seemingly without boundariesa time of jet planes, space travel and the Internetthe early years of the 21st have showed us the limits of our small world. Regional blackouts remind us that the flow of energy we used to take for granted may be in tight supply. The once mighty Colorado River, tapped by thirsty metropolises of the desert West, no longer reaches the ocean. Oil is so hard to find that new wells extend many kilometers underneath the seafloor. The boundless atmosphere is now reeling from two centuries worth of greenhouse gas emissions. Even life itself seems to be running out, as biologists warn that we are in the midst of a global extinction event comparable to the last throes of the dinosaurs. The constraints on our resources and environmentcompounded by the rise of the middle class in nations such as China and Indiawill shape the rest of this century and beyond. Here is a visual accounting of what we have left to work with, a map of our resources plotted against time. 19762005 >> Glacier Melt Accelerates Glaciers have been losing their mass at an accelerating rate in recent decades. In some regions such as Europe and the Americas, glaciers now lose more than half a meter each year. 2014 >> The Peak of Oil The most common answer to how much oil is left is depends on how hard you want to look. As easy-to-reach fields run dry, new technologies allow oil companies to tap harder-to-reach places (such as 5,500 meters under the Gulf of Mexico). Traditional statistical models of oil supply do not account for these advances, but a Follow Us: Latest News Most Read How Much Is Le? The Limits of Earth's Resources A graphical accounting of the limits to what one planet can provide By Michael Moyer and Carina Storrs Energy & Sustainability :: Feature Articles :: August 24, 2010 :: 11 Comments :: Email :: Print See Inside More In This Article Overview The End: A Directory and Online Exclusives Sidebar Click here for an interactive version of this article The Best Science Writing Online 2012 Showcasing more than fifty of the most provocative, original, and significant online essays from 2011, The Best Science Writing Online 2012 will change the way... Read More Read More Read More Read More More from Scientific American More to Explore Preschoolers Who Drink Daily Sodas Are More Likely to Be Obese by Age 5 Autism Risk-Factors Database Could Aid in Epidemiological Studies of the Disorder Threats to Sharks Destabilize Entire Ecosystems Can Herbs Ease Anxiety and Depression? How to Swim in Molasses: Microbes Have Evolved Many Wacky Ways of Moving Through Fluids TECHMEDIANETWORK | 2 hours ago See Three Asteroids in the Night Sky This Month NEWS | 4 hours ago Preschoolers Who Drink Daily Sodas Are More Likely to Be Obese by Age 5 NEWS | 4 hours ago | 1 Autism Risk-Factors Database Could Aid in Epidemiological Studies of the Disorder NEWS | 4 hours ago Threats to Sharks Destabilize Entire Ecosystems CLIMATEWIRE | 9 hours ago | 6 Climate Change Shifts Range and Behavior of Ocean Species See what we're tweeting about Scientific American Contributors docfreeride Cornelius's calculation that they can go back & at least their baby will be safe is heartbreaking #EscapeFromThe #PlanetOfTheApes 1 minute ago reply retweet favorite docfreeride Combing a daring escape from government captivity w/ active labor is a tricky situation. Run Zira! #EscapeFromThe #PlanetOfTheApes 2 minutes ago reply retweet favorite Sign In / Register Subscription Center Subscribe to Print & Tablet Subscribe to Print Give a Gift View the Latest Issue Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 1 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM technological improvement. Though still controversial, this multicyclic approach predicts that global oil production is set to peak in four years and that by the 2050s we will have pulled all but 10 percent of the world's oil from the ground. 2025 >> Battle Over Water In many parts of the world, one major river supplies water to multiple countries. Climate change, pollution and population growth are putting a significant strain on supplies. In some areas renewable water reserves are in danger of dropping below the 500 cubic meters per person per year considered a minimum for a functioning society. Potential Hot Spots: Egypt A coalition of countries led by Ethiopia is challenging old agreements that allow Egypt to use more than 50 percent of the Niles flow. Without the river, all of Egypt would be desert. Eastern Europe: Decades of pollution have fouled the Danube, leaving downstream countries, such as Hungary and the Republic of Moldova, scrambling to find new sources of water. Middle East: The Jordan River, racked by drought and diverted by Israeli, Syrian and Jordanian dams, has lost 95 percent of its former flow. Former Soviet Union: The Aral Sea, at one time the worlds fourth-largest inland sea, has lost 75 percent of its water because of agricultural diversion programs begun in the 1960s. 2028 >> Indium Indium is a silvery metal that sits next to platinum on the periodic table and shares many of its properties such as its color and density.* Indium tin oxide is a thin-film conductor used in flat-panel televisions. At current production levels, known indium reserves contain an 18-year world supply. 2029 >> Silver Because silver naturally kills microbes, it is increasingly used in bandages and as coatings for consumer products. At current production levels, about 19 years worth of silver remains in the ground, but recycling should extend that supply by decades. 2030 >> Gold The global financial crisis has boosted demand for gold, which is seen by many as a tangible (and therefore lower-risk) investment. According to Julian Phillips, editor of the Gold Forecaster newsletter, probably about 20 years are left of gold that can be easily mined. >> Fewer Fish Fish are our last truly wild food, but the rise in demand for seafood has pushed many species to the brink of extinction. Here are five of the most vulnerable. Hammerhead Sharks have declined by 89 percent since 1986. The animals are sought for their fins, which are a delicacy in soup. Russian Sturgeon have lost spawning grounds because of exploitation for caviar. Numbers are down 90 percent since 1965. Yellowmouth Grouper may exist only in pockets of its former range, from Florida to Brazil. Email address 14yo: "Don't listen to the audio of schizophrenic auditory hallucinations at the table, please." :D 4 minutes ago reply retweet favorite More Free Newsletters Get the best from Scientific American in your inbox Deadline: Aug 31 2013 Reward: $100,000 USD $100,000 USD $100,000 USD $100,000 USD Solve Innovation Challenges Male/Female Differences in the Pathogenesis and Presentation of Alzheimers Disease in Pre-symptomatic, Early Symptomatic and Late Stages The Geoffrey Beene Foundation Alzheimers Initiative (GBFAI) is launching the 2013 Geoffrey Beene Global NeuroDiscovery Challenge whose More Challenges Powered By: Latest from SA Blog Network Yes, T-Shirt Messages Matter Symbiartic | 7 hours ago Growing the Future of Meat Oscillator | 10 hours ago Celebrate Geek Week With the Geekiest Things I ve Ever Written Overthinking It | 10 hours ago "I'm Sick of Talking about Sexual Harassment!" M MM MIND IND IND IND MIND Guest Blog | 12 hours ago Fuel for Thought: Biomass to Briquettes Expeditions | 12 hours ago News From Our Partners Firefighter killed battling blaze in Pacific Northwest Best way to kill lab animals sought See Three Asteroids in the Night Sky This Month Climate Change Shifts Range and Behavior of Ocean Species Samsung's next Galaxy Note to debut September 4 Science Jobs of the Week GI Physician Bozeman Deaconess Hospital Project Grants for PHD Projects Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 2 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM reproduces late in life, recovery could take 200 years. Orange Roughy off the coast of New Zealand have declined by 80 percent since the 1970s because of overfishing by huge bottom trawlers. >> Our Mass Extinction Biologists warn that we are living in the midst of a mass extinction on par with the other five great events in Earths history, including the Permian-Triassic extinction (also known as the Great Dying; it knocked out up to 96 percent of all life on Earth) and the Cretaceous-Tertiary extinction that killed the dinosaurs. The cause of our troubles? Us. Human mastery over the planet has pushed many species out of their native habitats; others have succumbed to hunting or environmental pollutants. If trends continueand unfortunately, species loss is acceleratingthe world will soon be a far less diverse place. 2044 >> Copper Copper is in just about everything in infrastructure, from pipes to electrical equipment. Known reserves currently stand at 540 million metric tons, but recent geologic work in South America indicates there may be an additional 1.3 billion metric tons of copper hidden in the Andes Mountains. 2050 >> Feeding A Warming World Researchers have recently started to untangle the complex ways rising temperatures will affect global agriculture. They expect climate change to lead to longer growing seasons in some countries; in others the heat will increase the frequency of extreme weather events or the prevalence of pests. In the U.S., productivity is expected to rise in the Plains states but fall further in the already struggling Southwest. Russia and China will gain; India and Mexico will lose. In general, developing nations will take the biggest hits. By 2050 counteracting the ill effects of climate change on nutrition will cost more than $7 billion a year. >> Mortal Threats As the total number of species declines, some have fared worse than others. Here are five life-forms, the estimated percentage of species thought to be endangered, and an example of the threats they face. Mammals 18 percent endangered The Iberian lynx feeds on rabbits, a prey in short supply in the lynxs habitat ever since a pediatrician introduced the disease myxomatosis from Australia to France in 1952 to kill the rabbits in his garden. Plants 8 percent endangered The St. Helena redwood is native to the island in the South Atlantic where Napoleon lived his last years. Its excellent timber led to exploitation; by the 20th century only one remained in the wild. Lizards 20 percent endangered The blue spiny lizard must retreat from the sun before it overheats; higher temperatures have cut down on the time it can forage for food. Birds 10 percent endangered The black-necked crane suffers from habitat loss in the wetlands of the Tibetan plateau. Tier 2 Canada Research Chair in Primate Neuroscience Western University More jobs from Naturejobs.com Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 3 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM Tweet 13 30 percent endangered Archeys frog has been devastated by a fungal disease in its native New Zealand. 2060 >> Changing the Course of a River Climate change will shift weather patterns, leading to big changes in the amount of rain that falls in any given region, as well as the amount of water flowing through streams and rivers. Scientists at the U.S. Geological Survey averaged the results of 12 climate models to predict how streamflow will alter over the next 50 years. While East Africa, Argentina and other regions benefit from more water, southern Europe and the western U.S. will suffer. 2070 >> Himalayan Ice Snow melt from the Himalayas is a prime source of water for Asias major river valleys, including the Yellow, Yangtze, Mekong and Ganges. By 2070 ice-covered landmass in the Himalayas could decrease by 43 percent. 2072 >> Limits of Coal Unlike oil, coal is widely thought to be virtually inexhaustible. Not so, says David Rutledge of the California Institute of Technology. Governments routinely overestimate their reserves by a factor of four or more on the assumption that hard-to-reach seams will one day open up to new technology. Mature coal mines show that this has not been the case. The U.K.the birthplace of coal miningoffers an example. Production grew through the 19th and early 20th centuries, then fell as supplies were depleted. Cumulative production curves in the U.K. and other mature regions have followed a predictable S shape. By extrapolating to the rest of the worlds coal fields, Rutledge concludes that the world will extract 90 percent of available coal by 2072. 2100 >> The Alps Parts of the Alps are warming so quickly that the Rhone Glacier is expected to have disappeared by the end of the century. 2560 >> Lithium Because lithium is an essential component of the batteries in electric cars, many industry analysts have worried publicly that supplies wont keep up with growing demand for the metal. Still, known lithium reserves are big enough to keep us supplied for more than five centuries, even ignoring the vast supply of lithium in seawater. *Erratum (11/19/10): Indium was incorrectly described as being next to platinum on the periodic table. It sits next to tin, and does not share many of platinum's properties. This error also appears in the interactive version of this article. This article was originally published with the title How Much Is Left?. Subscribe Buy This Issue Already a Digital subscriber? Sign-in Now If your institution has site license access, enter here. Rights & Permissions Like 609 Share Share 2 11 Comments Add Comment Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 4 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM 1. DouglasHayBuettner 11:01 AM 8/24/10 We should use more than just wind and solar for renewable energy resources in the future. More science and technology will have to help us provide for saving, recycling, and proving new renewable energy sources. These sources could come from bio-fuel, nanotechnology, etc. Why don't human's do something about deforestation and extinction? Reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation is a UN program to help stop deforestation and extinctions from happening. Why wait until 2012? Why not start now? Climate change causes pressure on the agricultural markets, reduces productivity and increases mal-nourished children and wars in the world. What we need are more people working on collecting data and analyzing it to see what direction is necessary to take to solve the issues related to climate change, agricultural needs, productivity needs, pricing needs, etc. What is going to happen after the glaciers and ice is gone? What is going to happen when all the cold water is gone? Will things start drying out or will there be more precipitation and eventual freezing again? Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 2. DouglasHayBuettner 11:02 AM 8/24/10 We should use more than just wind and solar for renewable energy resources in the future. More science and technology will have to help us provide for saving, recycling, and proving new renewable energy sources. These sources could come from bio-fuel, nanotechnology, etc. Why don't human's do something about deforestation and extinction? Reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation is a UN program to help stop deforestation and extinctions from happening. Why wait until 2012? Why not start now? Climate change causes pressure on the agricultural markets, reduces productivity and increases mal-nourished children and wars in the world. What we need are more people working on collecting data and analyzing it to see what direction is necessary to take to solve the issues related to climate change, agricultural needs, productivity needs, pricing needs, etc. What is going to happen after the glaciers and ice is gone? What is going to happen when all the cold water is gone? Will things start drying out or will there be more precipitation and eventual freezing again? Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 3. aquaponics.me.uk 06:34 PM 8/24/10 There is a real human attraction for a disaster story, just think of Struwelpeter! Calm down, nothing is being used up, our landfill will be mined soon, it doesn't take 300 gallons of water to make a loaf of bread, the water just re-enters the hydrological cycle at a different place. The Aral Sea is refilling significantly, global warming will cause increased precipitation in desert areas, such as Antarctica, causing a drop in sea level as the ice accumulates! The problems are our physical damage to the biological environment, see www.aquaponics.me.uk - join us! Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 4. ennui 06:54 PM 8/24/10 I discovered the technology of the Flying Saucer in 1967 and patented it later. (That is how gravity control works.) I did not describe in the patent how they "tap" energy out of the Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 5 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM I suspect that Tesla used it for his electric Pierce Arrow Car in 1931 but did not dare to divulge how it worked, as he realized that it also could be used to power homes all over the world. The investors of the Niagara Falls Power plant would have terminated him. He did not take a patent out. I will patent it when I have enough capital to develop it safely and get world-wide patents. The invention of gravity control had been evaluated at $600 Billion if the USA had it before Russia. Nasa was not interested, it would make the Propulsion Engineers and the Rocket Industry obsolete. The free energy spin-off is worth a little bit more. Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 5. denisaf 05:29 AM 8/25/10 I have not yet seen the complete article but I would make a point about what is happening. Every day the systems of industrial civilization are irreversibly using up some of the limited natural resources and doing irrevocable damage to the environment. That is an unsustainable process. Finding new resources and implementing innovative technology does not change that principle. The common contrary rhetoric cannot change the fact that our decisions have led to the construction of a materialistic civilization that is addicted to ravishing its life support system. Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 6. mike cook 06:32 AM 8/26/10 The popular feeling is that human progress is unsustainable because we are using up "irreplaceable" resources. This cultural propaganda is nothing but a pessimistic mindset being brainwashed into children. All that negative mood represents is a complete misunderstanding of human progress, akin to postulating that humans would be in trouble as soon as they no longer could easily find flint to make spear points and arrowheads. Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 7. lesliehelm@comcast.net 12:24 PM 8/30/10 There is no source cited for the data on food production in "feeding a warming world." What institutions are making those kinds of projections? Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 8. lesliehelm@comcast.net 12:25 PM 8/30/10 what is the source for the data on "Feeding a Warming World." Who are the scientists or institutions making those projections. No sources are cited. Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 9. StudentAA 10:52 PM 1/19/11 Technological innovation could help solve some of our problems of shrinking natural resources. For example technology has solved Singapore's water problem with desalination, NEWater and imported water. I think technology cant really solve problems like global warming especially if we keep using fossil fuels. Singapore doesn't have enough natural water to supply the country's needs, this is 200 cubic meters per person a year. So Singapore has solved this problem by using technology. Now they use imported water from Malaysia by pumping it across Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 6 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM Add a Comment You must sign in or register as a ScientificAmerican.com member to submit a comment. Click one of the buttons below to register using an existing Social Account. sewage into fresh clean water, as well as turning salt water into fresh water. Singapore has 17 water catchment areas and if you see how much clean water they have now, it is enough to supply the country. Without technology it would not be possible for Singapore to get the water it needs. Something technology can not solve is the problem of people using fossil fuels. We have the technology to invent new ways of transportation and other sources of energy. People think the new technology is too expensive to use, so they dont make the change. Actually we should use bikes or other things that don't use fossil fuels instead cars, buses and other outdated transportation. Another reason people dont want to use new technology is because the companies that make money from fossil fuels attempt to prevent new technology. Technology can solve our problems of shrinking our natural resources but only if we choose to use it properly. We are not using different technology for energy and I think it is people that are causing the problem. Although there are many ways that we can replace fossil fuels with newer Eco friendlier technology people refuse to use them. On the other hand Technology has solved Singapores water shortage issue by providing enough clean water in other ways. Technology can not solve all our problems because I believe people refuse to use it properly. However, if governments made changes and worked together we could make a difference. Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this 10. denisaf in reply to mike cook 04:02 AM 2/8/11 That comment expresses the opinion of an individual without any backing argument. It does not stand up to any scrutiny. Perhaps he may care to read Laprin's Leaks and then make some constructive comments. Reply | Report Abuse | Link to this | Jump To: 1-10 | 11-20 | YES! YES! YES! YES! Send me a free issue of Scientific American with no obligation to continue the subscription. If I like it, I will be billed for the one-year subscription. Email Address Name Advertise About Scientific American Subscribe Special Ad Sections Press Room Renew Your Subscription Science Jobs Site Map Buy Back Issues Scientific American is a trademark of Scientific American, Inc., used with permission 2013 Scientific American, a Division of Nature America, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 7 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM International Editions Privacy Policy Subscriber Customer Service Travel Contact Us Use of Cookies Blogs Subscribe News & Features Topics Videos & Podcasts Education Citizen Science SA Magazine SA Mind Products How Much Is Left? The Limits of Earth's Resources: Scientific American http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=how-much-is-left 8 of 8 7/08/2013 1:26 PM