NACE Task Group 360 Review Standard Practice (SP0169) - - 2007 2007 (formerly RP0169) "more guidance is needed on cathodic protection (CP) criteria for controlling microbiologically influenced corrosion and corrosion at elevated temperatures" "this section contains criteria; however, it is acknowledged that other approaches have been successful in thepast"
NACE Task Group 360 Review Standard Practice (SP0169) - - 2007 2007 (formerly RP0169) "more guidance is needed on cathodic protection (CP) criteria for controlling microbiologically influenced corrosion and corrosion at elevated temperatures" "this section contains criteria; however, it is acknowledged that other approaches have been successful in thepast"
NACE Task Group 360 Review Standard Practice (SP0169) - - 2007 2007 (formerly RP0169) "more guidance is needed on cathodic protection (CP) criteria for controlling microbiologically influenced corrosion and corrosion at elevated temperatures" "this section contains criteria; however, it is acknowledged that other approaches have been successful in thepast"
Part A: Standard Practice (NACE SP0169) Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities IPEIA February 2009 Banff Centre J .F. (J im) Chmilar, P.Eng. Chmilar & Associates Consulting Ltd Cochrane, Alberta NACE Task Group 360 Review Standard Practice (SP) 0169 Review Standard Practice (SP) 0169 2007 2007 (formerly RP0169), (formerly RP0169), Control of External Control of External Corrosion on Underground or Submerged Corrosion on Underground or Submerged Metallic Piping Systems Metallic Piping Systems Chair: J imChmilar, Vice Chair: Travis Sera, Southern CaliforniaGas Company Los Angeles, 2 2002 ad hoc report to STG 05 Section 6 could not be reaffirmed as it exists, Ambiguity exists between the 0.850 copper/copper sulfate electrode (CSE) current applied criterion and 0.850vsCSE polarized criterion, There is confusion regarding 100 mV formation and decay, 3 2002 ad hoc report to STG 05 More guidance is needed on cathodic protection (CP) criteria for controlling microbiologically influenced corrosion and corrosion at elevated temperatures, Upper limits on CP criteria for coating damage and /or high strength steels are needed. STG 05 formed Task Group 285 to revise Section 6 in 2002 At CTW 2006 RP0169-2002 reaffirmed; review of the entire document including Section 6 was turned over to Task Group 360 under STG 35. Part of the NACE and ANSI protocol requires all standards be revised or reaffirmed every 5 years. 4 NACE Task Group 360 Work Developed a series of Eight Questions & Answers published in MP in December 2007 and February 2008 Significant modifications and additions to Sections 5 and 6 and addition of an Appendix that covers a review of International Standards. NACE Task Group 360 Work 6.2 Criteria 6.2.1 It is not intended that peopleresponsiblefor external corrosion control belimited to any specific criteria. This section contains criteria; however, it is acknowledged that other approaches havebeen successful in thepast. The useof any approach to achievecorrosion control through CP is theresponsibility of theuser. It is important that the user beableto provideempirical evidencefor any approach that is taken. 6.2.2. Thetwo fundamental polarization criteriain this sectionhavebeen shown to typically reducetheaverage corrosion rateof steel to less than 25 microns/yr (1 mil/yr) insoils and natural waters in thefield and laboratory tests at ambient temperatures.3,4,5 A singlecriterion for evaluating theeffectiveness of CP may not besatisfactory for all locations along astructure. 6.2.3 Steel and Cast Ductile Iron Piping 6.2.3.1 External corrosion control can beachieved at various levels of cathodic polarization depending on the environmental conditions. Any criterion selected must provideareliableindication that thecorrosion control objectives of theoperator havebeen satisfied. In theabsenceof specific datalisted in Paragraph 6.1.2 that demonstratethat adequateCP has been achieved, at least oneof thefollowing shall apply: 6.2.3.1.1 A negative(cathodic) voltageof at least 850 mV as measured with respect to asaturated copper/copper sulfatereferenceelectrode. This potential may beeither adirect measurement of thepolarized potential, or a current applied potential corrected for voltage(IR) drops other than thoseacross thestructure/electrolyteboundary. 6.2.3.1.2 A minimumof 100 mV of cathodic polarization. Theformation or decay of polarization can bemeasured to satisfy this criterion. 6.2.3.1.3 Criteriathat havebeen shown to successfully control corrosion on piping systems can continueto beused on thosepiping systems. 6.2.3.1.4 Other criteriathat can bedemonstrated to achievethecorrosion control objectives of theoperator. 5 WE ARE NOT ELIMINATING THE 850 ON CRITERIA NACE Task Group 360 Work 6.2.3.1 External corrosion control can be achieved at various levels of cathodic polarization depending on the environmental conditions. Any criterion selected must provide a reliable indication that the corrosion control objectives of the operator have been satisfied 6 NACE Task Group 360 Work 6.2.3.1.1 A negative (cathodic) voltage of at least 850 mV CSE. This potential may be either a direct measurement of the polarized potential, or a current applied potential corrected for voltage (IR) drops other than those across the structure/ electrolyte boundary. NACE Task Group 360 Work 6.2.3.1.2 A minimum of 100 mV of cathodic polarization. The formation or decay of polarization can be measured to satisfy this criterion. 7 NACE Task Group 360 Work 6.2.3.1.3 Criteria that have been shown to successfully control corrosion on piping systems can continue to be used on those piping systems. NACE Task Group 360 Work 6.2.3.1.4 Other criteria that can be demonstrated to achieve the corrosion control objectives of the operator. 8 The -850 on success is largely due to two things: 1) For many pipelines, 100 mV of polarization is achieved at less than -850mV off meaning that -850 mV on has IR drop built into it (especially older poorly coated lines), and The -850 on success is largely due to two things: 2) While maintaining -850 mV on, many on potentials on the same structure were considerably more negative than -850mV on 9 TG 360 members agree that: Operating companies need the ability to utilize on potentials which are properly supported. In addition, we need to ensure that the language in the SP0169 document does not create an issue with regulators by wording of statements in a negative fashion. NACE RP0169: Approved April 1969 Revised J an. 1972 Revised Sept. 1976 Revised J an. 1983 Revised April 1992 Reaffirmed 1996-09-13 Reaffirmed 2002-04-11 Reaffirmed 2007-03-15 and had name change to SP Revision History SP0169 10 NACE Task Group 360 Work Path Forward: SP0169-2007, will be sent to the STG 35, STG 05 and STG 30 membership who have registered to be in the voting pool. Task Group 360 Secretary: daniela.matthews@nace.org Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 11 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 12 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 13 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 14 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 15 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 16 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 17 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 18 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities 19 Part B: Real Life on Pipelines and Facilities IF your system is not changing, you DO NOT NEED to do interrupted surveys every year. Maybe once every 4 to 5 years and then if practical. Use Coupon technology as another tool ? Questions THANK YOU