Authors: Haringey Learning Disabilities Partnership Board
People with Learning Disabilities in Haringey are worried about current or threatened cuts to services, including support workers, social clubs, day centres, supported housing and residential homes.
Members of the Haringey Learning Disabilities Partnership Board have carried out a survey to clarify the concerns of service users, family carers and the staff who deliver these services.
This report gives the full results of that survey.
Authors: Haringey Learning Disabilities Partnership Board
People with Learning Disabilities in Haringey are worried about current or threatened cuts to services, including support workers, social clubs, day centres, supported housing and residential homes.
Members of the Haringey Learning Disabilities Partnership Board have carried out a survey to clarify the concerns of service users, family carers and the staff who deliver these services.
This report gives the full results of that survey.
Authors: Haringey Learning Disabilities Partnership Board
People with Learning Disabilities in Haringey are worried about current or threatened cuts to services, including support workers, social clubs, day centres, supported housing and residential homes.
Members of the Haringey Learning Disabilities Partnership Board have carried out a survey to clarify the concerns of service users, family carers and the staff who deliver these services.
This report gives the full results of that survey.
Report on the impact of cuts in Haringey to services for adults with Learning Disabilities
May 2014
2
The impact of cuts in Haringey to services for adults with Learning Disabilities Introduction People with Learning Disabilities and their family carers are among the most vulnerable in our community, and their voice is rarely heard. People with Learning Disabilities in Haringey are worried about current or threatened cuts to services, including support workers, social clubs, day centres, supported housing and residential homes. As members of the Haringey Learning Disabilities Partnership Board, we have carried out a survey to clarify the concerns of service users, family carers and the staff who deliver these services. We have asked people why services are important to them, how they value services and what they think about cuts to services. This report gives the full results of the survey; a summary is presented on pages 4 to 7. We call on the decision makers in Haringey Council and in the Haringey Clinical Commissioning Group to read this report and take heed of its key messages. And we are asking all candidates in the forthcoming local Council elections to make a pledge to protect services for vulnerable people. Vital support services for vulnerable people must be maintained and improved. It is a false economy to cut the services that enable disabled people to have an ordinary life and be included in society, as it means they will become more isolated, their health will worsen, and family carers will not be able to cope. Micheal Brookstein Co-Chair Learning Disabilities Partnership Board (LDPB) Diane Smith Co-Chair, LDPB Sylvia Brookstein, People First, LDPB member Mark Heath LDPB Chair Support, Haringey Mencap Mary Langan Haringey Autism, LDPB member Vida Black Carers representative LDPB Jill Darnborough Carers representative LDPB Sarah Miller Markfield, LDPB member About the survey Survey questionnaires were given out in April 2014 to users of Learning Disabilities services in Haringey, family carers and to staff working in private and voluntary sector organisations providing these services as well as local authority staff (via Haringey Unison). Survey respondents were given the option of giving their name if they wished, or they could fill it in anonymously. The survey questions are shown in the appendix to this report. A total of 190 responses to the survey were received. Over half of the responses (98) were from service users, 26 were from family carers and 66 from staff. If you would like more information about this report please email marylangan@virginmedia.com 3
Contents
Introduction 2 Survey methodology 2 Summary of the survey findings 4 - 7
Full survey responses: Section 1: responses from service users 8-18 Section 2: responses from carers 18-25 Section 3: responses from staff 25-37
Appendix: survey questions 38
4
Summary of the survey findings A summary of the main findings of the survey are on pages 4 to 7 below. Service users views: What difference do the services make to peoples lives? Responses showed that people value services, such as day centres, social clubs, supported housing, very highly. About half of service users said they were happy with the level of support they were currently receiving. The most commonly mentioned aspects of daily life that these services helped people with were: o Shopping, cooking o Making and attending health appointments, taking medication o Budgeting and paying bills o Socialising and going out It meets all my needs and helps me to live an ordinary life. Going out for daily activities helps me to socialise within the community and have a sense of belonging.
How would service users feel if they did not have the services? Responses showed that people with Learning Disabilities feel strongly that they would badly miss services. They said they would be upset, sad, angry, anxious, lonely and isolated if services were withdrawn. Many said that cuts to their services would have an impact on their health.
Service users said: I cannot think of not having these services. I will have a breakdown. I will be at risk and may die.
I would feel deprived of living a normal life. I would not feel valued.
I think I would go back to my old ways. Not eating proper meals, getting into debt and have more health issues.
I will be devastated because this will mean staying home and be isolated and cut off. It will really stress and stretch my family. It will affect my mental health and physical health badly.
If I couldnt come here it would be bad. It would make me sad, It would make me swear. It would make me cry.
5
Carers views Responses from carers echoed those of service users. Carers regard services as essential to their own well-being, as well as to the well-being of the person they care for. A key point made was that cuts to the services that enable carers to carry on supporting people at home would not actually save money - because they would mean that many carers could no longer fulfil this role, with the result that more expensive services, such as residential care, would be needed
Carers said:
These services are absolutely crucial to help him to socialise get out of the house and learn new skills, exercise. His mental and physical well being all depend on (going to the) day centre and being a part of society.
I would simply not be able to care for him if he wasnt attending the day care. It gives me time to recoup my strength and carry on caring for him for the rest of the day and weekends.
(If services were cut): He would need more expensive care (residential). He would get depressed and challenging and would need more drugs.
My health would be worse in fact I would have no life at all
All his support needs would fall on us his parents. We would not be able to carry the full load of care which would have to pass to other care sectors such as supported living or residential (care).
I want to have a life outside of my caring role.
Impact of cuts that have happened already Cuts that have already been made to Learning Disability services in Haringey were mentioned by several survey respondents (these are detailed on pages 18-19 and 24-25). Cuts included: o Reduction in support staff hours o Cuts to / or inadequate personal budgets o Cuts in the pay of support staff leading to higher staff turnover and a lower quality service o Reduced day and respite provision o Cuts to transport (to day centres, clubs and activities) o Ending of funding for day centre activities (for people in residential care). I have seen my daughters behaviour regress because she does not have the activities and has been more difficult to handle when she comes home.
Clubs I used to go to have closed down, like Art club, art and music therapy. This helped me to express my feelings.
6
At my centre some of the workers lost their positions. It was hard because they were there for years and it affects us and we miss them. Its not right and its not fair because its hard for people with LD to find other jobs
The (day centre) where my daughter goes has far too many service users and staff in a small building. This is because of cuts having to give buildings up because of cuts
Views on threatened future cuts Everyone who answered service users, carers and staff - said that they did not believe that there should be cuts to services for people with Learning Disabilities. These cuts are discriminating against the most vulnerable and at risk members of society and are unacceptable.
Im very frightened that yet more services will be cut.
I feel like they no longer care about people with Learning Disabilities.
My son has autism, ADHD, bi-polar, and severe anxiety disorder and needs 24 hours supported living care. It takes him a tremendously long time to get used to a new support worker, often months of severe tantrums and distress. However once he is used to someone, he becomes very attached. His team has been entirely consistent since they began work with him and this has been essential to the progress he has since made. Future cuts that may get made to the support workers pay will result in most of them leaving. They are quite clear about the fact that they cannot get by on less. The impact of starting again with what would likely be less educated and caring people is the stuff of my nightmares and I think would likely end up with my son back in a secure psychiatric provision, ultimately costing much more and ruining lives.
Views of staff We received a large number of responses from staff who work to support people with Learning Disabilities in a range of organisations, including council-run services and voluntary sector providers. The responses revealed widespread concern about the impact of cuts both on service users and on the staff themselves. Recurrent themes were: the restrictions on the ability of service users to do activities in the community because of lack of enough support staff the detrimental impact that this had on service users mental and physical health and well being. Many staff members expressed dissatisfaction with levels of income, complaining that pay had remained static or even fallen despite increasing workloads and rising living costs, particularly in inner London. Several staff mentioned that, as a result of high workloads and staff shortages, supervision and training were inadequate. Low 7
morale was linked to high staff turn-over. Many said that they did not feel appreciated by the local authority, and some were considering leaving. A senior member of staff in a provider organisation described the pressure that his organisation was put under by a Haringey Council commissioner to reduce the pay of his staff to a level well below the London Living Wage that the Council itself claims to support.
Staff said: Ive seen service users becoming extremely distressed due to being confined to the home too long.
Service users health and safety are in jeopardy.
Team meetings dont occur in my service. Monthly supervisions occur 6- monthly, due to not being able to leave the service, being needed in service. Health & safety is compromised staff have too many service users to work with. Some minibuses drive service users without escorts. Staff stress levels and work satisfaction have been adversely affected
A provider organisation said: The quality of support provided to our clients has a direct correlation to two things: What we pay our frontline support staff How well the staff are supported A consultant from Haringey came to cut our funding using the Care Funding Calculator the assumption used on the calculator is that we pay staff 7.07 per hour. Unfortunately, the myth is that you can pick someone from the Job Centre and give them two days training and the staff can be set to work without supervision managing very complex people. If this is the (Councils) expectation, then there is another Winterbourne waiting to happen!
8
Full survey results The full responses to the survey are set out below. The answers are grouped together in three sections as follows: Section 1: responses from service users Section 2: responses from family carers Section 3: responses from staff Section 1: responses from service users We asked: What services do you get now? Number of respondents day centre 35 support worker 78 social group or club 44 supported housing 33 residential care 11 other services mentioned were: respite weekends, Wolves Lane garden centre, Spotless cleaning, Stars in the sky, communication workshops, personal health budget. Care package which enables me to work at a garden centre and caf. Activity worker, walking groups
We asked: how do the services that you use help you? Service users responses: 1 Help to do my shopping 2 Shopping, visit my family, eat out, keep me healthy, cook my food 3 I get help to make medical appointments, attend them and administer my medication, help to cook my meals and keep my flat tidy and clean, help to do my weekly budgeting and pay bills and do my weekly shopping. Staff prompt me to do my personal hygiene or else I will neglect them. Staff help me to access the community and outdoor activities 4 shop 5 The services help me to live a better life, better health. With staff support I can go out in the community and have an ordinary life 6 I get help to cook my meals and do chores around the house. Help to pay my bills and do budgeting and my weekly shopping, help to make medical appointments, attend them and administer my medication. I get help to access the community and do outdoor activities, eg. snooker, swimming, gym. When I get anxious and agitated my support worker helps to distract me and help me to calm down. Staff needs to prompt me to do my personal hygiene or else I will neglect it 7 I meet my friends at MENCAP meetings. I get help to book medical appointments, attend medical appointments and administer my medication. If staff dont help me to administer my medication I will forget it and I am epileptic and therefore there are chances that I will get more seizures if I dont get my medication on time. Support workers prompt me to do my personal hygiene and personal care, if not prompted I might not have a shower and change clothes for weeks. I get help to cook meals and do cleaning around my house. I get help to do my shopping, budgeting, attend activities and pay bills. I get unpredictable seizures and support staff help me administer medication and keep me safe when I have a seizure 9
8 I meet my friends when I go to the day centre. Support workers prompt and support me to do my personal hygiene and personal care. If not prompted I will neglect my personal care, ie I am incontinent and when I wet my self sometimes if staff doesnt prompt me I wont change my clothes or have a wash. I get help to book medical appointments, attend medical appointments and to administer my medication. I get help to do my weekly shopping, budgeting, attend activities and pay my bills. I get help to cook my meals and do cleaning around my house 9 I get help to make medical appointments, attend them and administer my medication. I get help to do my shopping, pay my bills and do my weekly budgeting. I have to be supported to do my personal hygiene by my support staff or I will neglect them. I get help to cook my meals and do chores around my house. When I get anxious and agitated my staff helps to distract me to calm me down. I get help to access the community and do outdoor activities ie swimming long walks in the parks, gym 10 It helps me to be healthy by having healthy foods and regular appointments with doctor to monitor my medical conditions. I go out regularly to social club, caf, church and restaurant. I also do my shopping with staff support. 11 My support workers help me to attend to my personal hygiene, do my shopping, help me to cook, help me to keep healthy 12 Go shopping, cinema 13 These services help me to live healthy. By going to appointments with professionals, keep a record of my medical conditions. It meets all my needs and helps me to live an ordinary life. Going out for daily activities helps me to socialise within the community and have a sense of belonging 14 Social clubs, meet friends and go on trips, regular services. Day centre back up when I feel like using it. Somewhere to go 15 I go out and do activities, ie going to theatres and concerts. Filling out forms and house bills. Support with cooking a health issues 16 All the services I use help me a lot: meeting friends, participating in activities, accessing the community, going on holidays, staying in a safe environment and being healthy 17 Meet friends, keep healthy. (My daughter is unable to fill forms in so I will try to get her to answer me) 18 Help me with my housing, reading letters, meeting people, going on outings. Try to give up smoking 19 I meet with friends and it also helps to give my parents time to do things for themselves and for my younger brother 21 They help me to socialise, be independent and learn new skills 22 To keep healthy 23 My support worker supports me with shopping every week. I have very little money on benefits. She shops around for bargains, she support me to pay bills and cooks me hot meals and supports me to appointments 24 Yes I meet my friend which I enjoy being with and enjoy eating and doing lots of things while I am there and I am happy 25 I meet my friends. I get advice and guidance with filling out forms and housing issues & repairs 26 If I have problems at home I can talk to my manager at Spotless. They put me through different training courses at Spotless. They show us what to do and are very supportive. They train us on money management. If I didnt have my Spotless work I would struggle financially to pay bills and go places to socialise, to reach meetings. I get supported if I have problems and we also have good friendships from meeting there 27 Support worker helps with paying bills. They help arrange away vacations. They 10
support with medication and my daily blood glucose tests. You get support with mail when they arrive 28 My support workers help with my medication and finance. They help me to go out to do my food shopping and they help me and support me to any health appointment. They help to deal with maintenance in my flat 29 My support workers help me to paying bills. They helped me to go out to do my food shopping and clothes shopping. They support me to attend health appointment. Support with my medication and finance. Support and help with my housing management and maintenance 30 I get help to keep healthy by getting support to keep health appointments 31 It gives me support, independence, confidence, support with health appointments. Encourage to socialise at events they organise. Skills about safety in the community and support with incidents. Support with budgeting and taught life skills. Receive support and advice on any issues 32 By living in supported housing staff help me to read my mail, support me with medication. Staff help me to go food shopping so that I get healthy foods. Staff help me with my personal hygiene as I have a domiciliary worker. Staff help me to look after my cat. Help me to pay my bills, read mail, organise my days. Support with hospital and GP appointments 33 Interact with a wide range of people, support, shopping, accompany to activities 34 I get help with filling in forms, get help with applying for services ie cinema card. Explaining details about important letters to do with rent and house bills 35 Having a support worker it gives me confidence and advice. They help me with keeping healthy, going to the doctor, paying bills 36 I meet my friends 37 I get support to do shopping, stay healthy 38 Helps me because when I am painting and drawing I feel calm. Support worker helps me with shopping. They make sure that my flat is clean and tidy, I wash my clothes. Going to clubs it helps me meet up with my friends 39 I meet my friends, I get help to do my shopping, I get help to keep healthy. The services help me with socialisation, communication, keeping healthy etc 40 Attending the communication workshops helps me to communicate and interact more with other people 41 I like to go out for meals and to activities like Markfield at Nite and Kith & Kids projects. But I do not get a personal budget my parents have to fund these activities 42 I go to the centre to meet my friends 43 I meet my friends & it helps my confidence and social skills. I enjoy going to Markfield for Monday club and the day centre 44 Mix with other people. My carer takes me out shopping 45 I go out with my support worker to the gym and do other activities 46 Help to learn new skills, meet friends, and also keep healthy 49 I get out to volunteer. I meet my friends 50 I get help to stay alive 51 I meet my friends, I get help to keep healthy, I get help to do my shopping. I get to have a life with activities that are important to me 52 I go out in the community, go for cycling, like to do my art work and photography 53 I meet my friends and I learn to cook and I learn about food. I like to go to work because all my friends are there and I like what I am doing. 54 Help me sort out my flat and help me get my clothes ready. I meet my friends and I get help to keep healthy 55 Meet friends, do shopping, keep healthy 56 I meet my friends, I keep healthy & improve my quality of life 11
57 My support worker accompanies me to outdoor and indoor activities like swimming cycling and bowling 58 I meet my friends, I get to keep healthy, I play sport, I get to do beauty and pamper sessions, I get to do art sessions, I get to watch films, I get to cook with my friends, I get to play games, I get to learn about writing and numbers 59 I meet my friends, I get to cook lunch and eat healthily, I play sport, I participate in pamper sessions, I do art lessons, I get help with domestic tasks, I get to take photos, I go to watch films with my friends 60 They help me to be independent they help me to go out and about in the community socialising help to access other services. They help me with my finances and budgeting, shopping, doctors, hospital, optician, dentist appointments. Staff collect my medications, they help me to read and answer letters 61 Shopping, finances, paying bills, help with paperwork, reading, filling out forms, banking, help with healthy eating and attending doctors appointment. They help me in emergencies so that I do not panic. Help me to keep my home clean and with personal hygiene 62 We get support to do our shopping, access activities, maintain my garden, keep our home clean, banking, paying bills, prescriptions, medication, filling out forms, help to understand complicated issues 63 Meet my friends, help to keep healthy, do sport, cook and prepare food, watch films with my friends 64 Help me to socialise 65 Meeting friends, Mencap gym, eat healthily 66 Meet friends, help to keep healthy 67 Shopping, keeping healthy. Finance, accompany me to GP appointments 68 Socialising, improving in communication, taking part in creative activities, being active, making new friends 69 When I go to the day centre I see friends. Staff take me out to the park, museum and shopping. When I go to my social club I talk with staff, mix with others, do art work 70 Assist when cooking, I get to do shopping, exercise, keep healthy 71 It helps me to make friends and it helps me to build my confidence 72 With support worker use computer at home and go out 73 My support worker takes me to the cinema and go out for walks. It makes me feel better. I like to see my friends at Markfield and it is a good place to do my dancing 74 Dance, meet friends 75 Meet friends, sports, cooking, socialising 76 I get to try healthy food. I get to do exercising, helps me to socialise and talk to people 77 I meet my friends and I go shopping with my support worker 78 Meet my friends, socialise 79 I get help to keep healthy, see my friends. I get to talk about John Lenon 80 I like to dance, I get to see the members of staff, and my friends 81 It helps me to met my friends 82 I like to help cook and enjoy the meals. To dance to my friends 83 Doing art there. When I get support worker they take me out shopping and to lots of places 84 I get to see my friends at the day centre social club. With my support worker I go to the shops 85 At the day centre I get to do painting. My support worker helps me with my bad leg. I like to have a dance at the club 87 Going out to the cinema, gym, swimming, museum 88 See friends, shopping, keep healthy 12
89 I get to see other people, friends when I go out. My support worker helps me with lots of things, to get dressed to take to bus for instance. I get to do healthy activities when I go to the day centre. They make me feel happy 90 Markfield is great for getting out, going on lots of walks, keeping healthy and to socialise with others at the centre 91 It helps me to socialise with people and do sport 92 I meet my friends and socialise 93 I meet old and new friends. I gain confidence for the outside world. I do fun things 94 All for One club meet friends. Support worker at college 95 Meet friends 97 I get help to write letters and do shopping and go to the GP 98 I receive basic care
We asked: How would you feel if you did not have these services? Service users responses: 1 Sad 2 unhappy 3 I will feel sad and also I will get anxious. If cuts are implemented the services I use at the moment will be limited and that means I will have less access to the community and all the outdoor activities I do with staff as I wont be able to do them on my own. Also I wont be able to do shopping, budgeting, health appointments etc on my own 4 (picture of sad face) 5 My medical conditions would be neglected and get bad. I wont be able to go out and have a normal lifestyle 6 I will feel anxious and agitated. If cuts are implemented then I wont be able to spend much time with staff and this will affect my day to day life as I need support on a regular basis on my day to day life. When I have a pain or any medical issue I need staff to make an appointment and accompany me. Also I need someone to cook for me and administer medication and to help with my money. If cuts are implemented and hours are reduced that means I wont be able to have the same support that used to have which will make me anxious and agitated. 7 I will feel very insecure and unhappy it will make me anxious. I need a lot of support on a daily basis and not being able to have that support will have a negative impact on my life, ie. I will neglect my personal care, I wont be able to do outdoor activities. I always need staff to be with me or it will put my life in danger. I will feel very annoyed, angry and upset, anxious and helpless 9 I will feel very anxious and agitated 10 My medical conditions will be affected and I would not be able to go out frequently or go out for holidays. I would not be able to buy the things I like. I would not be able to do my daily activities. 11 I cannot think of not having these services. I will have a breakdown. I will be at risk and may die 12 sad 13 I would feel deprived of living a normal life. I would not feel valued. My needs would not be met. Hence affecting my medical conditions 14 I would be at a loose end no social life 15 I would be worried and confused about things Im not sure of, and might not know how to get important housing tasks done 16 I will feel unsafe. It will make me isolated 17 I would stay at home with Mum and do shopping and come home. My daughter likes to keep the day centre and home separate she does not like me going to the 13
day centre or the staff coming home 18 I would be lost without them. My only concern is that I find it more and more difficult to contact (provider organisation) and I have been told recently that I have to make an appointment 19 upset 20 I will be devastated because this will mean staying home and be isolated and cut off. It will really stress and stretch my family. It will affect my mental health and physical health badly. 21 Lost, bored, upset, lonely 22 Health problems and diabetes 23 I think I would go back to my old ways. Not eating proper meals, getting into debt and have more health issues 24 I would be very lost without these services as a user and a carer 25 Worried confused and unsure, and unable to complete and reply to questionnaires, forms and applications 26 I would be angry because I have become used to my job and I absolutely love my work at Spotless and my gardening. I like that it keeps me busy and I socialise with others at work. I would be upset and cry because things like that makes me a bit sensitive 27 I think its pathetic. It will bring a lot of peoples money down and affect their ability to access services. I would be upset if I did not have my supported housing as I wouldnt have a place to live. I would be angry as I wouldnt want to be in a hostel. I would feel terrible if I lost my support worker because she has helped me a LOT with bills. She is the best support worker 28 Not pleased 29 I dont know what I can do. Who can help me. I am worried 30 My health would deteriorate 31 I would feel upset. I would be angry. I would be anxious about where I would live if my supported housing service is cut. I would feel low. If Stars in the Sky was no longer available. I would be sad because they organise nice events that allow me to socialise 32 I would feel a bit lost and I feel like I could possibly struggle and maybe get into financial difficulty. I may also not take my medication correctly and therefore become ill 33 Kinda lost. Felt left alone to cope 34 I would feel confused left behind and wont know what to do 35 Upset and worried. Unhappy 36 I have friends to help and family 37 I would feel terrible, I need support to go to the doctors, hospital appointments 38 I would be a bit lost. I would cope on my own but I would need help with some things like reading my letters, paying bills 39 I would feel bored, isolated, unhealthy and unhappy 40 I would feel isolated. Going backwards instead of moving forward and learning more ways to understand and communicate better 41 I would be really cross and upset 42 I will be sad. I like going to the centre 43 Bored, upset, sad without an opportunity to meet my friends and feel lonely 44 I would be disappointed for lack of being out and about 45 Not sure, but would not be able to go out to the gym and other activities 46 It would affect my health and also my social life 48 I will feel bad 49 I would feel stuck at home and bored. I would miss my friends. I am worried about losing more support 14
50 Bad and sad and unhappy 51 Very upset and angry, bored, lonely, discriminated against, depressed 52 I will be disappointed and depressed. Will be sad to stay at home and do nothing 53 I would feel very bored and lonely. 54 I would feel angry, hurt and upset. I think it would be disgusting to stop my services 55 Alone 56 Down , depressed, unable to contact friends and get the support I need 57 I would be housebound and unfit and would not meet my friends 58 If I couldnt come here it would be bad. It would make me sad, It would make me swear. It would make me cry. 59 It would make me feel bad. It would make me sad 60 I would struggle a lot without this support. I would be low and down. I would get financial problems. I would not be safe and happy. I would miss the socialising and being involved with the community and knowing that someone is looking out for me 61 I would be very upset, I would be scared and would have panic attacks. I would not know what to with my finances, I would get into debt. I would be lost without support. My skills would get worse. I do not know how to handle health problems and medication well. I would become isolated and alone 62 It would be very difficult big risk of financial problems. We could become very isolated. I feel quite independent but rely on my support to maintain that and have a vibrant life 63 Sad, cry, angry 64 Upset, unhappy 66 upset 67 Upset, more medication support, my independence and learning skills will go down again, getting more sick. If my services are reduced I will get a panic attack 68 Would be bored at home and get agitated which could lead to behaviour problems. Mum would have no time for shopping and looking after the household it would be a nightmare 69 I would just stay at home feeling bored, not happy 70 I am not leaving. I want to come to Markfield 71 I would feel sad it would be upsetting. I would not have anything to do 72 I would feel sad, unable to go out and socialise 73 Sad as I enjoy going out with my support worker and to Markfield it is good for me 74 bored 75 I would feel sad and disappointed 76 I will be sad 78 I will be really sad 79 I would be upset and sad 80 I would feel sad 81 Burdened and upset 82 sad 83 I will feel sad 84 I would be upset. I would ask Cameron why? 85 Not sure 86 Sad angry, hopeless and worried 87 Feel very bad. Wont be able to cope on my own. Lost touch with my friends in the community. Not be able to travel on my own 89 I would feel really bored. I would have nothing to do 90 Disappointed and sad as these services are valuable to us in terms of support in our day to day life 15
91 I will feel upset angry and unfair 92 I will feel sad 93 I would feel sad as I wouldnt meet people and be stuck at home 94 I will be upset 95 upset 96 I feel broken heart and upset 97 I will feel sad and low down 98 Not happy
We asked: Do you get enough support now? What other services do you need that you do not have? Service users responses 1 No, I want to go out, more activities, stay out more, holiday 2 Visits to places, being out long on bus 3 At the moment I get enough support 5 yes 6 I only get 6 hours of staff support every day. I like staff to stay with me much longer so we can do more outdoor and functional activities 7 Not at the moment 8 Due to my medical conditions in the future I may need to have more staff support as I am getting very forgetful and confused most of the time, and also struggling to do lots of things on my own , ie laundry and washing up which I used to do on my own. I got severe tremors in my hands and I am not able to do cooking or even make a cup of tea as it is dangerous to use the kettle. Therefore if any cuts are implemented I am concerned about my life as the support I am getting now will be reduced 10 yes 11 yes 12 Spend more time out lots of places every day 13 Yes I have enough support 14 All provisions now are great. Family happy 15 yes 18 No I want to do reading classes 19 yes 20 No I do not get enough now. I need help with personal care and extra support for someone to wait with me in the mornings for my school bus, and wait in the afternoons when the bus brings me home 21 yes 22 yes 23 yes 24 I would like more support for my son over the weekend Saturday and Sunday. Would be very great for me and would give me more time to do my things and have time for myself too as a carer 25 I get enough support right now 26 At the moment I am happy with my support 27 At the moment staff are outstretched and are very busy so dont always get enough individual support 28 Yes at the moment 29 At the moment I have got staff to help me but staff are busy 30 Job search to meet my needs 31 At the moment my support is OK and sustainable 16
32 I feel like I get enough support from staff and I do not want it to be taken away due to the cuts. I want to start the gym and my activity worker will help me with that 33 Basic support 1 day a week 34 yes 35 I do get enough 36 yes 37 yes 38 Ive got it all, Im alright 39 Just necessary services I get by using my personalised budget 40 No I only have my sister who is my carer. I feel I would benefit from having a social worker who could give me and my sister the proper support we need like help with benefits and anything else we are unaware about 41 I have recently moved care homes and I am hoping that the day activities in the new home will be covered by social services. In the previous home the Council only paid for board and lodgings and I and my parents had to pay for all the day activities. I could not attend a day centre any more as that was expensive and stopped when I moved to the first home 42 Yes 43 Other services needed: cookery classes, money classes, keep fit classes, writing classes 44 Im happy with the support I get 45 I am on the waiting list for the Occupational Therapist 46 I feel I want to get married 47 yes 48 I want to go on the minibus 49 I would like more support so I can date my girlfriend and learn stuff like cooking and knowing peoples addresses 50 No 51 Art clubs, speech and language therapy 53 I receive enough support at the moment 54 I would like extra support so I can go to college in September 55 Yes 56 No I would like to attend evening social club to improve my quality of life 57 Yes I get enough support now 58 I would like to swim, I would like to go to the pub, I would like to play snooker, I would like to ride horses 59 Yes 60 I wish there was more employment and training options for people with LD 61 I get good support now. I do wish staff would call me at weekends to see if I am OK and to chat 62 I have enough support now my hours have remained the same for many years 63 yes 64 I would like to have a workshop as a part time job 65 Travel training. Would like my own place to live 66 Pay my bills, help for shopping, attend GP appointment 67 Yes I am satisfied with the support I am having 68 No theres never enough support. Evening support outside for example a club would be hugely beneficial and much needed for both mum and daughter 69 I get enough support 70 Yes my support worker is OK 71 I am OK with the services I currently have 72 I have enough support now and am happy with it 17
73 Im happy with the support I am getting 75 Move into house with girlfriend 76 Yes I am OK with the services I have 77 yes 78 yes 79 I get the right support now 81 yes 82 Yes I do 83 Yes I get enough support Ive got everything 84 Yes at the moment I do 85 Yes 87 If possible music lessons. Family trips with the person you care for 88 OK but I feel its not enough. Like to go out a bit more 90 Yes I get enough support at the moment 91 yes 92 yes 93 I get enough support 94 Developing my DJ skills. Get a job 95 job 96 Help getting a job 98 No I dont get enough support
We asked: how have you been affected by cuts or reductions to services? Service users responses 7 I have been informed that they are trying to reduce my care package which will result in staff working less hours with me. In the future if they decide to reduce or cut the services I am getting I will find it difficult to cope with day to day life as the support I get from staff is essential to me. I dont want to lose my placement due to cuts as I love where I live now and it will be very stressful for me to move to another place. Due to my medical conditions my physical health might get worse in the future according to the doctors and I might need more support I the future. Therefore if any cuts are implemented it will affect my life. 14 My friends find it difficult when transport cut to clubs 18 Yes day centres, training schemes 20 In the past I could attend Markfield and Team Spirit and still had enough money through personal budget for other community and social activities. Now I use all my money to pay for 2 days at Markfield 21 Yes - respite 22 Cuts cause delay in getting treatment 23 Personal Independence Payment: I reapplied for PiP in October2013. My support worker phoned the office in Jan 14 was informed it was passed onto the assessment provider. Got in contact with them they are to send out appointment for one to one consultation 24 Yes support worker has been laid off. I have seen the social worker about it 25 At my garden centre some of the workers lost their positions. It was hard because they were there for years and it affects us and we miss them. Its not right and its not fair because its hard for people with LD to find other jobs 26 Where I live support staff have been reduced and our manager took redundancy 27 Our project manager took redundancy and the supporting hours have been reduced from where I live 18
28 Support hours have been reduced. Manager took redundancy 30 Supported living related services 31 My supported housing the staff have been reduced, our manager took redundancy 39 Recent cut in community support work team and shared lives scheme affected me by losing their services 41 My attendance at a day centre was cut 3.5 years ago and I really miss going there. I used to attend the National Autistic Society day centre in Acton above my old school. I am hoping that I will soon be able to go back to a day centre some days a week as all my friends go to one and it is really unfair that I have been unable to go 43 No more cookery classes at Winkfield Rd so unable to learn cooking skills. Keston Road day service cut so Ive been moved around. Confused as to why it was closed 49 I lost one of my support workers 50 Clubs I used to go to have closed down like Art club, art and music therapy. This helped me to express my feelings 55 Yes Camden Society 56 The social club I attended the bus /coach service has been cut therefore I no longer can attend 60 Some staff at the organisation that supports me have been made redundant last year. One home had to close and the clients had to move elsewhere 61 I have heard that there might be cuts to the centre where I go. Losing this service would isolate me and make me feel lonely 64 A lady manager stopped visiting me 65 Yes a day centre in Hackney she used to go to has been closed down last year due to funding cuts 71 I know that other services are being cut. Though it is not affecting me I am worried that it might someday 72 I know services are being reduced. I would be worried if it happened to Marfkfield and I couldnt attend any more 75 I would like to go to the caf in green lanes again 81 One of my support workers was made redundant 82 Yes they have 88 Dont get much services 90 I am aware of services being reduced and cuts being implemented. It is worrying if I will be affected and cant access services 93 Quite a few services have been reduced over the years which means they cant do what they want to do and I dont get as many opportunities 97 Yes outreach it made me a bit sad and unhappy
We asked: Do you think that services for people with Learning Disabilities should be cut? Number of responses from service users: Yes 0 No 97
19
Section 2: responses from family carers We asked: What services does the person that you care for get now: day centre 14 support worker 11 social group or club 9 supported housing 2 residential care 2 other services mentioned: Cycling, swimming, horse riding. respite, occasional workshop
We asked: how do these services help the person you care for? Carers responses 1 The day centre is vitally important along with the Markfield Monday club and courses provided in the borough. Without their vital services adults with Learning Disabilities cannot improve their skills or socialise. The Monday club provides an opportunity for my daughter to socialise with others and art classes provide her with a lot of confidence 2 Helps with socialising 3 To learn new skills, keep healthy and socialise 5 Help to socialise, to keep healthy and safe, to learn new skills, to become more confident and independent. Better quality of life 6 Likes meeting people and friends, going out shopping, outing at seaside & different locations, keep fit, art and photography 7 Mencap helps my son keep healthy, learn new skills, social life and gives a good quality of life 8 The personal budget helps a lot, as otherwise my daughter would not be able to pay for a support worker to socialise, keep healthy and generally go out and about 9 Enables young person with autism to accept support from someone other than family 10 These services are absolutely crucial to help him to socialise get out of the house and learn new skills, exercise, his mental and physical well being all depend on day centre and being a part of society 11 My brother goes to the placement at Green pepper caf in Wolves Lane and the day centres when he is not able to go there or his other placement. He attends social clubs. He enjoys this and he would be socially isolated without it 12 They get the chance to mix with others people who are not family and it is good for them 13 It helps him socialise, keep healthy, learn new skills, reduce isolation and challenging behaviour 14 The services help him to socialise, learn new skills, communicate with sign language, learn to be away from home and be more independent 15 Learning independence, participation in the community, living skills 16 Help to socialise with other students. Help to maintain good health by diet and regular exercise 20
17 All of these things help my son in his everyday life and he always wants to be out 18 Travel mate takes the cared for person out. Help cooking, cleaning, socialising, gaining self confidence to live independently 19 The communication workshop is the only support my sister gets. She has attended 2 full courses that last between 4 to 6 weeks each. This is the second year and she enjoys going 20 Help to socialise, but she hasnt learned any new skills 21 The services help my son to socialise and also to communicate with his peers 22 It helps him socialise because he cant make friends. Keep him healthy and outings. Learning life and new skills. I have got a good network with those working with him 23 Helps him to socialise and keep busy 24 We receive a personal healthcare budget from the CCG to enable us to support our son (severe autism and bowel disease) at home, ie 2-to-1 care weekdays 3.30-8.30 pm on returning from college and weekends 10-6 pm. care meets his basic needs for food, preparing food according to restricted diet, toileting and washing, engaging in activities, talking out to local parks and social clubs, or on car drives, prepare & admin medications, accompany hospital appointments, restraining self-injurious and aggressive behaviours, support communication needs, accompanying on short breaks and family holidays. 27 Basic care is provided
We asked: How do these services help you as a carer? Carers responses 1 In order for my daughter to develop friendships with others and improve her independence and confidence. It may mean that she would be indoors a lot more and socially isolated 2 I am happy with the support I get 3 Help me to take a break 4 It should help me get the help/ rest deserved 5 Respite for myself. Freedom from knowing I am not alone in caring for my son. Better quality of life 6 It gives me a break as I am a single parent. I can do my own classes, go out meet friends 7 I do not need to find care for my son and I am able to have some quality of life for myself 8 When my daughter goes out with a support worker I get a respite from my caring duties and I can pursue my interests 9 Its my respite 10 I would simply not be able to care for him if he wasnt attending day care. It gives me time to recoup my strength and carry on caring for him for the rest of the day and weekends 11 My brother is well cared for by the services. I am amazed by all the service givers and the support we receive. It puts my mind at rest that my brother has a caring structure in his life 12 My daughter will not go to respite, so it gives me a chance to get things done like doctors, dentist, shopping, and get a rest until she comes home 13 Oh yes I want to have a life outside of my caring role. These services give me 21
time for myself & to care for my other children. They help take my mind off things 14 They give me time for myself so I can do what I need for myself 15 Relieves me of total responsibility, though I sill have responsibility to make sure it works, and my son visits every weekend 16 Helps to maintain a good relationship as parents. Help to reduce costs as we are pensioners 17 This gives me time to do all the things that I need to do and look after my family and my other disabled son 19 The communication workshops are the only support I get towards caring for my sister. Just knowing she is interacting with others and learning to communicate better is helpful for both of us 20 Having my daughter in residential care certainly does help, but I was disappointed that her day centre attendance was stopped when she went into residential care. I am hoping that in her new care home which I believe is less expensive this may start again 21 It helps me to have time for myself as well as spending time with his siblings 22 It has extended my life because of the bad health I have incurred and hospital visits 23 It gives me peace of mind that he is enjoying himself 24 This reduces care placed on us as parents, allows us to do shopping and domestic tasks, and enjoy some respite. 27 I am unable to provide the care my son needs and so basic care is provided
We asked: How would it affect you, and the person you care for, if you did not have these services? Carers responses 1 In the UK adults with Learning Disabilities do not have opportunities to gain employment skills, life skills and independence skills to gain confidence. As we get older we may be unable to take out daughter out so would mean she may become socially isolated and despondent. We are very grateful for the day services in Haringey and the Markfield Project for their great service 2 I would be helpless. My daughter would be disappointed for lack of socialising 3 It would affect our social life and also affect the user learning skills and health 4 terribly 5 We would become very frustrated, bored, depressed, exhausted and feel trapped and our quality of life would diminish 6 I will be housebound, will have to take him with me and none of us will enjoy 7 It would affect both of our quality of life, reduce his social life, unable to learn new skills 8 I would be overworked and I would not get any free time for myself. My daughter would be housebound and bored and would not have any interaction with her friends 9 Young person only able to be supported by family. As a carer become exhausted and lose friends 10 It would devastate our whole family as we would not be able to care for our son and he would be extremely unhappy and would have a devastating effect on him 11 I will be unhappy that he did not have the placements and clubs 12 Im sure we would be stuck in the house most days as she does not like mixing much with people and would only stay out about 1 hour or so. The day centre is good for her 22
13 I will probably give up my job. My mental and physical health will suffer. I will become completely isolated and never be able to do any other thing. 14 Very badly. We would lose the ability for him to socialise, and a lot more 15 He would need more expensive care (residential). He would get depressed and challenging and would need more drugs 16 Breakdown in relationships with parents especially when there is verbal and physical abuse every day at home. Ill health 17 We would be very upset without these services 18 Carers have to find extra time to look after their cared for. Carers getting old 19 I feel it would be taking us many steps backwards without any support. My sister needs to be able to build up confidence around communicating with others long term, attending these workshops, even for 6 weeks each year is better than nothing 20 I would be most disappointed and upset if my daughter did not have these services. She needs to have proper structured and meaningful activities, which for some time the social services have not provided 21 It would affect him a great deal because he has been going to the centre since he was a child and the progress he has made is great. His challenging behaviour will increase. I will not be able to rest or have time for myself and spending time with his siblings 22 My health will be worse. In fact I will have no life at all 23 It would be difficult for me as it would be hard to juggle all the household chores whilst taking care of him 24 All his support needs would fall on us his parents. We would not be able to carry the full load of care which would have to pass to other care sectors such as supported living or residential. 27 I would not be able to cope with looking after my son full-time
We asked carers: Does the person you care for get enough of the right services now? Carers responses 1 No there was a cookery class recently that was closed down. This means less opportunities for my daughter to develop skills for independence. Also classes such as handing money handwriting classes and day to day life skills classes would be significantly beneficial 2 Yes she does 3 yes 4 No they dont get social groups and clubs 5 At the moment they do (get enough support) but we are worried about cuts on rates for support workers and quality of care also various therapies such as Speech and language therapy and occupational therapy are not available 6 yes 7 He used to attend a social club in the evenings, however due to cuts to the service he no longer attends. Would like that service again 8 Yes my daughter does get enough of the right services as she has a personal budget 9 Need more social interactions 10 yes 11 Yes he receives excellent ongoing care I cant fault it 13 No he does not get enough. |He needs help with personal care all day. He needs an assistant to wait his bus in the morning and after school. He needs 23
money to socialise 14 Yes I am pleased with the services 15 Not enough facilities in the community for people with severe Learning Disabilities. Often there is nowhere to go. Some services cost more than he can afford. Have to stay at home gets frustrated and depressed 16 Yes my son seems to be getting the right services at the moment. But there is a long way to go 17 I think we get the right service that I know of, but I would love to have more help for my son he is very hard work when he is at home hitting and slapping himself 18 Not enough services available which the cared for person needs. Eg. day care, help cooking & cleaning 19 No. My sister has not had any real support since she was a teenager. I have tried in the past to acquire a social worker to support and fight her corner, but I was told because of cutbacks theres not much available 20 No she definitely needs more structured day activities and ones that she or we as parents do not have to pay for. This should be included in what the council is paying for her care as she does not have a personal budget and has to contribute most of her ESA benefit to the council 21 Yes he does 22 For now yes 23 yes 24 No. His care & support plan lists early morning care 7-9 am weekdays which he does to receive. His provision does not include college holidays care when he needs care all day and respite breaks to support parents have overnight breaks (we have had only two nights respite in last 2 years). Nor does it include care for self-help tasks he cannot perform himself such as cooking, laundering, cleaning the rooms he and his carers use. These care needs fall on his parents. He receives no Speech therapy or Occupational therapy support. 27 I do not believe my son receives the right care . Socially he needs more interaction. He needs to be stimulated mentally and physically. I feel with better care and support my son would have progressed further.
We asked: How have cuts or reductions in services affected you? Carers responses 1 Cooking classes were cut that were running in Winkfield Road centre which were very good. Also the Keston day centre closed and my daughter was shifted numerously to different services. More funding is required to provide day services and stop cuts 4 Not sure 5 Various clubs due to funding. Difficulty finding activities that my son likes and can access making life difficult for him 7 Used to attend social club in the evening, but due to cuts he no longer attends 9 Community care team 11 Transport has been cut to people going to Unity 70 club. They are my brothers friends. These friends need transport as they cant afford private transport. And its a sadness to see them without it as it enhances their life 12 Well the (Council day centre) where my daughter goes has far too many service users and staff in a small building. This is because of cuts having to give 24
buildings up because of cuts 13 He no longer has enough place at Markfield. & cannot afford Team spirit 14 Respite has been cut. It means less independence and socialising for him and less me time for me 15 Staff are paid less. There is a greater staff turnover and people without experience. They leave because of pressure 16 Yes it took a long time and a lot of effort to obtain the service. It has caused a lot of stress and anxiety 17 Yes his support work - which is now being looked into by social worker 18 Do not know yet 20 I have seen my daughters behaviour regress because she does not have the activities and has been more difficult to handle when she comes home. It is very wrong that someone of her age (25) has not had proper assessed day activities. The independent care home where my daughter lives, funded by Haringey Council, has cut their staffing levels. The manager of the care home told me that this was partly because of funding cuts. The care home pays very low wages to their support staff (less than 7 per hour). One of the other residents used to get two-to-one support, but this has been reduced to one-to-one support. There was a very bad incident recently when I was visiting my daughter at the care home. This other resident was not being adequately supervised there was no staff member at all looking after her - and she became very distressed and physically attacked and severely injured me so badly that I needed hospital treatment. This incident has been reported to the Haringey adults safeguarding team, but I have not heard back from them. 24 The CCG agreed a package of 110 hours a week in February 2013 but failed to deliver this. In May 13 (three months later) we decommissioned the support provider. This was used as justification to reassess his needs (which were found not to have reduced) and give us 100 hours in July 13. We are currently disputing this the present package. 26 They have made several cuts to the centre my son attends which have impacted on the care provided.
We asked: Do you think that services for people with Learning Disabilities should be cut? Number of responses from carers: Yes 0 No 26
Additional comments from carers 1 Day services are vital in Haringey for those vulnerable individuals living in the borough. Continuously the borough has cut services for this group and cuts can be saved elsewhere in the borough. They are extremely vital for carers and adults with Learning Disabilities 5 These cuts are discriminating against the most vulnerable and at risk members of society and are unacceptable. 9 Very frightened that yet more services will be cut 10 These services are an absolute lifeline for us. Without them our whole family would be devastated 11 We have all enjoyed these lovely services that are essential to us all 13 I need someone to come and assess my sons needs and mine as a carer 14 They should not cut services for these people because they are vulnerable 25
and need more help 17 They should not cut any services for the disabled people at all its not right 18 Benefits must not be cut. It should remain as it is, not increased 19 Why is it that nothing changes. The vulnerable are always the first to suffer govt cutbacks, excuses and empty promises for change and improvement 20 Individual assessments should be made of each service. It is wrong that we as parents were expected to pay for her day activities. If we had not done this she used to have to lounge around watching TV all day which would have been totally unacceptable. Social services showed complete indifference to this situation. The council has little interest once service users are placed in residential care. Very few checks are made on what is happening in these homes and even when there is a safeguarding issue social workers are slow to respond. Annual reviews are frequently months late and there is little follow up re recommendations. 21 Even though my son gets enough of the right services if they reduce the service in the future it will affect him and me by him taking out his frustrations on me 24 We have experienced cuts in his care plan which are illegal and breach s47(1) NHS & Community Care Act 1990 in that there have been no changes in his needs that justify reducing the hours in his care plan. 25 My son has ASD, ADHD, bi-polar, severe anxiety disorder. 24 hours supported living care, shared at night with one other service user. It takes my son a tremendously long time to get used to a new support worker, often 3 or 4 months of severe tantrumming and distress. However once he is used to someone, he becomes very attached. His team has been entirely consistent since they began work with him and this has been essential to the progress he has since made. Future cuts that may get made to the support workers pay will result in most of them leaving. They are quite clear about the fact that they cannot get by on less. The impact of starting again with what would likely be less educated and caring people is the stuff of my nightmares and I think would likely end up with my son back in a secure psychiatric provision, ultimately costing much more and ruining lives. 26 I feel that more services should be provided so that people with disabilities can have a much better life and become more independent. I would like to see more than the basic care being given.
Section 3: Responses from staff The staff who responded to the survey were from a range of different organisations that provide services: including Haringey Council, voluntary sector and private sector organisations.
We asked: Are you aware of any cuts or reductions to services for adults with Learning Disabilities? Staff responses 1 Its terrible. Theres nothing for the service users to do or spend their time. Every year or so there are more cuts 26
2 yes 3 Yes, lots of homes, day centres 4 Yes: cuts throughout all areas: staff, social workers, OT 5 No I wasnt aware 6 I do understand and am aware of cuts to these services, however I am not aware of specific centres/areas that will be affected 7 yes 8 yes 9 Yes many activities that enrich the lives of people with LD are now not being funded 10 Yes activities that were being funded have been cut 11 Yes I am aware that Haringey Council are making cuts 12 Yes this is constant. I was told by the commissioner at Haringey (name withheld) that he is not interested in a five star service.
One client in particular, the cuts have been so stringent that we cannot now continue supporting her in her own accommodation. I have reported the same to Social Services and they have called for a Health re-assessment ie. trying to get the CCG to take over her funding. Nobody from Health have contact us.
I have made it clear to Social Services that we would need to move her into shared accommodation.
A consultant from Haringey came to cut our funding using the Care Funding Calculator the assumption used on the calculator is that we pay staff 7.07per hour. When we informed him that we are currently paying our staff way above what they are proposing, he re-did his costings on the calculator to show that we should reduce our fees by a thousand pounds per week.
It was only upon close scrutiny that I noticed that he had achieved this by DECEIT ie. by reducing the number of hours provided to the client but keeping quiet about it. The good news is that this consultant is not around anymore. 13 I have heard that there might be some cut backs to support services 14 Several of the projects in our work have had to have reduced support hours 15 Yes colleagues, staff I know working for Haringey Social services 18 My service user needs more service than she got before. But the cut in hours has an impact on her daily life 19 Yes for the last few years services supporting people with learning disabilities has been experiencing massive cuts 20 Yes colleagues, media 22 I have heard this from our managers 23 Yes. When any review / assessment meeting is arranged by social services re service users the local authority are always looking for ways to make cuts/reduction. The culture of review/assessment has changed in the last few years. Local authority are more interested to cut money/hours rather than listening to the needs of service users or staff 24 yes 25 I was informed by the manager 26 Yes I have heard about cuts the government has announced more cuts are on the way. But this will make more misery for people who are using the services 29 Yes I have been informed by duty social workers from the Learning 27
Disabilities team when they did a review with my service users 30 I am aware of the cuts for adults with LD 32 Yes I am aware of cuts through discussions with managers in three organisations I work with, and with families whose children I work with 34 I have been made aware by my employer that cuts are happening and are ongoing 35 Yes I am really aware of cuts in my workplace now and before. I am affected too 36 Some placements are shutting down, most of the clients are not given proper support. Most of the clients are not being cared for by skilled and professional workers 37 Yes they are reducing our shifts 38 Our company was telling us the last few months they are going to cut our hours 39 Yes the last couple of months we are hearing this kind of news which is not good 43 Yes for the past 2 years clients budgeted hours have been drastically changing and this has had a drastic impact on both clients and support workers 44 yes 45 Yes Im aware of upcoming reductions as I have participated in my clients benefit reviews. From the way they discuss it with senior staff they seem to be trying to cut down the money they spend on our clients 46 Yes quite often at team meetings 47 Yes often social services cut down the budget for service users 48 Yes often discussed with my peers in the health sector 50 Yes I am aware of benefit reductions to adults with LD in my workplace as well as some other organisations and care homes 53 Yes for the past few years services for supporting people with learning disabilities have been experiencing massive cuts 55 Yes for the last few years the council have been reducing both support hours for disabled people as well as funding 56 Yes hours have been cut down. Care for service users is being neglected. Service users needs are no longer seen as a priority 57 Support hours have been reduced by a couple of hours a day. Day to day resources are tight as well. 58 Support hours are being reduced 60 Hours have been reduced. 61 Yes I am aware of and have personal experience of cuts to LD day services. Staff have been cut, staffing levels have been reduced. Minibuses have been cut, there are less minibuses available to transport service users. Money for activities and equipment has been cut 62 There have been staff reductions in the service I work in as staff leave they are not replaced. Spending on food has been reduced. 63 Yes I have heard from managers that commissioning managers at Haringey want us to provide more for the same amount of people. Though this does not cut the total amount of money the end result IS a cut as the pot of money is divided by fewer people meaning less money to provide the service per person.
I have also heard directly from parents that the numbers of staff members have been reduced in certain care provisions, with specific examples of serious safeguarding issues as a result. 28
I have also heard that certain care providers have cut staff wages which belittles caring work one of the most important and precious professions in our society. I work with our young people reaching 18 and transitioning from children to adult services. The team that manages the transitions are clearly understaffed as assessments frequently do not occur until well AFTER the young people have turned 18years old. If it does happen before it is almost always because the young person has a parent that is on the ball enough to fight and push to get it done. I have worked directly with several young people or supported parents of young people through our 18+ parent carers forum whos services have stopped when they reached 18yrs because their budget was not yet in place. This has caused considerable stress and anxiety for parents and young people who go from having regular services to nothing. Often this feels much like a stalling tactic to delay delivering a personal budget. When budget are put in place the services that are provided are often less than the young person had previously been receiving, for example I have seen the number of hours of respite care reduced meaning extra caring is put on the parents.
We asked: tell us about the effects of these cuts on service users Staff responses 1 Service users need activities to keep stimulated 2 Some of the service users lose their hours. People with Learning Disabilities are losing out and sometimes they stop going to day centres because of these cuts 3 Service users have to travel far which affects them. Not only have they lost their homes and day centres they also lost their independence 4 Less time spent with professionals 6 Service users are affected but cuts taking a toll on extra leisure activities and overall well-being 7 Loss of day centres, homes, carers, quality of life will decrease 8 Some service users will lose their day centres and their quality of life will decrease 9 A lack of meaningful activities can lead to reduced levels of general health and well being and social isolation 10 They find it difficult to understand why activities have been taken away from them. They feel rejected and frustrated. Their well being suffers as well as their social lives 11 Could result in much more limited services, thus not being able to meet the needs of service users and clients 12 The quality of support provided to our clients has a direct correlation to two things What we pay our frontline support staff How well the staff are supported
In my role I sometimes help out with recruitment. We recently did an Open Day and twenty people turned up. This recruitment was targeted for a particular service user and under the circumstances, we involved his mother in the recruitment. At the end of the Open Day her exact words to us was I would not let any of todays lot even look after my dog.
29
This is not being derogatory to staff in any way but that appears to be the quality of most of the people that the Job Centres are sending these days.
Even if we paid staff 10 per hour, they would only perform if there are sufficiently robust support structures in place. Unfortunately, the myth that you could pick someone from the Job Centre and give them two days training in Food Hygiene, Manual Handling etc and the staff can be set free to work without supervision managing very complex people.
If this is the expectation, then there is another Winterbourne waiting to happen!!! 13 Less support will affect service users with the amount of time they need to sort out complicated housing matters, repairs, benefits 14 They get less support hours and have to use their individual budgets to get support, meaning if a service user has issues it will be dealt with on their support day, whereas before staff on shift would have supported all residents daily as part of the shift 15 When cuts occur this usually means staffing levels in services are cut. This impacts greatly on service users having a social life. Ive experienced individual choice becoming group choice. Ive see service users becoming extremely distressed due to being confined to the home too long. The quality of service for the service user reduces 16 Service users social life is affected as there are usually staff cuts 17 It impacts greatly on service users having a social life. 18 We reduce the service user activity and outdoor activity. Sometimes my service user needs 2 people when she becomes agitated 19 Service users are at risk. One staff cannot look after more than one service user at a time. Service users needs are not being met. Service users health and safety are in jeopardy 20 Staffing levels cut this impacts on service users social life 21 It may affect well being of service users, impact on daily lifestyle 22 Service users have less outdoor activities, social life. It will also mean they have low quality service from the carers or support workers who are also affected by the cuts (demotivated staff will surely have poor quality of service. Service users will have less access to community facilities like community centres, leisure centres, etc 23 Our service users need/want choice. Their wants/choice and desire seem unimportant ton the local authority. I doubt whether the local authority is meeting everyones needs effectively as cost seems to be the most important subject. For example where service users need two to one support the local authority is pushing is to do with one to one support. Insufficient support can potentially put the staff and the public at risk 24 The service users we support are vulnerable clients who need lots of support and prompting. If cuts are implemented the quality of support they receive will be decreased and that will affect their emotional and general well being 25 Our service users are vulnerable adults, most of them need 24hr support for their living. If the council is going to cut its services (it means reduce hours of support) it mainly affects the service users lives 26 The service users are already in a difficult position with the cuts done in previous years 27 Talking about cuts doesnt make any sense. I have been supporting many clients for many years. They are becoming more difficult to support instead of increasing support they are talking about cuts and less hours with clients 30
28 The service users we support are vulnerable adults and they do need day to day support to enhance their daily living skills, ie. budgeting, cooking, cleaning the house and also to support more complex needs such as their medication, medical appointments. If cuts are implemented and the number of hours we work with clients can be reduced and as a result staff wont have time to do more meaningful outdoor and functional activities with the service users. This will have a negative impact on our clients life and make them more anxious and unsettled. 29 Some cuts have already started taking effect at my workplace. It has a great effect on my service users as the hours have been reduced and my service users do not get the same 1:1 support, especially as my clients medical and physical needs have been getting more complex over the last couple of years 30 The cuts will definitely have a negative impact on service users. Years of hard work of support teams will be wasted 31 It means the services they use will be limited, ie. day centres where they get a chance to meet friends and socialise and also do group activities together 32 Reduction in services will impact negatively on the quality of life of service users. Individuals will have less to do to stimulate them. I believe there will be an increase in the level of anxiety and stress of service users and thus a regression in their general health. As such this will defeat the essence of the cut in the first place as more medical provisions will have to be made to repair the damage that will have been brought about by the cut 33 It means that vulnerable adults will not get the support they need. Valuable facilities that they use will no longer be available. This will be to the detriment of the service users and their families 34 The service users are getting less time and attention which means they feel less supported and increases their stress and anxiety levels. Their quality of life will decrease considerably, including their health and social development. These cuts will have a big impact on service users and in turn society as a whole 35 The are getting worse. They are not happy. They may get more illness, they dont have any social activities which they may need 36 Clients are restricted limited social activities. They are deprived of their rights due tom limited staff to support them. Unpleasant behaviours of clients become more prominent due to (high staff turnover) 37 Service users have limited choice. They dont have a happy life. 38 They cannot do any activities of their own choice. Service users life will be dangerous. They will be stuck in one place. It will affect their life as they could become more disabled 39 We cannot provide the activities which service users like most cinema, swim, etc 40 Reduced freedom of choice for clients for instance if our client wants to go out in the community and only one support staff is present we are really forced to decline their request. 41 With less money it is difficult to spend money to buy what they like. With better funding it will help to have a normal life as anyone else 43 By reducing both hours and finance for service users all service users are being limited in their activities (going out, day centres). Reducing their quality of life 44 The company will find it harder to recruit qualified staff and the quality of services will decrease. Staff leave the job because of these cuts. Clients will become more vulnerable 45 These cuts will have a big impact on our clients we will have to cut down on 31
the activities we do to give them an ordinary life. It could even be a risk to their safety 46 Local authority is denying their independence. Local authority is reducing their quality of life. Lack of stability in their lives and well being, uncertain future 47 Service users will be denied their wish to live everyday lives independently and they will have to be forced to live with their parents into old age. This is also unfair on their parents. Our service users got used to expecting support to be able to go out and have a good day or good quality of life, this is being pulled away from them 48 We need to treat service users like other people. They should get a right to enjoy their life with support. Cuts will affect the meaning of their life 49 Limited choice. Not having enough support to be able to explore their capabilities in life 50 Higher concerns for the safety of our clients. The lack of vital measures for making sure that people with LD have their care tailored to their needs 51 Activities and facilities being reduced. Carrying their lives in narrow boundary which makes them more anxious and unstable 52 They may get unhealthy. They dont have social activities 53 Unable to meet their needs and desires in life, limited choice 54 Service users are at risk. Staff cannot look after more than one or two clients at a time. Service users health & safety are in jeopardy 55 Service users are being deprived of their lifestyle. Service users cant do daily activities like day centre, outings, hence leads to service users staying at home. 56 Activities for service users are more and more scarce. There is not enough money for them to go out. they have to stay at home most of the time and are being deprived of the things they want to have such as personal stuff that they cant afford to buy 57 Staff have to do a lot of compromises when it comes to users needs and likes. Their choices cant be met 58 Earlier there were two staff working all the day time. Now its being reduced, and means that there are less hours to go out and do activities with them 59 They have to reduce activities, choices. If they want to buy something if we havent enough money we cant give it to them 60 Where before we had 2 staff until 10pm now we have 2 staff until 7pm. That means that service users cant have an evening out of the house. It changes their psychology when they ask why cant they go out after 7. Residents are feeling they are being let down by their carers 61 Some sessions/activities have been cut, not gone ahead. Service users are having their routines changed regularly. Service users cant always do the activity of their choice. Service users are sometimes in more crowded environments as services double up or are shared. A Council day centre was shut for a few weeks in 2013 due to staff shortages 62 Having less staff makes it harder to give service users good sessions and outings. Spending less on food means the nutritional value of the food is not as good more processed and tinned food instead of fresh. 63 The two most significant ways that service users are affected is; Firstly loss of services as they/ the provision do not have sufficient money to pay for/provide a service. This leads to increased isolation, increased mental health issues and increased pressure on parent carers. I personally am continuing to support service users through mental health issues after the upset and stress of loosing services. Secondly service users are affected by the reduction in quality of services. 32
For example staff wage reductions mean the best staff are not retained, instead they are replaced with staff by staff with low motivation and lack of skills and experience. Often staff are agency staff who can change frequently. Our service users often have complex needs that need experienced, highly trained, highly motivated consistent staff to allow them to develop trust and relationships and be active, meaningful participants in society. Caring MUST be treated as a highly skilled profession rather than as a menial task that any one can do-they cant!
We asked: How have the cuts affected the staff who work in these services? Staff responses 1 Staff are just here for a wage. When most people finish work the service users are out of sight out of mind 2 By cutting the funding the day centres will close down and the staff will lose their jobs 3 Worrying about losing your job. It affects the way you perform 4 Staff morale is low. Time spent with clients, contact with other professionals is limited 5 Pay cuts, potential training 6 Staff have been affected by not having a pay increase in relation to inflation 7 Make redundant, working longer hours for some members of staff 8 Some staff will lose their jobs and other members will have to work longer hours or less hours 10 Staff have had their hours reduced or / and not had their contracts renewed. Also existing staff now have to work with less resources but still deliver a high standard of care 11 Jobs threatened. Less provision for clients 12 So far we have not had to reduce our staff wages as yet BUT having said that one of the bigger providers in the Borough has sent out a circular to reduce all their frontline support staff wages to 7.70 per hour. I understand that there is a lot of resistance to this BUT if the management get their way, then I can see a domino effect rippling throughout Haringey and we can certainly hear Commissioners heralding Well if so and so can do then you too can do it. 13 It can get frustrating and stressful 14 Staff in these projects now have reduced working hours. There has been several managers and service directors who had redundancy. Reduced working hours mean less money especially bank staff. Some permanent staff have lost contracts and moved to bank work 15 Workload increases which in turn can cause stress and increase in staff sickness. Staff cannot always give service users a good quality of service. No salary increase as the cost of living goes up. Staff can become demotivated. Low salary means that some organisations have to employ people who are not qualified for the job as qualified people will seek out a higher income. 16 No increase in salary, increased workload, demotivated staff 17 Workload increases, causes stress, no salary increase with cost of living. Leads to staff being demotivated 18 Increased workload, less income, impact on your family and social life, less income means you are demotivated 19 Staff are working under immense pressure to meet daily targets. The same amount of job tasks are expected to be completed in less hours. One staff is working with more than one client at a time. 33
20 Workload increases. No pay increase 21 Increase of workload of individual staff 22 More risk to staff specifically for those who work in mental care or work for people with challenging behaviour, especially when staffing levels are cut down. Staff have more workload leading to staff being stressed out and at worst becoming sick. This will affect the quality of work risking the well being of the service user as well as the staff. Less income for staff would mean lower quality of life affecting staff well being and health 23 We have not received any increase in our wages over the last few years and the reason always is cuts/reductions. The amount of risk and anxiety we take in looking after our service users is not valued by the local authority and feel unappreciated. Daily cost of living has gone up greatly and this is not reflected in our wages. Some experienced staff have already left for a better life, and some are considering leaving as some high st shops pay better than care home or supported living. If skilled staff continue to leave then service users will become more vulnerable 24 At the moment the wages we are getting is not enough for the hard work and risk we take. If cuts are implemented then that means the chances of having a pay rise will be reduced and also the amount of hours we work can be reduced 25 If cuts are implemented the employer has to reduce staff working hours, it affects staff wages. Sometimes we work with very difficult clients and so this job is responsible 26 It has been a very long time with no pay rise for people who work in the service 27 Obviously the reduced working hours will affect staff and clients. Clients will get less care and support. In the end staff leave the job. 28 If cuts are implemented the number of hours staff work will be reduced and that will affect staff wages, and also the pay we get does not justify the work we do, ie. some clients express very difficult behaviour. Our job satisfaction and motivation is very low as we think that we have not been paid enough for the hard work we do. 29 Increased pressure to meet deadlines. Feeling frustrated at the amount of work and responsibilities that we have as support workers and the pay we get does not do justice. And having to work with the constant reminder that there will be more and more cuts 30 Less money means less hours for the staff. The training provided will probably be affected too. Service users will be supported by insufficiently trained staff which may even put their lives at risk 31 The wages are not enough for the hard work and risk 32 Since staff may be required to work longer hours for less pay staffs ability to provide the same good quality of services will be reduced. We are presently struggling with the increase in inflation that has no commensurate increase in pay and are finding it extremely hard to meet out financial commitments to ourselves and our families. A further reduction in pay will greatly affect our ability to provide good services. As the saying goes: If you pay peanuts wages you get monkeys as workers 33 Staff will have less hours to work which will affect their pay 34 If hours are cut staff have to provide the same service in less time which is practically impossible. It means their job becomes more stressful. We have to be more rushed which creates tension in the workplace between staff and service users find it extremely hard /impossible to understand the complexity of the situation which can easily manifest as anxiety, stress or verbal/physical 34
outbursts. Staff have to work more hours to earn the same amount of money and feel exhausted and frustrated. 35 Staff will find another job 36 Staff are not satisfied and happy to do the work. Cost of living is high but compensation is not sufficient. The output, quality of care is poor, worrying for financial basics 37 It is already affecting us. We didnt get any wages increment for four years 38 It has affected our income and we are feeling frustration and deprivation. They are looking for other jobs 39 Staff are already facing problems. I have worked for this company for 6 years and not getting any salary increment 40 As support staff we go through a lot of risks every day. We feel that our wages must increase. I feel unappreciated by the local authority. The cost of living goes higher every year but our wages dont increase which is unfair. The skills we gain from this work should be appreciated by the local authority. This is not an easy job at all. 41 Support hours have been cut and we didnt get any increments for the last few years 42 The hours have been cut 43 Staff are being pressurised to work with more responsibilities and with no motivation factor leading to staff losing interest in performing tasks and start looking for other jobs. Support workers go unnoticed despite all their hard work 44 Staff shortages which leads to more pressure at work 45 This will be a big impact on the staff in finances and job security. It can make the staffs job difficult and risky 46 As a staff member our clients have complex needs and solutions to the causes of their anxiety outbursts one way of helping them is that we take time to know them and establish a good rapport. The consequence of the cuts is that we can no longer help them in the way they need to be helped which is heartbreaking. Another point is that the wages do not meet the cost of living we are struggling 47 We will be forced to look for better paying jobs. The risks of this job is not appreciated by the local authority 48 We cant give them enough support. As staff we have a lot of responsibilities 49 Lack of motivation due to poor wages. High rate of turnover 50 Skilled workers who have gained experience and mastered different approaches to cater for our clients will be forced to look for better paying and appreciated jobs 51 Staff shortage. Restricted working environment, less concentration at work 52 Increased turnover, less motivation. Staff quite reluctant to adopt new ideas as their hard work is unnoticed. Quite a depressing situation as cost of living is getting higher and staff wages remain constant 54 Staff working under immense pressure to meet daily targets 55 Staff are always working under pressure to deliver best services, however they are always ignored. Staff facing more workload on a daily basis. 56 Staff give their very best in supporting service users. There has been no pay rise for years due to funding reductions. Working with service users is not easy. The patience, risk and hard work that staff give themselves is not appreciated & rewarded. 57 Its really difficult for staff to keep the service users choices and needs fulfilled. This leads to behavioural changes in service users which makes it more difficult for staff 35
58 No of working hours are being reduced which affects staff wages 60 To be a carer means you should have the capacity to provide service users with a positive vibe and psychological support. When the hours or wages get cut the stress of everyday life kicks in. 61 Team meetings dont occur in my service. Monthly supervisions occur 6- monthly, due to not being able to leave the service, being needed in service. Health & safety is compromised staff have too many service users to work with. Some minibuses drive service users without escorts. Staff stress levels and work satisfaction have been adversely affected 62 I feel a lot less motivated and negative. Tired. 63 Staff in different care providers have had reductions in pay. This decreases moral and belittles the profession. Aside of this it is painful for staff to have to watch anyone go without services and the upset it causes them, or to watch parents struggling to get help.
Do you think that services for people with Learning Disabilities should be cut? Number of responses from staff: Yes 0 No 66
Additional comments from staff 2 These cuts will not result in any savings because staff who work with people with Learning Disabilities will end up losing their jobs. The government will end up losing more money because these people will go on benefits, they will be jobless. 3 Will it make any difference? 4 Cuts to areas within LD services will have a great impact to users, affect home, social and emotional lives 7 I feel like they no longer care about people with Learning Disabilities 8 Will my opinion really matter? People will do what they want regardless of people in a lower position 11 Do these cuts result in any real savings 12 Commissioners who speak openly about not wanting a five star service in Haringey should be hounded out of the Borough I am not sure if it is a disciplinary offence??? 13 Vulnerable people should not be targeted with cuts as support is essential to living independently 19 Lives of service users are at stake, under the amount of cuts, impacting negatively on the health and safety of service users. I am currently planning to leave this job and find something else. 21 More cuts from the government especially in the healthcare sector would mean low quality service that will have a huge impact on service users safety and well being. Less motivated staff would result in deficit of qualified support workers, carers or nurses 23 I hope the local authority takes our views seriously. I cannot see how further cuts can help improve the lives of service users and staff 24 I think that implementing cuts on vulnerable adults is not fair as they need a lot of support to live a quality life. Some service users are very dependent and they depend on us to help them on a daily basis. Implementing cuts will have a huge affect on their life. 36
25 As a result of these cuts service users will be neglected 28 It is very sad to see people with learning disabilities are in the middle of these cuts which means that people have to use services less often, which will restrict the amount of activities they do in the community 29 Its very sad that service users with learning disabilities and complex needs, seems that their needs are no longer valued and met as per their initial assessment when they started to live in their supported accommodations. I really wonder what will happen to their quality of life in the near future 30 The decisions about cuts must have been made by people who have no idea about social care. It is outrageous really to see how the most vulnerable of us will suffer (and there is no doubt that they will) because of someones cold calculations. I found this decision highly irresponsible and unfair really. Why the decision makers wont start reducing their salaries instead. If the aim is to save money why not dig in your own pockets first. 32 I believe cuts can be made in other areas of governance but not with the care of individuals. Government preaches the need to enhance human dignity a reduction in services will do just the opposite 33 Vulnerable adults desperately need the current support we provide. Without the current provisions heavy responsibility falls on the families of service users to support them with their time and finances 34 Cuts do not benefit anyone but the government and its not fair to service users or staff. Its hard enough for service users to get by as it is. If they receive less support their lives will become more difficult and our society will be worse off for it 35 The people in authority should really focus on the best interests of clients 37 Please stop doing this. It will affect the service users we cant provide good service and service users dont have a life 38 Please do not make cuts to services for learning disabled. It will make service users life more difficult 39 Please stop cutting otherwise we will face some big problem like accident, death. So please stop cutting funds 40 Further cuts will only out our clients in a tough situation and more support workers will surely leave their jobs because of the lack of appreciation and low wages 41 Will better funding it will help to give personalised support for clients and they can have a normal life 42 Improve care sector resources 43 The role of a support worker is basically about supporting people with mental health, learning disability. If support workers lose their interest in performing their job the quality of their work will be reduced. 46 The local authority are doing this as a short term solution not considering the long term. They ignore the critical stages of the individual in their LIFE LONG disability. Unfair to staff and clients 47 Making these cuts will affect the quality of our clients life as well as our lives which is truly unjust 48 In my opinion the reductions for service users are nor good for them and the people who support them 49 Request the local authority reconsider their decision otherwise less hope for staff and service users for the future 50 Building a good working relationship with clients will be impossible if this happens 51 Government and organisations should integrate to take care of these issues. The quality of services/support is getting low which will affect those who have 37
difficulty in surviving everyday life on their own 54 The life of service users is at stake. I am planning to leave the job for something else 55 The job of a support worker is very challenging as well as being underpaid. People wont be interested in working in this field 57 If cuts keep happening at this rate the standard of service users lives will be really really difficult to meet, and then we wont be able to call this a care home need to invent another name for the service provided. 59 The council shouldnt cut support hours. This job is a very challenging and responsible one 60 My feeling is that we are going back in time towards the dark ages 61 Service users are not getting the level of service they should due to lack of resources. Staff morale is low and many expect closure or privatisation over the next couple of years 62 I have seen service users regress and not get the service they need. 63 This cost cutting approach to care services continues to be incredibly short sighted with all actions focused on short term outcomes. For example reducing the amount of respite care provided may save money before this election but will in the long term increase the pressures on mental health and residential care as parent carers are pushed to breaking point thus costing more money. We need recognise that care is an area to invest in to ensure safe and stimulating services for our most vulnerable.
38
Appendix There were 3 versions of the survey questionnaire for service users, carers and staff. The survey questions to service users: (Note: the service user version of the questionnaire was adapted to make it more accessible with pictures and symbols) 1. What services do you get now? I go to a day centre I have a support worker I go to a social club I live in supported housing I live in residential care I get other services (please say what): 2. Please tell us how the services that you use help you (For example: I meet my friends, I get help to do my shopping, I get help to keep healthy.) 3. How would you feel if you did not have these services? 4. Do you get enough support now? What other services do you need that you do not have? 5. Have any services that you know about been reduced or cut? If so, please tell us how this has affected you. 6. Do you think that services for people with Learning Disabilities should be cut? Yes / No The survey questions to carers: 2. What services and support does the person who you care for get now? (day centre, support worker, social group or club, supported housing, residential care, other services) 3. Please tell us how these services help the person you care for (eg. help to socialise, to keep healthy, to learn new skills) 4. How do these services help you as a carer? 5. How would it affect you, and the person you care for, if you did not have these services? 6. Does the person you care for get enough of the right services now? If not please tell us what other services they need but do not get 7. Have any services that you know about been reduced or cut? If so please tell us how this has affected you 8. Do you think that services for people with Learning Disabilities should be cut? Yes/ No 9. Do you have any other comments
39
The survey questions to staff: 1. Are you aware of any cuts or reductions to services for adults with Learning Disabilities, either where you work or elsewhere? Please give details. 2. Please tell us about the effects of these cuts on service users 3. How have the cuts affected the staff who work in these services? 4. Do you have any other comments about this