Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mediummoist sand 2 2 . 0
Finesaturated sand. 2 . 5 3 . 0 - 3 . 5
Mediumsand 2 . 5 3 . 1
Grayfinedensesaturatedsand 2 . 5 3 . 4
!
0. 8
: 1.
0. 7
. . . ;>
N
0
C)
D. .
0. 6
II
. . .
0
0. 5
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . .
. . . .
e
ca
LL
cu
0. 4
~
: : : s
:t::
-a
0. 3
E
<C
II)
II)
0. 2
. . . _ _ . _ _ . . . . .
. . . .
II)
C
. 2
II)
0. 1
c
II)
E
s
0
0
1 1. 5 0. 5
b=5
2 . n
2. 5
II
. . .
S
u
ca
LL
II)
~
: : : s
:t::
-a
E
1. 5
<C
3
: 1. <II 3. 5
D
E E
i
t~
. .
I I
2
P =m e (1)
oz
!
!
4
61
80
Figure(2. 18) Response of a rigid circularfooting to aforce of constant
amplitude excitation (After Lysmer and Richart, 1966)
2 1.5 1 0.5
-------------------------.-;- .. ------- ... -------------------------------r -_._.-._-- ..... -----------------
P = constant
oz
3
.
f
Figure(2. 17) Lysmer displacement functions versus Poisson's ratio andfrequency ratio
(After Lysmer and Richart, 1966)
1.5 1 0.5
o
o
o
0.5
0.25
o
I,L-
-
c
~ 0.4
GI
Q.
E
o
u0.2
. 0.25
I,L 0.6
I ...
0.5
1
0.8 .
\)
1
62
Figure (2.21) Sliding response of a rigid circularfooting on elastic half space
(After Hall, 1967)
a.
1.5 0.5
4 . - - - - - - - - - ~- - - - - - - - - - ~- - - - - - - - - - _,
Lumped system
Figure(2.20) Equivalent Lumped system to halfspace (After Lysmer, 1965)
Half space G, p, u
Figure(2.19) Response of a rigid circularfooting to verticalforce developed by
frequency dependent amplitude force excitation
(After Lysmer and Richart, 1966)
4
3.5
t~
~I ~.
E E
3
2
II
P .,.=m.. <II
..
B
2.5
u
III
u..
GI
"a
:a
1.5
E
o c t
fit
fit
GI
C
0
iii
c
GI
E
0
0.5 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
a.
63
O/ro
Figure (2.24)Effect of embedment on the damping coefficient
(After Lysmer and Kuhlemeyer, 1969)
C/C
2
p
orb-
2.5 ,.--------,-------,-----------,
Figure (2.23) Effect of embedment on the spring stiffness
(After Kaldjian, 1969)
Depth to Radius Ratio (D/r.)
1 I l 1.6
{!
iil 1.5
{i
~1.4
1.3
1.2
1.1
1 ~~--~--~--~--~--~--~--~~
o 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4 2.8 3.2 3.6
Figure (2.22) Notationfor rocking and sliding mode of vibration
tv b
m
t
.
,
..
, .
z~
64
~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~~- - -
Figure (2.25) Effect of embedment ratiofor a circularfooting with (Bz=5.0)
(After Elzarka., 1991)
3 . 0 2 . 6 0.5 1.0 1.6 2.0
Di me ns i o nl e s s f r e que nc y
o .
0 . 0
c
~1.
.....
D
Cl
- 1.
e:
CD
a
:::E: O.
L-
a
. . . . .
~2.
-
2 .
0
5
~
I ; )
.Z5r 2r .25r
(~
H H
0
I
"
\
I
~
'J .~ ....
~
5
"
;4/
\\ . . .
V'
\\ o d / r = D. O O
\
w\:\
6 d / r = O . 2 5
6
'.
~~
o d / r = O . 7 5
0
I ~
lC d/r=l .50
3 .
o .
0 . 0
c:
a
-I .
.....
D
Cl
- 1.
e:
CD
o
:::E O.
L-
a
. . . . .
~ 2.
-
2 .
3 . 0 2 . 6
0.6 r.o 1.6. C.O
Di me ns i o nl e s s f r e que nc y
0
5
~
!\
' 2r I
0
j , .A ..
. ~
. .
5
p:
\
j.: .0.
11/
I
. . .
I
" - 1
u. . . . . . . lC~
<~
o d / r = O . O O
)c.
', \
t. d / r = O . 2 5
6
. . .
r
, ~
I
I I
o d / r = O . 7 5
01
lC d/r=I .50
3 .
65
~-'------
------
Figure(2.26) Determination of the spring stiffness and damping coefficient
for the impedancefunctions (After Dobry and Gazetas, 1986)
9
ROCKINt. 1",
1
"e
Q.= -v.-
5
SWAVIHG 1.,
o
,
J ,
0 .) '=-0 .........,o.s:l :-.o......J ,'--'-_ ,,:':-.s~~
Q.
l IB
SWAYING Iy 1
10
l iB, _
~)-
f . n . ,~ft
~Oh"''Q!rtd10. '
I"'" 0.'>0 I
66
0.5 0.4 0.1
o
o 0.2 0.3
Poisson's Ratio
Figure(2.29) Relation between Poisson's ratio v and velocity of propagation of
compression (P) ,shear (S) and Rayleigh (R) waves in a semi-infinite elastic medium.
(After Richart, 1962)
1
iR-Waves
3 -- .. - - 7 - - - - -.- -.- ...; - -.- - .; -.-.- -.- ; - .
U)
~
....
o
U) 2 -.-.- - + .. -.- - -.-.-.- : - .
~ p_Wa'leS-------
~ $-Waves
4 .-.--- 1..----.--.-_ __ _ _--i - - - ~ - --. _ _ _ -_.
5
Figure(2.28) Shear, secondary or Swaves
:<:- IDirection of propagation
& ; : ! i g ) - - . . ~ , Path of motion of
~l ~........... a particle
.!' "V .. ... ....
~'fI .: ~.... ~.... Relativepositions
"'~-...?' of soccessweparticles
~ .. alongthe pathof propagation
\Initial displacement
Figure(2.27) Compression, longitudinal, push or P waves
I
Direction of motion
Oense-~ 1)f a particle
=e.
. ~
~ Wavelength
~
.~
Source~
67
Figure (2.31) Body and surface waves
Source of vibrations
~PW~
Figure(2.30) Rayleigh wave, (a)-(g) Simultaneous positions of different individual
particles each of which is moving in all elliptical path as shownfor a.
Direction of
wave travel
r-wave len~h L If!
~ .........
68
Figure(2.33) Distribution of displacement wavesfrom a circular
footing on a homogenous, isotropic, elastic half-space (After Woods, 1968)
Relative
amplitu~
r 0,5
,_- -
Circular footin9
t
-. _- -__
--~-----.
--- ------. _------
Figure (2. 32) Wave systemfrom point source in an ideal medium.
(After Richart, Hall and Woods, 1970)
[b]
V@rticalparticle motion
la'
Horizontal particle motion
S w . . . ,. . R WIN.
69
__- .----_ ..
_._-_._-
Figure(2.35) Vibration isolation using a circular trench surround
the source of vibration - active isolation (After Richart et aI., 1970)
D
Circular, open trench of
radiusR.andDepth D
Oscillating Force
Amplitude of surface
displacement
------
-------
Figure(2.34) Effect of soil replacement
(After Elsalamony, 1993)
--_ ...__.----
10.0
( Er ep/ Esol 1)
8. 0
2.~_;_--;;;:;---;-::----:------.J
O~ ao ~o ~o
u/r - 0. 5
~
oy IfO.O U 1....0.0
~
o
"-'
U
to dJ
"-IU
C 3.2
C f't!
o C
_.o
+JUl
n! dJ
U ~
.... 3.0
"-I +J
.....to
C
0-
Il!
l:
304r----------,r------...---.
AII/ r Z .6 I u Ir-O.6
au Ir Z .6 u IrW Z .O
D0
UIr Z .6 u 1r-< l.O
.- ; - - - ~~- - ~~- - ~~~~~~~~
0.0 D.::! 0.4 a.e O.I! t..o
Di menSi Onl ess f r equency ( Av)
I Itu
, '2 ' I
u r "
, , D
o
c
0_2.0
~X
to - 1.5
U
_.
""'
_.
C
~ 0.5
l:
3.0
3.6,----::------------
o 8 7
70
Figure(2.3 7) Effect of frequency on the active isolation,
a-at frequency 2.5cps and b- at frequency 7.5cps
(After Elzarka, 1991)
6 3 2 . - 0
3 2 o
I
H
1 I I I 1
10
I 1
lJ. hl r=O.16
o hl r-I .60 .
o N o l ranch
h
r I
1
R
H . . 6 r
R = 2 r
4 f 7 . 5 c./sec.
, + hI r-2.50
:~t hl r=4.00
t
'i~~~
-<, +- - - ~- - +- , - . . . . .
. ~- . _- -. - - ~~es~~* ~~
R _l -t-
-+--l---t- I
,
\
\
+ ' .
,.
0\ .
\\\. +
~.'c
,.
I
. . . - - - i...
"D 0I -_j_~ .=---~ ...= = : " ~:t+----f
. _
1 5 ~~. ~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ' r - - - - - - - ,
,
I
I
h
r _l
f 2. ti c./set.
H 6 r
R . . 2 r
~-----------.-------~ ~- . . .
Figure(2.36) Vibration isolation using a straight trench-
passive isolation (After Richart et al., 1970)
o
o
o
Ampl itude of surface
displ acement
Sensitive instrument or tool
Straight, open trench of
depth Dand l ength L
I ncomping R ayl eigh wave
_.
L-
m
>
D
U
_.
c
m
E
C D
o 51-
D
C 1.
C D
- to
&
E
71
In the followingsection, thefiniteelement stepsandconcepts areintroducedfor
theisoparametricbrick eightnodeelement.
The finite elementmethod(FEM) isanumerical methodto solvetheproblemof
field continuum, and in our case to solve for the dynamic and static response of
foundations resting on soil half-space. It is used to convert continuous systemsinto
discrete systems, thus turning the partial differential equations governing the field
problems into a set of linear or nonlinear algebraic equations, or may be in time-
dependent problems into set of ordinary differential equations which can betreated
numerically in simpler way than the original differential equationsresultingfromthe
continuum. The FEM is superior to other numerical techniquesbecauseof itsabilityto
model irregular domains, different boundary conditions, different properties of
subdomains and finally its systematic steps that makeit flexibleenoughto handlethe
stressanalysisof solidsinthesamewayit handlesthethermal heat conductionanalysis.
3.1.1. Introduction
3.1. THE FINITE ELEMENT METHOD
Ana~ysisProcedure
Chapter (3)
72
(3.2)
{
displacement inthex directiOn(uJ }
a, =displacement inthey direction(vJ
displacement inthez direction(w.)
where8jisthedisplacementvector at nodei, i.e.,
(3.1)
According to Zienkiewics (l977f55 andIrons andAhmed(1980)C21;thenodal
displacementof theisoparametricbrick eightnodeelementisgivenby
The displacement field through the element isdescribedthroughinterpolating
functions called the trial or theshapefunctions. Theshapefunctionsaredependent on
the type of element and the degrees of freedom that may bedisplacementsor their
derivativeswithrespect to spatial coordinateof theproblem.
3.1.2.2.Selection Of Shape Functions
Thedomainof theproblemisdividedinto subdomainscalled"thefiniteelements"
as showninFigure(3.1). Theseelementswill betreated onebyoneleadingto formation
of equations of equilibriumor motion for eachelement. Thentheseequationswill be
assembled into overall system equations. The continuity of the system is achieved
through points ontheboundaryof theelementcalledthenodes.
3.1.2.1. Discretization
3.1.2. Systematic Steps of the Finite Element Method
73
where
(3.8)
For Co elementssuchastheusedeightnodebrick element; Ni maybechosenintheform:
(3.6)
(3.7)
Ni (Xi' yj' ZJ =I(Identitymatrix)
Nj(xpYj'Z) =0 (Null matrix)
functionsmust satisfy
The function family(Ni)ischosensoasto giveappropriatenodal displacements
when the coordinates of the appropriate nodes are inserted. Generally, the shape
(3.5)
u =t }
whereuisthegenericdisplacementvector, i.e.,
(3.4)
The relation between u and aeusingtheshapefunctionmatrixN canbewrittenas :
(3.3) N=N(x,y,z)
position only; i.e.,
The nodal displacement vector is related to the generic displacement vector u
through the shape functions' matrix N. These functions are polynomials of the spatial
74
and
Uj
v
I
{ : } = [ ~;
0 0 N. 0 0
" " " J
Wj
J
Nj 0 0 Nj 0
...
uj (3.15)
0 N. 0 0 N.
Vj
1
J
w
J
Equations (3.4) and(3.11) mayberewrittenas
(3.14)
(3.13)
(3.12)
r =thegenericcoordinatevector ={~}
rn=thenodal coordinatevector ={ rj}
r; = thecoordinatevector of nodei= { ~: }
where
(3.11) r=Nr
n
Because thiselementisanisoparametricelement(IronsandAhmedI980C21); the
same interpolation functions(Ni'S) areusedalsoto mapgeometry of original elementin
the space (x,y,z) into a normalized natural space (l; ,ll,l; ) that extend in every axis
betweenthevalues-1&1,hence:
(3.9)
(3.10) N.(x. y. z.) = 0
1 J' J' J
7S
displacementaregiveninamatrixformasfollows:
For thecaseof threedimensional stress statetherelationshipsbetween strainand
3.1.2.3.1. Strain - Displacement Relationship
3.1.2.3. Static Case Formulation
(3.17)
We have 24 degreesof freedomand8shapefunctions(i.e., onefor eachnode),
the shape functionsareoftenexpressedusingthemappedspacecoordinateof thepoint;
i.e., for node i having the mapped coordinates (~i, lli, ~i), thecorrespondingshape
functionsNi aregivenby(Zienkiewics1977c55):
x
I
Yi
m = n ;
0 0 Nj 0 0
00 O J
Zi
N. 0 0 Nj 0
...
Xj (3.16)
I
0 N. 0 0 Nj
Yj
I
z
J
76
(3.22)
As it has previously been shown that A matrix isadifferential operator with
respect to x, yandz whileN matrixisdefinedinthemappedspace, sotheN matrixisto
bedifferentiatedwithrespect to x, yandzusingthechainruleasfollows:
O N . a N . a x O N . O y O N . a z
-' =-'.-+-'._+-'.-
a ~ a x a ~ O y a ~ a z a ~
O N . O N . a x aN. O y aN. a z
-' =-'.-+-' .-+-'.-
m, a x m, O y m, a z m,
aN. aN. a x a N . O y a N . az
-' = -' .-+-'--+-'.-
al; a x e; O y al; a z a ;
(3.21) B=AN
where
(3.20)
Recallingequations(3.4) and(3.19); wecanobtain:
3.1.2.3.2. Strain-Nodal Displacement Relationship
wheretheA matrixisthestrain-displacementmatrix
(3.19) E =Au
a
0 0
a x
a
Ex
0
-
0
O y
Ey
a
{ : }
Ez
0 0
a z
=
a a
(3.18)
yxy
-
0
yyz
O y a x
a a
Y zx
0
-
az O y
a a
0
-
a z a x
or
77
.SotheJ matrixmaybewrittenas
(3.26)
y=:LNsi
Z ="" Nz.
L.J I 1
but theelementisanisoparametricelementsothat
Ox By a z
- -
a; a; a;
Ox iJ y a z
(3.25)
J =
- -
i1rl i1rl i7 rl
Ox iJ y a z
- -
a;; a;; a;
where J istheJacobianmatrixandisgivenby
ONi
ONi
a;
Ox
ON. ON.
I
=J
_1
(3.24)
i7 rl
By
ON. aN.
1 _1
a; a z
or
ON Ox By a z
ON. 1
-
_1
~ ~ ~ ~ Ox
ON.
Ox By a Z ON.
1 1
(3.23)
=
-
i1rl i1rl i1rl i1rl
By
ON. Ox By a Z ON.
1
-
1
a; a; a; a;
a z
which may be best written inthe matrix notation as follows:
78
aN. aNi
__ I
Ox ~
aN.
=J-I
aN.
I
__ I
(3.29)
Oy
C rt
aNi aNi
a z a;
or
In order to obtainthederivativeof N's withrespect to X, Yandz; thefollowing
equationisused:
Xl
YI
ZI
aNI
aN2 aN3 aN4 aN5 aN6 ON7 ONs
X2
Y2
Z2
a; a; a;
~ ~ ~
a;
a;
X3
Y3
Z3
J =
ONI aN2 aN3 aN4 aNS aN6 ON7
B NS
X4
Y4
Z4
(3.28)
C rt C rt C rt C rt C rt C rt C rt C rt
X5
Y5
Z5
ONI aN2 aN3 aN4 aN5 ON6 ON7 aNs
X6
Y6
Z6
~ ~ ~
a; a;
~ ~
a;
x7
Y7
Z7
Xs
Ys
Zs
Thismay berewritteninthefollowingform
(3.27)
aNI ON2
--Z +--Z +...
a; I a; 2
aNI ON2
--Z +--Z +:..
C rt I C rt 2
aNI aN2
--Z +--Z +...
~ I ~ 2
ONI aN2
--X +--X +:..
a; I a; 2
ONI aN2
--X +--X +..
C rt I C rt 2
ONI aN2
--X +--X +...
~ I ~ 2
J =
79
The stress-strain relationship for linearelasticsolidspacemaybeobtainedfrom
thegeneralizedHooke's lawinthreedimensional spaceasfollows
3.1.2.3.3. Stress - Strain Relationship
(3.31)
where
(3.30)
aNI
aN2 aN3 aN4 aNs aN6 aN, aNg
Ox Ox Ox Ox Ox Ox Ox Ox
aNI
aN2 aN3 aN4
aN~
aN6 aN, aNg
Oy Oy Oy Oy Oy Oy Oy Oy
aNI
aN2 aN3 aN4 aNs aN6 aN, aNg
(}z
8z
(}z
a z 8z 8z
(}z
8z
aNI
aN2 aN3 aN4
aN~
aN6 aN7 aNg
a; a; a; a; a; a; a;
a~
=J-1
aNI
8N2 aN3 aN4 aNS aN6 aN7 aNg
Ofl Ofl Ofl Ofl Ofl Ofl Ofl Ofl
aNI
aN2
8N3
aN4 aNs aN6 aN7 aNg
e x; e x; e x; e x; e x; e x; e x; e x;
80
or inmatrix form
(3.34)
G= E
2(1+v)
are the shear stress components along the planes yz, zx and xy
respectively.
and the law of the elastic constants
Y xy, Y yz, Y zx
respectively.
isthe shear modulus of elasticity
are the shear stress components along the planes yz, zx and xy
G
where
(3.33)
For shear strains
are the normal stress components along the X,yand z axes respectively.
are the normal strain components along the x.y and z axes respectively.
isthe Y oung's modulus of elasticity E
where
(3.32)
Ex=~[ax - vay - vaz]
Ey=~[ay - vo, - vaz]
s, =~[az - vay - vax]
For normal strains
81
(3.40)
Thuswehave
I-v v v 0 0 0
v 1- v v 0 0 0
v v I-v 0 0 0
E
0 0 0
1-2v
0
D=
0
(I +v)(I- 2v)
2
1-2v
0 0 0 0 0
2
0 0 0 0 0
1-2v
2
(3.39)
therefore
(3.38) D =C-1
where
(3.37)
Thepreviousequationmayberewritteninthefollowingform:
" =DE
whereC isthecompliancematrix.
(3.36)
or
Ex
1 -v -v 0 0 0
O" X
Ey
- V 1 - V 0 0 0
O" y
Ez
1
-v -v 1 0 0 0
O" z
-
2(1+v)
(3.35)
y xy
E 0 0 0 0 0 ' t xy
y yz
0 0 0 0 2(1+v) 0 ' t yz
Y z x
0 0 0 0 0 2(1+v)
' t z x
82
(3.49) K" is the element stiffness matrix
(3.48) qe is the equivalent nodal force vector =pe+f bNT dV
V
where
(3.47)
that may be written inthe well known form
(3.46)
Equating the internal and the external work we get
pe +f bNTdV = f BTDB dV ae
v v
(3.45)
(3.44) pe ={pei}is the nodal force vector
{
FeX i}
P'i =F:,:: arethenodal forcesatnodei
F Z,'
where
(3.43)
T
The external work =0 ae pe
(3.42)
_ _ {F:x:}
b =the body force vector
where
v v
internal work is equal to the external work. Thus
Applying a virtual nodal displacement oae, then due to the equilibrium, the
3.1.2.3.4. Element Stiffness Matrix "Virtual Work Approach"
(3.56)
(3.55)
(3.54)
(3.53)
(3.52)
(3.51)
(3.50)
83
or alternatively
pe +J bNTdV =J BTDB dV ae
y y
therefore
For equilibrium A must be minimumand hence
Thus we have
U (the strain energy) =.! J ETO'EdV =.!J acTBTDBacdV
2y 2y
W (the work done) =J uTb dV +aeTpc =aeTJ NTbdV +aeTp
y y
where
A=U- W
The potential energy A is given by
3.1.2.3.5. Element Stiffness Matrix "Minimum Potential Energy Approach"
84
whereC isthedampingmatrix.
(3.60)
Adopting the previous sequence, damping forces will develop in additionto
inertiaforces, thustheequationof motionof anelementwill beintheform:
3.1.3.2. Damped Case
(3.59)
whereM iscalledtheconsistent massmatrixandisdefinedby
(3.58)
e Ke e+Me..e
q = a a
writetheequationof motionas
The only change in equation (3.48) isto replacethetermbbyterm-pNie, sowecan
(3.57) dFj = -iipdV = -pN ae dV
The only difference between this caseandthestaticcaseisthedevelopment of
inertiabodyforcegivenbyd'Alembertprincipleasfollows:
3.1.3.1. Undamped Case
3.1.3. Dynamic Case Formulation
85
(3.65)
co co
f(t) =a, +2:aj cosjrot+2:bj sinjrot
j=J j=J
The previous analysiscanbeextendedfor anyperiodT as showninFigure(3.2)
bythefollowingequation
(3.64)
(3.63)
(3.62)
1 211
ao =-2 J f(t) dt
1t 0
1211
aj=-J f(t) cosjtdt
1t 0
1211
bj=-J f(t) sinjtdt
1t0
where
(3.61)
co co
f(t) =a, +2:aj cosjt+ 2:bj sinjt
j=J j=l
withtheperiod T =21t:
Fourier representedhisseriesfor periodic functionsbasedontheorthogonalityof
the sine and cosine functionsover theinterval [O,21t],thus for aperiodic function (t)
3.2.1.1. Fourier Series/or Periodic Functions
3.2.1. Introduction
3.2. EXPANSION OF FORCING FUNCTIONS BY FOURIER SERIES
shown inthe next section.
Although equation(3.60) has introduced the damping effect inthe solution, the
technique of damping introduction depends mainly on the solution method as will be
86
and
(3.72)
where
(3.71)
00
f(t) =~cjeiIDjt
j=-oo
F(t)can berewritten inthe form
(3.70)
eiIDt _ e-iIDt
sinrot =----
2i
cosrot =----
2
eiIDt=cosrot +i sinrot =>
From the Euler relation
3.2.1.2. The Complex Form of Fourier Series
(3.69)
2T
bj=-J f(t) sinjrotdt
To
(3.68)
2T
aj =TJ f(t) cos jrotdt
o
(3.67)
(3.66)
_ 21t
ro=-
T
where
87
The evaluation of each Cjinthe OFT needs N complex multiplication. Thus we
have to do N2 complex multiplication operations to evaluate all terms of'Cj. Similarly, N2
complex multiplications are needed to complete the process of the IDFT.
3.2.1.4. Fast Fourier Transform (FFT)
(3.77)
and Inverse Discrete Fourier transform (IDFT) isgiven by
(3.76)
N-J N-l .(271.)(Tk N-I (-2m).k
C
- ~c -imjlk_ ~c -IT'J N') _ ~c N"
j- """lk e - """lk e - """lk e
k=O k=O k=O
(OFT) isgiven by:
The application of Fourier Transform inthe numerical analysis is accomplished by
defining the function f1:t) as a set ofN discrete points as inFigure (3.3). Dividing the
frequency to N equal divisions (viz. 2n1T, 4n1T, etc.), the Discrete Fourier Transform
3.2. 1.3.Discrete Form of Fourier and Inverse Fourier Transform
(3.75)
T
Cj =J f(t) e-imj'dt
o
where
(3.74)
1~ i<tJI
f(t) = - """Cje j
T j=-oo
or in another form:
(3.73)
Olj=Jffi
88
(3.82)
N/2-1
Cj =L(fk +e-i7Ikfk+NI2)Wkj
k=O
or
(3.81)
N-l N/2-1 N-l
Cj = LfkWkj = LfkWkj +LfkWkj
k=O k=O k=N/2
hence
(3.80)
definingWas
(3.79)
N-l -271;
~ (-)kj.
Cj =LJ fk e N ,J =0,1,2, ... , N-l
k=O
where M is an integer. Thisconstraint isintroducedto simplifytheresultingalgorithm.
NowrecallingtheDFT
(3.78)
Chapra and Canale (1990f8 had described aFFT techniquecalledtheSande-
Turkey Algorithm, thisalgorithmrequires thenumber of pointsto beanintegral power
of2, i.e.,
reduce number of operations.
The Fast Fourier Transforms (FFT), are algorithms that have been developed by
many researchers to compute the Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT) inan economical
fashion, they speed the transform by utilizing the results of the previous computation to
89
(3.89)
(N/2)-1
C2j+1 =Lh, W2kj
k=O
and
(3.88)
(N/2)-1
'" 2k
C2j =LJgtW J
k=O
thus
(3.87)
and
(3.86)
Usingthe following functions each of length N/2
(3.85)
(N/2)-1
'" k 2k
C2j+1 =LJ (ft-fk+N/2)W W J
k=O
and for odd number
(3.84)
the equation (3.82) can be rewritten for even terms
(3.83)
Usingthe relation
90
u isthedisplacementvector at time(t).
U isthedisplacementamplitudevector.
where
(3.91)
Thesteadysolutionisassumedto begivenby
(3.90) P=Peiwt
o
If weassumeharmonicloadingintheform
3.2.2.1. Harmonic Loading
3.2.2. The Complex Response Method
This algorithm needs N log2(N) complex addition and Y 2 N log2(N)complex
multiplication. The reduction of the computational time which results from this
formulation is significant when the time interval is divided into a large number of
increments. Another aspect of theFFT algorithmisthat theorder of computedCj's is
differentfromthenatureorder asshowninFigure(3.5).
inFigure(3.5).
Using thisapproach 'divide and conquer" repeatedlywill beeventually as shown
points.
An insight look of equations (3.88) and (3.89) shows that, the N point
computation has been replaced by two (N/2) point computations. Becauseeachof the
latter requires (N/2)2 complex multiplications andadditions, thisapproachproduces a
factor of2 savings(i.e., N2 versus 2(N/2i=N2/2 ). Figure(3.4) showstheprocedurefor 8
91
(3.97)
and the dynamic stiffness S is then given by:
(3.96)
There are many approaches to introduce the effect of the damping, one of themis
by modifying the K matrix (Wolf 1985c53) as follows:
Where S is called the dynamic stiffness.
(3.95) s=K - ill2M +iroC
Where
(3.94) su=P,
or
(3.93)
Substituting equations (3.90) and (3.91) inequation (3.92), we get
(3.92) Mii+CiI +Ku =P
The equation of motion of the systemis given as
92
(3.99)
thefollowingequation:
Thus the displacementvector inthefrequencydomainU(roj) canbesolvedfor. Thenwe
canusetheInverseFourier Transformto calculatethedisplacement timehistoryU(tk)by
(3.98)
By applying the Discrete Fourier Transform to the forcing function, the
amplitudes of the loads in the frequency domain P(roj), are calculatedat all discrete
frequencies(roj). The equationof motioninthefrequencydomain becomes:
3.2.2.2. General Loading
It may be note that the dynamic stiffness matrix is dependent on the loading
frequency. This method does not suffer from the drawbacks of the other methods in
introducing of the damping, in addition to its similarity with the static equation of
equilibrium which facilitate the using of the static equation solvers.
93
(3.102)
1
I = = - [ f(- 1)+4f(0) +f(1)]
3
For n=3; theSimpsonrulecanbeobtained:
(3.101) I = = f(- 1) +f(1)
therangeof[ - I ,I ] . For example, ifn =2, wehavethewell- knowntrapezoidal rule:
where Hi is the weight of theequal- spaceddifferentpointsf(ti) definingthefunctionin
(3.100)
1 n
1= f _ f(t) dt= = L H i f{tJ
1 i= l
1- Newton-Cotes Quadrature inwhichtheintegrandistobecalculatedat somediscrete
points - usually at equal intervals - as shown inFigure(3.6a) usingapolynomial
passing through these points. As n values of the functiondefinesapolynomial of
degree n- l, theerror will beof theorder D(An) whereA isthepoint spacingand0
isthetruncation error function. Usingthismethod, theintegrationcanbewrittenas
I t has been shown that both stiffnessandmassmatricesresult fromintegration
over the volume of the element. Theseintegrationsarecalculatednumericallybytwo
basicmethods(Zienkiewics 1977c'j'j):
3.3.1. Methods for Numerical Integration
3.3. NUMERICAL INTEGRATION (QUADRATURE)
94
(3.105)
f2(l;) =f/l(l1,l;) d11=Hl1(l1j,l;)
j =l
constant, i.e.,
where nisthenumber of Gausspoints, thento integratewithrespect to 11andkeepingl;
(3.104)
isto first evaluatetheinner integral, keeping 11,l; constant, i.e.,
(3.103)
111
I =f f If(~, 11,l;)d~d11dl;
-1-1-1
Themost obviouswayof obtainingtheintegral
3.3.2. Evaluation of Element Matrices byNumerical Integration
coefficientsfor Gaussianquadrature.
2- Gauss Quadrature Insteadof specifyingthepositionof samplingpointsapriori, we
allow these to beallocatedat someplacessoasto achieveanincreasingaccuracy. If
we reconsider equation(3.100) andassumeagainapolynomial expression, thusfor n
sampling points we have 2nunknowns(Hi,ti)andhenceapolynomial of thedegree
(2n-l) could be constructed and exactly integrated, the error will beof theorder
O(A2n),as shown inFigure(3.6b). Thesimultaneousequations involvedaredifficult
to solve, but somemathematical manipulationshowsthat thesolutioncanbeobtained
explicitly in terms of Legendrepolynomials.Thusthismethodisfrequentlyknownas
Gauss-Legendre quadrature. Table (3.1) shows the positions and weighting
95
where (Hi, Hj, Hk) are the Gauss weights and (~i,11;, ~) are the coordinates of the Gauss
points. To calculate the integration exactly for this element we need 2x2x2=8 Gauss
points as indicated inFigure(3. 7).
(3.109)
11 1
Me =H I pNtN dxdydz =I I I pNtN detlJ I d~dlldl;
v - 1- 1- 1
and
(3.108)
1 1 1
Ke =I I I BtDB dxdydz =I I I BtDB detlJ I d~dlldl;
v - 1- 1- 1
respectively as follows:
hence, the expressions for the element stiffness and mass matrices are evaluated
(3.107)
From the above equations one may write
(3.106)
finallyto integrate with respect to l; , i.e.,
96
Theassumedshapefunctionshavethefollowingtwo important properties:
1.Theyarepolynomialsinthespatial coordinatesof theproblem.
The finite element discretization results in transforming thepartial differential
equation governing the continuum into a set of discretelinearor non-linear algebraic
equations or ordinary differential equations, asshowninFigure(3.10) asanexamplein
staticanalysisof 3Dsolidlinearelasticcontinuum
3.5.1. Equations Resulting From The Finite Element Method
3.5. SOLVER OFEQUATIONS
G vector isusedto addthecoefficientsof thelocal matricesintheir appropriate
placesintheglobal matricesasshowninFigure(3.9).
G ={O0 1 0 0 4 5 0 6 2 0 3 0 7 8 0 12 13 14 15 16 9 10 ll}t
Unrestrained joints have threedegreesof freedomfor each, boundaryjoint may
have fewer degrees of freedom. Eachdegreeof freedomisassignedauniquenumber,
this may be done aseconomicallyaspossibleto reducethebandwidthof theproblem
thus reducingthestorageof theglobal matrices. Thevector G containingthenumbersof
the degrees of freedom for an element is called thesteeringvector, for examplethe
element 1 inFigure(3.8) hasthesteeringvector
3.4. ASSEMBLY OFELEMENT MATRICES INTO SYSTEM MATRICES
97
We can find the unknown displacements (u) by getting the inverse of S.
Practically, the method of solution is to decompose the S into upper and lower
triangular matrixandproceedinforward andbackward substitutionsasfollows:
where the S matrix istheglobal stiffnessmatrix, uistheunknowndisplacementvector
andP isthenodal loadvector.
(3.110) Su=p
The used compiler (Lahey/Ergo 1992) makesuseof theextendedmemoryand
can createavirtual memoryonthedisk, thustheordinaryLU solver of Choleskyisused.
Theresultingequationsystemwill beinthefollowingmatrixform:
3.5.2. Cholesky Solver
The amount of storage depends not only on the number of degrees of freedom
but also on the band of the matrix. In 3D finite element analysis the amount of storage
required for the matrices is enormous and the storage of the complete matrices incore
may even be impossible for an ordinary language compiler because of the large number
of the degrees of freedom and the large band of" the equations. The used compiler
(Lahey/Ergo 1992) has the ability to address the extended RAM.
2. They are piecewise continuous with the degree of continuation depending on the
problem.
The use of piecewise functions leads to bandedness of the assembled matrices
thus we can reduce the amount of storage by not storing the zero terms that arise off
diagonal. Another aspect of the assembled matrices istheir symmetry about the main
diagonal that leads to storage of half-banded matrices as shown inFigure (3.11)
98
(3.119)
1sj~N
j-l
ljj = s,-~)\
r=l
the decomposition matrix L isgiven by itselement [lij]using the following equations:
(3.118)
S=L.LT
(3.117)
U=LT
or
unknowns issymmetrical, inthiscase:
Cholesky method applies only to cases where the matrix of coefficients of the
(3.116)
U=U-Iy
(3.115)
Y=L-lp
(3.114) LY=P
(3.113) U.u=Y
(3.112) LUu=P
(3.111) S=LU
Using backward substitution we can get
Usingforward substitution we can get
we got
Using the substitution
99
were innovated by the author basedonthepreviousconcepts. Somesubroutines were
borrowedfromSmith(1982f46 andChapraandCanale(1990f8.
A FORTRAN programusingthepreviousprocedures hasbeendeveloped bythe
author to analyzetheproblemof machinefoundationinteraction. Figures(9.14) to (9.16)
show thestructural chartsof theprogram(Smith1982c46).Most of theusedsubroutines
3.6. THE COMPUTER PROGRAM
whereHB isthehalfband width
(3.122)
j+l~i~N
HB+j-i
S..- "I.}.(. .)
y L... II" j,1+r-j
I.. = r=l
y I
j,(HB+l)
(3.121)
HB
Ij,(HB+l) = Sj,(HB+l) - _Ll~r
r=l
Equations (3.119) and(3.120) maybewritteninthebandedmatricesas shownin
Figure(3.13) to be
where N is the number of equations. An insightof theprevious equationsclarifiesits
columnwiseorder asshowninFigure(3.12).
I..
II
I
r=l
..=_---!.:=-_
u
(3.120)
j-l
Sij-_Llirljr
100
Figure(3. 2) Periodicjunction withperiod T
T T T
f(t)
Figure (3.1) Discretization of 3D solid continuum into ''finite elements"
AnEJement
I
I
I "-+-+--;;
4~__ __ 8
/
/
7
3
"elements"
Domain discretized
into subclomains
Table (3.1) Gauss quadrature points and weights
n t H n t H
1 0.0000 2.0000 6 0.9325 0.1713
2 0.5774 1.0000 0.6612 0.3608
3 0.7746 0.5556 0.2386 0.4679
0.0000 0.8889 7 0.9491 0.1295
4 0.8611 0.3479 0.7415 0.2797
0.3400 0.6521 0.4058 0.3818
5 0.9062 0.2369 0.0000 0.4180
0.5385 0.4786
0.0000 0.5689
101
Figure (3.5) Flow graph of the complete FFT, full
decomposition of Ni-pointDFTfor N =8
f a CO
0
W
f 1 C4
f2 C2
0
f 3
W
C6
f 4 C1
0
f 5
W
cs
fa C3
f7 C7
+
Figure (3.4) Flow graph of thefirst stage in FFT, decomposition
of N-point DFT into two Nl2-point DFTsfor N =8
f O
gO
f 1 91
N/2 - Point
f 2
g2
DFT
f 3
g3 . .
0
hO
f 4
W
1
h1
f 5
W
N/2 - Point
2
h2
f 6
W
DFT
+
3
h3
f7
W
+
Figure(3. 3) Discrete points defining thefunction
T T T
\ I
\ 1
\ I
\ 1
\ ......." /
......__/ \ /1
, 1
_I
/'--\
f \
1 \
I \
/ \
,..--,
f \
1 \
I \
/ \
f(t)
102
Figure(3. 7) Gauss points for 8-node brick element
Gauss point
Node
Each integrates exactly a seventh order polynomial
Figure(3.6) (a)Newton-Cotes and (b)Gauss integrations.
(b)
10.86114 )1
x x X
0.33998
v k
o
-1
f
_ _ . . . - -
~r--
/
t
-,
(a)
H
fF.1/7
o
-1
f
~,..-
~........,
/
t \.
-,
103
Figure(3. 10) Equations of continuum versus equations of the Finite Element Method
Keae =pe
Ke =f f f BtDB dV
v
0'x.x+'tyx,y +'tzx,z +Fx =0
O'y,y+'txy,x +'tzy,z +Fy =0
0'z.z+'tyz,y+'txz,x +F, =0
/ /
I
I
I
I
.-
[7
L/
For each finite element For aninfinitesimal element
/ C Iz
Finite element equations Continuum equations
Figure (3.9) Usage of steering vector to assemble elements' matrices
Addition
J
Addition
PdcmaK Disp
G(i)
G(j)
:Kglobal
in y direction
Figure (3. 8) - Steering vector" example"
Displacement restrained in
all directions
0,0,0
34,35,36
Displacement restrained
104
Figure(3.12) Order of Cholesky 's decomposition
o
L =
Columnwise order
of evaluation
Figure(3.11) Storage of the half banded matrix
Actual matrix Half-bandedmatrix
r .
. r
r _
r .
" ' .
r
I e I .
I
I -
I.
I.
r e
laI .~
I
I
I.
I . e
r e er.
--
I .
I -
!
I-
I .
rn
.~
I
.t:
t$
~
.~
~
....
.....
~
C U
...J
E
ro
~
'--'
::J ! :! ::- ,
.....
:i. ~
~
.....
]
.~
.t:
t$
~
-
~
.0
...-
.;::
+
:::::
V)
m
~
0
I
Q)
......
0)
8
~
-
0
:r
1i)
~
- -
- s
....L ...
rn tn
"0
...-
Q) :::::
+
I
"U
rn
c
~
I
C U
~
- -
.c
-ro
~
I
~
:::::
.0
.;::
~
~
~
......
~
~
m
.[0
I ~
.~
....
.....
cu
tn
E
ro
::J
.....
:i.
...-
+
rn
I
. ~
....
.....
-
cu
:r
E
X
...J
"U
m
Q)
..-
"U
+
I
c
rn
C U
I
.c
- -
- ro
I
106
- Find solution of the prescribed DOF's
-End
Figure (3.15) Structural chartfor the static program
(After Smith, 1982)
- Read the element stiffness matrix
- Assemble the element stiffness matrix into
the global stiffness matrix using the
steering vector
- Reduce the complete equation and modify the
coefficients of required DOF.
For each element
- Declaration and initialization of variables
- Define input and output data files
- Read the loaded DOF and the magitude of
each load
- Null the global stiffness matrix
- Null the load vector
- Formthe new load vector.
Figure(3.14) Structural chartjor element matrices' program
(After Smith, 1982)
- Write the mass and stiffness matrices to output files
e
- Add this contribution to the element mass matrix M
t
- Find the product p N N
- Find the product of p Nt N by (H;.H~Hk. IJ I)
e
- Add this contribution to the element stiffness matrix K
- Calculate the derivative of the shape functions in the global
coordinates
- Formthe strain displacement matrix B
- Find the product of DB
t
- Transpose B to B
t
- Find the product of B DB
- Find the product of B DB by (H;.Hj.Hk. IJ I)
-1
J and its determinate
- Calculate the J acobian matrix J
- Calculate the inverse of the J acobian
IJ I
- Formthe element shape functions and their derivatives inthe
local coordinates
For a/I Gaussian integration pOints
- Read the element properties, nodal coordinates and steering vector
- Null the element stiffness and mass matrices
- Formthe stress strain Matrix 0
For all elements
- Declaration and inilialization of variables
- Define input data files
107
Figure (3.16) Structural chartfor the dynamic program
(After Smith, 1982)
- Declaration and initialization of variables
- Define input and output data files
- Read the loaded OOF , the frequency and phase of
each load
For each Fourier mode
- Null the complex global stiffness matrix
- Null the complex load vector
- Findthe frequency of that mode
- Formthe newcomplex load vector using FFT
For each element
- Read the element stiffness matrix
- Formthe element consistent mass matrix
- Formthe complex element stiffness matrix
- Assemble the element dynamic stiffness
matrix into the global complex stiffness matrix
using the steering vector
- Reduce the complete equation and modify the
coefficients of required DOF.
- Findthe solution of each mode
- Rearange the data obtained from the solution of
each mode
- Apply the inverse Fourier transform to get the
history of the response of theprescribed DOF's
- For all time steps, isolate the real and print the
maximum response of the prescribed DOF's
-End
108
In this chapter, theresultsof thisparametricstudyarediscussedfor thedifferent
casesusingnon-dimensional chartsto explaintheeffect of eachparameter.
1. The effect of the different parameters of the vertical harmonicforcingfunctions
actingonsurfacefootings(i.e., thefrequency, theamplitudeandthephase)
2. Effect of thespacingbetweensurfacefootingsontheir interaction.
3. Effect of thesoil depthto theunderlyingfirmstratumontheinteractionbetweenthe
machinefootings.
4. Effect of thefoundations' embedmentontheir response.
S. Use of trenches to reduce the interaction between the adjacent machinesurface
footings.
It is aimed in this research to study the mutual interaction between the
machine foundations. A model of two footingswithdifferentconfigurationsandforcing
functions, isstudied. Thefollowingparametershavebeeninvestigated:
4.1. INTRODUCTION
Parametric Study
Chapter (4)
109
The results of dimensionless magnification factor (M,=ZstatiJ Zdynamic) versus the
dimensionless frequency factor for the first footing FI (Ao) are shown inFigure (4.2) for
four cases of FFR (FFR=0.0,1.0,2.0 and 3.0) at spacing (s=O.5B). The results of other
spacings are shown inAppendix (A). The case of singlefooting (FFR=O.O) is considered
4.2.3.1. Effect of Spacing and the Forcing Frequency Ratio (FFR)
A comprehensive discussion of the parametric study results is given in the
following parts:
4.2.3. Results and Discussion
1. The spacing of the footings s(sIB =0.5,1,1.5,2 and 3, where B is footing width).
2. The forcing frequency ratio FFR=ffi2/rol (FFR=0,1,2 and 3).
3. The forcing amplitude ratio FAR=P2/PI (FAR=0,0.5,1,1.5 and 2).
4. The forcing phase difference FPD= 9 (FPD =0,45,90,180,270 and 315).
The studied parameters are:
4.2.2. The Studied Parameters
The model consists of two identical square surface footings FI and F2as shown in
Figure( 4. 1), each footing has amass ratio (Bz) equals to 5. The properties of the soil and
foundation element are given in Table (4.1). The two footings FI and F2are loaded by
vertical harmonic forces given by PI cos (rolt) and P2cos (ID2t+9),respectively.
4.2. INTERACTION OF SURFACE FOOTINGS
4.2.1. The Studied Model
110
Figure (4.3) shows the peak values of Mz normalized using M, for asingle
footingat differentspacingversustheFFR. Itappearsthat themost pronouncedeffect of
the interaction appears whenFFR=l andthiseffect decreasesbyincreasingthespacing
or having two frequenciesmuchdifferentfromeachother. Theresponseof thefootings
decreases with values of FFR other than unity and until it approaches singlefooting
behaviour, the response also approaches single footing behaviour withincreasingthe
spacing.
The peaks of all cases are scanned andlistedinTable(4.2), theresultsof the
study show that theinteractiondiminishes at large(sIB) ratios andpracticallyvanishes
for thecaseof(sIB=3.0).
as a reference for each spacing to eliminate the error due to the mesh choice. For FFRs
other than the unity and zero, the curve has two peaks each one corresponds to the
resonance of one of the two footings. The case of (ID2=0)characterized asingleactive
footing (FI), this case will be designated as singlefooting (FI). Inspection of the results
in this case indicates that the vibration of the inactive footing (F2) is considerably large
(i.e., MzI =3.09andMz2 =2.4) becauseof small sIBratio. Thetwo footingsexhibitone
peak at (Ao=O.4)which is comparabletothat of thehalf spaceanalysisfor (Bz=5.0)as
shown in Figure (2.19). Thisvalueassuresthegood choiceof themeshingparameters.
The caseof (ID2=roi or FFR=1.0) hasthegreatest responseof other casesof FFRs witha
single peak at thepreviousfrequencyratio (Ao==O.4). Thefootingpeaks(MzI=Mz2=5.37)
are almost the sum of the two peaksof theactiveandinactivefootingsinthecaseof
single footing(FFR=O.O), whichmeansthat thereisdiminutivephasedifferencebetween
the two footings. For the cases of two differentfrequencies(FFR+':1.0),therearetwo
peaks for eachcurverepresentingthebehaviour of thefootings, oneat (Ao=O.4)for the
footing of lower frequency(FI),andtheother peak islocated at Ao==0.2for FFR =2.0
and A o ==0.13for FFR=3.0. Thesevaluescorrespondto resonanceoffooting (F2). Due
to thisbiasbetweenthetwo peaksintheir frequencyratio, theinteractionislessthanthe
caseof equal frequenciesandaboutthesameof thecaseof singlefooting.
111
The results of M, versus Ao areshowninFigures(4.7) and(4.8) for thecases
s/B=0.5, FFR=1 and 3 andFPD=O,45, 90, 180,270 and315. Theresultsof other
spacingsareshowninAppendix(A).
4.2.3.3. Effect of the Forcing Phase Difference (FPD)
Peak values arescannedandsummarizedin Table(4.3) for thedifferentcasesof
FFR and FAR of Figures (4.4) and (4.5). Figure (4.6) showsthepeak valuesof'M,
normalized usingthevalueof thecase(FAR=I.0) to showtheeffect of theFAR ratio on
the response of the two footings, the most pronounced effect of theFAR ratioisat
(FFR=3.0 ands/B=0.5), but it must bekept inmindthat thiscaseislesscritical thanthe
case of (FFR=l.O) whichinducedalargeinteractionresponseasshowninFigure(4.3).
Itis also to be noted that, the relationbetweenthenormalizingresponseandFARis
linearlyvariedfor (FFR=l.O) andnon-linearlyvariedfor other ratios ofFFR.
Figure (4.4) showstherelationbetweentheM, andAo inthecase (s/B=O.5and
FFR=1) for the four cases of FAR. Theresultsshowthat, theincreasingof theacting
loadincreasestheresponseof thefootings. For examplecomparingthecaseof (P2=0.5P1
or FAR=0.5) withthepeakvaluesareMzl=4.10andMz2=3. 79, againstthecase(P2=2P1
or FAR=2.0) withthepeaksareMzl=7.56andMz2=8.23, showstheincreaseinresponse
for both footings when increasing the forces' magnitudes. Figure(4.5) showsMs-A,
relation for the same spacingbut at (FFR=3.0). Inthiscasetheinteractionismuchless
than the case of (FFR=l.O), it isobservedthat increasingtheloadofF2, increasesthe
responsebut inalessratethaninthecaseof (FFR=I.0).
The results of M, versus A, areshowninFigures(4.4) and(4.5) for thecases
s/B=0.5, FFR=1 and 3 andFAR=0.5,1,1.5 and2. CurveswithFFR=l.Ohaveonepeak
and that withFFR=3.0havetwo biasedpeaksasitwas showninthepreviouspart. The
resultsof other spacingsareshowninAppendix(A).
4.2.3.2. Effect of the Forcing Amplitude Ratio (FAR)
112
Peak values are scanned and summarized inTable (4.4)for the different cases of
FPD at (FFR=1.0). Figure( 4.9) shows that the out of phase response isgreater than the
in phase response by 10%for s/B=1.5 and FFR=l.O. For sib =0.5 and FFR=l.O, out of
phase response is greater than the inphase response by 3%. It seems also that the effect
of the phase difference is much reduced at higher FFR.
The single peak at (FFR=1.0), which was observed inthe previous cases, is no
longer dominate, considering the phase difference, at (FPD=1800). For example, two
trifling peaks are espied at the same frequency (FFR=I.0). The out of phase response
may increase or decrease depending on the angle of phase difference, for FFR=1.0 and
FPD=O.O Mzl=5.25 and Mz2=5.27, when increasing the forcing phase difference by 45
the peaks are Mz1=5.38 and Mz2=4.35; i.e., this increase ofFPD increases the response of
F, and inthe same time decreases the response ofF2. At FPD=180 the response will be
minimum for both footings, Mzl=2.19 and Mz2=2.19 and then by increasing the FPD the
response of the two footings increases.
Curves with FFR=l.O have one peak and that with FFR=3.0 have two biased
peaks as it was shown inthe previous part. Itcan be shown that any value of 9(phase
difference) less than 180 has acorresponding angle (9+180) where the footings F1and
F2 exchange their response due to the symmetry of the problem, therefore the discussion
is limited to phase difference between 0 and 180.
113
A comprehensive discussion of the parametric study results is given in the
followingparts.
4.3.3. Results and Discussion
1.TheembedmentdepthwidthratioDJ B (DJB =0.0,0.25 and0.50).
2. Theforcingfrequencyratio FFR=(C02/COl) (FFR=1/3,1and3).
3. TheforcingamplituderatioFAR=(P2/Pl) (FAR=0.5,1and2).
4. Thesymmetricandunsymmetricembedmentof thetwo footings.
5. Rockingdueto vertical loading(,).
Thestudiedparameters are: .
4.3.2. The Studied Parameters
cases.
The model consists of two squarefootingsF. andF2. Theproperties of thesoil
and foundationelementsarethesameaswasmentionedpreviouslyinarticle(4.2.1). The
two footings areloadedbyvertical harmonicforcesgivenbyPI cos (COlt) andP2COS (C02t)
respectively. The spacing betweenthefootingishalf their width(B). Thefootingshave
different embedment depthsto represent thecasesof surface-embeddedandembedded-
embedded footings. Figures (4.10) to (4.14) showthemeshdetailsfor different studied
4.3.1. The Studied Model
4.3. EFFECT OF EMBEDMENT ON THE FOOTING INTERACTION
Figures (4.19) to (4.24) showtherelationsbetweenM , versus ~ andc I >versus ~
respec tively, for the c aseof embedmentdepth(De=0.25B) intheunsymmetric position
(interac tionof surfac e-embeddedfootings) at differentFFRsandFARs. Thetwo c asesof
single footinghaveto beinvestigated(ffi2=0andffil=O),theresults of thisc aseshowthat
the embedded footing F2 has less vibrationamplitudethanthesurfac efootingFl. The
114
Figures (4.17) and (4.18) show the relations M, versus A, and versus~
respec tively. for embedment of (0.25B) in the symmetric position (interac tion of
embedded-embedded footings). The single footing behaviour at ( o : > z = O ) indic ates a
dec rease inthevertic al responseandinduc edroc kingc omparedwiththesurfac efooting
c ase, this effec t is shown inTable(4.5) for thepeak values. For FFRsother thanunity,
the two peak behaviour isexhibitedandtheresponsewill belessc ritic al thaninthec ase
of (FFR=1.0).
4.3.3.2. Embedded Fo o tings
4.3.3.1. The Referring Case ( Surface Fo o ting)
Figure (4.15) shows therelationbetween~ andM,for thec aseof two surfac e
footings for different FFRsandFARs. Thec asewhenF1 istheonlyac tivefooting(i.e.,
002=0)has peak values M z1=2.840andM z2=2.046 at ~= 0.40whic harequitec loseto
the half spac e analysis as shown in Figure (2.19). The maximum valueof dynamic
response happens at FFR=1.0. For other valuesofFFRs, the two peaks behaviour is
exhibited with thesec ondpeak c orrespondsto theresonanc eof (F2), thesepeakshavea
less values thaninthec aseofFFR=I .0, bec auseof thebiasinthepositionof thepeaks
as shown in Figure (4.15) and by the peakvaluesinTable(4.5). For other valuesof
FARs the displac ementswill inc reasebut inlessratethaninthec aseof(FFR=I .0). The
same behaviour is also depic tedinM z-c I > giveninFigure(4.16). Peak valuesof roc king
andvertic al vibrationamplitudesarelistedinTable(4.5).
115
Peaks of vertical magnification factor and rocking for the previous cases are
drawn against the embedment depth/width ratio in Figures(4.25) to (4.27). These
Figures indicate the following:
Symmetric Cases
The vertical vibrations and accompanying rocking vibrations decrease
monotonically when increasing theembedmentof thefootingbut therockingdecreases
at higher rates.
Unsvmmetric Cases
There is no obvious trend for the unsymmetric cases; except for theeffect of
increasing the load of the embedded footingwhichaffectsgreatlythesurfacefooting.
The vertical oscillationof thesurfacefootingwill increasewithincreasingof thedepthof
embedment (in range of O-O.SB)but the rocking will decrease. Sometimes, asaddle
behaviour isnoticedfor thevertical oscillationandfor rockingwithapeak at DjB=0.25.
The case of embedment (De=0.5B) is also investigated and the results are given in
Appendix (B) and Table (4.5). The single footing behaviour (O)}=O)and the case of
symmetric embedment investigated indicate more decrease inthe two footings' response
due to embedment than the case ofDe=O.25B. Considering the case of the unsymmetric
position (interaction of surface-embedded footings), increasing the load of any footing
will increase the response of both footings, but increasing the load of the embedded
footing will have avery intensive effect on the behaviour of the surface one as predicated
by the peaks of the curve as given inTable (4.5)
critical case appears at (FFR=l.O), increasing the load of any footing, increases the
response of both footings, but increasing the load of the embedded footing has avery
intensive effect on the behaviour of the surface one as predicated by the peaks of the
curve as shown inTable (4.5). At FFRs different fromunity, the response of the footings
is less critical due to the double peak behaviour.
116
When the actual static displacement of the footing- with rock at definite depth- is used, the
magnification factor approaches00at shallowdepthsof rockinterfaceduetothedecreaseof thestatic
response, as it was shown in Table(2.5). However,thedynamic responsewill alsodecrease, soit is
preferabletorelatetheresponsetothestaticresponseof rigidfootingrestedontheelastic half space.
The results of thedimensionlessmagnificationfactor Mz=ZcJ ynarniJ Zstatic,surface and
the rocking cj > are plotted versus the dimensionless frequency factor (Ao) of thefirst
footing(FI) inFigures(4.30) to (4.33).
I. Thedepthof theunderlyingrock Z (ZIB = 0.5,1,2and3).
2. TheforcingfrequencyratioFFR=(ffi2!rol)(FFR=I and3).
3. Rockingdueto vertical loading(,).
Thestudiedparameters are:
4.4.2. The Studied Parameters
The model consists of two squaresurfacefootingsF, andF2. Theproperties of
the soil andfoundationelementaresimilarto thosementionedinarticle(4.2.1). Thetwo
footings FI andF2areloadedbyvertical harmonicforcesgivenbyPI cos (rolt)andP2cos
(C02t)respectively. The effect of the depth of the compressible layer is studied
parametrically (ZIB=O.5,1,2and3) for two spacingsof thefootings (s/B=O.5and 1.0) as
showninFigures(4.28) and(4.29).
4.4.1 The Studied Model
4.4. EFFECT OFROCK INTERFACE DEPTH
117
Figures (4.34) and (4.35) represent therelationbetweentheMz and< j ) versus
depth of compressible layer. It isnotedthat bothvertical vibrationsandaccompanying
rocking will increasebyincreasingthedepthof thecompressiblelayer. However thereis
no differencebetweenthevertical vibrationsor theinducedrockingunder differentFFRs
for depth of compressiblelayer lessthan(B) for spacingequalsto (0.5B), and(l.3B)
for spacing equals to (B), whichmeansthat all frequenciesgivealmostthesamesmall
magnitudeof vibrationresponseat shallowdepths.
Figures (4.32) and (4.33) represent the relation betweenM, and< j ) versusA,
respectively, for the case of (sIB =1.0). Thesamebehaviour depictedintheprevious
case is valid but with less interaction due to theincreaseof spacingas showninthe
valuesof peaksinTable(4.6).
Figure (4.31) shows the relation between < j ) and Ao for thesamespacing. At
shallow depths of rock interface, thereisnodifferencebetweenthetwo casesofFFRs
and bothgiveasmall inducedrockingasdepictedfromthemaximumvaluesasshownin
Table (4.6). The main characteristics of vertical vibrationspreviouslydescribedisthe
samefor inducedrocking.
4.4.3. Results and Discussion
Figure (4.30) represents the relation between M, versus A, for (sIB=O.S)for
(FFR=l and 3). Itis observed that at shallow depths of rock interface, thedynamic
response is small. The effect of FFR on the peaks vanishes for shallow depths, as
depictedinthepeak valueslistedinTable(4.6). Another aspect of shallowdepths isthat,
the two peak behaviour at (FFR=3.0) decomposesintotwo curveseachwithonepeak at
the resonance frequency of itsfooting. Thepositionof thepeaksisalsoshifted, e.g. at
ZIB=0.5, the resonance frequency factors are Ao=O.5for F, andAo=O.16for F2.At
greater depths of rock interface, thebehaviour of two peaksfor eachcurveat (FFR=3.0)
is obvious but have different frequency factors compared with the case of shallow
depths, e.g. for (ZIB=3), wherethe two peakshappenat (Ao=0.25)for F, and(Ao=O.l)
for F2. Thegreatest responsehappensat (FFR=1.0) for higher depthsof rock interface.
118
1. The depth of the trench D (DIB =0.5,1 and 2).
2. The width of the trench W (WIB =0.1,0.2 and 0.3).
3. The length of the trench L (LIB =1,2,3 and the case of continuous trenches).
4. The forcing frequency ratio FFR=(ID2/(l)l)(FFR=1I3,1 and 3).
5. Rocking due to vertical loading (.).
The used model is a three dimensional one. This isthe first employed model of
this nature to be used in studying the trench isolation. In all other reviewed researches,
the models were plane strain or axisymmetric to scrutinize the case of circular or strip
footings due to the difficulties in the three dimensional analysis. Using this model, the
length effect can beinvestigated along with the depth and width of trench. The studied
parameters are:
4.5.2. The Studied Parameters
The model consists of two square surfacefootingsF1andF2separated by adistance
that equals totheir width (B). Theproperties of thesoil andfoundation elements arethesame
as given inthe previous parts. Thetwo footings (F1andF2)areloaded byvertical harmonic
forces given by PI cos (COlt)and P2cos (C02t) respectively. Thevibration isolationusing air
trenches is studied for activeisolated footing(F1) andpassive isolated footing(F2). Thetrench
is assumed tobecontinuous or discontinuous, withvariabledimensions (depth D=0.5B,B and
2B, width W=0.IB,0.2B and 0.3B and length L= B,2B,3B and (0), as shown inFigures
(4.36) and(4.37).
4.5.1 The Studied Model
4.5. VIBRATION ISOLATION USINGAIR TRENCHES
119
Thestaticresponseisfor rigidfooting, restedonelastichalf-space.
4.5.3.1 Referring Case (Surface Footings with no Trenches)
Figure (4.38) shows therelationbetweenA o andM, for thecaseof two surface
footings for different FFRs. The case of singleactivefooting(ffi2=0)showsthat peak
values happen at (A o=:0.25), thisvalueisdifferentfromtheprevious caseswhichhave
the peak at (A o=:O.4);this may be dueto themeshviolationtotheknownruleof not
using aspect ratio greater than 4.0 for theelements, but themeshwasuseddueto the
computer storage limitation. A lthough the meshisnot predicatingaccurateresultsfor
A o, there is no great gross error inthedeterminationof thepeakswhichhappento be
Mz1=3.197 and Mz2=1.659comparedwithMz1=3.07andMz2=1.89asit was shownin
Table (4.2); therefore the curveisonlyshiftedalongthefrequencyaxis. Themaximum
value of dynamic response happenswhenFFR=1.0withpeak valuesMz1=Mz2=4.193.
For FFR=3.0, the two peak behaviour isexhibitedwiththeother peak corresponds to
resonance of the secondfooting(F2), at thiscasethefootingresponseisapproximately
thesameastheir singlebehaviour.
Figure (4.39) shows the relation between the induced rocking (q,) and the
frequency ratio (A o) for different FFRs. Thesinglefootingcase(ffi2=0)showsthat the
parts:
4.5.3. Results and Discussion
A comprehensive discussion of the obtained results, IS giveninthefollowing
The results of the dimensionless magnification factor Mz="Zdynamid zstatic andthe
induced rocking q, plottedversusthedimensionlessfrequencyfactor (A o) for thefooting
(F1) as shown in Figures (4.38) to (4.45). In case of (001=0),A , will represent the
frequencyfactor for F2.
120
Figures (4.42) and (4.43) investigate the case of trenchwidth (W=0.2B) for
continuous trencheswithdepth(D=B). Thecaseof (W=0.3B) isgiveninAppendix(C).
Thecaseof (W=O.IB) ispreviouslypresentedintheabovearticle.
4.5.3.3. The Effect of Trench Wulth (U1
The relations between Mz versus Ao andcj)versusAofor caseof (D=O.5B) are
approximately same as the corresponding relations of the referring case (surface
footings). For other casesof trenchdepths, thevertical vibrationandtheinducedrocking
dwindle with the increasing of trench depth for footingF2but remainsapproximately
constant for footing Fl. Therateof diminutionof'F, responsedecreasesafter thedepth
of (D=B) as shown in Figures (4.46) and (4.47), which show that, the trenchcan
decrease the response of the passive isolated footing (F2) byabout 30%for vertical
vibrationand 10%of theinducedrocking. Theactiveisolatedfooting(F1)appearsnot to
beaffectedbythevariationof trenchdepth.
Figures (4.40) and (4.41) investigate the caseof trenchdepth (D =0.5B) for
continuous trenches withwidth(W=O.IB). Bothvertical andinducedrockingvibrations
are considered. Other casesof trenchdepthsaregiveninAppendix(C). Peak valuesare
listedinTable(4.7).
4.5.3.2. The Effect of Trench Depth (D)
two footings have the same induced rocking value (cj)1~ == 0.06) at (Ao =0.25). The
maximumrockinghappenswhenFFR=l.Owithpeaks(cj)1=cj)2=0.1039). Thetwo footings
have the approximately the same response of the singlefootingat FFR=3.0but with
doublepeaks eachonecorrespondsto resonanceof oneof thetwo footings.
Figures (4.44) and (4.45) show the relation between Mz andc j , versusA o for
(L=B) for differentFFRs. Thec ritic al c aseisat (FFR=l.O), inthis c asethefootingswill
suffer from inc rease in the roc kingspec iallyF1, asshowninthepeakvalueswhic hare
given in Table (4.7). At (FFR=3.0) and(FFR=1/3) thetwo footingsbehavemorelikely
as a singlefootingwithF1havingaslightinc reaseintheamplitudeof itsvibrations. For
greater lengths, the vertic al vibration dec reases for F2andinc reasesfor F1 c ompared
withthepreviousc ase. Roc kingwill inc reasefor bothfootings
121
Figures (4.44) and (4.45) investigate the c ase of disc ontinuous trenc hwith
length (L=B). Thewidthanddepthof trenc hare(W=O.2B)and(D=B). Other c asesof
trenc hlengthsaregiveninAppendix(C).
4.5.3.4. The Effect of Trench Length (L)
Figures (4.48) and(4.49) illustratetheeffec t of thetrenc hwidthonthepeaks of
the vertic al vibrationsandinduc edroc king. Inc reasingthetrenc hwidthupto (O.lB), will
dec rease the vertic al response of the passively isolated footing. Inthesametimethe
response of the ac tively isolated footing will inc rease spec ially at (FFR=1/3) andat
(FFR=3). Considering the induc ed roc king vibrations, the two footings suffer from
inc reaseof thevibrationsspec iallyat (FFR=1.0).
Figures (4.42) and (4.43) show the variation of M, and c j , versus A, for
(W=O.2B) for different FFRs. Thec ritic al c aseisat (FFR=l.O). However, thevaluesof
this c ase are c loseto thec aseof (W=O.lB). Other FFRsratios arec harac terizedbythe
two peak behaviour whic h dec reases the valuesof thepeaks asshowninTable(4.7).
The c ase of (W=O.3B) gives also c loseresultstothec aseof (W=O.2B).Theseresults
show that thewidthof thetrenc hhasinsignific anteffec tontheresponseof thefootings,
for widthsgreater than(O.lB).
122
Figures (4.50) and (4.51) illustrate the effect of the trench length on the peaks of
the vertical vibrations and induced rocking. Increasing the trench length will decrease the
vertical response of both the passively isolated footing and the actively isolated footing,
the rate of decrease of the vertical vibration of the footing F1 ispaltry. For F2, the
decrease is substantial up to length of 3B and thenthereductiondeemedto bevery
small. For rocking, there is a slightincreaseintheinducedrockingupto lengthof 2B
andthentherockingappearsto beconstant for bothfootings.
123
Thisvalueischosento makethevertical massratio B, =(1-v). m3 =5.0
4 pro
Table(4.2) Effect of spacingand theforcingfrequency ratio (FFR)
s I B Si ngl eF o o t . F F R=l F F R=2 F F R=3
(F1)
Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz Mz,
Mzz Mzl Mz2
0. 5 3.09 2.4 5.36 5.38 3.42 3.34 3.08 3.l7
1. 0 3.07 1.89 4.54 4.54 3.14 3.14 3.08 2.7
1. 5 3.08 1.59 4.08 4.08 3.11 3.19 3.09 2.9
2. 0 3.28 1.23 3.75 3.75 3.29 3.24 3.29 3.27
3. 0 3.63 0.58 3.42 3.42 3.64 3.64 3.63 3.63
Table (4.1) Propertiesof soil andfooting elements
I t e m F o unda t i o ns So i l
Modulus of Elasticity(E) (kN/m") 2Oxl06 IOxl03
Poisson's ratio (u)
0.17 0.3
Dampingratio(l;)
0.01 0.05
Unit weight (y) (kN/m3)
18.0
184.72
124
Table (4.4) F;ffectof theforcing phase difference (FPD) at (FFR=1.0)
sIB FPD =0 FPD =450 FPD =90 FPD =1800
Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz Mz. Mzz Mzl Mzz
0.5 5.25 5.27 5.38 4.35 4.68 2.79 2.19 2.19
1.5 4.08 4.08 4.27 3.33 4.51 2.42 3.19 3.19
Table (4.3) E/fectojthe!orcingamplitude ratio (FAR)
FFR=1
sIB FAR =0.5 FAR =1.0 FAR =1.5 FAR =2.0
Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz
0.5 4.10 3.79 5.25 5.27 6.41 6.75 7.56 8.23
1.5 3.52 2.52 4.08 4.08 5.60 4.59 5.10 7.13
3.0 3.52 1.77 3.42 3.42 5.23 3.43 3.54 7.05
FFR=3
sIB FAR =0.5 FAR =1.0 FAR =1.5 FAR =2.0
Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz Mzl Mzz
0.5 3.02 2.27 3.02 3.11 3.87 4.53 4.81 5.95
1.5 3.04 1.67 3.09 2.90 4.35 3.09 3.44 5.81
3.0 3.63 1.813 3.63 3.63 5.44 3.63 3.63 7.26
-SSN8a
8~MS~M
~ II " ~ " "
" N N" -
'"8 S S8
S .... N S .... N
" : Q. Q. . . . . Q. Q.
Q. NNQ. NN
II II II II II II
N N . . . . . N N . . .
Q. Q. Q. o. . Q. Q.
g> g> 8
~ ~ I~
008
U. U. .... N
Q) Q) ~~~
g>~11 I I I I
_._ NN-
WWQ. Q. Q.
125
~~~~
N. . t " " ' : ( ' t )
. _ - +- - +- - - - - - - - - - - - - - +- - +- - - - - - - - - - - - - ~G ) r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 1
_ en
<oQ) ~~~<ocac: o
I . t ' ) en , . . . ~~c: oo<o
~ca~( ' t ) ~~G C: ! UO
<o~ . . . .~~N~EN
:s ~
I- e n 1--------1 Q) E t-----------------t
a e ~
CoO . . . .~l . t ' ) e<O~<OI . t ' ) Nen
~~" ' I I t ~~~~ o. . - o~( ' t ) c
' : i . oc: o~~c: ol . t ' ) ~~( ' t ) ~" ' I I t ~~
ON~<ON~eN~<ON~-
~ ~ ~
~ ~ d dt----------------1
o @ II "
:11_ .c_ .c__
tn.... ......... ... .... N
-u. 8Q.U. -Q.u.u.
G J - - - G J _ - 8Q) - -
en0>888MCo> 88~C
rae : "M" ... c:8"MII ...
o :;:;" N " N C :;:; " N II N C
0 . . . . 8 N8G J 08" , 88 . . . . 8G J
a08..:8 ....Eo E
.5 u, ..:Q. . . :Q. "C U. ~..: ~ "C
t : ~Q. NQ. NG J ~C: - NQ. NG J
~.! 0>1 1 II II II.aS ~II II II II.aE
c u G J . 5 N N N N ._ N N N N
OD: : : wQ. Q. Q. Q. wwQ. Q. Q. Q. w
-
8 8
" "
8 8
~~~
N . . . .( ' t )
000
ooc i
- 8 SN 88
- 8 8 8 M M 8 ~ M
g>g>81 1 " ~ " " Mi l II
:;:;:;:; II N N " 8N N II
00N88N 888
008 . 8 . 8
u.u. ..:~ N ~rr ..:~rr
Q) ~Q. N~~NNQ. NN
' Ol o>
e : e : II II II II II II II II II
._._ N N ...- N N ..- N N .....
WWQ. Q. Q. Q. Q. Q. Q. Q. Q.
. _ - +- - +- - - - - - - - - - - - - - i G ) ~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 1
_ en
~: ~O" ' l l t N~~~N<OOc: oc: o" ' l l t ~c: oc: o~
~~~~~~~UN~~~~~~~g~~
. . . .~~N~ENN~~~N~~~" ' I I t " ' l l t
U Q)
~tI--------i e1---------------1
e e
S~O~<O( ' t ) ~<O~N" ' I I t ( ' t ) ~Nc: o( ' t ) ~~
N~OO~~O" ' l l t ~C( ' t ) c: o<O~~~<O . . . .~( ' t ) ~~
~ _ " ~~~ ONC: ON( ' t ) ~N~O
~N~~N~- ( ' t ) . . . .~~~( ' t ) ~~~~~
Q Q
~d I-------I~ t--------------....
" "
. . . ." ' I I t
( ' t ). . . .
( ' t )N
00
00
..........
o 0
00
~~~~~
..... T- ........... ..-
00000
00000
126
Case
M Z 1 M z2
+ 1 ch
SD8cing Between Footinas =0.5 B
Depth of Rock = 0.58
P2=P11W2=W1 2.106 2.106 0.0223 0.0223
P2=P11W2=3w2 2.105 2.050 0.0211 0.0204
Depth of Rock =B
P2=P11W2=W1 3.493 3.493 0.0320 0.0320
P2=P11W2=3w2 3.389 3.231 0.0233 0.0230
Depth of Rock = 28
P2=P11W2=W1 3.989 3.989 0.0449 0.0449
P2=P11W2=3w2 3.033 3.080 0.0787 0.0840
Depth of Rock =38
P2=P11W2=W1 4.486 4.486 0.1709 0.1709
P2=P11W2=3w2 2.882 3.078 0.0877 0.0900
SD8cina Between Footings =B
Depth of Rock =0.58
P2=P11W2=W1 2.047 2.047 0.0124 0.0124
P2=P11W2=3w2 2.055 1.961 0.0026 0.0026
Depth of Rock =8
P2=P11W2=W1 3.259 3.259 0.0093 0.0093
P2=P11w2=3w2 3.328 3.330 0.0086 0.0081
Depth of Rock =28
P2=P11W2=W1 4.435 4.435 0.0131 0.0131
P2=P11w2=3w2 3.919 4.066 0.0268 0.0280
Depth of Rock =38
P2=P11W2=W1 4.180 4.180 0.1043 0.1043
P2=P11W2=3w2 3.195 3.242 0.0877 0.0902
Table (4.6) Effect ofrock interface depth
127
Case M z1 M z2
cjl1 cjl2
No Trench ,Referring Case)
SingleFooting.F, 3.197 1.659 0.0597 O.05n
PrP,.Wr"W, 4.193 4.193 0.1039 0.1039
PrP"wrlw, 3.204 3.313 0.0595 0.0620
Effect of Continuous Trench Del!th ~dth of Trench = 0.1B}
OtIpth of Irwlch = 0.5B
SingleFooting. F, 3.247 1.652 0.0626 0.0641
SingleFooting. F2 1.652 3.194 0.0570 0.0582
PrP,.Wr-W, 4.236 4.065 0.1176 0.1118
PrP,.wrlw, 3.254 3.212 0.0639 0.0649
PrP,. w,=lw, 3.323 3.196 0.0661 0.0498
Depthof trench = B
Singlefooting. F, 3.378 1.590 o.oseo 0.0599
SingleFooting. "2 1.590 3.270 0.0490 0.0571
PrP,.wrw, 4.235 3.570 0.1075 0.1000
PrP,.wr3w, 3.378 3.312 0.0791 0.0549
PrP,. w,=3w, 3.441 3.413 0.0715 0.0648
Depth of Irwlch ;;;; 2B
SingleFooting. F, 3.963 1.258 0.0795 0.0483
SingleFooting. F2 1.258 3.413 0.0610 0.0693
PrP"Wr-W, 4.235 3.570 0.1075 0.1000
PrP,.wr3w, 3.963 3.519 0.0791 0.0681
P2=P,.w,=lw, 3.854 3.413 0.0810 0.0694
Effect of Continuous Trench Width ,Del!th of Trench = B}
Wfdth oflrwlch =0.18
SingleFooting. F, 3.378 1.590 0.0680 0.0599
SingleFooting. F2 1.590 3.270 0.0490 0.0571
PrP,.Wr-W, 4.235 3.570 0.1075 0.1000
PrP"Wr3w, 3.378 3.312 0.0791 0.0549
PrP,. w,=3w, 3.441 3.413 0.0715 0.0648
Width of trench ;;;; O.2B
SingleFooting. F, 3.616 1.594 0.0737 0.0651
SingleFooting. F2 1.594 3.306 0.0533 0.0563
PrP,.Wr-W, 4.234 4.045 0.1262 0.1166
PrP"wr3w, 3.616 3.377 0.0749 0.0647
PrP,. w,=3w, 3.580 3.304 0.0676 0.0614
Wfdth of Irwlch ;;;; 0.38
SingleFooting. F, 3.863 1.601 0.0853 0.0694
SingleFooting. F2 1.601 3.381 0.0587 0.0561
PrP,.wrw, 4.545 3.608 0.1440 0.1216
PrP"wr3w, 3.863 3.436 0.0835 0.0692
PrP" w,=3w, 3.782 3.380 0.0882 0.0685
Effect of Trench Length, DeE!thof Trench = B. Width of Trench = O.2B}
Length of Irwlch = 8
SingleFooting. F, 3.388 1.6n 0.0630 0.0639
SingleFooting. F2 1.672 3.160 0.0603 0.0601
PrP,.Wr"W, 4.388 4.036 0.1204 0.1142
P2"'P,.Wr3w, 3.395 3.203 0.0646 0.0645
Pt"P" w,=3w, 3.324 3.163 0.0593 0.0599
Length of trench;;;; 2B
SingleFooting. F, 3.559 1.&49 0.0747 0.0843
SingleFooting. F2 1.649 3.250 0.0592 0.0596
PrP,.wrw, 4.462 3.804 0.1340 0.1228
PrP,.wr3w, 3.538 3.300 0.0765 0.0688
PrP,. w,=3w, 3.627 3.249 0.0822 0.0746
Length of trench=38
SingleFooting."1 3.588 1.615 0.0749 0.0684
SingleFooting. F2 1.615 3.290 0.0559 0.0579
PrP,.w-r-w, 4.369 3.707 0.1307 0.1195
PrP,.wr3w, 3.587 3.351 0.0768 0.0682
PrP,. w,=3w, 3.550 3.289 0.0668 0.0607
Table (4.7) Trench isolation
128
-------- ---------
Figure (4. J) - The geometry, boundary conditions and meshing
For the studied model (dimensions are in meters)
PLAN
+
1.0 1 1.0 0,5 0,50,5 0,5 s 0.5 0,5 0,:iO,5+ 1.0 + 1.0 +
- , + + + + t + + ~ - - -
x
in
d
lf1
ci
II')
d
t
~ ~ ~ ~
Fl F2
o
_:;
y
ELEV.
1.0 0.50.50.50.5 s 0.50.50.50.5 1.0 + 1.0 +
+ + + + + + + + + -
1.0
x
~ ~ ~
~
t >
z
Fl F2
l()
d
l()
c:5
9
C")
I l . .
9
129
co I.() VMN..... 0
9
I l . .
9
~
9
lit
i
U)
0
C\I
o
r c:)
N
~
Q.
II
!I
II
~
r-f
0
0
~
('I .- 0
'"
N 0 I...
<0 It) oq' ('t)
<0 to oq'
~
N
L L .
Z I N
e :
Z w
u,
. . . . .
i. O
0
1 1 1
1)
It)
0
I()
~
U J
N
N
W
II
IJ ..
IJ ..
r
*
+
~
~
~
I
e
<,
::3
. . . . .
.9l
CIl
IJ ..
+
. . . . .
u,
~
IJ ..
S
""
+
lit
0
U
c
a
</
a
I l . .
N
If. .
s
s
It)
c:i
~ ~
. . .
N
N
IJ ..
IJ ..
+
+
....
IJ ..
+
130
o co co .., N0
. . . .
131
o o
. . . .
~- +- - ~- - ~- +- - 4 0
132
I---+--+---+-+---+ 0
N0
N0 o IX) co "<I'
. . . . . .
II"! II"!
. . . . . . . . . . . .
N
N u,
u,
+
+
. . . . .
. . . . .
u,
u,
+
+
c
c:
N
II II
N
N
c,
c. .
I
10
I
c:)
I,~
t"r)
'*
II
8 ~
~ M
k;
9
II ~
II) ('l
0
8
C J
N
0
II')
Q. 0
~
0 IX) co "<I' N 0
0
IX)
co "<I' N 0
II . . . . . .
. . . . . .
z l I\ I
% 1 1 \ 1
~
ltl
r. oj
I/)
""-
~
0
I I
II"!
II"!
. . . . . .
"<
. . . . . .
k:
II
I
N
N
~ LL
LL
J :Q
+
+ I
- ~
\oJ
9
fl
<,
~ II)
0 ~ fI)
~
C J . . . . . . . -
;;y
Q.
LL LL
+ +
~
~
. . .
c:
< l
,[<l
Q.
~
It)
~
ci . . . . .
II
"
N
'"
Q. e,
10
c:)
133
~
(")
II
It:!
~
L()
. . . .
II
rn
e n
x
~
. . . .
~
"
N
0: : :
~
~
. . . .
L()
0. . . . . .
~
""N
II
-
e ,
m
~
II
I f j
~
~
~
~
c:(
~ LL
~
~~
~
(") (")
.~
"
II
IQ
~~ ~
0
L() 0
c i t " )
II II
mm
I f j e n
E ll
LO
0
. . . . . . . . .
~ ~
II II
~~
..q~
o(")
~
II II
mm
0
I f j e n
M
134
Figure (4.7) Effect of FPDfor sIB=0.5 and FFR=1.0
1.5
0.5 A o
a
N
:E3
2
4
6 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
5
e=315
a 1.5
0.5 A o
N
:E3
2
6 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
5
4
e=180
0.5 o
N
:E 3
2
6 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
5
4
e=45
1.5 0.5
o~. - - - - ~~- - ~~==~
o
N
: : : 2 3
2
6 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
5
4
e=2 70
1.5 0.5 a
N
:E 3
2
6 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
5
4
e=90
0.5 o
N
: : z 3
2
e=o I
6.-----1
5
4
siB = 0.5
8 BxB BxB
135
9=90 9=180
6
6
5
~
5
~
4
4
N N
: : : E 3
2
: : : E 3
1
2 2
1
0
0.5
A o
1.5
0 0.5 1.5
A o
9=270
9=315
6
6
5
b]
5
g
4
4
N
N
: : : E
3
2
: IE 3
2
2 2
1
0 0
0 0.5 1.5 0 0.5 1.5
A o A a
Figure (4.8) Effect of FPD for siB =0.5and FFR=3.0
sIB
-0.5 ( 02=3001
-
9=0 9=45
6 6
5 5
4
b]
4
g
N N
: : : E 3
2 : : : E 3
2
2 2
0 0
0 0.5
A o
1.5 0 0.5 1.5
A o
BxE 8 BxE
136
(0 = 0 .:1 .:1 ) z w / z w
o
(\I
o
>
o
IX)
o
~ - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - ~ ~ - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - - - + - - - - - - - ~ 0
f2
(\I
~
~
II
~
~
(\I
10
. . . . . .
_ _ . . _
II
t:'-l
C D
~
e n
~
0
. . . X
~
N
'=I)
. . . . . .
~
3:
"'0
II
~
-
~
~
~
C . . I
-
~
= =
10
\. ,)
~
~
. . .
~
~
~
II
C D
0\' ~
e n
. -
~
Q
<I
s
~
. . . . . .
~
t:'-l
3:
. ~
=
C')
. . c
II
~
N
~
3:
~
10
ci
II
C D
e n
II
~
3:
II
~
10
0
II
C D
e n
_x~
x
137
Figure (4.J 0) Referring case, surface footing
PLAN
1.0
1(')
ci
If')
ci
in
ci
o
......
t
~
0;
~ ~
Ft J;;F2
o
......
y
ELEV.
1.0
~ ~ ~ ~
I >
~
.c:
z
F1 F2
q
....
1(')
ci
1(')
ci
x
x
138
Figure (4.11) Embedment depth D e =O.25B. symmetric case
+ 1.0 + 1.0 +0.5~O.10.5~0.5+0.5+0.5+ 0.1.1.5. 1.0 ~1.0 ~
PLAN
o
....;
t
~
~ ~ ~ ~
F1.F2
o
....;
I()
<5
I(')
<5
l{)
<5
ELEV.
o
.....
P7)l7?; 177f 77
r/ '/
t
f 1
.~
o
-
F1 F2
I(')
o
I()
o
I()
<5
x
x
139
Figure (4.J 2) Embedment depth De =O.25B. unsymmetric case
+ 1. + 1.0 +0,5. 0.5.0.5.0.5.0.5.0,5.0'10'10.5.1.0 1.0
PLAN
t
~
~ ~ ~ ~
F1 ~F2
y
+ 1.0 + 1.0 ..5.'1.5.,5..5.,5.0'1'1.5. 1.0 1.0
ELEV.
:to ,25
~ ~ V/V7/
'//
r/,
t < 1
~-
F1
F2
U"l
o
U"l
o
If)
o
U"l
o
x
x
140
Figure (4.13) Embedment depth De =O.50B. symmetric case
PLAN
F1 ~ F'2
1.0 .. 1.0 O.S0.50.50.50.50.5 O.SO.SO.S1.0 1.0
+ T + .
o
.....
1.0 1.0 ..5.'10.5..5..5..5..5..'1.5.. 1.0 1.0
ELEV.
~ ~ ~ ~
f > ~
~
F2 Fl
l()
ci
111
ci
II)
ci
o
.....;
o
.....;
IQ
o
111
ci
x
x
141
Figure (4.14) Embedment depth De = = 0.50 B. unsymmetnc case
1.0+ 1.0 ..5.'1.5..50.5 0.50.50505 1.0 1.0
+ ' + ' +
PLAN
l()
ci
I()
ci
l/)
ci
t < 1
~ ~ ~ ~
F1"'F2
o
. . . . . .
ELEV.
1.0;O.5pO.~0.50.50.50.50.5050S 1.0 1.0
~+ '+' +
1.0
~ ~
F2
L-
~
to
t> 4
~
F1
o
. . . .
o
-
In
ci
In
ci
142
"!
"!
"!
-
-
N
u..
N
~
+
~
u..
~
+
u :
~
~ ~
+
-
u :
-
+
S S
.,
.(
II
II
~.(
...
...
0 e
e
I~
0:
e
<0
N
<0
ci
II
ci N
e,
"
"
ci
ci
'"ci
~
r --r
0
~
10 0
0
0 '"
10
'"
~
ci
o -
N
<0 ..... <0
It) .... '"
N_0
..... <0 10
"'" '"
-
0
.....
0
ZW
ZW
ZW
~
~
"!
"!
~
"'-
'"
~
L L .
'"
+
"":
i;)-
L L .
+
"":
......,
~
u :
~
...
+
~
N
N S
U1
u :
o ~
II)
+
0
~
o
N
0
a ..
II
III
s
s
.,
~ < t l
<,
~.(
II
II
...
C I)
N
e
e
c c
<0
II
0
II <0
N
N
C;;
a .. e,
...
~
~
i.....
III
....
II)
ci
0
"":
U
ci
0:
N
ci
'"
c;;
~H
0
0 It)
'"
10N
~
-
100
,..; ('j
ci 10 ....
'"
..... 0
ZW
ZW
143
~
~
~
~ ~
N
N u..
u..
~
-.:
+
. . .
+
~ ~
~ ~
~ ~
u :
~ ~
u..
~
+
+
~<l
e s
"
CO)
N II
0 I S
N
II.. I S
I S <0
0:
0: d N
II.
N
Q.
II.
Q.
. . .
. . .
d
d
N
N
d
d
~
~f
0
0
~
0
a
I t'> NI I I
0
8
0
~e8~C: ! i a8oo 8
a
0
8 s
. . .
a 8 0
a
. _
d d d a
-
d d d dddddddd
dddddd
C
~
~
\.,)
t
~
~
~
~
J 3
N
~
u..
N . . .
+
v
-.
u ,
~
+ . . . .
~ ~
'"
N ~
I S u , T"
. ~
1/1
I I I
u :
+
0
U
+
~
a: 0
I I
I I I
'"
s
~<l
e
<,
CO)
"
II
V) N N
I S
I S
0:
<D
0:
d
II.
I",
~
Q. Q.
. . . .
S
. . .
1/1
d
0
u
0:
N
d
a
S + +
a
a ~ 8
I t'>
0
8
0
I t'>
s
'"
N
0
0 ~
0 0 0
d
0
d
0
d
d d d d d d 0 d
144
G : !
G : !
G : !
. , . .
~
N
N U.
U.
+
"":
+
+
. . .
"":
. . . .
~
. . . . .
~
. ,. .
~
u.
L L
. , . . u.
. . . .
+
. . . .
+
+
e
II
e
. . .
0 a C')
II
~ ~<l
II
. . .
S
c
. . .
N
a
~
I ). .
c 0-
co
co N
~
d
d
I ). .
0-
~
~
. . . .
. . .
. ~ d
c: i
. ::
~
N
E
d
N
!
d
0
0
~
It) N
1 1 : >
. ,. . It)
0
0 . . ,
It) -e
. ,
N
. , . .
0
~
<'i d I"- co It) . . .
. . ,
N
. ,. .
0
z w z w
z w ~
II
'"
~
~
Q
-s
N N
~
U. u,
~
+
+
"":
"":
. . . . . .
t:
~
L L
N
u: :
~
.
e-
~
~
+ +
. . (:)
'";: .
~
a
III
0
r : : : : : --
u
. . .
L O
0-
. . . . . . .
S
e
~
0
~<l
C')
I I II
II
. . . . . .
~
s s
ttl
c . ~
I ). .
co
I ). .
~ <,
0-
c: i
0-
0)
~
aL
~
. . .
a
d
III
0
U
s :
N
d
0
. . . . 0 . . ,
I() N
1 1 : >
. , . . I() 0
. . . . . . . . . . . . ",..,U')(Y)WNIll""",I.l)O
<'i . . - d
1 : 1 1 1 : 1 1 . . . . . , ; N . 0
z w
z w
145
~ ~
- -
~
"":
-
C '!
-
s
~<l
C')
II
N
~
e
CD c ~
d
N
d
I) . .
11. \J
'<t
\J
d
. . . . . .
. t:
~
~
< ' I
!
c : : i
~
C D C D " ' < ' I - S " ' O ~~\ 3 a ~~~o 8
\ 3 ~ ~
g ':2
c ; 8
~
oooo~ 8
c i c i
c i ~ .
~
c i c i c : : i c i c i c i c : : i c i
c i c : : i c i c i c : : i
II
Q
- s
~
~
~
-
~
-
v "":
t:
~
-
~
'"
-c
N
~
-
IL
3
N
e
'"
O C'
0
o
......
r r
ltl ~
S
s
~<l ~
0
C')
II
II II
.~
N N
III a s
fX I
s :
C D k;
c i
<,
IJ . IJ .
11. 11.
Vl
. . .
. r
c i
s~ 3
'" 0
'"
u
c i
c
146
CD
'"
"!
..:
-
N
~
u,
+
! -0:
+
::
-
~ "1
u:
N
u,
+
..:
+
~ ~
~
'" ~
Q
i
CO
'"
~
Q
Q
~ S
s
\.)
..,
\.)
Q
'"
Q
'"
. _
Q
.::.
~
.
s:
~
Q ..
Q ..
~
Q
!':l~
N
~
Q N
0 N
~ Q
. _
-
~
C
c
~ on
..,
0() N
'"
-
0() C
0
~
'"
N
Q on N on on 0 0
c :::) ~ N
,.; Q
....
'"
on ..
..,
N
-
0
ZW ZW
ZW
II ~
'"
. : : ;
Q
~
- s
~
CD
"!
s
,..:
-
~
~
C
~
..
N
"':
-
.....;
+
u,
= ::
II ..:
+
~
.ij
f f :
"1
N
~ ~
..
'if
u:
3
u:
toC)
~
III
+
+
~
III
0
~
~
c
0\-
8
10
~ ~
i
.....
.,
~ 0
Q
..
.. .. 0
II
s
~
-
~
c
<D
.~
I!)
r
Q
<,
Q
III
k:;
~~ ..
:II Q ..
l:l
Q
~
c
N
c;;
N
c;;
0
*
ton Ii') ._. It) ..,
'" N'"
~ 1f t 0 0
. . M N ~ Q
..... CD on ...
..,
N
-
0
...
Z W
zw
......
III
147
'"
"!
'"
""'
N
'"
u,
IL
-.:
+
. . .
+
-. :
. . ;
N
u :
"! "! . . ;
~ u :
+
+
. {
. {
S
co
i
. ,
~
c
c
S
s
. ri
~
'"
N
'"
'"
c c
c
c
'-l . _
-l::
~
. . .
-.:
= =
"'E > c
<>
~
~
'"
N
~
C C
:;::
~
. ~
~
\:)
c:> 0
~
N
. ,
'"
... N
8 8
... N
'" '"
N
'"
~
'"
c:>
c:>
'"
c;
s
(; (;
s
s s '" '"
;;
0
8
'" '"
. . .
S
'" '"
<',
'"
C;
on
'"
~
~ c c
0
c
c;;; 0
:!
0 <:>
~
c:>
C; 8
~
c c c c c;;; 0
'" '"
c;;; c;;;
c
c;;;
0 0 c c;;;
~
, c;;; c;;;
~
c c
II
'I>
. _
Q
/ ;I o'J
~
"!
'"
;S
&
~
N
~
~
IL . . .
-.:
-
II
f
. . ;
:;::
~
f i :
I
N
-
k;
~
~
. .
u :
. . &::l
~ "
3 1
+
i s
~
~
~ u
I
c
t
. { . { ~
8
I. t)
a
~
I
co
co
~
c
c;;;
1
0
s
"--
II
.
~
0:
. ,
. ,
J :Q
IL
c;;;
c
;.~ a..
<,
k;
I
C 'Il . . .
...
c;;;
c;;;
III
'I I ,
0
~~
U N
N
0:
0 c;;;
~-~
0
'"
'"
..,
~ s ~ ;;
~
'" :s
'"
:!
'" '" '"
N
'" '" '"
+ +
..,
'"
s 0 0
0
0
c
. . .
'" '"
N
'"
'" 0
'"
0 c
'"
0
'"
0
<>
0
'"
'"
0
0
'"
c;;; 0 0 o 0
..
,
.......
III
148
~
~
. . .
N
~ u,
+
"":
+
"":
u:
. . .
~
u,
~
+ +
..-
< ./
<0 ttl
c:i N
c:i
c
e,
"i-
II N
N
II
a.
c
~ <0
<0
c:i
c:i
\,)
\,)
. ~
"' "
~
"' "
c:i
is 0
~
N
= ::
N
c:i
~ c:i
~
X
: ; ;
0
~
0
C
~~ I() I()
"' "
I() (' ") I() NI() ..- I() 0
e-,
<0 I()
" '"
' "
N 0
oq'
M N c:i
II
~
' "
Z W
z w
Q
II
; 'S
~
&
k;
<0
~
~
.....
= ::
~
. . ,
~
~
<,
~
III
"":
\j
..-
N
~.
u,
~
+
N ~
-
~
~
N
9
III
~
e n
u:
0
~
o
+
N
~
a..
LO
<
. ~
0
co
~
III
9
c
c:i
II ~ N
II
II
N
~
N e,
9
<0
<,
c:i
e n
" ': .
~
S
" '"
e n III
c:i
0
U
c
N
0
+ t-
o
r- <0 I()
" '"
('" ) N 0
C\I z w
<,
III
149
~
~
N
u..
+
t:
t:
e-
. . . .
L ; : :
<"!
N
+
. /.
. /.
CD
CJ )
0
0
c
. . .
Q.
: r
<"I
<0
H
~ 0
c
<0
0
ti
\,J
~
\,J
. . . . .
0
~
~ 0
~
i : :
N
~
0
('oj
0
: : : :
~
0
~
~ 0
It)
C! ;
It) ("'l It) N It) ... It)
0
~ ("'l 0 N 0 e- 0 0 It)
~
It) ("'l It) ('oj It)
0
Il)
0
~
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 ~ 0
'"
0 N 0
0 8
c : : ;
~.
0 0 0 0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0
0 0 0 0 0
II ~
c p
c p
. ,
II
Q
~
"S
~
k;
~
~ ~
--
~
. . ,p
: : : :
...... N
~
8
!Xl
u..
.
+
~
~
ooC: : >
L ; : :
N
~
oW
! ~
...
+
a
!II ~
0
~
u
r r
~
LO
e
.~
-
co
k;
III
0
9
0
II M
c
"
<"I
II
III
N
. . .
<0
9
Q.
0
<,
e n
~
~
~
e 0
!II !Xl
0
u
c
N
0
0
t+ -
It) ~ It) ("'l It) ('oj It)
0
III 0
~ 0 ("'l 0 N 0 e-
8 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 0 0 0 0
'"
c p <,
!Xl
150
151
~ U)
N
N
U.
U.
+
" " "
+
~
~
u : :
N
N
+
cl
cl
N
co
Q.
to
a:
0
N
0 D
....
a:
~
Q.
U)
C O
~
0
0
~
~
.....
.., .
..., .
.b
0
ci ~
~
N
N
~
ci
ci
::::
~
0
0 ~
~
I() N I()
<5
8
0
8
I()
C 5 ~
'"
I() NI() ~
8
0
~
~-
N 0
0
C 5
0 N0
0
0
~
0
ci 0
ci 0
0
0
0
0 ci
ci 0 ci
0 0 ci ci 0
II
........
,
q ,
\\)
II
Q
~
'S
~
~
~
'&
~ ~
-
~
: : : :
~ ~
.
~
":
~
~
..t: : .l
~ Q
~
~
9
III
~
0
~
U
N
Q.
~
LO
cl
. ~ N to
a
8
0
~
II M a:
II
N
II
J II
-
N
co
8
Q.
ci
<,
(Q
~ ..., .
9
0
III
0
U
a: N
0
0
-+ +
" " "
I()
'"
I()
N I()
0
10 0
0 M 0 N 0
<5 8
ci
0
0
0
0 0
0 0 0 0
N
q , .......
III
152
ll)
c : : : i
('\1('\1
a . . a . .
"
('\1('\1
I I
c : : : i
" I I
~~
a . . a . .
+ +
. _
.c
e,
(\')
as
c : : : i
~('\I
U)
c a
en
1 . 1 . 1 . 1 .
0
-
~('\I
C
CJ
a . . a . .
' e :
N
('\1('\1
....
c : i
I I I I
G)
\
('\I ('\I
E
a . . a . .
E
+ +
>-
U)
e
~
\
c : : : i
: : J
I I
~('\I
~
1 . 1 . 1 . 1 .
k;
j
~~
'5~
..I L o
a . . a . .
&
-
. . . 0
" I I CO
~
"
N0 ('\1('\1
"'5
0 0 0
a . . a . .
c : i c : : : i c : : : i c : i
....
+ +
= : :
~
!4d
.
~
~
~
~
ll)
. . . .
c : i
('\I
\'.)
LL
~
~
~
V 1 '
a . .
"
('\I ~
c : i
"
~ ('\I
o, . _
~
+
.c ...
e,
. ~
~
as
~
0
U)
c a
en
~ 0
-
LL
CJ
C
' e
~ ....
N
a . .
G)
c : : : i
('\I
E
I I
E ('\I
a . . >-
+
U)
.....
c : i
~
n,
0
I I
('\I
b~~~8~oO
o,
c : i c : : : i c : i c : : : i c : i c : i c : i
+
!4d
-
ll)
c : : : i
('\I
1 . 1 .
~
a . .
"
('\I
c : : : i
"
('\I
a . .
N
+
: : e
as
(\ ')
(I )
c : : : i
c a
en
~
0
-
1 . 1 . CJ
C C
~
....
N a . .
G)
c : : : i ('\I
E
I I
E
('\I
a, >-
+
rn
.....
c : : : i
~
o,
I I
0
('\I
(\')
~
N
~
a . .
N
+
' JnS' zINJZIN
' JnS' ZINJZIN
n
4
~
j
. .
Q)
U)
ftS
o
(. )
C
-
Q)
E
E
>-
e n
o-
s : : .
0..
. -
s :
0..
' r "
' r " u .
U._ - r -
- r - a . .
a . . N
II II
N C\ I
a . . a .
+ +
.....
o
C\ I
NU.
~ u . _ ' r "
o ~ a .
a . . C\ I
II II
N C\ I
0. . 0. .
:;l I D + +
C
('oj
o
88~8~oO
000000
!4d
!4d
88~8~oO
000000
H. . . +-....+--+--+o
~~
a . a .
I I II
N N
a . . a .
+ +
~C\ I
u . u .
....
o
('oj
o
m~C\ I
Ca . a .
C\ I C\ I
I I I I
C\l N
0. . 0. .
+ +
~C\ I
u . u .
~C\ I
u . u .
N N
a . a .
C\ I C\ I
I I I I
~~
a . a .
+ +
153
N
:E
a)
U)
ns
o
(.)
C
-
Q)
E
E
>-
tn
a)
U)
ns
o
o
C
-
Q)
E
E
>-
U)
c
::J
J ns'ZW/ZW
o
~
~u .
u . _
_ ~
~a .
a . C\ I
I I I I
C\ I C\ I
a . a .
+ +
. -
o
('oj
o
~~
a . . a .
I I II
C\ I C\ I
a . a .
+ +
~C\ I
u . u .
m~C\ I
C
- a . a .
C\ I C\ I
II II
C\ I C\ I
a . . a .
+ +
~N
u . u .
~N
u . u .
NN
a . a .
NN
I I I I
~~
a . a .
+ +
J ns'ZW/ZW
10 ('oj 10 .... 10 0
N . 0
.-
. s : : . ~
I l : _ . ~
C D ~
en
c a
o
C J
C
-
C D
E
E
>0
UJ
154
-- a ..
II
C\I
0. . .
+
-- LL.
N
:IE
-- 0. . .
II
N
a ..
+
. . -
o
N
o
r : D
-
C
( ' t )
o
.., .
ci
'J ns'zw/Zw
N . . . .COI O. . , . NO
. . . : 0000
I 4I I t-+-+-+--+-+ 0
I ( )
. . --~----r o
I ( )
0
C\I
L L
.., .
0
-- 0. . .
II
C\I
a ..
( ' t )
T
0
m
-
c
N
0
-- L L
. . -
--
0
a ..
II
N
0. . .
j
0
+
-- ( ' t ) I ( ) NI ( ) . . - SO
sssss
. 0 . 0 .
000
!lId
N
U.
I ( )
- - N
I ( )
0
0
- - N
L L L L
L L L L
NN
NN
a. . a. .
a. . a. .
NN
NN
. . , . II II . . , .
II II
0
-- --
0
-- --
0 . . 0 . .
0 . . 0 . .
+ +
+ +
.-
N . s : : .
:IE
0-
o.
( ' t )
G f
( ' t ) C D
0
- - N
U) 0
- - N
en
c a
L L L L
c a
L L L L
0
m
0
.~~I'
m
I iI~
- - N
-
- - N
C J
C
C J
C
0 . . 0 . .
C
0 . . 0 . . C
NN
NN
-
-
C D
N II II
C D
N
II II
0 NN
E
0
NN E
a .. a. .
E
0 . . 0 . .
E
+ +
+ +
>0
>0
en
en
c
c
~
. . -
~
....
0
(: )
- - N - - N
L L L L L L L L
-- -- -- --
0 . . 0 . . 0 . . 0 . .
1 II II
II II
NN
l8 C !
N
NN
I ( ) NI ( ) . . . . I()0
0 . . 0 . .
0. . . 0. . . N . 0
0 0 0
J nS'ZII\I/ZW
+ +
!lId
+ +
x
x
-;:;:;; z=o.s B
-;:;:;; Z=1.0 B
~Z-2.0 B
Z=3.0.....:B=-- __
-;:;:;;
155
Figure (4.28) Meshfor s=0.5 B
PL AN
1.0 1.0
+
t >
~ ~ ~ ~
~F1
F2
l()
c)
If")
c)
If)
c)
y
ELEV.
1.0
+
~ ~ ~ ~
t
~
F2 n
x
X
Z=3.0._:B=-- __
~
-;;:;;;; z::0.5 B
-;::;;; Z=1.0B
AZ"2.0 B
156
Figure (4.29) Mesh for s=B
PL AN
t
~
~ ~ ~ ~
F1 F2
I()
ci
1(')
ci
In
ci
y
1.0 1.0 .0.5.0.5.0.5.0.5. 1.00.0.5.0.)0.5.0.5. 1.0 1.0
ELEV.
~ ~
~
~
f1
F1 F2
z
. -
~ II')
"I
..
.,
lU
., d
c::i
9
0
.-I
157
Figure (4.30)Effect of rock interfacedepth (sIB=0.5),M,
Za38..,..:s..,
D.S
Za28...... :s..,
O.S
O.S
4
: E . 3
r- Z _ . _ O_ . 5 _ 8 ~. _ . . . . ~=_ 3 _ m~I_ _ ~===========: l ~
I--F1 -M-F21
-+-F1 __ F2!
o
0.5 Ao 1.5
Z =3 8 . . . . . . . . . . .
-+-F1
__ F2!
4 4
:i,
: E . l
0
O.S
Ao
1 .1 1 0
4
:S
siB = 0. 5
Rook Int.rr.o.
P coe ....t
tFz
1
158
Figure (4.31) Effect of rock interface depth (s/B=O.5), rj J
o
0.02
0.0&
-e-
0.04
__ F2
0.08
u
:z..28 G>z"'3<D,
o.os r""7-~----~;::=====:_1
0.08
0.01
0.0&
D.OS
0.04
0.03
am
0.01t---------_:~~===!b.-...--r_-------~
A o
0.5
0.00II
0.015
...
0.01
0.G2
1.5 0.5
0._
0.015
0.01
I-+-Fl __
F21
0.02
us
I
u
1.5
0.5
O.OS r--::--__.j~~~I1..-____;=====::::l
0.045 I
0.1)4 -+-F1 __ F2
0.034 .
0.03
0.02$
-eo.02
0.015
D.01
0.006
O+-------~~~=-=d~-.--r_~------~
0.1134 .,---------------------,
0.03
0.02$
0.02
0.015
0.01
o.oos
sI B =0. 5
r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
0.5
O+-----------~------~~~~~------~
a
0.02
0.015
0.01
Pco..... t
; F~
1
159
Figure (4.32) Effect of rock interface depth (siB=1.0). M,
1.5 1.5 0.5 0.5
4
23
--.- F 1 F 2
--.- F 1 F2
z,,3B Z"3B.~1
0.5 1.5 0.5
z,,2B...... 3<D ,
1.5
I--F 1 -If-F 21
1.5 0.5
ZO.5B....._,
I--F l
____
F 21
4
23
0
0.5
A.,
1.5
0
Z.B,_
I--F 1
____
F 21
4
23
siB = 1.0
r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
Rook Interlace
1
Peo..... _
; F.
160
Peoe.,t PeoeG!>t
t F, ;F2
I
BzB
BzB
'W'
Z
lIookInt~.o.
~~~~\.\.~\.~\.\.~~%"~'%.~,,,"~~'%~~~;~\.\.'*'\.~~~\.~~~~~
siS
=
1. 0
0.0'4 OJ lO3
Z0.S8G!>=3m,
0.0'2
I--F1
__
F21
O.acm
I--F1 _"_F21 0.01
O.ocn
0.008
-eg_ _.0015
0.-
0.001
0.002 O.OOOS
0.5
~
I.e 0.5
~
'.5
Z"8._
Z"8._3m,
0.01 OJ lO9
0_
0_
I--F1 _"_F2!
0.G07
I--F1 _"_F2!
0.-
0'-
0._
.-
0.004
0J I04
0.GC13
0._ O.ao:z
0.001
0 0
0 0.5
~
U 0 0.5 u
Z-2B._ z-2B.~
0.014 0.113
0.11'2
__ F1
_"_F21
O.ll25
__ F1
__ F2!
0.01
0.112
0_
+0.015 ..
O.ooe
u.
OJ lO4
0._
0.005
0 0
0 U ~ 1.J U 1.5
0.12 0.1
0.1
__ Fl
_"_F2!
0.01
__ Fl
.....
F21
0.08
0.0&
+0- ...
O.ll4
O.ll4
0.112
0.112
0
0 a.s
~
1 .5 0.5
~
1.5
Figure (4.33) Effect of rock interface depth (sIB=1.0),
.-
161
T""
~
C")
-
T""
- -
II
II) It)
0
C\I
N
. . ~
0
IS)
' """
+
~
<'Ii
II II
~R
m X l
. . . . . . . . . . . .
t i : In
In
-
- -
....
....
t :
LL LL ~
~
C\I C) C)
C C
. ~
. _
. _
' 0
. . . . 10. . .
0
~
0 0
-s
LL
u,
. . . . . . . . ~
mJ : ! mJ : ;!
T""
~
~
~
~N.c
N.c
~
~
II
~
,. . . . ....
. . . .
~
Q. Q.
~
CD CD
+
-
C C
5
~ ~
~
(J (J
~
0 0
~
a: : a: :
-
,. . . .
' I- ' I-
~
0 0 ~
1J
. . . .
~
(J
~
~ ~
I'Vj
W
W
~
~
IS) ....
II)
c:i
..-
. ~
0 ~
~
C")
II
~' --
+
0
0
IS) '0$" ('")
N . . . . . 0
II) "' C")
C\I
.....
0
zlI\I zlN
162
. . . . .
~
(t)
-...
- -
.....
10 0
II
N
0 0
~
LO
0 ~
N
II II
+
-e,
al al
~
--
--
UI t/J
~
- - ~ ~
LL LL
-
: : : : :
0') 0')
~
;. . .
N
C c:
~
0- O-
S
0 '0
~
;. . .
0 0
~
LL LL
. . . ...
'5
m2 m - 2
~
. . . . .
~
L O N . c ~N. c
~
~
II
. .... . . . - ....
~
t:. ;.
. . . . . C-
o.
t CI) CI)
C C
+
~
:::::
~ ~
. . . .
~
0 0
t:. ;.
0 0
e
0:: 0::
~
.... . . . .
. . . . .
0 0
"-
t:. ;.
t)
. . . .
~
CJ
~ ~
kl
i;)'
W W
IV")
~
11>
~
LO ci
0
.....
. ~
= =
(t)
~
II
N
~
+
0
0
N 11> . . . -
s
0
ci ci
~
II) ..... II)
0
ci ci
0
. . . . .
0
q
0 0
$
~
163
P L AN
1.0
;
F1 ~ F2
1.0 0.50.50.50.5 s0.50.50.50.5 1.0 + 1.0 +
; + + + . + + + + + -
Figure (4.36) Mesh/or studying air trenches (variable Wand D)
1,\
x
~co~uous Tr ench
y
+ 1.0 1.0 .0.5.0.5.0.5.0.5. s+0.5+0.~0.~0.5. 1.0 +1.0
ELEV.
~~ ~ ~
< 1 t >
~
F1
If)
ci
If)
Co
III
ci
C)
~ x
F e
If)
d
If)
d
164
PL AN
l()
c5
If')
c5
1J )
c5
t T Drscon il\UOUS r-ench
v
*
1\
~
1\
r1
\
V/,V/,
~ ~
F1~
F2
C>
. . . . . ;
y
1. 04 1. 0 40. 5. . )0. 5. . 5. s. 0. 5. 0. )0. )0. 5. 1. 0 + 1. 0
ELEV.
-~
~
t
N
Figure (4. 37) Mesh for studying air trenches (variable L)
------ ------ _----_. _. _-
x
F2 F1
o
-
111
o
If')
c5
If')
c5
165
II") M II") Nil")"'" II") 0
f"'l N - 0
o
v :
V')
- -
N
LL
N
+
LL
+
-
LL
-
-
+
LL
+
0
0
W
c e
U
N
e
N
e
II") II')
0 0
~
~
d
'- .)
0 0 ~
.....
II") ('t'l II") N II")
-
II") 0 II')
-::r II") ('t'l II")N II")
-
II"l 0
t
('t'l
N .- . 0 -::r
('t'l
N . . . . . 0
~
Z w
~
Z w
~
~
.....
-
C
II")
..s ;
-
~
c ...
-R
i Io..
~
CI'j
N
00-
LL
(V)
C\I
+
~
-
P ot
'-
('i
~ 9 II
-
e n
. . . .
~
0 P ot
-
. ~
U
LL r ..: : ;
N
+
0..
e
c e O
r r l
ex t
II
N
e
II
II"l
-
0
-
III
9
<,
e n
Vl
0
u
- 0..
166
167
'0
'0 '0
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
('\I
('\I
('\I
u,
u. .
u,
+ + +
. . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . .
u,
u,
u,
+
. . . . . .
+
+
. . . .
. . . . . .
- ~ <: >
- 9
I
W
(f'I
~
~
II
8
~
N
: : : :
9
8
C
~
. . . . .
-
~
~~
~
~ 0
0
'0
Mon ('\1'0
. . . . . . on 0
0
'0
Mon ('\1'0 on 0 ~~
M N . . . . . . 0
on ~ M
('\I . . . . . .
0 M N . . . . .
0
I. r'1
. ,.
w W
~
II
Q
'0
'0
'5~
. . . . . . . . . . .
~
~
('\I
('\I
~
u,
u,
+
+
l: : :
~
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
~
u,
u. .
C 'I I
+
+
-
~
PI
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
~
-
N
~
II
~
a
fI J III
. . . .
0
III
PI
~
C o)
" " "
rr
III N
.
<: >
8
~
0
I (f'I
-
II
~
u
9
8 ~
III
0
. @ J
. -I
.
~
0
II
~
;t
t
II
'"':.
~
~
9
II
'fl
<,
III
g . c :
0 III
Ul
C o)
;: I 0
0
0 s :: s ::
c . . ! f
'0
rr1 on ('\1'0 . . . . . . on 0
'I) Mon ('\1'0
. . . . . .
on 0
~F : <
M N
. . . . . .
0
rr1 N . . . . . .
0
0
' w
. . . .
u
168
'""
Q
9
9
~ I
II
("'l
N
II
~
9
N
N
9
9
;::;
\::I
;::;
-
. ::::;
. . . . .
. . .
C
u
~.
. . . . .
~
0 0
~
r- -
8
on "1"M N
-
0 N
-
00
8
"1" N0 r- -
~
on "1"M N.-<
0
C ?
000 00 .-<
0
0 0
C ?
0
C ?
o 000
0000000 0 0000 000o 000
~.
q , q ,
q ,
~
"
Q
I
V ')
I i
V ') 'S.
I
-
~
~
N "!5
C L LL
~
+ +
u
~
~
. . . . .
"&
~
. . . . .
u
. . . . 0. ~
. . .
~
II
9
~
tn
III M
0
III
0.
;::;-- o
c
N
~ U)
0 9
~
.
M
0
-
II
9
'""
~
9
III 0
.~
.-i
.
k;
0
~
II
~
!
II
....
Ii:
10
~
8
::I,c:
~
<,
In
o I:)
::I s ::
ell
0
0 0
s :: Q)
III
o
....k
- o on "1" MN..... 0
r-
8
on "1"C"I N
. . . . .
0
c:
~E-I
C ? C ? C ?
q q
C ? 0 0o 0
C ?
q
0
000000
0000000
u ,
c p
V ') V ') V ')
. . . . . . . .
....
N N N
LL LL LL
+ +
T
. . . .
LL
+
-
169
"')
v :
"')
. . . . .
. . . . .
N
N N
U. U. LL.
+ +
+
. . . . .
. . . . .
LL. U.
+ +
. . . . .
-
-
4(0
:i
Q
-
~-
9
~
I
W
C"l
~
II ;:
9
N
IN
C
9
9 ;:
I I ' l
= : : :
. _
"')
<: )
. . . .
0
~
~~
8.
~~
0
0
C
' <r I l ' l MI I ' l NI I ' l - I I ' l O
0
V" ' ) M" ' ) N" ' ) . . . . . " ' ) O
~
C"t) N _ :. <: )
I I ' l V M N . . . . .
0 M N 0
a",
a",
" " ,
o : S ~
~
v : "')
;:
- -
~
s : : :
N
N
~
LL.
U.
+
+
~
. . . .
~
. . . . .
-
~
LL.
U.
~
N
+
+
. . . . .
~
. . . . .
- ~
. . .
~
II a
~
CI t III . . . .
~
0
~
Q
~
r
III
N
Q
9
. . .
U
C"l
.~ -
II
Q
9
-
~ 9
III
I I ' l
('1;1
<: )
.
0
III
0
!
!
II
-
~
III
-
a I)
~
<,
CI t :S. ,. d
en
0 o 0 III
0
0
Q
: s I = :
c
C
"') M I I ' l N" ' )
. . . . .
I I ' l 0
V" ' ) M" ' ) N" ' ) - " ' ) O
. r!I. i
N
<: )
~ro
M
. . . . .
M N . . . . .
0
8 ~
" . .
170
II') II') II')
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
<'l
<'l <'l
U.
U. U.
+
+ +
. . . .
. . . . .
u, u,
+ +
. . . . .
0
-
-
-e
0
e
e
I
II
('f")
~
M
II
e
<'I
e
<'I
~
e
II')
-
- 0
c
;:::
-
. : : : : ;
-
'"
Q; : )~
II
0 0
8-
COr- - ' 8V1~C' "l N""' O
~ N . . . . .
~' 8~
N 0
COr- - 8V1~C' "l N- 0
~~
00 00000
. . . . . . . . . .
0
q 00 0 000
00000000 00 0000 00000000
q ,
~ ~
<: : : : )
~
. : : : . ~
II')
II')
~
. . . . .
. . . . .
. _
~
N N
~
U. U.
+
T ~
. . . . .
~
. . . .
-
u, u,
+ +
'" N
. . . . .
~
-
~
N
~
II
kl
s
~ en 1 % 1
. . -t
0
~ ~
u
r
III
< 0 . . . .
~ Q
e
II
I ('f")
~
-
II
Q e
-
. . . . .
1 % 1
e
. [0
V1 V1 ('I
0 0
k;
0
II C Q
"
t
II
-
~
II
C Q
S : : s . d
~
<,
en
o 0
: : s r :::
Ul
0
r ::: II
1 % 1 0
0
U
. r ! ~
1. 0 V1 ~ C' "l N . . . . .
0
r- -
8
V1~ C' "l N
. . . . .
0
- g E - t
q 0 0 q 0 0
0 q00 qq
0
0 000 00
000 000 0
o
cj I
'"
171
0
-
0
8
W
<
M
~
N
II
8
N
N
8
8
~
on ~
0
c
~
~~
II
8_
0 ~~
v :
Mon
NV:
. . . . on 0 0
v :
Mon NV:
. . . . . . on 0
~ M N . . . . 0
on V M N
.-.
0 M N 0
w W W
~
=:
~
v : v :
~
. . . . . . . . . . .
=:
N
N
~ L L
L L
+
+
~
-
(',. )
. . . .
. . . .
~ U.
L L
kl
C\I
+
+
. . . .
~
-
~
~
...
'a
II 9
~
III
In
"
0
~
~
u-
0
0
N
c
III
Q <
8
<
~
R I M
ti:
-
"
Q
8
-
8
In
on
v :
~
0 0
0
CCI
H
:It
t
II
~
~
CCI
9
III
'a
<,
'H
III
o II
e n
0 III
0
0 u-
. . c : . . c :
c
4) 0
v :
Mon
NV:
. . . . .
on 0
v :
Mon NV:
. . . . on 0
t: 7 I C
M N ...... 0
M N . . . .
0
C 41
. ~
W
W
..::I E o<
v :
v : v :
. . . . .
. . . . ....
N
N N
L L
L L L L
+
+ +
. . . .
. . . . . ....
L L
L L L L
+
. . . .
+ +
. . . .
. . . .
172
") ") ")
-
. . . . . . . .
N
N N
U.
U. U.
,
+
+
..... . . . . . .....
u, u.
u,
+
+
. . . .
+
. . . .
0
-
-
0(
Q
W
9
I M
~
<"I
II
9
N
9
N
~
9
V'l
0
<""l
c : : : i
~
~.
II
e_
0
0 0
~.
r-
8
V'l
;g~
N. . . . . .
0
"'t N. . . .
~8;g
N0 t--
8
V'l "'t ('t'l N. . . . .
0
II
0 q 00
. . . . . . . . .
0
q 0 0qq 00
~
000000c:i c:i 0 000 0 000o000
,
4 > 4 >
~.
~
~
") ")
~
......
. . . . .
~
N
, t: ;
N
~
U. U.
+
,
.....
'-J
~
-
.....
~
u, u,
N
+
. . . . .
+
i ;)'
P -4
~
-
~
. . .
~
II s
lit III .-t
~
0
P -4
(, )
c
III
0(0
N
,[0
Q
9
II
I M k;
-
II
Q 9
III
9
C'I
II)
V'l
.
c:i 0
0
II
III
:l
!
II
~
~ III
III
9
Ij.I
0 II
~
<,
lit
0
,t:!,t:!
III
U l
0
0
(, ) + l 0
t7I c
r--
~
V'l "'t ("")N
. . . . .
0
8
II) "'t ('t'l N. . . . .
0
c r s: : CD
0 qqqqq
0 0 q 0 q
CD ~ c:i 00o000
0c:i 00 00
. . : l E - <
4 >
4 >
('oJ
~
~
I
. . . . . .
00
~
-
-
-
c,
I
('oJ
a,
\0
+
-
-
= =
~
I
('oJ
~
-
"<1 "
-
. . . . . .
Il.
I
('oJ
~ c ::
o,
0
+
" 5 -
;:
ca
~ ('oJ
"0
- . . . . . .
= =
~
. !
I
-s
('oJ
CI)
= =
s ::::
m
> -
~
';
-
-
c,
. r::
~
-
U)
I
. . . . . .
Q.
ca
('oJ
OJ
c . .
Il.
-
C
+
\,J
~
N
kl
L L
('oJ
~
C)
u,
00
e
c;
~
0
;:
c
~
0
8
~
0
L L
u, . . .
Q)
. [
c;,
~
\0
c
0
00
+
-
u,
~ c;
0
e
:;:::l
~
~
Cl
('oJ
c
e n
0
+
0
. . :- . "'
173
a~epns 'ZWJ ZII\I
~ ('oJ _ 00 \0 "<1 " ('oJ 0
- - 000 t o
I ~
~
a:n~jJ ns 'ZIl\lJ ZII\I
~('oJ . . . . . . OO\O~('oJO
_ - 0 000
o
-
. . . . . .
00
~
. . . . . .
e
0
;:
('oJ ca
- . . . . . .
0
. !
CI)
m >
-
;:
s:
CJ
~
-
...... c.
<
OJ
C
"t-
L L
C)
00
e
;:
0
0
0
L L
\0
0
~.
. -
~
0
...
o
C"l
C"l
~
M
I
. . . . . .
00
~
. . . . .
. . . . . .
a,
I
C'l
n,
"?
+
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
~
M
I
C'l
~
-. :t
. . . . .
. . . . .
o,
I
C"l
~
c:
a. .
0
+
-5"
;;
ttl
~
C"l
'0
. . . . . .
~
. . . . .
~
. !l
I
"5
Q)
~
~
>
~
In
.
b
-
' i i i
. . . . .
~
e,
~ . . . e n N
. . . . . .
Q. ttl
C"l
CI,)
Q.
o,
-
\. l
C
+
~
N ~
U.
en
C'l
~
00
u,
~
0
e
d)
~ ;; c:
0
:;:::;
~
0 8
u,
LL
. . . .
(J ) . ~
\0
0>
k;
c:
0
i:i)
+
. . . . . .
-. :t
U.
0
d)
c:
:;:::;
8
u.
(J )
C"l
Cl
c:
0 e n
+
0
-
174
o
\0
o
o
-. :t
o
o
C"l
o
o
00
o
o
. . . . . .
o
~
~
I
1
r:~
I. ,
. . . '
-. :t
.
. . . . .
e
0
. _
- C"l
ttl
. . . . . '0
. !l
Q)
In
> ._
-
-
s: (. )
I -
. . .
I ~
...... Co
<t
CI,)
C
"l"'"
U.
en
00
e
. _
0
-
0
0
U.
\0
0
;
-. :t
0
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
00
L
0
C"l . . . . . . 00 \0 -. :t C"l 0
. . . . . .
0
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
cp
('I") ('I")
0 0
~
('I")
I
. . . . .
~
-
. . . . .
0. .
I
N
II") II")
Q.
('l ('l
+
0 0
. . . . .
~
('I")
I
~
. . . . .
0. .
I
, _
~
I-
N
,.
('l
N
0
~
e
D-
C
0
0
+
~ 0
. _
. _
~
-
t 'CI
- s ca
'0
"0
. . . . .
U)
f
~
. !
-
~
~
C D
CD
~ m >
m
> -
'ii)
. . . . .
-
;:
-
0. .
s : : .
s : : .
~ II")
-
Co >
II") ~
U) I
. . . . . "C
<C
. . . . "C
t 'CI
N
~
3:
~
a.
D-
O
0
+
-
<&-
~
L L
N
~
C)
L L
N
C
C)
1L
~
. _
e 0;
00'
-
. _
0
~
c
""::t-
O
0
:;:;
~
L L
0
8
u,
u,
~
,~ i
I~
. . . . .
'.
. . . .
C D
0
0
Ol
~ c
e n
~
+
. . . .
1L
0;
c:
II")
II")
8 0
0
0
0 1L
C D
Ol
c
e n
+
0
0
\0- . :t ('l . . . . . 00\0
~
('l
0
- . :t ('l . . . . 00 \0 - . :t
('l
0
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
0000
. . . . . . . . . .
0 0 00
8:J ejJ ns'ZW/ZW
8:J ejJ ns'zw/zw
175
o
M
0
N
3:
M
I
. . . . .
3:
-
. . . . .
D. .
I
N
Ir'l
a.
N
+
0
. . . . .
3:
M
I
N
: : :
-
. . . . .
D. .
I
N
N
0
C
D. .
0
+
;;
~
ftS ;S~
"0
. . . . .
fn
~ ~
-
~
("l
Q)
~
fj
>
m
' c ; ;
. . . . . ~
-
&.
a.
~
1rI
-
fn I
-
"C
ftS N
~ 0
~
Q.
a.
+
-
N
~
LL.
~
C)
N
kl
L L .
c:
c; 0\'
;;
. f;
~
0
"8
~
0
-
U.
L L .
~
0
(I)
. . . .
Cl
. ~ c
e n k;
+
. . . . .
L L
C;
Ir'l
C
0
. .
0
0
&
Q)
Cl
c
e n
+
176
\0- . :t N0
000
000
: I
l
. . .
Ir'l
o
o
N
0 C
0
~
-
0
tn
-
Q)
m
>
-
;;
1 r ' l : 5
o
. - : " C <C
O~
"l("-
LL.
C)
C
, _
-
0
0
LL.
-
0
M
o
0
\0- . : : t N
-
00\0- . :t N0
-
. . . . . . . . . .
0
0000
000 0000
cp
. .
~ ~
.
: ~I~
177
""!N ...... OO'CJ"'1'NO
............ 000 0
o
o
V') V')
.'
"'1' ~
~
~
I
)
......
~
~
Q)
"
.....
0
~
a
..
......
D..
~
I
~
(" l I/)
~
D..
-c
" V') Vl
+
"
: ~
~
~
~
.'
c: :
e
"
0
0
i
,
;:;
"
;: ;
~
( .
ca
'~~" .
C 'C S
: : : :
I
-
~
"0 ~
0
.!!
.!!
~
C D
(" l
C D
LL
(" l
: : : :
a: I
>
a: I >
~
~
-
-
' i n
e n
5
;:; . s : : .
c
~
~
-
fI) I
~ V)CI
Vl C I
:;:;
ca
8
......
Nj
(" l
c
0..
~ ....
I
~
LL
-
\,,)
G)
......
~ ..... D..
LI.
N
C l
I
~
LI.
c (" l
O'J
(j)
0..
~
c: :
O'J
+ +
~
l
I~
;: ;
c:::
II')
0
;:;
~
0
0
LI.
0 ~
u, ....
.~
V)
V)
~
......
......
......
LL
......
C l
~
C
~
:;:;
I
I
......
......
8 ~
LL
-
G)
......
C l
0..
I
C
(" l
(j)
0-
V)
Vl
+ +
0
0
'. I
~
~
I
-
V')
.,
V') ~
~
.
,
~ , , ......
a..
I
N
Q)
a..
_.
+
0
0..
,
E
>-
" .
~~
~. I ,
~
I
,
N
~
V')
V')
......
~
~
a..
I
~
'. I e
N
~
C
a..
0
0
+
;::
;::
....
c a
- c a
:~
l ' l E ' .
' 0
~
~
.I~
' 0
......
~ -
~
~
f
u
....
CD
-
CD
N ~
m >
m > ~ - b
-
' e n
' &
-
;:: .c
.c
......
-
U V')
-
Ul
a..
V')
en
<C N
en
c a I
.....
N
c
c
Q.
N
U
G >
G >
a..
~ ..J
..J
+
....
N
kl
u,
C)
u,
~
e
C)
N
"I
I~
,-
~
I C LL
~
-
0
;::
c:i l
0
0 c:
~
U.
0
:;::;
u,
0
.~
0
,
LL
~
V')
Q)
V') en
......
c:
......
(jj
+
-
......
LL
......
c:i l
c:
:g
0
LL
V') Q)
V')
0
en
0
c:
(jj
+
1-
J..
0
0
' <:t N ...... 00 - - 0 "'1" N 0
"'1" N ...... 00 - - 0 "'1" N 0
..... ......
0
0000
......
-
0
0000
00 0000
00 0000
I>
178
179
In order to study these parameters, different models of adjacent footings have
been studied to clarify the effect of each parameter. The analysis is based on the finite
element method. A special three dimensional finite element program has been developed
to perform theparametric study; themost pronounced factors are emphasized.
5. Use of trenches to reduce interaction between the adjacent machine foundations.
4. Effect of the foundation embedment on their response.
3. Effect of the soil depth to the underlying fIrmstratum on the interaction between
the machine foundations.
2. Effect of spacing between the foundations on the interaction between the
machine foundations.
1. The effect of different parameters of the forcing functions of the footings (i.e.,
the frequency, the amplitude and thephase).
The aim of this research isto study the interaction of the machine foundation. The
following parameters havebeen studied:
5.1. INTRODUCTION
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Chapter (5)
180
9. Both vertical vibrations and accompanying rocking increase by increasing the
depthof therock interface
8. For unsymmetrically embedded footing, the greater the load acting upon the
embedded footing the greater the response of surface footing, and this effect
increaseswiththeincreasingof theembedmentdepth
7. For symmetricallyembedded footings, thevertical vibrationsand accompanying
rockingvibrationsdecreasemonotonicallywith increasingtheembedment of the
footing;however, therockingdecreasesathigherrates.
6. Rocking and vertical vibrations are no longer uncoupled considering the
interactionof closefootings.
5. The greatest interactionhappens when thetwo footingsarebiasedthrough some
phaseangle, thiseffectisslightincaseof small sIBratios(sIB=O.5)but tendsto be
significantathigher sIBratios(sIB= 1.5)
4. The interactionincreasesin a linear formas theFAR increasesfor (FFR 1).For
theother FFR values, theresponsetrendsarenot linear.
3. "The closer the MO footing, the greater the interaction" is not always a true
statement, becauseat higher FFR (FFR>3.0),thefootingswill not suffer fromthe
effect of interaction. Thereforedifferent machine foundation can be constructed
withspacingequal to 0.5Bwhentheir FFR isgreaterthan3.0.
2. The most pronounced interactioneffect will appear at the least distancesIB=O.5
andat FFR =1.0.At sIB=3.0, theinteractionpracticallyvanishes.
1. The greatest interactioneffect appearswhen the FFR 1then it decreases as this
ratio increases and almost vanishes at FFR 3. At shallow depths of rock
interface, the difference between the footing responses at different FFRs is not
significant. The change of response with change of FFRs is notable when the
depth of compressible layer is more than 1.0B for spacing equal to 0.5 B and
I.3B for spacingequal to B.
Theobtainedresultscanbeconcludedinthefollowing:
5.2. CONCLUSION
181
Future research in this field is suggested to be more accurate using the viscous
boundaries toprevent theordinary boundary effect that may reflect thewaves back to
the region of interest. The study must include the interaction between the footings
under general cases of vibrations (i.e. torsional, sliding, ...etc.), taking intoaccount the
possible relative displacement between the footings and their supporting soil at the
contact area. The soil modeling must includethe effect of the confming pressure on
thesoil elastic modulus andtheeffect of soil anisotropy.
Interaction between footings must be studied thoroughly because it may be of
the same importance as thesinglefooting behaviour and may generate unpredictable
vibrations similar to the inducedrocking dueto vertical vibrations.
5.3. RECOMMENDATIONS
11. Increasingthetrenchdepth,widthor lengthwill decreasethevertical vibrationsof
thepassiveisolatedfootinguptoD =B, W=0.1B andL =3B andthentherateof
thedecreasewill bevery small.
10. Trench isolation can reduce the vertical vibration in passive isolation but may
increase the rocking for both footings and the vertical oscillation for the active
isolation with themost pronounced effect happening when FFR=1.0
I nt er act i on of sur f ace f oot i ngs
Appendi x ( A)
183
Effect of Spacing and FFR
PART (I)
184
105
1--+-+--+--+--+--+ 0
It)
to
N
L L .
N
t
L L .
t
..-
L L .
..-
+
L L .
+
8
8
II
C O ?
N II
9
N
9
to
c;;
('II
~
-
I lt . . . . . ;
M
II
II
9
. -I
I/)
I lt
~
0
U
0
N
0 W O j
a. (0 to ....
'"
N... a
<0 to . . . . (") N ... a
~
Z w Z w
~
0
VI
k;
1 ""1
to
to
~
.....
~
II ~
N
N
~
~
c:Q
u. .
~
'"':.
f
u. .
9 III
<,
t
I
I/)
Ul
~
0
U
~ c
..-
. ~
u. .
+
. . -
L L .
~
+
C ~
S
~
1 1
N
. . . II
9
N
9
to to
c;; c;;
185
. . . . .
u.
+
c J : 8
II N
N
I ! . .
8
8
~
to
ci
ci
!I
'I')
N N
~
....
u..
P o l
II
N
II 9 ...
~
In ri
0
P o l
"5
()
0
0
-
N
1 : : : $
Q.
<D I{) ..,. C') N
~0
<D I{) 'f C') N...0
Z W
Z w
~
~
VI
~
Lt')
I{)
~
-
~
f
e-
~
rI
II
N
N ~
U.
~
U.
+
C Q
+
I '"'!
!l
: : : s .
a
<,
In
C I)
..-
~
0 .....
u.
()
u.
+
...
c
+
.[ <l
~
N
U.
+
9
M
I ! . .
8
r- - - - - - - - - - - ~~~
.-
u.
+
N
U.
+
r-------------. ~
186
1--+--+--+---+--+-+0
N ~
p.,
~
..
II
II
'"
e
rI
~
III
p.,
0
CJ
0
0
t.oj
N
.....
Q.
C O It) V ("') N .... 0
C O ~ V
'"
c-. .... 0
~
Z w Z w
~
0
~ II
~
N
~
I()
.....
....
\.l
~
II
~ N
N u,
LL.
~
"'!
~I
~
+
+
I
9
~l
<,
~
III
r n
~
0
CJ
c
~
.~
u,
+
..-
u,
~
+
c 9
II N
...
II
9
...
S
It)
0
N
N
u,
+
u,
+
..-
u,
..-
+
u,
+
S
c : l I
e
c : l
M
"
' ! ...
N
s
S
I{)
I{)
0
0
~------------~
~------------~
187
Q
N
N')
-
~
II
N
II
9
.-I
~
1/1
~ 0
r')
~ 0
0
-
a.. (D I()
..., .
(") N ~ 0
(D I()
..., .
(") N ~ 0 ~
Z w Z w
~
0 k;
III
~
(Y')
I() I()
-
t;.)
II
~
~
N
~
~
~
U.
N
'"'!.
+
U.
I
S III
<,
: 1 ~ en
fI l I 0
~
C o)
c
~
.~
u,
+
.....
k;
u,
+
0 8
II N
'"
II
a
N
a
I()
o
~
I()
~
N
N U.
+
U.
+
~
u,
~
f
u.
f
8
8
CO')
I I
I !..
N
9
S
188
Effect of FAR
PART (II)
189
o
. . . . . .
1----+--+- __--+---+0
1----+---+--+-+---+0
('II
u,
+
. . -
u,
+
..-
u,
+
a:
a:
N
II
II
N
N
c,
a. .
10
~
c:)
0
t
~
~
II
. .
~l
8
~
<'I
9
II
II)
~J
(".l
~
0
8 ~ to)
N
0 0
a. .
T
0 co CD
. ,. .
N 0 0 CD CD
., ..
N 0
Ir)
-
. . . . . .
I
Z W
Z W ~
~I
L O
II
E ; 3
~
I
M
~ ~
~ . . . . . .
-e-
J
Q ::;
II
('II
('II
~
u,
u,
~
+
+
~
~ . . . .
9
<,
\J
II)
~ l
. . -
:g,
0 (1)
..-
u,
~
to)
u,
+
a:
+
i; )'
I
~
~
a:
a:
.~
~
~
~
0
. . . .
II
II
N
N
a. .
a. .
10
c:)
r---------... ~
('II
u,
+
o co co oq- N 0
-e--
2 W
..-
L L
+
190
r - - - - - - - - - - - ~w~
o ex)
., ....
~- +- - +- ~- - ~- + 0
..-
L L
+
N
L L
+
0:
0
0:
N
<C
II
II
N
N
Q.
0..
I()
It'!
ci 0
~
r - ...;
-
II
8
~
-
~ N
k;
8
II
II)
C"I ~
0
8
U
N
0 0
")
Q.
0
ex)
co
..,
N 0 0 ex) co
..,
N 0 .....;
-e--
2 W
., ....
2 W
II
~
It)
"':i
-
~
M
It'! It'!
~
., .... ., ....
II
N
N ~
LL
LL
~
+
+
-
-
ell
~
8
<,
~
II)
..-
..-
~
0 C I) LL
LL
U
+
+
~
0: I
~
~
c:
< l
0:
.~
II)
~
r .: .: ;
c: i
"""
II
II
N
N
o,
D..
I() I()
ci ci
~- - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
o ClO co ~ N 0
. . . . .
or"
LJ _
+
~ - - - - - - _ _ 1I 'l
. . . .
191
o co
. . . . .
or"
LJ _
+
N
LJ _
+
r------------- __ ~
c
c:
N
I I
I I
N
N
e,
c,
<:::l
. . . . ;
I I
-
~
~ a
~
a
II
~
I I ) ("l
0
a
1::3
u
N
,0 0
<:::l
c. .
~
0 co co ~ N 0
0 ClO co ~ N 0
-e-
. . . . .
Z W
I I
Z w
~
0
r. oj
~
(Y)
I I 'l I I 'l R ::
. . . . . . . . . .
~
N
I I
N
LJ _
~
LJ _
+
+
. . . .
al
\. )
"'!
~ a
<,
I I )
or"
~
0
U l
or"
LJ _
LJ _
t:::' o
+
+
c:
I
~
~
. ~
c
t t l
c
<{
~
&t')
~
0
"""
"
I I
N
N
c. .
c. .
I t) I t)
ci ci
. . . . .
L L
+
192
N
L L
+
~-------~
. . . . .
LL
+
c:
c: N
II II
N N
a. a.
c::,
I 'I " i
II
. . . .
~
8
k";
. .
M N
~
8
II
e n C'I
~
0
8
u
c::,
N
I 'I " i
a.
0 0
0 G) (0 'q' N0 0 co
(0 'q' N 0 II
~
Z W
~
Z W
~
!;. oj
0
-
Itl
~
c::c::
(\")
III
III
~
~ ~
II
N
N
~
LL
L L
. . . .
+
I
~
~
~
aJ
If ~
8
<,
W
~
e n
Ul
. . . . .
00'
0
LL
U
I
+
I
c:
T
~
~
. ~
c: c:
< l
k;
It)
~
I
0
'I""
II
II
N
N
e,
a.
LO
d
r-------_~
193
Effect of FPD
PART (III)
194
Figure (A-9) Effect oj FPD at s/B>1.5andFFR=1.0
9=270 9=315
6
6
5
b;]
5
~
4
4 2
2
N
N
:!E3
:i E3
2
2
o 1.5 0.5
P cos(rolt) P cos(fD2t +e)
; F1 ; F2
BxB
BxB
'*'
siB -1.5 0)2=0)1
-
9=0
9=45
5
5
4
< 4
~
1- ' - F1\
3
2 I
3
I -M- F21
N
I
N
:!E
:e
I
I
2
2
I I
I
I I
0
I
01
~51
0 0.5 1.5
0 05
A o
A o
9=90
6
0=180
6
5
5
~
4
b;]
4
1
N
N
2
:2:3
: E 3
2 2
195
Figure (A-10) Effect of FPD at sIB=1.5 and FFR=3.0
1.5 0.5
o~- - - - - - _+- - - 2C=~~K- ~==~
o
2
1.5
~
j-'-F 21
4
5
6 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
9=45
2
N
: : : !E 3
4
5
6 r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
0
0
0 0.5
A o
1.5
0 0.5
A o
1.5
9=270
9=3 15
6
6
5
5
4
~
4
~
...
2
~3
N
2
~3
2 2
0 0
0 0.5
A o
1.5 0 0.5
A o
0= 90 9=180
6
6
5
5
4
~
4
... ...
:iE3
2
: : !E 3
2 2
. . .
~3
9=0
P cos(m:zt +6)
; F 2
siB - 1.5
BxB.
196
Appendix (B)
Effect of Embedment
197
~
~ <D
N
N
U.
U.
+
+
"':
N
"':
u.
"':
. . . . . . . . . .
+
u ::
<'!
u ::
+
.....
+
<'! <'!
.....
u ::
+
~ < l
a
C O ')
0
"
N
e
a
~
<0
c
cj
('oj
~
'i
Q.
~
. .
u
o
\.l
. . . .
~
~
N ~
cj
~
~
0
0
~
It') N It') It')
0
0 "~~~N~~~O
N 0
r-, <0
It') . . . .
'"
N..... 0
z w z w z w
~
II
Q
C D ~
'S
.....
~
N
U.
+
N '"G
u.
. . .
+
....
-
~
u:
.
+
<'!
u:
<'!
~
e-
ooC ::i
1
+
~
'"
0
u <>
. . .
It)
0..
,
a
a
E S -
0
f D < l
C O ')
~ < l ~
II
cj
II
N
.~
a
Pl fD c
<D ~
<,
cj II
cj
Vl
0:
-
. . . .
. .
e
c:i
c:i
III
0
U
c
N
N
c:i
cj
N
0
0
It')
N It') .....
. . . . . .
.... It')
P) "" Nl()
.....It') 0 N
It') 0
m
. . . ; N . , . . ;
c:i
cj
z w
z w
198
II
~cl
N
9
a M
0
II
II. a
a
C D
0 c
~
N
~
II.
CL
~
. . .
0 ~
.~
N
.t:;
0
~
E
~
0
0
0
. . . N
0
~
8
N0
~
~
s
'"
0
8
0
'"
N
'"
~
00 s
0
0
8
0
0
0 0 0
N0
0
~ 00 0000
0 0 0
0
0 0
0 0 0
C
II
(I)
Q
C D
C D
'5
&
"G
. .
-
: : : :
~
"!
~
-
~
-
~
~
N
Q
a
III
0
U ~
N
10
CL
I
9
~cl
9
~
0
M
~ II
II
a
II
II
N
.~
a
a: I
c
C D
0 t.L ~
<,
II. II
Q.
N
Ol
Q.
. .
0
-
~
S
III
0
N
U 0
c
0
0
CO<D~N" " " ~~" " NO
.. N
0
~ ~
...
8 0
N
c;c;oc;g .. 88
00
0
8
"-
0000 0000
00 o 000
III
~
-
C D
N
o
-.:
o
N
-
-_ _
z w
~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - .~
. . . . . ,
, .._ '" '"
a
"
N
a
u ::
+
z w
N - 0
u ::
+
~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , ~
o
199
z w
'" o
, - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - , ~
z w
'" o
a
II
N
a
c
: 1 :
z;
+
o
N
u,
+
LO
o
II
~
<,
(I)
NN
............
III III
z w
u: :
+
-
9
lit
8
c
N
u. .
+
~- - - - - - - - - - - - - - , ~
200
'"
"l "l
..-'
'"
u,
"":
f
....
"":
'" '"
'"
-l <
-l
., .,
'" < >
i
< >
< >
s
~
'" '"
'"
~
< > < >
< >
\oJ
.~
... ...
...
. ~
< > < >
< >
E :
~
N N
N
~
~
< > < >
0
:::
: : :
.....
~ -
0 0
0
0
~
~ ;!
N~
'"
~ 8
N0
l(l
~
'"
0
*
0
'"
M
l(l
N on
*
0
~
0
0
~
8
0
0
0
< >
'"
0 0
0
0 0 0
c:i 0
ci
q
0 0
~
0 0 0 0 0c:i 0
c:i c:i 0
c:i 0 0 0
,
< I >
q,
< : : )
~ II
c$
.....
~
1
"l
"l
-s ~
& ~
...
"'G
~
..-'
N
"':
-
II
u,
:::
f
~
~
'"
N
.
~ ~
~
~
3
z;
~ VI
+
~
0
~
u
c
8
L O
e -l
~
a
'" '"
I
0
ci
0
E : 3_
II
3
~
.
a:
'"
'" ~
'I..
0
0
.~
<, A-
I)
k;
...
...
c:i
c:i
VI
0
u
a:
N
N
0
0
0
0
m
l(l
N
'"
0
*
0
~ '"
..,
on N
~ 0
~
0
0
0
'"
0
s
0
0
0 0
0
0
0 0
0
0
0 0 0
0 0 ci 0
... N
o il
o il .....
.....
III III
tD
U)
N
U.
+
...
"": . , . . . :
...
u :
N
"'! . . .
. . .
+
.[
-l
co
co
c: : i
c: : i
~
N
c a.
II C'II
C~ N
II
a.
tD
c
tD
~ c: : i
c
II
~
. . .
...
~
c: : i
c: : i
~
~
N
N
~
c: : i
c: : i
~
. . . .
b
~
0
0 E
10 M I() N 10 10 0
10 ... 10 M 10 N10 . . . 10 0
~
M N c: : i
"'"
M N 0
Z W
Z IN
: : :
~
~
U)
~
II
c $
...
'S ...
N
~
U.
+
~
- -
N
5
N
8
.
In
0
u :
u
~ N
+
. . c;)
a.
~
l{)
e
III
0
9
CD
~
II
c: : i
E8_
~
c
II C'II
~
C:Q
N II
9
N
a.
eo
.~
<,
c: : i
ct)
k;
~
~
8
... In III
c: : i 0
U
c
N
c: : i
m 0
. . . . tD 10 . . . M N 0
('I ('I
..............
ZIN
III III
201
c
<
a:>
co
~ 0
0
c
. .
~~
Q.
"
N
f '1 'i . .
II
Q. !O
~
I I
0
<0
0
~
~
. . r
0
. . r
~
0
~
\j
N
\j
0
N
0
. . . .
. :::
~
1 5
0
~
I() 0
0
I() N
0
8
N 0
0
I() . . r I() M I() N
!; !2
0
I() 0
0
0 0
. . r a M a N a
8
0 0 0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 :::::
0 0 0 0 0
~
cp
cp
~
~
<0
"
Q
N
- s
u,
+
. . r
~
~
. . . . .
: : : : :
u : :
N
~
-
.
'"
+
a
VI
~
0 . . c : : ,
U
~
. .
Q.
lO
C ~
0-
ex)
~
e
0
I I M
c
~
I I N
~
N
"
. [0
e
. .
C D
Q.
<,
0
~
(Q
'"'!.
8
. . r
0
VI
0
U
c
N
0
m
a
. . r I() M I () N I ()
0
I () 0
a
8
0
s
a
0 8
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
C 'I C 'I
<,
<,
cp
I I I I I I
202
C D
'C !
. -
. . r
. . r
"'!
N
. -
<D
<D
N
U.
N
+
U.
'<t
+
"":
('j
u ::
N
+
<
<
~
co
co
~-
c:i
c:i
e cr
~
II N
II
. . .
II
~
C L .
c
<D <D
c:i o
~
~
'<t '<t
a
c:i c:i
\j
.~
. ::
N N ~
c:i c:i
~
a a
~
. . .
I() <"l I() N I() I() a
I() '<t I()
<"l I() N
~
10 a ~
.,;
N c:i '<t
.,;
N c:i
~
Z W Z W
C
II
c$
~
. . .
;S
~
~
'<t
-= ::
N
~
U.
~
+
~
~
N ~
~
9 III
~
III
0
U
~
. . .
C L .
~
Il')
e
0
N
~
III
8
co
.~ II
c:i
('f')
c
II
N
~
-
II
~
N
S
0-
<D
<, c:i
e n
'"'!.
~
9
'<t
III III
c:i
0
u
c:[
N
c:i
m
a
..... <0
L{)
'<t
..,
N 0
C\I C\I
Z IN <; <,
III III
203
~
<D
N
N u,
U.
+
+
"":
"'<t
..-
u : :
"'!
u : : N
+
+
<
<
~
co
co ~~
0
0
N .....
c a.
I I
II N
~
...
<D
II
a.
0
c
<0
0
k;
~
'<t
~
0
"'<t
0
S
\,.,)
. -
N
~
b N
b
~
::
0
~
10 0
0
s
10 N
0
8
N 0
10
~
lO t') 10 N10
0
8
0
0
0
0
0 "'<t (")
0
8
0
0
~
0 0 0 0
0
0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0
~
<P
<P
~
I I
<0
Q
..-
-s
~
"':
~
. . . . .
s: : :
~
N ~
~
- ~
N
a
~
I I I
0
u
00'
N
a.
I
ltl
<
E 9 .
N
co
~
0
0
I I I
9
. ~
I I M
c
I I
N
~
II
-
...
co
~
9
a.
0
<,
fI l
~ ....
a
~
b
I I I lQ
0
u
c
N
0
0
m
10 t') 10 N lO
0
0
t') 0 N 0
0 0
0
0
0 0
0 0 0 0
('I I ('I I
<P
<, <,
I I I I I I
- r- ;
204
205
Vibration Isolation Using Trenches
Appendix (C)
206
Effect of Trench Depth
PART (I)
V)
V) V)
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
<'I
<'I
<'I
LL
LL
LL
+
+
+
. . . . .
LL
+
. . . . .
~
-
-
~
0
9
9
M
M
II
II
\. J
9
N
N l:::
9
9
~
!;')
;::
C
;::
l:::
. ';::
s
\. J
cq~
. . . . . .
0
0
~
V)
t"'l ". . , <'IV)
. . . . . ". . ,
0
0
V)
t"'l ". . , <'IV)
. . . . . ". . , 0
~
M <'i . . . . 0
". . , "<:t M <'I . . . . .
0 t"'l N . . . .
0
W
W W
~~
V) V)
Q
. . . . . . . . . .
'S~
<'I
<'I
&
LL
LL
"G
+
,
"S
:::
~
. . . .
. . . .
. :::
LL
LL
~
N
+
+
P o t
. . . .
. . . . .
-
-
'"
~
II
\. J
S
~
ell Pl
. -I
~
0
P o t
()
r
N
~ Q
9
Pl
I M
U
-
II
9 '-
II
-
9
~
til
Q
. -I
. . . .
0
. ~
n III
~
):
t
II
-
~
III
9
ell
~
<,
ell ::J . . c:
0 o 0 Pl
CIl
()
::J s :::
0
0
c
s ::: C D
V)
M". . ,
<'IV)
. . . . . ". . , 0
V) t"'l V) NV) V) 0 001 1 -1
~E-t
M N . . . . .
0
t"'l <'I . . . . . 0
8 "W
"W
207
") ") ")
. . . . . . . . . . . .
('l ('l ('l
u.. u.. u..
+ + +
....... .......
u.. u..
~
+
......
+
......
~
~
....
~
0
t::
0
<
e
'-':l
e
;::
I
II
M
C
<'l
II
e
N ;::
e
N
5
e
Irl
. . . . .
c:i
::
c
i,J
~~
......
~
~
0 0 0
~~
r-- \0Irl
;gS
('l . . . . . .
0
('l
r:
co \0 'I;t ('l
0 COf'\OIrl'l;tr"'l('l ......O
00
c:::
00
.......
0
00 00 00000000
Q 0000000 0 0000 00000000
< P < P < P
';5~
~
"'e
") ")
~
i,J
......
::
~
('l ('l
.....
u.. u..
~
+
T
.....
i,J
~
...... . . . . . .
~ u.. u..
N
+
. . . . . . .
+
...... ~
.... P I
r . . ) N
~
II 9 ~
III ! % I . -t
~
0
P I
o
r
N
. ~
0 e
IJ:I
I M k;
-
II
n
e
-
e
! % I
Q
ri
0
~
n
t
)
II
. . . .
~
Il
~
J
9
5 . . c:
~
< ,
III ::s 0
0 r:: r::
! % I
e n
0
0
U
'r!f
c
8
Irl 'I;t M('l ......
0
ggb~: 8; g8~8
~E-t c::: c::: c::: c::: c:::
0
c:i 00000
00000000
u
< P
< P
208
o
I i")
o
~1r l C" l I r l NI r l " " ' I r l O
<"'i N . 0
' . ,
C '<
9
M
II
9
. . . . .
LL.
+
N
LL.
+
' w
~1r l C" l I r l NI r l " " ' I r l O
<"'i C 'i ..... 0
-
9
M
II
N
9
.....
LL.
+
N
U.
+
209
' w
9
o
I i")
o
N
U.
+
~o
I i")
. . . . .
.....
u.
+
Q
D
-
' w
. . . . .
u.
+
o
I i")
o
N
U.
+
-
9
II
C '<
9
o
I i")
o
......
8
. "
o
U
~
1 % 1
<'I
II
Q
1 % 1
ri
o
~1r l C" l I r l NI r l " " " I r l O
<"'i C 'i ..... 0
W
Q
I
...
9
.....
u.
+
N
U.
+
II') II') II')
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
('l ('l ('l
u, u, u,
+ +
,
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
u, u, u,
+
. . . . .
+
. . . . .
+
~
< 1 ( 0 - : i -
0 9
~-
I
~
r: <" l : : . : : :
M
II
~
9
N
N
9
9
II')
~
0
C
;::;
.~
-
s
~
~~
"'"'-I
C
0 0
~
~88: gg88oo
('l . . . . . 00 I,() ' < T
('l
0
~88~g88oo
0
0000
00000000 0 0000 00000000
~ ~ ~ ~~
II
Q
II')
II')
';S~
. . . . .
......
&
('l
N
"G
u,
~
,
u,
,
~
::.:::
~
.....
. . . . . .
~
U-
N
+
-
P o.
~
-
~
N
~
II 8
~ lit III
P '4
0
Pt
~
o
c
N
0
U
0
9
<I(
III
"-
-
r: <" l
('II
9
II
~
- II
9
. . . .
III
.~
,..; 0
II')
0
0
k;
II
~
):
t
II
-
- ~ III
~
8
;:l . c
~
<,
lit
o t)
;:l c: :
rn
0
c: :
IX! 0
o
-M I-l
r--
8
II') ' < T ("l ('I .....
0
0
c
~~
0 0o 000
. . . . . 00 I,() ' < T
('l
0
000o 000 0
0 0 0 0
0
0000
u
~
~
21 0
211
Effect of Trench Width
PART (II)
o
II')
-
o
.. . .
' <t 1 l ' l C ' l I l ' l NV l - I r l O
~ N ~ 0
N
9
C"'l
"
9
. . . .
LI. .
+
N
LI. .
+
' <t 1 l ' l C ' l I l ' l NV l . . . . . V l O
~ N ~ 0
.. . .
9
C"'l
"
N
9
. . . . .
LI. .
+
N
LI. .
,
o
. . . . .
II')
-
o
o
. . . . .
212
. . . .
11')0
o
o
I
-
9
. . . . .
LI. .
+
N
LI. .
+
-
~
N
9
. . . . .
LI. .
+
N
LI. .
+
o
I I ')
. . . . . ,
III
: : l o t : :
o0
: : s c
c C D
. . . . I-l
~ E - i
8
s
. . u :
o
lXI
II
Q
. .
. . .
S
lit
o
o
0:
. . . .
' <t V l C ' l I l ' l NI I ' l . . . . . I I ' l O
~ N ~ 0
o
I
N
9
. . . . .
LI. .
+
N
LI. .
+
213
") ") ")
- - -
N N N
u.. u.. u..
+
+ +
-
u..
+
-
""E >.
-
~
-
~
0
9
9
s : : : :
II
C"\
~
N
II
.: :
9
N
N
9
9
~ Irl
0
s
5
-
8
~-
8-
0 0
....
00 \() "<t N0
~~~-;~8;g~0
00
~
"<t N0 ~~
0
0 0q q
0
0 q 0
00
.. 0 ....
0 0 0 0 000 0000 0 0
ci
cp cp cp
~
o : S -
") ")
"'j . _
- - ~
N N
~
LL u,
s : : : :
+ +
~
~
- -
-
u.. u..
~
N
+ +
-
~
-
P o l
~
...
~
II a
~ III P I
ri
0
P o l
0
U
N
P I
. . . . ~
Q.
0 9
t
II
('I'l
-
II
0
9
. ~
P I
9
~
C\'l
0
II
~
)
t
II
40!.
~
II
~
a ::J .c
~
<,
III
o 0
;:I c
Ul
0
r:: G I
P I 0
u
.p t 1.1
8
Irl "<t ("l N
-
0 ....
00
8
"<t N0
~E -t
q q q 00
<:)
0 q 0
0
<:)
000
<:) <:)
<:) <:)
0
<:)
o
cp
cp
214
Effect of Trench Length
PART (III)
."
' <t l l ' l t " ' l l l ' l Nl I ' l - l I ' l O
~ N ,...; 0
N
9
M
II
-
8
. . . . .
- LL.
T
N
LL.
+
r-------------e:
aN
' <t l l ' l Ml I ' l Nl I ' l . . . . .l I ' l O
~ ('~,...;0
-
9
M
II
N
8
. . . . .
LL.
+
N
LL.
+
r-------------a:
'r:
. . . . .
o
. . . . .
215
l I ' l O
o
~r- r- r- +- +- +- +0
Q
I
-
9
. . . . .
LL.
T
N
LL.
+
-
W
N
9
. . . .
LL.
T
N
LL.
+
o
re
o
!X I
II
Q
..
N
a
8
c
aN
' <t l l ' l Ml I ' l Nl I ' l . . . . l I ' l O
~ N ......0
Q
I
N
8
N
LL.
+
~------------.:
V) V) V)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
('l ('l ('l
LL LL LL
+ +
T
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
LL LL LL
+
. . . . . .
+
. . . . . .
+
'"
-
-
< 0
~
c
9
9
I
II
~
~
. . .
II
e
N
N
9
e
f'. l
V) I(') <:::)
0
0
~
~-
8-
~-
0 0 0
II
~8i S: 8gSgoo
~
('l . . . .
~i S
~
('l
0
~8i S: 8gSgoo
~
. . . . . .
-: 0
0q
00000000 00 0000 00000000
~
c j I c j I c j I
= :::
~
. . . . . .
~ V) V)
. . . . . .
. . . . . . ~
~
('l N
~
LL LL
+ +
. . . .
~
~
~
. . . . . . . . . . . .
~
LL LL
C'I
+
. . . .
+
. . . .
0
-
~ ~
N
~
II ~ 9
III
. . . t
~
0
~
. ~
C o)
c r
~
N
k;
C e
II
I ~
-
II
0
s
9
~
<'II
.
0
II
III
;l
t
II
-
.:
~
~
1 + - 1 < ' 1 1
9 0
II
~
<,
III
.d.d f1) 0 0 ~
C o) . j . I 0
is
11")
~
<'1 N
. . . .
0 . . . . co
is
-. :t N 0
c
tJ !~
q q q q
0
0 0 0
s:: C D
C D . . . .
000000
0000
. . :t~
c j I
c j I
21 6
" l
" l " l
. . . . . .
. . . .
N N
N
U. U.
U.
,
+
+
. . . . . . . . . . .
......
u,
u.
u.
+
. . . .
+
. . . .
+
. . . .
-
0
9
~
0
9
I
~
~
II
II
9
N
N
~
9
9
~
Vl
~
0
~
~~
8_
ccf
0
0
t't)
~" l ~" l N" l " " " " l 0 0
~" l ~" l N" l " " ' ' ' l 0
II
~ N . . . . . .
0
Vl ~ ~ N . . . .
0
~ N .....
0 ~
. . . .
'n
. . . .
~
s : :
~
" l " l
~
. . . .
N
N ~ U.
U.
" " "
+
+
~
.....
<:. , )
......
~ u.
. . . . .
~
+
u.
(\I
. . . . .
+
. . . . . .
0\'
-
~
. . .
~
II
(;
9
e n til
....
'-
0
~
~
u
0
4( c
III N ~
0
9
.[<l
I ~
-
II
~ 0
9
-
9
III
" l on
N
0
0
.
0
~
II
;J :
t
II
~
~
III ~
9
'HI'!
~
<,
e n
o n
f I) 0 $II
0
0
u
. . c : . . c :
.jJ 0
" l
~ Vl N" l . . . . . .
.,..,
0
' <t " l <' " >" l N" l - " l O
t7l c:: M N ..... 0
M N . . . . .
0
c:: G I
G I I-!
'n
' w
. . : I E - o
217
"1 "1 "1
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
N N N
1. 1. . 1. 1. . 1. 1. .
+ + +
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1. 1. . 1. 1. . 1. 1. .
+
. . . . . .
+ +
. . . . . .
0
. . . .
9
9
I
II
M
N
N
II
-s,
9
9
N
9
~
~
~
~
~-
8_
0 0
~-
~88~; gi j ~8
-:t N . . . . . co \C) -:tN 0
~88~ga~8
. . . . . . . . . .
0
00 o 0
00000000 00 0000 00000000 II
q , q , q ,
~
-s -
~
"1 "1
~
. . . . . . . . . .
13
-
. . . .
N
N ~
1. 1. . 1. 1. .
t::
+ +
~
. . . . .
~
. . . . .
. . . . .
~
1. 1. .
1. 1. .
~ C 'I I
+
. . . . .
+
. . . . .
. . D. i
~ . . .
~
II 8 . . . . . .
III al . -t
0
8
P o.
~
0 0
rr
III
4(
N
4(
~ 0 9
II
I M
. . . .
. . . .
II
. [<l
Q 9
9
~
III
C \I I)
Vl
"1
0 0
0
II
I I I
)
t
II
. .
~
III
I I I
1j.j(YI
a
0
II
~
<,
III
0 .t:.t: III
fIl
0
0
u . jJ 0
~
Vl -:t I "'"l
('I
-
0
e--
~
-:tl"'"l N
. . . . .
0
~c
Vl
c
q 00q q
q 000 0q
G I G I
000000
0000000
. . :I 1-1
E -4 ,
q ,
218
107, 1985
10.Dobry, R. and Gazetas, "Dynamic Response of Arbitrary Shaped Foundations",
J ournal of Geotechnical Engineering, ASCE, vol. 112,pp. 109-135, 1986
Found. Eng., ASCE 95, No. SM6, PP.,pp. 1411-1430,1969
8. Chapra, S. C. and Canale, R. P., "Numerical Methodsfor Engineers",McGraw-Hill
PublishingCo., International edition, 1990
9. Dobry, R. and Gazetas, "Dynamic StiffnessandDampingUsingSimpleMethods",
Proc. Symposium: VibrationsProblemsinGeotechnical Engineering, ASCE, pp. 75-
7. Chae, Y. S., " Vibration of Non-Circular Foundations", J ournal of Soil Mech. and
Vol. 248, pp. 327-368, 1956
Co., N.Y., 1996
6. Bycroft, G. N., "ForcedVibrationof A RigidCircularPlateonA Semi-infiniteElastic
Space and onElastic Stratum",Philosophical Trans., Royal Society, London, Ser. A,
SciencePublishingLtd., N. Y., 1987
4. Barkan, D. D., "Dynamicsof BasesandFoundations", McGraw-Hill Book Company,
NewYork, 1962
5.Bowles, 1. E., "FoundationAnalysisandDesign",5th Edition, McGraw-Hill Publishing
1.AlpanI. ,"MachineFoundationandSoil Resonance", Geotechnique, Vol. 11, 1961
2. Ayra S., O'Neil M. and Pincus G. "Design of Structures andFoundationsfor
VibratingMachines" , Gulf PublishingCo., Houston, TX, 1979
3.Banerjee, P.K. and Butterfield, R., "DynamicBehaviour of Foundations andBuried
Structures", Development in Soil Mechanics and Foundation, Elsevier Applied
REFERENCES
pp. 211-226, 1962
20.Idriss, 1. M. et al, "Nonlinear Behaviour of Soft ClayduringCyclicLoading", J ournal
of Geotechnical Engineering, ASCE, vol. 104, pp. 1427-1447, 1978
21.Irons, B. M. and Ahmed, S., "Techniquesof FiniteElements", EllisHorwood Ltd.,
Chichester, 1980
l l.Dolling, H. J ,"Schwingungsisolierung von Bauwerken durch tiefe, auf geeignete
Weise stabilisierte Schiltze", Sonderdruck aus VDI-Berichte 88, S. 3741, 1965
I 2.Elsalamony, R., "Dynamic Analysis of Circular Foundation onNon-Homogeneous
Soil", M. Sc. thesis submitted to Ain Shams University, 1993
13.Elzarka, H., "Influence of the Transmission of Machine Vibration on Soil and
Structures", M. Sc. thesis submitted to Ain ShamsUniversity, 1991.
14.Gazetas, G. and Dobry, R, "Analysis of MachineFoundationVibrations: Stateof
The Art", Inti. J ournal of Soil DynamicsandEarthquakeEngineering. Vol. 2, pp. 2-
42, 1983
15.Gazetas, G., Dobry, Rand Tassoulas, J L., "Vertical responseof arbitraryshaped
embeddedfoundation", J ournal of Geotechnical Engineering, ASCE, vol. 110, pp. 20-
40, 1984
16.Gazetas, G., Dobry and Tassoulas, J L., "Horizontal Damping of AnArbitrary
Shape Embedded Foundations", J ournal of Geotechnical Engineering, ASCE, pp.
458-475, 1987
17.Hall, J R., "Effect of Amplitude on Damping andWavePropagation inGranular
Material ",Ph. D. Dissertation, Universityof Florida, 1962
18.Hall, J R.," Coupled Rocking and Sliding Oscillationsof RigidCircular Footings",
Proc. of TheInternational SymposiumonWavePropagation andDynamicProperties
of EarthMaterials, Albuquerque, N. M., 1967
19.Hsieh, T. K., "FoundationVibrations",Proc. of Instituteof Civil Engineers, Vol. 22,
ASCE, Vol. 3, pp. 1267-1316, 1978
32.Masing, G., "Eigenspannungen and Verfestigung beimMessing", Proc. Of The 2nd
International Congress of Applied Mechanics, 1962
J ournal of Soil Mech. and Foundations, ASCE, 97(EM5), pp. 65-91, 1966
30.Lysmer, 1. and Kuhlemeyer, R. L., "Finite Dynamic Model for Infinite Media",
J ournal of Engineering Mechanics Division, ACSE, vol. 95, 1969
31.Lysmer, 1. , "Analytical Procedures in Soil Dynamics, Earthquake Engineering",
Michigan, 1965
29.Lysmer, 1. and Richart, F. E. "Dynamic Response of Footings to Vertical Loading",
Motion and Effects on Structure, ASME, AMD, Vol. 53, 1982
28.Lysmer, 1., " Vertical Motion of Rigid Footings", Ph. D. Dissertation, University of
26.Luco, J E. and Contesse, L., "Dynamic Structure-Soil-Structure Interaction",
Bulletin of The Seismological Society of America, vol. 63, pp. 1289-1303, 1973
27.Luco, 1. E., "Linear Soil-Structure Interaction: A Review", Eathquake Ground
Philosophical Transaction of The Royal Society, London, Ser. A., Vol. 203, pp. 1-42,
1904
24.Kumar, V., Bandyopadhyay, S. and Lavania, B. V. K. ,"Dynamic Cross Interaction
Between Two Foundations Under Horizontal Vibrations", 8th Symposium on
Earthquake Engineering, Roorkee, vol. 1, pp. 221-228, 1986
25.Lamb, H., "On The Propagation of Tremors over The Surface of AnElastic Solid",
22.Kaldjian, M. J , Discussion of "Design Procedures for Dynamically Loaded
Foundations" by R. V. Whitman and F. E. Richart, Paper No. 5569, J ournal of Soil
Mechanics and Foundations, ASCE, Vol. 95, No. SM 1, pp. 364-366, 1969
23.Kobori, T. and Minai R. "Dynamic Interaction of Multiple Structural Systems", Proc.
Of the 5th World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, pp. 2061-2069, New Delhi,
1973
33.Miller, G. F. and Pursey, H. ,"The Field and Radiation Impedence of Mechanical
Radiators on The Free Surface of a Semi-Infinite Isotropic Solid, Proc. of Royal
Society, London, vol. 223, pp. 521-554, 1954
34.Neumeur, H. ,"Untersuchungen uber dieAbschirmung einebestehenden Gebaiiudes
gegen Erschiitterungen beim Bau und Betriob einer U-Bahnstrecke", Baumaschine
and Bautechnik-l0, J ahgang, Heft, 1963
35.Novak, M. , Nogami, T. and Abou-Ella, F., "Dynamic Soil Reaction inPlain Strain
Case", J ournal of Engineering Mechanics, ASCE, 104(EM4), pp. 1024-1041, 1978
36.Pauw, A., "A dynamic Analogy for Foundation-Soil Systems", ASTM Special
Technical Publications No. 156, 1953
37.Prakash, S., "Soil Dynamics", McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1981
38.Quinlan, P. M. , "The Elastic Theory of Soil Dynamics", Symposium on Dynamic
Testing of Soils, ASTM STP No. 156, pp. 3-34, 1953
39.Ramberg, W. and Osgood, W. T., "Description of Stress-Strain Curves by Three
Parameters", Technical Note 902,National Advisory Committee on Aeronautics, 1943
40.Reissner, E. ,"Stationare Axialsymmetrische Durch Eine Schiittelande Masse Erregate
Schwingungen, Eine Homogenen Elastischen Halbraumes" , Forsch. Gebiete
Ingenieurwesen, Vol. 2, No. 11, pp. 4-11, 1936
41.Rei ssner, E. ,"Freie und Erzwungene Torsionschwingungen des Elastischen
Halbraumes", Ingenieur-Archiv , Vol. 8, No.4, pp. 229-245, 1937
42.Reissner, E. and Sagoci, H. F., "Forced Torsional Oscillations of anElastic Half-
Space", J ournal of Applied Physics, Vol. 15, pp. 652-662, 1944
43.Richart, E.E, R. D. Woods and Hall, J . R., "Vibrations of Soils and Foundations",
Prentice-Hall Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N. J ., 1970
44.Roesset, J . M., "Stiffness and Damping Coefficients in Foundations", Dynamic
Response of PileFoundations, ASCE, pp. 1-30,1980
AppliedMechanics, ASME, Vol. 24, pp. 55-58, 1957
51.Warburton, G. B. "Forced Vibrations of Two Masses onanElasticHalf-Space",
J ournal of AppliedMechanics, ASME, Vol. 38, pp. 148-156, 1971
52.Winterkorn, H. F. andFang, H. ,"FoundationEngineeringHandbook", VanNostrand
ReinholdCompany, N. Y., 1975
53.Wolf, J . P., " DynamicSoil - StructureInteraction", Prentice-Hall Inc., Englewood
Cliffs,N.J ., 1985
54.Woods, R. D., "Screeningof SurfaceWavesinSoils", J ournal of Soil Mechanicsand
FoundationDivision, ASCE, vol. 94, no. SM4, pp. 951-979, 1968
55.Zienkiewics, O. C., "The Finite Element Method", 3rd ed., McGraw-Hill Book
Company, London, 1977
45.Seed H. G. and Idriss, I. M., "Nonlinear Behaviour of Soft Clay during Cyclic
Loading", J ournal of Geotechnical Engineering, ASCE, vol. 104, pp. 1427-1447,
1978
46. Smith, I. M., "Programming the Finite Element Method with Application to
Geomechanics", J ohn Wiley &Sons, London, 1982
47.Srinivasulu, P. and Vaidyanathan, C. V., "Handbookof MachineFoundation", Tata
McGraw-Hill PublishingCompanyLTD., NewDelhi, 1978
48.Sung, T. Y., "Vibrations in Semi-Infinite SolidsDuetoPeriodic SurfaceLoading",
SymposiumonDynamicTestingof Soils, ASTM STP No. 156, pp. 35-64, 1953
49.Tschebotarioff, G. F. andWard, E. R., "TheResonanceof MachineFoundations and
The Soil Coefficients Which AffectIt", Proc. of 2ndInternational onSoil Mechanics
andFoundationEngineerin, Rotterdam, Vol. I, pp. 309-13., 1948
50.Warburton, G. B., "ForcedVibrationof A Body uponAn Elastic Stratum",J ournal of
~ yO J : ? - O J .J ...)
QL.L.~' J ~.;ll~~ 1f.).1,o
a..J w.; ~I ~.1.: .J ,1.......j
~ ~ r
~_"'.u- i~' ~ ..).i
QL.L.~IJ ~.;ll~~ ~l .w.i
~w.;)'1 ~.1.: .J " ~
~ ~ ~l>. - ~.cl l ~
~ .u- i J .)u, ,.).i
QL.L.~' J ~.;ll~~ ~l .w.i
~w.;)'1 ~.cl l r- i
~ ~ ~l>. - ~.cl l ~
if
..t ,.1- ~J "!-- __ - .J J ' b ot 01- ~ __ _... / ~
4.1\,..,)
4,i..u.1a...,~1 J ~\l .1 ~),) J s - J ~ 4.oJ .U
~~~~
.___."L:j~.\ i _Ie'
~~T .,;...t.y.1 .!Jj)
~ l#'~b.- - L..l;),1 ~ ?('
b
.. W I ~~ /if'!
. Sll (r
JI .-iI J o. / U",I . Sll (r'
~I
;
.;bI0-d/ifJ 'Sil (t
u;
.I' " J
~Y ~f r .11/Jp..ul .;\::...\11('
~ ~i J) b / jp..ul .;\::...\11 ("
.I' "')
J
.. -
~ I .f!'4A.t~
L-.,..~I a .,.l S "
4.JW J~1 1...t~1 ~
: t = i P l
: ~)Wl
~\ -;;...W\ 4;jW~ 4;_)~\ lS~ ~ ~W\ .p)\ ~ J ~ ~\ -- .) j~:J\ J J _ ,A :)\ oJ b
\ 0 .. 1 \A \ , W ~ \
\ o . . A A \ , W ;;~W\ ~\.? lS~ ~ a...W\ 4;jW~ J }J \'p)\ oJ b
' "
U 0~tl\ ~ ~WI 01j1..?' ~\ j#~Vl) J ::i;) j#J.;~~uP\;J~\ 1..i.AOLtJ ;)~\ I ..a.pb-
'"
4tll ~} 'J.r" ~ oi ~_ (~I r : r ~tll cr " ~?;))~~) 01j1..?' ~1 o..i.Ar : r ~I )J.Al\ o~
~~w~
Lo~'~
~WJ1'Lo~'~
~\l.1 .1 \.... ) ~
J.J..l.:t- l t J.J.~/~~, tY t...L 4 1 ,
4)1~
)L_j j..v ~~li c : ~ ~~li .))~ ~L:LdI~) ,~ y\..dl ~ ~.))~I ~I_;J I J ~ _;yl; ~I.)~ ..,-
J - - - - - - .5 : l ~I ~~ .)~)fl ~ .b:.)rlc: ,~I ~ ~j..v ~?i~~li c : ~j..v ~~li .))~ ~\..: .-
.4L-
.~.))~\ ~\_;J \ If.:i yl..d\ ~ ~I ~ r$>~WI ~I ~_;J \ ~ _;yl; ~I.)~ .r
.~I_;J I If.:i yl..d\ _;yl; ~ U. J ~u..1il~l: ~~..ul J yJ \ ~\.)~ .t
Lr.: - - - 1 yl..d\ _;yl; ~ 0,. ~).iU ~i.) ~j) ~ ~L:L~~ )f u~ J ~81 rff('J j)
~l; JU. ,- ;- "t.... s: ;bi ~ J ~ ~I_;J I If.:i ~~...ul y\..d\ L\.)~ ~i ~8\ ~ J j), ~I_;J \
J --->-\..dlJ )90\ J ~u..1il~l) ~I_;J I J ~ o: Y_;yl; ~ LS.~~..ul ~\ ub ~\ J L.r- - i
~.))~I ~\yill ~~..ul .:J )-.II J s - Ah;. .a..1I ~I ~ )4jWI )~I ~~ c r Y _;yl; ) J ~WI
-:~ L-LI.)...u1"OlAJ ~ rf ~i ~
~)L.....;; LJ \..: .- J ~.))~I ~Iyill ~~...ul yl.cll ~ ~I uYll.\ ~I_;J uljl~)fl ~ \ ...a .; ; .,
.~~lill ~)I)I ~I ~ .r:
~)\)I ~ ~ .r' ~)w~\..: .- J ~ ~I ~Iyill ~~..ul ~~)fI).iU) J J -I If.:i ~')I..J I."-
.~)I)I ~ _rJ I ~)wi~ ~\..:.-J ~ )f )uYL.J .J
.~.))~I uYL.J .J ~.)}J I jI~)f1 rf~ ~ _r.S 'i ~~ ~)rl lS.);:'")UI jI~)f1 ~.r
.uYll.1 ~Ij If.:i ~~...ul YI..d1 .)~I ~ ~~ .r" ~~.))fl ~~..ul)~i)l ~~..ul .t
J }~)fl ~ ~~~j J l ~~~~i~) ~Iyill J ...ul~ J I1~\..:.- J ul:~..ul ~ ~ ~I_;J I J ~.o
.~Iyill J ...ul~ J I1i~ ~\..: .-
jI~)f1 ;; '0: ; J J .;A51~ LS, ~I ~ C" ~WI ~I ~_;J \ ~ J i W5' jI~)f1 ~ jZ.i
.._,....J I lolAJ i W5' uYL...U ~)I)I ~I ~ .r" J ~I rY' ~UI
" ~ J ~I uP./' ~ '1 ~ ...l;1__,A)1 ~ J -:-I..l':.I1 rf ~\..J I ul}?~1 j:lZ r..i J ~L:..:l1il~1 ~. V
.o...l;\..4l\ uP./' j~i d.J ~ ~ J ~I J _,k ) o...l;\..4l1 uP./' ._.u..,;" ~ J ~I ~ ) o...l;\..4l1 uP./' rf
._,; L A .i ,,:.i ~ ~ u~tll ..u.1} ~ J -:-I..l':.I1J s - oJ J lI ~lyJ I ~i ~I Ih ~l:i rf)
J ~L.;l1 il~l) ~I~I Li~J ! -o J -:-I..l':.II) }.;a'11 ~ J ). o...l; Clpl [" W--, ~I ~ J ~'11
.J __,kjlohrf~). J 5 ' J s - Jy ~I ~lyJ l C~l ~ ~~..ul J ~I r..i