Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Polymorphism in nylon 66
M. L. CO L C L O U G H *
Metallurgy and Materials Science Department, Imperial College of Science and
Technology, London, UK
R. B A K E R t
Chemistry Department, University College, Gower Street, London, UK
The molecular structure of room temperature (RT) nylon 66 and its transition to the high
temperature (HT) form have been examined by X-ray crystallographic techniques. An
initial literature survey on the RT form revealed a number of anomalies in the spatial
relationships of the molecules within the unit cell, namely, poor ethylenic segment
packing, distortion of the amide group from a planar configuration and lack of similarity
on the projected cell base between RT nylon 66 and RT nylon 6. These anomalies have
been resolved, and models proposed which give a better fit between calculated and
observed data. The remainder of the paper describes the examination of the HT form
with the object of determining whether or not a three-dimensional hydrogen bonded
network could exist beyond 180 ~ C. By determining unit cell dimensions and measuring
intermolecular hydrogen bond distances it was possible to eliminate certain directions
for hydrogen bonded planes. On the basis that any such distance must not exceed about
0.31 nm, which is the maximum hydrogen bond distance reported in the literature, it was
concluded that a three-dimensional network could not exist. The cause of the structural
transition is attributed to progressive changes in ethylenic segment torsion angles.
2532
observed value. By means o f a short computer T A B L E I The atomic fractional coordinates of the
program the orthogonal co-ordinates were rotated 4~ rotated molecule with C-C-C bond angle 109~ '
(Model 1)
about the chain axis through various angles, and
triclinic co-ordinates output. The X-ray 70 com- Atom x y z
puter program package was used to generate Carbon 1 --0.100 0.012 0.038
IFc2l values for each angular change. After a scale Carbon 2 0.078 -- 0.009 0.108
factor correction, residual factors were calculated Carbon 3 --0.139 0.017 0.184
using Equation 1. The residual factor was plotted Carbon 4 -- 0.161 0.019 0.328
Carbon 5 0.061 -- 0.007 0.387
against angle of rotation. Fig. 1 shows this plot,
Carbon 6 -- 0.111 0.013 0.469
where a zero rotation indicates a molecule lying in Nitrogen 1 -- 0.005 0.001 0.247
(0 1 0). An anticlockwise rotation looking down Oxygen 1 --0.407 0.049 0.184
the c-axis onto the projected cell base is classed as
positive. T A B L E I I The observed and calculated structure factor
To assess the significance o f this residual factor amplitude squared terms for the 4 ~ rotated molecule with
minimum, shown in Fig. 1, Bunn and Garner's carbon bond angles of 109~ ' (Model 1) and for the
atomic co-ordinates were used to generate struc- molecule with a 9~ torsion angle change (Model 2)
ture factors which were compared to our observed IFcZl
Index (h kl) IFo:l
values. The percentage residual obtained was Model 1 Model 2
43.1%. A significant improvement over this is
(1 0 0) 2539 2026 2248
obtained for the 4 ~ rotated planar molecule,
(01 0) (1 1 0) 8762 8485 8279
R = 2 8 . 3 % . The atomic co-ordinates for this (]-10)(210) 923 1176 1432
molecule are given in Table I. The observed, (200) 261 386 547
reduced data is given in Table II, with the corres- (1 20) 1145 1247 966
ponding [Fc2l values. (020)(220) 1715 2488 2337
(3 1 0) 336 1 11
The second approach to the selection of C - C - C (320) 481 19 16
b o n d angles was suggested b y an examination o f (1 3 0) 168 726 483
published data on long chained molecules, [ 7 - 9 ] . (03 0) (330) (3 1 0)~ 355 1195 1079
The C - C - C b o n d angle was rarely 109~ ', a more (4 1 O) J
acceptable average being 111 ~ If however, an (i01) 1408 538 552
orthogonal plot is made of such a molecule, the
(002) 165 165 132
overall chain axis length extends to approximately (0 1 2) (1 1 2) 95 324 395
1.75 nm. Changing b o n d lengths within permitted (0]2)(212)(122) 127 232 133
levels of accuracy makes only a slight change in (003) (0 1 3) 470 304 298
this dimension. Although the accuracy o f mea- (]-03) 136 219 202
suring lattice parameters on a fibre pattern is not (i 1 3) 129 198 171
high, a difference between 1.72 nm and 1.75 nm is (1 1 3) 75 110 110
discernible. Consequently torsion angle changes (1 1 4) 34 55 48
have to be postulated to reduce the molecular (i 2 4) 54 73 50
repeat distance to 1.72 nm. Even if the limitation (2 1 4) (224) 286 320 350
is observed that the amide group is planar, there (1 1 5) 104 58 93
are still a large number o f torsion angle changes (005) (1 25) 120 140 98
which could give rise to the necessary shortening. (i15)(025)(]-05) 131 249 287
Manipulation o f CPK models indicated that not (]-16) 269 333 341
only did changes in the torsion angles adjacent (226) (]-06) 406 556 618
(2 1 6) 202 213 179
to the amide group shorten the chain axis, but
also improved the packing o f the ethylenic (117)(027) 983 1031 863
segments o f the molecule. The torsion angles (]-17)(227) 825 1108 1037
(2 3 7)(]-0 7)(]-27)} 1565 1761 1661
changed were C 2 - C 3 - N 1 - C 4 and C 4 - N 1 - C 3 - C 2 , (2 1 7)
and the changes made were o f equal amount, but (107) (03 7) 560 750 480
in opposite senses, so that an extended chain con- (2 1 7) (207) (3 27). 1186 1351 1296
figuration was maintained.
The torsion angle o f the group o f atoms C2-
{(2 07) (]-3 7) (227)~
(3 1 7) /
577 1416 1530
2533
RESIOllA FACTOR The atomic co-ordinates for this model are listed
in Table III. The corresponding values of IFr
are contained in Table II for the purpose of
33 comparison with Model 1 data.
32
2.4. Discussion
There are three important differences between
31
the two models proposed here and the one sug-
gested by Bunn and Garner [1]. The first of
30
these concerns the plane4ike qualities of the
29
amide group, which, as previously described,
was used as a structure modelling constraint.
28 Pauling and Corey [7] consider that the amide
bond dimensions are indicative of a partial double
27 bond structure which stabilizes a planar con-
figuration. Extensive experimental evidence,
L L L , I n I I r [ u L i I ~._ taken from a wide range of anlide-containing
-12 ~ -8 ~ -4" O 4" 8" 12" 16"
molecules is presented in support of their sug-
CHANGE IN TORSION ANGLE
Figure 2 Residual factor dependence on the simultaneous
change in the torsion anNes adjacent to the amide in
nylon 66.
it
data set and a least-squares analysis. The problem
of reflections (3 1 0) and ( 3 2 0 ) which consis-
tently calculate too low may also be resolved.
3.3. Data r e d u c t i o n
As for the room temperature fibre pattern, the for the other reflections was poor as indicated in
problem of overlapping reflections occurred. Table VI.
It was solved in a similar way, however, due to For the molecule in this position the hydrogen
the lack of data it was not possible to immediately bond spacing was 0.311 nm.
derive a scale factor which would put the observed Similar nearest neighbour calculations were
structure factor amplitude onto the same absolute performed with the amide group lying in the
scale as the Fc. Consequently the level of agree- (0 1 0) and in the (1 00). The distances were
ment between lEo21 and lee21 terms had to be 0.311 nm and 0.35nm respectively. By tilting
monitored by means of the scale factor. the amide groups with respect to the c-axis in
each of these planes the carbon-nitrogen distance
3.4. Structure modelling could be reduced to 0.288 nm in the (0 1 0 ) b u t
The work of O l f and Peterlin indicated that in the (1 0 0) the value always increased.
thermal vibration effects and torsion angle changes
occurred on heating, one superimposed onto the 3.5. Discussion
other. This combination will tend to smear out The existence of a three-dimensional hydrogen
the X-ray contributions from atoms engaged in bonded network in the high temperature poly-
such motion, so that an increasingly diffuse morph was proposed on the grounds that the
pattern will emerge. It was therefore considered projected cell base was hexagonal and the basal
that the greatest contribution to the sharply spacings reminiscent of hydrogen bonded "planes.
defined reflections would come from the amide NMR and other studies failed to confirm or deny
group, which, because of its plane-like qualities, the existence of such a network. However, optical
would not be involved in torsion angle changes, studies [5] on drawn and roiled fibres of nylon 66
and as a unit less susceptible to thermal effects. at 20~ and 220~ indicated that despite some
A planar amide group was moved up and down loss in fibre orientation, on heating they remained
the c-axis in the (0 1 0) and LFc2[ values output optically biaxial. If the amide groups were ran-
for reflections ( 0 0 1 ) and (002). The best domized or had formed a three-dimensional net-
position for the amide group was decided by work the fibre should have become optically
scale factor refinement. The scale factor agreement uniaxial. Cannon concludes that the network
was further improved by rotating the amide therefore does not exist at high temperatures.
group about its new position. A rotation of 10~ The approach adopted in this w o r k - w h i c h
towards the long diagonal on the projected cell confirms the findings of Cannon [5] - i s simple
base gave the best result. Moreover, the agreement and based upon geometric considerations. If the
was also good for two other intense reflections- nearest neighbour spacing at either extremity of
(0 1 0) (1 00) (1 1 0) and (2 07). The agreement the "60 ~ flip-flop" is the same and within the
2538
acceptable limits of hydrogen bond spacing, then the non-amide carbon atoms, though small, could
this would provide further support for the net- account for most of the anomalies observed by
work theory. If, however, they are greatly dif- Bunn and Garner. From information on the HT
ferent or outside the acceptable limits then the structure it is possible to propose mechanisms
network is very unlikely to exist. for the molecular motions which cause the tran-
The experimental evidence indicates quite sition to occur.
clearly that although the spacing of the planes on Starting with the non-planar RT molecule, a
the projected cell base in the (0 1 0) is reminiscent gradual increase of the amide associated (C2-C3-
of hydrogen bonded planes, the minimum NI-C4 and C4-N1-C3-C2) torsion angles with
nitrogen-oxygen spacing of 0.35 nm is not. temperature can be seen to cause the required
Consequently the three-dimensional hydrogen unit cell lattice parameter changes. With reference
bonded network is thought not to exist. The to Fig. 5, an increase in these torsion angles will
evidence also confirms that the preferred direction decrease the molecular chain axis repeat length,
of the hydrogen bonds is, as for the room tem- and will increase the sharpness of the zig-zags as
perature form, approximately in the (1 00) with well as the "b" unit cell dimension. Moreover, a
a nearest neighbour distance of 0.311 nm between further effect of the increased Sharpness is that
the nitrogen and oxygen atoms. the intersheet packing must change and a become
The quantitative experimental intensity data, increasingly obtuse to accommodate it. These unit
although limited, tends to confirm that an accept- cell changes could occur without influencing the
able position for the amide group should lie in or "a" dimension of the unit cell which is dominated
close to the (0 10) with the hydrogen bond by hydrogen bonds. The torsional oscillation of
direction close to (1 0 0). the hydrocarbon segments described by other
The support provided by the intensity data is workers [13, 14, 17] could take place serving to
as stated, meagre and open to some doubt, since augment the chain axis dimension decrease and
the positions of the non-amide carbon atoms and the "b" axis increase.
their contributions to the X-ray diffraction pattern A further consequence of this torsion angle
have not been considered. The strength of this change is that to maintain a continuous chain
case lies with the determination of the unit cell structure the amide groups have to rotate, effec-
parameters and the assumption that the amide tively pivoting about the hydrogen bond direction.
g r o u p - wherever it is positioned- remains sub- Cannon [13] considers that since the CONH
stantially planar as the temperature is raised. The infra-red frequencies are sensitive to changes in
first of these points has been covered in the experi- the association of amide groups, any statistical
mental section. The effect of high temperatures, distribution of amide-amide contact distances
although increasing the individual atom vibration or of the angle between adjacent dipoles should
within the amide group, is unlikely to convert lead to a broadening of the absorption bands.
the Sp 2 hybrid bonds to the more easily rotatable The spectra of nylon 66 [13] shows such a broad-
Sp 3 or to induce large out-of-plane oscillations. ening with increased temperature, which Cannon
Furthermore, infra-red evidence [15, 16] indicates attributes to amide rotation caused by the twisting
that on a time average all hydrogen bonds remain motions of the hydrocarbon segments. The X-ray
intact up to the melting point, Which means that data presented in this work on the position of the
the spatial relationship between intermolecular amide group at high temperatures (although
oxygen and nitrogen, and therefore interatomic limited) indicates that a change in amide position
oxygen and nitrogen, is at least similar to the room and therefore change in angle between adjacent
temperature relationship. Consequently the dipoles has occurred. A simple picture emerges
assumption, in keeping with studies elsewhere of the heat-induced transformation being driven
[7-9], that the amide group remains substantially by the twisting motions of the ethylenic segments,
planar, appears reasonable. which cause the torsion angles adjacent to the
amide group to change. This in turn causes the
3.6. Conclusion amide groups to rotate, the total effect giving
The initial work on the room temperature form of rise to the observed crystallographic dimension
nylon 66 established that torsion angle changes of change.
2539
Acknowledgements 8. M.G. NORTHOLT and L.E. ALEXANDER, jr.
T h e a u t h o r s w o u l d like to t h a n k Professor J . G . Phys. Chem, 72 (1968) 2838.
9. M.G. NORTHOLT and L.E. ALEXANDER, Aeta
Ball o f I m p e r i a l College a n d Dr P. Pauling o f
Cryst. B 27 (1971) 523.
U n i v e r s i t y College for the provision o f r e s e a r c h 10. D.R. HOLMES, C.W. BUNN and D.J. SMITH,
facilities. J. Polymer Sci. 17 (1955) 159.
11. v . VAND and I. P. BELL,Acta Cryst. 4 (1951)465.
12. A. KELLER and A. MARRADUDIN,J. Phys. Chem.
References Solids. 2 (1957) 301.
1. C.W. BUNN and E. V. GARNER, Proc. Roy. Soc. 13. C.G. CANNON, Speetrochim. Acta 16 (1960) 302.
A 189 (1947) 39. 14. H.G. OLF and A. PETERLIN, J. Polymer Sci. A 2
2. R. BRILL,J. Prakt. Chem. 161 (1943) 49. 9 (1971) 1449.
3. G.F. SCHMIDT and H.A. STUART, Z. Natur- 15. D.S. TRIFAN and I. F. TERENZI, J. Polymer. Sei,
forsch. 13a (1958) 222. 28 (1958) 443.
4. W.P. SLITCHER, J. Polymer Sci. 35 (1958) 77. 16. E. BESSLER and G. BIER, MakromoL Chem. 28
5. C.G. CANNON, F.P. CHAPPEL and J. 1. (1969) 443.
TIDMARSH, J. Text. Inst. 54 (1963) T210-T221. 17. W. P. SLITCHER, J. Polymer Sci. 35 (1959) 77.
6. J.D. BERNAL, Proe. Roy. Soc. A 113 (1926) 117.
7. I. PAULING and R.B. COREY, Fortschr. Chem.
Ors. Natstoffe. 11 (1954) 180. Received 30 December 1977 and accepted 18 April 1978.
2540