Hindustan Zinc known as lowest cost producer in the world commands premium for its integrated facilities with total metal production capacity of 754000tpa. At current zinc prices HZL is expected to generate EPS of 102 and 132 for FY11E and FY12E respectively. With increase in production and wide spread geographical presence HZL could lay hands on undeveloped Gamesberg mine which has potential to produce 400kt.
Hindustan Zinc known as lowest cost producer in the world commands premium for its integrated facilities with total metal production capacity of 754000tpa. At current zinc prices HZL is expected to generate EPS of 102 and 132 for FY11E and FY12E respectively. With increase in production and wide spread geographical presence HZL could lay hands on undeveloped Gamesberg mine which has potential to produce 400kt.
Hindustan Zinc known as lowest cost producer in the world commands premium for its integrated facilities with total metal production capacity of 754000tpa. At current zinc prices HZL is expected to generate EPS of 102 and 132 for FY11E and FY12E respectively. With increase in production and wide spread geographical presence HZL could lay hands on undeveloped Gamesberg mine which has potential to produce 400kt.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd. Key Rationale Hindustan Zinc known as lowest cost producer in the world commands premium for its integrated facilities with total metal production capacity of 754000tpa and debt free status. HZL has objective of increasing its capacity to 1mtpa by FY11E with total cost of `3600cr generated through internal accruals. At current zinc prices HZL is expected to generate EPS of `102 and `132 for FY11E and FY12E respectively. Giving 1 multiple to cash in the balance sheet of `290 per share and 8 multiple to its core business we feel the stock has great potential to make money for investors. Anglo American Zinc acquisition to benefit: Anglo American zinc acquisition at total consideration of $1338mn is profitable venture for Hindustan Zinc as ROE on the transaction is expected to be in excess of 15%. With increase in production and wide spread geographical presence HZL could lay hands on undeveloped Gamesberg mine which has potential to produce 400kt. The acquisition, which is EPS accretive, is expected to add around `1200cr to its operating EBIDTA during FY12E. We value the asset in the balance sheet at `118 per share. Capacity expansion to ramp up volume: HZL has successfully added 1mtpa to its mine capacity at Rampura Agucha and 210kt to its smelter capacity at Rajpura Dariba in FY10. It is further expanding lead smelter capacity by 100kt at Rajpura Dariba. Total expansion cost is anticipated at `3600cr, which will be funded through internal accruals. Cash rich status of the firm should facilitate such expansion. Capacity expansion is likely to increase zinc production to 747kt and lead production to 145kt by FY12E. Captive power plant to reduce cost: HZL being lowest cost producer in the industry commands premium to other players. Captive power supply is major cost-saving factor of its production. Its current power capacity is 493MW, which will be increased to 653MW to fulfill increased power requirement due to rising production. Rising silver production with rising prices: HZL is exploring all the possibilities to increase silver production. The firm is expanding mining capacity at Sindesar Khurd mine from 0.5mnt to 1.5mnt thus, increasing silver production to 0.5mnt by 2013E. With rising silver production we expect silver contribution to total business to increase from current 5% to 10%. However, rising silver prices in uncertain global economic environment could be major boost to HZLs profitability cost being constant. We expect silver business to be major trigger for HZLs re- rating in the medium term. Zinc and lead prices- stable outlook: Zinc demand is expected to increase by 13% and 6.3% in 2010E and 2011E respectively reaching 13.4mnt by 2011E. Lead demand is expected to grow at 4.5% in 2010E and 5.8% in 2011E. Rising consumption from Asian countries on account of increased infrastructure and construction activities is likely to keep zinc and lead demand outlook stable. Supply is also picking up with demand however surplus is expected to reduce over medium term for both the commodities. We expect very minimal downside risk for both industrial commodities over medium term. Valuation: Rising volume and stable realization to improve topline of the firm at a CAGR of 20% over FY10-FY12E bottomline at a CAGR of 18% over the same period. Any further upside in silver price would be addition to bottomline. At current market price the stock is available at 12.4xFY11E and 9.4xFY12E earnings and 8.2x and 6.3x FY11E and FY12E EV/EBIDTA respectively. We recommend Buy with target price of ` `` `1581. Buy Date 12 th November 2010 CMP `1234 Target Price `1581 52 week High / Low 1328/900 Equity Cap (current) `422.53Cr Face Value Re. 10 Mkt. Capitalization `52140Cr Avg. Daily Vol. (12 M) 222857
Anglo American zinc acquisition at total consideration of $1338mn is profitable venture for Hindustan Zinc. With this acquisition HZLs zinc and lead mine production is expected to increase from 1.064mnt to 1.462mnt. Total reserves and resources base is expected to increase from 272mn to 478mnt. The consideration values Anglo American Zinc at 6x EBITDA and is expected to accrue 15% ROE to the firm as against 5% on its current cash balance. Apart from this, unexplored assets at Gamesburg holds lot of potentials for further volume increase. Based on FY11E and FY12E earnings we analyze current share price includes `118 towards Anglo Americal Zinc.
Assets acquired
The consideration includes $698mn paid towards Skorpiaon mine, $308mn towards Lisheen mine and $332mn towards Anglo Americans 74% interest in Black Mountin Mining.
R&R Grade 2009 Prdn. Location Mine Ownership R&R(Mnt) Zn% Pb% Zn Pb Comments Skorpion 100% 8.3 11.30% 150kt Unique technology to extract zinc metal from zinc oxide ore Nambia Gergarub Co-expl. Agree. With Rosh Pinah N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. Black mountain 74% 51.7 1.50% 2.90% 21kt 36kt Mine life extension past 2020 possible
New mining infra coming online mid- 2010 Gamesberg 74% 137.6 6.90% 0.40% - - One of the world's largest undeveloped zinc deposits South Africa Potential to produce 400ktpa of zinc Ireland Lisheen 100% 8.7 11.90% 1.90% 172kt 19kt Underground mine producing high- quality zinc and lead
Historcal Lead Production (kt) (2) 20 16 19 31 35 36 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 2007A 2008A 2009A Lisheen Black Mountan 51 51 55
Hindustan Zinc Ltd. (HZL) 4 12 th November 2010
Gross Revenue Contribution (2) (2009) Lisheen 45% Skorpion 35% Black Mountan 20% Total : US$670m
EBITDA Contribution (2) (2009) Lisheen 34% Skorpion 47% Black Mountan 19% Total : US$213m
Gamesberg- One of the largest undeveloped zinc mine
Gamesberg is one of the largest undeveloped zinc deposits in the world. Total reserve base of Gamesberg is around 186mnt includes 154mnt at Gamesberg North at 6.3% Zn and 32mnt at Gamesberg East at 9.8% Zn. The mine holds potential to produce 400ktpa zinc at Gamemsberg North with potential to expand to 530ktpa through development of Gamesberg East. Thus, we feel the asset holds lot of potential to boost volume for HZL
400 725 410 390 240 200 394 382 264 209 Rampura-Agucha Red Dog Gamsberg Mehdiabad mount Isa Selwyn Ozernoe Lanping Penasquito McArthur River Potential New Mines Existing Mines Vedanta-owned Anglo-owned
Valuation
As acquisition is immediate EPS accretive we expect this to contribute around `1200cr in FY12E. With Vedantas expertise to develop the assets we are hopeful of improved profitability from these mines. Valuing the stake at 5x EV/EBIDTA we value the stake at ` `` `118/share.
Mining operations Rampura Agucha mine capacity increased from 5mtpa to 6mtpa. HZL owns 5 mines in Rajasthan with total resources amounting to 198mnt and reserves amounting to 102mnt with expected mining life of 20years. Rampura Agucha is largest and lowest cost open cost zinc mine in the world. HZL has successfully commissioned 1mtpa concentrator at Rampura Agucha, thereby increasing the ore production capacity from 5mtpa to 6mtpa. During FY10 the company has started underground development work beyond the ultimate open pit depth of 372meters from the surface. The project has state-of-the-art infrastructure facilities and mining equipments. These initiatives will facilitate faster rate of underground mine development and targeted production from Rampura Agucha mine on a sustainable basis.
Capacity at Sindesar Khurd to increase from 0.5mtpa to 1.5mtpa. Second largest mine owned by HZL is Sindesar Khurd mine with total reserves and resources of around 60.8mnt. The underground mine has high silver content of 215particle for one million. The ore produced at Sindesar Khurd mine is processed at Rajpura Dariba mines beneficiation plant. It will be processed at the mine after commissioning of Sindesar Khurd mine. HZL is expanding its ore production capacity from 0.5mtpa to 1.5mtpa thereby increasing silver production from 150kt to 500kt by 2013E.
Rajpura Dariba and Zawar mines are with total reserves and resources of around 42mnt and 61mnt respectively. The mines are well equipped with world-class infrastructure facilities. The firm is in the process of developing two new mines viz. Bamnia Kalan and Kayar with reserves and resources base of 5mnt and 9mnt respectively.
Reserves and Resources as on March 31, 2010 Resources Reserves Measured and indicated Inferred Proved and probable Grade % Grade % Grade % Mt Zinc Lead Mt Zinc Lead Mt Zinc Lead Rampura Agucha 20.99 14.67 1.92 23.66 11.80 1.92 75.71 14.23 1.99 Rajpura Dariba 7.66 7.80 2.26 26.75 8.12 2.03 7.80 6.25 1.40 Sindesar Khurd 17.25 5.67 3.52 32.83 4.98 3.35 10.74 5.45 2.95 Bamnia Kalan 1.69 5.29 1.84 3.37 5.00 3.80 Zawar 24.66 5.00 1.80 28.70 4.76 2.71 7.85 3.66 1.95 Kayar 2.30 12.58 1.87 6.71 9.95 1.67 Total 74.54 8.41 2.28 122.02 7.21 2.55 102.09 11.89 2.04
Increased smelting capacity to improve production
Chanderia smelter is the largest smelter owned by HZL with total capacity of 610000t of zinc and lead and 168tpa silver. HZL has commenced 210ktpa Hydro Zinc smelter at Dariba Consequently zinc-lead metal production capacity has increased to 964ktpa. This expansion is likely to increase zinc production form 578kt in FY10 to 664kt by FY11E and 747kt by FY12E.
The firm is in the process of increasing Dariba lead smelting capacity by 100ktpa by March 2011E. Lead production volume is expected to increase from 71.6kt in FY10 to 112kt in FY11E and 114.7kt in FY12E. Post- expansion HZLs capacity is likely to be 1064ktpa. Total capital expenditure for these projects will be met through internal accruals.
879 879 85 100 185 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 Current Cap Additional Lead Smelter 2011E Zinc(kt) Lead Smelter(kt)
HZL has strategically installed Captive Power Plants (CPP) to cater to the power requirement of smelters and mines. It has thermal CPPs at Chanderiya and Zawar with total generation capacity of 314MW. In addition DG sets are installed at Debari, Chanderiya and Zawar with total power generation capacity of 35.62MW. It has also installed 123.2MW wind power plant and 20.2MW waste heat recovery based plant to suffice its power requirement. To fulfill increasing power requirement through increased production capacity the firm is further setting up 160(2*80MW) thermal power plants at Dariba. Coal being the most important raw material for power plant the firm secures its coal requirement partly through coal linkages with Coal India and partly through imports from Indonesia and South Africa. The project is expected to be commissioned by September 2010.
Power Capacity(MW) 35.62 20.2 314 493.02 653 123.2 160 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 TPP DG Sets Wind Power WHRB Total addition TPP Post TPP DG Sets Wind Power WHRB addition TPP
Rising silver production and rising prices
HZLs aggressive plans on ramping up silver production with opening up of Sindesar Khurd mine will be positive trigger for its profitability due to rising silver prices. HZL has plans to ramp up its silver production capacity from current 150kt to 500kt by FY13E. Stupendous rise in silver production along with rising realization to improve silver contribution in total business from current 5% to more than 10% by FY13E. We expect silver production to increase substantially post 2012E. For FY12E and FY12E we expect revenue contribution from silver business to increase from current `344cr to `490cr in FY11E and `704cr in FY12E.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd. (HZL) 8 12 th November 2010
Rising silver prices could act as a big trigger for the firms profitability. Though silver contributes only 5% to its current profitability however rising silver prices under uncertain economic scenario would be major boost to Hindustan Zincs profitability given its increasing exposure to silver production.
73% 71% 9% 15% 4% 6% 14% 8% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 2010 2012 Zinc Lead Silver Other
Lowest cost producer to command premium
HZL is the lowest cost producer of zinc in the world mainly due to its integrated facilities which gives hoard from volatility in TcRc, captive power and high-grade mine status. HZLs average zinc production cost works out to $850/tonne as against world average of $1300/tonne. Similarly recovery of zinc in the mining operations has consistently increased from 88.7% in 2002-03 to 91.2% in 2007-08.
Cash rich to facilitate expansion
HZL holds around `12376cr (`292 per share) cash and equivalents in its books. Healthy cash balance has facilitated Anglo American Zinc acquisition which is expected to yield around 15% ROE to the firm. Rich cash balance and debt free status provides more room for expansion at lower cost. We expect HZL to generate operating cash flow of `5800cr in FY12E thus facilitating acquisition and future smelter as well as mine expansions.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd. (HZL) 9 12 th November 2010
Industry dynamics
Zinc surplus to go down in 2010 and 2011E
Reviving demand in the Western world and rising infrastructure demand and automobile demand in the Asian countries is driving zinc and lead usage. Zinc demand is expected to increase by 13% and 6.3% in 2010E and 2011E respectively reaching 13.4mnt by 2011E. Demand growth in the zinc industry is mainly driven by improving infrastructure and construction activities in the world.
Though major closed metal manufacturing smelters have come on stream after surge witnessed in Zinc prices, new capex in the industry is very minimal. This will further restrain the supply growth in the industry. Thus, we expect zinc metal production to lag demand growth. Therefore, reducing excess capacity in the system for near term. Zinc metal production is expected to increase by 10% and 5.6% in 2010E and 2011E respectively.
In 2010 Zinc mine output is expected to increase by 7% mainly on account of: Ramp up of 190kt/year capacity at Penasquito mine in mexico Hingher output in Australia, Brazil, India, Kazakhstan and Russsia Rising production in China In Peru, drop at Antamina will be offset by reopening of Iscaucruz
Further 6.6% increase is expected in mine output during 2011E: Reopening of Nyrstars Tennessee mines in USA Reopening of expanded Neves Corvo in Portugal
Globally new greenfield operations are witnessed in the regions of Saudi Arabia, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan. These initiatives will shape up further to improve mine output.
Zinc metal output is expected to increase by 9% and 5.6% in 2010e and 2011e respectively at 13.196mnt. Production ramp up is expected to be noticeable in regions such as Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Japan, Rep. Of Korea, Netherlands and USA as major suspended capacity during recession has been brought on stream.
New smelter capacity during 2010-11 210kt/yr capacity at Rajpura Dariba refinery Votorantims new 160kt/yr line at Cajamarquilla, Peru
Hindustan Zinc Ltd. (HZL) 10 12 th November 2010
China major driver of zinc
During last decade Chinas zinc demand has increased at a CAGR of 10%. China has been major driver for zinc demand increasing its contribution from 10% in 2001 to 35% in 2010 of the total consumption. Post stimulus to suffice demand revival China started importing base metals very aggressively. However, the rise in imports is at a faster pace than demand revival resulting into piling up of inventory. Therefore, reduced imports from China indicate inventory de- stocking process. Similarly, with sharp price increase unviable smelter have also come on stream resulting into production ramp up. Chinas zinc demand is expected to grow at 7%. Steady demand growth to keep prices stable.
China production, consumption and imports
Production (Tons) Consumption (Tons) 0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000 300000 350000 400000 450000 500000 J a n - 0 3 J a n - 0 4 J a n - 0 5 J a n - 0 6 J a n - 0 7 J a n - 0 8 J a n - 0 9 J a n - 1 0
0 50000 100000 150000 200000 250000 300000 350000 400000 450000 500000 3 1 - J u l - 1 0 2 8 - F e b - 0 9 3 0 - S e p - 0 7 3 0 - A p r - 0 6 3 0 - N o v - 0 4 3 0 - J u n - 0 3 3 1 - J a n - 0 2 3 1 - A u g - 0 0 3 1 - M a r - 9 9 3 1 - O c t - 9 7 3 1 - M a y - 9 6
Import (Tons) Exports (Tons) 0 20000 40000 60000 80000 100000 120000 140000 J a n - 0 4 J u l - 0 4 J a n - 0 5 J u l - 0 5 J a n - 0 6 J u l - 0 6 J a n - 0 7 J u l - 0 7 J a n - 0 8 J u l - 0 8 J a n - 0 9 J u l - 0 9 J a n - 1 0 J u l - 1 0
0 10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000 90000 J a n - 0 4 J a n - 0 5 J a n - 0 6 J a n - 0 7 J a n - 0 8 J a n - 0 9 J a n - 1 0
Indian zinc industry
Demand in Indian market for refined zinc increased by 25% to 525kt in FY2010, from 419kt in the previous year. This is mainly driven by the demand created by various infrastructure projects. The Indian zinc demand is expected to grow in the coming years based on a positive GDP forecast. The key components for demand growth are ongoing and upcoming infrastructure projects, telecom and power projects and automobile sector. Hindustan Zinc is the largest zinc manufacturer in the country holding around 74% share of the Indian Zinc demand.
Hindustan Zinc Ltd. (HZL) 11 12 th November 2010
Zinc price outlook
Global zinc industry has seen piling up of inventory recently however, with rising consumption and stable supply we expect inventory level to go down in the medium term. Thus, we dont foresee downward pressure on global zinc prices in the medium term.
Zinc inventory vs. stock price
Zinc user industry First Use of Zinc % Oxides and Chemicals 8% Galvanising 50% Semi-Manufactured Products 9% Brass Semis and Castings 15% Die-Casting Alloys 13% Miscellaneous 5%
End Use of Zinc % Transport Infrastructure Consumer Products Indusrrial Machinery Construction
Lead Demand supply outlook
Lead demand is expected to grow at 4.5% in 2010E and 5.8% in 2011E. Consistent demand increase in lead would reduce surplus build into the system. Again China is major player in lead consumption contributing more than 30%. However, rising automobile consumption in China assures consistent demand for lead.
Lead mine metal output is expected to grow at 7.1% and 4.5% in 2010E and 2011e due to increased output from China, India, Mexico and Autralia. Consequently, lead metal output is expected to increase by 4.5% and 5.8% in 2010e and 2011e. Lead metal output increase is likely to be result of new smelter capacity in China and 100kt/yr smelter at Rajpura Dariba. 130kt/yr new capacity at Enertec operation in Mexico would also add to production rise.
Lead Stock vs. price
Valuation
HZL commands $50-60/t premium on LME zinc price. As we expect zinc prices to consolidate at $2300/t-$2500/t in the medium term. On a conservative side we have assumed average realization of $2400/t for FY11E. Taking into consideration profitability of Anglo American Zinc we expect the firm to post EPS of `103 and `132 for FY11E and FY12E respectively. Any upside in the silver prices as anticipated would be addition to bottom line, costs remaining the same. Debt free status gives the firm lot of impetus for new acquisition or expansion. We expect the firm will be able to maintain ROE of around 23% in the medium term. However, at current market price these positives are not fully factored in as stock is available cheaper to its global peers. At current market price the stock is available 12.4x and 9.3x FY11E and FY12E earnings respectively. EV/EBIDTA works out at 8.2x and 6.3x FY11E and FY12E respectively. We recommend, BUY with target price of ` `` `1581.
HZL derives more than 70% of revenue through zinc manufacturing. Volatility in zinc prices has effect on the earnings of the company. Zinc being global commodity is volatile with the global happening. Though we are positive on the medium term outlook of the commodity any uncertainties in the global economy could have negative impact on zinc prices thus, having impact on companys earnings.
Lead and silver price volatility
Lead and silver contributes around 15% and 5% of the firms earnings respectively. Volatility in these commodity prices will have effect on the firms earnings.
Corporate Office: Manu Mansion, 2 nd Floor, 16, Shahid Bhagatsingh Marg, Fort, Mumbai 400 001. Tel. 91-226633 8900 / 2261 8787 / 4027 8900 Fax No. 91-22 2269 0041 Email: research@technogroup.co.in website: www.technoworld.in Strictly for Private Circulation only. All rights reserved. Techno Shares & Stocks Ltd DISCLAIMER: This information & opinions in this report have been prepared by TECHNO SHARES & STOCKS LTD. The report & the information contained herein are strictly confidential and meant solely for the authorized recipient and may be restricted by law or regulation in certain countries. This report is for information purposes only for the authorized reader and does not construe to be any investment, legal or taxation advice. This report is based on the information obtained from public sources and sources believed to be reliable, however, no warranty, express or implied, are given for the accuracy or correctness of the same and it should not be construed as such. It is also not intended as an offer or solicitation for the purchase and sale of any financial instrument. Techno Shares & Stocks Ltd and/or its subsidiaries and/or directors, employees, officers or associates including the persons involved in the preparation/issuance of this report may have (a) from time to time, any interest or positions (buy/sell etc.) financial (including in derivatives/commodities market) or otherwise in the companies/securities covered/mentioned in this report and may have acted upon the information &/or (b) been engaged in any other transaction, commercial or otherwise, in respect of the companies/securities covered in this report, like earning brokerage, commission or act as a market maker &/or (c) performed or may seek to perform any merchant/investment banking services for such companies or act as advisor or lender/borrower to such companies &/or (d) have other possible conflict of interest with respect to any recommendation or any information/opinions that could affect the objectivity of this report. As a result, the authorized recipients of this report should rely on their own investigations and analysis & seek professional advice. Any action taken by any one solely on the basis of the information contained herein is their own responsibility alone and Techno Shares & Stocks Ltd and its subsidiaries or its directors, employees or associates will not be liable in any manner whatsoever for the consequences of such action taken. No data/information contained in this report shall be copied, forwarded, transmitted or distributed, in part or in whole, in any form or in any media, without the previous written consent of Techno Shares & Stocks Ltd.