You are on page 1of 23

BOAZ UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

Prof. Dr. Semih Tezcan Fatih ardak

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

BOAZ UNIVERSITY DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING

OUTLINE Introduction Lean Production Lean Construction Techniques and Tools Lean Construction Comparison of Traditional and Lean Approaches Case Study Conclusion

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Introduction

The chronic problems of construction are well-known:

1. 2. 3. 4.

low productivity, poor safety, inferior working conditions, insufficient quality.

A number of solutions or visions have been offered to relieve these problems in construction.

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

What is Lean Production ?


Lean production was developed by Toyota led by Engineer Ohno. Lean production looks at reducing all forms of waste throughout the production process. Lean production is a Japanese approach to management that focuses on cutting out waste, whilst ensuring quality. The conception of the new production philosophy evolved through three stages:

1. 2. 3.
16/03/2012

It was viewed as a tool (like kanban and quality circles), as a manufacturing method (like JIT) and as a general management philosophy (like lean production).
CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Lean Production Concepts

1) Identify and deliver value to the customer value: eliminate anything that does not add value. 2) Organize production as a continuous flow. 3) Perfect the product and create reliable flow through stopping the line, pulling inventory, and distributing information and decision making. 4) Pursue perfection: Deliver on order a product meeting customer requirements with nothing in inventory.

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Lean Construction
Starting Point ? The lean production philosophy that had contributed to the manufacturing industry took the attention of the people in the construction industry as well. Especially, since the early 1990s , a lean construction concept has been tried to be created and promoted by means of institutes, governmental reports, construction management scholars, some occupational organizations and so on. Lean construction accepts the Ohnos production system design criteria as a standard of perfection.

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Definition of Lean Construction


The Lean Construction Institute (2004) defines the term lean construction as: Lean Construction is a production management-based approach to project delivery - a new way to design and build capital facilities. Lean production management has caused a revolution in manufacturing design, supply and assembly. Applied to construction, Lean changes the way work is done throughout the delivery process. Lean Construction extends from the objectives of a lean production system - maximize value and minimize waste to specific techniques and applies them in a new project delivery process.

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Waste in Construction
In general, waste is defined as the loss of those activities which, while they produce a cost, whether direct or indirect, do not add value or help in advancing a project.

Toyota defines waste as: Anything that is different from the minimum quantity of equipment, material, parts and labor time that is absolutely essential for production. The elimination of waste is a core focus of lean construction.

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

7 Forms of Waste

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Techniques and Tools of Lean Construction


Lean construction is to move beyond the traditional view of project management as transformation, to include flow and value generation. Paez (2005) classified the operative techniques utilized in lean construction through three levels. 1. Level One: Direct application of the techniques from lean manufacturing. 2. Level Two: Modification of the techniques taken from lean manufacturing. 3. Level Three: The all-in-all lean construction specific techniques.

Although these techniques can be applied separately, their complementary nature proposes that a combined utilization of techniques will increase leanness of a construction organization.

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

10

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Techniques and Tools of Lean Construction

Classification of Operative Techniques and Goals


16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
11

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Comparison of Traditional and Lean Project Delivery Systems


The phrase project delivery system has traditionally been used to indicate the contractual structure of the project, e.g., design-bid-build or design-build. Delivery involves designing and making capital facilities -buildings, bridges, factories, and so on.

Traditional construction projects are managed today by breaking them into pieces or activities, estimating the time and money to complete each, applying the critical-path method (CPM) to identify a logical order, and then either contracting externally or assigning internally to establish responsibility. Traditional project management attempts to manage activities by centrally applied scheduling and to control them using output measures

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

12

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Comparison of Traditional and Lean Project Delivery Systems

Traditional Project Management


16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
13

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Comparison of Traditional and Lean Project Delivery Systems

Lean Production Management


16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
14

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Case Study

Actvity : Placement of rebar for slab


16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
15

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Case Study

Task flow of placement of rebar for slab


16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
16

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Case Study

Lean proposal 1 for placement of rebar for slab


16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
17

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Case Study

Lean proposal 2 for placement of rebar for slab


16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
18

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Conclusion
Lean construction is still, to a considerable extent, work-in-progress. However, its development to date supports two major claims: 1) Lean construction is based on a better theory than conventional construction 2) Lean construction is more effective than conventional construction Thus, lean construction is not just another specific approach to construction, but rather a challenger of the conventional understanding and practice of construction. In consequence, it is in the interest of every player in the construction sector to assess this new thinking and practice.

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

19

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Conclusion
The Turkish construction industry have no or little idea about either lean production or lean construction. As a result of the master of thesis A Statistical Approach To Lean Construction Implementations Of Construction Companies In Turkey done by Tezel in 2007, the recommendations for Turkish Contractors are as the followings;

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

20

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Conclusion
1) Turkish firms should increase their customer focus.

2) Turkish firms to put more effort to increase their level of organizational learning
3) Contractors also need to clearly define the expected value from a project with every party involved. 4) Maintaining continuous flow, by rearranging time and the resources, should be carefully studied by the Turkish firms.

5) The risk management techniques should be more effectively used by the Turkish firms.
6) The resources should be kept flexible, especially towards changing environmental conditions.
16/03/2012 CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR
21

Introduction

Lean Production Lean Construction

Techniques & Tools Comparison

Case Study

Conclusion

Conclusion

16/03/2012

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

22

14.04.2011

CE 579 GRADUATE SEMINAR

23

You might also like