Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RogerThompson
WesternAustralianSchoolofMines CurtinUniversity
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
AimofPresentation
GSFM fourcomponentsof mineroaddesign GSFMandrollingresistance interactions Whatdoesroaddesignand constructioninvolve?
Geometric Structural Functional Maintenance.Design components
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Introduction
Poorroaddesignimpacts safety,trafficmanagement,& costpertonne hauled. Ideally,SHMS/SOP specificationsshouldincludea formalapproachtoroaddesign. Butwhatshoulddesign considerand;
Howisitspecified? Howisconformance monitored?
Engineering &Mining Journal, vol 210,n5 June 2009. Mining Media Ltd.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
RollingResistance
Primarymeasureofmine roadperformance isoften basedonrollingresistance
Frequentlythebasisofa costbenefitevaluation, but whatisrollingresistance andhowisitgenerated?
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
RollingResistance
Rollingresistanceisthe resistancetotruckmotion duemostlyto:
Roaddeformationunder thetyre, Tyre penetrationintothe road, Tyre deformationeffects ontheroadsurface.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Roaddeformationundertyre pressure
Tyre penetrationintotheroadsurface
Tyre deformationeffectsontheroadsurface
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
RollingResistance
RR %
RR%
Totalresistance%=RR% GR%
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplication
Ramps
1%RR 10%KPH
Surfaceroads
1%RR 26%KPH
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplication
RR %
Ramps
Percent reduction in speed per 1% RR increase (%)
Effect of rolling resistance on truck speed Base case rolling resistance (RR) = 2%
1%RR
10%KPH
25 20 15 10 5 0 0 1 2 3 4
Liebherr T282B 4.32kW(net)/tonne GVM 50/80R63 Tyres and 37.33:1 Drive ratio
Empty truck (EVM = 229 tonnes) Full truck (GVM = 592 tonnes)
GR%
Surfaceroads
1%RR 26%KPH
Performance Chart
7
ad
Grade (%) of ro
20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 1
Effective Grade (%)
9 10 11 12
Rimpull (kN)
Speed (km/h)
Effective grade (UPHILL) % = Grade % + rolling resistance% Effective grade (DOWNHILL)% = Grade % rolling resistance%
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
HaulRoadDesign
Howdowedeveloparoad designwhich;
Maximises safety Maximises utilityof environment(materialsand equipment),and Minimises rollingresistance andtotalroaduserscosts?
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
HaulRoadDesign
Fromasafetyperspective;
Geometricdesign Excessiveshearforcesand truckinstability. StructuralDesign Damage totyre andchassis,truck instability,missalignment. FunctionalDesign wet slipperiness,tractionand skidresistance,dust. MaintenanceDesign runningsurface.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
HaulRoadDesign
Fromarollingresistance perspective,minimise;
deformationundertyre StructuralDesign penetrationandtyre deformation Functional Design roaddeteriorationrate MaintenanceDesign
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
ImprovingMineHaulRoads
Unsprung mass acceleration due to two 100mm road defects 374t GVM RDT
15 Acceleration (m/s 2) 10 5 0 -5 -10 -15 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 Arbitrary time (s)
Measured truck response Actual road defect
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
ImprovingMineHaulRoads
First,youneedtoknowwhat iswrongbeforeyoucan decidedtofixit. Realtimemonitoringcanbe usedtorecordthetruckand tyreresponsetotheroad, andwhenlinkedwithGPS, givesthefirstindicationof WHEREandWHATthehaul roadproblemsare.
2 6 2 0 00 0 . 00
Truck path
start Defect 0.05 to 0.10m
0 0 0. 00
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
ImprovingMineHaulRoads
Thecureisnotnecessarily justmorefrequent maintenance. Noamountofmaintenance willfixapoorlydesigned road.Eachcomponentofthe roadinfrastructuremustbe correctlyaddressedatthe designstage.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
ImprovingMineHaulRoads
Investigatetherootcauseof theunder performance before decidingona remediationstrategy. Followanintegrated approachtoroaddesign, examineeachdesign component.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
IntegratedRoadHaulDesign
BASIC HAUL ROAD DESIGN DATA GEOMETRIC DESIGN GUIDELINES STRUCTURAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
GeometricDesign
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IntegratedHaulRoadDesign
BASIC HAUL ROAD DESIGN DATA GEOMETRIC DESIGN GUIDELINES STRUCTURAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
StructuralDesign
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IntegratedRoadHaulDesign
BASIC HAUL ROAD DESIGN DATA GEOMETRIC DESIGN GUIDELINES STRUCTURAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
FunctionalDesign
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IntegratedHaulRoadDesign
BASIC HAUL ROAD DESIGN DATA GEOMETRIC DESIGN GUIDELINES STRUCTURAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
Costs
Max Min
Min Max
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesign
Geometricdesign;
Determinestheroadlayout oralignment,both horizontallyandvertically. Practically,weoftenneed tocompromisebetweenan ideallayoutandwhatmine geometryandhauling economicswillallow.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Optimise truck performance against route grades and speeds and construction costs.
Assess junction and intersection layouts and associated safety components. Check drainage requirements with topographic contours in vicinity of route.
Survey and peg the route centre lines. Test soil properties for Structural Design phase
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignVertical Alignment
Alignmentoftheroadin;
Thevertical plane here wedesignforsafeand efficient;
Stoppingandsight distances(howreliably canwedeterminethese values??), Optimumrampgradients andverticalcurve transitions.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignVertical Alignment
Stoppingdistances;
Truckmanufacturersand sitetestingshouldconfirm thedistancesrequiredto bringatrucktoastop undervariousconditionsof load(NBempty),speed, gradeandtraction wet, dry,wearingcourse(s).
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignVertical Alignment
Sightdistances;precautions shouldbeappliedwhensight distancefallsbelowstopping distance;
Benchedgeobstructionsrequire laybacksorbatter, Verticalcurves crestsoften requireflatteningtoimprove sightdistances, Useaminimumverticalcurve lengthof150mandradiusof 1500mfordesignwork. Applyspeedlimits.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignVertical Alignment
Sightdistancesandmachine factors; Inadditiontosightdistances alsoconsiderdriverblind spots wherethedriverhas limitedornosightofpartsof theroad.
Final Report Blind Area Study Large Mining Equipment, Contract Report 200-2005-M-12695, CDC/NIOSH, USA, 2006.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignHorizontal Alignment
Alignmentoftheroadinthe horizontalplane herewe designforsafeandefficient;
Roadwidth, Curvatureandsuper elevations, Crownorcrossfall.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignHorizontalAlignment
Ramp 5 RampW W5
Ramp Ramp W3 W3
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
m 50
50 m
Ramp RampW W4 4
GeometricDesignHorizontalAlignment
Ramp 1 (W) Ramp W W1 (W) Ramp Ramp W1 W 1 (E) (E)
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
50m
50m
GeometricDesignHorizontal Alignment
Widthofroad;
Sufficientfortherequired numberoflanes (pavementwidth),and shoulders(carriageway width)andallthe associatedsafetyand drainagefeatures (formationwidth). 3.5W why?Effectof largervehicles.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignHorizontalAlignment
Thewidestvehicles proposeddeterminethe pavementwidth. TheTablesummarizesthese designroadwaywidths.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignHorizontal Alignment
Curvesandswitchbacks;
Designedwiththe maximumradiuspossible andbekeptsmoothand consistent. Changesincurveradii (compoundcurves)should beavoided.Alargercurve radiusallowsahighersafe roadspeedandincreased truckstability >200m minimumradiusideal.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignHorizontalAlignment
Superelevation;
Bankingappliedonthe outsideofacurvetoallow thetrucktomaintain stabilityinthecurveat speed. Shouldnotexceed5%7%, unlesshighspeedhaulageis maintainedandthe possibilityofsliding minimizedbyusingmedian berms tosplitsuper elevations.ReferTable.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignHorizontal Alignment
Crossfall(usewithextreme caution),crownorcamber;
Critical tothedesignand successfuloperationof mineroads. Ensureswaterdoesnot gatheronandpenetrate intotheroadsurface.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesignHorizontal Alignment
Crossslopeshouldbeused withcaution,possibilityof collisionincreasesorrunoff benchedge. Largedeflectionberms shouldbeplacedattheroad centerandedge. Crossslopeeasierto maintain.
Camber (crown) example Center-line 2-3% 2-3% Drain Cross-slope example Drain
2-3%
Drain
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesign
Safetyberms;
A'crest'orroadedgeberm willnoteffectivelystop trucks(especiallyhigh speedladenorunladen trucks)fromleavingthe road. Atbest,theywillprovide limiteddeflectionand warningtothedriverthat thetruckpathneeds correcting.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesign
Berm slopeshouldbeassteep aspossible(1.5V:1Hideally), butensurestabilityand maintenanceofheight. Forlargehaultrucks,theberm heightshouldbeatleast50% 66%ofthetruckwheel diameter. Steepberm sideaidsdeflection. Flatterberms allowthetruckto climb andoverturn. Medianberms considertraffic managementimplications.
Section A-A Outslope Conventional berm
Median berm
Bench face
Conventional berm
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
GeometricDesign
Alsoincludedinthe geometricdesignisdrainage;
Nomatterhowgoodthe design,waterwillalways damageamineroad. Keep waterOFFtheroads orat theveryleastleadwater offtheroadassoonas possible. Investigategeometry AND localtopographicdrainage patterns.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IntegratedHaulRoadDesign
BASIC HAUL ROAD DESIGN DATA GEOMETRIC DESIGN GUIDELINES STRUCTURAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
StructuralDesign
Structuraldesignrefersto theloadcarryingcapacityof theroad; Betterpavementresponse toappliedloads, Reduceddeflectionon surface,betterwearing courseperformance Eliminatedeformationin subgradeorinsitu.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
StructuralDesign
Twoapproaches;
Mechanisticdesign approachusingpavement layerlimitingverticalstrain criteria& CBRcovercurveapproach usingpavementlayerCBR values.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
StructuralDesign Mechanistic
Mechanisticdesignapproach usingpavementlayer limitingverticalstrain criteria;
Limitingstraincriteria tailoredtotrafficvolumes, typeandlifeofmineroad (ramp,pitormainhaul).
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
StructuralDesign Mechanistic
Wearing course
The strains resulting from the truck wheel loads decrease with depth except where these strain fields overlap. Here, higher strains are found and if more than 2000 microstrains the in-situ material is liable to collapse leading to structural failure.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
StructuralDesign Mechanistic
Haul Road Category
Limiting microstrains Limiting pavement layer vertical compressive strain values for mine haul road structural design 10000
CategoryI Permanentlifeofmine highvolumemainhauling roadsandrampsin and expit.Operatinglife>20 years CategoryII Semipermanenthigh volumeramproadsinpit. Operatinglife>10years CategoryIII Semipermanentmedium tolowvolumeinpitbench access,expitdump,or ramproads.Operatinglife <5years(>50kt/day)or<10 years(<50kt/day)
1000
100 0 40 80 120 160 200 240 280 320 Traffic volume (kt/day) x performance index
Maximum permissible vertical strains can also be determined from (kt/day x performance index). Where performance index is defined as; 1 Adequate but fairly maintenance intensive, 2 Good with normal maintenance interventions, 3 Outstanding with low maintenance requirements .
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
StructuralDesign Mechanistic
Whenabaselayerofselected blastedwasterockisusedin thestructure,amechanistic approachismoreappropriate. Theselectedwasterocklayeris locatedunderthewearing course,
Roadperformanceis significantlyimproved, primarilyduetotheload carryingcapacityofthe wasterocklayer.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplication Mechanistic
Thickness (mm)
Designchart(examples)are basedonafullyladenhaul truck,atmaximumGVM,(tons) withstandardradialtyres, inflatedto800kPa. Theroaddesignincorporates 200mmofsheetingwith CBR=80%,aselectedblasted wasterockbaselayer,builton 3mofinsitumaterialwiththe indicatedEmodulusshownon thecharts.
100
1000
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Thickness (mm)
Wearingcourse 200mm E= 350MPa Base layer thickness E= 3000MPa Insitu Thickness 3000mm
100
1000
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
StructuralDesign CBRCoverCurve
CBRcovercurvedesign approachusespavement layerCBRvalues;
Thicknessofsuccessive layersbasedonCBR (strength)ofunderlying layerandtruckwheelload (tonnes).
CaliforniaBearingRatioCBR (%)
1 10 100
55
CoverThickness(mm) 40 25
0.0
15
500.0 1000.0
Truck Truckwheel GVM(t)load(t) 1500.0 9015 150 25 240 40 320 55 390 65 450 75 510 85 570 95 630 105
CBR (%)
Modulus (Eeff)(MPa) . 10
1
21 .
2
28
3
35
4
41
6
55
8 . 10
69
20
138
40 60 80 100
207 276 345 . 414
14
104
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Wearing course CBR 80% Base CBR 55% Sub-base CBR 30% Compacted In-situ CBR 13%
In-situ CBR 7%
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IntegratedRoadHaulDesign
BASIC HAUL ROAD DESIGN DATA GEOMETRIC DESIGN GUIDELINES STRUCTURAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
FunctionalDesign
Wearingcoursematerial selection.Designfor;
Improvedtraction,skid resistance,reduceddust, Reducedrollingresistance throughreducedwearing coursedefects, Reduceddeterioration ratesandmaintenance frequency.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
FunctionalDesign
Thisisprobablyagoodmixof crushedrocktouse,everything smallerthan40mminsizeand nottoomuchfinematerial (<20%smallerthan2mm). Watchoutforsmoothround alluvialaggregateinthemix.
Thiswillnoteasilyinterlock andwillraveloutofthe wearingcourse.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
FunctionalDesign
Asmalljawcrushercanbeused toprepareblastedrockasa wearingcourseaggregate, ofteninamixofoneormore othermaterialstoformthe finalproduct. Itisalsousefulforcreatinga fineaggregatefromwasterock tobeplacedasadressingin loadingareas toreducetyre damageintheseareas.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
FunctionalDesign
Shrinkage Product .
Correctwearingcourse materialselectionwill;
Reduceroadrolling resistance through reducedwearingcourse defects & Reduceroaddeterioration ratesandmaintenance frequency.
Corrugates
Loose material
Recommended (1)
Recommended (2)
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
FunctionalDesign
Wearing Course Selection
400 Shrinkage Product . 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Grading Coefficient
Loose stones Tyre damage Dustiness Slippery w hen w et
Corrugates
Loose material
Recommended (1)
Recommended (2)
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplication
550 500 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 0
S h r in k a g e p ro d u c t
Dustiness
Loose stoniness
10
2 1
Corrugations
20 30
Grading coefficient
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplication
550
. S h r in k a g e p ro d u c t
Grading coefficient
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
DustPalliatives
Dustiscausedthroughloss offines,soconsider specifically;
Wearingcoursematerial selection;
Sizedistribution,clay content, Restraintoffines,
Trafficvolumes, Climaticconditions.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
DustPalliatives
Allsuppressionsystemsaim tominimise erosivity ofthe wearingcourse.Options include;
Improvedwearingcourse material, Regularwatering, Useofchemical suppressants.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
DustPalliatives
Chemicalpalliativesavailable include;
Water/wettingagents, Hygroscopicsalts, Lignosulphonates, Modifiedwaxes, Polymers, Tar/bitumenproducts, Sulphonated oils, Enzymes.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
DustPalliatives
Useofchemicaldust suppressants;
Shouldbeconsideredonlyas anadjuncttoother methods, Chemicaldustsuppressants havealimitedlifeandwill requireregularapplications, Variousgenerictypesto choosefrom,basedmainly onclimaticconditionsand wearingsurfacematerial.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
DustPalliatives
Trialachemicaldust suppressantfirstbefore makingafirm commitment, Carefulattentionshouldbe giventowholeoflife costingbeforeusinga chemicaldustsuppressant.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
DustPalliatives
Locality Data
Road, Climate, Wearing course parameters Hours per day of dust control required
Equipment Data
Productivity and operating costs of road (re)-construction, maintenance and (spraying) equipment
Palliative Data
Cost ($/litre) and application rates (establishment and rejuvenation)
Water Data
Cost ($/kilo-liter) and application rates (l/m 2)
Determine Wearing Course Maintenance Interval and Cost with Palliative Applied
Determine Wearing Course Maintenance Interval and Cost with Water-based Spraying
Method selection
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Locality Data
Road, Climate, Wearing course parameters Hours per day of dust control required
Equipment Data
Productivity and operating costs of road (re)-construction, maintenance and (spraying) equipment
Palliative Data
Cost ($/litre) and application rates (establishment and rejuvenation)
Water Data
Cost ($/kilo-liter) and application rates (l/m 2)
Determine Wearing Course Maintenance Interval and Cost with Palliative Applied
Determine Wearing Course Maintenance Interval and Cost with Water-based Spraying
Method selection
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IntegratedHaulRoadDesign
BASIC HAUL ROAD DESIGN DATA GEOMETRIC DESIGN GUIDELINES STRUCTURAL DESIGN GUIDELINES
AND
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
IS PERFORMANCE OPTIMUM
MaintenanceManagement
Maintenancedesignand management;
Routineroadmaintenance asaresultofprogressive wearingcourse deterioration.
Asatisfactoryroaddesign willrequireminimum maintenance. Toofrequent maintenance?Review designdatatofindrootof problem.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
MaintenanceManagement
Costs
Costs
Max Min
Min Max
Max Min
Min Max
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
MaintenanceManagement
Percentage increase in total road-user costs with maintenance interval
40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Days between maintenance B02 B05 B03 S Ramp B04 Percent change
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplications
Whyisthesegment maintenanceintensive?
Poordesignand/orbuild specs;
Geometrics, Structure(layerworks andmaterials), Functional(wearing course surfacing materials).
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
BenchmarkingRolling Resistance
Roadperformance evaluation,
Usedefectdegreeand extenttodetermineRR%.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Defect extent
Not seen or isolated only Intermittent Regular Frequent Extensive
Extent score
1 2 3 4 5
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplication
Defect Degree Extent Degree (1-5) (1-5) x Extent 5 3 3 5 5 1 3 5 2 2 Total score 5 9 15 10 10 49
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
PracticalApplication
3,25%
49
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Resources
Formoreinformationonissuedraisedtoday; http://mining.curtin.edu.au/people clickonRJTfor furtherlinkstohaulroadpublications www.edumine.com searchforhaulroaddesignand construction Uni BritishColumbiaandABET/ISO/IACET accreditedselfstudycourse. www.smartmines.com/mhroad/guidelines.pdf haul roaddesignguidelines(2000)forOilSandsMines (AlbertaCanada).
www.mining.curtin.edu.au
Resources
www.cdc.gov/niosh/mining/pubs searchfor IC8758.pdf 1977USBMhaulroaddesignguidelines www.mhsa.gov/readroom/handbook searchforph99I 4.pdfdesignandauditguidelinesformineroads SMEMiningEngineering www.smenet.org Handbook,ThirdEdition,2011,Ch10MineHaulRoads
Copyofpresentationandfullsupportingnotesavailable throughDEEDIMinesSafetyandHealthwebsite.
www.mining.curtin.edu.au