce their Records 6-month participant follow up survey Ultimate Outcome Reduction in smoking in Eastern Ontario Districts in order to eliminate tobacco- related illness and death What is the percentage of clients that have quit for 5 year period? # of clients that reported a 5 year abstinence. 5 year follow up survey