CURRENCIES INTEREST RATES EQUITIES COMMODITIES To contact FX CONCEPTS New York: 1 (212) 554-6830; London: +44 20 7213 9600; Singapore: (65) 67352898; research@fx-concepts.com
MARKET INSIGHT REPORT Will the Last One Out Please Turn Off the Lights By John R Taylor, Jr. Chief Investment Officer It is not just the demise of FX Concepts that has made our personal view of the world bleak during this past year, but also the deepening predicament of the entire foreign exchange business, from interbank trading to currency management to political blundering to a lack of macro reality perception. This is a widely underappreciated danger for global trade, cross-border investment, future growth, and global bank survival. Technology has brought some of these woes upon us, as our information advantage over the customer has grown so dramatically to allow risk free trading for the Goldmans and JP Morgans of the world. Put that together with everyones desire to outwit and take pennies away from the nebulous other side and we have been undone. High frequency trading and the banks part in the fixing or better said, the gaming, of the WM rates mixed with (very understandable) regulatory navet and lurid publicity have crippled the FX market. This is only one financial crisis away from bringing the whole banking system to its knees (think bail-in). We could write hundreds of pages about these inter-related issues and I look forward to discussing the technical, psychological, historical and moral dimensions of them (and what has been written so far) over coffee, wine, or harder stuff, with anyone interested, but not here. What we want to do in this short letter is to put forward our understanding of what the hobbling of this largest global market will do to volatility, price discovery, liquidity and how those changes will impact economic surprises sure to come in the years ahead.
Two images come immediately to my wandering mind when thinking about the future of trading rooms in the coming years and maybe were there already. The first is the last two weeks of August when historically everyone is on vacation and the fourth-string is watching the desk. I remember someone doing a lira trade against the dollar, thinking the lira amount was dollars and causing a move of over 1% in a short time, while also destroying all the intra-European crosses along the way. Today, the machine would certainly shut itself off, but who would do the business it might be real and those trades must be done. What happens to the price? Is there really any liquidity when the ones and twos are all hit and all the systems back away, but the volume to clear the market is really hundreds of thousands of ones and twos? Do the central banks bail us out you must be dreaming! This would look like a flash crash, a multiple of the August lira trade above, but this is not a mistake, no immediate reversal is ahead. It is a change in price that has blown away the liquidity that was no longer there. No people with risk authority and no risk capital in the system is the new reality. When business is done in ones and twos in a two-way market, things are great, but why should a bank risk its capital? The reward is gone and if there is some, it is probably illegal
The second image is of the 1970s. Low to no liquidity and cold nose was the order of the day. Markets ran all over the place, banks did not commit the capital, and central banks had absolutely no control. Global trade was the dominant factor in the market and corporations were at great risk because movements were so large relative to profit margins. Cross border investing was almost non-existent partly because it was so risky in a currency and liquidity sense. Global investment grew with FX, will it shrink with it too? Trend following was king because there was no liquidity to stand up to the most recent move. Options could make the future different because back then there was few options, but lack of capital and liquidity will shrink options portfolios too.
FX CONCEPTS FX CONCEPTS GLOBAL MACRO RESEARCH GLOBAL MACRO RESEARCH CURRENCIES INTEREST RATES EQUITIES COMMODITIES To contact FX CONCEPTS New York: 1 (212) 554-6830; London: +44 20 7213 9600; Singapore: (65) 67352898; research@fx-concepts.com
CURRENCY Europe Long-Term View
Has the Dollar Turned Up Against the Swiss? By John R. Taylor, Jr.
The Swiss franc has often acted as the canary in the coal mine for the entire currency world versus the US dollar and there is a chance it is playing that role again. Last May the dollar reached its high against the Swiss franc about seven weeks before it reached its high against the euro. This year, the dollar seems as if it has made its low against the Swiss franc on March 13, just a hair below the .8700 level, but it is not clear the EUR/USD or several other European currencies have finished their uptrend. The last possible spot for these highs should be at the start of the week of May 5, just about seven weeks after the USD/CHF low. Of course, much of the expected risk-on mood depends on the economic and confidence news that is clustered around the end of the month. We have already started with Wednesdays Chinese and European PMI projections. The Chinese PMI was not as good as hoped. Although the European ones looked good, too much of the positive was a function of the German input, something that is heavily discounted as we all know those numbers are not the ones we are worried about. The critical numbers will come next week with the FOMC on Wednesday, where the tapering will be continued but the world will be reading the nuances in Janet Yellens words and waiting to see what the other governors might say as well. This is followed by the real PMI readings and US non-farm payrolls. As all of this news is coming out at the end of what we believe is an important last gasp attempt to continue a very tired uptrend, a bad number or some negative words could cause the turn.
The technical picture for the USD/CHF shows we are very close to breaking above the downtrend from the July 2013 EUR/USD high. It is right around the .8870 level as of the time of this writing. As the USD/CHF touched a high of .8855 on Wednesday, we are not far away. However, the cycles argue we should have at least five trading days of dollar weakness ahead, taking us into the FOMC meeting. If this weakness proves inconsequential or is reversed by fundamental factors and the dollar closes above .8870, we will argue that a new and significant dollar uptrend has begun. Our target for the expected cyclical peak in June is around the .9000 level.
Our cycles for the equity market also call for a peak around the start of May, but we do not necessarily expect that to coincide with a weakening of the economy. A stronger economy implies higher interest rates, higher commodity prices, including oil and food, and higher inflation. All of these things are negatively correlated to the equity market at this point in the very major cycles. A decline in the euro and all the currencies related to it and a weakening equity market do not depend on things going wrong. This reversal is more the ordinary course of events than something extraordinary. A further crisis in the Ukraine or a more aggressive weakening in Chinese growth could upset this quiet apple cart, but we do not expect the fruit will fall.