dont know if the proposed PV installation will be structurally sound.
Contractors & Home Owners
dont want added cost of unneeded structural engineering.
Solar Support Components Manufacturers
take responsibility for the array above the roof, but leave it to others to determine if the roof framing can support the array. "These are electricians, putting PV panels on roofs, being asked to figure out structural support issues." Ellie Leard, Building Inspector
City of Berkeley Can we define a PREQUALIFIED
system? 80/20 rule
What does it look like? Pre-qualified System 1) Flush-Mounted 2) Wood-Framed Roof 3) Code Compliant Roof 4) Anchor Spacing Downward Limits Wind Uplift Limits Archaic Modern (Post-1930) Simple Worksheet Format Over-the-Counter Approval span tables 1. Flush-Mounted
(ICC Acceptance Criteria AC-428) 10 max
2 min Flush-Mounted PV Examples Wind Catchers dont prequalify
(special uplift loads) Especially with raised arrays, Failures can occur.. 2. Wood-Framed Roof S. K. Ghosh
Associates Inc. Wood-Framed Construction = Resilient, Robust 3. Roof is Code Compliant
-
Reasonably sound, no evidence of decay
= visual inspection
-
Complies with 1927 or later UBC
= built after 1930, or
= if earlier, complies with archaic construction span table
-
No second overlay reroofs
Innocent unless proven otherwise ! "Archaic" Construction horizontal span rough sawn 2x4s at 32" o.c. Archaic Construction
Re-roof Overlays = 2 to 4 psf Re-Roof Overlays Allowed: Explicit in code from 1979 to now
(example: 1997, Appendix Chapter 15) Roof Live Load = Construction Load Roof Live Load has been in Code a long time.. Older Codes' Roof Live Load: Low Slopes: 30 psf Steeper Slopes: 20 psf Berkeley 1911 Berkeley 1922 Berkeley 1928 UBC 1927 With all that Reserve Capacity,
whats the problem?
No problem, IF
you anchor to EVERY
rafter ! CONCENTRATED Loads:
(a few rafters do all the work!) CONCENTRATED Loads:
(a few rafters do all the work!) One Option:
Stagger the anchors ! The Other Option:
Do the math !
-
Roof live load decreases
at steeper
slopes
-
Load duration correction:
0.9/1.25
-
Slope correction factor:
cosine of slope Rafter Load Sharing: Load sharing is affected by roof sheathing thickness and rafter size & spacing Strength Increase: Every 2 nd
rafter = 1.50
factor Every 3 rd
rafter = 1.75
factor (based on 2x6 at 24 o.c. with plywood) Analysis Considers Two Load Combos:
PV Dead Load alone
PV Dead Load + Wind Down Demand/ Capacity Ratios Roof SLOPE No. of RAFTER Spaces X : 12 degrees 1 2 3 0: to 6:12 (0 o
to 26 o
) 0.63 0.71 0.80 7: to 9:12 (27 o
to 36 o
) 0.70 0.81 0.95 10: to 12:12 (37 o
to 45 o
) 0.74 0.86 1.01 13: to 17:12 (46 o
to 55 o
) 0.85 1.00 1.18 18: to 24:12 (56 o
to 63 o
) 0.89 1.06 1.27 Rules of Thumb for Downward
Loads:
Anchor every third
joist (for 24o.c. = 6 ft max)
Exceptions:
Up to
6:12 and 16 o.c.: every
fourth joist (5-4)
Steeper than 9:12: every second
joist
18:12
or steeper: every
joist
If anchors are staggered:
spacing may be twice
the above limits, but 6'-0" max. Maximum Anchor Spacing
(Perpendicular to Rafters) Roof SLOPE Maximum Anchor Spacing X : 12 degrees 16" o.c. 24" o.c. 32" o.c. 0: to 6:12 (0 o
to 26 o
) 5'-4" 6'-0" 5'-4" 7: to 9:12 (27 o
to 36 o
) 4'-0" 6'-0" 5'-4" 10: to 12:12 (37 o
to 45 o
) 4'-0" 4'-0" 5'-4" 13: to 17:12 (46 o
to 55 o
) 2'-8" 4'-0" 2'-8" 18: to 24:12 (56 o
to 63 o
) 1'-4" 2'-0" 2'-8" Wind Exposure Category B C D Hillcrest Wind Speed-up Effects Translate to Equivalent Exposure C or D Maximum Anchor Spacing
(Number of Rafter Spaces) Roof SLOPE Wind Exposure X : 12 degrees B C D 0: to 6:12 (0 o
to 26 o
) 3* 3 3 7: to 9:12 (27 o
to 36 o
) 3 3 2 10: to 12:12 (37 o
to 45 o
) 2* 2 2 13: to 17:12 (46 o
to 55 o
) 2 1 1 18: to 24:12 (56 o
to 63 o
) 1 1 1 * For 16 spacing, one more rafter space is allowed. Limits on Wind Uplift: Industry Workhorse: 5/16" diam. lag screw Solar Support Component Manufacturers' Guidelines Wind Uplift Zones:
middle,
edge &
corner
(3 feet from edges) Wind Uplift Anchor Tributary Areas: Bottom Edge Middle / Field Side Edge Corner Wind Uplift Anchor Tributary Area Limits
Use
Manufacturers' Guidelines or
Table Below: Roof SLOPE Trib
Area, Sq. Ft. X : 12 degrees Middle Edge flat to 6:12 (0 o
to 26 o
) 36 18 7: to 9:12 (27 o
to 36 o
) 26 26 10: to 12:12 (37 o
to 45 o
) 22 22 Wind Uplift Anchor Tributary Area Limits: Pre-qualified System 1) Flush-Mounted 2) Wood-Framed Roof 3) Code Compliant Roof 4) Anchor Spacing Downward Limits Wind Uplift Limits Archaic Modern (Post-1930) span tables Next Step:
Make Simple Structural Worksheet Special thanks for help & thoughtful comments ! Joe Cain & Amir
Massoumi, Solar City
Shon
Fleming, Sun Light & Power
Jeremy Rogelstad
& Chad Medcroft, Zep
Solar
Ron Jones & Stuart Wentworth,
Quick Mount PV
Ron LaPlante, Div. of State Arch. & Chair, SEAOC Solar Systems Comm.
Electrical Load-Curve Coverage: Proceedings of the Symposium on Load-Curve Coverage in Future Electric Power Generating Systems, Organized by the Committee on Electric Power, United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, Rome, Italy, 24 – 28 October 1977
Hawkins Electrical Guide, Number One
Questions, Answers, & Illustrations, A Progressive Course
of Study for Engineers, Electricians, Students and Those
Desiring to acquire a Working Knowledge of Electricity and
its Applications