Professional Documents
Culture Documents
As a citizen positioned within the expanding middle class of the United States, I
structure has, along with the convincing subliminal messages in product advertising, set
the stage for a massive trend towards a consumerist economy. We are made to believe
that capitalism supplies us with the things we require for the maintenance of our everyday
lifestyles, while all along, we are overloaded with glamorized images from the media,
enticing us to buy largely useless products that suddenly seem to become a part of our
basic “needs.” With the increase of political activism in the realms of social and,
Through the accumulation of products available for mass consumption, the individual
consumer can present him or herself in whatever way is most desirable. This can
members of the work force through the display of shiny, expensive products, we can
create the illusion that we are acting as model citizens, regardless of our actual
2
gluttonous leisure, with disregard for our responsibilities towards our greater society and
environmental health.
Construction of Consumption
The term “consumption” was first given real meaning with the introduction of
financial well-being for the sovereign (Wyrwa 432). Following the publishing of Adam
Smith’s The Wealth of Nations in 1776, consumption began to take on a more citizen-
based role within society, where “…‘consumption’ is defined as the actual purpose and
goal of production” (Wyrwa 434). In this way, the individual citizen can participate in
their capitalist economy through the physical act of consumption. In 1857, Franz
Vorländer introduced the idea of personal need as the driving force behind consumption
(Wyrwa 435). This maintenance of needs is what appeared to drive the cyclical economy
of production and consumption that pervades throughout much of the world today. By
consumers appear to shape the process of economic production. With the introduction of
wealth of products that help to present an idealized image of the active citizen participant.
Because of this, the social stratification that is inherent within capitalist economies is
literally visually enhanced, creating a consumerist society obsessed with the purchase of
items for luxury and comfort—a new system of needs. The mass consumption incited by
this want-based system constructs a false belief that the consumer has personal freedom
have in a system that controls the amount and very nature of the products that we
3
consume? While consumption is now seen as a natural craving, I find it hard to
completely refute the idea that mass consumption is driven by idealized manifestations of
the citizen presented by the capitalist producer. Although consumption is now seen
simply the model citizen that the economic society wishes us to portray (Wyrwa 446)?
While we may choose simply to portray ourselves as the idyllic citizen through
our consumptive choices, there are many individual opportunities for actual active
citizenship. The notion of public virtue, for example, is inseparable from the idea of a
good citizen. As members of society, we have a public duty to uphold the rights of all
citizens, regardless of class, race, and sex— at least in theory—and to make individual
and public decisions according to what is morally correct and most beneficial for our
country as a whole. We also have an obligation to maintain the health of our society,
nationalist identity to the rest of the world. So how do we reconcile our roles as both the
poster children for our intensely-consumerist society and the model citizens working
towards the advancement, and most importantly, the continuation of a healthy nation and
national identity?
Consumption and citizenship are clearly deeply intertwined within our social
system, but before I discuss current models of the relationship between the two, I would
4
problematize this unique relationship. The destruction of state socialist ideology
following the Cold War created an influx of new representations of identity in Eastern
Europe, inspired by fresh notions of masculinity and femininity. Pre-Cold War, the ideal
sacrifices for the good of society. A veritable “Superwoman” who had perfected her role
as “exemplary worker, model mother, and socially committed citizen,” the everyday
woman could rarely, if ever, uphold this ideal of femininity, domesticity, and socially
society introduced a much sought after notion of individual choice and self-representation
that many women had never experienced before. Through this apparent choice, however,
the media prescribed over-sexualized representations for the ideal woman as citizen and
consumer, perhaps creating a system of greater gender stratification, which was then
maintained through the illusion of individual choice to represent the self. Glamorized
images of both the ideal masculine and feminine selves pervade throughout the media,
giving us the false illusion of self-expression, while we continuously prescribe to the self
that we are supposed to be, as fitting the norms of the ideal consumer and citizen. This
display of hyper-masculinity and hyper-femininity seems to only serve as a ploy for the
economic producers to create differing markets for more widespread and specialized
inspired by model images of the perfect citizen, helping us to, indeed, become an ideal
citizen in any form or fashion, or are we simply striving to appear that way? Perhaps the
problem is that we view citizenship as a set of rights that we all inherently have, rather
5
than a responsibility that we have for upholding the ideals of society. Consumption,
therefore, becomes a right to personal expression, rather than a responsibility for the
Despite the increasingly more seductive life as the glamorous and comfortable
consumer, there are individuals who strive to perform the dual function of citizen and
consumer in their everyday lives. The simplest way to act as both citizen and consumer,
is to consume with some kind of agency. By making smart choices about products,
specifically for political reasons, the consumer takes back the responsibility for their own
characteristics of the model citizen (Micheletti 17). This citizen-consumer must employ
their knowledge of the market and products, which can lead to greater agency in the
performance of self as active citizen. Especially for women, this type of citizen-
consumption allows for a greater participation in the public sphere, whether or not the
consumer agency goes any further than a regular trip to the supermarket.
political life. We can also, however, take it one step further and make economic
sacrifices for the purpose of purchasing more ethically produced goods. This consumer-
citizen relationship is more visible in the political economy, especially when the citizen is
really dedicated to and vocal about a specific cause, such as fair trade coffee or
organically grown foods. Consumers can also make a difference in the public sphere by
acting according to “private virtue.” Shoppers who make decisions for the advancement
of their own self-interest are more likely to be active citizen-consumers, as their personal
6
concerns may be shared with others. This creates a community that is very outspoken
about their views on the consumption of certain products, however, they are not acting
with self-sacrifice for the larger community, as a model citizen might. Regardless of the
reason for this kind of consumption, the communities created can thereby strengthen the
performance that the everyday individual displays as consumer and ideal active citizen in
and Germany, we may see how policies and capitalist infrastructure serve to create
“information model” is used, based on the notion of consumer protection. Higher quality
product standards are upheld, there are regulations for accurate product labeling and
the product at hand. Because of this, the consumer is given the agency to seek out
information about the product, to enhance protection against product failure (Trumbull
163). In economies such as France (and the United States), a model of protection is
relied upon instead, where product failure is the moral and legal responsibility of the
producer. Consumers in this case appear to have much less agency, as they approach all
products as if they are of the same quality, creating a consumer society that favors low
prices (Trumbull 164). Quality is therefore favored in the information model, while
innovation is favored in the protection model. In the United States specifically, the lack
of agency consumers have for finding out accurate product information allows for an
influx of new and innovative product ideas at any time, flooding the market with
7
thousands of comfort and luxury-based products that seem to enhance our role as only a
consumer within society. In both of these models, the consumer is protected through
policy in some way, whether it is against the risk of product failure in the protectionist
model or against the risk of low quality products in the informational model. However,
citizens today, specifically the public concerns about the environment and natural
Consumer Responsibility
consumer and citizen is sticky at best, and it appears that we must in the future, especially
however, is difficult at best, and concerns a major shift in the thinking of citizens as
models for responsible consumption. The first, committed consumption, is based on the
idea that consumers make choices concerning the impact their purchases will have on the
society (Dietrich 3). The second model, critical consumption, portrays the consumer as
refusing to be passive in their consumer choices, while instead taking on major ethical
responsibility according to the products that they choose. Students at Grinnell College,
for example, have attempted to perform this type of consumption by petitioning against
8
the Coca-Cola Company, which has sketchy moral responsibilities. This type of
organizations that take on the specific ethical causes of the individual (Dietrich 5).
The third type of responsible consumption, and the most important one for the
development, which “meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of
future generations to meet their own needs,” sustainable consumption strives to provide
for basic consumer needs while preserving natural resources and reducing impact on the
citizen as consumer the greatest amount of individual agency and positive impact for the
greater good of the society today and in the future. It is indeed, the citizen acting as
responsible consumer, rather than the consumer presenting him or herself as the
responsible citizen. Along with this necessary shift in consumer attitudes and actions,
formal policy and legislation changes must also be put into effect in order to move
towards a more sustainable society. Legislation and production can, for example, be
rearranged to match more closely with the heightening attitudes of ethical responsibility
consumption, while only three percent of the market products for consumption were in
line with sustainable living standards (Berglund & Matti 553). So as consumers that
make choices according to personal preference and economic incentives, and as citizens
that make choices based on a larger scale for the greater good of the community, how do
9
Revising Conceptions of Citizen and Consumer
It seems that sustainable living will only become a possibility if we reform our
on the role of citizen as primary to our identity, we can then adopt the secondary role of
concerns as ethical individuals will be a natural part of our consumer lifestyle, informing
our personal as well as collective decisions in our private and public spheres of life. A
towards a collective for the common welfare of both the individual and the whole. This
through a study by the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency that ascertained that,
“private consumption is one of the two single largest causes of a continuous negative
impact on the global environment” (Berglund 559). To avoid more damage to our
environment and to hopefully reverse some of the damaging effects our consumer-based
style of living has already reaped upon the environment, we must find a way to revise
One of the first major revisions needs to take place in respect to our notions of
comfort and luxury. Heating and cooling systems all around the world, for example,
normalized temperature all year round, we have rid ourselves of certain social
conventions that would have been less stressful on the environment, such as wearing
more or less clothing depending on the weather. It is necessary, then, to revise our way
of thinking about consumption for the purposes of pure personal comfort or for the
10
performance as an idealized citizen. The idea is not to reduce the amount of
consumption, per say, but the ways in which we consume. As citizens, then, we need to
remain aware of our personal commitment to the environment at all times, allowing these
responsibilities to pervade throughout our many roles in life, not just that of the citizen.
an entire restructuring of our social society may be necessary for a move towards
sustainable living. Our on-the-go lifestyles turn us into consumers that make purchasing
decisions for convenience and ease. Ideally, we could revise this way of thinking,
slowing down the pace of everyday life, adding a siesta to the workday, and reinstating
the concept of the home-cooked family meal, however, this change may be an extremely
difficult one to make. So now, the challenge is how to allocate the time and how to
reform the attitudes needed for a viable and more sustainable way of life.
sustainable living. The production of fair trade products, for example, takes into account
the entire production process, showing greater concern for the environment and the
workers involved in the production. Fair trade products also align themselves with labor
and environmental standards, allowing for a citizen and value-based social contract
between producer and consumer (Dietrich 8). Also, the introduction of a sustainable
tourism industry based on social responsibility is necessary to meet “the present needs of
tourists, the tourist industry and the receiving community without jeopardizing the
capacity of future generations to meet their needs” (Dietrich 9). This is especially
11
important in developing countries where tourism is their leading industry, because a non-
sustainable tourism can badly damage the unique environmental resources of these
A Promising Trend
Prior to mass consumption, a consumers’ basic needs put little strain on the
environment. Following industrialization, and specifically, after World War II, modern
amenities for comfort were introduced and mass produced, leading to a consumerist
industrial pollution and production of household waste” (Dietrich 11). Now that we are
dealing with such catastrophes as global warming and the depletion of our natural
resources, the need for a society of sustainability is becoming a real possibility. World
wide we can see examples of sustainable living emerging from beneath the multitudes of
growing by more than twenty percent every year, easily attainable and recognized by
citizen-consumers because of seals of organic approval that are attached to such products
(Dietrich 13). This allows the consumer the agency to make an informed decision about
the products they are buying. Similarly, consumers everywhere are making social
more than “two thirds of consumers are ready to alter their consumption habits on the
basis of ethical criteria” (Dietrich 15). It appears that with the encroaching pressures of
12
natural resource depletion and general environmental destruction, consumers are readily
reforming into socially responsible citizen-consumers, applying their ethical codes to not
only their personal lives, but to their lives as citizens in the public sphere as well.
The role of the consumer is to maintain the growth of the economic market, but I
believe that it is, perhaps more importantly, a process by which we, as consumers and
luxury items (even imitation luxury items), the everyday middle-class consumer can
process. This enhanced performance of self has become so effective in portraying the
“good citizen” ideal that consumers don’t even have to try to actually be good model
citizens. The deep rift between social strata in capitalistic economies must be reconciled
to solve this problem of self-presentation. Perhaps if the fashion industry were to rethink
their ideas of seasonal trends, we may have less constant competition among consumers
to attain the idealized image of the citizen. In addition, we may be able to take some cues
from the German informational economic model, where innovation is less extolled, so
reliable and high quality products are readily available, with little need for the constant
I believe that sustainable living could definitely be a positive and viable view for
the future of our society. However, the citizen-consumer, as both an individual and a part
of the national collective, needs to reevaluate what kind of social responsibility needs to
take place on a regular base. A commitment needs to be made to ensure that we live our
lives, for the good of ourselves and for others, in a more renewable and sustainable way.
13
Not that reformation of a solidified and collective ideal throughout society will be simple
in any way. It will indeed take a large amount of personal and social responsibility, but a
little altruism never hurt anyone. Our environment will no doubt demand a more
sustainable economic system from us eventually, and with the proper education and the
References
Berglund, Christer & Simon Matti. 2006. “Citizen and Consumer: the Dual Role of
Individuals in Environmental Policy.” Environmental Politics. 15(4): 550-571.
14
Council of Europe, Strasbourg.
Shove, Elizabeth. 2004. “Changing human behaviour and lifestyle: A challenge for
sustainable consumption?” The Ecological Economics of Consumption.
Wyrwa, Ulrich. 1998. “Consumption and Consumer Society.” Getting and Spending.
Cambridge University Press.
15