KENSINGTON COLLEG OF BUSINESS AND UNIVERSITY OF WALES
BP Market Analyss an!
Strate"# Marketn" Re#$%%en!at$ns In t&e USA a'ter t&e G(l' $' Me)#$ Ol s*ll
Nahid Mohsen Pour 2/28/2011
Contains: 2962 words Without charts, content, references, tables
In this essay, I am performing Macro environmental analysis of ! business in the "#$, after the gulf of Me%ico oil spill, and also try to give #trategic Mar&eting recommendations to recover from the so called 'Mar&eting disaster in the "#$ mar&et( )ahid Mohsen !our 2
Table of Contents Introduction ******************************************************************************************************************************************** + $pproach ********************************************************************************************************************************************* + Importance of Mar&eting ********************************************************************************************************************* + !art I: Macro ,nvironmental $nalysis of ! business in the "#$ after the -ulf of Me%ico .il #pill ************ / !olitical $nalysis ****************************************************************************************************************************** / ,conomical $nalysis ************************************************************************************************************************* / #ocial $nalysis ********************************************************************************************************************************** 6 0echnological $nalysis ********************************************************************************************************************* 6 1egal $nalysis*********************************************************************************************************************************** 2 ,nvironmental $nalysis ******************************************************************************************************************** 2 #W.0 $nalysis ************************************************************************************************************************************* 3 #trengths ***************************************************************************************************************************************** 3 Wea&ness **************************************************************************************************************************************** 9 .!!.40")I0I,# ******************************************************************************************************************************* 9 054,$0# ****************************************************************************************************************************************** 9 !art II: #trategic mar&eting recommendations to ! to recover from Mar&eting disaster after the -ulf of Me%ico oil spill *************************************************************************************************************************************** 66 Industry $nalysis 7!orter8s 9ive 9orces: ********************************************************************************************** 66 Industry rivalry******************************************************************************************************************************* 62 argaining power of #uppliers ******************************************************************************************************* 6; argaining power of buyers *********************************************************************************************************** 6; 0hreats of new ,ntrants ***************************************************************************************************************** 6; 0hreat of substitute products********************************************************************************************************* 6+ !orter<s -eneric Competitive #trategies 7ways of competing: ************************************************************ 6+ $nsoff8s Model ************************************************************************************************************************************** 6/ Mar&eting Mi% = Mc Carthy +!s ********************************************************************************************************* 66 !roduct ****************************************************************************************************************************************** 66 !rice ********************************************************************************************************************************************** 66 !romotion ************************************************************************************************************************************* 62 !lace ********************************************************************************************************************************************** 62 Conclusion ********************************************************************************************************************************************* 62 )ahid Mohsen !our ;
ibliography ****************************************************************************************************************************************** 63 0able of 9igures ************************************************************************************************************************************* 69
)ahid Mohsen !our +
Introduction In this essay, I am going to have a loo& at the -ulf of Me%ico oil spill and how it affected ! business in the "#$* In order to have an academic approach, I have divided this report into two parts, where in part I, I will perform business Macro ,nvironmental analysis and in !art II, I will give my recommendations, based on business and management tools and models*
Approach My approach to address this problem is to loo& at the THF0RY, give FXAHPlF3, and AtAlY3F the issue* In THF0RY part, I e%plain the relevant theory or model I am applying, in the FXAHPlF3, I offer e%amples from the case study that matches to the theory and finally in AtAlY3F, I try to address the issue and analy>e the problem according to the relevant theory and model*
Importance of Marketing 7?otler !* , 2@@6: $rgues that mar&eting is the $chilles< heel of many formerly prosperous companies such ad -M, ?oda&, #ears and many other companies* 5e adds that even giant companies such as Microsoft, Intel or others, Aust can8t sit and rela%* Bac& Welch, -,8s former C,., always warned his company to 'Change or die*C 7?otler !* , 2@@6:
I thin& !, although a huge company in oil industry is not an e%ception* I can say that, constant revision of mar&eting strategies is essential for a firm to live, while in case of !, after the tragedy of -ulf of Me%ico, which has lead to financial and nonDfinancial losses to !, it is compulsory to review and update the mar&eting strategies* )ahid Mohsen !our /
Part I: Macro Environmental Analysis of BP business in the !A after the "ulf of Me#ico $il !pill
$ccording to 7?otler !* , 2@@6:, Macro environmental analysis is find out the e%ternal forces that affect a company to produce and sell, which are consisted of !olitical, ,conomical, #ocial, 0echnological, 1egal and ,nvironmental factors that affect e%ternally a business*
Political Analysis THF0RY $ccording to 7.%ford"niversity !ress, 2@@2: political factors refer to government policy such as the degree of intervention in the economy* 0his might include trading policies, lobbying, interDcountries relations, and E that can affect the business* FXAHPlF3 0he "# !resident arac& .bama has established the )ational Commission on the ! Feepwater 5ori>on .il #pill and .ffshore Frilling .n May 22, 2@6@, this can shows the very high intervention of politicians in the business* 7.il #pill Comission: ,vidence in our case is the increase of royalty rate to fund stronger government oversight of the offshore drilling, proposed by arac& .bama* 7$*Flouhy, 2@66: Due to the importance of the oil spill, Mr Obama toured the oil-hit areas several times and assured he would triple the manpower to contain and clean up the spill. (BBC,2010) AtAlY3F I can argue in here that in maAor businesses such as oil, which has a very high financial turn over, or there are many health and safety measures or environmental precautions, the political intervention will be higher* Economical Analysis THF0RY ,conomical factors that might affect a business can be world economy or national economy of the environment where the business is running* FXAHPlF3 #ome e%perts believe that this incident could be the trigger of the $merican economic collapse* ,conomy is supported fundamentally by its energy industry mar&ets producers 7I,$, 2@@+:*,nergy )ahid Mohsen !our 6
industry mar&ets will face to increasing demand s about 6@ percent, with the higher rate in fossil fuels, nuclear and replacement energy industry mar&ets having restricted comparative contribution 7I,$, 2@@+:* Fiscovering new substitute energy is growing and is replacing a percentage of total energy production* 9rom 2 percent in 2@@2 towards 6 percent in 2@;@*
AtAlY3F Critically reviewing the economical environment where ! is active in the "#$, we can see that the 2@@3 credit crunch has not affected the oil industry, especially crude oil production at all, the reason is that the demand in the mar&et is too high* I also can conclude that the crude oil is not only used as a source of energy but as a raw material for petrochemical industries such as plastic and other products* !ocial Analysis THF0RY #ocial factor may include the population growth rate, society attitude, average society age and cultural issues* FXAHPlF3 $fter the deep water hori>on disaster, and due to huge political and legal pressure by the "# government and local authorities especially in 1ouisiana, ! set up its G2@bn -ulf spill claims fund to compensate those who have been affected, without court intervention, however, many lawyers and Audges in the "#, have rolled out that this fund is not acting neutral* 7-uardian*co*u&, 2@6@:* 0his not only did not recover the bad image of !, but I believe it made ! image worse* 0he amount of environmental damages destroyed !8s brand image, thus maybe the consumers avoid ! products in the "# mar&et* Furing this decades refer to the statistic shows !eople<s consuming patterns completely are changed especially in the energy industry mar&et which is notable to a concern over the sustainability of the future*7bp*comHstatistic: AtAlY3F I can conclude the oil spill had negative impact on !8s reputation in the "#, especially in the areas that people8s lives have been directly and indirectly affected* $fter the oil spill, many people lost their Aobs, or their business declined including tourism, fishing and other industries* Technological Analysis THF0RY )ahid Mohsen !our 2
0echnology is another environmental and e%ternal force that affects a business* In case of !, as we can see on many sources of information, such as websites and newspapers, we can find out ! has the advantage of having advanced technology in deep water e%ploration of the oil* FXAHPlF3 ! has advanced technology in deep water e%plorationI they are concentrating on energy efficiency, investing in low carbon future and production of more efficient energies*
AtAlY3F $s ! has advanced technology and is also wor&ing to develop its technical &now hows, I can argue that in this regard, ! has competitive advantage over its rivals* 4eferring to the oil spill in -ulf of Me%ico, we can observe that !, finally could manage the largest oil disaster in human history* %egal Analysis THF0RY 1egal factors are those legislations that affect a business, such as employment law, anti trust law and etc* FXAHPlF3 In our case, the ! oil spill, we can observe the new legislations, forced ! to be more accountable for health and safety rules and paying compensation to those who have been affected* 7-uardian )ews and Media 1imited, 2@6@: $nother applicable rule that has affected ! is the so called oil pollution act that Budge Carl arbier, of the federal court of 1ouisiana has used to force ! in fulfilling its legal obligations* 7-uardian*co*u&, 2@6@: AtAlY3F -ulf of Me%ico oil spill has already leaded to many legal limitation of oil industry in the "# trying to ma&e ! accountable for the damages caused to the environment and society* 7-uardian*co*u&, 2@6@: We can see that the amount of accountability has increased significantly* Environmental Analysis THF0RY ,nvironment is very important and environmental activists are playing more important roles in the business* #ometimes the environmental activist can put pressure to the government and ma&e new legislations* FXAHPlF3 )ahid Mohsen !our 3
,nvironmental activists warned that the ! spill, which covers an area about the si>e of Cornwall, could turn out to be as catastrophic as the impact of the ,%%on Jalde> tan&er spill off $las&a was 26 years ago* 7-uardian*co*u&, 2@6@: AtAlY3F 0he oil spill disaster on the "# has caused many environmental activists to oppose e%ploration of oil under the sea, which might seriously affect some legislation as its conseKuences* )ew laws "#$ government, ," !ollution standards, International ,nvironment .rgani>ations, Change in consumer patterns, consumer behavior, global demands to alternative energy and discovering new energy sources could be considered as macro environmental forces on ! mar&et*
!&$T Analysis THF0RY #W.0 analysis can help managers to understand the organi>ation and its mar&et or environment, by contrasting its '#trengths( and 'Wea&nesses( with the '.pportunities( and '0hreats( in the mar&et* 7WI11I$M#, 2@@9: FXAHPlF3 !trengths ritish !etroleum is third largest energy company in the world because of its international mar&ets activities is considered as a multinational .il company 5eadKuartered in 1ondon and as a largest producer of oil and gas in the )orth of $merica* 7!: 0he company has huge mar&et impact, which gives it notable trading performance in the global energy industry* 7!: .ne of the other strengths of ! is -ood performance in International energy industry by the networ& of its subsidiaries and retail brands such as: !, $M.C., $4C., $4$1, C$#04.1, ! ,L!4,##, ! C.)),C0, ! 04$J,1, $M!M, "4M$5 C$#04.1* 7!:
AtAlY3F I can argue in here, ! can build its competitive advantage on its strengths which has already proven in the oil industry* 5aving established different brands, and a very wide distribution networ&, is one of the ?#9 6 s of !* Creating a high level loyalty by ! $M.C. as a strong oil brand*
6 D ?ey #uccess 9actor )ahid Mohsen !our 9
$dding two comments to !Ms statement: ')o harm to people( and( )o damage to the environment( $ notable increasing profit due to oil and gas energy prices* $ strong mar&eting performance more than 3o countries such as ,urope, the "#, Middle ,ast and China, etc* therefore p has a significant geographic mar&eting activities* &eakness .il spill in deep hori>on water in Me%ican -ulf, in $pril 2@6@, has made a huge financial loss to !, and has ruined the company8s reputation* I can argue that one of the very important wea&nesses of ! is improper management and safety issues* I can recommend to !, trying convert this wea&ness into strength, by better management practice* 0here has been several incidents for !, including 2@@/ 0e%as refinery e%plosion, causing 6@@ inAuries and 62 death, 2@@@ gallons of Methanol ran out in the oil field 7!rudhoe ay:, distribution of 22@@@@ -allons of crude oil In the $las&a tundra and many other similar incidents*
$PP$'T(ITIE! When we tal& about opportunities, we are in fact considering e%ternal environment, that affect a business, such as 7demographicDeconomic, natural and other macro environmental factors:* eing among the top / oils companies in the world, ! has several e%ternal opportunities, including by acKuisition in the )orth #ea area, !8s future profit by acting in the suitable boundaries area in the 4ussia region, Implement plan to achieve alternative energy methods insist of 5ydrogen, natural gas, wind and solar by 3b*"#G investment* 7!:
T)'EAT! #ame as opportunities, threats are also e%ternal elements, such as environment, legal and political issues* My research shows that one of the most e%ternal threats to ! is the pressure of environmental activist and legal pressure that will increase the cost of operation for !* "nfortunately, there are many e%ternal threats that affect !, many of them is originated from careless attention of !, that has caused damages to the environment*
AtAlY3F It is very important to find out !8s Wea&nesses 7internal analysis: and transform them into #trengths* .n the other hand, we need to find out !8s 0hreats and try to transform them into opportunities 7,%ternal analysis:* I can argue in here that one of the threats for ! has been so far, is less attention to the environment, I can recommend to ! to try to have some sort of emphasis on green products* $lso as ! has been successful in controlling the oil spill, now it can be considered as strength for !, and they can have new division for environmental protection* )ahid Mohsen !our 6@
Figure 1 SWOT
5ow toN Wea&ness #trengths 0hreats .pportuniti es )ahid Mohsen !our 66
Part II: !trategic marketing recommendations to BP to recover from Marketing disaster after the "ulf of Me#ico oil spill
In this section, I am reviewing the possible ways where ! can develop its mar&et, according to common business and management framewor&s*
Industry Analysis *Porter+s ,ive ,orces- THF0RY !orter8s five forces, is a framewor& for analysing an industry, as shown on the following diagram*
Figure 2 Porter's Five Forces 0he aim of !orter8s five forces analysis is to find out how a business can compete is a specific sector* FXAHPlF3 )ahid Mohsen !our 62
Industry rivalry .il industry is very vast, starting from e%ploration to refining and distribution, and there are many companies active in oil industry* 5owever, the number of main oil companies who can e%plore and mine oil fields is very limited* $s shown on the following diagram, the maAor oil companies are:
Figure 3Major oi !o"#anies ! Chevron Conoco !hilips 4oyal Futch #hell ! is in third place as a producer of crude oil in compare with Chevron, #hell, 0otal, Conoco* It seems Me%ican golf disaster had not effective impact on ! to refinery Crude oil* )ahid Mohsen !our 6;
Figure $ Major %as co"#anies
I can argue in here that unli&e many other industries, the rivalry in the oil industry and specifically in the oil e%ploration is too low* Bargaining po.er of !uppliers 0he suppliers for ! are countries that have oil reservoirs and oil fields* 0hey usually have a bid for their oil field e%plorations* I can argue that here the bargaining power of suppliers is too high and they can choose the contractor* Bargaining po.er of buyers 0he buyers or the crude oil, usually purchase in the oil mar&ets, and the mar&et price is determined by the demand* Threats of ne. Entrants $s the capital for oil companies is too high, and the level of technical &nowledge is too high and advanced, this has created a very high barrier for the new entrants* 0hus I can conclude there is almost no new entrants8 threat in oil industry and also for !* )ahid Mohsen !our 6+
Threat of substitute products Crude oil can8t be substituted by any other product, as it is not only the fuel but also the raw material for petrochemical industries* .ther sources of energy are bio fuel, nuclear energy, solar energy andE which at the moment aren8t cost effective*
Porter/s "eneric Competitive !trategies *.ays of competing- THF0RY !orter8s generic #trategies, try to define where the firm can compete* $s shown on the following diagram, a firm can compete on either cost or product differentiation*
I can argue in here that, there is not too much room in to compete on the price in the oil industry in two senses: Cost Fifferentiation )ahid Mohsen !our 6/
Crude oil price is determined in oil mar&ets, and this product can8t be differentiated* 9ocus 5owever, I can recommend to ! to try to focus on a specific service in the "#* $s, ! is the best company in deep water e%ploration, I would argue to ! to try to focus on deep water e%ploration*
Ansoff+s Model
Figure + ,nso--.s Mar*et /eveo#"ent Mode 0he $nsoff -rowth matri% is a tool that helps businesses decides their product and mar&et growth strategy* $nsoff8s productHmar&et growth matri% suggests that a business8 attempts to grow depend on whether it mar&ets ne( or e0isting products in ne( or e0isting "ar*ets)
)ahid Mohsen !our 66
0he output from the $nsoff productHmar&et matri% is a series of suggested growth strategies that set the direction for the business strategy* 0hese are described below: Mar*et #enetration Mar&et penetration means where the business focuses on selling e%isting products into e%isting mar&ets* In our case, it means trying to continue deep water e%ploration in the "#* ased on my analysis on previous sections, I would recommend to ! to use this as mar&eting strategy* Mar*et deveo#"ent Mar&et development means the business see&s to sell its e%isting products into new mar&ets* 0his would be trying to enter other countries mar&et* 0his, I can argue can wor& very well for !, as its competitive advantage in deep water e%ploration* Product deveo#"ent !roduct development means introducing new products into e%isting mar&ets* 0his for ! means introducing bio fuel and other products to the "# mar&et* /iversi-ication Fiversification is the name given to the growth strategy where a business mar&ets new products in new mar&ets* 0his is an inherently more ris& strategy because the business is moving into mar&ets in which it has little or no e%perience* 9or a business to adopt a diversification strategy, therefore, it must have a clear idea about what it e%pects to gain from the strategy and an honest assessment of the ris&s* 7$nsoff, ansoff<s product H mar&et matri%:
Marketing Mi# 0 Mc Carthy 1Ps
Product $lthough oil industry has vast sets of products, but the main product is the crude oil, which can8t be differentiated* In this regard, ! hasn8t any choice, e%cept planning to develop substitute products such as bio fuel* 5owever, if we consider crude oil e%ploration, I can argue there is no substitute product* Price 0he price of crude oil, as the primary product of ! and the maAor oil companies, is determined by international mar&ets and .!,C, and ! can8t play with the price* )ahid Mohsen !our 62
Promotion 5aving discussed several environmental disasters caused by !, I can argue the image of ! in the society has already changed to a company that is not environmental friendly* 5owever, as we can see on !8s website, recently they are trying to show their support toward environmental awareness* I would recommend to ! to try to have advertising campaign toward a better support of environment, and environmental awareness* Place I can argue that in terms of place, there are some limitations for oil companies, as the oil fields are limited around the world* !, and other oil companies can8t determine where to go for e%ploration, as it is a natural resource and is only available in limited number of places* Conclusion ased on the analysis I gave on !art II, I can formulate the mar&eting #trategies for ! in the "#$, as: 6D 9ocus of deep waters oil e%ploration79ocusing #trategy: 2D 0ry to have green advertising campaign 7!romotion: ;D 0ry to penetrate more into the "#$ mar&et +D 0ry to create better image 7#ocial factor:, by better approach to compensate those who have been affected* /D Continue lobbying 7!olitical factors:, or do it more efficiently* 6D Care for the environment 7,nvironmental factor:
)ahid Mohsen !our 63
Bibliography $*Flouhy, B* 72@66:* Newspaper, Hearts * $nsoff, I* 7n*d*:* ansoff's product / market matrix* 4etrieved @2 69, 2@66, from 0utur2u: http:HHtutor2u*netHbusinessHstrategyHansoffOmatri%*htm $nsoff, I* 769/2:* #trategies for Fiversification* Harvard Business Review , 66;D62+* !* 7n*d*:* BP Homepage* 4etrieved @2 6;, 2@66, from !*com: http:HHwww*bp*comHbodycopyarticle*doNcategoryIdP6QcontentIdP2@/2@// usinessFictionary*com* 72@6@:* BusinessDictionary.com* 4etrieved @6 @6, 2@6@, from usinessFictionary*com: http:HHwww*businessdictionary*comHdefinitionHenvironmentalDscanning*html ayman News !ervice* 72@6@, @6 66:* 4etrieved @6 66, 2@6@, from Cayman )ews #ervice: http:HHwww*caymannewsservice*comHaggregatorHsourcesH6NpageP; ,MI* 72@6@:* "#out $%&* 4etrieved @6 @6, 2@6@, from Music Bobs 1td: http:HHu&*musicD Aobs*comHdirectoryHemiDmusicDu&DirelandD93+922 ,MI -roup 1imited* 72@6@, May 23:* "B'() $%& %(!&* 4etrieved @/ 23, 2@6@, from ,MI: http:HHwww*emimusic*comHaboutH -uardian )ews and Media 1imited* 72@6@:* Be*ind t*e music+ an we ever measure t*e impact of down,oading- 4etrieved May 29, 2@6@, from Music log: http:HHwww*guardian*co*u&HmusicHmusicblogH2@@9HnovH62HmeasureDimpactDdownloading -uardian*co*u&* 72@6@, @2 63:* BP oi, spi,,+ fai,ed safety device on Deepwater Hori.on rig was modified in *ina* 4etrieved @2 62, 2@66, from -uardian*co*u&: http:HHwww*guardian*co*u&HenvironmentH2@6@HAulH63HdeepwaterDhori>onDblowDoutDpreventerDchina he* 7n*d*:* ?otler, !* 72@@6:* %arketing %anagement )we,ft* $dition. )ew Bersey: !earson !rentice 5all* ?otler, !* 72@@@:* %arketing %anagement, %i,,ennnium $dition. 1ondon: !rintice 5all* .il #pill Comission* 7n*d*:* 'i, !pi,, omission* 4etrieved @2 6;, 2@66, from http:HHwww*oilspillcommission*govHpageHaboutDcommission .%ford"niversity !ress* 72@@2:* /i,,espie+ 0oundations of $conomics 1 "dditiona, c*apter on Business !trategy* 4etrieved @2 6/, 2@66, from .L9.4F "niversity !ress: http:HHwww*oup*comHu&HorcHbinH923@699296;23H@6studentHadditionalHpageO62*htm !orter, M* ,* 7693@:* )ec*ni2ues for "na,y.ing &ndustries and ompetitors. )ewyor&: 0he 9ree !ress* )ahid Mohsen !our 69