Professional Documents
Culture Documents
and, for vehicles traveling on pulicl& accessile roads, dominated & light dut& vehicles,
emissions ma& e estimated from the following e4uation:
where ?, a, , c and d are empirical constants, and
/ H si%e#specific emission factor ,l)!M*-
s H surface material silt content ,K-
W H mean vehicle weight ,tons-
M H surface material moisture content ,K-
; H mean vehicle speed ,mph-
C H emission factor for 2783Is vehicle fleet e+haust, ra?e wear and tire wear$
*he source characteristics s, W and M are referred to as correction parameters for
ad<usting the emission estimates to local conditions$
C =
c
d a
,M)3$.-
;)G3- , ,s)2(- ?
/
For the WRAP, paved and unpaved road dust emissions were estimated using updated
!M* for the ase and future &ears provided & state and local contacts as part of the ase
and future &ear surve& wor?$ An& updated road dust controls provided were also
incorporated into the estimates$ "t is important to note that since the previous WRAP
road dust emissions estimates were prepared, /PAIs guidance on estimating paved and
unpaved road dust emissions was updated5 see
http:))www$epa$gov)ttn)chief)ap'()ch2G)inde+$html$ *he WRAP /missions Forum opted
to update the road dust emissions onl& to reflect updated !M* and controls, and not to
reflect the updated /PA guidance methodolog&$
A more detailed discussion of the development of paved and unpaved road dust
emissions can e found in Pollac?, et al$, (33:
Windlown Dust from !acant lands
Fugitive dust from wind erosion of agricultural and vacant lands represents a significant
source of particulate matter emissions, particularl& throughout the Western 6;$ For
agricultural windlown dust, emission factors ma& e estimated using the 6;DA wind
erosion e4uation ,W/L- ,AR1, 277C- which relates the PM23 emission factors to
various parameters characteri%ing the specific crops, soil erodiilit&, surface roughness,
vegetative cover and climatic factors$ PM23 emissions are otained & multipl&ing the
resulting emission factor & the total crop acreage in units of tons)acre)&r$ For non#
agricultural vacant lands, numerous wind tunnel studies have een conducted to estimate
appropriate emission factors ased on soil t&pes, surface conditions and threshold friction
velocities$
Windlown fugitive dust emissions have not een estimated & /PA in previous national
emission inventories$ />!"RO> has recentl& completed the development of a
windlown dust model for use in WRAP regional ha%e modeling efforts ,Mansell, et$ al,
(33:-$ A description of the model development and the most recent results for the WRAP
states can e found at http:))www$wrapair$org)forums)de<f)fderosion$html$ *he model
estimates fugitive PM dust emissions from vacant lands given wind speed data$ All
vacant land t&pes are considered5 mechanicall& distured lands, e$g$, agricultural tilling,
are not included$ *he current version of the model is set up to use the regional#scale land
use dataases for characteri%ing vacant lands, and also re4uires specification of soil
characteristics, specificall& soil te+ture$ *he model provides hourl& gridded emission
estimates that can e easil& summari%ed on a count& level$ A complete detailed
description of the model development and re4uisite input dataases is included in the
pro<ect Final Report and related documentation ,Mansell, et al$, (33:-
Emissions Modeling for Fugitive Dust Sources
For regional air 4ualit& modeling, the count&#level, annual ,or seasonal)monthl&- PM
dust emissions are spatiall& allocated to the modeling grid and temporall& allocated
hourl&$ "n addition, fugitive dust transport fractions are applied to the PM dust emissions
estimates prior to their use in the air 4ualit& model$ *he WRAP RMC utili%ed the
;MOM/ emissions processing s&stem to develop the necessar& air 4ualit& model#read&
dust emissions data$
;imilar to emissions modeling for other source sectors, the fugitive dust emissions were
e+tracted from the point, area and moile source inventor& data files and processed
separatel& through ;MOM/$ Dust emissions were e+tracted from the inventor& files
ased on ;CCs$ Processing the dust emissions separatel& allows for more efficient
4ualit& assurance of the data and the direct application of the fugitive dust transport
fractions$ *he application of transport fractions is discussed in more detail elow$ With
the e+ception of the windlown dust emissions, transport fractions are applied using the
growth and control modules of ;MOM/$ *he windlown dust emission models
incorporate the transport fractions directl& in the estimation methodologies used$ >ote
that, e+cept for the gridded emissions summaries, the data presented in the summaries
elow do not reflect the application of transport fractions$
*he final step in preparation of PM dust emissions for air 4ualit& modeling involves the
spatial and temporal allocation of annual, count&#level emissions estimates$ *he PM23
emissions estimates are also speciated as PMC ,HPM23NPM($.- and PMF">/ ,HPM($.-$
;peciation and spatial and temporal allocation is performed ased on detailed ;CCs$ *he
revised PM($.)PM23 ratios, developed & MR" ,MR", (33.-, were applied the final
versions of the gridded dust emission inventories presented elow$
Fugitive Dust SCCs and PM2.5/PM10 Ratios
*he development of the WRAP 1ase3( fugitive dust emissions inventor& were ased on
the specific ;CCs e+tracted from the area and point source inventor& data used in the
;MOM/ emissions processing$ As noted in Mansell ,(33:-, several detailed source
categor& codes that were either not included in the initial list of ;CCs for fugitive dust
processing, or were found to e reported using the most general ;CC descriptions$ For
e+ample, in some counties in Ari%ona, construction dust emissions were reported in terms
of the general @all processesA ;CC and were not included e+tracted from the area source
inventor& files$ Bi?ewise, agricultural dust emissions in California were provided
separatel& from other fugitive dust source categories and were therefore initiall& not
processed as fugitive dust within the ;MOM/ emissions modeling$
*he ratio of PM($. to PM23, as reported in the inventor& data were evaluated for the
1ase3( fugitive dust emission inventor& ,Mansell, (33:-$ *he PM($.)PM23 ratios are
generall& consistent with AP#'( guidance documents, although some e+ceptions were
found in the 1ase3( inventor&$ *ale 2 summari%es these ratios ased on AP#'( and
also presents the revised factors as recommended & MR"$ "n (33., the D/OF initiated a
pro<ect to evaluate the fine fraction of particulate matter in fugitive dust$ *he result
of this stud& indicated that the anal&sis procedures and findings on which the /PAPs
AP#'( 9uidance is ased ma& e iased & as much as a factor of ($ *he completed
D/OF stud& ,MR", (33.- provided recommended revisions, & dust emission source
categor&, and are included in *ale 2$
*ale ( presents the complete listing of fugitive dust emission source categor& codes
used & the RMC for e+tracting data from area and point source inventor& data files$
Also included in *ale ( are the original and revised PM($.)PM23 ratios used in the
;MOM/ processing$ >ote that several ;CCs listed were not included in the
development of the 1ase3( modeling inventories$ 1ased on the initial review of
emissions data for the 1ase3( inventor&, these ;CCs have suse4uentl& een
included in the current ;MOM/ processing procedures and are reflected in the
Plan3( and 1ase28a fugitive dust emissions inventor& summaries descried elow$
a!le 1$ AP#'( PM($.)PM23 ratios and recommended ratios from MR", (33.$
;ource Categor& AP#'( ;ection PM($.)PM23 Ratio
Current Proposed
Paved Roads 2G$($2 3$(. 3$2.
6npaved Roads 2G$($( 3$2. 3$23
Construction Q
Demolition
## 3$(38 3$23
Aggregate
0andling);torage Piles
2G$($' 3$G2' 3$23 ,traffic-
3$2. ,transfer-
"ndustrial Wind
/rosion
2G$($. 3$'3 3$2.
Agricultural *illing ## 3$((( 3$(3
a!le 2$ Fugitive dust emission ;CCs e+tracted from area and point source emissions
inventor& data files$
SCC Description
PM2.5/PM1
0 Original
PM2.5/PM10
Revised
2801000001 Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;Land Breaking 0.222 0.2
2801000002 Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;Planting 0.222 0.2
2801000003 Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;Tilling 0.222 0.2
2801000004 Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;e!oliation 0.222 0.2
280100000" Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;#ar$esting 0.222 0.2
280100000% Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;r&ing 0.222 0.2
280100000' Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;Loading 0.222 0.2
2801000008 Agriculture Production - Crops;Agriculture - Crops;Transport 0.222 0.2
280"000000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;Agriculture - Li$estock;Total 0.222 0.2
280"001000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;Bee! Cattle (eedlots;ust )icked-up *& #oo$es 0.222 0.2
280"001001 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;Bee! Cattle (eedlots;(eed Preparation 0.222 0.2
280"00"000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;Poultr& +perations;Total ,use 280"030000- 0.222 0.2
SCC Description
PM2.5/PM1
0 Original
PM2.5/PM10
Revised
280"00"001 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;Poultr& +perations;(eed Preparation 0.222 0.2
280"010000
Agriculture Production - Li$estock;air& +perations;Total ,use 280"020000 and
su*sets- 0.222 0.2
280"010001 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;air& +perations;(eed Preparation 0.222 0.2
280"01"000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;#og +perations;Total ,use 280"02"000- 0.222 0.2
280"01"001 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;#og +perations;(eed Preparation 0.222 0.2
280"020000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;Cattle and Cal$es .aste /0issions;Total 0.222 0.2
280"02"000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;#ogs and Pigs .aste /0issions;Total 0.222 0.2
280"030000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;Poultr& .aste /0issions;Total 0.222 0.2
280"03"000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;#orses and Ponies .aste /0issions;Total 0.222 0.2
280"040000 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;12eep and La0*s .aste /0issions;Total 0.222 0.2
280"04"001 Agriculture Production - Li$estock;3oats .aste /0issions;Total 0.222 0.2
22'"08"000 Aircra!t;4npa$ed Airstrips;4npa$ed Airstrips n5a 0.1
2311000000 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';All Processes;Total 0.208 0.1
2311000010 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';All Processes;Land Clearing 0.208 0.1
2311000040 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';All Processes;3round /8ca$ations 0.208 0.1
23110000"0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';All Processes;Cut and (ill +perations 0.208 0.1
23110000%0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';All Processes;Construction 0.208 0.1
23110000'0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';All Processes;9e2icle Tra!!ic 0.208 0.1
2311010000 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';3eneral Building Construction;Total 0.208 0.1
2311010010 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';3eneral Building Construction;Land Clearing 0.208 0.1
2311010040 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';3eneral Building Construction;3round /8ca$ations 0.208 0.1
23110100"0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';3eneral Building Construction;Cut and (ill +perations 0.208 0.1
23110100%0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';3eneral Building Construction;Construction 0.208 0.1
23110100'0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';3eneral Building Construction;9e2icle Tra!!ic 0.208 0.1
2311020000 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';#ea$& Construction;Total 0.208 0.1
2311020010 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';#ea$& Construction;Land Clearing 0.208 0.1
2311020040 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';#ea$& Construction;3round /8ca$ations 0.208 0.1
23110200"0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';#ea$& Construction;Cut and (ill +perations 0.208 0.1
23110200%0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';#ea$& Construction;Construction 0.208 0.1
23110200'0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';#ea$& Construction;9e2icle Tra!!ic 0.208 0.1
2311030000 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';:oad Construction;Total 0.208 0.1
2311030010 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';:oad Construction;Land Clearing 0.208 0.1
2311030040 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';:oad Construction;3round /8ca$ations 0.208 0.1
23110300"0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';:oad Construction;Cut and (ill +perations 0.208 0.1
23110300%0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';:oad Construction;Construction 0.208 0.1
23110300'0 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';:oad Construction;9e2icle Tra!!ic 0.208 0.1
2311040000 Construction6 17C 1" - 1';1pecial Trade Construction;Total 0.208 0.1
230"000000 7ndustrial Processes;;ineral Processes6 17C 32;All Processes;Total n5a 0.1
230"0'0000
7ndustrial Processes;;ineral Processes6 17C 32;Concrete< 3&psu0< Plaster
Products;Total n5a 0.1
230"080000 7ndustrial Processes;;ineral Processes6 17C 32;Cut 1tone and 1tone Products;Total n5a 0.1
232"020000 7ndustrial Processes;;ining and =uarr&ing6 17C 14;Crus2ed and Broken 1tone;Total n5a 0.1
232"030000 7ndustrial Processes;;ining and =uarr&ing6 17C 14;1and and 3ra$el;Total n5a 0.1
232"040000
7ndustrial Processes;;ining and =uarr&ing6 17C 14;Cla&< Cera0ic< and
:e!ractor&;Total n5a 0.1
2"30000020 1torage and Transport;Bulk ;aterials 1torage;All 1torage T&pes;Ce0ent n5a 0.1
2"30000100 1torage and Transport;Bulk ;aterials 1torage;All 1torage T&pes;Li0estone n5a 0.1
2"30000120 1torage and Transport;Bulk ;aterials 1torage;All 1torage T&pes;1and n5a 0.1
232"000000 ;ining and =uarr&ing6 17C 14;All Processes;Total n5a 0.1
SCC Description
PM2.5/PM1
0 Original
PM2.5/PM10
Revised
22>4000000 Pa$ed :oads;All Pa$ed :oads;Total6 (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>4000001 Pa$ed :oads;All Pa$ed :oads;Total6 A$erage Conditions - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>4000002 Pa$ed :oads;All Pa$ed :oads;Total6 1anding51alting - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>400"000 Pa$ed :oads;7nterstate5Arterial;Total6 (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>400"001 Pa$ed :oads;7nterstate5Arterial;Total6 A$erage Conditions - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>400"002 Pa$ed :oads;7nterstate5Arterial;Total6 1anding51alting - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>4010000 Pa$ed :oads;All +t2er Pu*lic Pa$ed :oads;Total6 (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>4010001 Pa$ed :oads;All +t2er Pu*lic Pa$ed :oads;Total6 A$erage Conditions - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>4010002 Pa$ed :oads;All +t2er Pu*lic Pa$ed :oads;Total6 1anding51alting - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>401"000 Pa$ed :oads;7ndustrial :oads;Total6 (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>401"001 Pa$ed :oads;7ndustrial :oads;Total6 A$erage Conditions - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>401"002 Pa$ed :oads;7ndustrial :oads;Total6 1anding51alting - (ugiti$es 0.2" 0.12
22>%000000 4npa$ed :oads;All 4npa$ed :oads;Total6 (ugiti$es 0.1" 0.1
22>%00"000 4npa$ed :oads;Pu*lic 4npa$ed :oads;Total6 (ugiti$es 0.1" 0.1
22>%010000 4npa$ed :oads;7ndustrial 4npa$ed :oads;Total6 (ugiti$es 0.1" 0.1
Fugitive Dust rans"ort Fractions
*he concept of fugitive dust transport fractions has een considered and refined in recent
&ears$ "t has een recogni%ed that, due to various mechanisms, dust particles are su<ect
to near source removal$ *hese mechanisms include gravitational settling, particle
deposition to the ground and impaction and removal due to particle capture & the
surrounding vegetation canop& and other ph&sical structures$ *he /PA for man& &ears
had promoted the @divide & fourA approach for reducing the emission from fugitive dust
sources to account for these processes$ *he idea is that onl& a limited amount of the dust
emitted & a particular source is transported significantl& to affect the total availale
emissions in the atmosphere for air 4ualit& grid modeling$
Recent research has shown that the amount of fugitive dust captured in the surround
canop& or on ph&sical structures can e related to the ph&sical characteristics of the land
surface, i$e$, land use)land cover$ *he /PA recentl& developed count&#level transport
fractions for use in emissions inventor& development for air 4ualit& modeling ,Pace,
(33G5 (33.-$ *he count&#level transport fractions were ased on the percentage of land
use in each count&$ *he transport fractions were calculated as a weighted sum of
landuse#specific fractions for each landuse t&pe$ Previousl&, landuse percentages were
derived from the 1/BDG B6BC dataase$ "n the WRAP fugitive dust emission
inventor&, transport fractions were revised to reflect a more current B6BC dataase$ *he
current gridded dust emissions for the WRAP are ased on the (333 >orth American
Band Cover ,(333 >ABC- dataase$ A description of the (333 >ABC dataase can e
found in Mansell and 0oats, (33.$
For the windlown dust emissions, transport fractions were developed and applied within
the wind lown dust model ased on the gridded landuse data used in the estimation
methodolog&$ A discussion of the application of the transport fraction for windlown
dust emissions can e found in Mansell, et al$, (33:$ *he original and revised transport
fractions for each of the relevant land use t&pes are presented in *ale G$
a!le #. Fugitive dust transport fractions as a function of landuse$
Fugitive Dust Transport Fractions
!C Categor" Original Revised
4r*an 0.30 0.00
Agriculture 0.8" 0.'"
3rassland 0.'0 0.'"
12ru*land 0.%0 0.'"
(orest 0.30 0.00
Barren5.ater 0.>' 1.00
$ridded Fugitive Dust Emission %nventor& Summaries
;ummaries of the gridded fugitive dust source emissions for the 1ase3(, Plan3(c and
1ase28 inventories & state and count&, annual and seasonal periods, can e found on
the *;; at: http:))vista$cira$colostate$edu)tss)Results)/missions$asp+$
References
Countess /nvironmental, (33'$ WRAP Fugitive Dust 0andoo?$ Prepared for Western
9overnorI Association, Western Regional Air Partnership$ Prepared & Countess
/nvironmental$ Midwest Research "nstitute$ >ovemer 2.$
/R9, (33:$ Documentation for 1ase(33( WRAP point and area inventories, not availale until
Oanuar&, (33:$ ,PBAC/0OBD/R-
Mansell 9$, et al$, (33:$ Final Report: Fugitive Wind 1lown Dust /missions and Model
Performance /valuation, Phase ""$ Prepared for the Western 9overnors
Association & />!"RO> "nternational Corporation, >ovato, CA$ Ma& .$
Mansell 9$, (33:$ ;ummar& of the WRAP Fugitive Dust /missions "nventories$
*echnical Memorandum prepared for the Western 9overnors Association &
/>!"RO> "nternational Corporation, >ovato, CA$ (( ;eptemer$
MR", (33.$ Anal&sis of the Fine Fraction of Particulate Matter in Fugitive Dust$ Draft
Pro<ect Report$ Prepared for Western 9overnorI Association, Western Regional
Air Partnership$ Prepared & Midwest Research "nstitute$ August 2C$
Pace, *$9$, (33G$ A Conceptual Model to Ad<ust Fugitive Dust /missions to Account for
>ear ;ource Particle Removal in 9rid Model Applications$ 6$;$ /PA$ August (($
Pace, *$9$, (33.$ Methodolog& to /stimate the *ransportale Fraction ,*F- of Fugitive
Dust /missions for Regional and 6ran ;cale Air Lualit& Anal&ses$ 6$;$ /PA$
Oune ($
Pollac?, A$, et al$, (33:$ Final Report: WRAP Moile ;ource /mission "nventories 6pdate$ $
Prepared for the Western 9overnors Association & />!"RO> "nternational Corporation,
>ovato, CA$ Oune 8$